╌>

Gun Rights Debate

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  darren-wolfe  •  12 years ago  •  57 comments

Gun Rights Debate

Let's discuss the gun issue here. I'm going to ask everyone, on all sides of the issue, to refrain from snark, condescension, insults, & making it personal. This is about the issue not the people discussing it. Please review the Code of Conduct before posting.

Now that that is out of the way I'll present my pro-gun rights side via one of my articles & a YouTube video of a presentation I gave. Please comment on what you agree or disagree with:

Progressivisms Violent World

(snip)

It is immoral to initiate the use of force or the threat of force against peaceful people. In other words, a person has to be actually engaging in aggression or credibly threatening to do so before it is morally justifiable to use force in retaliation. What does that have to do with guns? The mere possession of an inanimate object such a gun aggresses against no one. There is no moral justification for taking guns away from people who adhere to the non-aggression principle since this involves initiating the use of force to separate them from their weapons.

Property rights are part of this equation also. People have a right to their property. Guns are property. Separating people from their guns by force is theft of those weapons.

There is a moral justification for, at times, using force. That is self-defense. Since the initiation of force is immoral the right to self-defense seems obvious. Depriving people of their guns is clearly taking away part of their ability to use defensive force. This is another way that gun control is a violation of peoples rights.

(snip)

http://theinternationallibertarian.blogspot.com/2013/01/progressivisms-violent-world.html

& the video:


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Dean Moriarty
Professor Silent
link   Dean Moriarty    12 years ago

Excellent video, thank you. You did a great job of presenting your case. I agree with everything you said.

 
 
 
Darren Wolfe
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Darren Wolfe    12 years ago

Thank you all for the polite comments.

The mere possession of an inanimate object such a gun aggresses against no one.

Again, for like the millionth time, if one uses this logic , a citizen should be able to have a suitcase nuclear bomb in their possession, as long as they never use it.

Who's up for that as national policy?

I'm sure not up for initiating force as policy. Unless one can show that the mere possession of an inanimate object such a nuke aggresses against someone, the logic is consistent & correct.

The nuclear bomb argument is a red herring. There is no nuclear bomb problem in the civilian world. There are no civilian uses for nukes. It is pretty much impossible for a civilian to build a nuke, most govts can't do it. The purpose of the nuke argument is to establish the principle that weapons can be regulated by the govt. That shifts the debate from should they be regulated to how much to regulate them. I reject the principle that they can be regulated by the initiation of force, I.E. by govts. The law is not the way to handle this.

The limits of one persons gun rights are the rights of others. One has a right to control property & to contract with others. If the owners of a mall or tenants within want to ban weapons on the property they control they have that right. Put no nukes (or whatever) in the lease (apartments & houses for rent too.) The Home Owner's Association's bylaws can state no weapons if they so desire.

 
 
 
Darren Wolfe
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Darren Wolfe    12 years ago

That is ridiculous even for you John.

Please don't make it personal.

 
 
 
Darren Wolfe
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Darren Wolfe    12 years ago

Libertarians assume that the second amendment means unfettered rights to own any weapon under the sun, which is not true.

Not this libertarian. I'm not basing my arguments on the 2A or the constitution. I'm talking about principle here. Notice that I don't rely on constitutional arguments in the article or speech. It is all about the Non-aggression Principle (NAP).

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   96WS6    12 years ago

Excellent video

 
 
 
retired military ex Republican
Freshman Silent
link   retired military ex Republican    12 years ago

How many gun owners are part of a well regulated militia as called out in article 2 of the constitution. What percentage do you think even belong to any militia .002 % maybe. I own a gun and do not belong to a militia however do I really have a need for it anymore as I no longer hunt? Probably not. Those with volitle tempers should not own guns. I'm not quite in that catagory. Those who are severly depressed should not own guns those who are abusive to children or spousal abuse should not own guns. Just a start.

 
 
 
Darren Wolfe
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Darren Wolfe    12 years ago

The limits of one person's gun rights are the decisions made by the Supreme Court.

No, those are legal limits & the law often infringes on people's rights. Rights are defined by morality not law. In a perfect world the law reflects morality but I'm sure there will be no disagreement with the idea that we don't live in a perfect world.

 
 
 
Darren Wolfe
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Darren Wolfe    12 years ago

Those with volitle tempers should not own guns. I'm not quite in that catagory. Those who are severly depressed should not own guns those who are abusive to children or spousal abuse should not own guns. Just a start.

The thing is that there was less crime & murder before the govt was trying to keep guns out of certain people's hands. It isn't the availability of guns that is the problem, it is social factors that drive crime that we have to look at. Top of the list is the war on drugs. It drives much of the crime these days. End it & the murder rate will drop considerably.

BTW, the US murder rate is below the world average. The problem is nowhere as severe as the advocates of gun control make it out to be. All of the countries with higher murder rates also have fewer guns per capita than the US. These facts alone destroy the argument that we need more gun control & less guns.

There is also the question of the govt abusing its power. It says it just wants to disarm some people for everybody's good. Reality is that it will inflict gun bans on us to keep control. This is the history of both the UK & Japan, countries where people once had many guns but are now legally disarmed.

 
 
 
John Sturm
Freshman Silent
link   John Sturm    12 years ago

As a right firearms may NOT be regulated, perhaps in the future they will regulate other rights? Maybe only people with jobs should be able to vote? Maybe only Cops have the right to speak freely? Perhaps only Muslims have the right to free religion? For someone to claim a right can be regulated is a complete disregard for what rights are in the first place. A right belongs to anyone whom has not lost privilege to those rights. Therefore nobody can say only so and so can have a machinegun but you can't. The constitution is not the maker of rights, merely a law to blockade the government from trying to limit them. We have these rights through divine right, from the moment of conception we are citizens of this nation and entitled to all rights herein. Furthermore the job of the Supreme Court is NOT to interpret the meaning of the constitution, they are there to ENFORCE it! Also a nuclear bomb is NOT a firearm, it is an explosive device which requires very special skills to maintain, store and operate. A firearm can and should be owned and operated by any free man or woman.

 
 
 
John Sturm
Freshman Silent
link   John Sturm    12 years ago

As a right firearms may NOT be regulated, perhaps in the future they will regulate other rights? Maybe only people with jobs should be able to vote? Maybe only Cops have the right to speak freely? Perhaps only Muslims have the right to free religion? For someone to claim a right can be regulated is a complete disregard for what rights are in the first place. A right belongs to anyone whom has not lost privilege to those rights. Therefore nobody can say only so and so can have a machinegun but you can't. The constitution is not the maker of rights, merely a law to blockade the government from trying to limit them. We have these rights through divine right, from the moment of conception we are citizens of this nation and entitled to all rights herein. Furthermore the job of the Supreme Court is NOT to interpret the meaning of the constitution, they are there to ENFORCE it! Also a nuclear bomb is NOT a firearm, it is an explosive device which requires very special skills to maintain, store and operate. A firearm can and should be owned and operated by any free man or woman.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    12 years ago

The president's administration commissioned the CDC to look into and report on shootings and gun data in the US. This is part of a statement posted on its Web site and one of the reasons the rest of the country hasn't heard anything about it:

If one were to exclude figures for Illinois, California, New Jersey and Washington, DC, the homicide rate in the United States would be in line with any other country. These areas, of course, are noted for the most restrictive gun laws in the country, thus negating any opportunity for the president to celebrate the reports findings.

 
 
 
retired military ex Republican
Freshman Silent
link   retired military ex Republican    12 years ago

A nuclear device in a suitcase could level whole cities. Its inanimate like a gun its an inanimate object until someone detonates the weapon in both cases. Background checks for ammunition and gun purchases from store internet or a friend. They are all the same to protect the innocent. The amount of protection a gun will give you if someone wants to kill you is almost nill. There is almost no chance to fight back. Unless you cary the gun in your hand all the time and loaded and you can see the aggressor and he isn't already aiming the weapon at you. Kung foo shit is just that. Quick draw is dangerous in and of it self. Have a relative who shot himself by accident practicing quick draw with a 22 revolver and shot himself in the heart. Guns can kill even by mistake, often by mistake. 4 year old shooting six year old brother inanimate object made it happen. Why was gun in reach stupidity of grown up with the right to own a gun.

Police break down wrong door crippled man in chair has hearing aid dog who tries to protect master police gun dog down. No apology no offer to replace dog inanimate object in the hands of professionals kill way to often. No remorse. Few killers have any remorse. Travon Martin killed, killer has no remorse continues to exhibit aggression sooner or later he will kill some one else. He is within his right until he kills and cannot sell his tale to a jury. All the police investigations and fights mostly with women sometimes a kid.

Man shoots thru door and kills a child on halloween. Man kills a black girl who knocks on his door because her car is broke down and needs to use a phone. Inanimate object kills again all these people cannot be in the wrong they have the legal right. So you say. Stand your ground!!! Ok enough bye.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    12 years ago

This is part of a report put out by the FBI, which is on THEIR Web site and which hasn't received any play in the mainstream media:

What citizens can do in mass shootings:

While many attackers commit suicide, the new study states potential victims stopped the attacker in 17 cases that ended before officers arrived.

This tells us that citizens and bystanders have a very real and active role in stopping these events, Nichols said. If we can properly prepare and educate civilians, maybe we can get to where 90 percent are stopped by civilians long before the police arrive.

The FBI has been busy promoting instructional videos and literature to educate the public on workplace and other scenarios.

Run, hide and fight are your essential options in a shooting situation, Schweit said. The better prepared civilians are, the better theyll be able to respond themselves.

Spike in mass shootings creates demand for different police approach

.

.

By Jason Sickles, Yahoo!

Staff Writer

.Posts
Email
.By Jason Sickles, Yahoo! | Yahoo News Thu, Jan 2, 2014

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    12 years ago

I read both these reports within a week of each other. The president's people had been pushing the CDC (of all organizations, they would never had occurred to me) and the FBI to come up with reports the president could quote in his anti-gun speeches.

Unfortunately for him, Biden, and others, both the CDC and the FBI returned reports that refuted the arguments they were trying to make. It could be one of the reasons things went relatively quiet on the anti-gun front.

 
 
 
Dean Moriarty
Professor Silent
link   Dean Moriarty    12 years ago

Do you really thank that the people that just won their freedom fighting against their government meant that? They are the same people that took up arms and fought against the military.

 
 
 
Dean Moriarty
Professor Silent
link   Dean Moriarty    12 years ago

The definition of militia at the time meant the whole body of the people. Just a gay doesn't have the same meaning as it did then liberals have attempted to change the meaning of the word militia.

 
 
 
Darren Wolfe
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Darren Wolfe    12 years ago

Louisiana has the highest murder rate of any state, which is understandable since New Orleans often has the highest murder rate in the nation, by far.

Louisiana is also one of the poorest states. Perhaps the correlation is that poor areas have higher murder rates. Here in the Philadelphia area it is certainly that way. The poor parts of Philly are where the murders happen. Camden, NJ is one of the poorest cities in the country & has been setting records for murder despite NJ's restrictive gun laws.

New Hampshire has very easy gun laws & a murder rate below that of the UK, perhaps the lowest in the US. It also has the lowest poverty rate.

 
 
 
John Sturm
Freshman Silent
link   John Sturm    12 years ago

Every man aged 16 and over was a member of the militia and there was no police force in the 1780s so how exactly are firearms only meant for them when they did not exist? not to mention subsequent comments by the founders all in favor of an armed populace and armed private citizens. Have any of you anti gun folks ever even read the letters and quotes of Adams, Jefferson, Washington, Henry, Franklin etc? But that would be too difficult as the folks who want to take our arms don't read or have any sort of historical education. Instead of spouting at the mouth pick up a history book and read what this nation is about.

 
 
 
John Sturm
Freshman Silent
link   John Sturm    12 years ago

You are incorrect. Every man 16 and over were to attend militia drill or face a fine, they were to maintain and keep arms, sword and ammunition including some of the wealthy ones owning cannon. This didn't end at the end of the war. Look it up read perhaps study history instead of just saying NO No has no basis in fact nore evidence.

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    12 years ago

Funny that every neighbor I know (I mean EVERY) has guns, yet we have a super low crime and murder (0)rate . Must be luck that all those guns haven't just decided to run off and start ashooting spree.

:~)

 
 
 
John Sturm
Freshman Silent
link   John Sturm    12 years ago

Once again read a book. The militia is not equal to the national guard. The national guard is a state funded standing army, the militia are everyday citizens self funded self trained self armed. Ive studied the history of the 18th century for many year in particular the colonial militia. Not to mention the fact we were all armed well before the revolutionary war and long after, if the case was that arms were only meant for the militia, why pray tell were people still armed with privately owned cannons, firearms etc in the 1860s? Why did they wait until 1936 to paper machineguns? If what you are saying is true the government should have kept all guns for the military when the war ended in 1783. Surely the founders had plenty of time to disarm everyone.

 
 
 
John Sturm
Freshman Silent
link   John Sturm    12 years ago

Wow why do you even bother debating when you think you know everything already. The founding fathers who wrote the thing are wrong, the history teacher who specializes in colonial history is wrong. God forbid you pick a book up it may alter your preconceived victim status bestowed upon everyone the evil white man has gunned down over the years.

Firearms saved my life and the life of my wife, sitting on a friends porch a gang of ten inner city thugs advanced on us for no reason at all but a chance to victimize someone. When they made their intent clear I made mine clear with the pair of revolvers I had under my coat. The gang decided it was time to leave. So I say Molon Labe translation for those too dumb to read what that means Come take em!

So if the rules don't apply after the passage of time we have decided you no longer have the right to speak I guess that's alright? Maybe certain minority groups shouldn't have the right to vote perhaps? After all those amendments were passed so long ago we have to get with the times.

Perhaps keeping guns out of the hands of citizens would make it easier to rob them? Round them up ad put them in camps to kill the ones you dislike? You know who else talked about disarming the people and only allowing the military and police to own firearms ADOLF HITLER

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   Aeonpax    12 years ago

JFT,

I find myself in agreement with your statement;

  • "But those words are not in the Constitution or the 2nd Amendment. And those are what SCOTUS decisions are based upon. Those words also don't apply any longer. The Constitution is a living, breathing document that must be re-interpreted as time goes by"

I'm always a bit leery when those not trained in the disciple of constitutional jurisprudence, form arguments based on extraneous documents, then claim they are right and everyone else is wrong, including current and former Supreme Court justices.

While there is still debate on the "living document" vs "originalism" on how to interpret the US constitution, that becomes moot once a court decision is made. To that extent, however academic the informal discussions here (or anyplace else for that matter) are, such debates do not produce canonical legal conclusions.....meaning, it's till open for discussion.

The 2nd Amendment debates have produced a wide range of so-called constitutional experts. However, what does make this interesting is the fact that SCOTUS has never actually ruled on the broad range of issues that dominate the discussions on gun rights, so in a manner of speaking, those who present the strongest logical argument, the use of other ancillary documents included, at least can claim a theoretical victory.

I'm a gun owner and support most gun rights issues. but those rights are not sacrosanct nor where they intended to be. I believe that we the people, as a nation, can opt to put restrictions on gun ownership.

Short of a constitutional convention or amendment, legislatively, we have a right to define gun ownership based on a real or preceived threat to public safety. That conflicts with the NRA's ideology of opposing any restrictions.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    12 years ago

Article 5.

 
 
 
Darren Wolfe
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Darren Wolfe    12 years ago

Liberals will change the meaning of shit to comply with their sweet chocolat gumbo.

Please no more of this kind of commenting here. Add your opinion or present some facts.

 
 
 
Darren Wolfe
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Darren Wolfe    12 years ago

I'm not a constitutionalist, as far as I'm concerned the constitution has been a big failure. However, it still is claimed to be in the law of the land so it needs to be addressed. Only looking at the 2A in regards to guns is missing the point:

The Ninth Amendment reads, The enumeration in the Constitution, of certain rights, shall not be construed to deny or disparage others retained by the people. Obviously, not every right has to be listed to be valid. The right to own guns apart from membership in a militia clearly falls into this category. The real issue is the question, does the government have the legal power to take people's guns? One searches the Constitution in vain trying to find a clause that empowers it to do so. However, the Tenth Amendment reads, The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States respectively, or to the people. This should be a great restriction on governmental power. Since the Constitution nowhere grants the government the power to take our guns the Tenth Amendment should stop them from doing so. Unfortunately, these amendments aren't working. The Constitution has failed just as the anti-federalists warned us it would.... Patrick Henry spoke about the danger lurking in the document, O sir, we should have fine times, indeed, if, to punish tyrants, it were only sufficient to assemble the people! Your arms, wherewith you could defend yourselves, are gone... He went on to explain how the Constitution takes the power to defend their liberty away from the people:

Let me here call your attention to that part which gives the Congress power "to provide for organizing, arming, and disciplining the militia, and for governing such part of them as may be employed in the service of the United Statesreserving to the states, respectively, the appointment of the officers, and the authority of training the militia according to the discipline prescribed by Congress." By this, sir, you see that their control over our last and best defence is unlimited. If they neglect or refuse to discipline or arm our militia, they will be useless: the states can do neitherthis power being exclusively given to Congress. The power of appointing officers over men not disciplined or armed is ridiculous; so that this pretended little remains of power left to the states may, at the pleasure of Congress, be rendered nugatory.
[From Patrick Henry's speech arguing against adoption of the Constitution titled " Shall Liberty or Empire Be Sought? "]

The above is from " Democratic Socialism, Guns, and the Failure of the Constitution "

 
 
 
Darren Wolfe
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Darren Wolfe    12 years ago

Here are quotes from Mao. He explains how disarming the people is necessary to subjugate them:

After the enemies with guns have been wiped out, there will still be enemies without guns; they are bound to struggle desperately against us, and we must never regard these enemies lightly. If we do nor now raise and understand the problem in this way, we shall commit the gravest mistakes.
Report to the Second Plenary Session of the Seventh Central Committee of the Communist Party of China (March 5, 1949), Selected Works, Vol. IV , p. 364.

 All political power comes from the barrel of
a gun. The communist party must command
all the guns, that way, no guns can ever be
used to command the party.
"Problems of War and Strategy", Nov 6 1938

Governments want disarmed victims. This is what Mao had in mind and there are seventy million dead Chinese to prove it, part of the over two-hundred million killed by governments in the 20th century. Governments that implemented gun control have committed all of the major genocides.

Thats why theres never a good time to talk about disarming the people. What the discussion should be about is disarming the government. There is a massive imbalance between the power of the government and the power of the people. Not only the military but the law enforcement establishments here are overwhelmingly strong. We need to start shifting power away from the government by putting these functions back in the peoples hands where they belong.

" A system of licensing and registration is the perfect device to deny gun ownership to the bourgeoisie. "
-- Vladimir Ilyich Lenin

 
 
 
Darren Wolfe
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Darren Wolfe    12 years ago

we are never going to separate John from his delusions....

his warped sense of logic is only the surface....

Please don't make it personal

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    12 years ago

Neither have mine.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    12 years ago

EG it was personal. You are implying that John has a mental defect. I'm going through this article.. so far no purple.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    12 years ago

BF,

We should honor the request of the author. That is in our CoC. This article has been running very well. I would like to keep that up.

Signed,

The hall monitor.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    12 years ago

Bruce,

They would probably say the same about you. And that is the issue. Once the discussion deteriorates and the name calling starts, the game is over. I am going by who threw the first punch here and by the authors wishes. Let's leave it at that.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    12 years ago

It wasn't personal

Explain to me how calling someone "delusional" isn't personal?

The author made a request, and I am following through with it.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    12 years ago

BF,

No comment.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    12 years ago

EG,

Delusionalideals can only come from from somewhere. This issemantics.

I have insulted his positions.....

And that should be allowable.....

Then say that. John, your perspective on this matter seems illogical. Can you explain your logic, for example.

Maybe the conversation is just too adult for some to handle...

No. Maybe we should abide by the author's request.

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   Neale Osborn    12 years ago

Darren, you sound like a filthy Libertarian. I like that. Because I'm one too. IF people followed the ZAP (Zero Aggression Principle), which, simply put, means you never initiate force, you only defend against the initiation, we'd have no need for debate on this. People have the right to possess, carry, and use arms for self defense. Despite the blatant refusal of some to actually research the topic (and the use of words in 1787 vs today) there is NOT ONE SHRED of Constitutionality to licensing, regulating, limiting, restricting, or controlling the ownership, method or place of carry, or the types of weapons a person chooses to carry. That is why the 2nd Amendment ends with "The Right of the People to Keep and Bear Arms SHALL NOT be infringed." What part of "Shall not be infringed" isn't clear?

I'd like permission to copy and post this to "The Libertarian Enterprise" (properly attributed), to see what come about.

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   Neale Osborn    12 years ago

Have you ever researched WHAT a "well Regulated Militia" actually is, in the terms of the day/ Somehow, I doubt it. It has NOTHING to do with the National Guard, military service, licenses, or anything else. "Well Regulated" means well trained and in good working order. militia meant the regular militia AND the Irregular militia (per the 1792 North Carolina definition).

Regular Militia- Able-bodied men aged 16-45 who signed up for and do meet once a month, drilling on the town square (or a local field) in military maneuvers, bringing with them their personally owned military grade (read "assault rifles) weapons. They agree to subordinate themselves to local or state control in time of emergency, and to federal control upon orders from the governor.

Irregular Militia- ALL men (because only men were citizens then) who were or who had stated their intention to become citizens, who swore to maintain their skills with their personally owned military grade weapons, and promised to come when called for local or state emergency, and to be subordinated to the federal government by the governor.

Therefore, ANY American citizen, or person with a green card working on their citizenship,who swears to maintain proficiency with their firearms and come if needed IS in a "Well Regulated Militia."

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   Neale Osborn    12 years ago

BTW, the US murder rate is below the world average.

There you go againopposing emotions with facts. The problem is, guns are an easy target. They will never acknowledge that murder is murder. The device used is irrelevant. They never oppose the person, they oppose the tool. And ONLY if it's a gun. Assuming they ever get rid of ALL guns, they will promptly move on to knives, wanting a ban of all knives over 1.5 inches, claiming "no one needs a 6" blade to cut up veggies." It also will never be acknowledged by these same people that, since 1993, violent crime is down 73%, gun crimes are down overall 45% (gun murders down 70%), and over 100,000,000 new firearms are in American society, we now have 37 states with "Must Issue" or "Shall Issue" concealed carry laws, and 4 states with Constitutional Carry (NO license required for open OR concealed carry). Since, using their logic, that many guns HAS to lead to blood flowing in the gutters, those facts CANNOT be true.

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   Neale Osborn    12 years ago

The date is irrelevant. Don't like the 2nd Amendment, pass a new Amendment.

It is not only a false argument, it is deliberate lying, when someone chooses to use the modern definition of a word from a200+ year old document to justify their argument. Or do you think people actually collected bundle of gay people for their kitchen stove fuel (a faggot was a bundle of small sticks used to build a small hot fire for cooking, or to start the big fire), or that people lithomosexuals o fire and breathed in the smokein the 1930s (a fag was a cigarette), or that the Gay '90s was a time when everyone was homosexual (gay meant happy). Language evolves. To understand what was said in 1790, you must use the definitions in place in the 1790s, NOT the definition from 2014.

To do otherwise is to be either deliberately mendacious or incredibly ignorant.

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   Neale Osborn    12 years ago

Yup. Like I thought. Deliberately mendacious it is!

 
 
 
Darren Wolfe
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Darren Wolfe    12 years ago

Let me continue "opposing emotions with facts". Directly addressing the European situation is this article from the Harvard Journal of Law & Public Policy. Section E of chapter 5 is the relevant one though it is well worth reading the whole article.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    12 years ago

John,

You are getting close to the line there. Don't cross it.

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   Neale Osborn    12 years ago

Comment removed off topic

 
 
 
Darren Wolfe
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Darren Wolfe    12 years ago

They didn't have police because they didn't trust the govt with that much power. A good way of thinking that it would behoove us to bring back.

BTW, mocking by talking about bringing back old methods like drawing blood only serves to give away the fact that you don't have a serious argument to present against the militia idea. We're not talking about duplicating exactly what was done back when. We want to apply the principle that the people should have the power to use force in their hands as opposed to it being in the govt's hands.

 
 
 
Darren Wolfe
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Darren Wolfe    12 years ago

I'd like permission to copy and post this to "The Libertarian Enterprise" (properly attributed), to see what come about.

You absolutely have my permission. Take a look at my blog let me know if you find anything there you'd like to use

 
 
 
Jerry Verlinger
Freshman Silent
link   Jerry Verlinger    12 years ago

A new author, new to the site, posting an article on a very very old topic, with a very new approach.

Darren is not new to the site. He has been a member since July 13, 2013 and a member of the Police Brutality & Misconduct and Public Office Abuse & Misconduct groups since July 14th.

Anyway, what's wrong with a new approach on an old topic?

You really think we have reached the apex of the debate on gun control Bruce? I think not.

Keep your eye on NewsTalkers Activism and the Common Sense Gun Laws and Safety groups, I'm sure I will be able to get you to see the need for re-positioningthat'apex'.

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   Neale Osborn    12 years ago

Will do, this evening.

 
 
 
Darren Wolfe
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Darren Wolfe    12 years ago

The issue isn't firearms murders, it is the overall murder rate. In that regard the US is below the world average . Note that all of the countries with higher murder rates have gun control & fewer guns than here. No country that has banned guns has seen their murder rate go down. Quite the opposite it usually goes up.

There is also historical evidence to look at. The murder rate in Western Europe was way higher in the Middle Ages than it is now. Their murder rate dropped once firearms were invented & introduced. It declined for centuries as they acquired more, & more modern, guns. By the time countries such as the UK started restricting & banning guns they already had low murder rates.

 
 
 
Darren Wolfe
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Darren Wolfe    12 years ago

Actually, John, I like this point you make. The problem isn't guns it is the war on drugs. That's what drives many gang killings. The answer is to focus on the real problem,the war on drugs, & stop wasting time with this "war" on guns.

 
 
 
TTGA
Professor Silent
link   TTGA    12 years ago

There is no gun death problem statistically without the gang related shootings.

Precisely Fish. So why are we wasting time and money trying to pass gun control laws that do not deal with the problem? Use all that money and energy dealing with gangs instead.

As John just said:

Gang killings have nothing to do with restrictive gun control laws, Never have never will.

Guess what John, neither do any other killings. Why, then, are we bothering with gun control laws that will have no effect on killings? Since they have no effect on killings, those pushing for them must have some other agenda.

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   Neale Osborn    12 years ago

So what? OF course a country with more guns has more gun accidents. Irrelevant to the argument- Have more of ANY tool, and you will have more accidents with that type of tool. We ALSO have more crimes stopped by civilian guns than any other country- And you want that to stop, too, don't you?

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    12 years ago

You can own everything to make a nuclear weapon, if you have the proper permissions of the government.

But what will the neighbors think !

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   96WS6    12 years ago

Gang killings have nothing to do with restrictive gun control laws, Never have never will.

You mean the lawless gangs that ignore the gun laws that keep guns out of the hands of law abiding citizens??

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   Neale Osborn    12 years ago

I need something that tells me he thinks he's a libertarian before I start a statement like that one of yours, BF. Is there more to this?

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   Neale Osborn    12 years ago

Gotta say it- He acted like exactly what an agent provocateur would- taking the most extreme position and going farther with it. 99.9% of gun rights advocates would never do this, Peaceful demonstrations that show how law abiding we are. I suspect he did this specifically to damage the pro-gun movement. And I'd bet he serves no time, and gets no fine.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    12 years ago

That's a very interesting graphic SbLR . Do you recall the source ?

 
 
 
Darren Wolfe
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Darren Wolfe    12 years ago

Adam is on probation right now . I know him, not well but enough to be convinced of his sincerity & seriousness as a libertarian. I may not agree with everything he does but I will not turn my back on a brave man like him. Standing With #MyFriendAdam Kokesh Adam has also been arrested for marijuana activism Smokedown Prohibition V: Adam Kokesh and NA Poe Arrested (video and pictures) , Adam Kokesh Arrested At Smoke Down Prohibition in Washington, DC (video). Run "Kokesh" through the search function on my blog to see more.

As to his work with Code Pink, I tried working with the left too when the wars were a hotter issue. It doesn't make me or Adam less of a libertarian. Run "peace" through the search function on my blog to see more.

Anyway, the nice govt men took out Adam as an activist, for now. Let's hope he makes a comeback.

 
 

Who is online



85 visitors