"freedom of speech" on an Ivy League campus
SOURCE
http://news.yahoo.com/nyc-top-cop-kelly-shouted-down-brown-university-121224581.html
NYC top cop Kelly shouted down at Brown University
Associated PressAssociated Press 10/30/13
PROVIDENCE, R.I. (AP) New York City Police Commissioner Ray Kelly was shouted down by protesters at Brown University, forcing administrators at the Ivy League school to call off his lecture on "Proactive Policing in America's Biggest City."
More than 100 students and social justice activists turned out Tuesday to protest the NYPD's stop-and-frisk policy and its surveillance of Muslims. Many of them began shouting and chanting inside the lecture hall as the event began.
Brown officials asked protesters to allow Kelly to speak and reserve their comments until a question-and-answer session. When the shouting continued, the hall was cleared.
Students opposed to Kelly's visit first petitioned the university to cancel the lecture, said Jenny Li, a Brown student who helped organize the protest.
When the university did not cancel the event, "we decided to cancel it for them," Li said. She called the protest "a powerful demonstration of free speech."
Brown University President Christina Paxson said the protest "deprived the campus and the Providence community of an opportunity to hear and discuss important social issues."
"The conduct of disruptive members of the audience is indefensible and an affront both to civil democratic society and to the university's core values of dialogue and the free exchange of views," Paxson said in a statement.
Paxson said in a letter to the university community she will "convey my deepest regret" to Kelly and convene a campus forum "to discuss our values and expectations as a community."
A federal judge recently ruled the NYPD's stop-and-frisk policy violated the civil rights of minorities. The city is appealing the decision.
Tags
Who is online
90 visitors

Irony thy name is liberal students ...
You call that free speech ?! The cop was an invited guest of the university . HE WAS NOT ALLOWED TO SPEAK .
Students had the right to express their opinions in the Q&A after the talk . But instead they hogged up the entire process .
Oink oink ...
Making noise to keep someone else from speaking their thoughts and views is not free speech it is ignorance and a lack of the values upon which this country was founded.
If the situation were reversed and they were kept out of the auditorium where he was speaking because they disagreed with him there would have been a huge howling and wailing about them being denied right to speak their views.
Exactly the point RiO . No matter what one's opinion is about 4th amendment rights , there is no excuse for interfering in the discussion about those rights ...
Petey, Free speech is limited by the Government under the "Time, Place, Manner" clause..as well as by distance (the WBC had to stay off of private property and maintain a certain distance to prevent obstruction --can't recall the footage, maybe 150' ? Not sure). This protest by the students might have been illegal if they were on private property, or are under the "TMP" restriction, legally.
Huh ?
Aren't you questioning the students' right to free speech that is actually 'obstruction' of someone else's free speech?
Kelly was paid to give a speech, nothing "free" about it. His rights were not violated, he's laughing all the way to the bank. Does anyone think he didn't get paid, whether he spoke or not? Should we expect a civil rights lawsuit? Neh!
No . I am opposed to the repression of the free speech rights of Kelly . By obstructing his right to present his case the students are restricting free speech not aiding their own . As it is they had the right to make comments after the presentation was over .
1] You don't know that 2] You are using the word "free" in a monetary sense ... not a "free speech" sense .
3] Even if he was being paid the loud students were interfering with the rights of others in the audience to hear the man they came to hear . Interfering with speech is the exact opposite of constitutional free speech .
That is a separate issue from the free speech issue . The fact is the audience came to hear Kelly speak . They were thwarted by a few loud obnoxious ignoramuses who claimed they were excersizing their own free speech .
But all they were doing was interfering with the rights of the audience . AFTER you address that issue then you can state your case about "Stop and frisk" . If you insist on plunging ahead with the separate issue you will be off topic ... and invited to leave .
The only message he got was that Brown U students are subject to being bullied by the loud few . If they had waited they could have given him "the message" after he finished his talk .
Lol - yes, I'm so derailing!Hal It's a CoC violation to purposely derail a discussion. I'm sure there were at least 2 or 3 racists in the audience - at Brown University - that had their world turned upside down because they weren't able to listen to a bigot promote legalized hate.Hal,knock it off with the personal attacks. [ph]
An interesting question of ethics.
Here is why.
Although I do see the irony of the situation, what would be the reaction if this wasn'tCommissioner Ray Kelly, but someone reallydisgusting. Someone like David Duke or LouisFarrakhan Would the reaction have been:
Do we draw different lines for different people?
Just aphilosophicalquestion.
I gave you a choice . You chose to be a pest . You could have expressed your case against "stop & frisk " after you dealt with the topic of free speech . But now you are no longer welcome here . Also your sexual preferences are not the topic ...
That was my reaction . I probably wouldn't have been quite as acerbic in that situation . However it would still have been interference in free speech and I would be opposed to it . Now here's an issue for you . Why is it inevitably the liberal students who are the loud mouthed ones ?
I don't care what you call it . Jenny Li does NOT understand what free speech is . She should be flunked out of whatever course they teach that principle in .Is it or isn't it a suppression of free speech rights ?
Why are you making this liberal v conservatives? Do you think that conservatives don't do such acts. I assure you they do.
My query is one of ethics. Is freedom of speech an absolute? I would say not.
Not on college campuses . The conservatives are suppressed there .
Does this situation violate the unwritten "rules" of free speech ? Not in my opinion .
I expect that the majority who came to hear Kelly speak did think this was a big deal .
It is one thing to protest the presence of ROTC on campus . This was a violation of the constitutional right to free speech and that's why :
It is OK once you address the topic of this article . Do you see the title ? That is the topic . Stay on it . Once you have dealt with that you are free to go off onto other points .
And your use of free speech is implicitly fascist. Kelly and Brown University are guilty of promoting an unconstitutional NYPD policy. A moot point, literally. It is a policy of hate and discrimination. Promoting such an unconstitutional act is an afront the victims of this fascist policy.
I was always of the opinion 'free speech' was established as a protection against government suppression of speech against it. These protestors spoke against institutional discrimination. Youre also attributing a right of the people to the institution of the NYPD, who Kelly represents. He was not there as Ray Kelly, citizen. He was there as Commisioner Kelly, fascist.
Lets see, so folks are upset that this cop's 1st amendment rights to discuss his trampling of the 4th amendment were violated. Does no one else see the irony?
MY use ? I am not the topic at hand . Read the fucken title ! That is the topic . You want to talk about "stop & frisk" or facist government policies ? Fine . BUT FIRST DEAL WITH THE TITLED TOPIC AT HAND . If you can't be bothered to address that feel free to leave .
so much for free speech, bye bye.
So much for being incapable of following directions . DUH !
What folks ?
You, unless you've changed your mind and are now on the side of the protesters. I somehow doubt that's the case.
You're right . But I am not folks . I am only a singular folk ... although the temptation to mess with that word could be your way of getting too free with your speech .
Do you see the irony of this ignoramus of a student claiming she is advancing "free speech" by suppressing other's speech ?
Of course its ironic. She suppresses the cop's 1st amendment rights, he suppresses others 4th amendment rights. That's the problem with you republican/democrats. You pick and choose which amendments you like and discard the rest.
I'm sorry Petey, I think we were on the same page. I didn't state my question very clearly--used the wrong word; I see how that sounded like I was defending the students...I wasn't. I meant to say questioning the students 'action' not "right."
The students, imo, should show respect by listening, or they could have walked out. But to impede, obstruct and prevent - is wrong. I also think my point in bringing the law - TPM - might or should be applicable, from a legal stance, despite a school taking the issue there [legality] or not.
Ummm... no.
Seems that they are expressing themselves. So let's leave the conservative liberal thing out of this, and discuss the idea of freedom of speech.. which is what I think you are trying to do here.
When someone is going to say something that is very evil, should they not be countered?
OK , fair enough . Thanks for your comments .
OK , you have addressed the topic issue . Feel free to argue the case for the 4th amendment violations if that is your interest . I may even counter your points if they are at least cogent .
OK , the 3rd link happened at Notre Dame . That is not the Ivy Leagues . It is a Catholic college so that is an entirely different situation from your standard college/university especially in regards to the abortion issue .
The second situation happened in Texas . The red states are somewhat different . Also :
And that is the difference . Conservatives like to discuss . Liberals like to rant .
As to the 1st link :
That is not like the dictatorial rantings that liberals do . You have not proven your case ... but thanks for playing .
If what they have to say is legal then they should be allowed to speak ... and countered afterwards . If their speech advocates illegal acts , there are authorities that can be contacted .
I agree with your opinion entirely, Petey. The right of freedom of expression extends to everyone, and should not be used as an excuse to blockade another's similar right unless that exercise by another is meant to cause harm or danger to others. If so, anything goes.
Thanks much for staying on topic Buzz . Do you have an opinion about the NYC police in regards to violations of the 4th amendment ? If so feel free to express them .
Wait, so you are limiting this discussion to Ivy league schools? That is ridiculous. What about Johns Hopkins? Stanford? They rank higher than some Ivys. Besides, this is supposed to be about freedom of speech, yet I seem to be limited on what is accepted as a discussion. Now that is irony. As for making my case... making my case at what? That both political sides can be rude? What ever...
What if what they have to say is to pollute the minds of youth?
Frankly, if this was shouted down, I'd be good with it.
No . I'm excluding obvious non-standard situations . Most colleges are liberal . Picking special situations ... a Catholic college when talking about abortion issues is NOT standard . Don't play dumb ...
I would feel a lot better about this if students were permitted to write papers opposing the professor's views . But that won't happen . It also won't happen in anti-capitalist classes under the standard liberal professors .
Are you OK with shouting them down too ?
Excuse me? Playing dumb? Not cool. This has the feel of personal experience being brought into play. But whatever. Even if we excluded the Catholic University... which btw has over 40% non Catholics, that still included one that you dismissed because it was a "red state" school, which is bogus and the other was Yale. The quote might have sounded nice, but the pic tells a different story:
But that is what happened. And it started an investigation that lead to his dismissal. The thing is that for years Jefferies was poisoning the minds of those who took his class. Damage done.
Do you see those both as being equal? I don't. The first should be shouted down the second should get the pen.
BTW, my undergrad work was in accounting/economics and I never ran into a anti capitalist professor.
Nope. I've never studied the US Constitution, Bill of Rights, and Amendments, nor am I familiar with what the NYC police have done violating the law, so I'm really the wrong person to render an opinion. My comment was just based on freedom of expression, which is common in most western countries.
So there you have it . Until that paper not one student would stand up to this prof . The dictatorial system of grading made it inconvenient for any students to oppose this trash . That is what is wrong with the college system .
Of course not in those subjects . Those are business classes . But if you take a course in the liberal arts you will get dictatorial anti-capitalist liberals .
It was a black studies class. Probably, most of his students were black and had no reason not to believe him. It was someone who was auditing his class that wrote an account in the student paper.
I think like anywhere else in the academic world you will get an array of POVs. Yale has just been endowed for an entire school dedicated to conservatism.
And I did take sociology courses, since the accounting department was part of the liberal arts school and nada in trying to convince me of anything other than one very scary sex ed course and a professor who would expound on the virtues of cats over dogs.
That's too bad . The same type of thing happens in women's studies classes ...
On the Yale Campus ? Wow ... that's a new development .
I never experienced that type of course . Did I miss anything ?
Well ... its hard to argue with that ! Did you know its national cat day :
No, imo (on the countering), Perrie. To me, it could be similar to going to a performance of some type, in an enclosed building, and finding the performer offensive in some way. If a large group stood up and created a huge turmoil, I think the protesters should be restrained. They could walk out if they don't want to hear what is presented.
You hit the nail on the head. The 1st Amendment only protects against "government" intrusion against Free Speech. This is not a 1st Amendment issue. Period.
Now even if it was, those who protesting against Kelly's speech are also exercising their right to Free Speech and would be protected by law.
John,
I think this entire line about "Free Speech" is hilarious and those whom are claiming it violated their 1st Amendment rights have no clue as to what it means.
A state owned university is "open to the public" which is key here.."public property" So long as the state or federal governments are not involved in suppressing the speaker or the protestors, whom are equally protected by the "Free Speech" rights, there is no issue here.
I look at it as another one of the conservative/right-wing manufactured outrages of the week.
They picked the wrong venue to attempt a verbal justification for legalized hate, and that choice led to one group's freedom of speech drowning out the other group's freedom of speech. No crime, no trampling of freedoms, just incrediblybad judgment. If I wanted to publicly discuss the merits of flag burning, I wouldn't be surprised if I my freedom of speech was drown out by the crowd at the American Legion hall.
But if this "shouting down", preventing free speech to exist is not curtailed in some way, then no person who has a view opposing a group that has a different view will be permitted to speak - they will simply be shouted down and thereby shut down. The precedent will be there. How does that tickle the fancy of those who support freedom of speech and freedom of expression?
If there are no places to go where this kind of speech cannot be shouted down, then that speaks volumes about how unpopular the topic is. It is incumbent on the speaker to find the venue that has enough of an appreciation forthe message to be able to deliver it. Even the Tea Party, KKK and Westboro psychos manage to find a way to deliver their awful messages.
At the Reason Rally in DC, religiouszealotsdid everything they could to shout down the atheistspeakers, but their support couldn't even put a tiny dent in event.
Never took one. Did you?
NO! After film #4 I wanted to pluck my eyes out. So did my guy friend.
National Cat Day! Yea! Hey, you should post that!
No you are wrong
Anyone who thinks that there right to free speech if more important than someone else's ignorant and wrong
I remember now
"impasse"
Agood place to leave as the insults and absurdities start
Have a nice day
I'll grant that I crossed a line in the personal attack department, but I disagree about derailing this article. I saidthat I wasin jest, andthought that was obvious. My comment spoke directly towards what would cause this perceived infringement on freedom of speech. My follow up comments elaborate on that precisely. There was no infringement, just a stupid decision for a venue to discuss legalized hate.
He wasn't shunned . That would be staying away from his talk or even walking out in the middle of it . Instead he had his right of free speech denied and those of the audience who came to hear him . You don't get it ...
Flame ,
Holy shit ! Could you possibly say anything stupider ?! This was THE ideal opportunity to have a dialogue with a cop. But it was shutdown by loudmouthed ignoramuses who can't even understand what free speech is ... I guess that also includes you .
A Pax ,
Bill of rights , amendment 1 :
Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances.
OK , fair enough . I will add that the rights of the audience to hear the speaker were violated . And the credibility of the University to provide topical info was also violated . It may not have been a 1st amendment issue but the actions of these loud obnoxers did cause damage . They should be sued in civil court .
That is what you express as wit ? What about the tuition paid by the rest of the audience ? They wanted to hear what he had to say . They likely wanted to have a dialogue with a cop ... but they were denied .
Indeed :
I, and everyone else who disagrees with you, could spam this column to death until your comment is drown in a sea of shit that nobody is going to wade through to find it. That is a more accurate comparison than deleting a comment, and perfectly legal. Nobody deleted this guy's ability to speak, they just let him know that his opinion was not welcome in that particular venue. He's welcome to find another venue with a crowd of people who find it okay to isolate black people and humiliate them, arrest them without cause, precipitate a violent event, etc. I'm sure there are racist venues everywhere that welcome that sort of ideology.
Actually it was Stephi Cantley who posted that link in the cat group . She should publish it if anyone does ...
There is no such right and no such law. If the speaker was on private property and the audience PAID to hear him them yes, there is a violation of law there.
Nice try but again, there was NO constitutional right that was violated in this instance.
If it's a state run university, the taxpayers which makes it public property
Duh....
John, ..it seems significant to me that the ownership of the land would make a difference - public land or private. And if public land is involved, then protesting must respect the Time, Place, Manner Clause. I'm not familiar with the school. It might be 'open to the public' in either case, but proprietorship would seem to rule.
I went to a Catholic University which means the campus is "private property". Once, Anton Scalia came to give a commencement speech for the graduation law students. There were a hundred of so protestors but they were not allowed on campus, legally, because it's private property.
Exactly. The 1st Amendment only applies to "public" lands or property.
If this was government land, then doesn't the Time, Place, Manner clause come into effect? Speech going against speech is what happened, but there is always priority and the law ensures it.
That's correct, and it goes beyond that...distance. Time, Place, Manner places restrictions on protesting.
While this site is publicly accessible, since it is ultimately owned by a private firm, they can make rules and regulations (Terms Of Service) governing conduct here. There is no such thing as a violation of a persons 1st Amendment rights on any privately owned forum.
Brown U is a private school . Students paying tuition wanted to hear this talk as a cultural enrichment but they were denied .
The owner of the school had a responsibility to the lecturer, not a portion of the student body that objected and could have walked out.
flame, they aren't chained to a Lecture Hall. They can walk out.
lol, private property.
The students paid for enrollment and to follow the BSPs of that business. Enrollment isn't a free pass to do whatever they want on campus.
And, if it was public property, they are subject to the Time, Place, Manner clause.
But what happens when the protesters are students there ?
They can walk out, yes?
If I hold a fundraiser on my property, meaning the guests must pay, and if they don't like the speaker I provided, they can leave. In my view, they aren't actually paying for that speaker, they are supporting a cause...similar to campaign tours. Many might not have liked Obama's speech, but they were supporting the Democrats - why they paid.
Similar in this example, the student is supporting the University - the cause of higher education, with tuition, not every class or lecture that is offered.
Robert G., yes.
They are only liberal when it doesn't work for their own personal interests.
LOL!
Huh ?
Sounds like it should work. At some point, wouldn't they eventually catch up with everyone through SSNs and start garnishing wages...kinda like how they rob (
personal accounts through payroll deduction?
Maybe I shouldn't be responding without asking Petey first?
We'd be going off-topic, and he might not want that.
But that's not what happened on the Brown campus ...
flame, That's a cute raised eyebrow...clever and funny!
Speech takes many forms, yes? But they don't all come with the same set of guidelines and restrictions - for 'exactly' the reason this article exposes - because we can't let one person's 'physical' free speech impede on another's. (Yet, the guidelines would still be met by the appropriate proprietor.)
As an aside, I'm guessing the reason the press isn't subject to the same rules is because it's in writing, and the victim being told they're wrong, can do the same -- write their objection.
(Ok, thanks for the reminder!)
In that case, my comment stands.
AeonPax-Thank you, but I've been banned from this seed. My free speech has been dismissed summarily. But, I appreciate it when someone actually reads and comprehends.
A fish with ears ... the mind boggles !
Frank the Bunny from Donnie Darko
You were banned from this seed? Since your comment is here, you can't be serious, so what's the point you are trying to make? Is it that even if you are banned (such as being shouted down) you can still be heard? Please explain.
Frankly I think it falls more within the boundaries of civility, decency and maturity. We are supposed to be civilized and sufficiently intelligent to consider all viewpoints towards an issue and choose what we think is right.
Think of the United Nations General Assembly. If a nation wants to indicate its protest against another nation, the delegates walk out. They don't hoot and holler and try to act like little children or animals.