Could Death of Internships Hurt Grads' Careers?
I came across this article on LinkedIn and found it interesting and thought provoking in light of the current struggles faced by recent college graduates in entering the work force in their desired career fields.
The article is by J.T. O'Donnell, CEO of CAREEREALISM.com & CareerHMO.com but might have been written by a CEO or HR Director of many large corporations or smaller businesses.
This week, Conde Nast announced it was settling a lawsuit brought against the company this past June by two former interns. Four months after the two interns sued for being paid below minimum wage, the magazine also announced the end of their internship program.
Great Opportunities Gone Forever? Or, Workplace Slavery Abolished?
As someone who has offered internships in the past, I know how mutually beneficial the arrangement can be. The students gained valuable experience, and I got some much-needed help during the start-up stage of my business. Some of my interns even became the very first employees of my company. I know the interns found the experience useful too. I'm still in touch with many of them today. They didn't run for coffee or make copies. Instead, they got to roll up their sleeves and contribute to meaningful projects that helped them accelerate their professional experience.
However, I've also heard many stories from former interns of other companies who suffered through what they believed were horrific internships, quite a few at prestigious firms. They felt like workplace slaves and seriously questioned if having the company's name on their resume would ever be worth what they endured. A "Devil Wears Prada" type of experience. And, that leads to my question...
Will high-profile cases, like the Conde Nast incident, kill more internships?
And, more importantly?
If companies stop offering internships out of lawsuit fears, how will young people get the work experience they need to accelerate their careers?
While I don't want to see young people being taken advantage of, I also know plenty of them aren't familiar with the professional work environment. Less than 30% of high school and college students ever have a job in a professional setting (i.e. internship) before they graduate from college. If internships become even more scarce, how will these new professionals get the experience they need to be successful in the workplace?
https://www.linkedin.com/today/post/article/20140409193907-7668018-could-death-of-internships-hurt-grad-s-careers

During my time as a HR Manager/Director, we had a very active internship program which included students and all stages of their college careers. Our internships were all in white collar (mainly sales, marketing, R&D and engineering) and we employed a simple pay scale based on the intern's class standing paying $11, $12, $13 and $14 per hour for Freshman through Seniors.
We also had a fairly high success rate in converting interns into full-time employees upon graduation.
That is not a program that would work for all businesses but it worked for us and the managers and the interns seemed happy with the program, which I am confident added value to the company as well.
Don't the young people who intern for Supreme Court judges do it for free? What about the interns for senators?
scremminmimi
I think SCOTUS clerks are paid positions and not internships actually pay pretty well
As to the Senate, I imagine there are some that are paid and perhaps some that are not - not really sure about that
The internships I and the article are discussing are in the private sector
Thank you for clarifying, Robert.
Hhhhhmmmmm...How about just pay them the minimum Wage?
It would be counter-productive of having experienced workers in positions of responsibility to abolish the internship program. In Canada, the government funded the program for students on their summer vacations and as senior partner of a law firm I hired interns under that program which in fact led to most of them being hired by me upon their graduation and call to the bar. They not only became integral members of the firm but even when they left we kept up a good relationship. One quit law and started a car leasing business, and knowing how trustworthy he was I leased all my cars from him after that. Some of those interns now form the firm from which I retired, and if I needed legal services it is to them I would turn.
In China a poll was taken of employers who hire staff, asking what qualities they seek. Even though many might think that the main qualities should be superior education and intelligence, the main qualities determined were experience and personality. One of the best ways to get experience here where the competition for jobs is unbelievably fierce would be to volunteer even without recompense in order to establish experience. Perhaps that might mean holding two jobs, one of which to provide sufficient living expense income, or perhaps to be supported by family while doing the volunteer work.
I can see it as accelerating the dumbing down of a country if the internship programs are terminated.
This might be considered off topic but it relates a story of how one student managed to pay off his student loans :
Duke Grad Student Secretly Lived In a Van to Escape Loan Debt
Broliver
Not a bad thought, but as I pointed out some companies pay interns more than the minimum wage, based on the business discipline they are studying and the position they are filling with the company.
I think a minimum amount that they can be paid is a good idea, but a mandated one size fits all is not the answer here as the market and the talent and contribution of the intern plays a role in how much they are and should be paid.
Buzz
I am not sure that I am in favor of the government (we the people actually) paying for another program, but perhapsinternships could be paid as part of a Pell Grant (or other type) and be designed to insure that the student earned a certain minimum amount between what the private sector employer was paying and the amount received from the grant.
Some might receive nothing, some a little and some a little more
Petey
Off topic? Perhaps but very interesting nonetheless
I am not sure if it is different in the medical field, but my daughters have done internships and they had a choice of being paid $12 and hour or getting class credits.
The water company where I work does this, with pay, and its great! The interns get valuable experience that helps to contribute to their later careers, we get good, motivated help, and the company gets a relatively inexpensive help during the summer months. I think it is a win-win situation.
By that same token, back in the dark ages, when I was in college, there were no paid internships for geologists, so I volunteered for an oil and gas company, working on maps. I still had a 40 hour a week job, but I got to spend some time in the geology industry environment, which was VERY helpful!
I hate to hear that some of the interns are being taken advantage of, but, in today's world, the corporate attitude can really suck!
Dowser
No doubt there are instances of corporate malfeasance in this area, but there are also many companies that offer important experience and fair pay to a study still in the learning process of his or her profession and those good corporate citizens are largely ignored and lumped in with the bad apples.
Perrie
I too have had some interns that received college credit for their internships but we still paid them as they were adding value to our bottom line.
A good program attracts good students for internships and those interns many times turn into good employees when they graduate, if they are taken care of and feel valued.