Michigan Considering Bill Revoking Driver’s Licenses of Chronic Truants
Legislation in Lansing would take away drivers licenses from students who are repeatedly absent from school.
Democratic Rep. Andy Schor of Lansing introduced two bills last week in the Republican-controlled state House to combat the problem of truancy. Driving is a privilege and one that young people treasure, making it a good way to motivate them to stay in school, Schor said.
The legislation would compel judges to notify the secretary of state of cases of truancy. The secretary of state would have to suspend the license of a juvenile found by a circuit court to be willfully and repeatedly absent from schools for six months.
In cases where juveniles havent yet been issued a license, they would be denied a license.
Michigan law requires students to be in school until age 18.
Read more: http://www.nydailynews.com/news/politics/michigan-lawmakers-bill-strip-driver-license-kids-skip-school-article-1.1558807#ixzz2ozZZKSO8
Tags
Who is online
66 visitors

jwc2blue
Actually I think it is the state that decides who does and who does not qualify for a driver's license
I do however agree that if a responsible and caring parent is unable to keep a child going to school regularly they surely should not allow that child to drive or have access to a vehicle
jwc2blue
Grades is a bit extreme but since the state law (Michigan) requires school attendance this action is not unreasonable to me
Have a safe and happy new year yourself!
That's going too far ...
Petey
The law says they must go to school
If they are chronically truant they are not abiding by that law, why is denying them the privilege of a driver's license "going to far"
If they began to attend school regularly the prohibition would be lifted and they would be able to get a probationary license
These are just kids . If they have never driven before they won't even know what they're missing . Where's the motivation then ?
jwc2blue
I am not positive about this but the brief bit I heard about this makes me think that the prohibition for a license would end at 18 since there would no longer be a requirement for the child to go to school.
So that would not be an issue
I agree though that those who decide not to attend school and not to graduate are simply preparing for a career on social welfare assistance programs and they will need to get to the UE office or to McDonalds if they can manage to hold down a job later in life so you are correct that they will be needing to get a drivers license at some point.
Petey
The motivation to go to school should be to get an education
In the case of me and my brothers it was the fear of my father's wrath but that parental motivation is sorely missing in many homes these days
Once they are beyond 18 the restriction goes away anyway and they are free to drive to the UE office
I think that the state is taking an odd position on this. It should be the parents and not the state. If we did the same thing with who could have a gun, based on if they went for annual training or not, the NRA would have a fit. I understand that the state recognizes that parents are not doing their job, but still, this is a bit of a double standard.
Have a wonderful New Year, Robert!
How does that 18 year old law work in some of our cases we skipped grades in school and graduated younger some at 17 some at 16. Does that mean that the child is required by Michigan law to continue in school such as College or specialized training Mechanical, meat cutter, chef, ???? What if there is no financing available. But most are lucky enough to get scholar ships but minorities don't fair as well. A few minorities tend to take care of their own in some cases.
Many minds are lost or never developed to their full potential as educational possibilities are being pulled back due to economic difficulties. The cost of one of those new Planes just the cost of one would pay for many many educational years of school for thousands. Why has this country gone in the direction of the war, invasion and world control mentality. $$$$$$$ the only answer control by the War monger Barrens. Top 1 %.
The idea is good the implication is scary. Illness, druggy parents, child abuse, physical abuse and sexual abuse. Children who get sick with no health care. Detroit great example. Sounds like abuse of the minorities is there no other way. Girls who get pregnant and pull out of school to have the baby with many states demanding even rape victim or pregnancy by incest to carry child to term. Seems in many cases we could be punishing the wrong person, even limiting their chance to escape.
I have seen many of the children who were abused to the point of deformation physically and mentally by a father or mothers wrath. Giving parents free control of discipline in some cases is a death sentence.
jwc2blue
I would also support that and in fact seem to recall that Ohio toyed with that option but did not put it into effect, but I do recall some state in the Midwest that as fining parents of chronic truants.
r m e r
Giving anyone or any entity free control (without oversight and control) of anything is a bad idea.
I never really believed that my father "would break my ass" if I screwed up in school, but I had enough respect for him that I did as he said so as not to put him to the test.
And I certainly would never have gotten a driver's license at 16 if I were not getting A's and B's in school and I had the same rule with my boys. When their grades went down or they screwed up in other ways their driver's license went into my wallet and they walked
Perrie
I have guns and would have no problem with an annual safety refresher course.
The state has a probationary licensing program already for kids under 18 and they are simply adding good school attendance to the other requirements of the program
Hope you have a Happy New Year as well
r m e r
The "child" can only have a probationary license until they are 18 whether they are in high school or otherwise.
This is another requirement in the probationary license program
The cost of airplanes hardly seems relevant to this topic stay focused please,
r m e r
All of the things you mention are indeed problems but a new restriction in the probationary license program or not hardly is the cause or cure for those problems and in fact has little relevance
Afraid the law would be pretty much useless Robert.
Act 451 of 1976 PART 24 COMPULSORY SCHOOL ATTENDANCE 380.1561 Compulsory attendance at public school; enrollment dates; exceptions.
Sec. 1561. (1) Except as otherwise provided in this section, for a child who turned age 11 before December
1, 2009 or who entered grade 6 before 2009, the child's parent, guardian, or other person in this state having
control and charge of the child shall send that child to a public school during the entire school year from the
age of 6 to the child's sixteenth birthday.
As you can see, the law requires attendance until age 16 in Michigan It's been that way as long as I've been alive (65 years). After age 16, the child is no longer a truant, but is considered a drop out. The earliest age at which you can get a driver's license in the State is 15 (usually not until 16, though). Since dropping out and getting a license happen, in most cases, at the same age, the law wouldn't apply to very many kids.
If they'd really want to punish them, they'd just take away their smartphones! (Except where teenagers are concerned, that might violate the Constitutions ban on "cruel and unusual punishment").
Krish
Definitely cruel in the view of modern youth who must be plugged in all the time
TTGA
But they could still be denied a driver's license if they are "classified a dropout" until they turn 18 and are a no longer a dropout buteither a burden on society with a driver's license or a Mc-employee complaining about how little they earn.
Robert,
That would open a really big can of worms that I doubt that the Legislature wants to open. The next question brought up would be, "Why stop at age 18?" Someone would be certain to want to make obtaining a license conditional on being a high school graduate (I know these people, and there are at least three of them who would propose something like that, and many others who would jump on the bandwagon). As a former teacher, I'm all for encouraging staying in school until graduation, but that would probably be going a bit overboard. Legislation like that would have excluded both of my parents from driving, and might have hampered my father in his long career as a mailman. If encouraged, the Michigan Legislature might actually do something like that too. There are many people there who are very smart, but not too practical.
TTGA
Sounds like you are suggesting a slippery slope....
I think this is a good idea and there is no indication that there are any plans or desires to expand it as you suggest
I appreciate the feedback
Hope you had a good new year
How good is Michigan at revoking the drivers licenses of those who drink and drive?
A P
I do not know perhaps you should research it and let us all know
If Michigan is poor at enforcing laws against drunk driving, then they will be equally as lax at enforcing this law....ergo, another bullshit law.
A P
Your "ergo" is a non sequitur ness you have some data to back it up
Michigan might be very effective in enforcing this law with or without regard to how they enforce laws against drunk driving
Your reply is deafening in it's utter simplicity. Ergo means "therefore" as in Cogito ergo sum.
Let me rephrase my post so you can understand it;
A P
Rephrased your point is still incorrect
Careful on your high horse there, falls can be dangerous
I understood your comment and was simply pointing out that you were trying to make a logical connection that was (and still is) totally illogical
My point is solid, it is YOU that lack the necessary skills to comprehend it.
A P
I see that once again when the point is lost you take a personal shot
Very classy
There is no cause and effect between the two issues which is why your point is no point at all