Food Fight or Respectful Interaction... Which will it be???
In a article I saw recently about neo-secessionists someone made a comment asserting that these people want to return to slavery. Even though my opinion of those people is pretty bad, I replied saying, I think it is unproductive to vilify those who are different by suggesting they want things they don't really want. If there is anyone who actually does want to return to slavery, they have no hope of being taken seriously by the overwhelming majority of Americans (left, right or center). Vilification is pervasive in our national discourse. Im a flaming liberal, and I will be the first to say that lefties do this as much as righties. Just because I identify with the sentiment of leftie hyperbole better than I do with rightie hyperbole doesnt mean I think leftie vilification is more effective than rightie vilification.
I wonder
- Why is it so common to see nonsensical inflammatory statements, or even factual statements that are intended to inflame???
- What good do we think it will do to vilify others, or does being productive have anything to do with our purpose???
- What is our purpose when we vilify others???
- Do we really think the rest of the world needs to be educated about how evil the other side is??? And if so, do we think hyperbole will be persuasive???
- Does vilifying those who are different get us more of what we want???
I suppose there are two kinds of vilification nonsensical hyperbole and factual information intended to cast others in a negative light. I propose that the first type, nonsensical hyperbole, is completely counterproductive. The second type, using facts to cast others in a negative light, may have some chance of achieving a productive goal, but the way we do that can have a big impact on how others respond to what we say. And by others I mean anyone who may hear us, not just people who reply.
One thing we can do to bring about better and more productive communication is for each of us to make a genuine effort to see things from the perspective of those who are most different. Of course, that doesnt mean we are likely to adopt a new world view. It just means we will have an opportunity to acknowledge things the other side prefers, and to do so in a way that respects their right to have those preferences, and also to do so without necessarily endorsing those preferences.
You may say It is difficult to adopt such an empathetic approach when there is no equivalent reciprocation when vitriol is all that comes back. Perhaps so, but I have found that when I employ this approach most people who want only to be nasty avoid me. And those who do engage do so with more respect. You may ask, What good does it do to divert trolls, they need to be squashed? Well I think my approach does at least two things First, it may plant a small seed in the trolls mind about the merits of being reasonable, especially if they see this behavior regularly. Second, I think reasonable people who may be only watching such an encounter will give more credibility to the ideas of people who behave respectfully. Also, if almost everyone did this, or at least everyone from one side did this, then it would encourage the folks on the other side to behave better. I know, its kinda difficult to sit calmly chatting in the midst of a massive food fight but personally, I prefer doing that to hurling more slop.

I saw a great sign in a nearby cafe... It said, "Be nice or leave."
How simple, how clear,how sensible...
Good article Mal. I wonder how many would answer the questions honestly. Especially #3
Love the sign.
Mal, when I read this, it brings me back to our conversations when we first met. You were my first friend on the vine and my mentor, and the above statement reminds me of all the lessons you have taught me. What a wonderful site we would have, if we could all just try to do as you suggest!
I think that people who practice any of those questions posed by Mal, probably lack the insight or know why and only care about achieving their objectives.
That was taken here when Mal was less enlightened....
Dear Friend Malamuteman: I agree with and support this article 100%. Well said! I hope this catches on.
Peace and Abundant Blessings.
Enoch.
Nutshells it perfectly. ..Respect.
...But, food fights look like fun. You must enjoy them too! (heehee:)
Great Graphic Chloe!
So 37 people viewed this and 5 people made comments. I wonder what that says.
LOL... Thanks, Perrie!
And then they'll bitch to me that there is a mess in here.
What is our purpose when we vilify others???
Maybe it's two-fold. It gives us a sense of power in our otherwise powerless existence, and if someone else is evil, by elimination, we are the good guys.
It's sad, but....
"What is our purpose when we vilify others???"
These days thats how elections are won. It comes from the top down.
[Laughing, Mal gasps for breath...] Call 911... I can't breath... Gasp....
WOW!!! Amazing... just amazing, Chloe!!! Mal is very impressed!
Food Fight!!!!
Sitting, waiting for it to start. Checking supply of Rock Melon, great to use as artillery in a food fight.
Never use a grape, when you have rock melon.
Very insightful, mimi! I think those notions typically develop ingrade schooland junior high... Then if those kids never learn the folly of that reasoning they carry it into adulthood. It takes some of us a long time to discover our "good" power.
I've noticed that too, Dean. Most politicians devote there efforts to denigrating others, thinking that will help them keep or elevate their positions... rather than serving the communities they represent.
I've learned a great deal from you too, Perrie.
[Mal leans against Perrie with a big Malamute hug...]
Thank You Enoch!
I have admired your wisdom for years. Perhaps, now we will have an opportunity to become better acquainted.
Cheers,
Mal
Maybe they are stopping to consider the points raised here and taking adiiotnal time for intrpspection into their actions and planninga new approach to......naw. But it would be a nice dream to fulfill.
I said something to Dowser today along these same lines.
I got a flyer in the mail before the elections from a challenger for a seat in the county legislature. His position was to end 15 years of crony capitalism, change the corrupt government. That was all he had to say. I didn't even bother looking further into what position(s) he was taking becuase his mailer basically said 'The other guy sucks so you should vote for me'.
There's a lot of that type of thinking here.
Don't think we're talking about compromising.
I think we're talking about making such ridiculously stupid statements that are obviously lies, such as "You just want to go back to the horse and buggy days."
Now, if you said that to me, you would be correct. But everyone else on these threads would naturally not want to do so, so your statement is an obvious over the top lie made to try and insult the other person with something you know before you post it is untrue, so why post it?
Why not engage your intelligence and come up with a point that is relatable to the discussion and makes sense?
I agree, Dean. They are so blatant about it when they are on the campaign trail. Persuasive rhetoric, promises and lies are why they on the trail...to promote themselves by running the other guy into the ground. So then we do it, too.
I agree, John, compromising isn't going to happen on an internet site, because that's not why we're here. It's to discuss our viewpoints, agreement or disagreement 'of' the facts.
In my view, the problems we're talking about involve tactics. Many use logical fallacy, e.g. strawman, red herring or ad hominem, in their rhetoric instead of 'honestly' staying with the point or questions being asked...that's tactical diversion. That ends up making people angry...and there it goes.
MalamuteMan
Excellent article and hopefully what you propose will live long and prosper here on NewsTalkers
I wrote this in my blog shortly after joining NT and I think it is somewhat germane to the topic
Sad but true.
John, I agree with your thoughts, just to reiterate: while 'tone' can make a difference in the response we get, I don't think we should have to feel a need to 'falsify' our tone, if we are being tricked, fooled or lied to by other in a futile attempt at one-upmanship.
It's supposed to be an honest discussion, not a 'say whatever I have to to make him look dumb and me smart, so that I can look like I'm right.' That's not a discussion when someone is doing that - it's a game, imo...gaming the conversation.
i thought it was because denver had become such a progressive utopia, that some counties wanted no part of it.
what i think is missing is: i dont believe there has been any such refferendum in the united states since the war, and very few seem to be concerned about this latest development.
Good point, BF...a link isn't proof of anything other than another author's or journalist's opinion. Even 'facts' and data can be altered. Logic is all we've got, imo.
Me too, BF.
So true Gary!
Exactly. How about telling me what YOU are going to do?
Hi Robert,
Respectful interaction is about HOW we interact not what our ideas are.
I don't believe I said anything that would serve as a good basis for drawing that conclusion.
I don't think it is meaningful to use a hypothetical conversation such as that to make your points. I think that is called a "straw man."
Actually, I said...
I acknowledge that the use of the word "troll" is potentiallyinflammatory, especially since it would be possible to infer that I am assert a troll is anyone who holds ideas that are antithetical to my own. That was not my intention. In fact what I proposed... "...tomake a genuine effort to see things from the perspective of those who are most different." is quite the opposite.
By "troll" I mean someone whoseintentionis to bring about an unproductive argument or to disrupt a potentially productive discussion. This is often done by making hateful personal attacks.
Perhaps "reasonable" is also a poor choice of words. While I certainly have opinions about which ideas are reasonable and which are not, as I am sure you do, the primary point of this article is to suggest that people who have differing ideas and who may also think the ideas of others are "unreasonable" can still choose to engage is discourse with respect... and most importantly, bymaking a genuine effort to see things from the perspective of those who are most different... and I gotta say, I am doing my damnedest to do that with you right now.
It is true that I am suggesting it is better to "be nice" than to be nasty. But I don't think there is anything tyrannical about my suggestion. It is a suggestion, not a demand. If you want to be something other than nice, I will not get in your way... In fact, I have no idea how I could get in your way, even if that was my objective. As I suggested in my article, if you do make such a choice it will not do much to foster respect from me.
Again, I never suggested I want only to participate with "people who pretty much feel the same way about everything"... or to avoid controversy. Actually, what I said is quite the opposite. I said... "...make a genuine effort to see things from the perspective of those who are most different." I have no wish to live in an echo chamber... I want to seek out those who are different... to do my best to understand them and to work hard to find common ground with those people... with the goal of finding the best possible way to get along and cooperate in spite of our differences. It is my hope that those people will have a similar interest in understanding me and cooperating with me. But even if they do not, Iacknowledgeit is their right to make that choice.
Hi John,
Agreed... of course some people in Congress have the objective of trying to make sure nothing gets done... so those people ARE "doing something."
Agreed. I don't believe I suggested that compromise is my objective... at least not in the context of a discussion forum alone. I think I said this about six times in my reply to Robert (above). My primary point was to suggest...
I am only suggesting that we do our best to understand each other, and to interact with respect... and, in the spirit of the Golden Rule, to be respectful even when we are not treated with respect. I am also proposing that if we do that...
As I said, "compromise" in the context of the discussion forum is not my objective. It is my hope that if we make our objective understanding oneanother, not compromising, just understanding, that maybe that will be something we carry away from the discussion forum which will help us to get along better as a society of people with differing ideologies. Cuz if we don't do something that moves us in that direction the outcome will not be good.
If you make the choice to be "impolite" I acknowledge it is your right to do that. As I said in the article, "I prefer not to hurl more slop." That said, I must admit that in spite of my efforts to "be nice and reasonable", I do fall off the nice wagon from time to time.
I'm pretty sure mimi is taking to you, John. And if I may... I think mimi is saying, why not forego personal attacks and use facts to discuss the topic at hand in an intelligent way.
Hi Chloe,
I agree... but I just want to reiterate my main point...
As I said, I agree that our tone, or the way we express ourselves can make a big difference, but the main thing I was lobbying for was for us to do our best "to see things from the perspective of those who are most different."
Very germane indeed! And very well written to boot!
BRAVO, Robert! BRA - VO!!!
I'm sorry JoAnne,
I don't understand the connection of your comment to the topic of the is article. I would appreciate it if you could explain...
The rights of every man are diminished when the rights of one man are threatened.
John F Kennedy
Such a short sentence with such a widespread meaning. I guess I use things like this statement from John F Kennedy to guide me and help me stay on course. I feel like these words are some of the most important words every spoken in this country. I feel like I want to live by these words and I like the idea the country I call home lives by these words as well.
I don't think we are living by them these days and maybe never have, but it is in my opinion this is a worthy goal. I think we are actually moving farther away from this philosophy these days. I haven't said anything derogatory in this comment except I think many are either unable to understand this or maybe really just don't care.
I don't think the forefathers had a country in mind with half of the people being supported by the other half.
I do not like unscrupulous behavior from anyone and we've had this for as long as this country has existed, I know.
I feel I see situations changing in this country I do not agree with and I feel it is my responsibility to speak out. I can be civil in my response to most any response I receive, but even though I'm being civil, I can not for the life of me look at it from the other person's perspective when I have such strong beliefs that are completely contrary to many others.
I don't know if I've ever seen a discussion on religion or politics that hasn't been fueled by emotions at some point in my life time. Still civility is a worthy goal.
We have to be good ambassadors for our causes. I learned when I was a brand-new Girl Scout (whoo-whee, what a long time ago that was) that whether we liked it or not, no matter where we went or who we met, we were representing our group. This idea was reinforced when I joined the Navy.
It's still the same today. We've got to move beyond the "Yeah, well, you're a poo-poo head, too" stage - or this country is going to be left dying in the dirt.
Hi Sixpick,
Thanks for your thoughts.
I agree there is nothing derogatory in your comment. In fact it is quite civil.
I don't know you, but I am very curious about some of the things you said, so in the interest of getting to know you better I hope you will answer a few questions.
You seem to be very passionate about JFK's statement, "The rights of every man are diminished when the rights of one man are threatened. I agree, that is a very important idea. You say youdon't think we are living by those words today. I am curious if you have a particular way in mind that we are failing that idea. Is there someone in particular who's rights you feel arethreatened???
Something I said almost five years ago seems appropriate here...
There was a time when I would come home from school, grab the 22 and go hunting down by the river. Really never killed anything, but today I'd be hesitant to do the same thing.
One thing is the Boston Bombing. I know the younger bomber could have been tracked with a good tracking dog for up to two weeks and especially at the time he exited the vehicle, yet no one in the media ever considered this and there was undeclared Martial Law on nearly every TV channel the next day with military types in and out of homes without search warrants. It was completely unnecessary as I am 100% they could have tracked him, but chose to expose us to undeclared Martial Law via TV all day.
Gun rights. When I grew up no one questioned gun rights. Now it is a constant battle having the government trying to eliminate many elements of that right to maintain it.
Before you could protest the government if you disagreed with it and now you have to be so far away from any government activity you are rendered ineffective.
For the first time in history the Judicial Department rewrote the constitution instead of interpreting it and made it mandatory to purchase a product from a private business or pay a tax for not buying it.
Having the NSA having the power to get all the information on us they seem to want without our consent.
Having the IRS do what they did to conservative groups before the last election for up to a year with the knowledge of it happening from within some in the White House.
Confiscating a journalist material which contains information that is confidential such as the 20 phone numbers of the Associated Press for 2 months. The information gathered could have been with confidential material and if the same thing happened or did it during Nixon's administration it would and did violate the privacy of the journalist.
Mostly I feel we are losing a lot of our privacy and living under soft tyranny at this time. it didn't start five years ago, but has become much worse, it appears. And I guess what gets me is when the top dog hears about it on the TV like the rest of us. I kind of find that hard to swallow.
Oh I could go on and on, but in all honesty, it's late and I'm very tired. We can continue this later.
I am inclined to let you hear it from the horses mouth so to speak and some just want me to write everything out, when I think videos proving it can be much more effective at times.
For the first time I fear the government because I see and hear one thing one year or even one day and the next day the story changes like what was said the day or year before seems to vanish into thin air and them media doesn't address all things as it seemed they once did more than these days.
Thanks for your thoughtful and extensive reply, Sixpick.
If I were to respond to every topic you have listed here my reply would be much too long, so I am going to focus on just a couple of things.
Quickly, I agree that NSA activities need much better oversight and regulation.
Regarding this...
I assume you are talking about the Affordable Care Act. I am pretty sure there was no rewriting of theConstitutioninvolvedin the passage of the Affordable Care Act. There was a ruling on it by the Supreme Court, but that is different than rewriting the Constitution, and fully within the provisions set forth in the Constitution.
The basic idea for the Affordable Care Act originated with the Heritage Foundation in 1989. They proposed the "individual mandate" as a way to handle the "free-rider" problem (as they described it). This was intended to address the fact that many people without insurancereceivedtreatment at the expense of others who did have insurance. Based on your statement in your first comment, "...half of the people being supported by the other half.", I think this may be a concern of yours as well.
I find it interesting that many conservatives today characterize the individual mandate as an evil idea perpetrated on the American people by the President, when it would be moreaccuratelydescribed as the President's effort to seek compromise by adopting a conservative proposal.
Perhaps you're interested in my feelings about the Affordable Care Act. I'm not happy with it myself. Primarily because it is not doing what its title suggests it will do... that is, it is not making healthcare "affordable." Actually, the full title is the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act, and there are some good things it achieves in the way of patient protection, such as telling the insurance companies they cannot refuse to cover people because of a pre-existing condition, and the prohibition of lifetimebenefitcaps.
The biggest problem for me with the ACA is that it is trying to rely on "free-market" private insurance. While I think the "free-market" system is perfectly appropriate for some things (selling cars, clothing, etc), I don't think it is appropriate for healthcare. When people's health and very lives hang in the balance making a profit is not morally appropriate (I am talking about stock shareholder profits, not wages for doctors and other healthcare providers). It is plain to see that given the "freedom" of the "free-market" insurance companies will do whatever they can tooptimismtheir profits. I feel that basic health insurance should be handled by a non-profit cooperative or a single-payer system.
I want to go back to a statement you made in your first comment...
First, I'm pretty sure your correct, the forefathers had no such idea in mind. The forefathers did foresee that the government they did have in mind for their time would not be likely to be perfectly suitable for future generations, so the provided ways for the citizens to evolve the nature of their government.
Next, your statement suggests that you may think the "supported half" are abusive freeloaders. If that is the case, I think that is a distorted view. To be sure, there are freeloaders in our society, perhaps some of them can be foundamongthe poor, but I think it is fair to say there are plenty that can be found among the wealthy as well. The truth is that most people who receive "support" in our society are working hard in an effort to be able to fully support themselves, and accept that support only to achieve a very modest quality of life.
You may feel that if what I am asserting is true, that you should not have to contribute to the support of those people if you don't want to. I acknowledge that it is your right to hold thatpositionand lobby as hard as you can for what you want. I would like to tell you a little bit about my thoughts on "supporting" people in need. I will do that by quoting something I wrote in an article a few years ago...
In summary I would like you to consider this...
During WW II the country united in spite of our ideological differences. We prevailed in that conflict and in the process pulled our country out of the worst economic depression in its history to become the largest and most successful economy in the history of the world.
It seems to me that you and I have pretty opposite feelings about socialsafety-nets (and probably many other things)... but we are both American citizens... and like it or not, as Americans, we are stuck with each other. If we choose vivifyfellow American citizens, characterizing each other asfundamentally evil, then at the end of the day we are hurting ourselves... we are engaging in a kind of civil war.I think it is important for us both to find ways to cooperate with one another for the benefit of our country. So Sixpick, I want to do that... do you???
I don't ask for, nor desire, some "lala land" forum. The human condition, being what is is (imperfect) will always have emotional outbursts especially when it comes to topics such as religion and politics. An attempt for common courtesy is all I require but as had been said before, if you can't stand the heat, get out of the kitchen.
Nuff said.
It is absolutely your right to choose that course of action, John. I'm sure you know that I don't likedistortedand false commentary any more than you do. Furthermore, I am pretty sure you and I share a similar ideology. Still... MY choice is to do my best to treat everyone with respect AS A HUMAN BEING... and I feel I can do that while also expressing disagreement and even dislike for the IDEAS those individuals may put forward. I actually think I did that reasonably well in the comment I left for Sixpick above.
I guess the point I am trying to make in this article is that no matter how much I may dislike the ideas and even the discussion forum behavior of others, I believe it is counterproductive to my own objectives to respond with hatred and disdain myself.
I propose that we can "get in people's face" without being nasty... Furthermore... at the risk of being too repetitive... I want to reiterate this...
If you don't feel expressing hate and disdain for the individual is counterproductive to YOUR objectives... fine, then do what you think serves your purpose most effectively. I am only offering my perspective.
I guess the inspiration for this article came from the observation that I didn't see a whole lot of "attempting" happening.
Nor do I!!! And I hope my article doesn't sound like "lala land" is what I was proposing.
I've been in this kitchen (and others like it) for more than five years... I have seen it devolve, and I am doing what I can to keep it healthy and productive. Sticking with your metaphor, I'd say I love spicy food... but I prefer to eat it and savor it rather than throwing it about in a "food fight"melee.
Your welcome Robert!
I have no doubt that you have been the target of plenty of hateful statements in this forum... and as I said in the article...
I made a point to John Russell somewhere bellow... I think he and I share a pretty similar ideology, whereas I am pretty you and I have strikingly different ideologies, but still I think the point I made applies to all three of us equally well... Here's the point...
I get the feeling that many people participating in this forum don't agree with that idea... But that is really all I am saying... and I don't think ideology has anything to do with the pertinence of that idea.
John, If I may, and please don't read any challenge or opposition into this, as I am 'only' addressing my question 'out of curiosity' not with agenda or trying to prove anyone 'wrong.'
How do we know all of the information in Six's videos is false?
Next question:
How do we know what is the truth in 'any' presentation coming from the President or Whitehouse, as well as what was said when he was on the campaign trail back in '08? What about telling us the Benghazi ordeal was 'based' on a video issue from the US, when it was so obvious it was about armament transfer? Would you agree that lies have obviously and blatantly been told to us by the Whitehouse (not just referring to the insurance lie)?
I'm sorry if that might have sounded like I was attempting to 'challenge any particular issue,' as that is not what I'm wanting to bring - I'm just wanting to make a point about 'truth and deception,' and 'why' there is a need for it.
Doesn't it stand to 'reason' that 'every' government on this planet wants to use that particular nation's resources (monetary and other) to make itself stronger, rather than the people of that nation?
In other words, doesn't every country's government on this planet have an agenda well beyond the needs and wants of the people of that country?
Isn't the multi-billion dollar complex they built in Utah with 'our' money proof of that?
Isn't that proof that collecting information about us and other governments 'proof' that our country's tax dollars are being used to 'make' money in a buying and selling of information, collecting personal phone and internet data, proof that we aren't told the truth about our privacy?
The point --- don't we have obvious reason to be distrustful of our government Officials?
If I may point to an individual issue for a second, Mal, but why don't you see the same outcome (abuse and profit-making schemes by using our money for other things) for single-payer? Hasn't it been obvious that whenever the government collects and pools money from us - for whatever reason - those vast funds get used for other things? Because the government is corporate controlled, all of those monies will always be used for 'profit' by those business organizations and banks that control Congress. I don't see how anyone could judge a single-payer scenario as creating a 'non-profit' of sorts...same thing for the Medi insurances.
It's always about the money...always.
But "productive and unproductive" is an individual perception/opinion. What's productive to one could be unproductive to another simply because one is perceiving their viewpoints are 'winning' the argument, or not. Silly for anyone to reason it that way, but that is what appears to happen.
I dunno ... the people in the picture look like they're having a great time slinging crap at each other. I don't mind getting dirty to make a point.
Perhaps so, Chloe... I will also assert there is plenty of basis for distrusting other parts of our society... for example, parts of the business community have proven they will do whatever they can to optimize their profits... People in various political factions also haveagendas, and are commonlynefariousin their efforts to further those agendas, even some people with a religious agenda will dodeceptivethings to get their way. I suppose it is fair to say it is prudent to be somewhat wary of just about every organization run by humans... Whatever "bad" activities may be going on within these various organizations, including and especially our government, I think it is VERY important to look at the INTENTION behind those activities. While I suppose it is likely that there are some nefarious intentions to be found in our government, I think it is a distortion to suggest that our government intends us harm.
It's ridiculous for anyone to think disagreeing equates with respect, isn't it?
Example #1 - " We disagree that handling the issue like that is the right thing to do." End of discussion.
Example #2 - " You are an idiot for thinking like that. Any moron knows handling it that way would never work. " End of discussion.
Number two is disrespectful, obviously, but the point is that the use of ad hominem is a 'tactic' - they might not actually think the person is an idiot and a moron, but they attack the character as a way of controlling their opponent's response by diverting them from reason - and putting them into 'emotion.' It's an intentional tactic wanting a particular outcome...it was never about respecting or disrespecting anyone.
This poor pattern of approaching a discussion is why NV made a specific statement in their CoH that ad hominem is a violation.
Thank you for the same sort of conversation here MalamuteMan. This is a statement that may seem harsh to some, but I have put this up on many occasions. "I believe it is my moral obligation to help those who can't help themselves and help those who can do so."At this point I do believe you would find we have more in common than you would think.
I will address your response the best I can.
I am aware of the Heritage proposal as well as the GOP proposal. I didn't agree with it then and I don't agree with it now. This is not to say I don't believe in helping my fellow citizens who are less fortunate than I am, understand. And also I understand how difficult these times are for many in need.
My misuse of words in re-writing the Constitution maybe should have asked the question, where in the US Constitution does it say the Federal Government can tax a person who doesn't buy a product they want you to purchase? Don't want to sound arrogant or mean. I would like to see where that passage is.
I can look down the road and see the government charging some more just because they are not abiding by the governments guidelines set forth in the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act.
For example at this time if I'm not mistaken Congress will not be making the changes or have any control and should they decide if you own a gun then your premium may be higher for that reason only and we have no recourse to prevent it from happening.
Or with this new ruling from the Supreme Court maybe in the future you can buy a car that doesn't meet the standards set forth by the government, you can buy the car, but you have to pay an extra tax because it doesn't meet the government's guideline of getting the maximum gas mileage before you have to pay a tax. This opens up a lot more power to the government than I would like to see it have.
A lot of people are happy with the way things are going today. These same people were very unhappy with the same things going on not too many years ago. I've not been happy either time as I see more power to the government and less power to the people.
You are mistaken in your possible assumption I think the other half are freeloaders. I'm completely aware of Fascist Corporate Structure that has developed and grown in this country. I know it is not easy for many.
In this country a person growing up in complete poverty does have the ability to step out of it although even with all the avenues presented to them there are too many who don't take advantage of these opportunities. And I understand environment probably plays the biggest part in the lack of seeing these opportunities. I'm sure it can be pretty difficult to see opportunity when all you're surrounded by are drugs and crime your entire life.
I just want to step back a moment to you statement:
"I believe it is my moral obligation to help those who can't help themselves and to help those who can do so."
Now I must say, do you see anything different in the way we feel? I don't think so. The only difference I can see maybe you feel the government can take on that responsibility and make us do it. Don't get me wrong. 'I believe the government has its place in all of this, but the government started the Great Society many years ago and what kind of condition do we find ourselves in today? I would say more people moving to the receive side and more middle class supporting them and having to move to the receiving side as well.
I find this to be an unacceptable end product for all the opportunities we have brought forth in all these years to improve the lives of those whose lives could have been improved.
This tells me the governments solutions have not worked as we would have liked for them to have worked to improve the lives of many. Now do we just continue to do the same things that have proven unsuccessful or do we look for other means to accomplish our wishes of making this a better society for all and allow those who don't want to participate in their own success take from those who have taken advantage of these opportunities?
Nancy Pelosi has told everyone they could quit their jobs and get into their hobbies. Do you think this is a good selling point in helping people to take a little responsibility for themselves? I have the video of her saying this. It can't be denied when you actually hear it right out of the horses mouth.
As far as ACA, let me give you an example. A single person 63 years old in NC making $35,000 a year can expect a $3,500 yearly premium for their healthcare according to the Kaiser rate tool. Now if that person decides he/she wants to improve his/her life and increases his/her income by $11,000 they can expect to pay $8,500 yearly premium. Now these are rounded off figures and not exact. Well that is a $5,000 increase in premium, plus it puts those last dollars earned into a 24.67% tax bracket which rounded to 25% is another $2,750 they will have to pay in taxes.
This is what I would consider an area of the middle class in quite a few parts of the county. The total cost is $5,000 plus $2,750 which is $7,750. Now they've just increased their income by $11,000. So let's take $7,750 from that and we get $2,750 dollars they get to keep by increasing their income from $35,000 to $46,000.
Tell me, what would inspire a person to work harder or longer to make $11,000 and only get to keep $2,750 and that doesn't even include the state taxes in states that have state taxes or other taxes. More than likely they would take home less that $2,000.
I find this as a means to reduce the middle class even more than it has been dwindling. I do believe you can't bring someone up by bringing others down.
Understand the rich and the poor will not be affected by this. The rich will just hire a top notch doctor and pay the whole thing out of their pocket for any services they need and the poor with get the same services for the same price or less than they have been.
I won't get into the preexisting conditions discussion, because I feel we both have the same mindset other than different methods of accomplishing it at this time. Let me put it this way at this moment. I don't think a person following the rules and doing what we would consider is the right thing to do should have to worry about losing everything because of medical bills.
As far as WWII was concerned we were fortunate we weren't destroyed like many of the European countries that were left in total destruction. WWII actually set us up to accomplish these things because these other countries really needed help in re-constructing their countries.
I feel, of course everyone came together because the economy was booming and if you wanted work it was everywhere to be found. Without the destruction of the European countries we would not have had this economic boom. Back then we furnished steel and many other products for them.
I have to say addressing the ACA only and foregoing all the others made it a lot easier for you MalamuteMan, but many of these other issues I brought up were left out of this discussion and those are important issues for me as well. And Mal, that's just the beginning. I have many more I didn't even bring up.
Yes I'd like to improve our society, but the leadership on both sides are not working with us in my opinion to do.
LOL Hal,
Don't I know. But think about this for a minute. You might get a rise from what you view as your political enemies, but what about all those in the middle... the ever growing middle.... do you think that you make your point well with them, or just turn them off? I know personally, that I shut down when I read stuff like that...
Not everything is about politics. I interject on anything - religion, music, television, etc. I see nothing wrong with using colorful and spirited language to support or condemn things that I personally favor or don't favor. I see this place as a place to entertain, and be entertained, and vent, and polish writing skills, more than a place to try and change the world.
Yes, of course, it's a private and independent business/corporation. They 'need' to profit to stay viable. And now that our government functions as a business to stay viable -- it will also look for ways to profit to serve its best needs, instead of functioning as an 'agency' or intermediary in serving the people's needs.
The point here is 'individual' vs. 'collective' and how each logically and morally should be served. The individual (person or corp) is based on serving its own best needs for survival; the collective was supposed to be about serving the needs of the collective for its survival, but that's not what is happening. The individual 'corp' is using the collective to serve its best own needs (and wants) - in so doing - it must deceive us to accomplish that.
i.e., using the insurance industry as an example, if they were blatant about it, it might be stated in effect, " People of this nation - I don't really care if you have enough insurance or not, why I make the policy verbiage undecipherable to even an attorney, and you end up discovering that what you 'thought' was going to cover you, might not. All I care about is that you are purchasing my product at the price that I need and want to keep myself viable and wealthy in income."
That's regarding 'any' insurance product - car, life, personal property, medical insurance, etc. And there are plenty of examples if we research, exposing angry people that 'thought' they were covered for things that were not when they needed to access the policy coverage. How they get away with it is through coding. They'll create a heading, that *suggests*..but the actual coded procedure that the patient had, might not fall under the codes that the heading covers. I'm simplifying this for discussion, but it is very complex in the way they have set up the policies' verbiage... and it's obvious why they did that...to make money instead of having to pay it out.
Once again, Sixpick, Thank you for your thoughtful and extensive reply!
I am sorry that you are disappointed with my limited reply. In spite of limiting it primarily to the ACA, I devoted a great deal of time to writing it. I could respond to many other things you said in the earlier comment and to many things in this more recent comment as well, but I simply don't have enough time to do that.
You and I clearly have different views on many of the issues of our time, although as you pointed out we do have some common ground at least on the notion that those who are genuinely in need deserve a helping hand. I think you and I could discuss all of these issues and more until we are blue in the face, but it seems unlikely that either of us would change our views much. I think the most pertinent point in this discussionis the point I made at the end of the my last comment...
It has been a pleasurediscussingall of this with you and getting to know you better, Sixpick. I wish I could talk with you more, but I have other things I need to attend to, including replying to some of the comments other people have left in this article. I'll see you around.
Cheers,
Mal
This will happen whether we're under single payer or not. And the price will go up whether we're under single payer or not.
So Chloe, The example you provided suggest to me that the best way to handle insurance of any kind is through a non-profit collective.
Hal, I agree with those reasons for being here, too. I see nothing wrong with language [epithets] that isn't directed toward a person, either. It can add spirit, and definitely add to emotion when needed. It's entertainment, whether meant for fun or serious contemplation.
And also, we might be dealing with users that work for an industry and are here to promote their products. They might not be related to politics, but are here strictly to promote that business. There was an ex-commercial blogger that revealed that on another site.
Well I gotta say, that was refreshingly clear and candid, Hal.
I agree, we are not likely to change the world with what we do here. I too come here for some of the things you listed. But, as Perrie said, when the discussion get too nasty, I just leave. One of my objectives (in addition topolishingwriting skills, etc.) is to learn about people who have different ideas and to have them learn about me. If there is lots of hateful rhetoric flying around, it doesn't seem like much meaningful learning is likely to happen.
I've tried endlessly here and elsewhere to urge discussion to proceed as if taking place in a courtroom or before a neutral, third party arbitrator only to be told, i.e. "this isn't a courtroom," etc. . In other words, a plea for reason, fairness and common courtesy will often get a response that consists of none of those elements.
Beyond simple indifference or unwillingness/inability to "discuss"/debate, comes the hard-headed, mean-spirited, zeal-without-knowledge hurler of vitriol. This profile is often characterized by bitching about those of us who feel the importance of backing our positions with relevant information and citing of sources.
"Cutting and pasting" is criticized by those who want to hit-and-run and not engage in point-counter-point conversations. I wonder how these types react to the interior of a library (assuming they've been to one); do they feel overwhelmed by all those books, etc., and feel disdain towards those who dared put all that damned information around?
Then there are the trolls -- those "who sows discord on the Internet by starting arguments or upsetting people, by posting inflammatory extraneous , or off-topic messages in an online community, consciously or otherwise with the deliberate intent of provoking readers into an emotional response or, of otherwise disrupting normal on-topic discussion."
If they have nothing of substance to say, they will post quips, insults, the famous faux-condescending amusing inanity, "LOL" and other no-value pieces of crap. And if they are challenged, they'll likely respond with further insults, even when retaliated upon with a more intellectually-composed, thoughtful, dead-on target smack down than the weak ass one the threw as the cheap shot first punch.
But wait, there's more. These folks drive on a one-way street; take all of the article and rants about Obama lying regarding people "keeping their insurance". Relentless. But today, when it was revealed that the Benghazi "cover up" attacks foisted on the Obama administration IS A LIE, the accusers were either silent or, tried to make light of the significance.
Let me conclude by expressing my feelings towards such disingenuous participants. First, my personal philosophy regarding first encounters.
For those not quick to pick up metaphorical meanings, the translation is as follows:
I will initially assume that a given individual is honorable and sincere and, even in disagreement over an issue, will proceed on that assumption. But, if that individual does not give me a "biscuit" after I have "heeled," I will you know.
Good article, Mal.
n other words, a plea for reason, fairness and common courtesy
As I'm new here, I'd like to fit in. Apparently, to be a fair participant, one should post a highly controversial opinion, pronounce it an incontestable fact and preemptively declare all dissenters as lying racists. And then if my "facts" are challenged, I should just throw out tangentially related blurbs that are barely relevant to the actual issue at hand other than possibly containing a key word or two that puts the blurb within a mile or two of the issue at hand.
I learn something new everyday. I guess in a court room setting, the learned advocate simply tells the judge that his contested position is correct and that anyone who opposes it can only do because he/she is a racist. Throw in a couple straw men and ad homenimsand then declare victory. Seems like law school is way overrated if that's how one comports themselves in the courtroom. A couple minutes in preschool would prepare you just the same.
Your paranoia is showing counselor.
Where positions are irrational and/or clearly predicated on oft-debunked "points" from sources that mount endless attacks from "birthers," "deathers," "xenophobes," "racists" (do we need to post more of the signage and commentary), then calling out the plausible motivation is fair.
When I challenge your facts, I always post the counter-points upon which I base my challenge ALWAYS. If we are then at an impasse, so be it and further discussion will likely be counter-productive if not incendiary and personal.
You guess wrong! In such a setting, you make your case as does the presenter of the case across the table. Again the paranoia. When people take positions that are consistently in opposition to their own interests without offering a viable alternative, the motivation is necessarily suspect. The handwriting on the wall ain't that hard to read.
In "law school" as you have mischaracterized it, yeah -- self-fulfilling prophecy.
Interesting that although we never agree and I think you tend to talk down, I find your arguments are thoughtful and far above the quipper empty cans.
No doubt we will disagree here as elsewhere, so, rather than make it a pissin' contest, I suggest we agree that we're at impasse.
Peace.
Fair enough.
Thus explains your on-going participation ending the speculation, which, not so ironically, pretty much called it.
I read somewhere that some will place their caches in quipper empty cans.
Please verify.
Thanks AMac!
An amazingly concise description!
What?!?!?!?!? I thought zeal alone was a perfectly good substitute for knowledge.
[Mal attempts to hide his smirk...]
John,
I just wanted to let you know I understand your frustration and anger... It is difficult for me to keep my cool when I hear some of the things that are said here... Glenn Beckisms are the worst... they make me want to scream and throw things at my monitor! I have some serious teeth marks in my lower lip... Perhaps there are people who will smile with satisfaction knowing I experience that kind of consternation...
Mal is being disrespectful??? Oh dear... Mal is soooooo embarrassed...
Here's you something John I threw together. Sounds like it too. Since I've been a little under the weather, I picked up my guitar and messed around with it more in the last few days than I have in the last 5 years. Kind of ragged but just wanted to test it out here if you don't mind just to see if it worked and how bad it actually sounds. But if it doesn't sound too bad I may put some more time into it and I do learn fast. It shouldn't take me long to pick up some timing and a get better. Just excuse this off topic and humor me.
Mal, I'm sorry, I didn't see this before.
You had me thinking (Mark the calendar!) - a consumer cooperative or a group non-profit might be a very good idea. I was looking at this Wiki info:
Consumer cooperatives are enterprises owned by consumers and managed democratically which aim at fulfilling the needs and aspirations of their members. [ 1 ] They operate within the market system , independently of the state, as a form of mutual aid , oriented toward service rather than pecuniary profit. [ 2 ] Consumers' cooperatives often take the form of retail outlets owned and operated by their consumers, such as food co-ops . [ 3 ] However, there are many types of consumers' cooperatives, operating in areas such as health care, insurance, housing , utilities and personal finance (including credit unions ).
Considering the civil tone you have set here, my "lala land" inference is " post hoc ."
It is to those who understand the meaning of "zeal-without-knowledge"; so, allow me to translate.
ZEAL - great energy or enthusiasm in pursuit of a cause or an objective
WITHOUT - in the absence of
KNOWLEDGE - facts, information, and skills acquired by a person through experience or education
* Not naming names in deference to promoting "meaningful exchanges".
I agree; presupposition/presumption is the result of the sum total of one's life experiences to any moment in time. But I would contend that what is perceived as "reasonable" and/or "acceptable" is often as simple measuring it against "The Golden Rule".
My comment was a way ofacknowledgingthat I see zeal absent of knowledge. My comment did not identified or targeted anyone in particular, and it was verypertinentto the topic of "meaningful exchanges."
With all due respect, Robert, I believe some of your comments in this article are intended to incite behavior that you can call out as contrary to the spirit of the message of this article.
If you want to prove that I amfallible, let's just take care of that right now... I AM! Will I ever do things that are disrespectful of others??? Probably. Is it my intention to avoid disrespectful behavior as much as I can??? It is. To be perfectly honest, it looks to me like you have no such intention. Whatever you choose to do in that regard is your right, and it will serve as part of the basis of how you are judged by others.
Well said AMac!!! The Golden Rule is certainly the foundation of my ethics, and the basis of my ideas about "reasonable" and "acceptable."
I want to add something to that...
Your comment, Robert, seems to make the erroneous assumption (and others have made a similar error) that I am advocating that we should never say anything negative. I am not. I certainly think we should feel free to challenge things that others say if we feel their comments deserve such a challenge. Furthermore, I think it is even appropriate to sometimes use somewhat abrasive language in making such a challenge. It is personal attacks that I am suggesting we avoid.
For example, if someone says something I find utterly preposterous, I think it is perfectly appropriate and reasonable for me to let them know that is how I view what they have said... and in making such a statement it incumbent on me to give a good explanation for why I feel that way. I also feel it is perfectly possible to do that is respectful of the individual as a human being. By the same token, I am saying it is disrespectful and counterproductive for me to tell that person they are a "blithering idiot" (or some other personal slam) for having made such a statement. I do not consider taking exception with what someone has said to be partaking in a "food fight."
Beautiful Guitar Music Six..I enjoyed it..
It's an article... an opinion article... not a "guide"... I have done my best to "demonstrate" the reason and basis of my opinions. If you find my arguments unsatisfactory, well... all I can say is I've done my best.
I have no interest in entering into a tit for tat on that issue... If you are honest with yourself, then you know what your intention was... perhaps my impression is incorrect... that is all I offered, my impression.
There's a lot of truth in your words, for me anyway, Hal. These social sites have "ruffled my ruffles" - I just don't know if that's good or bad.
I'm way more tolerant now, which is good, but like someone else here once said that has left -- " It's negatively changed my outlook and approach to life. "
I think that's happened to me, too. There's a bit of a negative attitude that didn't used to be there. Maybe constantly being around righteousness and negativity can rub off on us? I *think* I'm handling it, tho. But, if anyone here thinks I've totally lost it, please let me know! (You know, of course, don't you, that you will be wrong??!! --- Just kidding.)
Good to point out, Robert G., the ambiguity of words like those. There's no basis for definition; just like words as "fair" and "equal". All of those words are always 'relative.'
I agree with that, too.
I do use the word 'reasonable' as an adjective or an adverb to indicate that my thought processes were from a logical stance, not emotional. But, I know we can't always be sure, considering emotion rules. lol
and you're the judge of that why????
That certainly isn't MY intention.
I want to make it clear that my intention was and still is to encouragediscussion, not to thwart it. Any behavioral ideas I have proposed were offered as options that any individual can make as their own personal choice, not as something others would impose on themagainsttheir will.
Just as a plea to behave with respect for everyone leaves you feeling that I (and perhaps others) want to "shut you out, down and off", I would like you to know that hateful, angry, nasty behavior does tend to shut me down and drive me away, whether that is the effect you intend or not.
I must say... it is rather sad to me that, in spite of my well intended efforts, people will find a way to see something negative in my intentions.
Mal, I can't speak for Robert, but any negative comments or innuendo that might appear directed towards a particular individual - won't ever be the case. It's always an implied and universal "you," so to speak.
There are those that use that tactic in discussions on the web, I know, hoping that the intended person 'catches' it. I think that approach is just as rude, hurtful as a direct insult, so I don't do it.
This comment isn't to suggest you thought so - it's just to let you know that I'm not someone that tries to make comments 'personal.'
There are several distinctions that should be made with regard to this:
A "Newton's Law" regarding dialogue/debate/discussion/comment-reply TONE
"Equal & Opposite Reaction" vs. "Unprovoked Aggressive Reaction"
1) If/when an aggressively-written (usually partisan) discussion is posted, the author/seeder should expect and accept equally aggressively-written replies, however
2) aggressively-written comments that DO NOT ADDRESS THE DISCUSSION'S CONTENT AND/OR INSTEAD, ARE PERSONAL ATTACKS ON THE AUTHOR/SEEDER OR ANOTHER MEMBER, ARE IMPROPER, UNWARRANTED AND CoC VIOLATIONS.
That said, calling out such comments IS NOT A WAY "TO SHUT PEOPLE OUT, DOWN AND OFF" but justifiable and not the disingenuous use of a so-called "reasonable pretext".
Playing with the term "reasonable" is just that; even in law, there is a standard known as "The Reasonable Person Standard"
The coming to a discussion with a quip, and/or a direct or oblique shot at a member with nothing of value regarding discussion content, SHOULD BE REPUDIATED as it is indeed unreasonable being unprovoked.
The concept is centuries old; those consistently unwilling to declare an impasse when clearly there's nothing more constructive to be gained in a dispute, seem to live to agitate, frustrate and thwart detente. They'd rather provoke hostility than see peace. It's a manifestation of a character disorder.
No, I don't decide value; neither does one's personal value change what is factual -- only whether or not the holder of the values is willing to be reasonable, or instead, dogmatic.
Not necessarily; controversy may be real because the particulars are in dispute and for good reason; but ascribing one's belief to what is, or, appears to have a preponderance of fact on its side, is again an act of dogmatism.
Another quip and at shot at me. Notice when I quote scripture, I quote only secular/philosophical scripture. Admonishing about "casting one's pearls before swine," or, noting the consequences of "living by the sword" are didactic/common sense ideas containing no mention of a deity.
So Robert, here's a "pile of crap" that I find particularly appropriate regarding those who come to these discussions to stir the sh uhhhmm, stir the pot rather than dialogue.
Proverbs 11:29
Those who bring unpleasant exchanges time-after-time, whether or not they have the facts on their side, troubleth their own houses -- be it NT, NV or where ever.