Dann Sisters' Battle To Save Their Cattle In Stark Contrast To That Of Cliven Bundy
In 1973, the BLM forced the Dann sisters from their ancestral land, took their cattle and sold them.
The battle continues today in the U.S. count system. The Dann sister are Western Shoshone Indians, and the land is theirs by treaty and ancestral right. They are now in their 80's and one of the sisters has walked on. But the fight still continues.
This is the same land in Nevada that Bundy as the so called patriots are claiming is their ancestral land.
The double standard continues. If your Indian you aretreated and dealt with differently then if your a white rancher/so called patriot.
Watch the video and read the two links in the story.
http://indiancountrytodaymedianetwork.com/2014/04/19/video-dann-sisters-battle-save-their-cattle-stark-contrast-clive-bundy-154521
Tags
Who is online
79 visitors

So this is Bundy ancestral land, I think not.
The video is heartbreaking. Stories like this one about the Dann sisters is why we can't "get over it."
So, does anyone know where I can buy land at pennies over $1.oo/acre as the US government claims it did from the Shoshone, and without placing one of those dollars into the hand of the actual owner?
Did I misunderstand what I heard from the video? An Indian agent (BIA) accepted $27million for the 24million acres of land... without any contact with the Dann sisters who privately owned their home... "on behalf" of the Shoshone Nation, therefore the courts ruled they had no further ownership of it?
And when the BIA accepts payment "on behalf" of Indians, doesn't it go, basically, back into the coffers of the US government, much like simply transferring your pocket change from your pants to the bedside table? (The money changed locations, but it's still YOUR money.)
If I'm wrong about this, please let me know. I get confused whenever you try to explain how the BIA works in regard to overseeing money for the childlike nave clueless uneducated Indians./s
The money is "supposed" to go into a trust fund and is overseen by a trust fund manager (it's early, not enough coffee, can't remember names/titles).
1st is correct. It goes into a ''trust''...Now remember now many of those trusts ended up with nothing in them.
Also the sisters were arrested a couple of times and their livestock taken after the 1973 arrest. The last time was 2005.
Thank you, 1stwarrior. Thank you also for the quotation marks around the word "supposed." That's what I was driving at. It is absolutely galling that there is still a BIA in existence.
The entire time I watched the video, I was astounded at how hard these two women worked, and then to have this crap happen to them. Outrageous!!!
It is criminal.
Yes, it is criminal. The BIA has "lost" billions of dollars and the Supreme Court ruled the BIA has no fiduciary responsibility for the money.
So under the "guardianship" of the US, land and homes are taken, the owners never given their day in court, and the money can disappear AT THE HANDS OF THE GUARDIAN with the highest court in the land saying they don't have to "find" it OR produce any paperwork to show what might have happened to it.
And now Clive Bundy is claiming he owns that land and doesn't have to lease it for his cattle because his ancestors squatted there.
The entire thing about Bundy, especially comparing it to what happened to the Dann sisters, is sickening, especially considering that the feds GAVE BUNDY'S CATTLE BACK TO HIM THAT THEY HAD ALREADY REMOVED!
It is sickening isn't it Tzia. Sadly, beating up Indian women isn't nearly as bad as giving poor old Buny a hard time because he broke the law./s
And they sold the Dann sisters cattle. Double standard, double standard and double standard.
Oh, yeah.... forgot to mention they sold the Dann sisters cattle.
It's the media attention, Kavika. There hasn't been a real media event for Indians since Pine Ridge. I'd suggest another one, but Indians have a tendency to be shot by feds instead of just getting their stuff back.
It's sickening and infuriating.
Why does it still exist? If there was ever a government entity that has no purpose, it is the BIA. Instead of cutting programs that help women and children, why isn't the GOP going after this dinosaur agency? It's doors should be shuttered. There's no reason to keep them open.
The Dann sisters. What a sad legacy for their family and friends. Their entire life was defined by the criminality inflicted upon them. They should have been able to leave behind their land, cattle and other assets, along with the wonderful memories of a life built upon success in a tough profession. Their family's future generations will all be changed by the theft of their assets and the battle to be properly compensated. They aren't even receiving recognition that a wrongful harm was inflicted upon them.
I wonder where the defenders of Bundy are this morning. Shouldn't they be here defending the Dann sisters who actually owned the land and weren't freeloaders bilking the taxpayers?
I have to say this video brought tears to my eyes and a pain in my heart. But I ask, did anything come of it? If they are running Bundy off the land today, I suppose not.
So they had legal ownership and the government took it from them. Bundy doesn't have legal ownership and they will remove him.
We lost our freedoms many years ago.
And this continues on today. Just look up "land taken by government".
And maybe we are coming to realize the biggest threat to our Liberty is a unrestrained government. Where do we take it back? Do we start today? Is it too late?
Did you guys catch the part in the video where the narrator said Indians were not allowed to testify in the court proceedings about the taking of this land? And that when the sisters went to court they were not allowed to mention the treaty or the fact that their father had outright purchased the land?
What a crock! So who, exactly, got their "day in court" we hear so much about? Certainly not these sisters.
''It is criminal'', yes it is 96. This is but one of many such cases involving Indians.
Bundy is still on the land, the BLM gave him back his cattle.
Yet, the Indian sisters have fought the government for over 40 years, and have both ancestral and legal right to the land.
Where were the ''Patroits'' to help them fight for their land?
I'm waiting for them to show up Mashkawide'e. You would think that they be armed and standing side by side with the Dann sisters. Oh, forgot, their just Indians.
Yes, I did catch that part mimi.
Not surprising, the government uses the law to met their own ends.
The games are rigged at every level of every bureaucracy and entity that can get its hands on OPM* -- with the most hypocritical and egregious riggings orchestrated by those empowered to administer for the very individuals they fuck over! Be it a government, union or corporate entity (which in reality owns the government), it's "We the People" who are subjugated.
And whether it be the "Victimcrats" on the left or the faux-patriots on the right, somewhere along the line, they either sell us out, or, are duped (often willingly) into dancing to the tune of ones of that call the tune.
* Other People's Money
I don't even know where to start. I am so upset from watching that video.. heartbroken for those brave old ladies and the injustice that has been done to them.
The government steals their land, gives it to be used by strip miners, won't give the Dann sisters their day in court, yet kowtows to Bundy and a gang of his armed friends in the name of "freedom". Who's freedom? Not the Dann sisters. The Dann sisters were the only ones who were generous enough to let everyone graze on their tribal land. And the thanks they get for their generosity is that they are screwed.
You bet if any Indian did what what Bundy did they would call them terrorist and not patriots. What a freakin' double standard. I am disgusted.
I really do think a great opportunity is being passed up here by the Indians and Americans in general. We can't say to ourselves, "They screwed us, so screw them." Those people out there probably don't even know anything about these sisters, but they are fighting against the government running over the people. We must all join together to fight this. You're support is a lot bigger than you realize. You should support Bundy and maybe you'll see what I mean. You may find many more people supporting you who are unaware of many things. This is the perfect time to stand together. A hardened heart will not see the possibilities ahead, but will only see the possibilities lost.
Quite the contrast; I didn't realize I could dislike Bundy any more than I already do.
Sorry Sixpick, there's a piece of the story of which you seem unaware. And you like the rest of us are a victim.
It's possible Larry!
You're right, Perrie, that is what they would call them... in the media headlines after they had shot every single one of them that stood there with or without a gun in their hand.
And one other thing now that I have stopped screaming. IF the Dann sisters had gotten the support from the Natives the way Bundy got his support from the other white ranchers, there would have been another "Wounded Knee" because the government couldn't let that stand with out shooting somebody.
And people ask why the Native Americans don't trust the government.
Six, I believe your heart is in a good place, but look at this another way for a minute... Bundy is not a fool. From the minute the Dann sisters went to court you can bet that he and every other rancher on that land has kept up to date on every single ruling that has been made about it.
It simply would not be in his best interests to support the Dann sisters, or any Indian in the Indian's efforts to reclaim stolen land.
Who wants to be first in line? Oh it can't be you because they put me in the back. Screw you. The opportunity is there for those who have been put in the back of the line as well, but the seemingly complex but simple solution is right before our eyes.
A couple of times a week I pass a sign in a little town in this county that reads, Mint Hill took a WWII veterans land. I did a search on it a few weeks ago, but put the wrong town in. I found the same situation exists all over the place. Thousands of them are taking place everywhere in this country.
Bundy is a thief and the government helped him do it. Now the thieves have turned on each other. No honor among thieves, is there.
I trust anything that comes from the government about as much as I trust a $10 whore. They'll stack the deck in there favor every time and rarely lose.
A Mac, I'd like to see the accounting for that land. Pretty much is saying if the sisters had maintained it as their private property it would have cost them $1.2 billion every 10 years. I don't think so. We're only talking about a very small part of the 84% the government controls in Nevada, not the whole USA. But that is from Salon and is expected to mislead and twist. No offense to you, but hope you can see my point. Comparing the sisters or the portion Bundys is using of the 23% of land controlled by the government in the entire USA is not apples to apples.
See the dot. I don't either.
@Grump:
That's the best description of this situation I've heard so far, Grump.
''Another Wounded Knee'', without a doubt Larry.
I don't support thieves, scoundrels and liars. It's against my principles.
I say that as a white Mormon who's spent her life with ranchers and farmers and supporting them. While I'm not an active Mormon, my family is. My brother and cousin were bishops. My father and uncles were in the Seventies Quorum, right below the Twelve Apostles. My gggrandfather came across the plains with Brigham Young and was instrumental in settling Utah, Wyoming and Idaho. My gggrandmother's life story is preserved in the BYU library and their cabin in a Utah state park. Their names were Samuel and Sophia Jewkes. Check them out. Their information is on the Internet.
I resent him hiding behind his supposed Mormonism as an excuse for his lawlessness. The simple truth is the Mormons did settle the land and push the Indians out. That's well documented. No Mormon today should use that unfortunate fact to justify his personal act of theft from the taxpayers or for inciting violence against our federal employees. If he was an honorable man, he would not want to profit at our expense, to have people killed so he can profit or to cheat his fellow ranchers out of profits by illegally avoiding expenses they pay.
I also don't see how anyone can think the situation is remotely the same. Bundy doesn't deserve to be mentioned alongside the Dann sisters.
That is true Grump, hope that they eat their young as well.
I'm with you Larry. On another thread/article a couple of days ago about Bundy I pointed out that the land belongs to the Shoshone. Many kept saying he was doing the right thing.
He's a liar and thief, plain and simple.
Six, the Indian people through outthe U.S. have been fighting this for centuries, both with warfare and in the courts. This is nothing new to us.
There is no way I would support Bundy. His claims are bogus from the start. His ancestral land, give me a break. It quite clear that he has no claim to this land.
A hardened heart is not what I have Six. I can forgive, but never forget. Having been in most every protest by Indian people since the 60's we continue to fight for our rights, which in many cases, including up to today, we have had taken away.
This situation, in no way, is anything like the Bundy situation. Those were never his lands, and his lie about it being his ancestral land is nonsense.
''The games are rigged at every level of every bureaucracy and entity that can get its hands on OPM* -- with the most hypocritical and egregious riggings orchestrated by those empowered to administer for the very individuals they fuck over! Be it a government, union or corporate entity (which in reality owns the government), it's "We the People" who are subjugated''.
Right on the money Mac.
''YES'' to all of your comment Perrie.
Oh the irony and hypocrisy; the angry wealthy-white men and their angry, white Obama-hating-gun-loving, alleged government-loathing supporters, scream about "entitlements" (buzzword for "welfare-queen minorities", the elderly and working poor") while supporting candidates and legislators who dole out corporate welfare at the expense of
some of the same angry schmucks who support their efforts to do so at their OWN expense.
And then they fist pump when Ted Nugent and Wayne LaPierre piss in their faces and tell them "it's raining."
"Yoose is partriots"!
Ahhhhh I feel better having gotten that off my chest.
Anyone else?
OK Mac, take a deep breath now...breath in, breath out..repeat..
Not if it hadn't been stolen from them by government encroachment it wouldn't! How can anyone who has first been robbed, then taxed on that which was stolen from them, NOT CRY FOUL?
I'm cool; once I get it out there, I'm cool.
But your concern is greatly appreciated.
OK, just making sure! lol...
I hate calling 911, they always put me on hold!!
Yes, I feel better now as well Mac.
Usually I just smack someone with a Tomahawk, but I guess your vocal outburst is more accepted.
NO TOMAHAWKS Kav!!! Paramedics frown on that! (bow and arrow...ok)
And here I've been so good about not waving mine around the last several months...
I like to use my "little" long bow and "reach out and touch somebody" - quietly.
They get the point.
...
Never Mind Cliven Bundy: Heres the Real David vs. Goliath Story Between Ranchers and Feds
I wonder where all the ''Patroits'' are at on this. You would think that this would be a cause celeb or them...Oh, forgot, just a couple of old Indian women, they don't count.
I'm saying it again, 1st and Kavika... it is well past time for an Indian uprising.
Dear Friend Mimi: I am in solidarity with you, Kavika and 1st Warrior. This is over the top!
Double standard doesn't really get past the surface of what is going on here.
It makes me sick, as an American to see this sort of thing.
Where is the law? In the Constitution, isn't there an equal protection clause?
I don't see anything approaching equal protection in any part of this.
Peace, Abundant Blessings, and Justice, Justice Shall You Pursue.
Enoch.
The plan was fine Robert, you should really get up to date on the ''Indian Wars''...The big problem on our part was thinking that you'd be honest and honor your word. It seems that is not part of the make up of your ilk.
This article drives that point home. But, being blinded with bigotry, you probably can't see the obvious.
Luv ya too Mike -
Mike, as I pointed out in other threads (yours I believe). Bundy is a liar and full of shit. It isn't his ancestral land, never has been. I think that this article settles that question.
If the ''patriots'' want to rally behind him and his phony cause, that's up to them. If they were real ''patriots'' they would rally to the Dann sisters, who actually have just cause to fight the government.
''Am I to understand that people care about this, now that there is some Indians involved?''
I really don't see the hoards of ''patroits'' rushing to care about a couple of old Indian women.
Your welcome
You are not really going down that road, are you Mike? We've cared about this type of thing long before this article was ever posted.
You're kind of missing the point here. Personally, I DON'T CARE about Bundy. He should have paid up or removed his cattle. The land is not his any way you want to cut it.
Mike, we have always cared. Now that you mention it yes we feel the "law is the law", so if it was good enough for the Danns to get raped by our government, then bend over Bundy and spread em it's your turn in the barrel (bitch).
BS Mike, we've cared about ''this type of thing'' for centuries. Are you not understanding that the government in this case is wrong. Oh course I/we would fight it.
The Bundy case is nothing more then some asshat screaming, his ancestral land, and leading a bunch of anti government types to follow his lead.
Good luck with that.
No where to be found, obviously. There are no fair deals, anywhere, if you are an Indian.
Kavika, do you honestly believe I do not stand with you on this? Maybe I used the wrong words when I said stand with Bundy, but it wasn't meant the way it came out. The light is shining on Bundy right now. The whole world probably knows Bundy.
I have a dream...
I have a dream and in my dream I see hundreds if not thousands of Indians and people who believe in Liberty and Justice all standing together on this land and you can see them for as far back as the eye can see. The story is being heard by the world and the people who never knew of this and many other things are hearing it for the first time. Their voices are clear and loud enough for all to hear their story.
Happy to hear that your comment re Bundy isn't what I understood it to be. For that I apologize.
I hope that you are right, and the dream comes to fruition Six. It would be a wonderful sight.
I like that dream. I have another.
In my dream, Indians are mounted on their finest cow horses, painted with symbols to ensure a good round up. They gather about 400 head someone carelessly left roaming on heritage tribal land and drive them over to the Dann sisters' place as a token to help heal at least part of the harm that was inflicted upon them.
We always care about what is right. Bundy isn't right. He's a crook. Whole different story there. Too bad you're having trouble with the concept.
Mike, your making a lot of assumptions. To say that it was the Bundy story that I/we wouldn't know about this is a ridiculous statement. Having lived in NV for years, I'm quite familiar with Bundy and the Western Shoshone case.
What I find interesting is that this ''IS happening'' is nothing new to us. It may be to you, but it's something that we have been fighting for centuries.
And yes, screw Bundy, I could care less about the thief, except that he pays what is owed. If your willing to support Bundy and his non payment of land usage, I'm not.
Wow. Could you be anymore arrogant? Indians have been fighting with the US govenrm
Oh, you mean like at Wounded Knee where an estimated 10,000 rounds were exchanged and people died? Or didn't you know about that?
WoundedKneeincident -Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Of course I'll be on the side of the common man, I'm a populist.
What I've seen you say is a bunch of insults aimed at people who've been fighting this war for decades. They aren't just a loud mouth couch potato slumming their way through life. They've been there in person and expended great effort to stop what you claim to protest from safely behind your computer screen.
If you had the principles you claim, you'd be asking for some advice on how to fight the government rather than mocking them.
No, scremimmimi, you read it right on the BIA accepted the money. I would think the money would go to the Soshone Nation.
I am getting to the point that I don't have a lot of faith and trust in any government anymore. And if they want to come after me for that, well, dammit BRING IT!!!!!!!!!!
Yes....
First they came...
You know the rest.
The light is one. The center of the stage isn't yours unless you take advantage of it. Now is the time. Just because the light isn't shining on you doesn't mean you can't take advantage of it while it is shining. Next year it will be out, maybe forever.
In the video, I didn't see anyone defending you, but do you think it would be the same if you told your story today while the light is on and the cameras are rolling.
I think it would be great for the Indians to go unarmed to this land and tell their stories, get that video out and anything else you can use to take advantage of the situation.
I think you would be surprised in a very nice way. People will be moved by the video and I'm sure there is more. But the main thing is the attention span is very short. Next year there will be a solar company or something on that land and you'll regret you didn't take advantage of the opportunity.
When you mock people, you are insulting them, so let's not pretend you didn't, okay? At least have the fortitude to admit the truth.
The rest? Not going to bother. You came in here pretending you're a hotshot leader when all you're doing is sitting on your couch typing words anonymously. That says it all for me.
Really? Wanna claim you've been on the front lines? Prove it. Give my your real name and show me yourself in a photo at Bundy's place. I'll be waiting.
Question here, Mike...
If Ms. Dann (her sister has passed away) is finally successful in her efforts to reclaim her land and the rest of the Shoshone are as well, where will you stand then? Because if the Shoshone were to get their land back, Clive Bundy is then trying to squat for free on Indian land.
I'm sharing your dream, Loretta.
I'm so angry about Ms. Dann (I believe her sister has passed on) that if I were to hear that she went back to her land with a tent and refused to leave, I would be on my way to stand with her as soon as I could pack my dogs and horse.
Let's do this Mike - per the Constitution, treaties are the "law of the land". The Western Shoshone have a treaty with the U. S. that says that land is theirs - so, the "law of the land" should be followed.
Bundy, on the other hand, owns 160 acres and is using, illegally, 302,000 acres of Western Shoshone land that has been taken by the BLM, and is not paying for a lease the BLM broke with him 21 years ago, so he owes over $1.2M to the government.
Why is everybody cheering Bundy?
Well said ambiv. No, more then well said, it was said from the heart.
Chi-miigwetch (many thanks)
How much does the discovery of the microscopic gold found play into this?!?! The video is heartbreaking and disturbing. Will this ever end for the American Indians!!!!!!! I stand with the remaining Dann sister.... many blessings to her and the Shoshone People.
Good point! But I am sure Harry and the rest of the government will make sure they all get screwed. My prediction is they will all be run off the land.
Hi Mrs. D. ! It really is heartbreaking.
Yes, it is, and I'm glad for once that I am getting older. I don't want to have to live through what's coming.
When this whole thing started with the Bundy's, I never once thought that was land that belonged to the Indians. I read and see this, and I want to cry all over again. And I want to kick myself in the ass for it.
Tzia, that it is. I really wish the Indians could get together and try to put a stop to this without being slaughtered. With the Feds being such butt wipes, I would have to stand with the Indians, and even though I'm Granny aged, I would lay down my life to make these things right again.
At least, I would go out knowing that I did something worthwhile for once.
Kavika, that is a damn good question. Right now, I feel like I am far more of a patriot than these great pretenders are.
I think everyone who is going through this should be included. Unfortunately there are many more cases of this than I originally realized, just doing a quick 2 minute search I found about 5. Bruce actually posted an article on one of the others.
Larry, it ain't just the Native Americans that don't trust the government. Tis old gal don't trust them any more than I could throw this 8 floor building.
I knew from many years ago that the Indians had been screwed over horribly, but thanks to Kavika and others, I am now realizing the full story of it and it pisses me off to no end. I've said it before and will say it again here. If it came to an uprising with the Indians against the government, I would be standing front and center with the Indians.
If you're "disinterested" in Kavika's comment, why in the bloody blue blazes are you here?
I'll be right there with you, screminmimi. Me and Phugs.
Dear Leotie,
I know you would, in a heartbeat!! ((()))
Kavika, when I met you over on NV, and I asked you to teach me some things about the Indians, I didn't know how blessed I would be in asking.You have taught me so much along with the others in our group, and I appreciate every word of it. I know I could have read and done research on my own, but I feel like I get the truth from you and all the wonderful people in the group.
Again, thank you so very much.
Kick some BLM ass Phuggy
Trying to play the Devil's Advocate wasa fairly decent touch Mike - but - this is not a subject for the twisting of and play on words.
And Yowell's - but that's a different thread
So, the Bundy dude gets to play Al Capone of the Sagebrush, but compared to the Dann sisters, he appears to be a cow patty in the sun, kinda crusty on the outside but soft on the inside. This man does not know the meaning of hardship or dignity as the Dann sisters have known.
That's a good description, Paul.
It is a very sad story Mrs D. Ihope that someday she wins her case.
Your welcome Leotie.
''This man does not know the meaning of hardship or dignity as the Dann sisters have known''.
Very true Paul. Thanks for stopping by.
Think The Native American Rights Fund (NARF) needs to jump back into this, along with the ACLU.
And now would be a good time for them to do it, 1st, while there is so much publicity surrounding Bundy.
Six was right about using the spotlight while it was shining. The publicity he has brought to his own situation could be a huge help for Yowell and Ms. Dann.
I would hope it would help everyone in a similar situation.
screminmimi,
have you ever been reading something and it evokes the mind's eye imagery (that is the essence of how we interpret what we are reading) , and your mind instantly provides you with 20+ scenario-layouts to choose from? Well, every now and then I actually capture (in my mind) the good ones, instead of losing them to bio-cyberspace ( I mean, really, isn't that what "forgetting" something is?
) Well anyway (sorry, I get to thoughtstream babbling sometimes),
that seemed to fit the situation quite nicely, and thanks.
Your avatar is cool. Nice.....horsy........just don't put my eye out with one of them hooves
Excellent Friend Kavika, it was my honor.
Glad you like him, Paul. His name was Ranger.
I just came across this article-- I missed it when it was originally posted.
This is so sad.
When I some across things like this I often wonder-- what can be done to empower people & groups (in this case American Indians) who are victimized like this?
Perhaps a first step would be to publicize it, although I don't know how. Mimi I think you are right-- one of the problems is that this is not covered much, if at all, by the American mainstream media.
Mimi, is correct on that Krish. Since the crap with Bundy, the Dann sisters have been getting attention. One of the sisters walked on, but the other is still fighting. There is also another case involving a Shoshone Indian that has been fighting the same battle for years.
Human Rights Defenders Carrie Dann and Mary Dann
Haven't seen any mention of money under Bundy's land. The Dann sister's are just another example of rape and pillage.
Interesting.
IMO an important step is making people aware of these issues. There are some people who would be sympathetic-- even some who would become activists-- if they knew about it. But issues re: mistreatment, discrimination, etc of American Indians had not gotten a lot of attention in the media (at least until fairly recently). Even people who are activists in human rights usually participate in things like black rights, or, more recently, gay rights. Why? I think part of it is just because these 2 causes are better known by the masses.
The money is all in Bundy pocket Steve. The Dann sisters are just old Indians fighting to save what is rightfully theirs.
Treaties with the US government mean nothing, when it comes to Indians. Greed is the motivator, not moral responsibility.
The question is why are they better known. I have an answer, that will piss off a lot of people, and get all types of, oh no, get over it responses.
I believe we are in full agreement Kavika. In northern New Mexico the fight is over water rather than gold or oil. It doesn't matter really what the subject matter is, the fact remains, the government or true believers or oath keepers or whatever they want to call themselves, must be in charge because it profits them.
And when they have extracted the last bit of profit from the earth, what good will it do them when earth will no longer support them?
When all the trees have been cut down,
when all the animals have been hunted,
when all the waters are polluted,
when all the air is unsafe to breathe,
only then will you discover you cannot eat money.
Cree Prophecy
Fitting and veryreal, the future is around the corner.
Very perceptive-- we could all learn from that!
True words! Something we should all remember.