Eight Crucial Questions for Abbas (and One for President Obama)
Eight Crucial Questions for Abbas (and One for President Obama)
By John Ryan, The Gatestone Institute, March 15, 2014
Question #1: Does Israel have a right to exist?
President Barack Obama meets with Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas in the Oval Office in 2009. (Image source: Official White House photo)
There seems to be a double-standard when it comes to how Israel's Prime Minister, Benjamin Netanyahu, and the Palestinian Authority's erstwhile President, Mahmoud Abbas -- now in the tenth year of his four-year term -- are treated by the Obama White House, as well as by many journalists. While Netanyahu is humiliated , insulted , threatened , and told that he must make "painful concessions" for peace, such as releasing more than 100 terrorists merely to get the Palestinians to come to a negotiating table, Abbas a facilitator and supporter of these terrorists is treated with kid gloves, and with Obama virtually begging him to visit.
Here, however, are some questions, starting with the most important, that should be posed to Abbas when he takes a seat in the White House on March 17:
- Does Israel have a right to exist?
- Yasser Arafat, the first president of the Palestinian Authority [PA], accepted Israel as a Jewish state, and the homeland of the Jewish people. As the recent UNESCO exhibit documented, Jews have been on Israeli land, and in the disputed areas in Judea and Samaria (the West Bank) for 3,500 years, 2,000 years prior to the advent of Islam. You, however, recently said that you do not accept Israel as a Jewish state. Why?
- Will you stop using the humanitarian aid money given to you by the U.S. and the U.N. for prohibited purposes, such as paying salaries to and glorifying terrorists, and inciting mass hatred against Jews , even among Palestinian children ?
- Why did you not immediately fire Jibril Rajoub, the supposedly "moderate" senior PA official, after he said in May 2013 that if the PA had a nuclear bomb, it would drop it on Israel that very day?
- Are you prepared to make any concessions to advance the peace process? For example, will you rescind your July 2013 statement that if you get your own state, not a single Jew will be allowed anywhere within it?
- If you strike a deal for peace, how will you ensure that all Palestinian parties, both in the West Bank and the Gaza Strip, uphold it; that the next president of the PA does not say, "Abbas signed that; I did not."?
- If and when you get a Palestinian state, will you announce in Arabic that this agreement brings an end to the conflict?
- And will you then formally order the PA to stop glorifying terrorists and calling for the destruction of Israel in the Palestinian media, school textbooks, summer camps, sports stadiums, crossword puzzles and other outlets?
It would be telling to hear how Abbas answers these questions.
It would also be telling to hear how President Barack Obama answers one question: If Abbas refuses to agree to these "painful concessions," will you stop issuing executive waivers that enable American taxpayer money to still be sent to him, even though you know it is being used for prohibited purposes?
http://www.gatestoneinstitute.org/4216/obama-abbas-meeting
Tags
Who is online
103 visitors

There is no way that Obama would have the guts to don the kid gloves and ask such questions.
Of course not, Buzz. It would be akin to pouring out the whiskey while the drunken abuser sleeps off his latest binge, to try and ensure peace in the household upon his awakening.
The only way to ensure peace in the household is to bow to the abuser's every whim, knowing all along he is only looking for an excuse to lash out.
Well, John, I guess what will satisfy you is if the Jews all moved out of Israel and handed all the land and the improvements therein to the Palestinians. I'm sick of seeing Israel make concession after concession and the Palestinians doing nothing else other than demanding more and more concessions, more and more benefits. Since you call it rank propaganda I'm sure you disbelieve every point made. You probably even deny that rockets are fired into Israeli civilian areas from Gaza. I stand behind every one of the points made in the article, so why don't you publish something that is more to your liking?
John.
I'm always a bit leery about Israeli propagandist, but....
Consider the following;
1 - The questions are rhetorical but why are they rhetorical? Because Obama, or any other president, would not ask them out of fear of alienating Saudi Arabia and their oil. The House of Saud plays a very dangerous game here. It's their money that's propping up the Palestininian governemnt or more accuritly, the militant anti-Israeli sentiment in Palestine. That puts the US between a rock and a hard place as our government supports Israel.
2 - Rather than summarily dismiss the OP's article, I looked up a single point; Abbas's refusal to recognize Israel. He did state that but I wanted to find out why? What was his rationale?
Abbas stated;
"We recognized Israel in mutual recognition in the (1993) Oslo agreement - why do they now ask us to recognize the Jewishness of the state?" he asked.
"Why didn't they present this demand to Jordan or Egypt when they signed a peace agreement with them?" Abbas added. - ...
Abbas is splitting hairs here. Both Egypt and Jordan "recognized" Israel. No mention of a "Jewishness". Where did he come up with that idea?
Maybe I'm oversimplifing this but the recognition of Israel as a state has nothing to do with religion. Were Israel athiest, wiccan, satanic, christian, buddist or hindu, would that matter then? Abbas it would seem is also playing a game.
Whether or not the questions are considered propaganda is meaningless, since they refer to concerns with factual bases. There are two kinds of propaganda - that which is true and that which is false. For example, BDS uses false propaganda to stir the emotions, such as stating that Israel is an apartheid state.
Abbas is going to blow the negotiations when he gets his terrorists released. He does not have and has never had any intention of reaching a peace settlement and has no power to enforce any peace settlement.
Buzz has posed eight questions that strip the blinders off anyone who blames Israel for the lack of a peace settlement, which the world will do when, not if, a settlement is not reached. The US keeps beating Israel over the head to give in, give in, give in, one more concession, just one more, and we will see the light at the end of the tunnel. Well, here is the light for Israel...
That's the only light in the tunnel Israel will ever see from negotiations with Abbas, with Israel tied to the tracks by the US and the rest of the world afraid of angering the Muslims.
Diplomatically, Abbas does not play from a strong hand if he keeps mentioning "Jewishness". If he continues down that path, it gives Israel the upper hand and the moral high ground to continue to disqualify Abbas's intentions. The rejection of a state because of religion violates every code and principle of the UN and international law.
If you are going to go that route, the rest of the world has a right to refuse to recognize any of the Muslim countries based on their refusal to separate their religion from their politics.
Abbas is not serious about the negotiations. Never has been.
Others such as ?
1. Does Israel have a right to exist?
I don't believe Israel should waste time negotiating with a party who disputes your right to even exist. This whole "peace process" has been and will continue to be a farce. It is the Palestinians who need a deal and who are by far the weaker party. Let them come to the table when they are truly serious about resolving the problems (most of their own making).
I cannot think of any political group, nation, religion wherein those within them do not favour themselves more than others. Perhaps someone can help me with an answer to that, because it is an exaggeration to say "disfavour" when it really what is meant is the other side of "prefer". As an example, please point out to me any true Christian who does not prefer to be a Christian (in fact many will proselytize to convert others to Christianity) or a Muslim believer who does not consider non-Muslims to be inferior. I am not saying that the Government of Israel does not treat non-Jews differently than others, but those differences are minimal compared to other countries surrounding it. For example, Christians and Muslims are not drafted into the armed forces, and can only join voluntarily.