╌>

Why Abbas Thinks Jewish State is a ‘Delusional Myth’

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  jonathan-p  •  12 years ago  •  19 comments

Why Abbas Thinks Jewish State is a ‘Delusional Myth’

Netanyahus demand and the PAs refusal to recognize Israel as a Jewish state are clearly not just a quibble over semantics.

A major obstacle blocking progress toward an agreement between Israel and the Palestinian Authority is Prime Minister Binyamin Netanyahus demand and PA President Mahmoud Abbass refusal to recognize Israel as a Jewish state. The Jerusalem Pos t reported this week that US Secretary of State John Kerry thinks Israels demand is a mistake. The question is: Why are both sides so concerned about that which is already accepted internationally? As early as 1917, the Balfour Declaration supported the establishment of a national home for the Jewish people.

In 1922, the League of Nations confirmed the British Mandate to establish a Jewish national home, and UN resolution 181 in 1947 recommended the establishment of a Jewish state. Since Israels founding followed directly upon this international process anticipating a Jewish state, why, so many years later, does Israel demand and the PA refuse to restate the obvious? A recent declaration by Abbas sheds light on why PA recognition is essential for authentic peace and why the PA president refuses to grant it. In a speech in Morocco, Abbas defined Jewish history in Jerusalem as a delusional myth and claimed that Israel is trying to invent a Jewish history by brute force. ( Official PA TV , January 17, 2014).

Abbas has a long tradition of denying Jewish history. In another talk he described Jewish history in Jerusalem as illusions and legends and referred to the Jewish Temple in Jerusalem as the alleged Temple, a term the PA uses to deny that it ever existed. ( Al-Hayat Al-Jadid a, August 22, 2012).

Abbass refusal to recognize the Jewish state is not merely his personal vendetta, but, reflects this fundamental element of PA policy to deny Jewish history especially in Jerusalem.

On numerous occasions when archeological finds with Jewish symbols and Hebrew texts were uncovered that illustrate aspects of Jewish history in Israel, the PA hastened to tell Palestinians that Israel invented the story, distorted it or even planted the finds. When Israeli archeologists last year displayed gold artifacts with Jewish symbols, such as a menorah and a shofar, found 50 meters from the Western Wall in Jerusalem, former PA prime minister Ahmed Qurei immediately denied its authenticity on official PA TV: I think all this is a forgery, forgery of the truth. Its all an attempt to make claims. They did not find anything. ( Official PA TV , September 11, 2013).

What must therefore be understood is that the PAs refusal to recognize Israel as a Jewish state is not a mere technicality, but part of an overarching policy of denying thousands of years of Jewish history in Israel, and thereby denying Israels right to exist. And although in the Oslo Accords in 1993 the PLO recognized the existence of Israel, the PA differentiates between recognizing that Israel exists and recognizing Israels right to exist.

The PAs ambassador to India, Adli Sadeq, explained that Israelis who believe the PA recognizes Israels right to exist are deluding themselves: [Israelis] fool themselves, assuming that Fatah accepts them and recognizes the right of their state to exist... There are no two Palestinians who disagree over the fact that Israel exists, and recognition of it is restating the obvious. But recognition of its right to exist is something else, different from recognition of its existence. ( Al-Hayat Al-Jadida , November 26, 2011).

Palestinian children are also educated to distinguish between Israels existence and right to exist, as an official PA schoolbook teaches: Palestines war [in 1948] ended with a catastrophe that is unprecedented in history, when the Zionist gangs stole Palestine... and established the so-called State of Israel. ( Arabic Language, Analysis, Literature and Criticism, grade 12, published by the PA Ministry of Education ).

And PA TV teaches 8-year-olds that all of Israel is occupied land since 1948 and this situation is only temporary: We will never forget that we have land that was occupied in 1948 which will return to us one day. ( Official PA TV , February 23, 2013).

Abbass denial of Jewish history and refusal to recognize Israel as a Jewish state are the ideological foundations for the PA teachings that the existence of the State of Israel constitutes a theft by Zionist gangs and that Israels existence is temporary. This is not PLO rhetoric from the pre-Oslo days. This is current PA education and indoctrination and remains a most severe impediment to a genuine peace process.

Netanyahus demand and the PAs refusal to recognize Israel as a Jewish state are clearly not just a quibble over semantics, and Netanyahus demand is in fact a minimalist request. Any PA recognition if it is to impact at all on peace must include recognition that Israel is the continuation of thousands of years of Jewish history and therefore Israel has a right to exist. Furthermore, in order for these declarations to be more than mere embellishments to yet another insincere agreement, they must be immediately integrated into PA childrens education and public discourse. Without this, Abbas recognition of the Jewish state would be like Arafats recognition of Israel in 1993: a meaningless ornament to a deceptive peace process that is cited regularly by the PA to create a faade of sincerity.

PA public recognition and education of its citizens to see Israel as a Jewish state with a history and right to exist are absolute necessities if there is ever to be a Palestinian population that accepts Israel as a neighbor and truly seeks peace. For now, while Abbas recognition on the diplomatic level would certainly not be enough to affect this change, it is nonetheless a necessary first step in the right direction.

The author is director of Palestinian Media Watch. His recent book, Deception, co-authored with Nan Jacques Zilberdik, documents activities and statements of the Palestinian Authority leadership.

http://www.jpost.com/Opinion/Op-Ed-Contributors/Why-Abbas-thinks-Jewish-state-is-a-delusional-myth-345549


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   seeder  Jonathan P    12 years ago

One of the things you hear often in regard to the conflict is that the statements or actions - no matter how atrocious - should be taken with a grain of salt, because they are perpetrated by the "extreme elements" of the movement.

This article details statements made at the head, by the head. They are indicative of a people that are so deeply entrenched in falsehood and hate, that it would probably take 3 generations to normalize and properly inform the population of the real facts. And it would probably have to begin today. Unfortunately, there are no changes in the offing, and the world continues to support this group in spite of what they know.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    12 years ago

England is a Christian nation. Does anyone have the right to tell them not to exist that way?

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   seeder  Jonathan P    12 years ago

When one reads articles on NT about Israel, it is so striking to see how much people advocate for ONE SIDE of the issue. Here on NT, it seems maybe 95% advocate for Israel. That's fine, if that is the makeup of the group, but these articles end up coming off more like propaganda than perhaps they are in reality.

Propaganda oftentimes is a wishful thinking/opinion laden treatise, reflecting deep bias. I selected this particular article because it contains a number of recent statements, spoken from the leader of the Palestinian movement. Do those quotes further cement my opinion on the conflict? Sure they do. The key is that there is a great deal of verifiable history included in the piece.

There are those on the site that demand more in the way of fact-based information when seeking to form an opinion. I feel that this article meets that criteria.

In any case, is not at least a part of the dispute over recognizing Israel , by the Palestinians, and others, related to recognition as a "Jewish" state, with pro-Jewish laws that the opponents believe would be prejudicial against non-Jews living or working in Israel?

It could be, in the minds of some people. History reflects equal rights for all citizens of Israel, without regard to race, creed or religion. There are no barriers to education or employment for anyone in the country. Hence, you see many non-Jewish (read: Arab) doctors, lawyers, Army officers, and entrepreneurial types in Israel. There are Arab Members of Parliament (that's the government) and there was an Arab Supreme Court Justice. Could there be better outcomes for more Arabs in Israel? I'd say yes, absolutely. I'd compare it to the situation with African Americans in the US. In both cases, a long distance has already been traversed, but there is certainly more to be traversed.

That there is a difference between recognizing Israel's "right to exist as a nation" and Israel's "right to exist as a Jewish nation".

The thesis of the article is that the Palestinians wish to control Israel's demographicoutcome. Their first step is to not recognize Israel as a Jewish State. This would pave the way for the "right of return" for whomever considers themselves "Palestinian". Have you ever asked yourself why, if they are given their own, sovereign state, do they want to impose the right of return of all "refugees" to Israel? What's the purpose of having your own country? Why impose yourself on a different country if you now have your own country that you've been clamoring over for decades? The answer is, to overrun the country so that you can impose your own brand of law in that country. And that law, John, is the law that every other surrounding state in the region abides by.

I hope that's clear enough for you.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    12 years ago

As of today, do not Palestinians and other nationalities living in Israel sometimes complain that they are treated unequally because they are not Jewish? I am sure I have seen articles about this somewhere.

The Arab Christians and Muslims that live within Israel proper, do not complain. They have seats in government and can serve in the army.. if they choose. It is thePalestinians that are living in the disputed territoriesthat are complaining. There is a difference.

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   seeder  Jonathan P    12 years ago

Well SURE you have, John. Nobody's denying that here.

How does that impeach Israel's right to exist?

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   seeder  Jonathan P    12 years ago

Steve Miller

 
 
 
pokermike
Freshman Silent
link   pokermike    12 years ago

Obama and advisors after being informed John Kerry says he has a plan to solve the Israeli-Palestinian dispute.

4700_discussions.jpg

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   seeder  Jonathan P    12 years ago

Kerry clearly drew the short straw. This is all that can explain how he was given this task.

Every President since Nixon (5 Rep, 3 Dem) has had the arrogance to believe that they could fit a square peg in a round hole.

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   seeder  Jonathan P    12 years ago

I know I'm derailing my own seed, but every time I see you post, I start singing -

"2 pints of booze"

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    12 years ago

The thesis of the article is that the Palestinians wish to control Israel's demographicoutcome. Their first step is to not recognize Israel as a Jewish State. This would pave the way for the "right of return" for whomever considers themselves "Palestinian". Have you ever asked yourself why, if they are given their own, sovereign state, do they want to impose the right of return of all "refugees" to Israel? What's the purpose of having your own country? Why impose yourself on a different country if you now have your own country that you've been clamoring over for decades? The answer is, to overrun the country so that you can impose your own brand of law in that country.

This is the same situation I have been saying about what is happening in the US. We already have the Muslims here; in approximately twenty years we will have the first wave of Chinese exerting their "right of return" as American citizens with dual citizenship with China, courtesy of these luxury birthing clinics that have popped up around the country and which are perfectly legal. And the young, indoctrinated Chinese citizens will be arriving on a continuous basis, filling up the colleges, moving on to top business and political internship positions, changing the face of business and law in the US.

While Americans are worried about the Hispanics, the Muslims and the Chinese, both better educated and better funded, will be racing each other to erase American democracy from history, all with the help of the American congress.

And yep, I'm a conspiracy theorist. Before you laugh at me, you should read a few books on Chinese philosophy. Not that it would help; you already know what the Muslim world thinks of the West and you ignore it.

There are a few thousand Muslims in this world who would love peace with Israel and with the West, who would love to raise their children without the specter of hate and death over them. But they cannot even voice their wishes out loud for fear of being murdered by their own people. To wish for, to aim for, peace is what we all should do; to not learn and recognize the signs of the enemy is more than folly, it is a sin, for it brings death to your children and your people.

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   seeder  Jonathan P    12 years ago

Why thank you.

Thank you kindly.

Is that the inspiration for your moniker?

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    12 years ago

The Israelis gave custodianship of the Temple Mount to Jordan; now the Muslims are running Jews away from there and though it is not illegal for them to be there, police are making them stay away saying it will incite riots for them to pray there.

The whole freaking world is changing ITS behavior instead of schooling Muslims in how to behave in polite society.

Syria set off an explosive device underneath an IDF jeep yesterday injuring four soldiers, one of them seriously, and Israel retaliated. Are they TRYING to get Israel into Syria?

There is no peace with these people. None.

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    12 years ago

Strange that Israel is asked to live-up to a different standard than it's neighbors, by some.

Nearly every other country in the region is a Muslim nation, and have not been asked to identify themselves any differently as a qualification for recognition of their Statehood. Israelis enjoy rights that are the envy of many of their neighbors, with opportunities for personal, professional, and economicgrowth for all, that are second to none other in the region. Folks from other countries (even Palestine) bring their sick loved ones to Israel (not Israel's neighbors) for the best possible medical care. An Israeli can grow up dreaming of becoming a Judge, member of the Supreme Court, a soldier, a cop, a baker, a poet, a politician, a dress maker, an actor----regardless of their ethnicity, religion or skin color---and obtain that dream. How many of Israel's neighbors are able to compete with israel in these areas? Yet no one is asking for verification of any of those things to authenticate their claims of national identity.

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   seeder  Jonathan P    12 years ago

I think this is what's rubbing against the Arabs. They know all of this, but they also know that things will not change for the citizens of Palestine. It will merely be another UN sanctioned Islamic kleptocracy, with no hope for the people. Their problem is that the proximity is too close to the country you have described. That will make for unpopular leaders, who will no longer be able to blame the Zionist interlopers for their unfortunate circumstances.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   Len    12 years ago

Nearly every other country in the region is a Muslim nation, and have not been asked to identify themselves any differently as a qualification for recognition of their Statehood.

Bingo, Larry!

I was scanning this thread to see if anyone would write this, or I would have. But you caught the gold ring.

Not only this, but Gaza, Jordan, Syria, Iraq and Lebanon are Judenrein -- no Jews allowed to live there. So when John spouts off about so-called lack of equal rights for Arabs in Israel, he shows complete ignorance of the situation.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    12 years ago

In any case, is not at least a part of the dispute over recognizing Israel , by the Palestinians, and others, related to recognition as a "Jewish" state, with pro-Jewish laws that the opponents believe would be prejudicial against non-Jews living or working in Israel?

No-- not in the least! There are no "Jewish laws" that discriminate against Muslims.

And in terms of both law and actual practice-- Muslims in Israel have even more religious freedom than they would in most if not all Arab states! (And that goes for other, non-religious freedoms as well).

The right to practice Islam, including any sect of Islam (or any other religion) is enshrined in law-- and in actual practice. (Try being a Shia in a Muslim Sunni state-- or vice-versa).

And not only the freedom to practice religion-- but also non-religion! Many Muslim countries have severe laws (& actual punishments) for so-called "blasphemy". Israel however protects religious freedoms for all religious views.

Here are some links-- interesting stuff! Category:Blasphemy law by country

Of course you might expect harsh laws limiting religious freedoms in places like Iran, Saudi Arabia, Pakistan. But what about a country like Egypt?

In Egypt, the law against blasphemy is one of the instruments which the government and the Sunni majority use to persecute Egyptian minorities who do not subscribe to Sunni religious views. The most persecuted minorities are Shia, Sufi, Christians, Bahai, and atheists[citation needed]. The persecution may involve surveillance, harassment, prolonged detention, mistreatment, torture, and the death penalty. ( Link)

However, the main point of this current issue is misunderstood by most people. Abbas' objection is not about the Jews as a religion. Rather, its about the Jews as a nation-- as an ethnic identity.

So here's the real reason Abbas won't agree to Israel as a Jewish state: if he did agree, then he would have to give up any claim to the so-called "Right of Return". And no Palestinian leader can do that-- and live to tell about it.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    12 years ago

I think that John would rather cut off his right arm than support Israel in this endless conflict. He has taken a stand and even if the truth smacked him in the face he wouldn't accept it.

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   seeder  Jonathan P    12 years ago

So here's the real reason Abbas won't agree to Israel as a Jewish state: if he did agree, then he would have to give up any claim to the so-called "Right of Return". And no Palestinian leader can do that-- and live to tell about it.

Actually, the real reason why he won't agree is because they would cease to have a purpose. The Palestinian people were "created" for the sole purpose of "the struggle". If/when that ends, all you have left is a group of people in need of permanent financial aid.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    12 years ago

"...all you have left is a group of people in need of permanent financial aid."

...and their descendants, until the rest of the world goes broke supporting them.

 
 

Who is online


90 visitors