One-third of Americans reject evolution, poll shows
One-third of Americans reject evolution, poll shows
By Chris Francescani, Reuters, December 31, 2013
Mosaic of Adam and Eve, inside Monreale Cathedral, Monreale, near Palermo, Sicily, Italy (copyright Melvyn Longhurst/Corbis)
NEW YORK (Reuters) - One-third of Americans reject the idea of evolution and Republicans have grown more skeptical about it, according to a poll released on Monday.
Sixty percent of Americans say that "humans and other living things have evolved over time," the telephone survey by the Pew Research Center 's Religion and Public Life Project showed.
(Click this link for the full survey):
http://www.pewforum.org/2013/12/30/publics-views-on-human-evolution/
But 33 percent reject the idea of evolution, saying that "humans and other living things have existed in their present form since the beginning of time," Pew said in a statement.
Although this percentage remained steady since 2009, the last time Pew asked the question, there was a growing partisan gap on whether humans evolved.
"The gap is coming from the Republicans, where fewer are now saying that humans have evolved over time," said Cary Funk, a Pew senior researcher who conducted the analysis.
The poll showed 43 percent of Republicans and 67 percent of Democrats say humans have evolved over time, compared with 54 percent and 64 percent respectively four years ago.
Among religious groups, white evangelical Protestants topped the list of those rejecting evolution, with 64 percent of those polled saying they believe humans have existed in their present form since the beginning of time.
"This has been a staple of evangelical Protestantism for nearly 100 years," said Alan Lichtman, an American University history professor and author of "White Protestant Nation: The Rise of the American Conservative Movement."
A quarter of those surveyed told Pew that "a supreme being guided the evolution of living things."
The survey of 1,983 adults in all 50 states was conducted from March 21 to April 8. The margin of error was 3 percentage points, meaning results could vary that much either way.
Tags
Who is online
66 visitors

Personally, I believe in the "Superman" theory - that when life on Mars was ending, a space ship with a young boy and a young girl (Adam and Eve) was sent through space to make a new home on Earth. Any memories of their origins have been forgotten and any records and the ship were either lost, or are still to be found. What a revelation THAT would be.
The good news is that two thirds do believe in the concept of evolution.
Based on the way some people act I am starting to think they have devolved ...
That begs the question of how humans "got on Mars" in the first place.
Either they developed there through evolution or they got their from an alien planet.
There is nothing in the Jewish view that contradicts evolution. We say, however, not that evolution is random but that God directs it.
It is amazing that, even with such recent books on the subject such as "Genesis and the Big Bang" and "The Science of God," by Gerald M. Schroeder, no one sees fit to discuss the Jewish synthesis of science and biblical truths. These are not in conflict if one remembers that the Bible was never intended to be a science textbook.
Maimonides wrote in the Twelfth century, "Study astronomy and physics if you wish to comprehend the relationship between the world and God's management of it." ("Guide to the Perplexed")
The Big Bang theory confirms Exodus 1. Both Maimonides and Nachmanides figured out the gist of this theory 800 years ago. You can read Maimonides' discussion in "The Guide of the Perplexed," Part 2, Ch.13-30, in connection with his proof of the existence of God.
In Ch. 17 Maimonides wrote, "As for us, we declare against [Aristotle] that this nature ... does not resemble in anything the state it was in while in the state of being generated, and that it was brought into existence from absolute nonexistence."
In Ch. 30 he wrote, "The foundation of the whole law is the view that God has brought the world into being out of nothing without there having been a temporal beginning." (i.e., time itself forms part of the creation).
In Chapter 25, Maimonides wrote, "Know that with a belief in the creation of the world in time, all the miracles become possible and the Law becomes possible, and all questions that may be asked on the subject vanish."
Let me also quote Rabbi Moshe ben Nachman (Nachmanides, 1195-1270) exactly from the English translation of his commentary on the Torah (Shilo Publishing House, NY 1973). Remember; he lived before Copernicus, Galileo, Kepler or Columbus. In his introduction to Genesis he said:
"I --- give proper counsel to all --- not to reason or entertain any thought concerning any of the mystic hints which I write regarding the hidden matters of the Torah, for I make firmly known to [the reader] that my words will not be comprehended nor known at all by any reasoning or contemplation, excepting from the mouth of a wise Kabbalist speaking into the ear of an understanding recipient."
"Now listen to the correct and clear explanation of the verse in its simplicity. The Holy One, blessed be He, created all things from absolute non-existence. Now we have no expression in [Hebrew] for bringing forth something from nothing other than the word, bara (Heb. for created). Every thing that exists under the sun or above was made from non-existence at the outset.---."
"With this creation, which was like a very small point having no substance, everything in the heavens and the earth was created."---
"After having said that, with one command God created first the heavens and the earth and all their hosts, Scripture returns and explains that the earth after this creation was tohu, that is, matter without substance. It became bohu when He clothed it with form Then [Scripture explains that in this form was included the form of the four elements: fire, water, earth and air." ---]
"It appears to me that this [primeval] point, [which God created out of absolute nought], which took on form and became bohu, is what the Sages call: 'The rock of foundation' from which the [universe] was founded."
While we too have our fundamentalists normative Judaism has never taken the Bible literally, but has always understood it to be written in the language of man. It had to be understood by the farmer of 3000 years ago as much as by the physicist of today.
If you want a more complete explanation of the Jewish views on Creation and Evolution they are readily available in the Pentateuch and Haftorahs, edited by Dr. J. H. Hertz (Soncino, 1960). Dr. Hertz has included special articles on these subjects on Pages 193-194.
"Thus evolution, far from destroying the religious teaching of Gen. 1, is its profound confirmation. ... The thing that eternally matters is the breath of Divine and everlasting life that He breathed into the being coming from the dust (whether originally or through a process). By virtue of the Divine impact, a new and distinctive creature made its appearance -- man, dowered with an immortal soul. The sublime revelation of the unique worth and dignity of man, contained in Gen. 1:27 (and God created man in His own Image ...) may well be called the Magna Charta of humanity. [The Bible's] purpose is not to explain the biological origins of the human race, but its spiritual kinship with God. ... [If the Bible] had provided them ... they would not have been understood. And to full grasp the eternal power and infinite beauty of [Gen. 1:27] we need but compare them with the genealogy of man, condensed from the pages of one of the leading biologists of the age (Haeckel): --
"Monera begat Amoeba, Amoeba begat Synamoeba, Synamoeba begat Ciliated Larva, Cilaeted Larva begat Primeval Stomach Animals, Primeval Stomach Animals begat Gliding Worms, Gliding Worms begat Skull-less Animals, Skull-less Animals begat Single-Nostrilled Animals, Single-Nostrilled Animals begat Primeval Fish, Primeval Fish begat Mud Fish, Mud Fish begat Gilled Amphibians, Gilled Amphibians begat Tailed Amphibians, Tailed Amphibians begat Primary Mammals, Primary Mammals begat Pouched Animals, Pouched Animals begat Semi-Apes, Semi-Apes begat Tailed Apes, Tailed Apes begat Man-like Apes, Man-Like Apes begat Ape-Like Men, Ape-Like Men begat Man."
"Let anyone who is disturbed by the fact that Scripture does not include the 'latest' scientific doctrine try to imagine such information provided in a Biblical chapter."
Secular people have been fighting the Big Bang because it is something that cannot be explained scientifically, and science is a god of secularism. Scientists can postulate it, and even prove it (they are getting closer and closer) but they cannot explain what caused it or what happened before it. The significance of the Big Bang, postulated by Maimonides and Nachmanides in the 12th Century, is that it agrees with Genesis 1, and this bothers some seculars no end, so they are fighting it tooth and nail.
One secular scientist who has gone this route is Dr. Robert Jastrow, physicist, chief, Theoretical Division, Goddard Space Flight Center, NASA 1958-61, director Goddard Institute of Space Flight Studies 1961- ; author of `Exploration of Space,' 'Until the Sun Dies' (1977), and 'God and the Astronomers' (1988).
I am not quoting a religious zealot but rather an illustrious physicist and astronomer; in fact a self-styled agnostic. Here is what he wrote:
I'm sitting here dumbfounded. I find it extremely hard to believe that 1/3rd of Americans reject evolution. I don't know anybody who rejects evolution and I know a bunch of people. Maybe it's just who I have chosen to hang out with over the years. Maybe I am a hermit.
I believe that the earth is approximately 4.5+ billion years old. I believe that humans evolved over time, and are still evolving. As a species, we've really not been around that long. Hey, I've drilled up wood that was almost 80,000 years old.
Adam and Eve, I believe is a parable or metaphor, or whatever, a symbol, (?) for perhaps the first intellectually aware people. Whether those people were Neanderthals or Cro-Magnons or whatever, I don't know.
I have learned, through the years, that it is impossible to argue with people that feel the earth is only 10,000 years old. No matter what you say, they won't believe you, and think you're an infidel, (or worse), if you even discuss it. Just like all those water superintendents that believe that all the water in the Ohio River came from Michigan. You can stand in a well field and throw a rock into the Ohio River, but their water comes from Michigan. Yeah, right.
The mind has a hard time believing that mundane random processes could possibly result in a package of DNA, proteins, and chemicals which can grow one cell into a human being, with its amazing physical organization, not to mention the even more amazing spiritual/mental "organization"; it boggles my imagination as much as anyone elses.
The odds have been calculated and they are not at all encouraging. But first there were some falsely encouraging experiments. The Russian, Alexander Ivanovich Oparin, in his book, The Origin of Life (1936), described the conditions likely to have existed on primitive Earth, and the random chemical and physical processes possible. These processes, he asserted, inevitably led to life. Seventeen years later, Stanley Miller used almost the same conditions in his experiment to produce amino acids. Oparin speculated and Miller proved that lightning and other sources of energy naturally present on Earth could convert inorganic molecules into several of the compounds present in life.
The world-famous biologist, George Wald [a full professor at Harvard, and Nobel Prize winner], supported these results. Writing in Scientific American, Wald presented a convincing logical argument ... that accounted for spontaneous generation of life... "... However improbable we regard [creation of life], or any of the steps it involves, given enough time, it will almost certainly happen at least once ... Time is, in fact, the hero of the plot. ... Given enough time the impossible becomes possible, the possible probable, and the probable virtually certain. One has only to wait; time itself performs the miracles. (Wald, The Origin of Life, Scientific American, Aug., 1954)"
Unfortunately, Wald's skills in mathematics were less than his skills in biology and it is on the mathematics of the problem that Wald's rather unoriginal argument rests. In 1968, Prof. Harold Morowitz, a physicist at Yale, published his book, Energy Flow in Biology. Along with other physicists and mathematicians he had become concerned about the casualness with which some scientists studying the origins of life were assuming that unlikely events must have occurred. These scientists were making assumptions without any attempt to rigorously investigate the probability of such events.
Morowitz presented computations of the time required for random chemical reactions to form a bacterium -- not an organism as complex as a human, not even a flower; just a simple, single-celled bacterium. Based on his [optimistic] calculations the time exceeds not only the 4.5 billion year old age of Earth, but the entire 15-billion-year age of the universe. The likelihood ... is less than that of your shaking an omelet and having the yolk and white separate back into the original form of the egg.
Many still believe Wald's conclusion although Scientific American acknowledged Wald's error in 1980, 26 years later. "George Wald, in 'The Origin of Life,' assumes that a primeval soup of organic molecules somehow originated. He then proceeds to show that, given enough time, random combinations of molecules might form biologically relevant associations and, ultimately, life. Although stimulating, this is one of the few times in his professional life when Wald has been wrong. Examine his main thesis and see. Can we really form a biological cell waiting for chance combinations of organic compounds? Harold Morowitz, in his book, 'Energy Flow and Biology,' computed that merely to create a bacterium would require more time than the Universe might ever see if chance combinations of its molecules were the only driving force. ... the oldest fossils indicate that the most primitive cells arose early in the history of the Earth. Thus relatively short spans of time were available for the origins of cellular life. ...
"During this early era small organic compounds must accumulate, biological polymers must form, protocells must arise, and a genetic and protein-synthesizing system must evolve. These events are not consistent with the Wald hypothesis of random associations. The point is that even the simplest form of life requires a molecule to be highly organized, and this would take more time than the 15-billion year age of the Universe if random combinations are the only way. There is also a chance of the process' dissolution. We are swimming upstream in the flow of entropy, with the likelihood of disintegration much greater than that of formation, especially considering the instability of the compounds."
If destruction predominates over formation, how did living organisms regularly produce complex compounds with such abundance? Life does it by working in the highly protected environment within its cells, by using catalysts that have the ability to select and concentrate the needed chemicals and to increase rates and extents of reactions, and by expending considerable energy to accomplish these tasks. These catalysts, called enzymes, are themselves proteins produced by already living cells. A reaction that may take seconds [under ideal conditions] might take years or longer in an uncatalyzed system. Neither enzyme nor protective cell wall were available to the molecules that preceded life.
According to Prof. Robert Shapiro, Chemistry professor of NYU, the odds of a single, viable bacterium evolving by chance on Earth is one in 10 to the 39,950 power. In arriving at this figure, he allowed for an amino acid stew covering the earth's surface to a depth of six miles and reactions taking place every second within every cubic micron over a period of a billion years.
There seems to be so much purpose and structure in life, how can it be random? The answer of course is that it is not random in the sense of a single accident, the sudden instantaneous generation of life. Randomness generates a virtual infinity of possibilities, but "natural selection" (again, a self-evident, practically trivial principle), in combination with the environment, "determines" what continues and what falls away. And five billion years is an inconceivably long time - that is roughly two hundred million "begats" of 25 years, and many more "begats" for amoebas, etc. And we are not talking about 200,000,000 "trials" of a SINGLE "experiment", there are billions and billions of "experiments" happening simultaneously across the globe. Then add in big events or natural catastrophes, which suddenly mix things up, e.g., asteroid impacts, climate changes, giant solar events that bathe earth in radiation, etc. Does it all "add up"?
I don't really know, but the fossil record seems to say that this is how it happened, even if we don't understand all the details.
Ironically, the fossil record itself also dispels Wald's argument of life arising by chance. Neither 15 billion years nor 4.5 billion years were available for this random development of life. Life, we are learning, appeared on Earth almost immediately after the Earth formed!
Another major problem for Darwinism is that of macroevolution. Darwin wrote, "...If it could be demonstrated that any complex organ existed which could not have possibly been formed by numerous successive slight modifications, my theory would absolutely break down."
Many such organs have been identified. The mating apparatus of the male dragonfly is not homologous with any known organ in the animal kingdom; it is not derived from any pre-existing organ; and its origin is as complete a mystery as it well could be (Tilliard, professor of Zoology, 1917).
Writing in American Scientist, Prof. Richard Goldshmidt, a UC-Berkely biologist, challenged his Darwinian colleagues to explain bird feathers, and sixteen other animal organs that defied evolutionary development, including teeth, mollusk shells, the poison mechanism of snakes, and insect compound eyes. Poisonous snakes have special sacs to carry their poison so that they do not poison themselves. Many snakes are immune to their poison. Apparently the special sacs and neutralizing agents must have developed at the same time as the poison. Otherwise the snakes would not have survived their own poison to procreate and pass on their mutations to their progeny.
The human eye: If the cornea is fuzzy, or the pupil fails to dilate, or the lens becomes opaque, or the focusing goes wrong -- a recognizable image is not formed. The eye either functions or not. So how did it come to evolve by slow, steady, infinitesimally small Darwinian improvements? Did the lens and retina evolve in synchronism during thousands of chance mutations? Darwin, himself, said two years after writing the "Origin...," "the eye, to this day, gives me a cold shudder."
Steven Jay Gould, writing in the Oct. 1996 Discover, includes the following relevant comments: "To produce a creature with our structural and neurological complexity evolution must be creative in the vernacular sense of this word -- that is, evolution must be able to develop novel structures with previously unrealized functions. ... Yet if evolution worked simply by fashioning exquisitely adapted creatures in an ascending series, humans could never have originated at all. Precise adaptation, with each part finely honed to perform a definite function in an optimal way, can only lead to blind alleys, dead ends, and extinction. ... The key is flexibility, not admirable precision. Ironically, then, to make us at all, evolution must work by processes contrary to the prejudicial hopes that we invest in Darwin's legacy..." Gould then goes on to explain his own theory of adaptability rather than specialization and concludes: "We are quirky, if glorious, accidents not to be repeated on this planet."
Coincidences?
A detailed discussion of the *odds* is given in "In the Beginning -- (Biblical Creation and Science) Ktav Publishing, 1990" by Nathan Aviezer, chairman of the Physics Dept. at Bar-Ilan U.
The author reviews all the "coincidences" necessary for life on Earth, as we know it. Consider the following very brief summary of just a few factors, for which the author provides many references, linking them to Biblical verses as appropriate.
1. Goldilocks climatology: Earth is just the right distance from the sun to maintain oceans, as well as to provide a hospitable temperature and atmosphere for the support of human life. Mars is too cold, Venus too hot. A difference of just a few percent in many variables would have ended the possibility of life; possible because of a very delicate balance. If the Earth were a few percent closer to the sun, the water would boil off; a few percent farther away and the atmosphere would not be breathable by humans because of the excessive carbon dioxide. We are far enough from other stars to preclude our being subject to stellar explosions and the consequent cosmic radiation which would sterilize us at best, and kill us at worst.
2. The Moon: Frequently neglected the specific structure and movement of the moon, is a major determinant of the weather, as well as the seasons. Without the moon, we would not have the mild climate that permitted human cultural, intellectual and technological development, notwithstanding the factors in 1. "Our moon was formed from a planetary collision because the colliding body just happened to have the required mass, just happened to have the required velocity and angle of collision, and just happened to have the required composition for its core and mantle."
3. Origin of Life: There is no satisfactory explanation for the origin of life from inanimate matter. A chicken/egg situation exists. All living cells require nucleic acid for replication. They also require proteins which can be produced only by nucleic acids. But nucleic acids can be produced only in the presence of proteins. Inanimate matter contains neither proteins or nucleic acids.
While the universe is about 15 billion years old, remember that planet Earth is only 4.5 to 5 billion years young. Therefore, the earliest algae appeared as early as 0.7 billion years after the Earth was formed. According to "Genesis and the Big Bang," (Gerald Schroeder), "Fossil evidence for a variety of microbial life forms has been found in sedimentary rocks more than 3.3 billion years old. The oldest sedimentary rocks are dated at about 3.8 billion years. In this span of approximately 0.5 billion years, the common ancestor of life must have developed the extraordinary and exquisite chemistry of life and also mutated sufficiently to have produced a variety of progeny. (Pg. 114)"
"Random Events cannot account for the origin of life, at least not in the time available." -- Harold Morowitz, Yale physicist and author of "Energy Flow in Biology"
4. Evolution: Evolution is not inconsistent with the bible if you consider that each "day" was an era. However, the Darwin theory has become discredited by recent evidence. His theory stated, briefly, that evolution works in small cumulative increments to yield more and more complex species. If this were true you would expect to find transitional forms in the fossil record. Such forms, that lead from one class change to another, have not been found. This is the principal reason Darwin's theory has lost credibility.
To the contrary, the fossil record provides evidence that species have appeared and disappeared very suddenly, and during their stay have hardly evolved at all. (Scientific American, June, 1984). Current fossil evidence indicates that living organisms appeared *suddenly,* with no sign at all of a *gradual evolution.* Those organisms reflected the same exceedingly complex protein/nucleic acid mechanism that life universally exhibits today.
I am not shocked by this. Being a science teacher for almost 20 years, many of my students outright rejected evolution. So did several of the teaching staff. This fascinated me. So I did my masters thesis on how to teach evolution to students who reject it. It's a bit unorthodox from a science teachers POV, and it predates "intelligent design"... but it worked.
Maybe I'm not a fully evolved human, a virtual child in the development of humanity, because I'll be damned if I have the time, the patiance or even the desire to read Len's ultra-long comments. Since this is my seed I try to be a responsible moderator so I would appreciate if someone who wants to undergo the tedious burden of reading through them will let me know if there is anything in them that would be a reason to ask that they be deleted.
I kind of believe a bit in the "Chariot of the Gods" thing. I think that there is a whole lot of things that are kind of unexplained, like you pointed out Mike. In an almost infinite universe, I find it hard to believe that we are alone.
Actually, I don't know why you haven't Randy. Wait... don't you beat up JehovahWitness when they come to your door?
Von Daniken is a complete hoaxter and has been caught over and over in his hoaxes.
Well, this was still wood and it was between the periods of glaciation that made it have to be around 80,000 years old. It was slightly carbonized, but it still splintered. I froze it in my mother's freezer for years, and then, naturally, she threw it away one day when she was mad at me. SIGH!!!
I'm still retrieving rocks that she threw out in the back yard... Jade from Wyoming, green calcite from Colorado, etc. Oh well...
You haven't spent much time in KY, have you?
Here, I'd say its about 50%... Remember, we have that Creationist museum.
*the grump chuckles for the rest of the day*
Thank you Mike. I'm not a speed reader, in fact I'm quite slow and methodical. As a person who had to read and vet multi-million dollar contracts it was a necessity. I once made my cient an extra half a million dollars because the other lawyer had used one wrong word which I discovered in a multi-paged agreement that he had prepared.
I know. Here's another one of those famous scenes...