Independents Lost; The Co-opting of Words in a Time of Hyperbole
I have been a registered independent since I turned 18 in 1978. Back then, it was very clear what an independent was. An independent did not want to affiliate with a party and did not ascribe to a particular agenda or platform. In 1978, there was only a small libertarian movement and no Tea Party; so we had a basic two party system, each with their own specific platform. People who identified as independents had a different philosophy. We believed in picking our candidates by how closely they identified with our own key issues. Think of this process like ordering from a Chinese menu: one from column A, two from column B, with each independent deciding themselves which candidate matched up based on their convictions.
Over the years, I have belonged to many independent groups. I say groups, because having an Independent Party, would be an oxymoron. The point of being independent is to think for ones self. These independent groups were to help Indies, find like-minded Indies, discuss important issues and exchange ideas and to get the right for Indies to vote in primaries in all 50 states, since we want to be a full part of the political process.
Recently, I decided that I wanted to get back into the fray and join an independent group, since my home state of New York doesnt have open primaries. What I found was to me, disturbing. Upon googling independent party for a local branch, I found that
the word Independent was co-opted by conservative and progressive groups. I found the Independent American Party, whos ideology was so far right, that they even included preppers, giving advice on what food stores well. Yikes!
Still looking I found the American Independent Party, which turns out to be yet another ultra conservative group. What I found interesting, as I read through these sites, is that that they both used the word Patriot in such a manner as to imply that if you didnt agree with them, you were not a Patriot. I found this very disturbing.
I continued my search and found Independent Voting.Org. I go looking for a platformthere is none. So far, so good. Then I see their mission statement.
Our mission is to develop a movement of independent voters for progressive post-partisan reform of the American political process.
Progressive is a key word for liberal. Moreover, while the site recognizes that independents are currently the largest voting block (according to the Pew, more people have declared themselves independents than belong to any one party), they also feel that Indies are fundamentally a liberal movement, which of course, they are not. All of these groups had nothing to do with true independents. They are parties, with fixed agendas and platforms. Their use of the term Independent is a misnomer. They have co-opted a term to mean something that it didnt mean 40 years ago.
On page two of my Google search, I finally found a true independents group, The Independence Party of NYS. Free of words like Patriot, and Progressive, its mission statement rang true to all of us who identify as true independents:
So why discuss a single word independent too thoroughly? It is part of a bigger issue. In the political arena, so many other terms, have been carefully distorted, abused and co-opted. We live in a time of hyperbole, where words used to evoke emotion, and by co-opting these words, we hijack peoples emotions. I am a patriot. I love my country, but I am not a conservative. Yet the word patriot has stolen by the extreme right. The implication is very plain. If I am not a member of this movement, then I cant be a patriot. In addition, according to these sites, if I am not a patriot I am a traitor. Most Americans would call themselves Patriotic and would find being called a traitor abhorrent. As an indie, I believe in grassroots movements, but I am not a progressive. Yet these two concepts seem tied together. I also found out, that if I dont like President Obamas policies, I am a racist. How utterly disturbing. Words like Nazi, fascist, and Marxist, communist are constantly used in ways they insult their true meanings. They have been co-opted by the extremes of both parties to illicit strong feelings. Feelings that they hope will make you want to join their alliance. With each passing misuse, those words are losing their true historical context. The true powerful meaning of those words and the real ugliness of that period of history is getting lost. We might as well just call Hitler a bad man and Stalin a meanie.
And it isnt only these sites that twist our language. Its found in the news media. We live in a world where political personalities try to fill our heads with words that would discourage independent thought. Terms like rightwing nut, Libtard, Teabagger and Koolaid drinker were developed to insult and diminish the other side. They use these terms as weapons and tools to deceive and hide their true agendas. They use words to obfuscate their true intentions. They try to unite their side against the other by evoking our emotions. Thats why Independent has suddenly been latch onto by both the left and the right. Its their desire to mislead the ever-growing group of independents. They are trying to manipulate Indies by carefully manipulating our language with provocative words and phrases, in the hopes of scaring them into choosing a camp. All I can say is, how very Orwellian of them.

The problem is there is no money to promote realIndependent's groups . The bucks go to the left & the right.
I couldn't agree with you more EG!
I hope you are right. Sometimes I get so disgusted at what our country has become.
I often question the ''Patriot'' handle. I guess if you served in the military and where in combat zones and are not far right, your not a ''Patriot''...Interesting, but BS.
Yeah I've heard it all before. Fence sitter. Strange how at election times we are wined and dined and given a rye and not white bread.
They are not independents John. They are partisans, like you and they were bad losers, like most.
That is a big part of it. And that gives the parties control over what states do with their primaries. If all 50 states had independents voting in primaries, things would be quite different, which is exactly what the parties don't want.
rye or fry, but not white...
LMAO Kavika.... definitely not white!
Absolutely. This patriot tag is very annoying. The definition of Patriot:
That is the only meaning that counts.
It does seem to work that way.
Bush: Developed Patriot Act
Obama: ExpandedPatriot Act
Yup. It does seem that way.
BTW, there is that word again. ThePatriot Act is anything but patriotic. The word co-opted again to hide an agenda.
Amen!!
Why Winning The Independent Vote Can Actually Be A Bad Thing
In the final days of the 2012 presidential campaign, Mitt Romney's political director Rich Beeson was steadfast about his candidate's chances in key swing state Ohio .
"Whoever wins independent voters in Ohio, wins Ohio," Beeson said on "Fox News Sunday," two days before the election.
He was, of course, wrong. Romney won self-identified Independents in Ohio by a overwhelming 10 points, according to exit polls , butlost the state to President Barack Obama by 2 points.
A similar trend was seen across much of the country Romney won among Independents by 5 points, 50-45, but lost to Obama, 51-48. The numbers illustrate why winning the Independent vote in pre-election polls isn't necessarily a telltale sign of victory, as many political strategists have suggested.
In fact, what the Independent vote is often more telling of is a lack of commitment among "leaners" to the party.
The best example of that is seen in a candidate to which Romney is often compared John Kerry, whowon the Independent vote by a single point in 2004, but lost the election by about the same margin as Romney did in 2012.
What this means is that the Independent vote is, for two reasons, an unreliable indicator of electoral success. In 2004, Kerry was a candidate who was never completely accepted by the Democratic base. Sound familiar? Except this time, Romney was never fully beloved by the Republican base.
Jim Williams, an analyst at Public Policy Polling, explained during the "unskewing" controversy that a voter's choice to identify as an Independent can change by the day. Republicans who were disenchanted with Romney might have been more apt to identify as Independent, as Democrats were in 2004 when they were dissatisfied with Kerry.
In 2012, a much more reliable indicator of success and a better example of the "swing" vote came from voters who identified as "moderate." In every critical battleground state, Obama won the moderate vote. In Iowa, he captured more than 60% of it. Overall, Obama beat Romney by 15 points among moderates.
True Independents, on the other hand, made up an increasingly small sample when adding in which way Independent voters lean. Take this NBC/Wall Street Journal/Marist poll of Ohio, for example:
NBC/WSJ
According to the poll, just 10% of voters were truly unaffiliated with either party. Hardly enough to win any state, let alone the election
Read more:
Perrie
Very interesting article, thanks for sharing your thoughts on being an independent in the U.S.
I have been a registered independent since the 70's for many of the same reasons you cite, first and foremost in that I want to decide for myself who the best candidate is for a position without regard to which political machine pays their bills
A viable alternative party (parties) to the two major party would indeed be the best thing for the country but that is unlikely to happen any time soon. Some of my fellow Buckeyes favor open primaries for all state and local elections but there is resistance from left and right on such a change - some of the more radical reformers suggest that the top two or three) vote getters in the primary would advance to the general election even if all of them were from the same party or no party. As you might imagine Democrats and Republicans both proclaim that such a thing would certainly bring about the end of democracy as we know it.
Money is the life blood of the political parties and it is much more important to them (all of them) than their constituents, the good of the state(nation) and their focus is not o legislative success but rather on their own reelection.
I will continue to vote for the candidates that I deem best suited to serve
Again great article and thanks for sharing your perspective
John,
I am trying to foster a good discussion here. You were asked a question by EG.
So do you?
But that isn't where I want it to go. I want a discussion, even if at the end of the day, we don't agree. I think that these words we use have prevented us from having a national discussion and that was done on purpose.
Hiya Soul,
I would agree with that statement, if the quote was true. But it isn't. It is something that has been repeated many times on the internet until people just took it for granted that it was absolutely true. There is an interesting discussion about this here:
This is one of the issues that my article is about.
Well, I wouldn't take it to the extent of not being human... but not belonging.
Joanne,
You do realize that you didn't even try to address the content of my article. Is this your way not only to shut down the discussion but also say that Independents don't count? If so, then you are part of the problem.
I can think of as many conservative governors along with liberal ones. I don't think it makes a difference how liberal or conservative they are... the point is to shut out any dissenting voices. In that way, they both retain control.
Hiya Robert,
Thanks!
Lucky you! In NY, indies are a no go.
Which is why how we chose to have this as a national discussion, it is important that we don't let the parties dictate the meaning of words. They are shutting down the discussion by dividing us with these words.
Which is a big problem, that was made worse with "Citizens United". Just look at that term and see it for the lie it is. It has nothing to do with citizens and everything to do with big corporations.
Think of me, when you do.
Signed,
Frustratedin New York
I never voted a straight ticket until these last six election cycles. The term Liberal is a misnomer in respect to Republicans or Democrats. When the Republicans signed a pact that they would not vote for anything the President wanted I decided there was no more interest in the Republican party for me. The Republicans are pro war anywhere anytime.
Liberal means what not anything. Liberal in what respect. The most supposedly Liberal seems to be the the Democratic party. Republicans are trying to get Republicans and other citizens to believe the Country is meant to be Christian ( Catholic ) only. (My perception.) Republican Right Wing Christians no longer believe in the Bible except when it coincides with their desires. What does the three parties really represent? Republican = big business, Democratic = working class, Independent what ever they desire. If only it were that easy. Current day Politics need to be limited to one term Senate and House. They would no longer be a new campaign starting right after winning the election. Cash to any candidate should be a criminal offense. Both for the Politician and the Company CEO and CFO, limit campaign expenditure county, state and Federal. Every Politician running gets the same amount. Drastic but we need some limitations its a free for all. Cash winner almost always wins.
Lies against A POLITICIAN SHOULD BE CRIMINALIZED. News and Media shows should be fined for every lie say maybe $500,000. If repeated $500,000 more.
Always exceptions one Bernie Sanders!
John,
I am not a libertarian, or a democrat. Yet I feel both have something interesting to offer in a discussion. If we shut each other out, then there is no compromise, and our nation must compromise in order to survive.
Even our founding fathers knew this. The Declaration of Independence was one big compromise.
Impractical from a legal standpoint ...
Soul,
Thank you for clarifying your last post. Now I get it and agree. I think that having discussions like this, IS the way to change how we have a national dialog. If we insist on reasonable discussions, using words in their proper context, then I think eventually it will catch on.
Call it a grassroots movement
Hiya RM,
I am not sure what you mean that the word "Liberal"misnomer in respect to Republicans or Democrats. What does liberal mean to you?
I believe that was done by the Tea Party and not all republicans, but I think that an act like that divides.
Well, I am not so sure that the Democrats are any different. Vietnam kind of case and point.
Democrats are many things from Blue dogs to liberal ones. The whole party isn't liberal per se, but has liberals in it.
I kind of agree with the notion that extreme ends of the Republican party see this as a 'Christian Nation" (btw, that isn't Catholics. Catholics are a minority Christian group, usually aligned with Democrats. I am guessing you meanEvangelicalChristian like Baptists and Pentecostals, etc).
I don't think we can divide up these groups into those desires. Like most things in life, I think that it's far more complex than that... and I can tell you as an independent, I never get what I want... including respect. I don't even get to vote in primaries, LOL!
Well I have to agree with you there 100%
The courts would run 24/7 and we could do a lot of funding from the monies from the news media LOL!
What is Petey?
Any organizing groupthroughout history, to a greater or lesser extent, has co-opted phraseology in order to gain or remain in power because the way to nudgepeopleto action is to play on their emotions.
Are we getting older and wiser, therefore the stridency of the messages seems greater, or is it in fact greater?
Politicsis driven by traction, aka elections and the mean to win them. In todays political theater, we have focus groups and polling to judge the attitudes of the people. In order to get more people to vote for a candidate, the parties look at the results of polls and focus groups in order to develope a message to gain more votes, to gain traction, to wheedle out more people who might otherwise stay home and sit on their couch for whatever reason.
Combining the need for more votes with the use of language to get out the vote has resulted in the dichotomous atmosphere that you describe, I feel.
Have a great day!
This proposal from RMer :
Libel & slander can be prosecuted but political statements generally lack provability .
I've always agreed with that.
My semi-serious, semi-joking opinion has always been, " The only reason our actions involve logic/reasoning at times, is because our hearts (emotions) aren't into it!"
Brolly,
A very interesting perspective. I agree.
Gee, that was quick and easy, LOL!
HA! Good one Chloe! I've got to remember that.
Oh yes, quite true Petey.
Robert,
Since it has nada to do with the topic, other than to say indies don't count (which we all know anyway/sarc).... until the next election. And only Joanne knows if she is a patriot or not, but I am guessing she is.
An argument I have had since I turned 18. (A few years before you did Perrie) To me at least, if there is to be any kind of meaningful and reasonable discussion concerning politics or religion, it is best to stick to the denotative meaning. If I do not "feel" the same way about a word, the connotative meaning is going to become a sticking point and most likely lead to either 1) No discussion, or 2) a screaming match.
Words can and do have a connotative value which can be as valid as the denotative, but it can also be more destructive.
Judging by the various hits I get on my political and philosophical searches, I'm an independent libertarian tree hugging redneck Latino Native American. I hardly know what box to get in.
Independent is merely the latest catchphrase. We have a long political history of them. "Taking my country back" is a good phrase. Has a lot of feeling to it. The only problem is, I didn't know my country had gone anywhere.
I am becoming very distrustful of speakers/bloggers/posters use of words. It is very easy and misleading to use a word for its connotative use only.
Mike,
I have often written about this misnomer about Indies. But my article wasn't about whether or not indies matter in the political landscape (which BTW I believe they do), but the misuse of words for political agendas. She successfully got this thread off topic.
LOL, Me too!
Absolutely true. Believe it or not I have to be sure about that when I moderate. Sometimes I ask for clarification. I even do that when commenting. I find that the written language provides for more connotative values, which leads to more unnecessary strife.
Steve,
In all my time that I have devoted to independents and independent movements... the main difference I have found with true independents, is the idea of a third party. Some see it as a necessary evil. Kind of the big tent of politics. Others see it as an oxymoron, and although a third party would be better, since more choices is always better than less, they don't want a party that would be labeled Independent.
But no matter what, they are not a left or right movement.
Robert, the answer is no. There is no such thing as an Independent.
All quite true. My family (again) is a good example of what I keep coming across. They agree that R and D are playing the same game, but they cannot see a way out of the box. They are uneasy in open space.
So we are figments of our own imaginations. Cool!!!
Is there a possibility of there being an Independent, or are they an absolute impossibility?
Yup-- that's the only way a true democracy can actually work.
There are a lot of indies who would agree with you Randy. I'm on the fence
Steve,
I get that. But a good start would be just being able to vote in all 50 states in the primaries. Then the rest would follow...
LMAO you guys.. Sometimes I feel invisible.
But to answer Robert.
This article isn't about what an independent would do. It is about the twisting of our language to gain a political agenda. Did you read the article?
Mike,
Orwell was right.
Steve,
Love that visual!
Mike..
You need music to go with that!
I'm shockingly shocked that you are shocked!
Steve,
So do I!! lol
I think so, as well, Perrie. I seeded articles in the past about his views, and I think he had it right on the money!
BINGO!
There are two parties in this country and only two parties in this country that can win an election in Washington. Occasionally you have a Senator run as an Independent and win. But for all practical purposes we really have only two parties with the power to gain or hold on to the power.
The only other and mind you I think it is getting close to our last opportunity is the people themselves. We are becoming more and more divided as a nation and I don't see anything pushing back against it from continuing with the exception of a nation of disillusioned citizens who are waking up to the reality they have lost control of their government. I would like to say losing control, so I will say it isn't over until it's over. I disagree with "the only thing you have to fear is fear itself." I think we have plenty to fear.
We are not United Americans anymore. We are a nation divided by diversity. We would like to be United Americans despite our diversity. It's in the way different minds process things. Some will jump on that and some will understand it is a call to unite as Americans with the true meaning of the word patriot.
Well these politicians we have in Washington are certainly not patriots. And there have been few patriots in Washington for a long time.
And how are we to even begin to come together as Americans? What a task that will be.
Since we do not have control of our government or politicians do we think they are going to do anything we want them to do, like voting to serve one or two term political positions? No! Do you think they are going to cut the money out of elections? No! How do you think they got so rich? Politics is big business. Look at some of the politicians when they do leave office. What do they do? Why do you think they get so much for speeches or go to work for some lobbying organization and get paid such extravagant salaries . Face it folks, we're screwed. There is hope though, I mean real hope, not the kind we were promised, but it is up to us.
If you are dissatisfied with our government and think it has become too powerful and we have lost our power over it, then I recommend we learn all we can from this book by Mark Levin. Don't turn your eyes and ears off since many of you will have entirely different political ideologies than he does. This is the only way to regain our power over this government, get the money out, cut the terms or have people that actually represent us instead of corporations, which both parties represent.
A little information about the book.
For a century, the Statists have steadfastly constructed a federal Leviathan, distorting and evading our constitutional system in pursuit of an all-powerful, ubiquitous central government. The result is an ongoing and growing assault on individual liberty, state sovereignty, and the social compact. Levin argues that if we cherish our American heritage, it is time to embrace a constitutional revival.
The delegates to the 1787 Constitutional Convention in Philadelphia and the delegates to each states ratification convention foresaw a time whendespite their best efforts to forestall itthe Federal government might breach the Constitutions limits and begin oppressing the people. Agencies such as the IRS and EPA and programs such as Obamacare demonstrate that the Framers fear was prescient. Therefore, the Framers provided two methods for amending the Constitution. The second was intended for our current circumstancesempowering the states to bypass Congress and call a convention for the purpose of amending the Constitution. Levin argues that we, the people, can avoid a perilous outcome by seeking recourse, using the method called for in the Constitution itself.
The Framers adopted ten constitutional amendments, called the Bill of Rights, that would preserve individual rights and state authority. Levin lays forth eleven specific prescriptions for restoring our founding principles, ones that are consistent with the Framers design. His proposalssuch as term limits for members of Congress and Supreme Court justices and limits on federal taxing and spendingare pure common sense, ideas shared by many. They draw on the wisdom of the Founding Fathersincluding James Madison, Benjamin Franklin, Thomas Jefferson, and numerous lesser-known but crucially important menin their content and in the method for applying them to the current state of the nation.
Now is the time for the American people to take the first step toward reclaiming what belongs to them. The task is daunting, but it is imperative if we are to be truly free.
...
Independents lean one way or the other and in today's society they do not determine who wins elections by being able to think for themselves any more than anyone else. In fact a moderate candidate betting on the independent votes may not draw enough from his/her own party to win an election any more than an extreme right or left would.
Chloe...
Link please!
They are not going to vote against themselves. They are the government and then there are the rest of us.
It's in my head, Perrie.... ughhhh....oooohhh...ouch! ...I tried to unscrew it from my neck, but it didn't work.
It's from a flick called Videodrome. Warning: Not safe for anyone under the age of 35 or a puritans heart.
George Orwells Letter on Why He Wrote 1984
Well, its going to take a very large groundswell to change that system. Probably something along the lines of an 8.4 on the Richter scale.
I think I've said this before, but how do we get people to start thinking about what they hear?
By the way, it's good to see you again. I do so admire your work.
Some wisdom from his article here..
"...Everywhere the world movement seems to be in the direction of centralised economies which can be made to work in an economic sense but which are not democratically organised and which tend to establish a caste system. With this go the horrors of emotional nationalism and a tendency to disbelieve in the existence of objective truth because all the facts have to fit in with the words and prophecies of some infallible fuhrer. "
Perrie.....
One look at the playbook of either major party, and you will see that they are both filled with political buzzwords to color peoples opinions before they even know the details on a topic. They sell fear, because fear sells. As examples....
Gun control, Obamacare, liberal, Muslim, social-(whatever), (whatever)-gate.
And I have to say that conservatives have done a better job of boiling things down to what I call bumper sticker politics. A simple quick strike to sell fear into individuals without the need to understanding the details of an issue. It may have something to do with the Sesame Street mentality that we have due to information overload, or it is an effort to keep things brief so they don't go looking for details.
In short, many people don't think on things for more than 20 seconds. This might also explain why we have the type of dysfunctional congress that we have.
Oh but think of the revenue opportunity Petey! The national debt would be gone in no time.
I agree, Petey... the winners will, unfortunately, always be those with the most money.
__
The powers that be understand the value of the one word catchphrase very well. I call it bumper-sticker politics. Their goal is to move people for or against a topic using a simple word or statement. The last thing most of them want is for people to go looking for the real details on issues.
I don't know if we can. Sesame Street has programmed much of Americans perception into accepting what they see and hear at 20 second intervals. Based on what I have seen out of many of the young engineers I have been hiring and working with over the last 20 or so years, I think I have seen a shift away from curiosity.
JOhn
I know you asked Mike in Ga but in my view the "powers that be: in American politics are the two major parties that control the money (or the money controls them I am not sure) and thus control the country.
It's silly to you John because you don't understand it. This is not a conservative or liberal idea. This is for those people, which there are many who have become aware they have lost control of this government. His conservative ideas has nothing to do with the "The Liberty Amendments". It takes 3/5ths of the state legislatures to overrule the President and Congress and only that will give us limited term limits, get the money out of politics, limit Supreme Court Justices and give the power back to the people. Now it is up to us Liberal, Conservative or whatever who want to regain power in Washington and that is a fact. Then we can have real "Hope and Change" which we don't have now. You are so loyal to Obama that you don't realize the way it is now when the cards fall the other way, you'll be totally against it, but you will have no more control than you do now. The government has all the power and it is becoming more centralized. That is not a good thing to most Americans. Of course there are those who would relish the idea of Communism.
Thanks Six!
This article rang true to me, for sure!
When we went to war in Iraq, which then somehow got us into Afghanistan, I was sick to my stomach. I knew that it was this generation's Vietnam, and that it would be a long and basically pointless war that we could not win and could only abandon. I was afraid to voice my opinion to anyone, because then, I wasn't a True Patriot, but a Traitor.
I started my life as a moderate. I am still a moderate. A centrist. A person in the middle. The past few years, with the black/white world we now live in, every political test I take turns me into a liberal. What's up? I haven't changed my moderate stance. The political climate has changed-- and both sides are using words that inflame, label, and basically, hurt others.
I am sick of this: "My way or the highway" kind of politics. We're not getting anything done, we're just spinning our wheels. People are suffering, while our elected leaders sit on their hands and fight with one another.
I have absolutely no time for those who would inflame. Glenn Beck stating that he knew that he had a hand in dividing our country-- but does he stop? Nope. I used Glenn Beck as an example, but all the political pundits do it. They smear and insult and tilt things toward their own bias to the point that there IS no truth.
I think you're right, Perrie. The words "Patriot" and "Progressive" have been usurped, just as other words are usurped to the point that they are, basically, meaningless.
King, Angus S., Jr. - (I - ME)
Sanders, Bernard - (I - VT)
I've been meaning to get the book Mike. It is a movement that has already started in a number of states. It is neither conservative nor liberal, but American people who have awaken to the reality that the government has gained complete control over the people. It is explained in the book the process and it is the only way we are going to save this country for all. Even those who think, it's just to control Obama will not like what is in store for us if we don't regain the power over this government.
And I don't care if anyone thinks I'm a conspiracy theorist. If they can't see it, then we who can must act in order to save them as well.
OY. Somehow this whole thing went off topic, but since I am not a control freak.. let's carry on.
Six,
First, of course independents have little power. The can't even vote in primaries in all 50 states. Now why do you think that is? It's the other two parties who have made it nearly impossible to do. I have been involved on a very personal level, and I can tell you, that IS by their design. The new influx of indies don't realize that. They are just disgusted with our government. They tend to be moderates and the disenfranchised. They are not organized....yet. But from what I have heard at meetings, that might change.
Again I don't think that diversity is a big deal. It is not why we have become dysfunctional. It's everything else in our government that has. Our Supreme Court has been bought. How else could "Citizens United" have passed through? Our entire government is also bought and since we don't have term limits, they get fat off of corporate funding. There are too many agencies, and too much waste that comes with them. They all start with good intentions, but grow into monsters. The EPA was a good idea, but just ask the all the first responders at 9/11 how they feel about them now. ChristieWhitmanliedabout Ground Zeroairquality,9/11. There are ALS clusters around major chemical plants. This is corporate sponsoredgovernment intervention. It's disgusting.
To get back on point....our parties have created this divide. It actually works... for them and not for us. And they did that bypoisoningour minds. Our two party system keeps us from uniting against them. You want to get back your country? Find common ground and go with it. There are enough things that most Americans agree on, like term limits, election funding, getting rid of the pork. Find the things we have in common and don't let the parties tell you what to think.
EG,
When I run an article, I am very careful with it. It is my baby, since I write them, instead of seed them. I am also very good at herding cats. It's my specialty. Have faith, and most people will respond in a good manner.
Fly,
I have not taken stock of each parties "buzz words". I am sure that both have a nice amount of them. But it is quicker to sell fear. Fear works. We saw that with Nazi Germany. Hitler sold fear. Sadly we are a very predictable animal. We run on our gut, and that is what the parties know and count on.
Our dysfunctional government is broken because they want it to be. It works for them. They have stop representing us, but we are too dumb to have noticed. You are right when you say that many people don't think on things for more than 20 seconds. If they did, they would be horrified. And the worst thing about this is... our parties know this and use it against us.
Robert,
You seem to be the only one confused, and I think that is because you focused on the independent part. The only thing to take away from the word independent, is that it's another co-opted word. Nothing more. It was a spring board to the meat of the issue. How our language has been twisted to manipulate by the powers that be. Hence why I included pictures. It wasn't to make the article colorful. They were examples. Stop misdirecting the discussion.
Well thank goodness, you are talking right up my alley now. But the thing I'm trying to get across there is no way to regain the people's power over the government with votes. You can build your Independent Party until they control 75% of everything, but it will only be a short term solution and they will become power hungry and the corruption will still exist. The only way to accomplish what I and you have outlined above is through the State Legislatures. Washington is not going to ever give up their power, no matter who is in control on their own.
By the way if a discussion accomplishes something positive it is worthwhile. Words do make a difference. Independents lean on way or the other which makes them a part of one party or the other when we only have two parties. Think about it. A third party is going to lean one way or the other. Whichever way it leans will probably hurt that party if we have a third party.
So here we have it. Both Fly and Mike on the same page. Normally you two would disagree, yet here we find common ground. And that is what we should be aiming for. But the parties fill our head with crap, and as pointed out here we are programmed and we have a hard time with objectivity. We are fed a mass media diet and our brains have rotted.
Dowser,
You are so on point! And I have never given the "War on Terror" as the starting point for this, but maybe it was. I was far to close to the situation. We needed to do a hit and run in Afghanistan. Instead, we got involved with "Nation Building", little good it's doing for us now. Iraq... that is our Vietnam. But terms like "WMD"s, "war on terror" seemed so appropriate at the time for many. Personally, I never bought into the war in Iraq. Definitely not killing Saddam. When that day arrived, I knew we had just made a more powerful Iran... we are still paying for that one now. But we all want to be Patriots. We even name our missals after that concept.
according to a new Economist/YouGov.com poll.
The poll asked those who voted for Obama's reelection a simple question: Do you regret voting for Barack Obama?
55 percent of Democrats said yes, as did 71 percent of independents
Hello Joanne.....
THIS ARTICLE ISN'T ABOUT INDEPENDENTS!!!
I realize that this is quite purposeful by you. Knock it off.
Mike,
She got you to go off topic.
John,
Stop being obnoxious on my article. Next time I will get a mod.
I think it's very possible that some use the word "Independent" semantically, and also as a scapegoat. I've read articles in the past that suggest we do this because we are now embarrassed to be associated with either 'side.' We still have left or right leanings, because the issues 'are' left or right in principle - so they aren't "Independent" thoughts by nature - they just don't want to be labelled - and to me, that's the gist of it - we don't 'all' fall under a label, but those that want to control us, use their epithets to do exactly that!
If we wanted Sadam Hussein dead, why didn't we turn him over to the international war crimes thingy at the Haig? Why did we allow Iraq to turn it into a farce? Terrorists killing terrorists-- let the man die with a modicum of dignity. Let the world decide that he deserves death-- not that rabble that actually executed him. That was an embarrassment, to me. That we played a part in allowing that to happen-- well, I was ashamed. It wasn't 'professional'.
All of us love our country. That shouldn't be questioned, just because we happen to disagree with some of the things our political leaders do or say.
...and with good reason!
96,
Definitely..
I don't want to wear a label and don't. I have principles that I view as morally correct and politically correct using Constitutional 'protections,' but that sure doesn't mean my thinking agrees with 'every' issue from a - 'side.'
TOTALLY OFF TOPIC......
I am going to be setting up a trial on wordpress which does have a an ignore function. Ning doesn't offer this, but I am sure that if we decide to stay with Ning, I could find a code writer for it... is this something we really want as a group??????
Dowser,
It was because President Bush wanted him dead that we didn't hand him over to the Haig. There is no death penalty in the EU.
I would say a very high percentage do love our country. And you are right, it shouldn't be questioned!
Oh I totally agree.
I can see that I am going to have to do an article about independents. The only reason that they lean one way or the other is because we only have two parties and if you want to vote in an election at present, you have to pick the lessor of two evils, as you see it, or not vote at all. Frankly, right now, no party fits me.
Gonna have to disagree with you there. Many countries have more than two parties and each is very different. A true third party could be a moderate party It could be alibertarianparty. We could have 4 parties. The point is that with more choice, you break down the strong hold the 2 party system has.
I don't understand why people need to delete, ignore or HATE other people.. on the internet... This is the internet not a real-life discussion - take it for what it is... in a political environment -- it's just someone's opinion - So What??!!
Some people like to play manipulative games - I'm not referencing anyone in particular with that statement. But, if we feel someone is manipulating us or setting us up - we only have ourselves to support, as the Mods might not recognize deception. In that event, don't play with them; seek those that are honest, level-headed and 'caring of others' type of people.
This isn't a difficult concept...'ignore' and delete can be! It's saying "I hate you" and the world doesn't need more of that!! Haters should leave, not force us to go along with destructive attitudes, imo.
Again, I'm not referencing anyone in particular. I'm just seriously disappointed in people on these social sites using this venue as a means to get away with being mean-spirited, causing more division between people.
John,
In no way am I implying that Saddam was a good guy. He was evil. But hegemony prevailed, and what we thought was in our interests turned against us and created an even bigger monster, Iran. Iraq was always what kept Iran in check, and now we have a vacuum of power to deal with.
Thanks for saying that Chloe!
Thank you, my friend.
I get very emotional over those buttons and what they can do to people that were once exchange partners that worked very well.
Not here, but what I've seen happen is that those using their power with those tools can influence other people, that didn't have the 'hate,' but now do because they don't want to appear disloyal to that friend.
Perrie, if I may, to prove how allowing the hate to grow and how ironic it can be - there is someone that was once on another site that started a private group because he was sick of all of the 'hate' -- he, in turn, used his group to perpetuate it by controlling others. Hate is a disease, in my opinion, and I think as good people, we should try to stamp it out.
Agreed. It is a useless emotion.
Hi jwc,
Actually, there was excellent dialog shortly after that. It seems that the kiddies always need a page till the settle down. But on my articles, the teacher is always in the room.
OMG, et tu? The main complaint is that our language is being used against us. I just used my search for an independent group as a spring board to the discussion. The term independent is among a whole list of words that have been co-opted to mean something else.
There are 2 types of independents. One has no interest in forming a party, but would like to be able to vote in primaries. They view an independent party as an oxymoron. The other group sees it as a "big tent" party, where a platform is achieved by the long unused word... compromise.
They are here and we talk among ourselves. It isn't fun to be mocked, so many don't participate in these discussions. It used to bother me a lot... but not so much anymore.
Good one Mike!
Did I ever say that he should have been kept in power? I said he should have been convicted in an international court of law for crimes against humanity. I don't think that means he should have been left in power.
I don't give a toot about what happened to Mussolini, it wasn't right. It should have been handled "professionally" in an international court of law.
I think you're being intentionally argumentative and obtuse.
No I said he should have been left alone.
Yes he was a murder, but he kept an evil regime in check. Without him, we now have to deal with another evil empire that is about to go nuclear. And in case you have missed the news, KimKim Jong-un, has been doing mass executions, murder of babies, rape, torture, fed his uncle to dogs, and has been proclaimed by the UN, who usually does little, as being as evil as Hitler. Ummm.. any takers? That is what happens when an evil empire is allowed to go atomic and that is what Saddam kept in check. This is an ugly world, but sometimes we have to do a balancing act and resist our need for selective hegemony. Seems that we don't care much about Syria. How much more or less evil is Assad? But then Assad never tired to kill a presidents dad before either.
An interesting way to put that. I've always thought of it like this, linear thinking.
I'm currently trying to train a young lady who wants all the steps to be A, B, C, D, E. Everything process starts with A but the rest of the steps could be C,E,D,B or any other order. Drives her nuts! I take it as a given.
Sometimes you have to go outside of what you have been told and do G so that you can have B. In effect, create a new process.
Language is the same way. As long as most hear the right words, the group must be good. There is no curiosity to see what is behind the curtain.
Wow ... that is a very interesting way to look at it. I think a lot of people are not comfortable withoutlinear thinking. I have to think about it myself. I guess we all expect things in a certain order. We like to know where we are going. It's all about comfort levels.
Gee... I'm a bit out of mine.
Interesting thoughts, Steve... Some things have to be: first the bread, then the peanut butter, others don't have to be in a certain order to work - like, chocolate milk. We can put the chocolate in the glass first, if we want to.
If we ever thought that we were going to turn them into a democracy, we must have been mad.
I think we agree, Randy.
Come now Perrie. I can't see you being out of your comfort level.
In my example above, we always know where we are going, what the final product must look like. It is the steps to get there that aren't always in the same order.
In political terms it could be something like this:
Rather than always being R then D, how about, Independent, Green, Libertarian or something else. Why just always Republican, Democrat?
It is the same with the co-opting of words. They make us 'feel' that this group will get us back to Kansas, when in reality they are leading us directly to the wicked witch.
The 'feel' of the words makes us believe we are safe when we aren't, we are being co-opted to achieve an end we do not want. And it is independent thinking, or lack thereof, that is allowing this.
I read what was going around about PNAC at the time, but it was played up as the evil MIC; I hadn't known of any Iraq implications at the time. Did you ever give the notion any credibility that he did it to fulfill his Father's requests? (Bush)
Quite true, but what if the order is for a peanut butter, jelly and banana sandwich? (Yuck!) Which comes first? Obviously, you (almost) always will start with the bread. The other parts, does it matter?
OK, now I think I get what you mean, Steve and I can sign on to that. In fact, I agree.
I would say - most of the time, no; probably because I cook, I can see how things often come out better when added in a certain order, e.g. lasagna, maybe? I've noticed when I've made other combination dishes, the herbs and spices are better when they are touching certain ingredients more than others - but that might be personal taste, I don't know. With many things, order doesn't seem to matter, imo, too.
I guess we've been talking about two different things. I've been talking about the system we now have and you're talking about changing that system. Right now we only have the two party system and calling oneself an Independent doesn't mean a thing to me in this current party system. You're correct, you only have two choices. And how do you think we are going to produce this third party? I am serious and not being sarcastic. At this point it would seem comparable to having a runner letting the other two runners start 4 seconds before him/her in a 100 yard dash. I don't think we have the time to pursue this first. I think we must take the power away from Washington first as I've proposed above which you repeated in a comment right below mine having the same objectives. I think you understand I'm not a hard right. I tend to strongly resist when I see the hammer and sickle coming down on us and want to stand my ground.
Being Independent is a frame of mind, not a political party. Voting for a candidate that best suits your beliefs requires more than two choices, especially when both choices are heavily influenced by corporate money.
We should have never eliminated Saddam. That compares to killing your only guard dog. And the war in Afghanistan wasn't the one we should have been in as Obama said. Notice we never get involved in any country or war unless there is money in it for the Industrial War Complex. People can be getting killed my the thousands and unless we can find a reason to drop a bunch of bombs we don't get involved.
Zackly, Six.
Well put!
Aeon,
I tend to go with your way of thinking. And we NEED more than two choices each election. The competition will make them have to perform. Right now we have a political monopoly.
AP,
That's close to the point I've made as well. I still see them as having values from the moralism of either side, but they don't want to be labeled as either one. That's my own stance, as well.
I don't see any actual independent thought happening - and can't, because the values are already part of our nature - we just don't want to be locked into saying - 'only' a Democrat or Republican can value 'this.'