Mississippi River Mouth Must Be Abandoned to Save New Orleans from Next Hurricane Katrina
Hurricane Katrina demolished New Orleans 10 years ago, a grim anniversary to be marked next week. Huge earthen levees dissolved and concrete floodwalls toppled over. But the real culprit when the tropical cyclone made landfall was outside the city. Thousands of square miles of wetland marshes and swamps that had once provided a buffer between the city's coastline and the ocean had been badly tattered from decades of human damage . Thick, robust wetlands would have absorbed much of the surge of water that Katrina pushed up from the Gulf of Mexico. But levees had starved the wetlands of needed nutrients, making plants weak, and thousands of miles of manmade canals had torn the vegetation apart, allowing Katrinas onrushing storm surge to flow right into New Orleans.
![]()
An image from 2001of the active delta front before Hurricanes Katrina and Rita destroyed much of itin 2005. Credit: NASA
Extensive studies done after Katrina verified what lifelong residents of southeastern Louisiana already knew: Unless the rapidly disappearing wetlands are made healthy again, restoring the natural defense, New Orleans will soon lay naked against the sea (see satellite image, below).
So, how does one reengineer the entire Mississippi River deltaone of the largest in the worldon which New Orleans lies?
Three international engineering and design teams have reached a startling answer: leave the mouth of the Mississippi River to die. Let the badly failing wetlands there completely wither away, becoming open water, so that the upper parts of the delta closer to the city can be saved. The teams, winners of the Changing Course Design Competition , revealed their detailed plans on August 20. Graphics from each plan are below.
Scientists worldwide agree that the deltas wetlands disintegrated because we humans built long leveeshigh, continuous ridges of earth covered by grass or rocksalong the entire length of the lower Mississippi River. The leveed river rims the southern boundary of New Orleans and continues another 40 serpentine miles until it reaches the gulf. The levees, erected almost exclusively by the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, prevented regular floods from harming farms, industries and towns along the rivers course. However those floods also would have supplied the brackish marshes with massive quantities of silt and freshwater, which are necessary for their survival.
Silt carries nutrients that grasses and mangroves need to stay lush, and it provides new material to build up the soft substrate beneath those plants, which subsides naturally under its own weight. Incoming freshwater mixes with the delta's saltwater to create the reduced salinity required by the region's vegetation. This soup also prevents pure ocean water from intruding further inland, which kills grasses and trees from the roots up.
Instead, hundreds of miles of navigation channels, cut by the Corps for more than half a century through the wetlands have torn the wetlands apart from within. So have thousands more miles cut by industry during the same period to build and maintain oil and gas pipelines running in from the Gulf.
The studies done by university experts, engineering firms and the Corps itself since Katrina concur that the only realistic way to reconstitute healthy wetlands is to make cuts in the levees, install gates, and open those gates periodically to allow sediment and freshwater to once again flow into the marshes. The three winning design teams rely heavily on that strategy, yet they also differ in where and how to use the so-called diversion structures.
The river nowadays only carries perhaps half of the sediment it used to, because communities on its banks for hundreds of miles siphon off water for irrigation, industry and many other uses. There is simply not enough sediment to rebuild the entire delta, according to the winning teams, which operated independently. Rather than try that and fail, the teams found it is better to essentially end the river many miles north of the current mouth, where much sediment is sent like a shot out into the deep ocean and lost. Then engineers could redirect all the sediment to portions of the delta closer to New Orleans. Capture every grain, is one teams slogan.
The need to let the end of the delta, known as the birds foot because of its shape, die is also assumed in the official Louisiana Comprehensive Master Plan for a Sustainable Coast , although not necessarily called out in detail. The plan took seven years to develop, after significant political wrangling among state, federal and local authorities.*
The master plan would tap about half the rivers sediment for diversions, and try to restore as much of the delta as possible. Founders of the Changing Course competition, led by the Van Alen Institute and the Environmental Defense Fund , and supported by the Rockefeller Foundation, Kresge Foundation and other large institutions, saw that approach as a weakness, and announced the competition to seek alternative ideas.
The competition also encouraged a 100-year outlook for the delta, instead of the 50 years outlined in the master plan. In the end, the three winning blueprints, chosen from 21 entrants, complement the state plan well, says Steve Cochran, director for Mississippi River Delta Restoration at the Environmental Defense Fund, who oversaw the competition.
Cochran also hopes the winning designs will prove valuable to other delta regions around the world: Every place is different, but the kinds of innovations needed are similar.
Only one of the three groups, the Baird Team, included a cost estimate: between $4.3 billion and $5.7 billion. But it also cited savings of up to $2 billion in eliminating the need to replace certain aging flood control structures now on the river. The other two plans are larger in scope and would likely be more expensive. Cochran says his committee did not require cost estimates because the state and the Corps would decide which aspects of the plans to implement, and do their own estimates.
The winning teams received neither prize money nor other rewards. The teams got involved primarily to gain notoriety for potential large contracts in the future. The coming work in southeastern Louisiana is huge, even on a global scale, Cochran notes. The real goal for Changing Course was to educate the state, the Corps and other industries and authorities that will be involved in reengineering the region about how to best exploit the Mississippi River to save the region. The teams have been explaining their ideas to all these people along the way, Cochran says.
Additional details of the three plans are shown below. The full set of designs can be obtained online from Changing Course .
http://www.scientificamerican.com/article/mississippi-river-mouth-must-be-abandoned-to-save-new-orleans-from-next-hurricane-katrina/
Tags
Who is online
55 visitors

It seems almost counter-intuitive that we need to let the Mississippi delta die in order to save the Mississippi delta, but that is the conclusion of the experts.
A series of photos demonstrate the conclusions
Credit: USGS and NASA
Image courtesy of Changing Course
Image courtesy of Changing Course
Image courtesy of Changing Course
Interesting plans. The best plan is by Mother Nature, which we have seldom listened to in the past.
I would agree that something has to be done. I like the Studio Misi-Ziibi (Ojibwe for Mississippi) plan. Save the entire Delta. The money would come from not getting into another useless war.
Kavika
Appreciate the feedback
The best plan is by Mother Nature
I think that is somewhat the path being advocated, though some of the outerwetlands will be lost, the closer in wetlands and the city itself will be protected
It is not perfect for sure, but better than doing nothing - not letting perfect get in the way of better as they say,
RIO, the Misi-Ziipi plan would save almost everything. That I'm for.
And that is the "perfect" that I mentioned above, which we are unlikely to get, so shouldn't we at least try for better than currently projected
Dear Friends RIO and Kavika: I agree with you both.
Let nature be nature.
We need wetlands.
We need to be better stewards of the environment.
Here is to living more in harmony with Mother Earth.
Enoch, Walking, not driving today. (In summer, I prefer to walk, rather than starting my car).
RIO, something is better than nothing. Sadly we rarely fix things they way they should be, but do less than is really needed.
Of course I'm for almost complete restoration, but unfortunately will have to settle for less, if anything at all.
Enoch
Your feedback and perspective is always valued
Thanks for sharing it
A good and peaceful day to you
Well said - hard t argue with that view
Same for you and yours Robert.
E.
The satellite photos are certainly beautiful, aren't they?
Maybe we should ask Holland for help. They should know what to do about deltas, etc. Maybe if we stopped messing with things, they would be all right and rebuild themselves.
I'm all for restoration of whatever we can, but maybe we need to just get ourselves out of the equation-- stop trying to fix things, and just let nature take its course. If sea levels rise, New Orleans, and a whole lot of other places, will be uninhabitable, anyway...
Dowser
Great points!
Thanks for the feedback and perspective
Several Billion $$ seems to be an awfully high price to pay for an unlikely event like a repetition of Katrina . I would think it would be a lot cheaper to relocate the population with buses in such an event .
Another hurricane, even one not as strong as Katrina, coming right up the delta pipe into New Orleans will be devastating
Evacuation is certainly part of the reaction process to a hurricane, but other actions can be taken to protect the wetlands in the delta and protect the city
Isn't such a specific course highly improbable ?
Thread removed for being off topic.k Gronkjaer suspended for 2 days for multiple CoC violations and personal attacks.
What wildlife would be affected by allowing this area to die off?
Revitalizing a large river delta even just for plant life would be a very big undertaking .
We have been waiting 20 years now for the predicted sea level rise that never seems to come.
I agree with the plan to let the Mississippi rebuild the delta itself, it built it in the first place.
Would probably take a few score years, but would probably be faster than anything man could devise. (mother nature is rather resilient that way)
But there is no arguing with the point of why do we mess with mother nature at all? We cannot bend her to our will, Katrina proved that beyond any shadow of doubt.
I imagine that at some point in the future, the mighty Mississippi will flow unhindered to the sea again. And rebuild everything we have destroyed. When we finally get sick and tired of rebuilding New Orleans. Or wind up extinct.
I bet you would get great odds on which one happens first. (but you would never live long enough to collect that bet)
N M
A great point, nature finds a way as they say.
Great points and well presented perspective - thank you for the feedback
The geography of the air sort of funnels that way
As to the odds, I am not sure that anyone really handicaps mother nature that well
scremminmimi
Great question - I do not know
It is possible that it would migrate to the reforming wetlands that would be preserved, again I am not sure
Actually the point of the one approach is to let mother nature revitalize the a portion of the area
jennilee
I have family that lives in Florida and would never consider living anywhere else and I simply laugh when they bitch and complain about hurricanes, tropical storms, storm surge and property dame (not to mention property insurance costs).
I tell them -you live where hurricanes happen learn to like and accept that or move. I live in NE Ohio, it snows a lot - rather than complain about I bought a snow blower, and now I am moving to a development where someone else plows and shovels the snow - problem solved.
jennilee
To paraphrase a former president "that depends on how you define a lot!"
It is telling though that our three boys (Florida, California, Missouri) rend to visit in the non-winter months - I wonder if there is a lesson there?
We are starting to think that a visit to our son in Jacksonville in Jan or Feb should be part of our winter planning in retirement - we love to go see the one in Missouri in the fall and the weather is sort of the same all the time in San Francisco so that is always an option.
I love New Orleans. We go every other year, usually early April. Love the food and people.
The French Quarter used to have the best in Jazz and Blues, but the last few years it's turned to hard rock and country...A shame for sure.
I have visited New Orleans several times and it is always great fun!
Greta photos