Kerry to Senators on Iran: “Stop Listening to the Israelis” -- Daniel Greenfield 11/14/2013
Despite Obama Incs embarrassing attempt at selling out to Iran, an attempt that was averted only when France staged an intervention, while Iran laughed itself silly, it not only relaxed sanctions on Iran, but is furiously pressing the Senate against sanctions , despite Irans rush to the bomb.
Kerry, fresh from threatening Israel with a Third Intifada and groveling to the Iranians so badly that the French had to step in, took point.
Describing Kerrys testimony before the Senate Banking Committee on Wednesday, Kerry, a Senate aid told BuzzFeed that every time anybody would say anything about what would the Israelis say, theyd get cut off and Kerry would say, You have to ignore what theyre telling you, stop listening to the Israelis on this.
Kerrys closed-door briefing was fairly anti-Israeli, U.S. Sen. Mark Kirk (R-IL) told reporters.
I was supposed to disbelieve everything the Israelis had just told me, and I think the Israelis probably have a pretty good intelligence service, Kirk said.
U.S. Sen. Bob Corker (R-TN) described Kerrys testimony as an emotional appeal. I have to tell you, I was very disappointed in the presentation, Corker said.
Speaking to reporters before the briefing, Kerry said, We now are negotiating [with Iran]. And the risk is that if Congress were to unilaterally move to raise sanctions, it could break faith in those negotiations, and actually stop them and break them apart.
Now remember that Obama spent years claiming that sanctions were the only way to get Iran to negotiate. Iran has trashed the negotiations yet again.
But now suddenly sanctions will destroy the negotiations. Meanwhile Iranian calls for Death to America and simulated missile strikes dont interfere with the negotiations in any way.
Article printed from FrontPage Magazine: http://frontpagemag.com
URL to article: http://frontpagemag.com/2013/dgreenfield/kerry-to-senators-on-iran-stop-listening-to-the-israelis/
Tags
Who is online
155 visitors

To hell with strengthening the bulwarks, the ocean is going to destroy us eventually anyway so it may as well be tomorrow.
Sanctions are a waste of time with Iran, let alone trying to pacify them. The US should turn Tehran into a crater.
Iran has the US, the "great Satan,"in its sights as well as Israel. Don't you know this?
Why is Obama suddenly shifting to Iran's, Russia's and China's side, reversing himself as he did with ACA?
First he said that the sanctions are working. Now he is about to reduce them.
It will not benefit the homeless to be nuked.
"All optionsare on the table" goes the way of "You can keep your insurance and doctor; period," "I have Israel's back,"and the red line on Syria.
Speaking of an uncertain trumpet, this POTUS is worse than uncertain. He isreliably adissembler and liar.
OMG...Kerry is sec of state????!!!!!
O M G !!!!!
He could have been president!
OTOH it is hard to tell whether he could have been worse than O.
i understand he was against iran having the bomb, before he was for it...oh, and something about gengis kahn
Maybe it's just me, but I see some problems with these negotiations. Iran is a regime which for 30 years incites crowds in the tens of thousands every Friday to chant "Death to America" and "Death to Israel". They are also the acknowledged leading financier and supporter of terrorism in the world.
On par with Kerry's feverish pressuring of Israel to negotiate with Palestinians who attempt to kill Israeli civilians on a daily basis and vow there will be no peace until both Israel and the Jews are eliminated.
odly enough, it is our abundance of fossile fuels that the left hates, that plays a huge roll in our ability to inflict sanctions on those in the ME we wish to influence.
odd how the left is always against efficient and clean fossil fuel extraction leading towards energy independance....or is it?
So ... you are in favor of seeing a nuclear war take place in the middle east ?
I've never heard that position adequately explained ...
LOL!
That is great.
Great witticisms here. I wish I was so smart.
Seriously ?
(This is not a personal attack, it is giving advice and directions.)
Once "smiley" Rouhani has wiped Israel off the map, the big Satan, America, is the next target, but Israel comes first, then YOU!!
That's not what the Ayatollah in charge says . But thanks for more ignorant bullshit .
Israel has never threatened to "wipe Iran off the map". Israel only wants to defend itself by taking out the means by which Iran would carry out IT'S threat to wipe Israel off the map and to get rid of what they called a "cancer". The Iranian people shout "Death to Israel, Death to America", but have you ever seen any news that says Israelis go out in a mob to shout "Death to Iran" and burn the Iranian flag? Come on, JFT, wake up and smell the roses. I know that's hard to do when you've been poisoned by the Palestinian propaganda.
Could the WTC be levelled by terrorists? Could a terrorist, such as a Hezbollah militant (proxy for Iran) sneak a nuclear device into the USA and cause considerable devestation? Could a couple of pressure cooker bombs close down a city?
Okay, flameaway, maybe you have nothing to worry about. but Israel does, although you may not give a damn about another Hiroshima.
Huh ? Israelis bought the land they are on from previous owners . In the middle of the multiple world wars which affected that region there were no "official owners" anyway . The British granted that region to both the Hashemites and the Israelites but short changed Israel in the amount of land . Learn some farging history before you spout off your inane ignorant crap !
Why ? They were attacked . They won . They even returned some of the land . The deal was called the Camp David accords . History ... study some .
Whatever are you referring to ? Israel fights her own wars .
So ... you believe terrorists when they claim motives in English ? You are extremely naive . BTW why don't you post a link to demonstrate that crap you call facts ... Since you didn't put in your usual "!" mark I guess you lack the passionate belief in that particular BS .
At the same time Israel has discovered very large natural gas deposits off their shores. They are in developement and will be a real exporter. That also changes the balance of things, and hastens the sheiks.
The left has a lot of environmental wackos who fear great damage from oil drilling, fracking, nuclear power, etc.
There has been damage caused by these things but they are manageable.
They are silent at reports of eagles and bats being shredded by wind turbine blades or the spoiling of thousands of acres of land and sea by wind farms.
The actor, Judd Hirsch wants to build a 170-foot wind turbine on his property for personal use. The town is in an uproar over it and justifiably so. It will cost him $140,000 and he says it will reduce his electricity bill to zero. He will not live nearly long enough to break even.
He says one tower can do no harm. but what if all the other townspeople erected towers also?
Promises, promises. Do you mean like red lines?
Even NewsVine would not have considered it inappropriate (many times it was allowed to stand) - it was not a personal attack, it was advice and directions, besides the fact that it was an appropriate response to "Fuck 'em both."
The land will never be returned. That shouldnt even be part of the bargaining table. It's sort of like saying that Texas, Arizona, and New Mexico should be returned to Mexico because it was once theirs. The reality is territories are constantly shifting, being conquered, etc...and if we start returning land to original "owners", where do we stop? Because, at some point, every piece of land everywhere is currently in the hands of somebody other than who held it initially.
I'm sure it occurs to people. It just doesnt matter. As long as there have been and will continue to be people, lands will continue to change hands, and it will almost never be consensual. To hang your (general) hat on that seems like a waste. Besides, there was a war and Israel won that war. The spoils go to the victor. They also purchased a fair amount of that land. Plus, Palestinians and such also took that land from somebody else at some point. Which was my initial point anyway....that land always ends up changing hands at some point. Even though it is presented as an issue as far as so called Israeli occupation is concerned, the reality is it's a red herring. The real issue has been and continues to be blatant racism on both sides of the conflict and a lack of desire to move beyond that. So, rather than say "We hate all Jews" or "We hate all Muslims", instead we get occupation and terrorism as the issues du jour and the attendant rationalizations for a complete lack of moral standing on both sides. How lovely that is.
Not really. I think hanging on to the land argument is silly.
I dont actually disagree that it would be nice to stop taking land. It is however completely unrealistic. The real issue continues to be race and religion. I'd say it is the adherence to race and the waste of time known as organized religion that should be ended permanently. I guarantee there would be no issues between Israel and the various Muslim nations then.
JFT
Comment removed for CoC violation [ph]
You don't know what you are talking about with your insulting unproven slanders.
I've participated on this article taking me out of the moderation equation, but calling somebody an anti semite is a clear COC violation. Nothing regarding JFT has been proven, contrary to your claims here. Please kindly remove your post and actually debate the merit of posts rather than making personal attacks on the posters Len.
Flame ,
You make it sound as if Israel has a lot of land . You really need to get some geographical perspective . So here it is . The green is Muslim dominated . That tiny red sliver is Israel :
Hard to see , isn't it ?!
Flameaway,
In antisymmetrical warfare, Iran would not bomb the US directly. Hizbollah has already infiltrated through Mexico and they could set off untraceable suitcase nuclear weapons.
...
Also, untraceable Iranian submarines could launch nuclear weapons that first create a stratospheric explosion that wipes out all our communications. This is called an electromagnetic (EM) pulse. Then we would be sitting ducks for direct strikes from those subs.
Iran has, or is developing, all of that.
JFT and Flameaway,
Israel's previous owners were the British, and before WW1, the Ottoman Empire.
"There are no Palestinians"
By Larry Miller
The Weekly Standard | April 21, 2003
The accords leads to March 1979 Israel-Egypt Peace Treaty, breaking a 30-year refusal to negotiate with Israel face-to-face, Egypt became the first Arab state to make peace with Israel . The terms of the treaty called for negotiations for Palestinian self-rule that would lead to a just, comprehensive and durable settlement based on UN Resolution 242 (withdrawal from Territories to secure and recognized borders). 31
Arab Response: Rejection
You laugh at the only actually peace treaty in that region ? You are not at all interested in peace then . Thanks for confirming that .
You keep saying this without a shred ofproof. Only Iran has threatened to obliterate Israel; not the other way around.
If you know anything about Jews, you would know that their humanity is extraordinary.
The Arabs have boasted that they will defeat Israel because, while Israel values life, the Arabs value death.
Golda Meir said: " Peace will come when the Arabs will love their children more than they hate us.
You are quite the humorist ! That wasn't a serious statement , right ?
>>the Israeli government feed right into them with their continued settlement building in the occupied territories.
Those territories are disputed, not "occupied."
THE MYTH OF THE "OCCUPIED" TERRITORIES: SETTING THE RECORD STRAIGHT
The following article was written by Professor Beres in June 1992.
Excerpts:
Actually the Grand Mufti commanded the Arab residents to leave in order to avoid being slaughtered when the Arab states attacked . The few Arabs who stayed behind are now Israeli citizens . Interesting citizenship selection process !
BTW an ignorance of middle eastern history does not get you a pass here . If OTOH you can post info proving your points you might have a leg to stand on ... but you won't and need an intellectual wheelchair .
The undisputed facts are that:
>>Israel has struck first numerous times in Iraq in the old days and still today in Lebanon. The Israelis of today are a warlike people with a warlike right wing government.
Israel's only strikeagainst Iraq was to destroy its nuclear bomb facility in 1981. During the first US/Iraq war, Iraq fired many Scud missiles at Israel but Israel did not retaliate.
The IsraeliLebanese conflict describes a series of related military clashes involving Israel , Lebanon , and Syria , as well as various non-state militias acting from within Lebanon.
"Hard to see , isn't it ?!"
It's not hard to see, Petey, it's just hard for Muslims and their supporters to accept reality, especially the fact that the tiny sliver of land ISN'T Muslim controlled.
Eugene Rostow a US diplomat, formerly dean ofHarvard Law School,who helped frame Resolution 242 wrote:
I have asked Bob Nelson to post his series here about the ME. He is probably the most knowledgeable person I have ever met on the subject and I think that there is so much disinformation out there, that his will be quite insightful. I hope that he takes me up on the invite.
Who is Nelson? I have never seen him post here.
Hi Len,
He has posted here many times before, and you have met him on occasion. He wrote an excellent series on Israel and the ME, and those like Larry and others who knew him at NV, they would tell you that probably no one knows the history of the ME like he does.
You might even learn some history of the region [if you take his info seriously] . But judging what you said previously it seems unlikely :
Opinions are a dime a dozenbut are robust when backed up with evidence.
It is not required IF you state that what you say is an opinion . In your case your ignorance of the region is wide & deep . That is not a problem in itself . But when you get loud & stupid about your ignorance expect to be put in your place ...
"My mind's made up. Don't bother me with facts." (JFT)
How do you negotiate a two-state solution when one of the parties wants a single state and will avoid negotiation and conduct jihad till they get it????
Here are the relevant sections of the Hamas charter:
His opinions are not backed up by anything but his inflated self perception [due to drugs & therapy ] .
Israel said to be working with Saudi Arabia on Iran strike plan
Riyadh reported to give Jerusalem okay to use Saudi airspace and to cooperate on other tactical support, according to Sunday Times
According to the Sunday Times, Riyadh has agreed to let Israel use its airspace in a military strike on Iran and cooperate over the use of rescue helicopters, tanker planes and drones.
The Saudis are furious and are willing to give Israel all the help it needs, an unnamed diplomatic source told the paper.
More at:
flameaway: Do you think Israel has not tried to make peace with its enemies. Israel makes concessions such as releasing from their prisons terrorists with blood on their hands (they were glorified by the PA), walked away from Gaza, put a moratorium on settlement building for 11 months to get the Palestinians to negotiate (at the 11th hour the PA, that refused to negotiate until then woke up and demanded an extention). Olmert offered Arafat 97% of his demands and Arafat walked away. Now let's consider Turkey, that mounted a flotilla designed to break through Israel's LEGAL (as determined by the UN) blockade, demanded an apology from Israel, got one and then made a pile of further demands. (That, by the way, is what Iran is going to do - it's in their nature.)
Notwithstanding anything Israel does, and I've been there twice and I know how the Israelis feel, their enemies want no part of peace. By the way, have you ever been there or are you just an arm-chair critic?
JFT please direct me to actual law that the settlements are illegal. HItler was right that if you scream "illegal" and "Illegitimate" loud enough and long enough people will start to believe this. Give me a link to a court judgment or proof that they are contrary to any law or treaty to which Israel is bound. Just because the UN or the USA or anyone else SAYS so, is not good enough.
However, on the other side of the coin, here is some pretty good evidence from a legal expert that in fact the settlements are neither illegal or illegitimate. Read and learn.
...
So maybe the Palestinians should get the hell out of the lands that THEY occupy illegally.
I asked Bob to do so months ago. It's about time some people got educated with what is real rather than what is propaganda. If Bob doesn't post them to clear the air, perhaps Krisha has them saved and can post them.
Although Bob was a member here, unless he is registered under a nom de plume he does not seem to be a member any more.
Artificial homeland? What's YOUR artificial homeland? Give the 13 Colonies back to Great Britain. Control and ownership changes many times for many reasons, so why is Israel different than any other nation? If you follow the actual history starting with the Balfour Declaration, the San Remo accords, the League of Nations, the UN, (forgetting the more ancient history) you may as well declare that every nation is illegal. English colonists displaced the aborigines in Australia and New Zealand, the French and Brits displaced the North American natives, and on and on. So tell everyone to go back to where they started, and then maybe everybody will be standing on top of each other somewhere in Africa. I think you have to accept the existing situation.
Well, if they can build a moon rocket then they'll put a nuke right up your tush.
Think about this. Israel has the capability to annihilate its Muslim neighbours - but why doesn't it do so? If the Muslim neighbours had the wherewithall to annihilate the Israelis, then as they have vowed and threatened to do, why the hell don't they? Maybe the boast (which you deny existed) that the Muslims believe in dying as martyrs whereas the Israelis (and Jews generally) believe that life is sacred could be the reason? But hey, go and promote the Palestinian cause. Send them a donation - it will most likely end up in a Swiss bank account. Get on a boat and try to break the LEGAL blockade. I don't give a shit.
He doesmake them available on his blog...
...along with a big number of other good pieces (for a self-described bleedin'-heart Liberal
).
Flame at :
Jews were in that territory for thousands of years . There is nothing artificial about their being there . But your "argument" is !
Jews were conquered by the Romans quite a long time ago . Until then they had a legitimate homeland pretty much where Israel is today . There have been a series of conquerors of that entire region for centuries including the Ottomans . Want to see a quick video of that history ? No ? Who cares ! Here it is anyway :
Muslims are always pissed off , if not at the Jews then at each other . Saying they are pissed off is foolish and redundant . Might there be a "better" location for the Jewish homeland ? I'm sure its possible BUT there would be NO HISTORICAL PRECEDENT for it . The British pretty much settled the location anyway so all of your "arguments" are non-sequiters .
You called my map silly . Just because your main gestalt involves being silly does NOT mean you can apply that to everything you encounter . Look at the video for "maps of war" above . It will make your reference to the Ottoman "Empire" appear silly ...
I can tell you've never spent a day in energy production.
There is no such thing as "clean fossil fuel extraction" JoAnne.
Perrie is correct about Bob's knowledge base on the ME. What is even better is that he knows how to condense it down and communicate it so most of us can get our heads around it's many facets.
Some of it is relatively clean ...
Good to see those posted here, Larry. Nice promotion for Bob's blog, too!
Subs don't battle. Our anti-sub sonartechnology would be effective.
But in asymmetrical warfare subs and infiltrators can accomplish lots by stealth.
Muslims should not have been able to destroy the WTC but they did. You can be sure Iran is planning surprises.
Perhaps those who decry the right of the Jews to a homeland in Israel will read Bob's history of the region, which is well documented and supported, rather than wallowing in Palestinian propaganda.
Ah yes, but unless France stays strong and stands up for the safety of civilization, they will, flameaway, they will.
Some can only see a pixel. Some can see the picture made up of millions of pixels.
Hi PJ,
You generally write sensible notes but I beg to differ with this:
Surely you have heard of Hezbollah. You must be aware of their worldwide terrorist acts from Buenos Aires to a US Army barracks in Lebanon to Bulgaria to Kenya.
Hezbollah is the foreign terror arm of Iran.
Yuri Bezmenov, ex-KGB agent said those who have been completely brainwashed can be carried to the gulags and they will completely deny they ever existed.
Flame ,
It seems that your main argument centers on the past existence of the Ottoman empire . So you choose to tremble in fear over a long defeated set of tyrants ? They lost . They learned from the west about democracy and non-religious governance . Remember K. Attaturk ? Where is your recognition of more recent history ... Is it cowering in fear ?
No . They were defeated by the Romans ... as were the Muslims . Get your historical facts straight at least ... Geez !
There are Muslims living in Israel but no Jews living in Palestine. Wonder why? And what about Christians? There are Christians living in Israel. What about Palestine? For that matter where are the Muslims being persecuted? And where are the Jews and Christians being persecuted? Gedit?
Randy,
Even if you only go back to the time of Jesus, (2,000 years ago), there were no Muslims. Islam is only 1,500 years old. And Jews go back much further than that in the region.
Thank you very much for posting these Larry.
Only the morally bankrupt could support the Palestinians. I despise them. For more than 90 years they have repeatedly proven themselves to be lazy, whining, genocidal welfare queens. My disdain for the so-called "Palestinians" even exceeds the hatred shown them by their brother Arabs. No Arab state gives them citizenship or equal rights. Eqypt controlled Gaza as a military occupied land from 1948-1967 when they easily could have annexed it. King Hussein of Jordan killed thousands of them in 1970 after they tried to overthrow him. The PLO then filtered into Lebanon where they instigated the civil war which lasted 15 years and destroyed a once peaceful and prosperous nation. Kuwait expelled 200,000 Palestinian workers after the Gulf War in 1991. They had shown their gratitude for employment and a better life by siding with the invader of Kuwait, Saddam Hussein.
In addition to being treacherous parasites, they are incredibly stupid. Instead of sitting down with Israel, negotiating the best deal they can, and begin working for the future of their children, they teach hatred to those children and instill dreams in them that someday Israel will be wiped out and the land free of Jews. Until they renounce terrorism and recognize the fact that Israel is not going away, let them wallow in their misery. The miserable bastards won't ever get an iota of sympathy from me.
And ? They still are . Read the Bob Nelson series :
...
The Arabs were given the majority of the land mandated to the Jews under the Balfour declaration . In factthe Jews should have been granted a lot more of the land that is now called Jordan . You don't hear them pissing & moaning about that ... But you do hear US liberals whining about a few minor settlements inside a disputed territory ...
If you want to trouble yourself about injustice learn about the Jews who were kicked out of their ancestral homes throughout the entire middle east . There were approx 1 million of those refugees . They of course ended up in Israel . So if you want to talk about financial compensation ... what about the so-called Jewish Nakba ?
Randy,
There has never been a time that Jews were not there. Countries may come and go. Those are man made entities. The question was, were they always there. The answer is yes.
And if this was a popularity contest, many countries would lose.
BTW, no where did I see you comment on the Bob Nelson article I posted.
The Palestinians incessantly moan about returning to their homeland. It is simply another lie in their nearly century-long propaganda war. The fact is when the British Mandate took over from the Ottomans after WWI virtually all of the land was government owned. Jews owned about 8% of the privately held land. Palestinian Arabs owned about 6%. Over the next two decades, the rich Arab families sold much of their land to Jews at exorbitant prices. Even though strictly limited by the British authorities, the immigrating Zionists proceeded to build roads, schools, electricity, and develop agriculture in the swamps and desert lands. So successful were they that nearly 1 million Arabs eagerly moved there to take advantage of the economic opportunities initiated by the Zionists. Except for a few massacres instigated by the Grand Mufti (uncle of Egyptian born arch-terrorist Yassir Arafat) in the 20's and 30's, the land was gradually developing and modernizing to the benefit of both Jews and Arabs.
The Jews have proven themselves worthy of the "gift" of part of their historical homeland. Despite over 60 years of constant attack by their Muslim Arab neighbors they have managed to build a vibrant economy and the only true democracy in the whole region. Since the inception of the tiny State of Israel they have earned 7600 patents which have benefited the world. The 300 million Arabs, even with their trillions in petrodollars, have gotten about 700 patents in that time. Hebrew University is ranked no. 21 in the world in computer science (ahead of Cambridge and Yale), while there is no university in the Muslim world ranked in the world's top 500.
You need to read the articles.
There was many an attempt to get along by the Jews and Christians who lived there, long before WWII. The Muslims wanted no part of it.
They may have been living there but they had not made themselves into a country . By contrast the Jews quickly organized themselves into a cohesive unit and became a country .
The Arabs who did live there were ordered to leave when Israel was declared a country so as to not be slaughtered by invading Arab troops . The ones who stayed on became Israeli citizens . As to the ones who left ...tough noogies !
What, in your not so humble opinion, makes you think the Israelis would want to get rid of Iran? What are you imagining would be their motive?
But the Palestinians do get moola from you. Some of the money you pay in taxes supports financial aid sent to the PA by the USA, and as well the USA is one of the supporters of UNRWA, the UN body that sends pogey to the Palestinians who were "refugees" and their children and their grandchildren and their great-grandchildren (until UNRWA bankrupts every nation that supports them). The EU recently discovered that the billions of dollars in aid that they sent to the Palestinians has ended up in a few Swiss numbered accounts.
The aid that the USA sends to Israel is for military aid (since Israel is supported by a whole lot of nations that want to wipe them off the face of the earth) but most of that aid is used to purchase military equipment from America, helping to keep a lot of people in their jobs, or can also be used for joint (USA and Israel) development and research for sophisticated new military equipment, such as the Iron Shield.
And interestingly enough, the Arabs who are Israeli citizens have been polled and the vast majority of them would rather live in Israel than in ANY Arab country. Don't you wonder why?
Wow!!! Is it ever great that "Krish has returned". You've really been missed.
Nope.
Wrong again!
Flame,
You are ignoring two factors; how Islam, which began in theseventh century, conquered all that land and Jewish history there. I will cover Islam first and Jewish history in another message.
Islamic imperialism began early in the seventh century by Muhammad himself.
He ordered at least 60 raids and wars, often involving massacres, and personally participated in 27 of them. Muhammad massacred, beheaded, tortured, terrorized, raped, and looted in the name of God. Described below are three of his massacres and a partial listing of his sex-slaves from the Muslim holy books and Islamic writings.
I see your thesis thatPalestine had been Muslim before Israel. But Jews blanketed the Middle East before the Muslim conquests; those Muslims your heart bleeds for.
Over the following centuries Muslims conducted long wars involving the Europeans, the Moors in Spain, the Tartars in Russia and the Turks in Europe. But in the Muslim world, they do not describe encounters in these terms. They never use the words "Arab" or "Moors" or "Tartars" or "Turks" in this context. The division is always the wars between the Muslims and the unbelievers.
Jump to the Ottoman conquest of Constantinople: While Mehmet ll was shelling the citys walls, the inhabitants took refuge in the cathedral of St. Sophia and began to sing psalms. The Ottoman troops who, beating their drums, stepped over the walls breaches, and overwhelmed the defenders, hacked them to death. They burst into the cathedral and beheaded even newborn babies. They amused themselves by snuffing out the candles with the little severed heads. The massacre lasted from dawn to the afternoon.
Meanwhile the city burned, the soldiers crucified, hung and impaled, the Janissaries raped and butchered 4,000 nuns in a few hoursand chained the survivors to be sold as slaves.
The servants prepared the victory feast during which Mehmet ll got drunk (in defiance of Sharia) and, having a soft spot for young boys, sent for the firstborn of the Greek Orthodox Grand Duke Notaras; a handsome 14-year old. Before everyone he raped the boy and, afterwards, sent for his family; parents, grandparents, uncles, aunts and cousins. In front of the boy he beheaded them, one by one.
That is how Constantinople became Istanbul.
Those Jews and Christians whom the Muslims do not murder become dhimmis. History shows that when Muslims gain ascendency they quickly stamp out religious freedom at worst, as in Saudi Arabia, or severely restrict it with dhimmitude. A dhimmi is a Christian or Jew who is protected but subjected to punishing legal restrictions on both his personal and religious freedom as well as being subject to extraordinary taxes.
The House of Islam (peace), dar al-Islam, includes those nations that have submitted to Islamic rule, to the soul crushing, liberty-condemning, discriminatory Islamic law of Sharia. The rest of the world in in the House of War, dar al-harb, because it does not submit to Sharia. No non-Muslim state or its citizens are innocent. The Christian, Jewish, Coptic, Hindu and Zoroastrian peoples of world have suffered under subjugation for centuries. Dhimmis are forbidden to construct houses of worship or repair existing ones, are economically crippled by the heavy jizya (tax), socially humiliated, legally discriminated against, criminally targeted and generally kept in a permanent state of weakness, fear and vulnerability by Islamic governments.
Flame,
Here is the second part on ME history. The first was on Islamic Imperialism. This is about Arab and Jewish population in Palestine.
Zionists did start showing up in droves in 1871. However, they moved into land purchased for ten times the price of black American farmland. No reputable person even accused Jews of stealing land before the Arab refugees fled after the UN partition.
The Palestinian population went up and down over the centuries. There were seven million Jews in the Roman Empire in 70 CE when Jewish independence ended, according to Josephus, and there were 3 million 60 years later when large numbers were either killed, fled, or were deported after a revolt. While there were about 200,000 people in Palestine (including what is now Jordan) in 1785, by the mid 1800s this had been reduced to 50-100,000 as a result of drought and Bedouin raids.
In the mid 1700s British archaeologist Thomas Shaw wrote that the land in Palestine was "lacking in people to till its fertile soil." Also in the Eighteenth century, French author and historian, Count Volney, wrote of Palestine as the "ruined" and "desolate" land. "Many parts --- lost almost all their peasantry. In others --- the recession was great but not so total. --- upwards of 3200 villages were reckoned; but at present, the collector can scarcely find 400. --- Our merchants have themselves seen the greater part of the environs become depopulated. The traveler meets with nothing but houses in ruins, cisterns rendered useless, and fields abandoned. Those who cultivated them have fled."
In 1817-18 travelers reported that there was not "a single boat of any description on the lake [Tiberias.] in an 1827 German encyclopedia Palestine was depicted as "desolate and roamed through by Arab bands of robbers." In 1840 a traveler wrote that the once populated area between Hebron and Bethlehem was now "abandoned and desolate" with dilapidated towns. The "masses" of Jerusalem were estimated at less than 15,000, of whom more than half were Jews.
In 1843, A. Kieth wrote in "The Land of Israel," that, in Volney's day, "The land had not fully reached its last prophetic degree of desolution and depopulation."
The British Counsel reported in 1857 that "The country is in a considerable degree empty of inhabitants and therefore ITS GREATEST NEED IS THAT OF A BODY OF POPULATION."
In the 1860s it was reported that "depopulation is even now advancing." At the same time H. B. Tristram noted in his journal that: "The north and south of the [Sharon plain] land is going out of cultivation and whole villages are rapidly disappearing from the face of the earth. Since 1838 no less than 20 villages have been erased from the map [by marauding Bedouin] and the stationary population extirpated."
When Mark Twain toured Palestine in 1867 he wrote the following:
"Stirring scenes --- occur in the valley [Jezreel] no more. There is not a solitary village throughout its whole extent -- not for 30 miles in either direction. There are two or three small clusters of Bedouin tents, but not a single permanent habitation. One may ride ten miles hereabouts and not see ten humans.---- We reached Tabor safely--- we never saw a human being on the whole route. Nazarath is forlorn. --- Jericho the accursed lies a moldering ruin today... 'Peace on earth, good will towards men' is untenanted by any living creature.--- Bethsaida and Chorzin have vanished from the earth, and the 'desert places' around them, where thousands once listened to the Savior's voice --- sleep in the hush of a solitude that is inhabited only by birds of prey and skulking foxes."
While there was always a Jewish presence in the cities, European Jews began coming in a small but steady stream in the 1870s-80s. This is called the First Aliyah. They settled largely in Western Palestine, along the Mediterranean coast north of Jerusalem roughly between Jaffa and Haifa, and along the West bank of the Jordan north of what is now called the West Bank territory. This aliyah was followed by several others; the Second Aliyah from 1907 to 1917, the Third after the war, and the Fourth following 1924-5 which followed the closing of America to Eastern European Jews.
Just as now, where neighboring Arabs are largely dependent for work on Israeli employers, so was the situation always.
Who has heard of Jews seeking employment in Ramallah, Nablus or Bethlehem? As Jews cleared swamps and reclaimed land, and later as they built industry, Neighboring impoverished Arabs came to work from both within Palestine and from neighboring countries; Syria, Lebanon, Egypt, etc. When they had work at all in their place of origin, they were felahin, tenant farmers that worked for effindis, large landowners.
There were not enough workers for the labor-intensive tasks among the Jews. Under the British mandate, however, only Jewish immigrants were kept careful track of.
The significant point about the new Gentile arrivals is that they were headed to the same place as the Jewish immigrants -- to seek work. Quoting Dr. John Voss, Chairman of the American Christian Palestine committee in 1953:
"The Arab population of Palestine was small and limited until Jewish resettlement restored the barren lands and drew to it Arabs from neighboring countries."
There is more of the same in later years. There was large-scale immigration of both Jews and Arabs. Winston Churchill said in 1939, "So far from being persecuted, the Arabs have crowded into the country and multiplied till their population has increased more than even all world Jewry could lift up the Jewish population." [Martin Gilbert, Churchill, vol. 5, p. 1072.]
And Franklin D. Roosevelt said: Arab immigration into Palestine since 1921 has vastly exceeded the total Jewish immigration during this whole period.
The point is that, while in some areas population was predominantly Arab, in other areas Jewish population was considerable. This was considered in forming the borders when the UN recommended partition in 1947.
Flame,
Part 3, adding to Jewish Palestine history:
Where does Jerusalem fit in Islam and Muslim history? It is not the direction in which they pray, is not once mentioned by name in Muslim prayers, and it is connected to no mundane events in Muhammad's life. The city never served as capital of a sovereign Muslim state, and it never became a cultural or scholarly center. Little of political import by Muslims was initiated there.
The implication that Jews returned after being away 2000 years to expel indigenous peoples is a fabrication of radical Arab/Muslim propaganda.
There was no active movement to form a unique Palestinian state prior to 1967. In 1956, Ahmad Shuqairy, who would found the PLO eight years later, told the UN Security Council: "it is common knowledge that Palestine is nothing but southern Syria." In the early 1960s, many Palestinians looked to Egypt's Abdul Nasser as their leader as much as to any Palestinian.
The Jewish connection to Jerusalem is an ancient and powerful one. Judaism made Jerusalem a holy city over three thousand years ago and through all that time Jews remained steadfast to it.
Jerusalem appears in the Jewish Bible 669 times and Zion (which usually means Jerusalem, sometimes the Land of Israel) 154 times, or 823 times in all. The Christian Bible mentions Jerusalem 154 times and Zion 7 times. In contrast Jerusalem and Zion appear as frequently in the Qur'an as they do in the Hindu Bhagavad-Gita, the Taoist Tao-Te Ching, the Buddhist Dhamapada and the Zoroastrian Zend Avestawhich is to say, not once.
Jews pray in its direction, mention its name constantly in prayers, close the Passover service with the wistful statement "Next year in Jerusalem," and recall the city in the Grace blessing at the end of each meal.
The destruction of the Temple looms very large in Jewish consciousness; remembrance takes such forms as a special day of mourning, houses left partially unfinished, a woman's makeup or jewelry left incomplete, and a glass smashed during the wedding ceremony.
In addition, Jerusalem has had a prominent historical role, is the only capital of a Jewish state, and is the only city with a Jewish majority during the whole of the past century. Jerusalem represents the purist expression of all that Jews prayed for, dreamed of, cried for, and died for in the two thousand years since the destruction of the Second Temple.
The Romans changed the name of Jerusalem to Aelia Capotolina, and Judea to Syria Palestina, after the failed Jewish revolt of 135 CE, a revolt in which over a half million Jews were killed and almost a thousand villages destroyed. Even after this disaster many Jews remained, redeemed slaves and refugees returned. Religious schools were set up, the Jerusalem Talmud was compiled in 400 CE.
Even after the destruction of the last Jewish commonwealth in the first century, the Jewish people maintained their own autonomous political and legal institutions: the Davidic dynasty was preserved in Baghdad until the thirteenth century through the rule of the Exilarch (Resh Galuta).
During this period, the Jewish national center shifted from Judea to the Galilee, where hundreds of synagogues were erected from the Mediterranean to the Golan Heights. Jewish law was there codified in the Mishnah by Judah Ha-Nasi. Despite the catastrophic losses in Jewish lives during the wars against the Romans, Jews still constituted the majority of the population of the Galilee in the fourth century. In the Upper Galilee village of Pek'in there remained a continuous Jewish presence from the Roman era to the rise of the State of Israel.
In 135 CE Jews took part in the Bar Kochba revolt against imperial Rome and even re-established their capital in Jerusalem. Defeated by the most brutal of the Roman legions under the command of the emperor Hadrian, Jews were forbidden to reside in Jerusalem for nearly five hundred years. Once a year on the ninth of the Hebrew month of Av, they were allowed to weep at the remains of their destroyed Temple at a spot that came to be called "the Wailing Wall." In the meantime, the Roman authorities renamed Judea as Palestina in order to obliterate the memory of Jewish nationhood.
According to the meager sources, there were 43 Jewish communities in Sixth-century Palestine; twelve town on the coast, the Negev, and east of the Jordan, and 31 villages in the Galilee and Jordan valley. In 351 the Jews again revolted against Rome without success. In 438 Empress Eudocia removed the ban on Jews praying at the Temple site. With hope of restoration, Jews allied with the Persians, when the latter invaded Palestine in 614, against the Byzantines.
With the defeat of the Eastern Roman Empire (Byzantine) by Persian armies in 614, the Jewish people recaptured Jerusalem and made it again their capital briefly. Yet Byzantine rule was soon restored and Jews were forced again to vacate Jerusalem until the defeat of the Byzantines in 638 by the Islamic armies of Caliph Omar, who again opened the city for Jewish resettlement. Eretz Israel became a part of successive Muslim empires - the Rashidun (the immediate followers of the Prophet Muhammad, who ruled from Medina), the Umayyads (who ruled from Damascus), the Abbasids (who ruled from Baghdad), and the Fatimids (who ruled from Cairo).
By 640 Palestine was Muslim, first under the Arab Omayyads of Damascus, then under the Abbasid dynasty (mainly Turkish), and finally under the Fatimids from Cairo. Then the Crusaders came for about 200 years. The Muslims took the Jewish lands and later the Crusaders massacred the Jews (who fought with the Muslims to defend Jerusalem). After the city's fall the Crusaders gathered the Jews in a synagogue and burned them. Jews also fought the Crusaders in Haifa, holding out for a month.
Even after all this, in the Eleventh century, there were Jewish communities in Jerusalem, Tiberias, Ramleh, Ashkelon, Caeserea and Gaza. The Arab geographer Abu Abdallah Mohammed, in the Tenth century, describes Jews as assayers of coins, dyers, tanners and bankers. Under the tolerant Fatimids, Jews served in their regime. At this time Jews in Tiberias evolved their vowel-pointing system so the pronunciation of Hebrew words would be passed from generation to generation. A large number of poems and religious literary works originated.
Under Islam, Jews were to be protected as a "people of the book," but were nonetheless forced to pay discriminatory taxes like the jizya (poll tax) and the kharaj (land tax). The crushing burden of these land taxes led to a loss of Jewish land control in the Galilee during the first several centuries of Islamic rule. During the Crusader occupation of Eretz Israel, many Jews were physically slaughtered, especially in Jerusalem. Nevertheless, the great Jewish scholar and poet Rabbi Yehuda Halevi (1075-1141) still called for the mass immigration of Jews to the Land of Israel.
The beginnings of Jewish recovery in Eretz Israel started with the defeat and expulsion of the Crusaders in 1187 by the Kurdish Muslim warrior Salah ad-Din who, like Caliph Omar, allowed the Jews to resettle in Jerusalem. For example, between 1209 and 1211, three hundred rabbis made their way from France and southern England to settle in Jerusalem, once it was safe again to do so. They were joined by rabbis from North Africa and Egypt. The great Jewish scholar Nachmanides (Ramban) erected a synagogue in Jerusalem in 1267 that still stands in the Old City.
In the thirteenth century, Jewish families restored the community of Safed, which would become the international center for the study of Jewish mysticism by the sixteenth century. Reinforced by their rising numbers, Jews became assertive again about their claim in Jerusalem, so that the pope forbade sea captains from transporting Jews to Palestine in 1428. Despite the hardships, Jews continued to return. The great commentator of the Mishnah, Ovadia Bartinura, left Italy to settle in Jerusalem in 1488; his tomb is at the foot of the Mt. of Olives.
The influx of Jewish refugees from the Spanish Inquisition in 1492 into the Ottoman Empire, which took control of Eretz Israel in 1517, led to a substantial expansion of the Jewish presence in Safed, Hebron, and Tiberias, where Sultan Sulaiman the Magnificent allotted his Portugese Jewish advisor, Don Joseph Nasi, land grants for Jewish resettlement. Even before the rise of modern political Zionism, Jews continued to stream into the land from Yemen and Lithuania, whose numbers included the students of the halakhic scholar the Vilna Gaon in 1809-1811. By 1864, a clear-cut Jewish majority emerged in Jerusalem, more than half a century before the arrival of the British Empire, the issuing of the Balfour Declaration, and the establishment of the League of Nations Mandate.
After the Crusaders the Kharezmians and Mongols wreaked destruction on the Jews. They were in turn defeated by the Mamluks. By 1267, there was still a Jewish community when the famous Rabbi ben Nachman (Nachmanides) settled in Jerusalem. A Jewish community remained in the Old City till it was driven out by the British led Arab Legion from Transjordan almost 700 years later.
All the above is just the tip of the iceberg of continuous Jewish residence in Palestine, and continuous immigration of those who returned to the land their ancestors left. While modern Zionism began in 1882, the movement to the land had never ended.
Hundreds of place names of villages and sites are Arabic versions or translations of ancient biblical or Talmudic names.
Israel is the only state that was created in the last century whose legitimacy was recognized by both the League of Nations and the United Nations. The League Mandate that was issued by the victorious powers of World War I did not create the rights of the Jewish people to a national home in Palestine, but rather recognized a pre-existing right, for the links of the Jewish people to their historic land were well-known and accepted in the previous century by world leaders from President John Adams to Napoleon Bonaparte to British Foreign Secretary Lord Palmerston. These rights were preserved by the successor organization to the League of Nations, the United Nations, under Article 80 of the UN Charter. The ancient, even biblical, association of the Jewish people with the Land of Israel was accepted in the Judeo-Christian tradition as a historical axiom.
Given the historical background, it is impossible to argue that the Palestinians have a claim to the Land of Israel superior to that of the Jews.
I am also familiar with history of the region. Bob did a good job but omitted many salient details of how the region came to be. Let me recommend another fine source that fills in missing pieces as well as treating many more topics:
Where does Jerusalem fit in Islam and Muslim history? Well, the following video sheds some light on this fascinating query!
Mordechai Kedar is an Israeli scholar of Arabic literature who teaches at Bar-Ilan University in Tel Aviv. He appeared on al Jazeera and interacted with the host in a discussion of the actual importance of Jerusalem to Muslims. (Or, perhaps more accurately, its actual lack of importance to Muslims throughout history). Aside from the irrefutable facts he presents , what I found to be especially interesting is how he catches his al Jazeera host in a blatant example of taqiyya!!!
A truly enlightening video!!!
Oh, sorry that I can't see that. I visited the Dome of the Rock about 13 years ago - had to take off my shoes to go into the building. There is in fact a big rock there. I put my hand on it and nobody killed me - but do you think there could be a fatwa declared for my death? You know, the third in line: "Death to Israel, Death to America, Death to Buzz". Actually, Salman Rushdie should fit in there somewhere, I guess.
By the way, I always understood that the Temple Mount was of no genuine importance to Muslims, it's just something they made up to prevent the construction of a new Temple over the foundations of the Temple of David, which IS of importance to Jews.
PJ,
I had to go six pages back to find a Reply button under one of your messages. II hope you can find this.
On Hezbollah and terrorism:
If the marines were in Lebanon to fight a war, their bombing would not be terrorism. But they were there as a UN peacekeeping force. And they were not murdered by an army but by a couple of Hezbollah suicide bombers.
According to the National Counterterrorism Center, it WAS a terrorist attack and it was not the only one, manyagainst civilians:
Secondly, the Jerusalem Post article mentioned several other terrorist acts. The Buenos Aires bombing of a Jewish communal center, in which about 87 Jews were murdered, was a terrorist act even by your definition.
That is not referring to Iran in particular but to French appeasement of Islam in general.
The French government is doing little to protect Jews against Muslim attacks which are rising over 50% annually, and Jews are exiting. The French have taken the Arab side in the conflict withy Israel.
Not every dictionary is so restrictive in its definition of terrorism. For example dictionary.com:
"theuseofviolenceandthreatstointimidateorcoerce,especially forpoliticalpurposes."
or World English Dictionary:
"systematicuseofviolenceandintimidationtoachievesome
goal"
Merriam-Webster:
: "the use of violent acts to frighten the people in an area as a way of trying to achieve a political goal"
And do you not see the same trend in Scandinavia, Belgium and England? Almost everywhere politicians are whores who will pander to any growing voting bloc to get their votes. Since Muslims are becoming so numerous, as compared to Jews in many countries, this is what is happening. Thank God for Canada which stands strong in its support. As well almost two thirds of Americans favour Israel (Gallup poll).
Your criticisms are debatable. The Shah as a "puppet" is your opinion. We would not have needed to invade. There are other ways to project power and Carter even tried one that unfortunately failed.
You lost the debatebecause the people turned Carter out of office for his wimpishness. Since then he has shown an affinity to dictators.
After 444 days the hostages were released just after Reagan became president.
I wasn't a military target when I had to hide in a bomb shelter on a Kibbutz in Northern Israel because Hezbollah was lobbing missiles there. How many non-military targets does it take to make them what they are in fact listed to be?
Interestingly, both the Torah and Qur'an support Israel's return to history in their ancient land
Rashi's explanation of why the Torah begins with Creation instead of Israel: "Now for what reason did He commence with In the beginning? Because of [the verse] The strength of His works He related to His people, to give them the inheritance of the nations (Ps. 111:6).
For if the nations of the world should say to Israel, You are robbers, for you conquered by force the lands of the seven nations [of Canaan], they will reply, The entire earth belongs to the Holy One, blessed be He; He created it (this we learn from the story of the Creation) and gave it to whomever He deemed proper When He wished, He gave it to them, and when He wished, He took it away from them and gave it to us."
The Qur'anic equivalent:
"Say: 'O God, King of the kingdom, Thou givest the kingdom to whom Thou pleasest, and Thou strippest off the kingdom from whom Thou pleasest; Thou endurest with honour whom Thou pleasest, and Thou bringest low whom Thou pleasest; all the best is in Thy hand. Verily, Thou hast power over all things." (Sura 3:26)
Now to your request:
The Qur'an commands Israel to conquer the Holy Land:
"And [remember] when Moses said to his people: 'O my people, call in
remembrance the favour of God unto you, when he produced prophets among you, made you kings, and gave to you what He had not given to any other among the people. O my people, enter the Holy Land which God has assigned unto you, and turn not back ignominiously, for then will ye be overthrown, to your own ruin." (Sura 5:20-21)
Verse No
Pickthall
Shakir
Sherali
Yusufali
5:20
And (remember) when Moses said unto his people: O my people! Remember Allah's favour unto you, how He placed among you prophets, and He made you kings, and gave you that (which) He gave not to any (other) of (His) creatures.
And when Musa said to his people: O my people! remember the favor of Allah upon you when He raised prophets among you and made you kings and gave you what He had not given to any other among the nations.
And remember when Moses said to his people, `O my people, call to mind ALLAH's favour upon you when HE raised Prophets among you and made you kings, and gave you what HE gave not to any other among the peoples;
Remember Moses said to his people: "O my people! Call in remembrance the favour of God unto you, when He produced prophets among you, made you kings, and gave you what He had not given to any other among the peoples.
5:21
O my people! Go into the holy land which Allah hath ordained for you. Turn not in flight, for surely ye turn back as losers:
O my people! enter the holy land which Allah has prescribed for you and turn not on your backs for then you will turn back losers.
`O my people, enter the Holy Land which ALLAH has ordained for you and do not turn back, for then you will return as losers.'
"O my people! Enter the holy land which God hath assigned unto you, and turn not back ignominiously, for then will ye be overthrown, to your own ruin."
It also refers to the reinstatement of the Jews in the Land before the last judgment:
"And thereafter We said to the Children of Israel: 'Dwell securely in the Promised Land.' And when the last warning will come to pass, We will gather you together in a mingled crowd." (Sura 17:104)
It recognizes that Jews will pray towards Jerusalem and Muslims towards Mecca:
"...They would not follow thy direction of prayer (qibla), nor art thou to follow their direction of prayer; nor indeed will they follow each other's direction of prayer..." (Sura 2:145)
The purpose of this distinction is to prevent conflict. All qur'anic commentators explain that "thy qibla" is obviously the Kaba of Mecca, while "their qibla" refers to the Temple Area in Jerusalem. To quote just one of the most important of them, we read in Qadi Baydawi's Commentary:
"Verily, in their prayers Jews orient themselves toward the Rock (sakhrah), while Christians orientated themselves eastwards..." (M. Shaykh Zadeh, "Hashiyya ala tafsir al-Qadi al-Baydawi", Istanbul, 1979) some Muslim exegetes also quote the Book of Daniel as proof of this (Daniel 6:11).
flame,
You wrote:
Unfortunately I am at a loss to respond because, of the three long history messages I wrote, I not only don't know what paragraph you refer to but not even which message.
The farther you go from the event the more foggy it seems, but you are invoking moral relativism and throwing up your hands.
Which folks? When?
I readily admit to being an advocate, not impartial and certainly nota moral relativist. There are more than enough advocates on the other side so you need to make a judgment between us.
It is not their religion but their actions. They have committed over 21,000 terror acts worldwide since 9/11/2001. There is a list of them on this web site:
Sadly, disaster is in Jewish genes because we have experienced it in every generation. It is amazing we are still here and vibrant. On a scale of innocence, we and Islam are on extreme opposite ends.
We did not bring our successive persecutors on ourselves. Your comment bring to mind the following quote by Konstantyn Jelenski in the Parisian journal Kultura, May 1968:
Americans, including the American government, should stay the hell out of discussions about the Israelis building settlements where Arabs claim are "ancestral lands."
They should stay the hell out of discussions about Palestinians and ancestral homelands.
This is Native American Heritage Month. Not one media outlet, national or local, radio, tv, or Internet has made mention of it though they all sit on our ancestral lands.
You go, Israel!
Take what you can while you can and never believe there are no nuclear weapons lying in wait below the ground for you. Iran allows no inspections of nuclear facilities, their word is suspect.
Ancestral lands are sacred to no outside entity and should not be considered as leverage at a negotiating table when the participating principles have never honored the concept.
I stand with Israel.
This is a discussion for Dowser, since she is a hydro geologist. I would like her to weigh in on this subject.
Gas Drilling Is Called Safe in New York
By DANNY HAKIM
ALBANY The states Health Department found in an analysis it prepared early last year that the much-debated drilling technology known as hydrofracking could be conducted safely in New York, according to a copy obtained by The New York Times from an expert who did not believe it should be kept secret.
The analysis and other health assessments have been closely guarded by Gov. Andrew M. Cuomo and his administration as the governor weighs whether to approve fracking. Mr. Cuomo, a Democrat, has long delayed making a decision, unnerved in part by strident opposition on his partys left. A plan to allow a limited amount of fracking in the states Southern Tier along the Pennsylvania border is still seen as the most likely outcome , should the drilling process receive final approval.
The eight-page analysis is a summary of previous research by the state and others, and concludes that fracking can be done safely. It delves into the potential impact of fracking on water resources, on naturally occurring radiological material found in the ground, on air emissions and on potential socioeconomic and quality-of-life impacts.
But it remains difficult to discern how much original research the state has done on potential health impacts, and environmentalists worry that the administrations lack of transparency is hiding a lack of rigor in its assessment of public health risks. At the same time, the drilling industry, and landowners who have leased their land in the Southern Tier, have grown increasingly frustrated with delays by the Cuomo administration to announce a final plan. State regulators have now been studying the issue of fracking for about four years.
Emily DeSantis, a spokeswoman for the State Department of Environmental Conservation, said the analysis obtained by The Times was out of date. The document you have is merely a summary, is nearly a year old, and there will be substantial changes to that version, she said.
She added that a revised version of the Environmental Impact Statement on hydrofracking which last ran about 1,500 pages would include more material delving into health issues. The administration has also turned to three outside experts to review the states own health assessments.
The assessment obtained by The Times finds that fracking can be done safely within the regulatory system that the state has been developing for several years.
By implementing the proposed mitigation measures, the analysis says, the Department expects that human chemical exposures during normal HVHF operations short for high-volume hydraulic fracturing will be prevented or reduced below levels of significant health concern.
The analysis also rejects a broad quantitative risk assessment of fracking the kind of study that would try to project the probability of various hazards saying it would involve making a large number of assumptions about the many scenario-specific variables that influence the nature and degree of potential human exposure and toxicity
More:
He's right . Fracking can be done safely . But when there are too many companies in a hurry safety will be ignored .
Great post Screm.
Flame,
Islam's bent to jihad and terror is not my subjective prejudicial fantasy. It is objective truth and I showed you evidence.
Here it is again; a complete list of 21,800 worldwideterror attacks since 9/11/2001, and not just on Israel -- far from it -- that comes out to about five a day for the last dozen years.What more evidencedo you need?
The historical record is replete with such jihad operations.
OK, JFT,
Hamas, which governs Gaza, is a small part of the Palestinian
People. (BTW, before 1947 the Jerusalem Post was the Palestine Post and Jews were Palestinians.)
You wrote this because you evidently saw the Hamas Charter. You should have also looked at the PLO Charter which turns out to be very similar. This is fromthe charter of the West Bank government:
Article 9: Armed struggle is the only way to liberate Palestine. Thus it is the overall strategy, not merely a tactical phase. The Palestinian Arab people assert their absolute determination and firm resolution to continue their armed struggle and to work for an armed popular revolution for the liberation of their country and their return to it. They also assert their right to normal life in Palestine and to exercise their right to self-determination and sovereignty over it.
Article 10: Commando action constitutes the nucleus of the Palestinian popular liberation war. This requires its escalation, comprehensiveness, and the mobilization of all the Palestinian popular and educational efforts and their organization and involvement in the armed Palestinian revolution. It also requires the achieving of unity for the national (watani) struggle among the different groupings of the Palestinian people, and between the Palestinian people and the Arab masses, so as to secure the continuation of the revolution, its escalation, and victory.
Article 11: The Palestinians will have three mottoes: national (wataniyya) unity, national (qawmiyya) mobilization, and liberation.
Article 12: The Palestinian people believe in Arab unity. In order to contribute their share toward the attainment of that objective, however, they must, at the present stage of their struggle, safeguard their Palestinian identity and develop their consciousness of that identity, and oppose any plan that may dissolve or impair it.
Article 13: Arab unity and the liberation of Palestine are two complementary objectives, the attainment of either of which facilitates the attainment of the other. Thus, Arab unity leads to the liberation of Palestine, the liberation of Palestine leads to Arab unity; and work toward the realization of one objective proceeds side by side with work toward the realization of the other.
Article 14: The destiny of the Arab nation, and indeed Arab existence itself, depend upon the destiny of the Palestine cause. From this interdependence springs the Arab nation's pursuit of, and striving for, the liberation of Palestine. The people of Palestine play the role of the vanguard in the realization of this sacred (qawmi) goal.
Article 15: The liberation of Palestine, from an Arab viewpoint, is a national (qawmi) duty and it attempts to repel the Zionist and imperialist aggression against the Arab homeland, and aims at the elimination of Zionism in Palestine. Absolute responsibility for this falls upon the Arab nation - peoples and governments - with the Arab people of Palestine in the vanguard. Accordingly, the Arab nation must mobilize all its military, human, moral, and spiritual capabilities to participate actively with the Palestinian people in the liberation of Palestine. It must, particularly in the phase of the armed Palestinian revolution, offer and furnish the Palestinian people with all possible help, and material and human support, and make available to them the means and opportunities that will enable them to continue to carry out their leading role in the armed revolution, until they liberate their homeland.
Article 16: The liberation of Palestine, from a spiritual point of view, will provide the Holy Land with an atmosphere of safety and tranquility, which in turn will safeguard the country's religious sanctuaries and guarantee freedom of worship and of visit to all, without discrimination of race, color, language, or religion. Accordingly, the people of Palestine look to all spiritual forces in the world for support.
Article 17: The liberation of Palestine, from a human point of view, will restore to the Palestinian individual his dignity, pride, and freedom. Accordingly the Palestinian Arab people look forward to the support of all those who believe in the dignity of man and his freedom in the world.
Article 18: The liberation of Palestine, from an international point of view, is a defensive action necessitated by the demands of self-defense. Accordingly the Palestinian people, desirous as they are of the friendship of all people, look to freedom-loving, and peace-loving states for support in order to restore their legitimate rights in Palestine, to re-establish peace and security in the country, and to enable its people to exercise national sovereignty and freedom.
The rest is here:
Does that still allow a 2-state solution?
Ugh ... tiger breath . What have you been eating ?!
You can trust US promises and treaties... ask any Indian, or look at reservations today.
You're welcome, my pleasure.
This entire seed of comments has been so much fun; like the ol's days in the trenches!
:~)
Is that much different from leopard breath Petey?
Randy,
People always want peace. Governments don't. And the concept that this is only a one way dance with Israel doing the stepping on the toes only, goes to show you don't get the nuances of what's been happening for years.
The reason the Muslims will not give up a battle for control of Israel is because of the Islamic precept that all territories once occupied by Muslims must forever remain under Muslim domination. This is apparent in Spain with what is called the "Andalusian Spring".
The point is that they will NEVER give up. It is part of their religion and you know that they MUST adhere to their religion. I once posted an article by a Muslim who verified this, and this is the reason Israel is forced to continually and probably forever have to defend itself even notwithstanding a peace agreement.
"From the perspective of the Arab leaders, reaching a two-state solution is to betray God."
...
It is also well documented that even if an agreement is entered into by Muslims, they are permitted to abrogate it. So what is the purpose of negotiation? Even a Peace Agreement means nothing to them.
Ditto Mimi!
Your statement is biased and not based on reality. At the same time, do you also believe that Jews are descended from apes and pigs?
In which case just go to war and see who wins and put an end to the rest of the world having to deal with your (both) bullshit.
We all know who would win the war. It would be much shorter than even the Six Day War in 1967. How long after it was over would you be changing your name to "Justice for Palestine"? Perrie says "you don't get the nuances" and Buzz says you are biased. They are both being much too kind. I say your comments in this thread are simply ignorant.
Buzz,
The idea of NT was to aspire to be better than NV. You are a lawyer and have a felicity with words to get your message across. Us it.
Yup. Some do-- some don't.
Do you think that while there are some Palis in the W Bank who want a two-state solution,there might also be some Israelis who also want a two-state solution? Or do you think that only some Palis wnt peace-- but that no Israelis do? (in other words, do you think that its all Israel's fault-- and only Israel's fault?)
Many years ago, before she achieved fame (note the Rolling Stone Magazine cover) I met a singer named Sarah McLachlan. (She was also on the cover of Time Magazine but the photographer has barred use of the cover photo.) We shared a taxi once to go to where she was going to do a mike check. I have to say I was truly impressed by her voice, but at the time I wasn't aware that some of the things that she has written or said made a lot of sense. For example:
Peoples ignorance really pisses me off. Stupidity is when you cant help it ignorance is when you choose not to understand something. (Sarah McLachlan)
..
And the people of America voted in George W. Bush (Peace Be Upon Him!) to be President.
Twice!
Does that mean to you that "the bulk" of voting Americans are/were neo-cons? (Twice).
Nope: PM reaffirms Israels commitment to two-states
Does that make you happier Perrie?
Or do you want to see some more quotations, like by Albert Einstein and others?
Actually what would make me happy is not having discussions like this one or moderating... but this was decided a long time ago by voting on the CoC and I have my responsibilities and ethics to uphold.
BTW there is going to be our updating of the CoC article this week. Got an ax to grind, let it be heard there.
He was Secretary of State before he wasn't.
Or sumpthin'....
Damn!! I wanted the Time cover, but it's gone. Maybe this one will suit your taste.
Randy,
During the 2000 peace accords with Clinton, Israel was willing to give Arafat everything he wanted with only one exception, Jerusalem. ThePalestinians would have had a homeland a long time ago. Clinton said:
"I regret that in 2000 Arafat missed the opportunity to bring that nation into being and pray for the day when the dreams of the Palestinian people for a state and a better life will be realized in a just and lasting peace."
Do ya not believe Clinton either?
You can't lay this all at the door of Israel.
So let me get this straight...
Until Israel got Jerusalem in the 7 day war, it was fine that the Arabs had half of it, and it didn't need to be an international city, but Israel gets it as the spoils of war, a war they didn't want, and then it should be an international city. No double standard there.
Forget it. It's not worth the effort.
The three religions that you think are a pile of junk? Now you care?
And now it is available to all, unlike before.
And Clinton apparently disagreed with you about it not being our problem. I'll take is expertise on this.
And apparently you disagree with France's Socialist President as well:
Perhaps you feel you are better informed about the realities of the situation than both Clinton and Hollande!
Israel got its nuclear technology from France, not from the U.S.
Israel, the only western democracy in that area, immeasurably helped Washington during the cold war and beyond.
It was not a one-sided deal as you imply.
Why now when the US most needs their help ?
The U.S. is circling the wagons as it withdraws from the world, helping its enemies, dissing its loyal friends and bankrupting its treasury.
Without new leadership we are going the way of Blackberry.
Hey, I told you 50 million times to stop exaggerating.
Oh, and I suppose you feel that the USA has got nothing back from Israel. Now I KNOW you don't do your homework.
I am really getting tired of repeating over and over again to people who feel benefits only flow FROM the USA the advantages and benefits that the USA, and in many cases not only the USA and the rest of the world, derive from Israel.
Two big problems. Nothing emerged as an obstacle in Geneva other th...
Trust but verify. It's not as if the technology they are using is a secret. If they are serious about cooperating they will allow full inspections. The problem is that they do not see why they are the ones to be treated like bad children and that it is they who have something to prove. They have stuck to their position consistently, that as signatories to the Non-Proliferation Treaty, they are entitled to their rights under that treaty and that they have no interest in a bomb.
If we continue with American imperialism, we're done as a nation. Truly are. And two things coming at us. We're going to be irrelevant in the world. You see this in foreign affairs when you see all these other countries making arrangements by themselves; don't even invite us to the meeting. Why? We come to a meeting; we think we know it all. We're the superpower you've got to listen to us.
I think it has something to do with being historical enemies of the main western influences . Persia was defeated by the ancient Greeks . That was a significant turning point in history .
Okay. I can't argue with that PJ.
It was an ideological conflict as well as an actual war . And the ideological differences are still alive today ... go figure !
IMO the Israel/Palestine conflict will last at least as long.
Actually I did an article about this on the vine . The Persians were surprisingly innovative ... but the Athenians were even more innovative .
Hey; the Muslims have been jihading for1600 years. Do you expect them to stop in our lifetimes?
1600 years? Since the biblical Ishmael Arabs have been doing this: based on Psalm 120, written nearly 3000 years ago.
Coals of broom are coals that appear to have gone out but are still lethally hot.
Kedar was a son of Ishmael ( Genesis 25:13 ) and hence the name was given to an Arabian tribe descended from him, a surrogate for Arabdom.( Isaiah 42:11 ; Isaiah 60:7 ; Jeremiah 49:28 ).
As is written in Ecclesiastes:
Well ... maybe . The thing is I wrote it as a followup to another viner's article [at their invitation] . One should really read their article first to get the needed backgound info . FYI here is the vine link :
How can anyone legitimately argue with that, Len. The problem is, that they still do
Thanks for reading it.
The Iranian supreme leader,Ayatollah Ali Khamenei, has said Tehran will not take one step back "one iota" from its nuclear rights, despite diplomats in Geneva proceeding to a third round of talks on the issue.The Iranian foreign minister, Mohammad Javad Zarif, has since indicated a way around the first sticking point, saying Tehran has the right to refine uranium but is not insisting others recognise that right.
Israel needs peace. They cannot survive forever in growing sea of Arabs. Who wants to live in a constant state of siege?
most of those who are thinking of leaving are not motivated by the security situation -- in fact, its the exact opposite. When the security threat mounts, the Israeli public views leaving as treason, and few emigrate at such times. Indeed, according to the researchers, few Israelis leave for ideological reasons, such as the occupation, antidemocratic legislation or even the emergency call-up orders, which have been widespread in recent years.
most of those who are thinking of leaving are not motivated by the security situation -- in fact, its the exact opposite. When the security threat mounts, the Israeli public views leaving as treason, and few emigrate at such times. Indeed, according to the researchers, few Israelis leave for ideological reasons, such as the occupation, antidemocratic legislation or even the emergency call-up orders, which have been widespread in recent years.