I actually found this heart breaking. In the one of the richest countries in the world, how do we find it acceptable for these people to go without healthcare? They are hard working and proud and they don't want to beg. If it wasn't for these people who are angels on earth, they would go without any health care. How sad is that?
It is disgusting that the legislature in W Virginia can't get it worked out with their governor. I wonder how many people they represent really understand what is going on?
It really is heartbreaking. Sadly, many of our politicians don't seem to think that it's a big deal that we have this situation. Ofcourse, the useless SOB's have only the best healthcare, paid for my you and I.
The bigger tragedy is that there are thousands of areas just like this across the country. One of the problems is that so many of us forget the Ramon noodle days once we get gainful employment. And once the money starts to add up for us we distance ourselves more and more until those Ramon noodle days are just a dim memory.
Now, to get the "emotional" responses - why does the government have to give you insurance??? Show me, in the Constitution's Bill of Rights, that insurance is a "Right".
This isn't about Obamacare, it's about the Medicaid cut off. These folks are too poor to pay for Obamacare. You make want to blame this on the coal industry (actually more coal is being burned as clean coal, they are just not mining anymore), but it also is going on in Penn. where the iron mills used to be. And these are not lazy bums. They work hard. You are making an excellent case for not working. Then they would get medicaid.
Royal:
While it is true that this has always been this way for people of Appalachia, it doesn't make it right. We are actually behind Cuba when it comes to infant mortality. What does that say about us?
Totally concur there will be poor people. But the onus of "providing" for those poor people is not on the rest of the population nor on the government. The people and the government are not "required" to support the poor people.
Nor does giving land to others in there. I see the preamble says We the people, notI and the rest go pound sand. There are many things directly missing in the Constitution.
When I lived in the Boston area many years ago I worked for the organization that managed the funds for the social services groups such as Food Stamps, Meals on Wheels, Spanish Center, Senior Citizens Community Outreach, etc.
I asked my boss, the director, how someone like the congressmen who voted on whether we were funded from year to year, could possibly understand how some of these people felt not knowing where their next meal was coming from or even if they were going to GET a next meal.
He said they don't think or care about the "people" in the programs or about the programs. What they think about is how little money they can get by with giving the majority of the masses, and promising the rest that more is coming, to keep them from revolting against government and causing anarchy and it didn't matter which party was in control of Congress it was a joint effort... just prevent a revolt.
He was friendly with several members of Congress from both parties.
Opted to NOT take the three year TEMPORARY bribe. It blamed the state, and blamed Republicans.
Yes it did, but maybe I was still in shock how you focused in on the smoker and seemed to ignore all the other sick folks with basic health issues. Long before Obamacare, these folks didn't have basic health care.. it also mentioned that too. These woman have been doing this for years.
I am not a fan of Obamacare, since it was poorly conceived, but it was the only thing that could get passed, so there you have it. But as the world's richest nation, I think we should be able to provide basic care for hard working Americans. Sorry that you don't feel that way.
America's Real healthcare problem is that health care is upwards of 5x more expensive there than the rest of the world and that the rate of increase is higher as well. The number of uninsured are simply a SYMPTOM of this problem. ACA does not address the actual problem, until something does, the symptom of people without insurance will continue. Why is everything so much more expensive here, why can I go to "Canada on-line Pharmacy" and buy the same drugs for less than half what they cost here? THIS is the REAL problem with our healthcare.
And millions of people know already, without a 60 minute slant of what THEY are just figuring out. Or can't pretend about, anymore.
OK so we are going with the "Kill the messenger" defence instead of asking why should hard working Americans should go without health care. Like I said, they would be better off not working. But hey, then you could call them lazy... so for them it's a lose, lose... that has zero impact on you personally.
You are spot on Mimi. And in no way am I blaming a specific party about this. I feel that both parties are guilty of turning their backs on these people. They didn't just suddenly show up... they have been here for a very, very long time.
John - that is a socialist point of view, i.e. - the state should take care of all.
For thousands of years, there have been rich, middle-class and poor people. Even in Sweden, Finland, Iceland where socialism, social medicine is abundant, there a poor people. There will ALWAYS be poor people. If "society" wants to take care of that issue, let society take care of it. It is NOT the government's responsibility to take care of everybody - that is society's responsibility and, right now, that is sadly lacking.
Sadly, the Declaration of Independence is not what this country operates from. The Declaration of Independence was our manifesto of complaints against the European monarchies. The U. S. Constitution is our Standard Operating Procedure.
Show me, in the Constitution's Bill of Rights, that insurance is a "Right"
You don't understand the constitution obviously. The document "prohibits" or "proscribes" certain actions. If an action not expressly "prohibited", then it can legally be "prescribed" by our legislators or by an act of the federal courts. The constitution is silent on the issue of health insurance which means laws can be constitutionally mandated to allow for it.
"We The People" may petition our government to provide health care, there is NOTHING in the constitution which prohibits it.
Don't take this wrong Aeon - this is not a slam - but - I do understand the Constitution much better than you.
The Constitution can ONLY be changed by being amended by approval of 2/3's of the states and by Congressional concurrence. So, no, they can't "add" healthcare into their interpretations of the Constitution without amending the Constitution.
Yes, the Constitution is silent on the issue of Healthcare, but no, laws can't be "constitutionally mandated" to allow for it. The Constitution has no "Mandating" authority with which to require healthcare.
I do understand the Constitution much better than you.
Funny joke.
The Constitution can ONLY be changed by being amended by approval of 2/3's of the states and by Congressional concurrence.
And you claim to know more than me about the constitution? LOL. It does not require a "constitutional amendment" merely to enact a law providing for health care. Check this out; Things That Are Not In the U.S. Constitution , I mean for crying out loud, the ACA was a law not a constitutional amendment.
So, no, they can't "add" healthcare into their interpretations of the Constitution without amending the Constitution.
It's a little late to be asking that question. While all those other countries were honing their universal healthcare systems, we were ignoring that concept and allowing the free market to capitalize on peoples' concern for their well-being. Trying to undo what we've done with the cost of US healthcare will probably be as difficult as undoing what we've done to the environment through fossil fuels.
You have shown, quite obviously, that I do know more than you.
Congress enacts laws - hence Obamacare. Obamacare started as a slip, then it became a slip law then, after approval of the Congress, became a statute and then was codified into a law. It is not a regulation, as yet, it is still a law.
Technically, SCOTUS is the reviewing body of all statutes to determine if they are in compliance with the Constitution - if not, it is nulled and sent back to Congress to fix.
Obamacare, as a whole, can't be appealed, however, portions of the law, that the legal profession believe to be in violation of the Constitution, can be appealed.
Yes, you are out of your league on this one, but nice try.
Nice spin job but you are not using knowledge and logic.
The U.S. Supreme Court upheld President Barack Obama's sweeping health care legislation -- the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act -- in a narrow 5-4 ruling. -
How the hell did the Supreme Court uphold the constitutionality of a law (not a constitutional amendment) that according to YOU, is unconstitutional? That doesn't make sense.
Technically, your grasping at straws here....I call it quibbling. And now you are backing away from your original statement.
Technically SCOTUS is working on the next case on their docket at the moment, not reviewing anything ACA oriented. That's the job of congress.
Robert, what ten things? You mentioned Obama changed coal laws, I asked you to show me. You mentioned that the woman was a smoker... implying her poor choice, I pointed out that they showed people that were getting just basic medical care. You mentioned that CBS noted that it was Republicans that voted down the stop gap and I pointed out that this has been going on for much longer than Obamacare. You mentioned that CBS is biased. That may be true, but so are these facts.
The amici is an opinion of the lawyers filing the brief. They do bring up some points, but, as to whether or not those points are legally definable and defensible, that is for SCOTUS to determine. I did notice that, during the hearings, SCOTUS never even addressed the "tax" issue.
Medicaid/medicaire are not additional taxes. They are collected and funded through FICA which is tied to Title 26, Internal Revenue Service Tax Code, and was passed and enacted in 1936 by the Roosevelt administration to fund Social Security. SCOTUS has ruled that Congress has that authority under their Congressional powers section of the Constitution, Article 1, Section 8.
Why do I have to answer my own questions. Looks pretty much like tiny WV is number 3, so how is Obama affecting them. Your turn to find an actual link.
How is anything I said a personal attack? I might have stuck words into your mouth, but I was doing that based on your responses. Still my bad... but not as bad as jab you got in there calling me ignorant. I'll let it go. Here let me say it another way.... who would you say, in your own words, should be helping these people... or do we not help them at all?
It's been going on for decades... not just during the Obama administration. I blame them all.
Aeon - I know this is over your head, but my "original" comment was - " Show me, in the Constitution's Bill of Rights, that insurance is a "Right". " - .
The Constitution does not "require", through any of its articles or amendments, that citizens of the U. S. will be "given" health insurance. That was my statement.
However, through the law-making process, if written properly, health insurance can become a law - as long as it is done, properly, in accordance with the Constitution.
No - the Constitution does NOT prescribe rules for its own interpretation. In 1803, Marbury v. Madison , 5 U.S. 137 (1803), was a landmark United States Supreme Court case in which the Court formed the basis for the exercise of judicial review in the United States under Article III of the Constitution . In that case, the Supreme Court "decided" that THEY determine the rules of review of cases involving Constitutional concerns through Statutory interpretation.
Statutory interpretation is the process by which courts interpret and apply legislation . Some amount of interpretation is often necessary when a case involves a statute . Sometimes the words of a statute have a plain and straightforward meaning. But in many cases, there is some ambiguity or vagueness in the words of the statute that must be resolved by the judge.
I'm not denying or stating that it can't John. A single payer policy can be done, if properly done through the Congressional processes - which, IMHO, Obamacare was not because the tax issue did not originate in the House of Representatives.
My main point is that there is nothing in the Constitution that states citizens are required to have health insurance. How that statement has gotten to here - I dunno
1) I have proved you are clueless on constitutional issues.
2) I proved that the ACA was not unconstitutional. You keep moving the goal posts with irrelevant commentary.
3) I have proved that just because the constitution does not specifically mention something, does not legally prohibit such laws from being enacted by congress.
4) SCOTUS has already ruled that the ACA is constitutional.
4) You don't read links which are proof. evidence and facts...which you don't like. Hell, you didn't even read the article; Does the Constitution prescribe rules for its own interpretation . On page 933 it clearly states;
5) You've been given an opportunity to present your case. Your case is illogical and flawed. You have given your opinion which holds zero weight. No proof, evidence or facts.
If you cant construct argument based on facts, and legal logic, don't waste my time with your bullshit.
You keep referring back to Obamacare, as if that was the cause of all of this. It isn't. It was there before Obamacare, and these nurses and doctor were doing this long before, too. These people lacked care for decades, here, in the riches country in the world. You seem to think that I am transfixed on Obamacare, or the three year stop gap, I am not. Personally, I would have rather had a European style of healthcare, but that would have never gone down here. I would have liked the system to have worked like Medicaid, but it doesn't.
And while you bring names like Pelosi who I personally despise into this discussion...I can say that we have been talking about a healthcare system even as far back as Nixon. He wanted it. But politics aside, and silly quips like wanting a million dollars, this is a basic need to life and one as a society we should be able to give to those who work hard and give back to society.
"If" it were processed properly and followed all the steps required under House and Senate rules in accordance with the parameters established in the Constitution, i.e. House of Representatives offering payment through collection of some sort of fee/tax, and SCOTUS (whhoooppeeee dooooo), in their review of it and finds it within the boundaries established in the Constitution, sure, it'd be a good law. But - it still wouldn't be a "Constitutional" right - just a right authorized by statute/law.
"I have proved you are clueless on constitutional issues" - where??? With a friggin law student's article where he quotes two SCOTUS decisions that thoroughly supports my comments??? - Read further young one -"And finally, where the text of the Constitutionsuppliesno rule or principle concerning the issue in question, theConstitution is not a source of governing law concerning that matter;thedecision defaults to some other source of governing law."
You say - "does not legally prohibit such laws from being enacted by congress." - and I concurred.
You said - "You've been given an opportunity to present your case. Your case is illogical and flawed. You have given your opinion which holds zero weight. No proof, evidence or facts." - giving you links to SCOTUS decisions and Constitutional links are not proof????
"If you cant construct argument based on facts, and legal logic, don't waste my time with your bullshit." - then you need to get off this discussion - you are way over your head - and your eyes are brown.
John - truthfully, I don't know of any way that society can handle all the things that, IMHO, they need to take care. That's one of the huge problems that Roosevelt and Johnson ran into which is primarily why the New Deal and the Great Society laws came from - society wasn't taking care of its own.
What I personally don't like seeing is where the government is taking on more and more and more of societies ills through "entitlement programs". Industry should be getting involved more - communities should be getting involved more - families should be getting involved more. Instead, we are getting a quagmire of governmental interference/insertion and it gets frightening as to how much intrusion do we "truly" need from the government???
Obamacare will cover extra medicaid expenses for states for three years.
Then what?
Maybe then we stop subsidizing corporations and exempting them from Federal taxes.
Beyond that
Beginning in 2014 coverage for the newly eligible adults will be fully funded by the federal government for three years. It will phase down to 90% by 2020.
90%!
By then, maybe some Republicans will grow a soul.
It's about human beings who could get sick or DIE not politics.
Here.. let me say it... other than doing away with pre-existing conditions, Obamacare with all it's fixes still falls way short of the mark and probably will not work out. I can't say it sucks yet, since it has to actually be sucking to do that, which we are not up to yet. Do you feel better? Probably not, since it isn't partisan enough for you. Now that I have said it, was there another plan in the works that would have solved this problem? I read the Republican plan... it wasn't any better in this regard. Cheaper.. probably... but wouldn't help these people.
And no I didn't just realize it. But I also didn't just realize that we have a large amount of people who need basic health care, for decades now.
OK Robert, since we both know how it plays out from here, this will be my last posting about this... you can have the last word.
People have been going without healthcare for 238 years - that's a fact. It is not the government's job to provide healthcare - that's a fact (in my mind, anyway). Healthcare has been and still is an "option" that people have and that is and has beentheir choice. What do you want to do - take away individual choices?
The whole concept that health care is optional is like Marie Antoinette, telling the poor to "let them eat cake". It's a mindset.
When I worked in the "hood" I would see parents have to chose between taking their kid to the dr for strep throat or make ends meet. What ended up happening is the kid would get scarlet fever or worse rheumatic fever and then end up in the hospital with heart problems. Does that seem like a choice to you?
We the People of the United States, in Order to form a more perfect Union, establish Justice, insure domestic Tranquility , provide for the common defence , promote the general Welfare , and secure the Blessings of Liberty to ourselves and our Posterity , do ordain and establish this Constitution for the United States of America.
Then there's
"Government of the people, by the people, for the people, shall not perish from the Earth."
Going to assume that's directed to me?? If so, "promote the general welfare" does not say nor does it mean "Provide, free of charge, anything the people want." It means advocate, or to help (something) happen, develop, or increase - there's no "provide" in that definition.Presenting options/opportunities/venues is helping.
John - I agree with you on that - something needs to be made available.
Perrie - please don't try to sad-eyed, teary-faced trick with me. I've been to countries where there is NO insurance and few, if any, doctors or medical facilities. I have seen a lot more "sad" than you have in the "hood". And, no, the example of Marie is a very bad one also. "Let them eat cake"????
238 years Perrie - 238 years of deciding whether or not to choose to have some form of coverage and now folks are saying "oh no, I want it for free" and that makes it good? That makes it something where you have no choice. As John says, there are plenty of people who CHOOSE not to have healthcare - some good, some bad - but it is their choice.
The present government we have will turn the horse into a camel after all their committee work. I wouldn't/don't want them making any decision for me - that is MY choice - not theirs.
If so, "promote the general welfare" does not say nor does it mean "Provide, free of charge, anything the people want." It means advocate, or to help (something) happen, develop, or increase - there's no "provide" in that definition.Presenting options/opportunities/venues is helping.
And who is saying it means that? No one I know.
Food stamps for example go to THE WORKING POOR; they work full time for crap wages and the government provides food stamps WHICH IS A SUBSIDY TO WAL-MART and other employers who fatten their bottom lines at the expense of tax payers.
Workers pay into UNEMPLOYMENT INSURANCE so that's not free either.
And if not THE PEOPLE, for whom is the promoting of "general welfare"?
Corporations are making record profits, give out big CEO salary packages, get government subsidies and many of the largest PAY NO FEDERAL TAXES.
When jobs are exported, when thieves on Wall Street cause home foreclosures and a down economy, IT'S THE PEOPLE WHO PAY THE PRICE; we bailed out Wall Street and the Banksters and now the big bonuses have returned -- and while they were fucking us over, they were getting the Bush tax cuts.
Health care in the U.S. was, and is,provided by employers, and blossomed during WWII due to wage controls imposed by the government. In order to draw employees, and off set the wage controls, companies used health care as a benefit to draw new employees.
The 238 years is a straw man argument 1st. This country has not been deciding on this for that amount of time.
Universal healthcare was proposed by FDR, and later by Harry Truman. Both saw the need for it.
Comparing 3rd world countries to the U.S. is not a comparison. I too have been to many 3rd world countries, and a comparison of the U.S. to them is disingenuous. I lived in countries with National Health care, (Australia, Canada) and found it to be a much better system then what we have in the U.S.
A fair comparison would be the U.S. vs developed countries. When you match up those countries, you'll find that the U.S. falls short in in many things.Many of those''socialistic countries'' are far ahead of us, not only in health care, but by many other standards.
The argument of,I want the choice is interesting. Of course we all want the choice of what ever it is we are disagreeing with. ''For the greater good'' is always an interesting debate. I don't like paying taxes, but if everyone felt that way, how would we run the country? Roads, and all the other things that those taxes provide for us, is part of the deal.
I do not see anything wrong with Universal Health Care, having actually lived under it, I would do it again.
Is ACA the answer, I don't think it is, because of the obvious problems that it has created, it could and should have been done in a way that it would actually cover those in need.
I choose to try to make it a workable system, that covers all Americans. It may not be a right, but it's the ''right thing to do''.
That's when vans stated loading up people with mental health issues at the medical facilities where mental health personnel were being laid off, diving them to the busy parts of town, and dropping them off. No place to house them any more, no personnel to care for them, no funds for their meds.
Poor people wouldn't be if we had a Congress with fewer Republicans, one that would raise the minimum wage and stop sabotaging jobs bills to make Obama look bad!
I'M OLD MIKE; WOULD YOU LIKE ME TO DIE TO HELP SOLVE THE HEALTH CARE PROBLEM?
SICK PEOPLE ARE ACTUALLY HUMAN BEINGS.
Take health insurance off the backs of employers, implement Single Payer that's the fix!
After all these years, I know when you're rattling my cage; but there are others who will not acknowledge your use of hyperbole for effect, or, who actually think your comments represent "the way things really ought to be".
So, I just come back at you to keep them on their toes.
It keeps me sharp as well so don't stop being Mike or whoever you are this week.
We have millions of illegal aliens who are outside the health care umbrella and that is not a good thing for any of us or for our children who attend school with them. We also have illegal aliens who have experience in the health care industry who cannot practice here because they are not certified and cannot afford the education process to become certified.
Theyhave to take jobs driving taxis, or working in fast food, or things completely outside the medical field because they simply cannot afford to re-engage with our educational system to go through all the expense of med school, internship, etc., to qualify for the same degree they held in their home country.
While I understand that some may not have been "up to snuff" with regard to qualifications for an MD, I fail to believe all of them could not qualify for some type of special program that could qualify them for a paramedic or nursing program that could fast track them toward a degree.
If there are people with these skills who are in the illegal alien community and we are going to allow them residence here anyway, we should at least provide some way for the skilled among them touse their skills in a way that is most beneficial and offers earning potential.
There must be a way to connect the illegal aliens who need some medical assistance and who would go to someone they trusted, with a qualified person under supervision from the medical community.
America's Real healthcare problem is that health care is upwards of 5x more expensive there than the rest of the world and that the rate of increase is higher as well.
Attribute that to the "for-profit-health-care-as-a-commodity" model which includes 31 cents of every premium dollar going to waste (prior to ACA), outrageous CEO pay packages (in the last few years, the CEO of United Health Insurance made $50,000 AN HOUR !), and clerical departments devoted to finding ways to deny claims!
Attorney General Outraged Over Reported $102 Million Payday For United Healthcare CEO, Urges Insurance Department To Weigh Executive Pay In Future Rate Cases
It is never too late. Ignoring the problem and treating the symptom is not going to fix the problem and will make the symptom worse. What you are suggesting is throwing in the towel. That isn't the way we work in this country, at least it didn't used to be...
1st, I'm aware that Jefferson said that. The reason that I don't believe that it is revelent, is that I don't believe that he would have covered all Americans. His history is not one of ''all men are created equal''. Being a slave owner, it don't see him or the U.S. at the time covering Blacks or Indians.
That is an outstanding idea! I have to say, that would solve an lot of problems.
Did you know that we are the only western country that requires MD's from other countries to go through med school again? My cousin is a doctor in England, and he wanted to come here to live, but he doesn't want to go through med school again after being in practice for about 15 years.
With ACA, there will be a shortage of MDs. The med schools know this, but they are behind the curve.
I'm not suggesting that at all. I'm merely pointing out the reality that the rampant capitalist approach to healthcare is what got us here. If it were up to me there would be immediate regulatory action to mandate costs to be in line with what the rest of the developed world experiences. The fact is, that would definitely be perceived by the right as a fascist move by a federal government abusing it's power like never before in history. Instead, they pretend that there's some magical free market solution that will cut healthcare costs by two thirds (still making our the most expensive in the world btw.) Our current healthcare system is rife with conflicts of interest that will never allow a significant reduction in prices for goods and services. Healthcare should never have been a for-profit venture. Obama haters know this is a fact, and they know that the only realistic solution is a paradigm shift that will be perceived as an attack on the private sector. They want the costs to get under control, and yet they would equally want to villianize the POTUS for making it happen.
I have been thinking about this for a few years. Read about doctors who come here having to drive cabs, work food stands. It's insane.
We have illnesses and diseases among the illegal aliens getting footholds in the US because they fear to go to clinics and they aren't checked because they crossed the border illegally.A way for med students to intern could be to supervise these people in street clinics or, good grief, in the holding areas of immigration where they say there are people who need medical care.
It is foolish in the extreme to waste this wealth of expertise because of the AMA rules even if we have to form a new branch of it to deal with this situation.
I'm not a fool. We are at the point where the people to fast track need to be those with remarkable skills... not those doing jobs that Americans supposedly "won't" do but those with skills that most Americans "can't" do. Bi-lingual medical personnel familiar with illnesses and diseases common to areas these illegal aliens are migrating from would fit that category.
And as you said, we will have a shortage of doctors for everyone with ACA. Right now, most doctors in my area are not accepting new patients.
With ACA, there will be a shortage of MDs. The med schools know this, but they are behind the curve.
I too think that mimi has a good idea . As far as the AMA being "behind the curve " ... it depends on which curve . They are waaaay out in front of the "restraint of trade" curve !
I actually found this heart breaking. In the one of the richest countries in the world, how do we find it acceptable for these people to go without healthcare? They are hard working and proud and they don't want to beg. If it wasn't for these people who are angels on earth, they would go without any health care. How sad is that?
It is disgusting that the legislature in W Virginia can't get it worked out with their governor. I wonder how many people they represent really understand what is going on?
It really is heartbreaking. Sadly, many of our politicians don't seem to think that it's a big deal that we have this situation. Ofcourse, the useless SOB's have only the best healthcare, paid for my you and I.
The bigger tragedy is that there are thousands of areas just like this across the country. One of the problems is that so many of us forget the Ramon noodle days once we get gainful employment. And once the money starts to add up for us we distance ourselves more and more until those Ramon noodle days are just a dim memory.
Now, to get the "emotional" responses - why does the government have to give you insurance??? Show me, in the Constitution's Bill of Rights, that insurance is a "Right".
Nor does it mention taking land from others in there, right?
To Robert:
This isn't about Obamacare, it's about the Medicaid cut off. These folks are too poor to pay for Obamacare. You make want to blame this on the coal industry (actually more coal is being burned as clean coal, they are just not mining anymore), but it also is going on in Penn. where the iron mills used to be. And these are not lazy bums. They work hard. You are making an excellent case for not working. Then they would get medicaid.
Royal:
While it is true that this has always been this way for people of Appalachia, it doesn't make it right. We are actually behind Cuba when it comes to infant mortality. What does that say about us?
Totally concur there will be poor people. But the onus of "providing" for those poor people is not on the rest of the population nor on the government. The people and the government are not "required" to support the poor people.
Zackly Royal.
BTW, our Declaration of Independence says:
We hold these truths to be self-evident , that all men are created equal , that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights , that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness .
They are trying to pursuit happiness. It's hard when you work hard but can't cover basic medical needs.
Total on point Larry!
When I lived in the Boston area many years ago I worked for the organization that managed the funds for the social services groups such as Food Stamps, Meals on Wheels, Spanish Center, Senior Citizens Community Outreach, etc.
I asked my boss, the director, how someone like the congressmen who voted on whether we were funded from year to year, could possibly understand how some of these people felt not knowing where their next meal was coming from or even if they were going to GET a next meal.
He said they don't think or care about the "people" in the programs or about the programs. What they think about is how little money they can get by with giving the majority of the masses, and promising the rest that more is coming, to keep them from revolting against government and causing anarchy and it didn't matter which party was in control of Congress it was a joint effort... just prevent a revolt.
He was friendly with several members of Congress from both parties.
Yes it did, but maybe I was still in shock how you focused in on the smoker and seemed to ignore all the other sick folks with basic health issues. Long before Obamacare, these folks didn't have basic health care.. it also mentioned that too. These woman have been doing this for years.
I am not a fan of Obamacare, since it was poorly conceived, but it was the only thing that could get passed, so there you have it. But as the world's richest nation, I think we should be able to provide basic care for hard working Americans. Sorry that you don't feel that way.
Please find me those rules.
America's Real healthcare problem is that health care is upwards of 5x more expensive there than the rest of the world and that the rate of increase is higher as well. The number of uninsured are simply a SYMPTOM of this problem. ACA does not address the actual problem, until something does, the symptom of people without insurance will continue. Why is everything so much more expensive here, why can I go to "Canada on-line Pharmacy" and buy the same drugs for less than half what they cost here? THIS is the REAL problem with our healthcare.
OK so we are going with the "Kill the messenger" defence instead of asking why should hard working Americans should go without health care. Like I said, they would be better off not working. But hey, then you could call them lazy... so for them it's a lose, lose... that has zero impact on you personally.
1st, a society is judged by how it treats it's worst off. You may be comfortable not seeing these folks, but I am not.
You are spot on Mimi. And in no way am I blaming a specific party about this. I feel that both parties are guilty of turning their backs on these people. They didn't just suddenly show up... they have been here for a very, very long time.
BF, did you watch the video?
These people work. This is all they can do, given where they live. This has nothing to do with poor choices.
John - that is a socialist point of view, i.e. - the state should take care of all.
For thousands of years, there have been rich, middle-class and poor people. Even in Sweden, Finland, Iceland where socialism, social medicine is abundant, there a poor people. There will ALWAYS be poor people. If "society" wants to take care of that issue, let society take care of it. It is NOT the government's responsibility to take care of everybody - that is society's responsibility and, right now, that is sadly lacking.
Sadly, the Declaration of Independence is not what this country operates from. The Declaration of Independence was our manifesto of complaints against the European monarchies. The U. S. Constitution is our Standard Operating Procedure.
Ahhhh - but the Constitution does not function by what is NOT in it - as SCOTUS.
You don't understand the constitution obviously. The document "prohibits" or "proscribes" certain actions. If an action not expressly "prohibited", then it can legally be "prescribed" by our legislators or by an act of the federal courts. The constitution is silent on the issue of health insurance which means laws can be constitutionally mandated to allow for it.
"We The People" may petition our government to provide health care, there is NOTHING in the constitution which prohibits it.
Don't take this wrong Aeon - this is not a slam - but - I do understand the Constitution much better than you.
The Constitution can ONLY be changed by being amended by approval of 2/3's of the states and by Congressional concurrence. So, no, they can't "add" healthcare into their interpretations of the Constitution without amending the Constitution.
Yes, the Constitution is silent on the issue of Healthcare, but no, laws can't be "constitutionally mandated" to allow for it. The Constitution has no "Mandating" authority with which to require healthcare.
As you would say - "Sowwy".
Funny joke.
And you claim to know more than me about the constitution? LOL. It does not require a "constitutional amendment" merely to enact a law providing for health care. Check this out; Things That Are Not In the U.S. Constitution , I mean for crying out loud, the ACA was a law not a constitutional amendment.
Before you start off giving me some teabag explanation of the constitution, read this; CONSTITUTIONALITY OF HEALTH CARE REFORM .
You don't know the constitution.
You have shown, quite obviously, that I do know more than you.
Congress enacts laws - hence Obamacare. Obamacare started as a slip, then it became a slip law then, after approval of the Congress, became a statute and then was codified into a law. It is not a regulation, as yet, it is still a law.
Technically, SCOTUS is the reviewing body of all statutes to determine if they are in compliance with the Constitution - if not, it is nulled and sent back to Congress to fix.
Obamacare, as a whole, can't be appealed, however, portions of the law, that the legal profession believe to be in violation of the Constitution, can be appealed.
Yes, you are out of your league on this one, but nice try.
Is he the AG for Kansas? I'd like to read his article - got a thread?
Nice spin job but you are not using knowledge and logic.
The U.S. Supreme Court upheld President Barack Obama's sweeping health care legislation -- the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act -- in a narrow 5-4 ruling. -
How the hell did the Supreme Court uphold the constitutionality of a law (not a constitutional amendment) that according to YOU, is unconstitutional? That doesn't make sense.
Technically, your grasping at straws here....I call it quibbling. And now you are backing away from your original statement.
Technically SCOTUS is working on the next case on their docket at the moment, not reviewing anything ACA oriented. That's the job of congress.
Suggested reading: Does the Constitution prescribe rules for its own interpretation.
Spot on RL. WV is like a thrid world country right here in the US. Even Drs without boarders goes there. That's just wrong.
Robert, what ten things? You mentioned Obama changed coal laws, I asked you to show me. You mentioned that the woman was a smoker... implying her poor choice, I pointed out that they showed people that were getting just basic medical care. You mentioned that CBS noted that it was Republicans that voted down the stop gap and I pointed out that this has been going on for much longer than Obamacare. You mentioned that CBS is biased. That may be true, but so are these facts.
The amici is an opinion of the lawyers filing the brief. They do bring up some points, but, as to whether or not those points are legally definable and defensible, that is for SCOTUS to determine. I did notice that, during the hearings, SCOTUS never even addressed the "tax" issue.
Medicaid/medicaire are not additional taxes. They are collected and funded through FICA which is tied to Title 26, Internal Revenue Service Tax Code, and was passed and enacted in 1936 by the Roosevelt administration to fund Social Security. SCOTUS has ruled that Congress has that authority under their Congressional powers section of the Constitution, Article 1, Section 8.
Robert, do tell where they are mining coal.
Here let me help you:
Why do I have to answer my own questions. Looks pretty much like tiny WV is number 3, so how is Obama affecting them. Your turn to find an actual link.
Nah - different guy - name is similar to the Kansas AG who drafted all of those immigration bills - brain fart, sorry.
How is anything I said a personal attack? I might have stuck words into your mouth, but I was doing that based on your responses. Still my bad... but not as bad as jab you got in there calling me ignorant. I'll let it go. Here let me say it another way.... who would you say, in your own words, should be helping these people... or do we not help them at all?
It's been going on for decades... not just during the Obama administration. I blame them all.
Did not originate in theHouse of Representatives - the word "Shall" is prerogative- it is unconstitutional - period -
All Bills for raising Revenue shall originate in the House of Representatives; but the Senate may propose or concur with Amendments as on other Bills.
ARTICLE I, SECTION 7, CLAUSE 1
Aeon - I know this is over your head, but my "original" comment was - " Show me, in the Constitution's Bill of Rights, that insurance is a "Right". " - .
The Constitution does not "require", through any of its articles or amendments, that citizens of the U. S. will be "given" health insurance. That was my statement.
However, through the law-making process, if written properly, health insurance can become a law - as long as it is done, properly, in accordance with the Constitution.
No - the Constitution does NOT prescribe rules for its own interpretation. In 1803, Marbury v. Madison , 5 U.S. 137 (1803), was a landmark United States Supreme Court case in which the Court formed the basis for the exercise of judicial review in the United States under Article III of the Constitution . In that case, the Supreme Court "decided" that THEY determine the rules of review of cases involving Constitutional concerns through Statutory interpretation.
Statutory interpretation is the process by which courts interpret and apply legislation . Some amount of interpretation is often necessary when a case involves a statute . Sometimes the words of a statute have a plain and straightforward meaning. But in many cases, there is some ambiguity or vagueness in the words of the statute that must be resolved by the judge.
That is SCOTUS's job, not the Constitutions.
And, as I said, medicare is funded through FICA taxes, not as a separate tax, as is specified by the IRS Codes.
I'm not denying or stating that it can't John. A single payer policy can be done, if properly done through the Congressional processes - which, IMHO, Obamacare was not because the tax issue did not originate in the House of Representatives.
My main point is that there is nothing in the Constitution that states citizens are required to have health insurance. How that statement has gotten to here - I dunno
1) I have proved you are clueless on constitutional issues.
2) I proved that the ACA was not unconstitutional. You keep moving the goal posts with irrelevant commentary.
3) I have proved that just because the constitution does not specifically mention something, does not legally prohibit such laws from being enacted by congress.
4) SCOTUS has already ruled that the ACA is constitutional.
4) You don't read links which are proof. evidence and facts...which you don't like. Hell, you didn't even read the article; Does the Constitution prescribe rules for its own interpretation . On page 933 it clearly states;
If you cant construct argument based on facts, and legal logic, don't waste my time with your bullshit.
Robert,
You keep referring back to Obamacare, as if that was the cause of all of this. It isn't. It was there before Obamacare, and these nurses and doctor were doing this long before, too. These people lacked care for decades, here, in the riches country in the world. You seem to think that I am transfixed on Obamacare, or the three year stop gap, I am not. Personally, I would have rather had a European style of healthcare, but that would have never gone down here. I would have liked the system to have worked like Medicaid, but it doesn't.
And while you bring names like Pelosi who I personally despise into this discussion...I can say that we have been talking about a healthcare system even as far back as Nixon. He wanted it. But politics aside, and silly quips like wanting a million dollars, this is a basic need to life and one as a society we should be able to give to those who work hard and give back to society.
"If" it were processed properly and followed all the steps required under House and Senate rules in accordance with the parameters established in the Constitution, i.e. House of Representatives offering payment through collection of some sort of fee/tax, and SCOTUS (whhoooppeeee dooooo), in their review of it and finds it within the boundaries established in the Constitution, sure, it'd be a good law. But - it still wouldn't be a "Constitutional" right - just a right authorized by statute/law.
Are your eyes brown???? They should be.
"I have proved you are clueless on constitutional issues" - where??? With a friggin law student's article where he quotes two SCOTUS decisions that thoroughly supports my comments??? - Read further young one -"And finally, where the text of the Constitution supplies no rule or principle concerning the issue in question, the Constitution is not a source of governing law concerning that matter; the decision defaults to some other source of governing law."
You say - "does not legally prohibit such laws from being enacted by congress." - and I concurred.
You said - "You've been given an opportunity to present your case. Your case is illogical and flawed. You have given your opinion which holds zero weight. No proof, evidence or facts." - giving you links to SCOTUS decisions and Constitutional links are not proof????
"If you cant construct argument based on facts, and legal logic, don't waste my time with your bullshit." - then you need to get off this discussion - you are way over your head - and your eyes are brown.
John - truthfully, I don't know of any way that society can handle all the things that, IMHO, they need to take care. That's one of the huge problems that Roosevelt and Johnson ran into which is primarily why the New Deal and the Great Society laws came from - society wasn't taking care of its own.
What I personally don't like seeing is where the government is taking on more and more and more of societies ills through "entitlement programs". Industry should be getting involved more - communities should be getting involved more - families should be getting involved more. Instead, we are getting a quagmire of governmental interference/insertion and it gets frightening as to how much intrusion do we "truly" need from the government???
Maybe then we stop subsidizing corporations and exempting them from Federal taxes.
Beyond that
Beginning in 2014 coverage for the newly eligible adults will be fully funded by the federal government for three years. It will phase down to 90% by 2020.
90%!
By then, maybe some Republicans will grow a soul.
It's about human beings who could get sick or DIE not politics.
Robert,
Here.. let me say it... other than doing away with pre-existing conditions, Obamacare with all it's fixes still falls way short of the mark and probably will not work out. I can't say it sucks yet, since it has to actually be sucking to do that, which we are not up to yet. Do you feel better? Probably not, since it isn't partisan enough for you. Now that I have said it, was there another plan in the works that would have solved this problem? I read the Republican plan... it wasn't any better in this regard. Cheaper.. probably... but wouldn't help these people.
And no I didn't just realize it. But I also didn't just realize that we have a large amount of people who need basic health care, for decades now.
OK Robert, since we both know how it plays out from here, this will be my last posting about this... you can have the last word.
People have been going without healthcare for 238 years - that's a fact. It is not the government's job to provide healthcare - that's a fact (in my mind, anyway). Healthcare has been and still is an "option" that people have and that is and has beentheir choice. What do you want to do - take away individual choices?
Healthcare is life. Is eating an option?
The whole concept that health care is optional is like Marie Antoinette, telling the poor to "let them eat cake". It's a mindset.
When I worked in the "hood" I would see parents have to chose between taking their kid to the dr for strep throat or make ends meet. What ended up happening is the kid would get scarlet fever or worse rheumatic fever and then end up in the hospital with heart problems. Does that seem like a choice to you?
Then there's
Abraham Lincoln
Read more at ...Going to assume that's directed to me?? If so, "promote the general welfare" does not say nor does it mean "Provide, free of charge, anything the people want." It means advocate, or to help (something) happen, develop, or increase - there's no "provide" in that definition.Presenting options/opportunities/venues is helping.
John - I agree with you on that - something needs to be made available.
Perrie - please don't try to sad-eyed, teary-faced trick with me. I've been to countries where there is NO insurance and few, if any, doctors or medical facilities. I have seen a lot more "sad" than you have in the "hood". And, no, the example of Marie is a very bad one also. "Let them eat cake"????
238 years Perrie - 238 years of deciding whether or not to choose to have some form of coverage and now folks are saying "oh no, I want it for free" and that makes it good? That makes it something where you have no choice. As John says, there are plenty of people who CHOOSE not to have healthcare - some good, some bad - but it is their choice.
The present government we have will turn the horse into a camel after all their committee work. I wouldn't/don't want them making any decision for me - that is MY choice - not theirs.
And who is saying it means that? No one I know.
Food stamps for example go to THE WORKING POOR; they work full time for crap wages and the government provides food stamps WHICH IS A SUBSIDY TO WAL-MART and other employers who fatten their bottom lines at the expense of tax payers.
Workers pay into UNEMPLOYMENT INSURANCE so that's not free either.
And if not THE PEOPLE, for whom is the promoting of "general welfare"?
Corporations are making record profits, give out big CEO salary packages, get government subsidies and many of the largest PAY NO FEDERAL TAXES.
When jobs are exported, when thieves on Wall Street cause home foreclosures and a down economy, IT'S THE PEOPLE WHO PAY THE PRICE; we bailed out Wall Street and the Banksters and now the big bonuses have returned -- and while they were fucking us over, they were getting the Bush tax cuts.
I rest my case.
1st, you still have no clue about the constitution....but that's ok, just lay off the tea and you'll be fine.
Health care was working great until Reagan went on his deregulation craze.
Have to agree with you there Aeon. Deregulation of agencies that are could lead to abuses, was one of the worst things to ever happen to this country.
I'll make sure my instructors receive your evaluation.
Totally agree.
Health care in the U.S. was, and is,provided by employers, and blossomed during WWII due to wage controls imposed by the government. In order to draw employees, and off set the wage controls, companies used health care as a benefit to draw new employees.
The 238 years is a straw man argument 1st. This country has not been deciding on this for that amount of time.
Universal healthcare was proposed by FDR, and later by Harry Truman. Both saw the need for it.
Comparing 3rd world countries to the U.S. is not a comparison. I too have been to many 3rd world countries, and a comparison of the U.S. to them is disingenuous. I lived in countries with National Health care, (Australia, Canada) and found it to be a much better system then what we have in the U.S.
A fair comparison would be the U.S. vs developed countries. When you match up those countries, you'll find that the U.S. falls short in in many things.Many of those''socialistic countries'' are far ahead of us, not only in health care, but by many other standards.
The argument of,I want the choice is interesting. Of course we all want the choice of what ever it is we are disagreeing with. ''For the greater good'' is always an interesting debate. I don't like paying taxes, but if everyone felt that way, how would we run the country? Roads, and all the other things that those taxes provide for us, is part of the deal.
I do not see anything wrong with Universal Health Care, having actually lived under it, I would do it again.
Is ACA the answer, I don't think it is, because of the obvious problems that it has created, it could and should have been done in a way that it would actually cover those in need.
I choose to try to make it a workable system, that covers all Americans. It may not be a right, but it's the ''right thing to do''.
That's when vans stated loading up people with mental health issues at the medical facilities where mental health personnel were being laid off, diving them to the busy parts of town, and dropping them off. No place to house them any more, no personnel to care for them, no funds for their meds.
Exactly like they did in Nevada - dropping them off in LA, Sacramento and San Francisco. Talk about some pissed off legislatures.
No it wouldn't since they try to charge me for my own meds when I was hospitalized.
And I am one of those sick people you talk of...
And my dad is one of those old ones.
Maybe the issue is that insurance is an unregulated for profit business started as a gambling idea.
Yeah, that might be a bit of the problem.
Us here in NYC, too. Brilliant minds at work.
Kavika,
Well done!
Oh for sure it is. Prayer? You?
But I love ya!
(How'd this damn thing get so big???)238 years - Thomas Jefferson Also Supported Government Run HealthCare - ...
Illegals do not qualify for the ACA.
Poor people wouldn't be if we had a Congress with fewer Republicans, one that would raise the minimum wage and stop sabotaging jobs bills to make Obama look bad!
I'M OLD MIKE; WOULD YOU LIKE ME TO DIE TO HELP SOLVE THE HEALTH CARE PROBLEM?
SICK PEOPLE ARE ACTUALLY HUMAN BEINGS.
Take health insurance off the backs of employers, implement Single Payer that's the fix!
G'night Mike.
I prefer wholistic approaches :
Do you think the prisoners at Auschwitz prayed for anything?
Good luck with the prayer thing.
Mike,
After all these years, I know when you're rattling my cage; but there are others who will not acknowledge your use of hyperbole for effect, or, who actually think your comments represent "the way things really ought to be".
So, I just come back at you to keep them on their toes.
It keeps me sharp as well so don't stop being Mike or whoever you are this week.
Good one Petey!
Ha! touche' or tushee
1st,
It is not unconstitutional, it is extra-constitutional.
This is a healthcare dialogue, PH... no derail about getting touchie with someone's tushie!
Yes it is Swami! What's the good news?
If you guys are going to talk about touching tushie I will have to place parental controls on my keyboard for this thread....
We have millions of illegal aliens who are outside the health care umbrella and that is not a good thing for any of us or for our children who attend school with them. We also have illegal aliens who have experience in the health care industry who cannot practice here because they are not certified and cannot afford the education process to become certified.
Theyhave to take jobs driving taxis, or working in fast food, or things completely outside the medical field because they simply cannot afford to re-engage with our educational system to go through all the expense of med school, internship, etc., to qualify for the same degree they held in their home country.
While I understand that some may not have been "up to snuff" with regard to qualifications for an MD, I fail to believe all of them could not qualify for some type of special program that could qualify them for a paramedic or nursing program that could fast track them toward a degree.
If there are people with these skills who are in the illegal alien community and we are going to allow them residence here anyway, we should at least provide some way for the skilled among them touse their skills in a way that is most beneficial and offers earning potential.
There must be a way to connect the illegal aliens who need some medical assistance and who would go to someone they trusted, with a qualified person under supervision from the medical community.
Make mine the latter.
(Tongue-in-cheek comment).
Attribute that to the "for-profit-health-care-as-a-commodity" model which includes 31 cents of every premium dollar going to waste (prior to ACA), outrageous CEO pay packages (in the last few years, the CEO of United Health Insurance made $50,000 AN HOUR !), and clerical departments devoted to finding ways to deny claims!
Attorney General Outraged Over Reported $102 Million Payday For United Healthcare CEO, Urges Insurance Department To Weigh Executive Pay In Future Rate Cases
It's time for Single Payer!
I agree. That is when you started seeing commercials for drugs on TV and the whole system took a crap.
It is never too late. Ignoring the problem and treating the symptom is not going to fix the problem and will make the symptom worse. What you are suggesting is throwing in the towel. That isn't the way we work in this country, at least it didn't used to be...
1st, I'm aware that Jefferson said that. The reason that I don't believe that it is revelent, is that I don't believe that he would have covered all Americans. His history is not one of ''all men are created equal''. Being a slave owner, it don't see him or the U.S. at the time covering Blacks or Indians.
Of course that is my opinion.
Mimi,
That is an outstanding idea! I have to say, that would solve an lot of problems.
Did you know that we are the only western country that requires MD's from other countries to go through med school again? My cousin is a doctor in England, and he wanted to come here to live, but he doesn't want to go through med school again after being in practice for about 15 years.
With ACA, there will be a shortage of MDs. The med schools know this, but they are behind the curve.
I have been thinking about this for a few years. Read about doctors who come here having to drive cabs, work food stands. It's insane.
We have illnesses and diseases among the illegal aliens getting footholds in the US because they fear to go to clinics and they aren't checked because they crossed the border illegally.A way for med students to intern could be to supervise these people in street clinics or, good grief, in the holding areas of immigration where they say there are people who need medical care.
It is foolish in the extreme to waste this wealth of expertise because of the AMA rules even if we have to form a new branch of it to deal with this situation.
I'm not a fool. We are at the point where the people to fast track need to be those with remarkable skills... not those doing jobs that Americans supposedly "won't" do but those with skills that most Americans "can't" do. Bi-lingual medical personnel familiar with illnesses and diseases common to areas these illegal aliens are migrating from would fit that category.
And as you said, we will have a shortage of doctors for everyone with ACA. Right now, most doctors in my area are not accepting new patients.
I too think that mimi has a good idea .
As far as the AMA being "behind the curve " ... it depends on which curve . They are waaaay out in front of the "restraint of trade" curve !