There's no doubt the Affordable Care Act will redistribute wealth
People at the top of the income ladder will pay more; people at the bottom will benefit. But how, exactly, will that work?
A new study finds that Obamacare's redistribution will be stunningly lopsided. Scholars at the liberal Brookings Institution have discovered that Obamacare will increase the income of Americans in the lowest 20 percent of the income scale, and especially in the lowest ten percent. But all other income groups -- even people who make very modest incomes in the $25,000 to $30,000 range, as well as all income brackets above that -- will experience a decline in income because of Obamacare.
In other words, Obamacare is going to cost some of the very people it was designed to help.
Brookings scholars Henry Aaron and Gary Burtless sought to determine the law 's impact on income in 2016, when almost all of Obamacare will be in effect. To do so, they adopted a broad definition of income -- not just a person's wages, but also pension income, employer health coverage, government cash transfers, food stamps , other benefits , and now, subsidies from Obamacare.
They found quite an impact. "The ACA may do more to change the income distribution than any other recently enacted law," Aaron and Burtless wrote. Obamacare provides billions in subsidies to those who qualify, expands Medicaid benefits, cuts Medicare , fines those who don't purchase government-approved coverage and levies new taxes -- all of which will change how much income millions of Americans bring in each year.
Aaron and Burtless' first finding is no surprise: Obamacare will mean more for the lowest-income Americans. It will increase income by 9.2 percent for the lowest bracket households making below about $21,000 a year for those in their working years, age 25 to 64.
Then the surprise. Obamacare will reduce, by an estimated 0.9 percent, the incomes of working-age Americans in the next-lowest income bracket, households making between about $21,000 and $40,000 a year. And in the next income group, households making between about $40,000 and $65,000 a year Obamacare will reduce their income, too, also by 0.9 percent.
A 1 percent reduction in income is relatively small. But it is still a reduction -- and not at all what President Obama and Democrats in Congress promised. When the president pledged that Obamacare would make the health care system "better for everybody," it's doubtful Americans interpreted that as meaning it would reduce their income.
"The administration is playing with fire," said former Congressional Budget Office director Douglas Holtz-Eakin. "They sold this as 'only rich people pay, and everyone benefits,' and now we're finding out it's not true."
Less surprisingly, Aaron and Burtless found that Obamacare will also reduce the incomes of Americans in higher brackets. For working-age households bringing in between about $65,000 and about $104,000 a year, Obamacare will reduce income by another 0.9 percent. And for those in the highest bracket, households above $104,000, the decrease will be 0.5 percent.
Why? There could be a number of factors, but the authors suggest that because the Affordable Care Act will make health care more expensive, a significant number of people who receive health coverage through their job will be affected. "Incomes fall ... primarily because the expansion in employer-sponsored insurance is predicted to cause a modest drop in money wages as employers devote a larger share of their compensation payments to health benefits," the researchers wrote.
Aaron and Burtless also found that Americans age 65 and older will see their incomes drop, and by bigger margins. Those at the bottom of the household income scale same boundaries as above will see a drop of 1.3 percent, and those in the next lowest group will see a decrease of 1.7 percent. The next income category will see a 1.1 percent drop, and the top two categories will see drops of 0.7 and 0.2 percent. Since most Americans in that age group are on Medicare, it seems likely the income decreases are caused mostly by Obamacare's cuts in the rate of growth of Medicare spending.
In an interview, Burtless stressed that most people above the lowest bracket will not see their income affected by Obamacare. But in a Jan. 27 Brookings panel discussion, Aaron noted that Obamacare's costs have to be borne somewhere.
"Some very large benefits will accrue to the millions of people who will become newly eligible for Medicaid and refundable tax credits [under Obamacare]," Aaron said. "But the president and Congress went to great lengths to prevent the ACA from adding to the federal budget deficit. Someone has to pay for those benefits."
That someone, it turns out, is a very large group of Americans who aren't rich, and who didn't expect to be falling behind because of Obamacare.
http://washingtonexaminer.com/byron-york-obamacare-will-reduce-incomes-of-most-americans/article/2543390

and each and every one of them would vote for him all over again.
Hey Middle Class, that's you!
Our Government has become Robbing-Hood; taking from those perceived to be rich, to give to those perceived to be poor. Of course some of the "rich" aren't rich at all, straining from paycheck to paycheck, sacrificing and working their asses off to take care of their families; and, not all the "poor" are poor either, with so many just too damn lazy too get off their asses.
Did you ever have a serious health issue, requiring hospitalization and followup?
Yes.
Have you ever had someone take your money because they felt someone else was more entitled to it?
Guess Larry hasn't been out of work lately. Mywife's Office has been hiring and they get hundreds of applicants for every job offered. They have had to hire a company to wade thru the applicants. These people are mostly out of work people. Larry there are millions of people out of work only college educated people are hired at my wife's place of work. Thousands of interviews for the openings they have. Many ten times that if you consider the Resumes sent in response. They have a company to do initial interviews to whittle down the 10 or less finally accepted for face to face company interviews.
First, I'm sorry that you said 'Yes.' Hope things are better.
Second, then you know there is no money changing into your hands, no handouts, only check writing or debits from you account. No one gets paid to be sick. This concept is complete bullshit. As close as we get to a benefit is having the hospital and insurance company dancing over your large bill. AND if you're really lucky, they pay it all. Maybe higher premiums are paid by some, but that's not redistribution, it's called price of service.Better service = higher price.
No sir. But I do give to charity.
Affordable health care will not raise the cost of health care. Medicine will not go up doctors rates will not go up because of affordable health care. Crazy.
See, that's the problem. The premiums are higher (much higher, largest we've ever seen, over thirty percent increase with jumps in the deductibles as well) and the service is no better. That equates to REAL MONEY going out of real families pockets.It'snot bullshit and it's not just chump change either, it's the difference between paying the mortgage or buying groceries and the kids school chlothes, or repairing the car or fridge....
The funding of the ACA is being borne on the backs of the Middle Class; What will drive the economy once the Middle Class is broken?
While that is noble and worthy, it is not at all the same thing as a tax.
You don't have to speak of me in the third person RMeR, I'm right here.
And no, I haven't been out of work recently or for very long; when one job is over, I got bills to pay, so I go right out and get another job. Perhaps whomever is without a job and would like one where you live, should consider moving to northern Minnesota or North Dakota, we have jobs.
I do believe in Universal health care. I do NOT believe we should break the backs of the Middle Class to do so.
I agree, big government should step in force the private sector to price their products and services according to a universally accepted pricing schedule, thus taking money out of the pockets of some of the most successful capitalists in the world. Obama is not being a big enough dictator. Go socialism!!
So do I. But the reason that we have this crazy system now is because a block of our congress didn't want it.
I agree. This is a totally half baked system.
With all due respect Hal it's not like you can go next door to the competitor for a cheaper price. Especially if you're taken to one by an ambulance. There is no capitalistic choice for consumers.
My comment was purely sarcastic. The point I was alluding to, is that the people who scream the loudest about Obama being a socialist dictator are the ones who repeatedly point out that the PPACA does not address the real problem, which is price gouging. The only realistic way to address that in any significant way would be single payer, which amounts to government intervention to mandate maximum charges for products and services ... which is indicative of a socialistic response. It's where we are today, because we were dumb enough to not adopt socialized medicine long ago like the rest of developed world, and we let capitalism rape the shit out of the healthcare industry to the point where a pint of saline costs us $100 rather than $2.
What's the problem? That a better plan costs more money? This was my point. Frankly, I don't understand what you mean. I can't afford top shelf insurance. Most people can't, its cost prohibitive. Yet any one worried about income redistribution, a fear of the richer class and their bullet point minions, can certainly afford higher priced insurance. If you are referring to the actual bills paid, then that is a different issue. I thought this was about Obamacare, which it about obtaining healthcare insurance, not the price of the care itself.
And I guess I missed where the 30% figure comes from, sorry.
The middle class has been carrying the tax burden in the US of A for a long, long time. Im not saying its right, but it's a fact Jack Larry. I'd love if that were not so. Because if it wasadifferent reality, this middle class working stiffmight actually feel good about something.
I just think "income redistribution" is as big a lie as "trickle-down economics". The rich will fight to maintain their status quo. All their lawyers will tell you so. Nothing is being redistributed. Has your take home gotten bigger, smaller or stayed the same? Ive gotten a raise, but my health insurance costs more than that raise. Inflation is insidious that way.
Maybejust maybe, that block of congressrealized that the bloated, complicated mess that was first introduced could/would do no less, than dump an exorbitant bill on the Middle Class. Was that block acting out of selfish partisan interest? Most assuredly. Does it change that fact that right from the get-go this law was dependant on the Middle Class to foot the bill?
No, it doesn't.
Yaba daba dooo...
Hmm yes, it is nice when you have a choice isn't it?
I detecta hint of sarcasm. Maybe even a condescending tone. But in any event, even when I had no money I had a choice and still gave. How about you smartass?
What's the problem? That a better plan costs more money? This was my point.
My point is that we (I mean personally, me and my family) have had the largest jump in insurance premiums we have ever experienced. We recieved the news via mail from my wife's employer sent out five days after the ACA opened this last fall. They have never gone all out to explain why the rates were going up and it's because it was such a drastic increase, they felt they had better explain. Their explanation came in the form of one sentence that cited "market preasuure" as the reason. Our Insurance is exactly the same, not better; but, is costing us much more (that's where the 30% came from, sorry for being unclear).
Yeah, the Middle Clas, which drives our economy and floats our collective boat, has been unreasonably taxed for too long, and the ACA insurance may very well swamp the Middle class. Is it worth it, as a country and as citizens, if we now have universal health care,yet broke in a few yearsso that but the uber rich can afford insurance anyway? That is where this is heading. There are only so many burdens that can be borne by the Middle Class, and I believe that this is one burden that may very well break us.
Thanks for the explanation. I am with you on the middle class points you've made.I can't remember a year that our premiums went down or even stayed the same.Yes, the coverage is also less too.
However, redistribution of wealth, by definition, concerns wealth. Depending on where you get the definition, of course. From the rich to the poor and seems to involve public services/entitlements. I have a problem calling it income redistribution when is concerns private industry profits, like health insurance companies, etc. Those greedy bastards stand to get 30-40 million new subscribers due to ACA.
While, I may be better off than I was, I'm not wealthy, not by a long shot. So, charging me more is like blood from a stone, IMO. But I'd do with less somewhere else, just so the hospital doesn't take everything we've worked so hard for over the last 30-40 years.
PS-BTW I've looked at my earlier posts andI mistakenly wrote "income redistribution", when I meant to write "redistribution of wealth", as in the title. That could be a source of confusion andI apologize for that.