And she just taps the heart and it starts beating... So they killed the baby.
The series focuses on the personal narrative of Holly ODonnell, a former Blood and Tissue Procurement Technician for StemExpress, a biotech start-up that until last week was partnered with two large northern California Planned Parenthood affiliates to purchase their aborted fetus parts and resell them for scientific experimentation.
ODonnell describes the harvesting, or procurement, of organs from a nearly intact late-term fetus aborted at Planned Parenthood Mar Montes Alameda clinic in San Jose, CA. I want to see something kind of cool, ODonnell says her supervisor asked her. And she just taps the heart, and it starts beating. And Im sitting here and Im looking at this fetus, and its heart is beating, and I dont know what to think.
The San Jose Planned Parenthood does abortions up to 20 weeks of pregnancy. Referring to the beating heart of the aborted fetus, ODonnell remarks, I dont know if that constitutes its technically dead, or its alive.
State and federal law require that the same treatment be given to an infant born-alive after an abortion as to a normally delivered baby (1 U.S.C. 8, CA Health and Safety Code 123435). California law also prohibits any kind of experimentation on a fetus with a discernible heartbeat (CA Health and Safety Code 123440). StemExpress has been cited in published scientific literature as a source of fetal hearts used for Langendorff perfusion, which keeps a heart beating after it is excised from the body[.]
ODonnell also tells how her StemExpress supervisor instructed her to cut through the face of the fetus in order to get the brain. I cant even describe what that feels like, she says.
http://hotair.com/archives/2015/08/19/new-cmp-video-and-she-just-taps-the-heart-and-it-starts-beating/

"Abortion kills babies, but sometimes abortion isnt enough to finish the job. These clinics are killing children born alive from these procedures, simply to harvest their organs. That violates the federal BAIPA law. Will the Department of Justice enforce it?"
Your tax dollars at work, ensuring aborted babies are born alive so their organs can be harvested.
Yeah America!
If this account is true, it is abominable!
But sources matter and until such time if ever, this is verified, there are other sides to the story that must also be considered.
And if articles such as this seed can be posted verbatim, in full, it is equally acceptable to post rebuttal seeds thus
What the Planned Parenthood Attack Group Wont Tell You About Its Findings
All sides of a controversial, emotional, moral and potentially legal matter must be given an airing; but those who consistently post one side of such issues and try to mock, shout down and/or insult those with opposing, rebuttal views, do nothing but create vitriol while trying to discourage dissent.
I get the abortion industry absolutely has to respond with propaganda. How could it not given the barbaric material contained in these videos? However, simply "saying we don't do something" is not proof, especially in the face of proof that they do in fact do that do those things.
You have it backwards, Sean. In the United States, THE BURDEN OF PROOF must be satisfied by the entity/individual(s) making the allegation! An argument is made in rebuttal if the accuser can do nothing but double down on the charge, that's not "proof" of anything other than a possible "agenda".
It's enough for an indictment or a DOJ investigation at the least. But we know neither will happen. If O'Donnell had alleged that her boss called called the President a racial slur, the DOJ would be all over it. Allegations of killing a baby outside the womb simply can't match that in importance.
Laws, as we see with HRC, are only used against those people disfavored by the Obama administration. The Democrats make too much money off the abortion lobby to ever do anything that might hinder the baby grinder from operating.
Although it's amusing to see the abortion lobby act with such shock to the allegation that they stab babies in the brain with scissors when they cheerfully admit to suffocating them. Who knew moving a baby's head a couple inches can make such a difference in one's moral calculus?
No matter how many people that worked for Planned Parenthood come forward with testimonies to the atrocities preformed there it seems the left will still deny it and support it.
Believe it or not I got in quite a debate with a newer NT member that seemed to support this type of thing. He had the stones to say I was making him look like a baby killer but lacked the guts to voice his stance on the matter for this reason. So the truth is that supporting killing live born babies DOES make you a baby killer but do you think he recanted or even re-thought his position? Hell no. He must be one of those "progressives".
Thanks for this A. Mac.
And no matter how many right-wing-agenda groups and makers of fraudulently-presented "evidence" come out with edited, refuted content, it seems the right will still support it.
What was the first thing I posted in this article, 96? It was/is
And you guys never acknowledge anything done with the intent of being "fair and balanced" -- ironic isn't it?
The groups you laud have a history of fraudulent acts.
And Republican legislators used FRAUDULENT INFORMATION to defund ACORN!
You OK with lawmakers getting in bed with frauds that help advance their agendas? So much for the Constitution the strict constructionists praise until it doesn't work in their favor.
My (non-erotic) fantasy is to get these guys in a formal, litigative-setting and question them where doubling down on fabricated "arguments" will get them nowhere but tossed-out for lack-of-evidence, non-credible witnesses/sources andfrivolous litigation(the practice of starting or pursuing "legal" argumentsthat, due to their lack of legal merit, have little to no chance of being won.
The "politics-of-politics" so-to-speak is one thing, but the politics of ideology that purports to take the moral high ground while lying its ass off to own it is not only reprehensible, but dangerous and a threat to democracy.
Let's cut to the chase.
99% of ALL abortions are simply because women are too fucking stupid to use birth control..
Hence, their "choice" is to kill a fetus.
Sure, the other 1% is rape, incest, and the other excuses, but let's call a spade a spade for once.
All I can say is: Can I watch?
People don't seem to realize that Planned Parenthood meets a real need for birth control, mammograms, gynecological, and obstetric care. Without Planned Parenthood, many of our neighbors would have little access to medical care. So, don't throw the baby out with the bath water!
Glad to hear you don't support killing live born babies. Too bad everyone isn't on board.
A lot of truth to that. Sad to say I know more than one woman who uses abortion as her form of "birth control". They simply don't like using the "other forms". Pretty sick IMO.
ports to take the moral high ground while lying its ass off to own it
A very fair assessment of Planned Parenthood. I agree.
le don't seem to realize that Planned Parenthood meets a real need for birth control, mammograms, gynecological, and obstetric care.
Yes, its impossible to imagine those things existing without being attached to abortion factories. If only there were a way for a taxpayer subsidized business to provide certain services and not others.
If you are too faint of heart to watch the video, and I don't blame you if you are, The video as described by John Hindraker "consists mostly of Miss ODonnell describing an incident in which a babys heart was still beating, and she was instructed to cut through the babys face so that his brainthe baby was a boycould be removed for sale."
Sean, you're too intelligent to argue the Pee Wee Herman defense.
That is not the definition of "choice".
Good point. Countless whistle blowers don't seem to cut it.
Sworn testimony under oath (a written, signed affidavit) and actual, verifiable proof as required under the American legal system/Constitution.
Possibly you might be induced to care if/when you or a member of your family is charged with a criminal act based on fraudulent "information".
Think about it.
Then she should be called/subpoenaed as a witness for the prosecution if/when Planned Parenthood is formally indicted and prosecution.
Further,her testimony, under oath (along with a written, signed affidavit) and, actual, verifiable proof (under the requirement that the accuser satisfy that "BURDEN OF PROOF") as required under the American legal system/Constitution should suffice.
Spin your political wheels all you like, then ask the question (and not with a rhetorical "answer"), why this hasn't come about.
I'm not really joking, you succinctly summarized how I view Planned Parenthood even though you obviously didn't mean it that way. They lie about everything.
If you can watch these videos and feel good about turning baby organs into lamberginis for "doctors" more power to you, I guess.
then ask the question (and not with a rhetorical "answer"), why this hasn't come about.
I believe I answered that. How much do abortionists donate to the party that runs the Department of Justice and the IRS like they are the privateenforcementwings of that same party?Howfanaticallyunited are theDemocrats in support of abortion on demand? There is no possible evidence that could compel the department of Justice to perform a real investigation into Planned Parenthood. None.
The DOJ and IRS will almost surelyrigorouslyinvestigate the video makers instead. That's how Obama operates.
The evidence exists, besides O'Donnell's tesimtony:
The video also features recordings of Dr. Ben Van Handel, the Executive Director of Novogenix Laboratories, LLC, and also of Perrin Larton, Procurement Manager of Advanced Bioscience Resources, Inc. (ABR). Novogenix is the company that has harvested fetal organs from abortions done by Planned Parenthood Federation of Americas Senior Director of Medical Services, Dr. Deborah Nucatola, in Los Angeles, while ABR is the oldest fetal tissue procurement company and works with Planned Parenthood in San Diego and other clinics around the country. Van Handel admits, There are times when after the procedure is done that the heart actually is still beating, and Larton describes abortions she has seen where the fetus was already in the vaginal canal whenever we put her in the stirrups, it just fell out.
If Planned Parenthood is defunded, where will women who depend on PP , including those who cannot afford abortion from a non-subsidized provider , go ?
Getting rid of Planned Parenthood will not get rid of abortions.
So what is the alternative for those women ?
And you know this from watching videos that have been challenged for inaccuracies and edits recorded by entities with a history of fraud.
At least be open-minded enough to acknowledge that there are two sides to this story, and, that if the charges have any merit, those making the charges would have pursued LEGAL RATHER THAN POLITICAL REMEDIES!
I'll bet you never asked that with regard to conservative agendas when a Republican is in the White House.
Make your case without further innuendo and unsubstantiated paranoia/political rhetoric.
Let's cut to the chase.
99% of ALL abortions are simply because women are too fucking stupid to use birth control..
Link? Proof? Something? Or did you just pull that figure out of your ass? Just wondering.
Never mind. The answer is obvious.
Oh, so you think that women are too stupid to know how babies are made?
Rape and Incest: Just 1% of All Abortions
So, what's your excuse now?
Birth control would be a good start.
As I expected..... crickets.
The one part of the abortion debate that NEVER gets discussed is the obvious irresponsibility of the women that insist on having unprotected sex without the use of birth control.
They just gotta have that dick. They are so horned up, and craving it, that they can't be bothered with taking a pill, or forcing the man to use a condom. Nope, they want the pure satisfaction of feeling that baby batter.
So, when everyone is done talking about the bullshit side of the debate, remember that it's a woman's right to choose to have unprotected sex, and they choose to NOT be on birth control..... then they CHOOSE to have an abortion, as a way to erase their previous irresponsible behavior.
You see, I'm a man, so I am keenly aware of what happens when you knock-up some cooz, so I take precautions against it.
Why women cannot be as wise, is the greatest mystery of our time, and THAT is at the root of the abortion debate.
I don't there is any obligation on taxpayers to pay for abortions. As Joey says above, higher costs might incent them to use birth control, rather than using abortion as birth control.
If liberals believe there is an absolute necessity for cheap abortion, they are free to set up their own clinics with their own money. They have enough of it.
And where is taxpayer money being used to pay for abortions, Sean?
And how is it that many right-wing "minds" oppose both birth control and abortion? It's not logical rather, it's psychotically ideological.
Educate yourself.
ABORTION AND CONTRACEPTION
You are missing the point Sean.
You guys ( the right) act like Planned Parenthood and the right to privacy according to the constitution ( manifested in this case as abortion) are one and the same, and they are not.
IF you show that Planned Parenthood is unworthy , that does not mean the right to abortion has been discredited.
Where will poor women go for abortion ? or are they (the poor) supposed to suffer for your self righteousness ?
Will women who don't need subsidized abortions have paid any price as a result of the crusade ?
When abortions are outlawed, only the rich will get abortions.
LOL! Thanks for answering my question.
Ever hear of to save the life of the mother? Or because the fetus is too malformed to survive outside of the womb? And do have something from THIS century? Not from more then 25 years ago?
"To save the life of the mother" is just another rare exception, and in fact, that happens way less than the rapes and incest abortions.
Face it, abortion is about women being irresponsible whores, not much else.
In YOUR opinion.
An ectopic pregnancy is one that occurs outside the womb, usually in one of the fallopian tubes. Because the fetus cannot survive and the mom could suffer life-threatening internal bleeding, ectopic pregnancies, which may account for as many as one in 40 pregnancies, are terminated at the earliest sign.
That's not too much of a rarity, is it? And that's just ectopic pregnancies. I strongly doubt that one in forty women who get pregnant and then have to have an abortion are "being irresponsible whores".
...
A. Macarthur,
Come on man, you know better than to believe that people honestly self report on their own immoral behavior.
They're not going to walk into the abortion clinic and say "nah, I don't bother with birth control, I was just horny, now let's suck this baby out of me".
They are having an abortion because they don't want a baby, it's post facto birth control.
Next you will tell me that since 80% of prison inmates claim innocence, that we are wrongly convicting 80% of the people in prison.
I have a revelation for you, people lie, especially about their own irresponsible, criminal, or immoral behavior.
Taxpayer money is not being used to fund abortions.
Mr. Giordano,
Don't create straw men to replace actual rebuttal; I posted specifics you are free to say you don't agree with them, but don't project what you think I might say next in an effort to discredit my or the specifics I post.
You came into this discussion with a pronouncement of statistics you arbitrarily decided represented realities they do not.
And I have one for you; people do all sorts of things like making blanket indictments from generalizations.
Don't talk down to me debate and disagree, but don't make declarations then claim victory.
A. Macarthur
I'm not talking down to you, or claiming victory.
What I am saying is that those "facts" are bunk.
Otherwise, where is the national outcry for better contraception?
Joey-What does your mother think of this position of yours and how long have you hated her? Your total disrespect for women undermines every ill-mannered point you will ever make:
Do you really believe any rational person will take you seriously? Or is this merely trolling chum? Either way you fail any moral high ground you assume.
Planned Parenthood provides free and comprehensive contraception to poor women.
One Miscreant
I'm not trolling, I'm just stating a fact relevant to this debate, that nobody ever has the guts to address.
In this age, with countless contraception options, enormous availability, and very low costs, it's the irresponsible behavior of women fueling the abortion boom.
People historically have the same old debate about abortion, is it murder, or a woman's right to choose, but nobody ever talks about the cause of abortion.
The cause is irresponsible women.
Just because I have the guts to point it out doesn't make me a troll, it makes me a person that isn't afraid to address the cause of a problem.
If liberals believe there is an absolute necessity for cheap abortion, they are free to set up their own clinics with their own money. They have enough of it.
My wife and myself are quite liberal, yet we don't have a lot of money. We are on a fixed income (mostly Social Security) and while we have enough to get by on, we certainly couldn't fund an abortion clinic. Can you?
Exactly!
And they should use contraception, instead of abortion.
The cause is irresponsible women.
Abortions, outside of rape and incest, are caused by "irresponsible whores" is what you said in another part of this thread. That is certainly trolling.
You people should really do some research on the current sexual liberation of women.
It's no mystery that abortion rates have risen in parallel to the rising tide of a more sexualized female population.
With abortion available when needed. Don't get me wrong, I hate abortions. Every pro-choice person I know or have ever met does too! So do most pro-choice politicians.
However, I honestly and sincerely believe that the option should be legal and should be a decision left up to the mother and her doctor and her own conscience. I don't have the right to make the decision for her. I don't believe anyone else does either.
Randy
I actually agree with you completely.
I just think that abortions have turned into the contraception "Plan B", and that's pretty ugly.
A million a year in the US alone.
17 million black babies since 1973.
We'd call it a genocide if it were any other activity.
I'll post some stats below.
WHY DO ABORTIONS OCCUR?
The takeaway? Baby is inconvenient.
That's a pretty shitty reason to kill it.
Actually, your "facts" are bunk. You make these pronouncements and declarations as if they were based on anything but your perceptions. I respond specifically to you but you attempt each time to discredit me as if I'm (ironically) doing what you do.
As for the national outcry for better contraception if there were none, then why the following efforts to thwart it? I always give you et al the time, effort and respect of specific answers; I don't appreciate off-handed dismissals. The "outcry" you asked about is included below in the right wing efforts to silence it.
War on Birth Control/Contraception
Not so; in fact, I address your "facts" every time, at which point, you arbitrarily declare in one way or another that only you know what's real and what's "bunk."
Wrong again!
American women are having significantly fewer abortions than in the past. Since 2010, the Associated Press recently reported , the number of abortions nationwide has decreased by about 12 percent.
This decline has been happening, slowly and steadily, for a quarter of a century: Since 1990, the rate of abortions has fallen by more than a third, and the raw number of abortions has fallen by more than half.
But though the rate of abortions has changed, the politics of of this issue have become stale. Theres already evidence that the issue will play a role in the 2016, just as it has in nearly every election of the last four decades. Last week, for example, South Carolina Senator Lindsey Graham proposed a bill that would ban most abortions after 20 weeks of pregnancy nationwide, and Wisconsin Governor Scott Walker released an open letter in support of a similar ban in his state. For her part, Hillary Clinton hasnt really made a point of expressing support for abortion and birth-control access since declaring her candidacy, but she also hasnt shied away from affiliation with organizations like Planned Parenthood. In the 42 years since the Supreme Courts ruling in Roe v. Wade , public opinion hasnt changed much : Roughly half of Americans believe abortion should be legal only in certain circumstances, while slightly less than a third believe it should be legal under any circumstances and slightly less than a fifth oppose it altogether.
A. Macarthur
How could I have guessed that you would try to drag politics into this.
I specifically said an outcry for better contraception, not any gibber jabber about Republicans not wanting to pay for it.
One million abortions a year, and they aren't because contraception is ineffective, it's because irresponsible, sex-hungry, baby makers got knocked-up, and don't want to be bothered with a kid.
And why?
Because a baby is an inconvenience.
Tripling down doesn't cut it, Joey.
When you want to have an actual discussion. I'll be around.
One million abortions a year, and they aren't because contraception is ineffective, it's because irresponsible, sex-hungry, baby makers got knocked-up, and don't want to be bothered with a kid.
And I disagree completely as that is a wildly over-broad generalization and untrue because of it.
.75 interfere with work, school or other responsibilities (how irresponsible of them)
.75 cannot afford a child (yup let's have those would be dad's who DNA is part of the mix pay)
.50 they do not want to be a single parent ('cause what we need is more baby mamas)
_________
2.00 The New Math!
Now let me be clear, I am not for late term abortions, most people are not. But it takes two to tango and frankly maybe if we started going after the would be dads too, this article might have a different tone.
u guys ( the right) act like Planned Parenthood and the right to privacy according to the constitution ( manifested in this case as abortion) are one and the same, and they are not.
No, the invisible to all those without their secret Orphan Annie decoder ring "right" to an abortion has nothing to do with exposing what Planned Parenthood does with millions of tax payer dollars. Knowing that a tax payer subsidized business uses human beings in ways that are more at home with the Aztecs or Nazis is something the public should know.
hat does not mean the right to abortion has been discredited.
Show me where the "right" to abortion is contained in the Constitution and I will call it a right. It's a figment of 5 justices imaginations, and can easily disappear back into the emanations and penumbras should 5 other justices decide the Constitution has "evolved."
Of course, exposing what happens at planned parenthood won't make abortion illegal. But if it makes people wrap their heads around what horrors are visited upon babies with beating hearts and a functional nervous systems, maybe some people will reconsider their support for abortions after the first trimester at least.
As we learned with gay marriage, the modern Supreme Court interprets the Constitution in line with popular wishes.
they (the poor) supposed to suffer for your self righteousness ?
I'm sure they will suffer less then the babies who are stabbed or suffocated and sold for gold. Don't you? Use birth control, don't have sex or give the kid up for adoption. Much easier than killing innocents, don't you think?
And where is taxpayer money being used to pay for abortions, Sean?
Ask John, he understands.
If you've ever handled and allocated money, you know how absurd the pretense is that taxpayer money isn't used to subsidize abortions.
And Santa exists!
The idea that tax dollars don't subsidize abortions is an accounting fiction so people like you can tell the public who abhor the idea of using tax money that it doesn't happen. Run a business someday and then try and say that with a straight face.
Seriously, the silly shit the abortion lobby get people to parrot is silly. Just think about how a business operates and you will see how silly it is.
As I expected..... crickets.
Why do some people say that before giving people a real chance to post an answer? I mean some of them post a question and even include it (crickets) in the post itself before anyone can get a chance to even read it. I don't know about others, but I have a L-I-F-E and do not always get around to answering questions right away. Especially when Adult Swim is on The Cartoon Network. Give people a real chance to answer before accusing them of not answering with the "crickets" line. It's the polite thing to do.
Having abortion on demand or not having abortion on demand is a moral and societal issue, not a legal one. If abortion is a constitutional right based on right to privacy than "on demand" must be permitted.
Looking at the "reasons" you lay out Perrie, it is somewhat troubling. The top and bottom ones are mainly related to convenience. The baby would "interfere" with something the woman wants or needs to do, or she doesn't "want" to be a single parent. Who "wants" to be a single parent? Very few.
Over the course of decades the ease of rationale has increased it would seem. We should never accept as optimum a situation where 'convenience' is a gold standard reason to abort.
The abortion issue will never be totally settled, because it cannot be, given the entrenched beliefs of the two sides.
Perrie Halpern
With most people giving three different reasons, the math will never add up.
Do tell, Sean.
Just provide citation and we'll go from there.
But I'm open to any specifics you have regarding taxpayer-subsidized abortions; these damned accusations without citation are the enemy of honest dialogue.
And that's your rebuttal, Sean?
Seriously got any specifics? This righteous indignation without a shred of particulars makes it difficult to take you seriously. If there's a parrot in the room
it might be you.
I was referring to the subsidies given directly to planned parenthood for the last few decades. Money is fungible. The Feds give planned parenthood a million dollars and say don't spend it on abortion. So they spend it on rent. That leaves planned parenthood free to allocate monet they otherwise would have had to spend on rent for abortion.Once you think about it you Realize how silly the claim is, especially for a non profit.
Those are not my reasons, they are Joey's. Furthermore, if a man had to bare some of these inconveniences, I think we would see a whole different attitude about this. What angers me, is when I read some dude calling women oversexed, when it's fine for a dude to score. Well I can do math and two horny people can make some really bad mistakes, but it seems that only one has to wear the scarlet letter? Sorry, I don't buy that.
As for abortion itself, there are fewer now than there have ever been, and I hope with "Plan B" that those numbers get even lower. Yet there are those who are against even that.
I agree that abortion will never be totally settled, but it is the law of the land, and even if it wasn't, they would still be available to those who could afford them.
By the way, there are several totally reputable websites that list the exact same stats and info on all of this, A.Mac. used one, so did I.
ANNUAL ABORTION STATISTICS
WHO HAS ABORTIONS?
ABORTION AND PUBLIC FUNDS
Perrie Halpern
I get your point, and I don't entirely disagree, but additionally, if women are getting unintended pregnant, then it's a pretty safe bet that they were having unprotected sex.
So, even if people didn't care about the chance for getting pregnant and needing an abortion, but they obviously aren't too worried about STD's.
Our entire society is over-sexed, men and women.
Have you seen the articles that talk about how sites like Tinder are killing the bar scene? Or that millennials are have more sex, but worse sex than ever?
Or, that all these meaningless hookups are leaving the participants unfulfilled and depressed?
I'm not making any of this up.
In the end, it is still a moral question as to whether or not a "baby" should be aborted for reasons of convenience. This is no doubt why there has been such heated debate over the years as to just when it becomes a "person".
I just explained that, Sean
Regarding
Or actually for the following
FYI:
The PPH aspects that educate and provide health care to men and women DON'T MATTER TO THE IDEOLOGUES!
They can't rally a myopic base with stuff like that!
For pro-life advocates life after birth is an inconvenient truth.
I just explained that, Sean
Except you obviously didn't read the link I provided to the GAO report. Here it's spelled out in black and white:
"Among a sample of 18 insurers, all but three issuers indicated that the [abortion coverage] benefit is not subject to any restrictions, limitations, or exclusions, the GAO wrote in its report."
Read more:
Regarding therest, it would be easier if you just said , "you are right,money is fungible", rather than posting a whole lot of irrelevance.
I am the product of protected sex. And are not two adults responsible for their sex?
I am not disagreeing with the rest of your post, but part of the problem is poor sex ed. As a sex ed teacher, I can tell you all the misconceptions that people have, like you can't get STD from oral or anal sex.
And yes, our society has become very impersonal. I guess we can blame a whole lot of reason for that, including computers and cell phones and texting...but I am not a sociologist.
Maybe 3 reasons equal not going through with the pregnancy?
More directly, the tax money directly given to planned parenthood Subsidizes abortion.
Has anyone here pontificating against abortion ever undergone genetic counseling? Has any one of you men, especially you, Joey, had to face the fact that there is only a 25% chance that your baby will be born and be "normal"?
My husband and I had an amniocentesis with our son. I was 42 and my husband was 39. They took a sample of the amniotic fluid, (and boy, that's just so much fun), and tested it to see if my son had any of the approximately 300 genetic ailments that they can test for. THEN, we spent 2 hours discussing the approximately 300 genetic ailments they can't test for.
Let me tell you, this baby was WANTED. I had always dreamed of becoming a mother, and was terrified that something would be wrong with him... Have you ever faced that choice? Depending on what may be wrong, you can have a nightmare of problems. And at the time, your insurance could refuse to pay for anything because it could be determined that the baby had a pre-existing condition.
We were so fortunate, blessed, in fact, that we didn't have to make that decision, because my son was clear of anything they could test for. Naturally, we worried about all the things he could have that they couldn't test for.
However, my best friend since high school DID have to make that decision. Her baby was going to be born with a terribly debilitating, painful, birth defect that could have made the baby miserable her entire life. She and her husband discussed it with their pastor, their parents, and decided to deliver the baby early. The baby was born at 22 weeks, and died peacefully in their arms, her birth defects obvious. That heart breaking decision was made by them both and was a nightmare for them.
The baby was buried at the cemetery, and I can't help but feel that they made the decision that was right for them. They were able to have two children, and then, something went wrong and she had to have an emergency hysterectomy, following the birth of their younger son.
The night I was admitted to the hospital, when my son was 32 weeks into the pregnancy, he had a 25% chance of living through the night, and I had a 50% chance of living through the night. I managed to hang onto him until 36 weeks, (normal pregnancy is 40 weeks), and he was a preemie, but he is now a fine young man, 17 years of age. He is beloved, and we have been blessed with him, every day of his life.
So, all of you sexist pigs out there who want to blame the woman for everything, all you out there who have never had to face these choices, or rear it alone, who wish to blame "irresponsible women", need to stop a moment, and walk about 1 hour in their moccasins. You have no idea. And frankly, you never will. Keep your pants zipped, and 1/2 of the abortions in this country won't be necessary.
And remember that birth control doesn't always work.
Many of the responses to this article make me ill. Neanderthals-- A song that would fit your attitudes is this, except that Alley Oop was never as crude, rude, and unacceptable as you:
Thank you, Dowser !!!
Dowser,
I appreciate what you have gone through, and I get it.
But you, and your situation isn't responsible for over a million abortions a year, inconvenience is.
This is part of the problem with this entire subject, nobody can talk about it, without introducing countless non-sequiturs.
Sure, you and your friend had real considerations, I understand, but did you read the statistics?
75% said is was inconvenient to have child.
1% claimed rape or incest.
12% equals 120,000, not ONE MILLION.
I'm not advocating making abortion illegal, but like many idiots of the past, I do believe it should be legal, but rare.
It isn't rare, it's common.
It's become the defacto Plan B of birth control, and killing a fetus deserves more consideration that a tooth ache.
But not in our society.
So, while your individual story is compelling, it's not representative of the problem.
And just like the people that scream "rape and incest", it's a fraction.
Read the goddamned statistics, then tell me what's happening.
Perrie Halpern
That would make sense, except only one of the partners actually gets a baby in her womb, and only one partner gets the choice to abort it, and typically, only one partner has to pay the other partner child support.
So, is there equity? NO, there isn't.
Thus, women should remember that they are the ones that get pregnant, not men, and they should use birth control, instead of abortion.
And they don't, and that is my entire point.
A. Macarthur
Part of that is because I'm one of the only members on this site that routinely has sex with young girls of child bearing age.
I know the demo, because I engage the demo.
Seriously, a show of hands, who among us has any relationship with a child bearing female?
Randy,
Go look at the numbers, they ain't no secret.
Randy,
Sorry about that, I guess I jumped the gun.
I meant no offense.
ABORTION AND PUBLIC FUNDS
I meant no offense.
Oh I wasn't offended and it really wasn't directed at you. Your post just reminded me that I have always wondered why that happens and wanted to say so. I should be saying no offense intended to you.
Perrie Halpern
And by the way, Sex Ed is bullshit!
In our society, there doesn't exist a girl/woman of child bearing age, that doesn't know EXACTLY how a baby is made.
The average age a girl loses her virginity in our culture is 14, and by 14, every girl in this country know that inserting peg A into slot B is what makes a baby.
You guys are dancing around the obvious, most women get abortions because they were too stupid or lazy to use birth control.
It isn't because their birth control failed, or because of rape, or incest, or medical complications.
They are just filthy sluts that got knocked up.
I know that doesn't suit the PC crowd, but it's a fact.
That's why their reasons are inconvenience.
They should practice birth control, instead of baby murder.
But you, and your ilk, have empowered them into thinking that abortion is just some harmless procedure, which is a lie.
It's killing a viable human being, that's what it really is.
And yeah, it's legal, but it's also repugnant.
And what makes it doubly repugnant is that it's treated like a root canal, instead of the tiny little micro-murder that it is.
And because of legality, just like with legalizing drugs, it's tacit approval.
"Well, it's legal, so it must be ok"
It's not "ok", it's barbaric, and is fueled almost entirely by the irresponsible behavior of women.
It's like when the gun nuts talk about shooting people for self defense, which represents like 0.01% of the actual gun deaths in America.
It's a great defense, but indicative of such a small percentage of the killings, that it's almost meaningless.
Well, that's abortion. Sold on rape, incest, and health threat to the mother, but that's not what's happening a million times a year, what is happening is post facto birth control for a bunch of whores.
Look into the numbers, see how many have multiple abortions.
For fuck's sake, look at black women!
I guess they get raped more, and suffer incest more, and have more health concerns.... my ass.
They are irresponsible, MORE.
You guys, like most topics, have blinders on, that prevent you from seeing truth, and instead leave you entrenched in partisan talking point bullshit land.
Sex Ed, what a joke!
You know what?
I don't care what you ***** ***** ***** ***** , this is goddamned disgusting.
Dowser
Yeah, and Hitler made the trains run on time.
That was Mussolini. Learn some history.
For the record, I am not in favor of abortion-on-demand beyond that, neither do I agree with the blatant hypocrisy of many so-called, self-identified "Pro-Lifers" who simultaneously support the Pro-Gun, Pro-War, Pro-Torture ideologies, who are Anti-God's-Green-Earth (Environmentalism), anti Health Insurance for children and other Human Beings and generally anti-everything that amounts to aiding (secular) humanity if doing so means reaching into their own pockets an ideology which it callously "justifies" by labeling it "the redistribution-of-wealth."
And yes, XXJefferson, I'm back! Are you mocking me, Dude or merely expressing incredulity over the fact that anyone of normal or higher intellect would bother "casting his pearls" before you?
Perhaps not, but it is certainly part of "Pro choice"
I'll say it a third time; if her allegations are true, let there be a formal charge -- an indictment -- with sworn, written testimony and the allegations made UNDER OATH WITH THE PENALTIES FOR PERJURY IN PLAY.
Why haven't the makers of the videos (which would be subpoenaed as material evidence and examined for authenticity, editing, etc.) pursued legal action? I speculate the reason this hasn't transpired to be, that the video-makers have perpetrated a fraud for the purpose of political and ideological agenda advancement.
Let's have the charges placed "on the record" and formally owned by Holly O'Donnell and go from there.
$50.00 wager to the charity of choice that it will not happen
I get the point of those who accept the videos on their face-value rather than repeating the particulars of your indignation, RESPOND TO MY COMMENT.
Particularly WILL YOU STATE HEREIN THAT YOU WANT THE VIDEOS SUBPOENAED AS PART OF A FORMAL INDICTMENT OF PPH, THAT YOU WANT TO SEE SWORN TESTIMONY BY THE MAKERS OF THE VIDEO THAT "NO MANIPULATION HAS BEEN INVOLVED IN EITHER THE MAKING OF OR PRESENTATION OF THOSE VIDEOS," and that, HOLLY O'DONNELL, ET AL PROVIDE THEIR STATEMENTS IN SWORN AFFIDAVITS?
I await response of either "YES" or "NO" to this question from Sean, Joey, XX, 96, etc. .
Own your position here "on the record" so-to-speak.
All I'm saying is that these instances DO occur. I was so sick with pre-eclampsia and on labor stopping drugs, that I was slowly dying-- and letting the labor just happen early was a definite option. Not one I wanted, but a necessary option. Oh, and as more and more women are delaying childbirth until they are older, it is going to become more common. I was 43 when I had my son-- at that time 3% of births were to mothers that were 43 years old. Today that is up to about 6%-- it has more than doubled. The rates for mothers 35-40 years of age have tripled. Older mothers have more complications.
What I don't understand is this: You wish to limit abortions, and I understand that. Abortion shouldn't be a method of birth control, it should be used judiciously and wisely. So, why don't we make birth control free for women? AND for men? Let's insure that everyone has easy access to birth control, and that it is free.
I well remember when insurance companies covered Viagra, but wouldn't cover birth control pills. It was, at the time, $25/month. Then, our state forced the insurance companies to cover birth control pills, and gee, they had a copay of $25. Amazing, isn't it?
And guess what-- having a baby is no piece of cake. Way back when, women's average agelife span was about 28-30 years old, while men's was 40-42. Seeing as how all things are equal, men and women ate the same food, lived in the same conditions, etc., the only difference was that women bore children. Having a child is VERY hard on a woman's body. Some people have no trouble at all, and some women have nothing BUT trouble.
I propose that men, as a whole, refuse to have unprotected sex. You would get a double bonus-- protection from disease, and no responsibility for a child... And what if, a birth control failure, leading to a pregnancy, required the man of the partnership to support the child and the mother, maybe, just maybe, the abortion rate would drop. Maybe more single women would have their babies. And what about the states offering state run day cares, for a nominal fee? That might help as well. It's hard enough to make it on a secretary's salary, without having to pay 1/2 of it to day care.
Maybe if we all worked together, we could reduce, drastically, the need for abortions. But this attitude that women who want an abortion are irresponsible whores has GOT to go. It still takes two to tango, and, if the women are irresponsible whores, the men are irresponsible bastards.
Also, I know of NO ONE that has had an abortion that didn't agonize over the decision. One just doesn't go off blithely, to an abortion clinic, walk in pregnant and walk out not. It is an ordeal that requires a great deal of planning and determination. In our state, you have to watch a video of your baby, and hear the heart beat, and go through a trans-vaginal ultra sound. There is ONE clinic in our state-- otherwise, one goes to the doctor's office.
The women have to brave the protestors on the street, then undergo counseling, then, after 4 hours, the procedure starts. That takes a couple of hours. It isn't a walk in the park, a piece of cake-- it is a gut-wrenching choice, (at least for the women I have known), that stays with one forever.
No one chooses to have an abortion just as a matter of convenience. It is very painful, and the risks of infections, scarring, etc., can be quite daunting. For my friends, who were traumatized by the whole ordeal, it was a nightmare, but a necessary one, if they wished to stay off of welfare and continue to work. So, you want these women to leave the work force and stay home, on welfare?
I certainly agree that sex Ed is a joke. But I'm here to tell you, and I hate to admit that I was so naive, but at 18 years of age, due to the repressed background from which I sprung, I had no idea how it all worked. I knew the body parts, but had no idea how they "fit together".
They do seem to be doing a better job these days, than when I was in school in the 60s and 70s. My stepdaughter had a "baby" that she had to care for, for 6 weeks. After that, she was pretty determined to not have unprotected sex or get pregnant. That baby "went off" every two hours, without fail, and had a clock set for 2 am that started a 4 hour crying fit.
Hello pot, meet the kettle!
I beg to differ about sex ed.
The number of teens having sex in NYC is at an all time low, due to the intense sex ed these kids have in school. We teach them abstinence, about STDs and the consequences of unwanted pregnancies.
Check this out:
A Mac... although what you say is true. What do you think would happen if Holly O'Donnell gave a written sworn statement? I think I know what would happen. The usual suspects would run her through the mill. They would be working 24/7 to find something, anything to discredit her in any way they possibly could from the day she was born. All the Liberal sites would have articles up within hours which they probably already have to discredit her.
Do you think they would perform the same process toward Planned Parenthood? It always stays the same day after day. Those who are against Planned Parenthood's possible criminal activity provide videos edited as all videos are along with the unedited version of those videos and those who are trying to protect Planned Parenthood try to tell everyone don't believe their eyes and ears. Although I agree sworn testimony should be required.
I notice there are no results from any of the Liberal sites when searching the name Holly O'Donnell. I don't know if you are aware of it, but I've become quite aware of silence when it is beneficial to remain silent and plenty of articles from these same sites when it is beneficial to produce them.
I've noticed some at the very top of our government remain completely silent when it benefits their agenda, could benefit the citizens of our nation and speak out when it benefits their agenda and hurts our nation. Most people look on the same sites they always do to get their information and those sites only produce articles when it fits their agenda.
I've also noticed some really get the wringer and some never get vetted or questioned about any possibility of corruption, misdeeds or outright lies. If it weren't for opposing views provided by those so called right wingers just think how much could have been accomplished by now. I could list many. Just think how many lies would have remained unknown to the public. And that works both ways.
As far as abortion is concerned, there is no clear cut answer in my opinion, only guidelines we should adhere to as best we can emphasizing the importance and value of every life in our society to promote a more humanistic future for us.
Would you shut down Planned Parenthood ?
To what purpose?
The people who are trying to discredit PP don't really care about this particular issue (fetal use) as much as they care about ending abortion, period.
Which cannot be done. So we are left with a reckless and irresponsible discussion on the part of those wanting to defund this organization.
Holly O'Donnell and the video-makers are "usual suspects" in their own right, my friend.
Six, When individuals make serious allegations, "mill" or no "mill,"if they proceed with a formal complaint RATHER THAN A POLITICALLY/IDEOLOGICALLY MOTIVATED PUBLIC AIRING, they make their claim more credible.
If all these accusers do is media grandstanding, THEY NEED TO BE CALLED OUT TO MAKE THEIR ALLEGATIONS "ON THE RECORD," rather than in the media. A false allegation is a serious matter it can defame and ruin a reputation merely by allowing it to stand without challenge.
It takes courage to make these charges against PPH, BUT IT TAKES COURAGE ANDINTEGRITYto present so-called "material evidence" for official scrutiny and a legal document with your signature!
Don't give me "through the mill," that's a cop out; "YES" or "NO"
Just for the record, I looked up Holly O'Donnell on the best news sources I could find-- Here are the results--
I also tried CNN, BBC, and Fox. Could it be that, instead of just liberal sites ignoring it, real news sites realize this is a NON-NEWS item, and a hoax? So, all this outrage is over nothing-- or not something that really happened?
Good, Perrie! I'm glad to see that it is getting a lot better!
Of course I agree with that A Mac.
Just for the record you didn't put up any Liberal sites that had any information about Holly O'Donnell as my comment was talking about. Maybe you should read my comment Dowser again to see what I said. Also maybe you should look back and realize Planned Parenthood isn't the only organization which provides help to females. You must have missed my earlier comment. We see what we want on both sides, I suppose. This is from an earlier comment I made which evidently no one saw.
If Planned Parenthood Loses Government Funding, Heres a Map of Health Clinics That Could Take Its Place
Anti-Choice Group Features Former StemExpress Employee in ...
5 Things Media Should Know About The Sixth Attempt To Smear ...
hopelessly partisan
I didn't even bother to look up any others. I've found some only see what they want to see and it is futile to expect to overcome Yuri Bezmenov's explanation of why that is so.
A lot of what you're saying is true, but I'm not one of them, but would you expect complete unbiased advice from a salesman who had a stake in whether you purchased his product or not?
"So they killed the baby."
OK, Holly O'Donnell -- you have alleged that PPH has committed murder!
Sign a sworn affidavit and file a formal complaint and own your allegation!
So far, only Sixpick has had the courage to answer the following
Holly O'Donnell has alleged a MURDER took place; if that in fact happened, I would think those understandably outraged would want all the alleged evidence examined in a formal proceeding. I get the political/ideological rants, now it's time to call for the evidence, not from accusers on YouTube, rather from those accusers in a venue where they will be required to satisfy The Burden of Proof.
Own it boys.
Ok, please tell me what liberal sites you would like me to search, and I will gladly include those in my search.
What other organizations provide help to poor women? We have county health departments, but other than that, I don't know of any.
I will look at your link-- maybe that will help educate me...
I looked up Abortions in Louisville, and found one place. A Woman's Choice, on Market. Listed as one of the worst places to get an abortion, because of the protesters in front of the building. Link .
I looked up free women's health clinics, and found a list of 14 places. Link
We are the largest city in KY, and have a population of 1 million people, approximately 500,000 of them women, and we only have 14 places that offer free services to poor women? Not one of them listed abortions as a service.
Planned Parenthood has 3 locations listed, but two of the three are across the river into Indiana. It would be hard to get there, as there is little bus service between the two states. There are two PP clinics in KY.
Just for jollies, I checked and there are only 3 clinics in the entire state that provide abortions. There were about 30 in the whole state.
I don't know the political leanings of these sites, Six. Do you? Would you consider hopelessly partisan.com to be neutral?
Please, tell me where you want me to look, and I'll gladly do it.
Snopes, however, has an article about it... LINK I've got to go pick up my son from school, I'll be back to read the article later...
Since that link didn't work, maybe this one will--
Link
Fetal Tissue sales are the crux of the matter, according to snopes. While I support stem cell research, (I have a step-daughter with MS), and I realize that the stem cells have to come from somewhere, I do not support gathering that tissue in the manner described by Miss O'Donnell. However, I do wonder if her charges are true. Being unable to verify her story on any other reputable news site, like AP and Reuters, doesn't give me much of a feeling of confidence in her accusations.
While there are those who would stop all abortions, period, and wish to shut down PP, I'm not sure that the problem will go away until society, as a whole, changes its attitude toward women, in general.
It's not just attitude . It's understanding . Women have this awesome power to bring forth life . Neither the law nor men's brains have adapted to that reality .
Obviously, Petey... Well put.