╌>

Sharon: Myths, Facts, and Blood Libels

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  jonathan-p  •  12 years ago  •  30 comments

Sharon: Myths, Facts, and Blood Libels

Former Israeli prime minister Ariel Sharon passed away a short time ago at the age of 85. He never recovered from the devastating stroke he suffered eight years ago, on January 4, 2006, five years after being elected prime minister.

Sharons long and controversial career as Israeli general, politician, and builder and then dismantler of settlements (in Sinai, Gaza, and four in the West Bank) has inspired so much vituperation and calumny that it has often been difficult to separate fact from fiction.

Time magazine was one of many publications to slander Sharon, falsely claiming he ordered the 1982 the Sabra and Shatilamassacre of Muslims by Christians in Beirut. Sharon successfully sued Time .

Already today, some in the international media have started to vilify him. In Britain, BBC Radio News at 4 p.m. eulogized Sharon by giving the floor as the sole speaker to a Palestinian man who claimed Sharon should not have been allowed to die of natural causes.

The publiclyfunded BBC, the worlds biggest news broadcaster,breaking its own charter to be balanced, is already repeating lies on its website that Sharon caused the Second Intifada. (The networkhas repeated it in at least elevenlinks in at least four different articles on its website just in the last five days.)

The BBC (and some anti-Israeli journalists at the New York Times ) fail to report what the Palestinians themselves say. For example, Marwan Barghouti, the de facto leader of the intifada, said: The intifada did not start because of Sharons visit to Al-Aqsa.

Palestinian Authority communications minister Imad Al-Faluji added: Whoever thinks that the intifada broke out because of the despised Sharons visit to the Al-Aqsa Mosque is wrong. This intifada was planned in advance, ever since President Arafats return from the Camp David negotiations, where he turned the table upside down on President Clinton.

And Yasser Arafats widow Suha, on Dubai TV, said the intifada was pre-planned, too: Immediately after the failure of the Camp David [negotiations], I met him [Yasser Arafat] in Paris upon his return and he said to me, You should remain in Paris. I asked him why, and he said, Because I am going to start an intifada. They [Bill Clinton and Ehud Barak] want me to betray the Palestinian cause. I will not do so.

More generally, while Ariel Sharon was a complex figure, and like many Western and Middle Eastern leaders, not without some wrongdoing many of the accounts are grossly unfair.

In the past, much coverage of Sharon in the European and Arab media has been accompanied by blatant anti-Semitism. In Spain, for example, on June 4, 2001 (three days after a Palestinian suicide bomber killed 21 young Israelis at a Tel Aviv disco, in the midst of a unilateral Israeli ceasefire), the Spanish liberal magazine Cambio 16 published a cartoon of Sharon (with a hook nose he does not have), wearing a skull cap (which he did not usually wear), sporting a swastika inside a star of David on his chest, and proclaiming: At least Hitler taught me how to invade a country and destroy every living insect.

A week earlier, El Pais , Spains equivalent of the New York Times , published a cartoon of an allegorical figure carrying a small rectangular-shaped black moustache, flying through the air towards Sharons upper lip. The caption read: Clio, the muse of history, puts Hitlers moustache on Ariel Sharon.

Cartoons in the Greek press in 2004 showed Sharon as a Nazi officer. One of Italys leading papers, Corrieredella Sera , ran a cartoon on March 31, 2002, showing Sharon killing Jesus. (The cartoon, which was timed to coincide with Easter that year, was published as Israelis lay dying from the Netanya Passover massacre three days earlier.)

Hundreds of similar anti-Semitic motifs have been applied to Sharon in recent years. The Economist magazine in London compared him to Charles Dickenss infamous anti-Semitic stereotype, Fagin.

We still have to wait and see whether journalists in the supposedly respectable world media have decided to rid themselves once and for all of the anti-Semitic overspill in their Israel coverage. While it is too early to tell, I doubt Sharon will be hailed as a modern Moses, as the influential British paper the Guardian dubbedYasser Arafat on the front page of the newspaper when he died.

Tom Gross is the former Middle East correspondent for the London Sunday Telegraph .

http://www.nationalreview.com/corner/368195/sharon-myths-facts-and-blood-libels-tom-gross


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   Len    12 years ago

Sharon was great till he founded the Kadima Partyand evacuated Gaza, an actionwhich has been causing problems and deaths to this day.

But what else do you expect from the BBC? The Balfour Declaration is the last good thing Britain ever did for the Jews. Since then it has been downhill all the way.

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   seeder  Jonathan P    12 years ago

You've no doubt seen and heard copious amounts of media coverage on Sharon in the last few days. As with anything emanating from Israel, most people have a predisposition.

Factual information is always available, if you're interested. Sharon was not agentle soul, and acted only in the best interest of his country. He acted with a heavy hand at times, and that did not endear him to his enemies. Whoda thought? /S

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   seeder  Jonathan P    12 years ago

Len,

As they say, no good deed goes unpunished. Being a "glass half full" kinda guy, I think the Gaza move was a good illustration of why Israel need not make peace with the Palestinians before they make peace with Israel. It accelerated Israel's preparedness for conflict, which is also inevitable.

The British will perpetually be bitter about Israel. The loss of control of Israel was symbolic of the end of centuries-long British domination of the world. They attempted to create a region they could control, but all it did was create an even more tightly packed, incendiary environment.

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    12 years ago

Rest in Peace Mr. Sharon, you deserve it.

Another illustration of anti-semitism in the media's portrayal of Sharon, among a long history of such. The antisemitism that has long envaded populi throughout the centuries, is political and racial in context. The "myth", the "conspiracy", is by it's very nature, rooted in lies and directed by ideology. Yet these wild conjectures, said enough times in the right places, take root and fester, taking on a life of their own. Ask Dreyfus how quickly lies and conspiracy theories can become all too real, all too quickly.

Suggestions that move societies,,, the myth, the conspiracy that never was, yet lived on.

And lives on.

The single best recent work that takes an historical look at the "jewish conspiracy"; and,is my foremost recomendation for both entertainment and education at the same time...

The Prague Cemetery

The Prague Cemetery (original title: Il cimitero di Praga ) is the sixth novel by Italian author Umberto Eco . It was first published in October 2010; the English translation by Richard Dixon appeared a year later. Shortlisted for the Independent Foreign Fiction Prize in 2012, it was described as Eco's best novel since The Name of the Rose . [ 1 ]

-----------

According to Eco, "the characters of this novel are not imaginary. Except the main character, they all lived in reality, including his grandfather, author of the mysterious message to abbot Barruelo which gave rise to all modern anti-Semitism". Eco goes on to say:

"The nineteenth century was full of monstrous and mysterious events: the mysterious death of Ippolito Nievo , the forgery of the Protocols of the Elders of Zion that inspired Hitler's extermination of the Jews, the Dreyfus affair and endless intrigue spun by the secret police of different countries, the Masons , Jesuit plots, and other events whose accuracy can't ever be authenticated, but that serve as fodder for feuilletons 150 years later. [ 3 ] "

Eco infuses the novel with other books as it explores the 19th-century novels that were plagiarized in the Protocols of Zion , and is structured like one. [ 4 ] The spirit of the novel is Alexandre Dumas , in particular an intertextuality with his novel Joseph Balsamo (1846).

---------------------------------------

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    12 years ago

Feuilleton ( French pronunciation: [fjt] ; a diminutive of French : feuillet , the leaf of a book) was originally a kind of supplement attached to the political portion of French newspapers , consisting chiefly of non-political news and gossip, literature and art criticism , a chronicle of the latest fashions, and epigrams, charades and other literary trifles. The term feuilleton was invented by Julien Louis Geoffroy and Bertin the Elder , editors of the French Journal des dbats in 1800. The feuilleton may be described as a " talk of the town ", [ 1 ] and a contemporary English-language example of the form is the "Talk of the Town" section of The New Yorker . [ 2 ]

In English newspapers, the term "feuilleton" instead came to refer to an installment of a serial story printed in one part of a newspaper. The genre of the feuilleton in its French sense was eventually included in English newspapers, but was not referred to as a feuilleton.

In contemporary French, feuilleton has taken on the meaning " soap opera ".

German and Polish newspapers still use the term for their literary and arts sections.

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    12 years ago

What is interesting is Mr Echo's occupation. He is what Robert Langdon of Da Vinci Code fame , wishes he could be...

Umberto Eco , OMRI ( Italian: [umbrto ko] ; born 5 January 1932) is an Italian semiotician , essayist , philosopher , literary critic, and novelist . He is best known for his groundbreaking 1980 historical mystery novel Il nome della rosa ( The Name of the Rose ), an intellectual mystery combining semiotics in fiction, biblical analysis, medieval studies and literary theory. He has since written further novels, including Il pendolo di Foucault ( Foucault's Pendulum ) and L'isola del giorno prima ( The Island of the Day Before ). His most recent novel Il cimitero di Praga ( The Prague Cemetery ), released in 2010, was a best-seller.

Eco has also written academic texts, children's books and many essays. He is founder of the Dipartimento di Comunicazione at the University of the Republic of San Marino , President of the Scuola Superiore di Studi Umanistici , University of Bologna , member of the Accademia dei Lincei (since November 2010) and an Honorary Fellow of Kellogg College , University of Oxford .

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    12 years ago

The British will perpetually be bitter about Israel. The loss of control of Israel was symbolic of the end of centuries-long British domination of the world.

To understand the British, they have never gotten over ANY of their losses. Even till today, they do not teach about their loss of the "colonies", as they like to refer to us, and still say that Australia is a country full of Irish prisoners. These are two huge powerful players and they can't hide their resentment. Now imagine how a little upstart country like Israel sticks like a craw in their throats. I should know... I lived there.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    12 years ago

The Palestinians fired two rockets at Israel during Sharon's funeral.

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   seeder  Jonathan P    12 years ago

The truth is out there, for anyone who wants to view this in an objective manner. Unfortunately, the predisposition against Israel and Jews is so great,the masseswill believe anything that is put in front of them, as long as it portrays the Jewish State and its inhabitants in a negative manner.

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   Aeonpax    12 years ago

I'll just leave this here;

SAjFoWp.jpg?1

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   seeder  Jonathan P    12 years ago

Ooooh, look.

Someone left a little turd on my seed.

From Wikipedia:

Media usage [ edit ]

The disputed quotation was published by a number of media outlets and websites in the Muslim world and elsewhere in conjunction with anti-Israel commentary, including on IslamOnline ; [2] the English language Pakistani newspaper, The Nation ; [3] and the London-based Arabic newspaper, Al-Hayat , which published the quote in a July 11, 2005, opinion article. [4] As'ad Abdul Rahman, chairman of the Palestinian Encyclopedia , used the quote as his lede for an opinion piece about alleged Jewish control of the world media in the Gulf News of December 4, 2004. [5]

A student columnist used the quote in her December 11, 2003 Daily Illini column, [6] [7] but later admitted the quote was false and apologized. [8] The incident was still being discussed as late as 2007. [9]

A columnist for The Hoya , the student newspaper of Georgetown University in Washington, D.C., used the quotation on March 19, 2002, introducing it with "Then again, we shouldn't be surprised about Sharon's feelings toward Palestinians; in 1956 when talking with Israeli General Ouze Merham, he said []" [10]

The Daily Star English-language newspaper in Bangladesh published the quotation on January 31, 2005 in a commentary article by retired Brigidier General M. Abdul Hafiz, who introduced the quotation with "Back in 1956 in an interview with general Ouze Merham, Sharon, a remorseless butcher of Sabra and Shatilla, said []" [11]

Please read the rest of the entry at your leisure:

And here's something just for you, AeonPax:

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   seeder  Jonathan P    12 years ago

AeonPax,

Upon further reflection of you post, I'd like to point a couple of things out to you about your post:

1)There is no record of any General Ouze Merham in the Israeli Army

2)In 1956, Jews were not referring to the Arabs as "Palestinians". They were referring to them as Arabs, or Arab refugees, or Egyptians, as the case would dictate at the time.

3)There is no record of this "interview" other than in Arab newspapers.

4)There is no other time in his 50+ year career as an Israeli leader that he ever said anything like that. So, there is no evidence and no pattern.

There is nothing to support this comment.

In conclusion, I have taken note of the manner in which you posted the "interview", without attribution, without your opinion, or anyone's opinion. Just a cowardly hit and run.

How very, very Palestinian of you.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    12 years ago

I'll bet she doesn't respond ...

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    12 years ago

@Jonathan P:41.gif 41.gif 41.gif

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   seeder  Jonathan P    12 years ago

The very existence of Israel sticks in the craw of so many, since they believed there would be no need to recon with Jews after WWII. The rejuvenation of the nation and race is just too much for too many to handle.

The shock with which the world reacts to Israel's refusal to allow themselves to be subjugated/conned again is the little solace that I get these days.

The gloves are off, and they will never go back on again.

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   seeder  Jonathan P    12 years ago

Hey,

I really am a nice guy. I've got a smile for everyone I meet.

I really don't know why people fuck with me.

Really, I don't.

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    12 years ago

Then again, The post is an absolute perfect example of the sorta tidbits Sharon's "myth", as mentioned here, is built upon.

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   seeder  Jonathan P    12 years ago

All they needed to do was have an accurate hit for once in their lives, and the game would be over. Dignitaries from more than 20 countries in attendance.

It's like a cockroach infestation that you can't eradicate. They have no regard for their lives, or anyone else's.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   Len    12 years ago

Ariel Sharon: His Eye Was Not Dim

Ariel Sharon often seemed bluff and simple, and he would play that role: in discussions with his kitchen cabinet down at his ranch (they called it the farm forum), he would react to some erudite advice by saying: I am a simple farmer, not a professor. Explain that again, in simple terms so even I can understand it.

But Sharon was not so simple: he was at different times clever, smart, devious, emotional, unemotional, funny, dry, tough, compromising, unyielding. He was a pariah who transformed himself by the end of his public career into an extremely successful politician and widely admired statesman. Nicknamed the bulldozer for both his physical appearance and his military tactics, in politics he was unpredictable and wily. A hero of the right for decades until his decision to withdraw from Gaza in 2005, the father of the settlements pulled all the settlements out of Gaza and became very briefly the hero of the peace camp. This founder of the Likud Party pulled Likud apart and founded a new party called Kadima when his plans required it. At one point he lacked a majority in his own cabinet to pass the Gaza withdrawal plan, so he summoned two unconvinced ministers to his officeto fire them so he would have the majority in a smaller cabinet. They knew what was coming so they refused to meet with him, whereupon he fired them by fax. It was not easy to get around Ariel Sharon once he had made up his mind.

All these contradictions made him a fascinating man to watch and to deal with. Yet he really was, I think, a simple man at root. He saw himself as a Jew whose job it was to protect the Jewish state.

More:

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   Len    12 years ago

I did not know you were an antisemite who scrapes the bottom of the barrel for defamatory material.

Will I see you next quoting the "Protocols of the Elders of Zion," "Mein Kampf" and skinhead literature?

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    12 years ago

I'll just leave this here;

LOL!

Just curious-- where did you get that from?

24.gif 24.gif 24.gif

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    12 years ago

And I'll just leave this here:

Date sent: Wed, 24 Apr 2002 15:11:58 +0200

From: International Policy Institute for Counter-Terrorism infoATict.org.il Organization: International Policy Institute for Counter-Terrorism

Subject: Re: Ariel Sharon In an interview with General Ouze Merham, 1956

Hello, The comment that you quoted is indeed an invention, and a rather lame one. To begin with, any public expression of such sentiments would be grounds for dismissing a soldier from the army. Hatred is considered to render the soldier incapable of clear judgement and unreliable in carrying out the will of the state. Indeed many young hotheads have been dismissed from active combat duty because of their expression of racist sentiments--sentiments that could have serious consequences in an army in which Jews serve alongside Druze and Bedouin Arab soldiers. One clue to the fact that the comment is a pure fabrication is the use of the word "Palestinian." In 1956, the term had still not taken hold in reference to Palestinian Arabs, but was at times used to refer to Jews born in Mandatory Palestine prior to the establishment of Israel. The Arabs in Palestine often referred to themselves as residents of "Greater Syria," or of the new state of Jordan. Many were also eligible for citizenship in the new state of Iraq, by virtue of their parents having come from the region prior to the establishment of Iraq. However, a large number had been caught in the process of migrating to look for work at the very time when the modern states were being set up by the great powers, and thus found themselves stateless on arrival in Mandatory Palestine. At any rate, the term "Palestinian Arab" was made popular only in the early 1960's by what eventually became Yasser Arafat's Fatah movement, the Palestine Liberation Movement, which was founded in 1964. It did not catch on right away, and certainly had not gained enough provenance to have been used by Ariel Sharon in 1956. There is simply no way that an Israeli--and certainly not one expressing the sentiments ascribed to Sharon in this comment--would at that time have used the term "Palestinian" to refer to the Arabs. Even when the term began to be used by the PLO in the 1960's, it was scoffed at, on the grounds that there had never been any state in the region called Palestine (see Golda Meir's comment, "There is no such thing as the 'Palestinian people'," referring to the PLO's use of the term.). I hope this will help to clarify things.

Sincerely,

Yael Shahar

International Policy Institute for Counter-Terrorism

As well, it is noted that there is no record of a General named Ouze Merham

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    12 years ago

I'll bet she doesn't respond ...

I won't bet against that. She has used rense.com as a source in the past - so you can figure out where SHE's coming from.

If she DOES respond it would be with an insult, which appears to be her style.

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   Aeonpax    12 years ago

I found the quote, posted on a .jpg, here:

I found it interesting which is why I posted it here without comment. It would appear that outside of the world of Jewish or Israeli influence, this alleged quote by Ariel Sharon, is taken verbatim by many who refer to him as a butcher & pig and celebrate his passing.

While I do not doubt that the quote is indeed a hoax, the lesson here is that despite that fact, many will continue to give it credence thus fueling the everlasting and perpetual state of war in that part of the ME.

Such ignorance however is not confined to just the Palestinians however, judging by the replies here.

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   Aeonpax    12 years ago

I have a life outside of the internet. Try it sometime.

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   seeder  Jonathan P    12 years ago

Yes, it is an instructional on myth, and how it should beaddressed.

The unfortunate facts point to the fact that, even when exhaustively proven to be falsehood, they endure as "fact" to those that hate.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    12 years ago

Such ignorance however is not confined to just the Palestinians however, judging by the replies here.

and:

I have a life outside of the internet. Try it sometime.

As I said above:

If she DOES respond it would be with an insult, which appears to be her style.

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   seeder  Jonathan P    12 years ago

While I do not doubt that the quote is indeed a hoax, the lesson here is that despite that fact, many will continue to give it credence thus fueling the everlasting and perpetual state of war in that part of the ME.

Such ignorance however is not confined to just the Palestinians however, judging by the replies here.

I'm calling bullshit here.

You're backpedalling. You're in an offhand way claiming that we were supposed to know what your intention was by merely posting the alleged interview. You could have added brief commentary that would have provided instant clarification of your position, which you have still not taken. Again, we're left to guess. That is what elicited the responses that followed.

You claim in a later post that you have a life.

Your initial post does not buttress that claim.

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   Aeonpax    12 years ago
  • I'm calling bullshit here.

That's nice.

  • You're backpedalling

I see you don't like my reply...hmmmmm

tDoqU4q.jpg?1

  • You're in an offhand way claiming that we were supposed to know what your intention was by merely posting the alleged interview.

I posted a quote, not an interview.

  • You could have added brief commentary that would have provided instant clarification of your position, which you have still not taken

I could have but I didn't. Deal with it.

  • Again, we're left to guess.

Who is "we?" You never asked me to explain it but jumped to your own conclusions. Tsk.

  • That is what elicited the responses that followed.

As only one person had the intelligence to ask for an explanation before jumping to conclusions, I just called it as I saw it. Again, deal with it.

The lesson here is ASK before saying something stupid.

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   seeder  Jonathan P    12 years ago

'sigh'

Well, I suppose I could wait long enough for the moderator to come.

In the meantime, maybe if you weren't such a cunt, we could participate in more robust an meaningful debate.

I suppose it's not meant to be.

 
 

Who is online




80 visitors