“What do you think about Indian mascots?”
A white man and an elderly Native man became pretty good friends, so the white guy decided to ask him: What do you think about Indian mascots? The Native elder responded, Heres what youve got to understand. When you look at black people, you see ghosts of all the slavery and the rapes and the hangings and the chains. When you look at Jews, you see ghosts of all those bodies piled up in death camps. And those ghosts keep you trying to do the right thing.
But when you look at us you dont see the ghosts of the little babies with their heads smashed in by rifle butts at the Big Hole, or the old folks dying by the side of the trail on the way to Oklahoma while their families cried and tried to make them comfortable, or the dead mothers at Wounded Knee or the little kids at Sand Creek who were shot for target practice. You dont see any ghosts at all. Instead you see casinos and drunks and junk cars and shacks.
Well, we see those ghosts. And they make our hearts sad and they hurt our little children. And when we try to say something, you tell us, Get over it. This is America. Look at the American dream. But as long as youre calling us Redskins and doing tomahawk chops, we cant look at the American dream, because those things remind us that we are not real human beings to you. And when people arent humans, you can turn them into slaves or kill six million of them or shoot them down with Hotchkiss guns and throw them into mass graves at Wounded Knee.
No, were not looking at the American dream. And why should we? We still havent woken up from the American nightmare.
-- Native American perspective on the mascot issue; this is an excerpt from Wolf at Twilight by Kent Nerburn.
Tags
Who is online
77 visitors

And they want us to "Get over it" and look for the American Dream??? How 'bout ending the nightmare first? Better yet, how 'bout acknowledging the nightmare happened and is still continuing?
To be honest I never gave it much thought. By the same token I never gave much thought to the Fighting Irish figure either. I'm three quarters Irish and was brought up to be proud of my heritage. No sports team mascot could affect that. There's way more to the Irish and Native Americans and all ethnicities than a stupid caricature.
I'm in no way trying to make light of the nightmare the Native Americans have endured from the European settlers and the continuing injustices.
And we have had Irish presidents. Name one Native American president.
I will say it again, 1stwarrior...
Indians are not real people to the rest of the citizens of America. Indians are a living side show, a form of entertainment, or an object of derision.
I can't. Can you name the ones that ran for the office?
I'd rather have an Indian for a school mascot than be stuck with a cornjerker.
Hoopeston High Cornjerkers
None. Indians do not have the base to run for national office of president. We are the invisible people in this country. The great Civil Rights movement managed to bypass the First People; the Human Rights activists don't know Indians exist; the ACLU barely even knows anything beyond blacks and Hispanics live in the US.
Know this, Pat Wilson.... every ethic and racial group that has set foot on the shores of this continent has had its hardships trying to find a foothold in the young United States of America. Each group has its gut wrenching horror stories to pass down from the early struggles to make this country what it is today.
But no group... not the blacks, not the Chinese, and not the Irish.... can stand beside the Indians in the magnitude of the evil and destruction that was done to them from the day the invaders first stepped a booted foot on this land to this day. And there is never an article posted about Native Americans that doesn't have someone trying to equate the history of their own ancestry here in America to the devastation wrought upon the Native people who called North America home for centuries before Europeans came, and the continuing lies and broken promises and treaties this government continues to practice.
Obama gave a speech about how blacks just can't "get over it" because they keep getting their feelings hurt by the way whites treat them on a daily basis. He says we need to understand why they can't "get over it."
Screw that. We have our own shit we're tired of being told to "get over it" when nobody even knows what "it" is and isn't interested in finding out. And we don't have a president talking for us.
The fact that people have to be convinced that it is demeaning... that they are fighting so hard to deny it.... shows how irrelevant Indians are to the social fabric of this country.
And that is just downright wrong.
The same thing I think about Irish, Greek, Norse, Swedes, Scots, Americans, English, Dutch, Roman etc.. mascots. Its a nice honor.
Maybe you missed this in my post :
From you :
I'm well aware of that, you don't need to tell me what to "know".
Thanks anyway.
How many Blacks do you have to piss off before you get a national reaction? How 'bout how many Hispanics - Jews - Women - LBGT. The answer? Very, very few.
Over 65% of the Native Americans are offended by the mascot issue - and NOBODY gives a ratzazz.
Equality???
Those not offended - that's their issue. If not offended, removing the mascot will make no never mind.
And you didn't answer my question Egilman - how many?
Mascots based on race should be banned. I think if there was a team called "brown skins " or "black skins" the NAACP would be having fits over it. Although I personally think a name like "braves" is complimentary, Native Americans may not see it the same way. This is just one reason it is best to stay away from it completely.
Charles Curtis, KAW, was VP - does that count?
Damn good point. Those with the lowest self-confidence have to ride over all others to bring them down to their level.
Interesting thing about the Braves name is that the tribes have no issue with the name - but, they have SERIOUS issues with the tommahawk chop.
You're right BF - money is the name of the game. Notice all the anger starting to spew 'bout the teams being listed a TAX EXEMPT/Non-profits???? That, my friend, is BS.
Florida State and the Seminole tribe are in total concurrence on the name for FSU. In fact, the tribe helps the school market merchandise and promotes the team.
Since the tribe whose name is being used doesn't find it to be offensive - no harm, no foul.
Robert - I understand exactly what you're saying. But - to a group of peoples in the U. S., the name is as offensiveas "The Queers", "The Ni**ers", and "The Kikes" would be offensive to those groups.
That is what has to be taken into consideration - does it offend someone/something, and, if so, fix it so it doesn't.
I could do that... but the addy would still read the same. Usually the large T in the middle kind of indicates that, though.
Actually, you are not the first person to complain. I have had several over our 3 year period. Hence why I am open to listening.
Which shows that I care.
But I don't want to get involved in this, in case I have to moderate. The only reason I made my comment IS because it has come up before.
" demand for a token victory over nothing, and a little more washing out of cultural differences, not a victory for diversity"
Whose opinion says it is a "token victory over nothing"? Robert - read the article again - read what the elder says the name reminds Indian people of - that is not "nothing". If people would only take/use their sensitivities that THEY demand from others, they would have a better understanding of what the Indians are trying to get across - the use of the term "Redskins" IN ANY FORM is offensive because it brings up way, way, way too many past injustices to at least the ancestors of 5.2M Indian people in the U. S. Many of our Grandparents were alive and experienced the horrors of Wounded Knee, Grassy Knoll, Sand Creek and so many others.
No, it's also not a " little more washing out of cultural differences. " Our culture and traditions and history have been TOTALLY effected by the term and actions of the instigators of the term "Redskins" - that's not a " little more washing out ".
Sounds to me like you're pushing for the "Get over it" conclusion but haven't figured out how to say so.
I think Perrie is going to hang you by your thumbs
I've noticed that when she "promises" to do something - everything settles down for a bit - obviously don't wanna be hung by something else (eeewwwwww).
Look at the news the past week - how many "headlines" stories have hit about "Blackface" and how racist, undermining, demeaning it is because "it reminds the nation of the terrible history of slavery in this country." "Redskins" doesn't remind you??? Just like the elder says above - No, were not looking at the American dream. And why should we? We still havent woken up from the American nightmare.
What is the difference??? Blackface is bad but Redskins is good?
Ya ever watch any John Wayne movies Egilman? How 'bout some good ol' Henry Fonda movies? How 'bout any movie John Houston directed that had Indians in it? I'm sure you have. Did you count all the Indian actors?? Didn't even make it past one did you?
Remember John Russell's thread on Troop F and the huge discussion dealing with how the Indians were/are stereotyped? Then there was a huge hit by Mel Brooks - not a single Indian, a huge nosed comedian playing a "Chief" purely for laughs (Marty really is funny in other roles) who just happened to be Jewish and white.
How 'bout driving in the SW down the ol' Route 66 and the road stands on the side of the road with garishly dressed people claiming to be Indian selling trinkets made in China. Or go on-line looking for Indian articles of clothing, jewelry, books on Indian culture, traditions, history - oh yeah, made in China orwritten by white-people telling how "wrong" the Indians are to want to have their own cultures/traditions/history?
Who is putting us down? Who has "attempted" to keep us under their thumb for 521 years because they haven't even bothered to try to understand who/what/why we are as a people - not as an object?
You want political bullshit? How 'bout - the Indian peoples have had 271 SPECIFIC laws passed by Congress that tells us what we can and can not do. NO OTHER ETHNICITY in the U. S. has ANY law written/passed with that dictum. We can't live in our homes on a reservation without PERMISSION from the U. S. gvnmt - gee, I don't see that happening with the Blacks, Browns, Yellows or Whites.
No, that is not how WE view ourselves - that is how DOMINANT SOCIETY views us. That has to change.
So, we all gonna wear Blackface tonight?
Cute? NOT.
Really?
November is Native American Heritage Month. Let's compare it to African American Heritage Month.
During AAHM, every day on every major television network there were Public Service breaks sponsored by the networks, hosted by well known celebrities and even politicians, featuring black men and women, living and dead, who had achieved personal goals and accomplished astonishing feats of historical and social significance throughout the lifetime of the building of this country. Every week during AAHM on every major television network there were programs and/or movies and stories dedicated to black individuals. Every school in the country dedicated itself, the entire month, to the retelling of the history of slavery in the US, the Civil War, the "separate but equal" days following it, the bitter days of the Civil Rights movement, the legend and death of Dr. King.....
Now take a look at Native American Heritage Month, instituted during the month of November, which celebrates Thanksgiving, a purely white man's holiday not particularly appreciated by Indians and which generates not only its own big buildup that would overshadow any other "holiday" in the month of November, but which is also the beginning of the hullaballoo that heralds the onslaught of Christmas.
Sure!!!!! We can slip Native American Heritage Month in there somewhere. But wait a minute..... where are the celebrity network sponsored sound bytes featuring Native Americans? Where are the programs and movies featuring a story of an outstanding Indian man or woman? And as for schools spending the whole month telling the true story of what happened to the Indians here in this country, or even talking about outstanding Indians who excelled in sports or theatre or art or even those who showed extraordinary courage in service to our country during war time...... yeah, like that's ever going to happen. You can't even find ten teachers in this entire nation who could name three Native Americans whose military service is so outstanding their story would make a riveting Spielberg movie.
OH, AND BY THE WAY..... EVEN THOUGH NOVEMBER IS "NATIVE AMERICAN HERITAGE MONTH," A PROCLAMATION HAS TO BE ISSUED EVERY YEAR, AS IT HAS BEEN SINCE 1994, FOR IT TO BE CONSIDERED AS SUCH. THERE IS NOT, AND NEVER HAS BEEN, A LEGAL NATIONAL HOLIDAY TO HONOR NATIVE AMERICANS, AS CONGRESS HAS REFUSED TO ISSUE ONE.
NATIVE AMERICAN DAY? THERE ISN'T ONE... NATIONALLY. EVERY STATE THAT DECIDES IT WANTS TO HAVE ONE PROCLAIMS ITS OWN DAY. WE ARE INVISIBLE TO THE NATIONAL GOVERNMENT.
WE HAVE BEEN HERE LONGER, HAVE HONORED THIS COUNTRY GREATER, THAN ANY ETHNIC GROUP HERE, AND HAVE NO FEDERAL NATIONAL HOLIDAY. WE ARE INVISIBLE TO THIS GOVERNMENT UNTIL IT WANTS THE BLOOD OF OUR PEOPLE IN WAR AND MORE OF OUR LAND.
So did you catch the story on Yahoo News this morning, made national headlines, how a big costume company had to recall all its traditional Chinese costumes for women and its Chinese sushi chef costumes for men because the Asian Cultural Community in New York protested that they were racist?
No argument, no fuss, just an immediate recall and an apology by the costumers. Damn! What is about the fact that Indians are Indians that makes such a difference do you think, that makes people tell us we are being too sensitive, we are just looking for headlines, we are making a big deal out of nothing, and we should just GET THE HELL OVER "IT" ??????
Gads mimi - I hate it when you tell the truth. Why don't you say what's on your mind???
Excellent Dingo - excellent. Sadly it is going to go over so many of their heads.
Absolutely mimi - as, as I stated above - Blackface is bad but Redskins is good? Amazing how the U. S. population will drop like a hat at the sound of another ethnicity they are being offended - and we're told to "GET OVER IT"!!!!!!!
Thanks flame - I see our job as trying to educate the masses, as you will, about our traditions/cultures/histories so they will hopefully understand why this, and other things, offends us so much.
And the American public is not the Democratic party - thank God. However, Snyder is not a politician, he is a businessman whose only goal is to make money, no matter who he offends.
The Indian people are tired of the offense, and we are not divided on that issue - change the mascot - it seriously offends us.
Yeah, but you tell the truth, which is harsh and unpalatable, 1stwarrior. And you get the knee-jerk statement like, "Oh, but, what about the blacks, and what they went through? And then there were the Irish, and the Chinese, who built the railroads, look how THEY were treated. All ethnic groups had it hard here! And look at how the Hispanics are being treated now, and the Muslims!" No one wants to allow Indians their day to tell it like it really was. Indians always have to share the stage, and while sharing it, get shoved off it to make room for the other group who was the "really" oppressed one in America.
You can't take a soft shoe approach, or a diplomatic approach about it. And when you just come on out, hard line, with it, you get a response like Egilman's. And it's been, what, over six hours since my response to him, with the facts about the
"Native American Month" that isn't, and all is quiet on the American front.
You have tried to hard so educate, as has Kavika, but it appears the people you are educating are people such as myself, who in spite of being Indian, has had so much of Native American history... the real history.... and the real present... buried and obscured. Those who could benefit from your teaching just seem to have their minds made up and don't want to be confused by the facts.
But I continue to be grateful for your educational articles, 1stwarrior, as I do for those of Kavika, Honemana, Tsula, Gunny, and if he would get his dang rear end back here, Blue Wolf.
I'm waiting for the comments, 1stwarrior. It's all in my head that there is no national Native American Heritage Month, no national Native American Heritage Day?
If for no other reason, after the veil of secrecy was lifted from the fact that Code Talkers significantly changed the course of both World Wars, and that without them we definitely would not have taken Iwo Jima, that would have been the perfect time to declare a National Native American Heritage Day and National Native American Heritage Month.
And it sure as hell DOES NOT need to be in NOVEMBER!
Indians are not real people to the rest of the citizens of America.
.....no, Mimi...not the "rest," just only SOME. You are special and important to me.
And I do not at all see the teaching of hidden truths and injustices from our history and present as an "agenda of guilt." (Did I really just read that right, Egilman? Shove it?????????????????????????????? )
But, but he has all those Indian friends...
OM Friggin' G Kavika - those are really sick - and people truly feel they're not causing any harm or hurt???? BS!!!!!!!
I do not include you, Stephi. Please forgive me, Sister.
I'll bet one of his best friends is an Indian...
Only proves that thesome on here with their BS, fit right in with the video.
The journey in your road can only be as good as you make it.
You're heard/read my story - this discrimination thing has really been a biggy with me, 'speciallybeing the Mentor at the CG Academy and CG Bootcamp for Indians, trying to help them NOT scream out in pain over the stupidity, selfishness, and mostly ignorance of our people. I've been asked so many times why do I put up with the crap day after day after day. My response is simply - people need to hear the message. Whether they listen or not is their issue - but, I will get the message out there.
No, Egil won't respond - he does this - slams - watches - goes someplace else (or so I've been told). I LOVED your points - as I always do.
Thanks Dingo
And 'member, he's "adopted" into one of the tribes
Or his great great grandmother was a Cherokee Princess.
Doncha know.
So many people have been borrowing my tomahawk lately, it's a good thing I laid in a few extra..... and Kavika and I think some guy named 1stwarrior asked me not to wave it around so much....
Liberals have such a problem with this. Should they support freedom of expression, or should they have to admit that the conservative view that somethings are just not socially acceptable because they are in bad taste and can hurt someone's feelings is totally correct?
If these were a group of fools dressed in offensive "sexy" inappropriate Indian costumes, it would not have caused a twitter, a tweet, nor a ruffled feather.
When I read this, I sort of lost my cool.
I would tend to agree with you. There are many threads here I dont comment on for various reasons; Lack of interest for one and my refusal to add to a groupthink mentality for another. As Im not big on sports, the issue of mascots is not something I ever dwell on. It just doesnt matter to me. However, what I found interesting in this thread was not the topic per se, but the dynamics (or manipulation) of the topic by an ingroup.
Such threads are not structured for academic discussion but rather as a sounding board by an ingroup whose seeming intent is to force agreement on an issue or face a cacophony of overt criticism. Not at all open minded but in fact, counter productive to an issue.
Unfortunately, there are other identifiable groupthink participants here in NT, just say something critical of Jews or Blacks and see how fast you get called anti-semitic or racist.
As a matter of civility, I am against anything in poor taste such as calling a team the Hooters (you can only imagine what their mascot would be, maybe some Owls) and names that are directly meant to hurt or otherwise denigrate a person or peoples. After that, who is to say what is inappropriate or not? The Thunderbird which etymologically comes from the Native American spiritualism of certain tribes, comes to mind as a potential name of contention.
While I am against the PC mindset, I do believe in fairness and if the reasons to be against a name or in this instance; mascots, are logical and sound, sometimes the needs of the many do not outweigh of the few.
Egilman and AeonPax, you have both brought out an excellent point - one that John Russell and two others have also brought out - "group think".
Aeon - as you stated, just mention something derogatory 'bout any other ethnic group and you'll be crawled all over for being racist - you see it happening all over the web. I mean, look at the headlines that were made over the "stupid/inappropriate" Blackface activity - jeeezzz. My immediate question when I saw/read that was - WTF, over? I mean - EVERYONE knows how touchy something like that is to the Black community (and others), yet . .. . . . it happened.
However, but - it "appears" to many (yes, mostly Indians) if any derogatory words or actions are taken against the Indian community - nothing is said by the world community (yes, that includes NT/NV) either pro or con. Many in the Indian community jump on the chance to say something - to attempt to right what they perceive as a wrong to our culture/traditions/heritage, and they do it with a vengeance because of their lack of support. Some would say that they "shout it from the roof-tops" - just to get people to listen. Why? Simply because they have no support group - no following - no backup plan. Their only goal is to get others to understand that what has occurred is not right.
There are a number ofIndians on NT/NV whose primary goal/desire is to help educate and indoctrinate the general public on Indian issues and concerns and about our cultures/traditions/heritage. Most of them will not come to the main forum because of the animosity shown when they do comment on anything.
Some come to this forum to "slap back" at comments to tell the commenters just how wrong they are. Some will come here and argue, to the death, that because the general population doesn't know or understand our history, the general population can't possibly understand so just STFU. Those members are in a pure defense mode - and have been so most of their lives - and, in perspective, rightly so.
I, for one, will always try to educate/discuss Indian topics - that is my main purpose for coming to this forum. You will notice the topics I place are not to be antagonistic - the topic will be placed, I will attempt to explain what has occurred and the potential impacts resulting, so others, not knowledgeable of Indian culture/traditions/heritage, will gain something from getting involved in the discussion.
I know, from the makeup of the NT community, it may not be appropriate, but I think I will place a thread up - just for discussion - about how to get the communication/education process going regarding Indian topics and their culture/traditions/heritage.
Egilman - I could tell you who the individual was - but - I don't think it would serve any purpose. Suffice it to say - they made a comment, you countered, they countered and you never responded which kinda ticked them off - hence the comment.
"he is adopted" refers to President Obama, not you. In fact, that whole string you've italicized is directed to someone else, definitely not you.
Please read the comment/response to you and AeonPax on page two. I very seriously would like to approach that topic. Willing to help?
We need to get the pres to issue an Executive Order or get a legislative act passed. It really shouldn't be that hard.
Our symbols, music and artarereflections of ourselves. When we attempt to describe others with art, we surely miss the mark, and much of the time it is an intentional misrepresentation as an attempt to rerwrite history. Most people would be appaled at the truth, while others see it as a way to right wrongs.
Egilman,
The president issued a proclamation announcing November as Native American Heritage Month for 2013, and if I remember correctly, November 23 as Native American Day for 2013.
Both those dates show the inability of Barak Obama, the man who stuck his nose into the Martin/Zimmerman affair and made the speech about blacks and their inability to get over their feelings about the history of slavery and racism, to remotely understand the significance of the month of November and the proximity of his allotted Native American Day to Thanksgiving, to the annihilation of the Indian, his culture, his family, his way of life, his ancestral home, and his future.
How could a black man, who claims to know how the descendants of slaves, still living today under the yoke of bigotry, poverty, lack of resources and opportunity, miss the obvious fact that November, like October which celebrates the coming of Columbus, is NOT a month to proclaim as a "Native American" ANYTHING?
Any Native American Heritage Month should be during the warm Spring or Summer months so that Tribal gatherings and festivals can be celebrated in the outdoor arms of Nature, with displays of art, dance, and things of that nature. It should not be a by product mixed with a white man's holiday that celebrates the taking of the Indian's homeland by genocide, lies and centuries of prison camps.
Thank you for saying you would support a National Native American Heritage Day and Month.
I have NEVER seen that - really cute.
Curious what he means by " do hereby proclaim November 2013 as National Native American Heritage Month. I call upon all Americans to commemorate this month with appropriate programs and activities, and to celebrate November 29, 2013, as Native American Heritage Day. "
Who gets to define appropriate?
Dear Friend 1st Warrior: Joint ventures may be helpful here. Ask our good friend Kavika about some of the joint writing and advocacy projects he and I have done together. Involving your friends is a good idea in the good things you do.
Regarding this specific article topic, what I think about mascots is that any mascot which uses a group image should listen carefully, and seek the counsel of that group. Sensitivity isn't transmitted genetically. It comes about through open dialogue, education, and good faith attempts to arrive at a consensus which is acceptable to all stakeholders. At a very minimum, toinsure mutual respect for all stakeholders.
Peace and Abundant Blessings to you and yours, my good friend. Know that I fully support your educational efforts here. Also, that I am not alone in mybest wishes for what you do.
Enoch.
Dear Friend Screminmimi: You raise an excellent point about Native Americans in service to the United States.
No other group has a higher proportion of people in uniform to their percentage of the population than Native Americans. This is a documented fact.
More light needs to be shed on the bravery,achievements, and ultimate sacrifices of Native Americans to the United States in combat roles.
Credit earned is credit due.
Peace and abundant blessings, Enoch.
This is Wolf's time of the year, and, in a way, I really envy him with his connections to Mother Earth and our four-legged, winged, swimming friends - I'll save my thoughts about envy with the two-leggeds after more study
Mimi - all of us feel and believe education with an occasional mild confrontation, in an educational manner, will gain understanding similar to the honey vice vinegar adage. Many of us feel as though we are nothing more that small stones in the chasms of the Grand Canyon with our total lack of knowledge - but we try to pass on what we have.
Thank you so much for your beliefs and understandings - and your support and teachings. I respect you for being as you are and who you are.
And really, curiously, why hasn't any president done so? Mr. Collier, back in the days of formation of the Indian Reorganization Act, even tried to get something going - still - nothing. I mean, we have national chocolate eater's day - jjjjeeezzzzzz.
I just found a really neat site about holidays observed for each month. There are many observed for American Indians! So, if they have all of this, why can't our presidents declare them nationally?????
And as much as I LOVE chocolate, this is so ridiculous.
But, ya still love chocolate
And, RW, you know as well as I and everyone else in the world - Superman and Batman are fictitious characters - so is the "All knowing man" in the Himalayas. There is no one person qualified to hold that position 'cept maybe Creator - but, he's busy trying to rid the world of racism
As sad as it is to say - the most viable party to play that part would/could/should only be the newly formed Tribal/White House Council. They've only had one meeting, they're getting ready to hold # 2 - we have to give them a chance as they grow.
The problem that I have with that 1st is that there are no Indians or Indian organizations on the ''council''...At least there were none when the council was formed.
No, and there shouldn't be - the Council is the government's side of the G2G consultation program. The tribes are the other side of the equation.
Since they've (the government) has only met once, they are still trying to get their feet on the ground and develop the G2G communications process that will involve such a large group of people. The tribes have a "pretty fair" idea of how it should be handled, but they have admitted they also need to fine-tune what their expectations are.
But - until they both meet and conduct their first meeting - all we can do is wait and pray - at least, that's what I'm gonna do
Oh no, having to pray is not a good sign.
That's just my back-up plan
Ya can't slam'em 'til they screw up