╌>

Be a Saint, Not a Scrooge -- Pope Francis's challenge is important, whatever your thoughts on his economic views.--Peggy Noonan, WSJ, 12/5/2013

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  len  •  13 years ago  •  11 comments

Be a Saint, Not a Scrooge -- Pope Francis's challenge is important, whatever your thoughts on his economic views.--Peggy Noonan, WSJ, 12/5/2013

We're not a year into his leadership, but it's Christmastime and the pope has been much in the news. Let's look at how he's doing.

He continues to capture the imagination. When he says something, people look and listen. His approach is not to lecture on the finer points but to embrace, and through the embrace communicate the essentials. An image of the first nine months: Francis on the phone, calling strangers. "Hello, it's the pope, I read your letter!" He famously eschews the specialthe regalia, the car, the palace, the shoes. He wears a cross made not of gold but of common metal. That seems in line with his tastes and nature but carries a symbolic punch: The church should not use its dignity and greatness, its art and finery to separate itself, unconsciously, from the people.

In a world full of loneliness and poverty he says: We are all equal, and equally loved.

Somehow you get the impression that even though he is 76everyone thinks he's youngerhe's going to be around a long time. And his papacy is going to be big.

His apostolic exhortation released last week set out general guidelines for the church as it tries to bring people to it. I read the controversial economics section twice, and to me it sounded pretty much like how modern popes talk and think. The world is swept by "consumerism," by the worship of things, which leaves our hearts "complacent yet covetous." The desire to acquire blunts the conscience, crowds out God's voice, and keeps us from hearing the only invitation that will make us happy.

His concerns in this section are classically Catholic and, in their emphasis, economically liberal: "Today we have to say 'thou shalt not' to an economy of exclusion and inequality. Such an economy kills. How can it be that it is not a news item when an elderly homeless person dies of exposure, but it is news when the stock market loses two points?" That struck me as a rebuke not only of "Wall Street" but of the media, which report the latter but not the former. Francis continues: "Today everything comes under the laws of competition and the survival of the fittest." He scores "trickle-down" economic theories "which assume that economic growth, encouraged by a free market, will inevitably succeed in bringing about greater justice and inclusiveness in the world." This view reflects "a naive trust" in the economically powerful.

He must have heard about the carried-interest tax break, and corporate welfare.

All this has been portrayed as an attack on free-market economic thinking, but it struck me more as an attack on mindless selfishness, greed and go-with-the-flow acceptance of the unrightness of the world. It made me think of Charles Dickens. The pope's message in part is: Don't be Scrooge. He cared only for money, had no respect for the poorhe thought they should die and decrease the surplus populationwasn't the least bit interested in treating his employees justly or with compassion, and missed out on all the real joy of life, until he wised up.

But is Francis saying more than that? Is he hostile to capitalism, and do we see this hostility in the pointed use of phrases such as "trickle-down," a term the left uses to disparage the idea that created wealth, when invested or spent, spreads and benefits others?

I don't know, I don't think so, and we'll see. I don't think he's saying be a leftist but something more revolutionary and fundamental: Be a saint. Be better, kinder, more serious and loving, and help create systems that reflect good, kind, loving people.

The pope has a way of colorfully saying, through words and actions, that the church is on the side of the poorthe materially and spiritually poorand always has been. I think he's saying that here: that the Church has a bias for the poor and impatience toward those who would abuse them. And he is speaking not infallibly but as a matter of a worldview rightly shared.

The popes of the modern era have been more or less European social democrats, of the economic left. I've never heard a pope worry about the depressive effects of high tax rates, have you? Or the dangers of high spending? Popes are sometimes geniuses but not economists.

And priests are like soldiers. I've never met a member of the military who cared much about taxing and spending. Their general view is that taxes should be high enough to allow a great nation to support a first-rate military and keep you safe, end of story. Soldiers aren't really paid commensurate with their responsibility and importance; it's not as if they're in the 60% bracket. Priests tend to be like that, too. They're not paid much, they're housed and fed by their order or parish. Taxes are more or less abstract to them. How high should taxes be? High enough for a first-rate country to help its citizens get the good things they need, end of story.

Priests know what's important in life, and it isn't money. You have to factor that in when you talk economic policy with them, just as you have to factor in that soldiers would give their lives for you.

Back to Francis, previous popes and economic policy. Our experience forms us. It shapes our thoughts and assumptions. John Paul II and Benedict XVI came from a particular 20th-century European experience. In their youth it was the rise of Nazism, and through their adult lives it was the constant threat of Soviet communism, which was both expansionistit took John Paul's Poland and half of Benedict's Germanyand atheistic. They saw communism as a limiter of freedom and a distorter of the human heart.

The great foe of Soviet communism? America and the West, which had the wherewithal and spiritual strength to resist it. The West brought with itwas rich because offree-market capitalism. John Paul and Benedict, whatever their private thoughts on how nations should arrange themselves economically, came to have a natural appreciation and respect for what made the West wealthy. They understood its positive utility.

Francis may turn out to be different in this regard. It is possible his appreciation for the wider apparatus of economic freedom does not run so deep. He is from Argentina, not a frontline state in the Cold War, and not necessarily a placePeronism, corporatism, the military's influence, the intertwining of money and governmentthat would give you a dreamy sense of free-market potential. Trickle-down didn't always work so well there.

We'll see the implications, if any, of all that.

For now, Francis really has a way of breaking through the media clutter, doesn't he? At a dinner the other night a smart young priest referred to how Francis's comments can often be taken a number of different ways. He said, "Maybe he's just unclear. But he's a Jesuit, so I assume it's deliberate." You mean strategic ambiguity, I said. We laughed because that's what we both thought. Francis wants to get us thinking about what we should be thinking about. He wants to invite thought.

And he's succeeding, isn't he?


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Enoch
Masters Silent
link   Enoch    13 years ago

Dear Friend Len: Thanks for another thought provoking article.

I am very favorably disposed and impressed with Pope Francis. I wish him well.

Peace and Abundant Blessings.

Enoch.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

I am surprised this did not draw more comments; especially from the liberals here who could assert; "See ,-- the Pope is a liberal like us."

But the Pope is callingfor personal improvement, higher values and charity; not government control.

Those are also conservative objectives.

Rush Limbaugh referred to the Pope as a "Marxist" but he is wrong. The following is from a conservative Catholic friend:

I usually agree with Rush, but this time I do not agree with him. Pope Francis' words are NOT "pure Marxism." If Rush really thinks Pope Francis is a Marxist, then he really hasn't done his homework on Pope Francis when he was the Jesuit provincial in Argentina and stomped on those Jesuits who were beginning to embrace Liberation Theology.....and paid the price when his term as Jesuit provincial was over when the Jesuits virtually exiled him to some remote Jesuit outpost where he was assigned to do the equivalent of "teaching high school." And that is where he would have remained had he not been rescued by Blessed Pope John Paul II and elevated to the rank of Bishop and then Cardinal of Buenos Aires Argentina.

Traditionally, the Catholic Church has tended to favor MODERATE capitalism because of its inclusion of a social safety net for those who through no fault of their own are financially down and out. What Pope Francis is against is monopolistic laissez fairecapitalism.

It was the late Archbishop Fulton J. Sheen who, when discussing capitalism and communism,once asked rhetorically if there any substantial difference between one regime in which the means of production were concentrated in the hands of a few commissars and another regimein which the means of production were concentrated in the hands of a few elite capitalists or fascists ( or Nazis???).

It would appear that in either case, the means of production wind up being concentrated in the hands of an elite few while the plight of the poor remains the same - except in cases where people tragically feel themselves compelled to sell their consciences for bread.

When "the Evil Empire" was still in its heyday, a sardonic joke was making the rounds to the effect that "in capitalism, the domination of man by man prevails, but in socialism, it is just the other way around.

Here is an article from The Catholic World Report which discusses the effort being made to portray Pope Francis as a supporter of the bogus "spirit of Vatican II."

Pope Francis the Conservative?

After some miscues and moments of confusion, the pontiff seems to be getting his label-free legs underneath him

November 24, 2013 02:32 EST

By Carl E. Olson

_________________________________________________________________________________________________

The radical socialists and theirpropaganda wingare trying to do to Pope Francis what their communist forefathers ( i.e. KGB )tried to do to Pope Pius XII with their "Hitler's Pope Myth....only this time they are trying to portray Pope Francis as a leftist/Marxist instead of a Nazi sympathizer/collaborator.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

Pope>>"This imbalance is the result of ideologies, which defend the absolute autonomy of the marketplace and financial speculation. ... A new tyranny is thus born. ..."

John:

He is not talking about individual morality or charity Len, or the wonders of "economic freedom" , as your sleepy eyed hero Noonan tries to claim. He is talking about the widespread and systematic devaluing of the lives of hundreds of millions of people.

From my wise Catholic friend:

Russell is right. The Pope is talking about a dehumanisingsystem of dysfunctional capitalism that he saw first hand in Argentina. I don't think anyone - including Rush Limpaugh -should want to brag any more about beingassociated with this type of "capitalism" than about being a Marxist.

When all is said and done, there is not much difference between the two.

As I have often pointed out, when the Soviet Union was in its heyday, there was a sardonic joke making the rounds to the effect that "in capitalism, the domination of man by man prevails, but in socialism, it is just the other way around."

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   Aeonpax    13 years ago

Len,

Thanks for your confused spin on what you and Noonan think Evangelii Gaudium means.

Perhaps Noonan missed these points;

  • With this in mind, I encourage financial experts and political leaders to ponder the words of one of the sages of antiquity: Not to share ones wealth with the poor is to steal from them and to take away their livelihood. It is not our own goods which we hold, but theirs. ( 57 )

or this,

  • A financial reform open to such ethical considerations would require a vigorous change of approach on the part of political leaders . I urge them to face this challenge with determination and an eye to the future, while not ignoring, of course, the specifics of each case. Money must serve, not rule! - ( 58 )

or this,

  • Just as goodness tends to spread, the toleration of evil, which is injustice, tends to expand its baneful influence and quietly to undermine any political and social system, no matter how solid it may appear . ( 59 )

maybe this,

  • When a society whether local, national or global is willing to leave a part of itself on the fringes, no political programmes or resources spent on law enforcement or surveillance systems can indefinitely guarantee tranquility- ( 59 )

perchance this,

  • Some simply content themselves with blaming the poor and the poorer countries themselves for their troubles; indulging in unwarranted generalizations, they claim that the solution is an education that would tranquilize them, making them tame and harmless. All this becomes even more exasperating for the marginalized in the light of the widespread and deeply rooted corruption found in many countries in their governments, businesses and institutions whatever the political ideology of their leaders. ( 60 )

did Noonan miss this?,

  • I ask God to give us more politicians capable of sincere and effective dialogue aimed at healing the deepest roots and not simply the appearances of the evils in our world! Politics, though often denigrated, remains a lofty vocation and one of the highest forms of charity, inasmuch as it seeks the common good ( 174 )

Or better yet, just read the whole thing before you and Noonan ideologically obfuscate and taint the mans words to fit your own convoluted world of political unreality

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

What is the alternative? Income equality?

Did it ever occur to you that a major reason for the disparity is the monumentally high immigration rate; especially illegal immigration?

 
 
 
JoAnne Odel
Freshman Silent
link   JoAnne Odel    13 years ago

if only the war on coal had existed in scrooge's time, they would have been so much better off.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago
  • With this in mind, I encourage financial experts and political leaders to ponder the words of one of the sages of antiquity: Not to share ones wealth with the poor is to steal from them and to take away their livelihood. It is not our own goods which we hold, but theirs. ( 57 )

I am sure Noonan missed no points. You seem to think conservatives are Neanderthals. It is not a matter of black or white. I cannot speak for her but here is my own reaction.

Sharing wealth with the poor does not necessarily mean income redistribution but rather being charitable. In my own tradition Isaiah wrote of this in a passage read publically in synagogues on the holiest day of the year, the Day of Atonement, a fast day:

Why, when we fasted did You not see? --- Because on your fast day you see to your business and oppress all your laborers! Because you fast in strife and contention and strike with a wicked fist! Your fasting today is not such as to make your voice heard on high. Is such the fast I choose --- ? NO, this is the fast I desire: to unlock the fetters of wickedness, --- to let the oppressed go free; --- to share your bread with the hungry, and take the wretched poor into your home; when you see the naked, to clothe him, and not to ignore your own family. Then shall your light burst through like dawn, and your healing spring up quickly; Your Vindicator shall march before you; the presence of the Lord shall be your rear guard. Then when you call the Lord will answer; when you cry He will say, Here I am." (Is. 58)

Undoubtedly Pope Francis is well aware of this model.

What you may not be aware of is that conservatives give far more to charity than liberals:

-- Although liberal families' incomes average 6 percent higher than those of conservative families, conservative-headed households give, on average, 30 percent more to charity than the average liberal-headed household ($1,600 per year vs. $1,227).

-- Conservatives also donate more time and give more blood.

-- Residents of the states that voted for John Kerry in 2004 gave smaller percentages of their incomes to charity than did residents of states that voted for George Bush.

-- Bush carried 24 of the 25 states where charitable giving was above average.

-- In the 10 reddest states, in which Bush got more than 60 percent majorities, the average percentage of personal income donated to charity was 3.5. Residents of the bluest states, which gave Bush less than 40 percent, donated just 1.9 percent.

-- People who reject the idea that "government has a responsibility to reduce income inequality" give an average of four times more than people who accept that proposition.

...

Politicians must inspire charity but that is a far cry from dispensing it with other people's money.

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   Aeonpax    13 years ago
  • You seem to think conservatives are Neanderthals.

It is you who said that.

  • I am sure Noonan missed no points. You seem to think conservatives are Neanderthals. It is not a matter of black or white. I cannot speak for her but here is my own reaction.

My friend, Len, you make the grave mistake of launching your own beliefs in what the bible says, as if what it says contains some kind of all-encompassing truism, which it does not. While the bible contains much information, the fact that anyone engulfed in any kind of christian based faith which allows anyone to freely to interpret it as they see fit makes it, makes it a less than suitable source for basic standards, such as morals.

 
 
 
JoAnne Odel
Freshman Silent
link   JoAnne Odel    13 years ago

i am not worthy to judge the Holy See on matters of the Church, but for politics i believe we may be better served by Urban II at this time.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago
My friend, Len, you make the grave mistake of launching your own beliefs in what the bible says, as if what it says contains some kind of all-encompassing truism, which it does not. While the bible contains much information, the fact that anyone engulfed in any kind of christian based faith which allows anyone to freely to interpret it as they see fit makes it, makes it a less than suitable source for basic standards, such as morals.

Dear AP,

Isn't what you are doing interpreting the Pope and Peggy Noonan as YOU see fit; and prejudiciallyagainst Noonanto boot? You contended thatthe words she analyzedcontradict her conclusions. Here is her conclusion:

I don't think he's saying be a leftist but something more revolutionary and fundamental: Be a saint. Be better, kinder, more serious and loving, and help create systems that reflect good, kind, loving people.

The pope has a way of colorfully saying, through words and actions, that the church is on the side of the poorthe materially and spiritually poorand always has been. I think he's saying that here: that the Church has a bias for the poor and impatience toward those who would abuse them. And he is speaking not infallibly but as a matter of a worldview rightly shared. ---

Francis wants to get us thinking about what we should be thinking about. He wants to invite thought.

Thanks for your thoughts.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

The dispensing of charity always comes down to "if I feel like it".

The alternative to "if I feel like it" is -- what; some "benevolent" tin-horned dictator, and his political party,ordering you about? The "tyranny of the majority" -- of one senator now?

By your lights, the hungry should have to depend on someone else "feeling like" helping them. What hogwash. "Income inequality" to a large degree is people who work being told that their work is not valuable enough to allow them to put food on their table. Exactly the popes point about the ideologies of the financial manipulators.

You are reading YOUR ideas into Pope Francis. As stated ina Huffington Post blog, however:

Allow the progressives a moment to enjoy their adversaries' discomfort. But before they start claiming Pope Francis as the standard bearer for the progressive movement, they ought to remind themselves of a few less enjoyable realities.

As observed by pundit E.J. Dionne - a liberal-leaning Catholic and unabashed Francis admirer -- the pope is no liberal on abortion. Nor, despite his tone change on the matter of same-sex couples, has Francis come out in favor of gay marriage or ordination of women, or contraception. The day could come when progressive activists are no longer swooning over Francis but lamenting his "conservative" views on these and other liberal causes.

Which, one suspects, will be of little concern to this new face of the worldwide Catholic Church. To state what should be obvious, Francis is not a player in American politics. He's not even American, for God's sake. Growing up and pursuing his vocation in Argentina has no doubt had a profound effect on him.

Even more important, the pope is not a politician, a media loudmouth or an activist. He is a religious figure, wholly dedicated to representing the Gospel of Jesus Christ as he understands it to a world caught up in a thousand other things.

As conservative Catholic George Weigel writes, "Pope Francis is a revolutionary. The revolution he proposes, however, is not a matter of economic or political prescription, but a revolution in the self-understanding of the Catholic Church."

Prophetic is probably the best word for the role the pope is playing -- not in the sense of predicting the future, but of standing outside of business and politics as usual and speaking hard and inconvenient moral truths.

 
 

Who is online



JohnRussell


101 visitors