╌>

Atheists as Useful Idiots for Islam's Violent Advances

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  jonathan-p  •  12 years ago  •  65 comments

Atheists as Useful Idiots for Islam's Violent Advances

The problem of Islamic terrorism and hunger for powercontinues to grow in the world today. There are more and more incidents occurring in more and more places across the world. 'Boko Haram' seems to be making the most news, but there are continuing difficulties within the Islamic countries themselves, along with disturbing developments in Europe. The frequency and amplitude are clearly increasing.

More and more evidence points to Islam. But the more evidence we are confronted with, the more backlash and PC scolding there is. Every time there's a Muslim attack, we are told that it has nothing to do with Islam. And the more these acts are defended - yes, defended - in this manner, the more emboldened these groups become. The longer we take to finally admit that Islam is the problem, the longer it will take for us to act against it.

Thenwe have the atheists.

No matter what I say here, there are those in the ranks of atheism that will take umbrage, so please let me define 'useful idiot' for you. The term was born to define Soviet sympathizers in Western nations during the cold war. It is a pejorative term, but I can't seem to find a better word to describe this. I'm not trying to make this personal.

In the face of this scourge, I have run up against a gauntlet of atheists who, in the debate about Islamic terrorism, lament but basicallyexcuse theterrorist behaviorby pointing out that "other religions did this too". I then receive the yada yada about how all religion is yada yada, and that's fine, but it has nothing to do with the thousands of dead innocent civilians, and the tens of millions who live in Islamic countries who live a life of subjugation and fear, and tens of millions of people who live in free countries who are increasingly being subjected to the intimidation of this faith.

I understand that faiths have dark moments. I understand that there are problems in Christianity TODAY and Judaism TODAY and Buddhism TODAY, but what has that got to do with this incredibly violent, audacious assault on the free world by Islam TODAY?? How can you excuse this because of the Hebrew extermination of the Jebusites 3,300 years ago, or the Crusades 900 years ago?

Yes, all religions have shortcomings, and they have shortcomings TODAY.

Why excuse Islam's violentmarch to a global caliphate?


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    12 years ago
I know of zero atheists who see Islam as equally violent as modern Christians. I think you miss their point. Christianity is the get-out-of-jail-free card for an ugly amount of ruthless criminals, once they get caught and end up incarcerated for life (or death for that matter). It's a farce that doesn't cure any problems, but acts to clear the conscience of those who deserve to suffer from guilt for the hurt they cause.
 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   seeder  Jonathan P    12 years ago

It's a farce that doesn't cure any problems, but acts to clear the conscience of those who deserve to suffer from guilt for the hurt they cause.

That's a very, very wide sweeping generalization of the faith, but let's go with that for the moment.

What, then, is Islam?

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    12 years ago

Jonathan, this is the good thing about Christianity today. You can be an open gay, transgender, Christian or Atheist in a Christian country, but in an Islamic country none of the above are allowed.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    12 years ago
Fundamental Islam is an extreme version of brainwashing, whereby the concepts of good and evil no longer comport with the accepted secular definitions, and where murder and suicide can become celebrated extensions of "good". Mainstream Islam isn't much different from mainstream Christianity - just different attire and less bashfulness about accepted norms of subjugation.
 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    12 years ago

Moral Equivalency.

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   seeder  Jonathan P    12 years ago

So, where "mainstream" Christianity enjoys leadership of many countries in the world, "fundamental" Islam enjoys an equivalent position of control.

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   seeder  Jonathan P    12 years ago

Are you saying that atheists for the mostpart place all forms of religious violence into one cauldron without differentiating?

 
 
 
Miss_Construed
Freshman Silent
link   Miss_Construed    12 years ago

I dont know about all atheists...

But I place all forms of religious violence into one cauldron.

Violence for the sake of religious beliefs is violence for the sake of religious beliefs. As someone who doesnt ascribe to any single religion, I see that kind of violence as ridiculously wrong.

 
 
 
Miss_Construed
Freshman Silent
link   Miss_Construed    12 years ago

I'd say that fundamental Christians can hold their own against Fundamental Islamists. I'm sure Fred Phelps would have cheered on his own grandson for murdering an abortion proponent or running into an abortion clinic with a bomb strapped to his chest.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    12 years ago

Are you saying that atheists for the mostpart place all forms of religious violence into one cauldron without differentiating?

Yes.

But I place all forms of religious violence into one cauldron.

While I agree with the comment, I don't think that one can say that Christians engage in the level of violence the a significant component of Islam does. A few Christian lunnies does not equate to literally tens of thousands if not more of extremist Muslims. Hence, moral equivalency.

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   seeder  Jonathan P    12 years ago

Violence for the sake of religious beliefs is wrong at every turn. We recognize Christian violence without question, as it should be. In the example you cited, the murderer was brought to justice, and the supporters of this animal were met with the appropriate, proper swell of disapproval, ESPECIALLY Christian fundamentalist groups that are appalled at the use of violence in this manner.

Fundamental Islamic violence is not being handled this way. Not even in a remotely roundabout way. It's being rationalized, debated and excused. It's being whitewashed, minimized, and the folks who are defending it are surely NOT being met with any meaningful disapproval.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    12 years ago

Hal and Miss..

I don't get how you can comparefundamental Christians to Islam extremist. While there are a handful of cases wherefundamental Christians have acted on their beliefs by killing people, just look at today's front page, and that is just today. There isn't afundamental Christian group, that equates to the death tolls to the WTC, The Madrid Bombings, The London Bombings, The Boston Bombing, wide spread of murder in Africa... do I need to go on, or would you like acomparativedeath count?

Don't get me wrong, I am not a fan offundamentalreligion, since I think that it tends to bend the basic message into something else, but to say that allfundamentalreligions are created equal, is afallacy.

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    12 years ago

Apologists abound, as useful idiots, moral bankrupts, or cowards.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    12 years ago
I didn't make any comparisons between Islamic Fundamentalists and Christian Fundamentalists. My comparison was between the mainstream varieties. While I am disgusted by religious fundamentalism of any stripe, Islamic Fundamentalists clearly take the cake in the area of violent behavior. Not that there's never been cases of Christian terrorism, but by volume there's no comparison between the two in the modern era. As hideous as Westboro Baptists are, their weapons are lawyers, not bombs.
 
 
 
Miss_Construed
Freshman Silent
link   Miss_Construed    12 years ago

I never said that the amount of Christian Loons and Muslim Loons were the same numerically... however the severity of their violence in the name of their beliefs for the people in those numbers can be and often is equivalent irregardless of which religion.

In my view/opinion/understanding, the way to combat those loons is combating extremists. Combating extremists with any result typically occurs within a faction (i.e. only Muslims can temper their own faith). If you generalize and ostracize a faction (i.e. throw all Muslims into the same pot, over and over) they typically swing more extremist in response because it becomes and us against them mentality.

Interchange Christian for Muslim in that statement = same thing.

The only other way is through conversion, which is historically bloody and often cruel. Conversion through knowledge can happen, but is slow and does not work if there is too much power with the fundamentalists.

Compassionate acceptance of differences is not the same as approval or excuse of violent actions. We must walk softly with a big stick.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    12 years ago
If neither religion had a place in government to begin with, then governments could get back to the business of secular management of the populations they serve, without irrational rules that form the basis of discrimination.
 
 
 
Swamijim sez
Freshman Silent
link   Swamijim sez    12 years ago

Jonathan--

With all respect, I think you may be overlooking a couple of points here...

1. In any discussion of the relative 'merits' of religion, atheists are guaranteed to point out that (from their perspective) all religions are completelyirrational, rely on 'brainwashing' the young to 'keep the faith', and have histories of scapegoating, intolerance and violence. From an atheist POV, Christians, Muslims, Jews, Hindus & any/every 'god centered' belief system are essentially all just different varieties of crazy. The fact that Christian or Jewish believerstoday aren't engaging in widespread repression, intolerance and violence doesn't make those faiths 'morally superior' from an atheist perspective-- it only means that Christianity (or Judaism or Hinduism) isn't as 'actively crazy' today asthose faiths have been in the past.

Those sorts of comments from atheists (IMO) are not intended to excuse or defend Muslim extremists or terrorism at all... it's simply the atheist reaction/response to a Christian or Jewish or Hindu claim to some kind of religious 'superiority' whensaying "We don't do that anymore, but Islam still does". Uncomfortable to hear, of course, and almost certainly a 'diversion' from a topic that was intended to focus on extremist violence, but certainly not justifying or denying violence and terrorism by Islamist fanatics...

2. Muslim extremists claim to speak for all of Islam, which doesn't make that true. Judging all of Islam by the statements & actions of a percentage of fundamentalist extremists is fairly much like judging all of Christianity by the statements & actions of fundamentalists claiming 'God hates gays & they'll burn in hell' or extremists bombing abortion clinics & murdering abortion docs. Millions of Catholics quietly disregard edicts from the Vatican, and millions of Muslims quietly disregard statements from Muslim clerics. Fundamentalist Islamist extremist Sharia law is intolerant & demeaning to women, gays & others-- and Christian fundamentalist extremists advocate for laws that would be equally intolerant & demeaning, if Christian fundies had the political traction to get them enacted.

And that brings us toa couple of real andimportant differences... Most Western governments aren't propped up & controlled by religion, while ME governments still are. We aren't going to hear the ruling class of Saudi Arabia (for example) speak out against extremist clerics, simply because Muslim clerics in general support the governments. By the same token, we've never heard the government of Italy (for example) say anything against edicts issued by the Pope, either. (Note that in thehistory of Europe, when the Church & theState were hand-in-glove, religious intolerance & violence were actively supported by the government.)

Another important reason we don't hear much overt condemnation of radical extremists from many Muslims and/orgovernments in Muslim countries is really simple: the fanatics are heavily-armed psychoes. Take a look at Nigeria as an example: non-extremist Muslims are rejecting Boko Haram loudly-- and bombs go off in the marketplace and villages are slaughtered.

Islamist extremists are dangerous terrorist fanatics who will kill anyone who opposes them, period. I'm not seeing atheists (or anybody else) denying or defending or excusing their actions. Are those extremists actuallyrepresentative of all of Islam? Doesn't seem to be a ton of evidence to support that-- but plenty of opinions & heated rhetoric on both sides...

Is Islam today more repressive/less tolerant than Christianity or Judaism or Hinduism today? My personal opinion is 'yes'-- but I'm not a Muslim (or Christian or Jew or Hindu or atheist, for that matter). Obviously millions ofMuslims don't agree with my personal opinion, or they'd convert to another faith.

 
 
 
Miss_Construed
Freshman Silent
link   Miss_Construed    12 years ago

Good reply Swamijim sezSmile.gif

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    12 years ago
Conversion is not the answer, critical thinking is. It is impossible to logically end up with religiously affiliated answers using critical thinking.
 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    12 years ago
Ditto. Well thought and expressed Swami.
 
 
 
Miss_Construed
Freshman Silent
link   Miss_Construed    12 years ago

I did make that comparison and I stand by it.

Religious fanaticism is rampant in all sects. Just because it happens less right now for one over the other doesnt make one religion more acceptable than another IMO.

Society is what keeps the reigns on religion. If Christian leaders had their way undeterred, they would slip right back into the dark ages within a short time span. It's human nature to seek power and position.

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   seeder  Jonathan P    12 years ago

This is to my point.

If Christian leaders had their way undeterred,

That's the crux of the craw. Christian leaders HAVE their way deterred. They ARE hamstrung from doing what you allege they want to do. And that's great, for ALL of us.

Now then, there's a problem that is affecting the ENTIRE WORLD, and it's happening RIGHT NOW. It's another religion, whose leaders HAVE their way undeterred, to the point where the rest of the world outside their dictatorships has become unstable. This problem needs to be attacked from as many different angles as possible, because it's a large, dangerous problem that is STILL gaining strength.

My argument is that the atheists are not giving enough emphasis to this problem, and hampering the dialogue by virtue of clinging to the (anti)dogmatic maxim that is "moral equivalence". Sure, it sucks when ANY religion acts out this way!! But there's only ONE right now that's threatening the stability of the entire world.

Can we please delineate, until we're stable again?

 
 
 
Miss_Construed
Freshman Silent
link   Miss_Construed    12 years ago

That was kind of where I was going with the conversion through knowledge aspect.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    12 years ago
Ah - when I think of bloody and cruel conversions my mind goes straight to religious wars and conquistadors.
 
 
 
Miss_Construed
Freshman Silent
link   Miss_Construed    12 years ago

I have no compunction with being vocal and active against Extreme Islamism in my own neighborhood and country.

However, I also subscribe to the thought that the US is not world-centric and does not have the authority or right to impress itself on any outside countries. (that of course, is not always carried out in such a manner at government level, it is just how I personally feel about it)

If outside countries are having the issues with religion RIGHT NOW, then their societies need to deal with them RIGHT NOW. For us to impress our rule and law on them only creates more discord and more irrational factions of hate.

I, apparently, don't see the instability in the world that you do. That has nothing to do with religion or lack thereof... I just dont see the emergency or the need to be involved in everyone else's societal affairs.

When they arm themselves with weapons capable of creating a world wide issue, then it becomes a world wide issue. That fine line is what got dear GWB in trouble.

I'd love it if the world were one day stable (it's never been stable), but as long as people believe things differently, it never will be.

Maybe one day we will have an alien invasion... that is probably the ONLY event that would actually draw all of humanity together because until then, the only "us against them" action we get is between ourselves.

 
 
 
Miss_Construed
Freshman Silent
link   Miss_Construed    12 years ago

I probably should have separated the sentences...

The only other way is through conversion, which is historically bloody and often cruel.

Conversion through knowledge can happen, but is slow and does not work if there is too much power with the fundamentalists.

Maybe underlined the word "can"... meh...

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    12 years ago

Ah - when I think of bloody and cruel conversions my mind goes straight to religious wars and conquistadors.

True, 600 years ago. I don't see that happening anywhere at the present time.

I am also not against critical thinking.

Interchange Christian for Muslim in that statement = same thing.

Again, moral equivalency. They are not the same. No one is bothering Africa, or African Muslims... mainly because heck, we don't give a crap about Africa. Yet Boko Haram feels the need to terrorize Christians who are minding their own business. So, this isn't because we did something to piss them off and this is reactionary. This is just pure aggression, on what they feel is an inferior faith. They have said this plainly and with great clarity.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    12 years ago
Perrie, even today the majority of the wars, conflicts and threats that occur in the ME have a religious component to them.
 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    12 years ago

Well said Swamijim.

On paper, Judaism, Christianity, and Islam are much more simliar than dissimilar especially since they have the same root. All three believe in the God of Abraham. Christanity incorporates the Five Books of Moses and Islam incorporates both the Five Books of Moses and the New Testament. As practiced and interpreted, all three religions can be tolerant or intolerant depending on who'spracticing them at the time.

It has taken a great deal of religious conflict spanning centuries and two world wars (with a death toll in the millions) for peace to come to the West. Western values are spreading across the planet aided by the internet and new concepts are being introduced into areas that have not changed much in a thousand years. At last count, there were 1.6 billion Muslims. Most take change in stride and the overwhelming majority are peaceful. They're not thinking about a world wide caliphate and probably wouldn't even know what you're talking about since a caliphate hasn't existed for centuries. Their main concern is the same as everybody else's . . . they want to live comfortably and enjoy themselves when they can. In some areas, change is violently resisted because it's coming too fast and they see it as western values replacing religious-based values. I suppose you could contort that into a war on Islam (but that's not really what the Koran had in mind). If they can get others to see this as a war on Islam, then the response would be Jihad but that's obviously not easy to do since the vast majority of Muslimsremain peaceful.

But I think Jonathan's real problem here is exactly as he expresed it . . . he can't whip the atheists up against Islam because they will never see Islam as any worse than other religions. That's becauseaethists rely on reason instead of faith. Thank God for atheists (lol).

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    12 years ago

Swami, I'd like to address you point for point.

1. Point well taken. I can understand the atheist POV here.

2. Of course we understand that there is a difference between Muslim extremist and your average Muslim. But you start to border on moral equivalency when you make a comment like:" fairly much like judging all of Christianity by the statements & actions of fundamentalists claiming:

God hates gays & they'll burn in hell' or extremists bombing abortion clinics & murdering abortion docs.

While I find these acts disgusting, they don't compare to the number of deaths that radical Islam has done in the last 10 years. Not even close. And yes it is true that most ME states are a blend of religion and government, one can point to Saudi Arabia andKuwaitand see that they have managed to keep radical Islam to a minimum. In fact, what I would say, is the poor the country, the stronger the hold of radical Islam. That is because the poor get their assistance from the very groups that foster this mind set.

Are those extremists actuallyrepresentative of all of Islam? Doesn't seem to be a ton of evidence to support that--

It's not that extremist represent most of Islam, but in the M/E many state sponsored textbooks (as you pointed out there is little division between faith and government there), such as Iran's Holocaust denial, and Sauditextbooks that breed hate. BTW, there is much proof that Iran does support terrorism world wide, even from our state department.

Obviously millions ofMuslims don't agree with my personal opinion, or they'd convert to another faith.

Or no faith at all.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    12 years ago
Anyone can be a murderous tyrant, even an atheist. However, there is a common misconception that atheist dictators murdered populations for the same reason religious leaders did - which is dead wrong. Dictators murder their countrymen in order to kill any opposition to them. If they happen to be non-religious, they aren't trying to force the citizenry to become atheists, they are forcing them to not group together and become a threat to the dictatorship. It doesn't matter if the group threat originates as a gathering of Christians, Muslims, Hindus, atheists, or a social club, it was forcibly disbanded by murdering anyone who defied orders not to gather and thereby present a potential threat to their power.

Religious leaders, on the other hand, acted upon their religious zealotry. Religion was the tool that justified their acts to themselves. You joined them, or you died. This is exhibited and instructed in many places throughout religious doctrines of all varieties.
 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    12 years ago

Excellent comment RL!

 
 
 
Swamijim sez
Freshman Silent
link   Swamijim sez    12 years ago

Perrie-- tnx for your feedback.

My point 2 was not intended to suggest a 'moral equivalence', but rather in response to statements in JP's article that 'broad-brush' equated all of Islam with extremism... You state

2. Of course we understand that there is a difference between Muslim extremist and your average Muslim.

Yet the article maintains

The longer we take to finally admit that Islam is the problem, the longer it will take for us to act against it... Why excuse Islam's violent march...

Clearly equating all Muslims with terrorists, and labeling atheists & anyone else who doesn't buy that equivalency as 'useful idiots'. Your comment

It's not that extremist represent most of Islam...

doesn't appear to be the position that JP is operating from.

I'm certainly not equating or even implying that Christian fundies are in the same boat as Muslim extremists--- merely saying that judging all Muslims by the actions of extremists of that faith is as much a logical fallacy as judging all Christians by the actions of extremists of Christian belief...

I fully agree w/ your assessment of religious propoganda in state-authorized books in the ME. Iran IMO is a 'terrorist state', without question.

Hope I've been able to make my statements a bit more clear...

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    12 years ago

Swammi,

Totally get your very rational reply.

I would like to comment on one of your items:

The longer we take to finally admit that Islam is the problem, the longer it will take for us to act against it... Why excuse Islam's violent march...

Although I wouldn't have phrased it this way, I think the point that Jon is trying to make is that over the last 40 years or so, we have seen a large increase in the spread of radical Islam. It is now common place to hear it preached on the streets of Europe. We see the spread into Africa. Even here in the US, we have seen signs of it in Dearborn, MI. The thing about an invasive plant, is that it spreads quickly. The "Tree of Heaven" is now seen now in all 50 states, but it is not a native of this land. It is hard to be rid of, since it grows quickly and anywhere, and gives off a poison that kills nearby plants. Not only does it's pods plant seed that blow in the wind, if you try to cut it down, the root system left behind will grow a new plant. This is the true problem with radical Islam. It is hard to eradicate and hard to stop once it has taken root.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    12 years ago
Reading through the comments to this post make me ashamed to be an atheist, once agsin. The thread is rife with the type of bigotry and prejudice that make atheists about as popular at parties as zealous Jehovah's witnesses. The issue adn problem with the world isn't religion, it's human nature. Get rid if religion and the world won't get an iota kinder. In fact the opposite is true.It never ceases to amaze that an educated person can trumpet athesidts and atheism as some sort of panache for the world. These are the sort of atheists who marched thousands of innocent to the guillotine in France in the name of reason. It's like the 20 th century never happened. Stalin, Mao, pol pot and hitler murdered about as many people as Christians were ever born. Thanks, but I'll put up a guy giving me an unwanted bible over the killing fields.The historically ignorant championing of atheism goes hand in hand with the equally silly compulsion to find moral equivalence between all religions. I'm sorry, but bombing an empty abortion clinic 20 years ago doesn't equate to the thousands every year executed or murdered by devotees of sharia law. Being an atheist shouldn't impair your ability to,think critically but unfortunately it does. It's a very primitive form of reasoning, if you can call it that, that stops thinking at "it is a religion, therefore it is bad."Sadly atheism is just a different manifestation of the religious impulse for many people. Religion or the lack their of is just one form fanaticism takes. The impulse gets transferred to ideology or movements like environmentalism. A guy like dr. Michael Mann is exactly the type of Person who would have guillotined people in France or burned them in the inquisition. The fanatic will find his way to something to be fanatic about.
 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    12 years ago

113.gif

 
 
 
Miss_Construed
Freshman Silent
link   Miss_Construed    12 years ago

I can only assume you attribute some of your comments to what I have said. If I just made an ass of myself... I apologize.

1. I am not trumpeting atheism. I'm not an atheist. I just dont subscribe to a specific definition of God.

2. I (try my hardest to) judge people based on being people, not their affiliations. Regardless of religion, people are people. Religion is a reason for people to band together for good and for not so good.

3. I am not saying eradication of any one or all religion will fix people. They will just band together over something else. Hence my alien invasion comment.

4. I do not assume a Muslim is any more or any less moral than a Christian or an atheist. Morality is a societal stick and I think it should be up to individual societies to determine what their sticks are, how long they are and how hard they beat themselves up because they dont measure up with the stick.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    12 years ago

And Sean... we have a winning comment!41.gif

 
 
 
pat wilson
Professor Quiet
link   pat wilson    12 years ago

I'm not trying to make this personal.

But your title does just that. And it really distracts from the point you are trying to make which seems to be that people are defending Muslim attacks. I don't see that in evidence myself. Please tell me where atheists or any other "ists" are defending islamic extremists.

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   seeder  Jonathan P    12 years ago

I've read through the threads, and there are a number of specific and pointed responses that I could make, but I believe I can make a single, sweeping comment based upon what I have absorbed.

The atheists' approach to the current issues that Islam presents to us is a scholarly one. That is, to take the issue and place it in the perspective of something to be analyzed, and base the analysis upon the historical effect of religion vis a vis instability in the world. What they have concluded is:

1)Islam is no more or less unstable than any other major (and probably minor) faith that this world has seen.

2)Islam is still in its youth, compared to the other religions that at some point dominated this world. The other religions have gained several degrees of stability that Islam has not yet come to realize. The other faiths have, at some point, acted in a similar, repulsive manner, especially in their eras of primacy.

3)The majority of the participants here (believer and atheist) seem to have concluded that change in the faith can only occur in a meaningful way from the inside.

4)No one seems to know what to do about the current confrontation.

And finally, I would like to let you all know how absolutely thrilled and proud I am to see this conversation resemble something that there is much too little of here, and anywhere in the blogosphere. This was a potentially controversial and possibly incendiary topic that everyone jumped into with their absolute best intentions. I learned more about the atheist perspective on this subject here than I could ever have learned anywhere else. For this, I am very grateful.

Thank you all.

Please do not consider this the end of the discussion. I just gotta hit the hay.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    12 years ago
Sean, regardless of the mindless thumbs-up-at-a-boy responses to your comment, it makes no sense considering there's no militant atheists making comments in this thread at all. Hope you enjoy the glad handing from your fellow conservatives (and Perrie for whatever reason), but you are simply bashing atheism because it's more commonly associated with liberals, which you have zero tolerance for under any circumstances. It must suck for you to have enough brains to realize that the concept of gods is ridiculously ignorant, but have too big of a chip on your shoulder to share that opinion with anyone. Trust me, we non-believers are just as ashamed to have you as you are to be one of us.
 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    12 years ago

Hal,

I am not bashingatheism and I don't associate atheismwith politics. As a matter of fact, I was just reading about Philip K Dick, the author, and he was a anti government atheist. I think you are missing Sean's point. That evenatheist can act irrationally and without morals. It is part of the human condition, and notnecessarilypart of religion.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    12 years ago

Hal is very good at missing points . He sees only what he wants to see .

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    12 years ago

Interchange Christian for Muslim in that statement = same thing.

Miss_Directed why don't you ask these people which religious group would they want to migrate into their country, Muslims or Christians?

 
 
 
Miss_Construed
Freshman Silent
link   Miss_Construed    12 years ago

Because... for some reason... there is a reading comprehension issue here... let me help you out...

In my view/opinion/understanding, the way to combat those loons is combating extremists. Combating extremists with any result typically occurs within a faction (i.e. only Muslims Christians can temper their own faith). If you generalize and ostracize a faction (i.e. throw all Muslims Christians into the same pot, over and over) they typically swing more extremist in response because it becomes and us against them mentality.

Not really sure how this interchangeable statement automatically means I need to ask how badly beaten people feel about the people who just beat the shit out of them.

I would think that it's a pretty easy assumption that when people are generalized by their beliefs and ostracized on the basis of those beliefs, they group together and grow more fundamentalist in response instead of tolerant of other groups and open minded.

I'm pretty sure I've seen more than one article here about how Christians are being singled out and prejudged because they are Christians and asking to pull together against the secularists who are daring to prejudge them.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    12 years ago

Good post Sean!

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    12 years ago

I'm around Muslims every day Miss_Directed. I don't have and have never really noticed any difference in the people I am around like the ones entering Sweden, but there are a lot of radicals it seems and once their population grows to a point it's like they change.

They know better to do or say much until they reach a level in the population where they can have an effect. Until then they seem to do just find. It's not the everyday Islamist who cause the problems. It's the radical element and as far as I'm aware the Christians haven't had radicals that were not heavily condemned by the non radical Christians. I just don't see much of that in the Muslim community. I guess the squeaky wheel gets the oil and the attention, so maybe that's why we see the Radicals only, at times. I agree with your comment, though.

 
 
 
brightstarone
Freshman Silent
link   brightstarone    12 years ago

Atheists as Useful Idiots for Islam's Violent Advances

The article doesn't make sense.

What is the point? .... that Atheists are responsible for the violence that comes out of religious extremists, because they are not subjective and emotional?

Atheists being non religious would not take sides and would be more objective in their discernment of religious extremism.

Religious extremists on the other hand are subjective and eager to take sides because they can't wait for Jihad or a Crusade; Thus they would ignore the overwhelming majority of non violent religious people that exist in all religions and concentrate their focus and fear-mongering on the minority of religious extremist assholes that commit sins and break the rules of their own religious tenets.

I don'tagree with the premise of this article.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    12 years ago

Obviously millions ofMuslims don't agree with my personal opinion, or they'd convert to another faith.

Sure, and if they did so they'd be killed. What other religion does that?

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    12 years ago
Before Sean made his comment, I made this comment:

"Anyone can be a murderous tyrant, even an atheist."

Of course, when a liberal atheist says this, it goes unnoticed, but when a conservative Uncle Tom atheist says it, the conservative crowd hoists them up on their shoulders like it's some genius revelation. Sean's comment makes atheists out to have equal or even higher potential compared to religious rule for doing evil, which ignores the fact that religion has historically been the justification for doing evil. Atheism is nothing more than the belief that there are no gods - it's not a doctrine, it doesn't have rules, it commands nothing, and the only justification it embodies is that extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence. Religion is the polar opposite of this.

You want genius revelation? Try Steven Weinberg's famous quote:

"With or without religion, you would have good people doing good things and evil people doing evil things. But for good people to do evil things, that takes religion."
 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   seeder  Jonathan P    12 years ago

Hal,

Your take on Sean's comment notwithstanding, I don't see the "bashing" that you're referring to. I don't see any politicization (lib v con) either. I see that a number of people consider my article as a "shot" taken at atheists, but for the wrong reasons. I sought information and insight on a seemingly unfair favoritism given Islam by atheists. The discussion certainly became much wider in scope, but came back to the original thesis.

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   seeder  Jonathan P    12 years ago

brightstarone,

The premise of the article has to do with current events, and the varied reaction by atheists to the current events. It's not a theoretical, academic scholarly question, but it did require that approach to get to a something resembling a response.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    12 years ago
Sean claims that the comments in this article make him embarrassed to be an atheist - how is that not the ultimate in atheist bashing? There is no militant atheist rhetoric happening on this thread, yet he is embarrassed to be associated with us? Sean's history here at NT is overtly conservative, and openly intolerant of anything liberal. The fact that most atheists are liberal is what drives him to despise the typical atheist. It's very difficult to be an atheist and yet fall in line with conservative politics, and that is his internal struggle to deal with.As far as your obtuse opinion that atheists somehow favor Islam over Christianity - it is just that - obtuse. We have no endorsement for any religion, and you see that as an endorsement for the one that yours is in competition with. I know a ton of atheists on the internet, and none of them favors Islam over any religion.
 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    12 years ago
Speaking of being intolerant of anything liberal ...
 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   seeder  Jonathan P    12 years ago

Break it up, you 2.

Hal,

The conservative bent has reactionary qualities. The liberal takes a more theoretical position. That's the nature of the beast.

By your own thoughts, Sean has an inner conflict. Those are his demons, not yours.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    12 years ago
Being an atheist doesn't require a "set" of beliefs, it requires one single belief - there are no gods. Conservatives takes political positions that frequently are propped up with religious fanaticism, and are therefore contrary to the logic behind the one single common belief of atheists. It's that simple.
 
 
 
brightstarone
Freshman Silent
link   brightstarone    12 years ago

Jonathan P, regarding reply:

brightstarone,

The premise of the article has to do with current events, and the varied reaction by atheists to the current events.

The premise is bogus, as in any demographic of people Atheists are not monolithic. Their are many variable and nuances within any group that belie your narrow and sweeping generalizations, based on the limits of your personal experiences.

And your convenient focus on "current events" only takes the credibility out of your argument because current events are the product of past history in proper context, which when taken into consideration gives a deeper truth that is more in context.

It's not a theoretical, academic scholarly question, but it did require that approach to get to a something resembling a response.

Your contradicting yourself JP, first you state that it is not a "theoretical, academic scholarly question" suggesting that I used an "academic " approach in my postthat was improper or not required; but then you say that this non "academic" question required an "academic and scholarly response..... ????

Again like the article you make no real point.Grin.gif

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   seeder  Jonathan P    12 years ago

Thank you for your response.

Like my article, and the many posts following, there was indeed a point. If you feel there was none, that's fine. Not everyone gets the point of everything in this great big world.

A number of people were able to present many thought provoking points. Personally, I came home with a greater perspective than I ever thought I would.

That, brightstarone, is the point.Grin.gif

 
 
 
brightstarone
Freshman Silent
link   brightstarone    12 years ago

Jonathan P 2, regarding reply:

Thank you for your response.

You're welcome.

Anumber of people were able to present many thought provoking points. Personally, I came home with a greater perspective than I ever thought I would.

That, brightstarone, is the point.

Ok if you say so, I guess .....Grin.gif

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov    12 years ago
Equating fundamentalist Christians with Islamics is ridiculous. By several orders of magnitude. The only way to do it is to be blinded by anti-Christian bias.
 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   seeder  Jonathan P    12 years ago

Equating 2014 Christian fundamentalists with 2014 Islamic fundamentalists is disingenuous.

Comparing both parties on their worst behavior shows a close correlation. But Christianity is 600 years more mature that Islam. We can only hope that it will take Islam less than 600 years to grow up. Invoking Christian misbehavior when someone speaks of Islamic misbehavior today changes the subject.

 
 
 
pat wilson
Professor Quiet
link   pat wilson    12 years ago

Never mind answering my question, Jonathon. I won't ask any of you in the future.

 
 
 
Cady Stanton
Freshman Silent
link   Cady Stanton    12 years ago

1435 years after the birth of Christianity compared to today's Islamic extremists would be more comparable. The rebirth of democracy in the land of Christianity has had a dulling effect on the authoritarian righteousness of Christians, compared to 1492 or 1662. I have no doubt that if Muslims were the dominant religion who won WW2 and Christians were the down-n-outs, then the roles would be reversed.

However, if you are a gay Uganda person who now faces the penalty of death just for existing, due to the export of lies and homophobia by USChristian Fanatics, then you might feel differently.

I personally find these distinctions distracting from the real elephant in the room, which is that men tend to create 95% of the violence in this world -- with the reason being just a hidden version of "I control land, I control women, I control the resources, I breed."

See we all have our own version of reality.

 
 
 
brightstarone
Freshman Silent
link   brightstarone    12 years ago

Sean Treacy regarding comment:

Reading through the comments to this post make me ashamed to be an atheist,...

Your entire post was worded from a religious persons point of view attacking Atheist and defending religious ideology. It is hard to see where you are an Atheist from reading your post.

....the type of Person who would have guillotined people in France or burned them in the inquisition...

The French peasants who "guillotined" people were not atheist and so were not driven to guillotine because of a lack of religion, they did what they did because of the poverty that they lived in; under the governing system of monarchy ruling with the authority of divine right. And the inquisition was perpetrated by religious fanatics not atheist.

Nazi Germany was a Christian Nation and Shitler was not a declared atheist, in-fact he used God in his speech's to justify his actions saying that God was on their side.

Your entire post was weirdly skewed and out of context; the environmental movement in no way equates with religious fanaticism you were trying to make it seem as though everything is the same and that there are no differences in order to excuseor minimize the religious extremists and their Crimes against Humanity.

It sure looks like you are pretending to be an atheist to advance an anti atheist pro religious narrative, the very words in your posting makes this transparently obvious.

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   seeder  Jonathan P    12 years ago

My apologies. I didn't mean to ignore you.

There is ample evidence of this type of behavior throughout threads that discuss current events relating to Muslim violence and terrorism. It's very common, and quite easy to find. If you follow any of the threads on this very article, you see a number of NTatheists stipulating to this fact.

If you don't see it, perhaps you don't become involved in those discussions.

 
 

Who is online





86 visitors