This is the Most Outrageous, Immoral Attack on Obamacare Yet -
While Republicans wage a futile battle against the Affordable Care Act in the House and Senate, conservative activists are trying to sabotage the law on the ground. In particular, they want to keep young people out of the health insurance exchanges, which are scheduled to go online in less than two weeks. For one right-wing group, that means scaring college students and young women in particularwith the specter of government intervention, in the most literal form possible.
As reported by Yahoo's Chris Moody , Generation Opportunity, a Virginia-based group that is part of a coalition of right-leaning organizations with financial ties to billionaire businessmen and political activists Charles and David Koch, will launch a six-figure campaign aimed at convincing young people to opt-out of the Obamacare exchanges.
The first event is a college tour, scheduled for the end of month, where the group will try to counter-program against pro-health reform activists. To kick-off the tour, Generation Opportunity has released a few ads, with a straightforward message: If you sign up for Obamacare, the government will molest you with a medical instrument.
There's a second video that shows a similar scenario, except with a young man receiving a forcible prostate exam. Again, featuring the same Burger King-esque Uncle Sam. At the risk of sounding like a concern troll, I'm not sure this is a smart approach for conservatives or anyone else affiliated with the Republican Party.
Tags
Who is online
93 visitors

dirty little secret: there really are death panels, who do not answer to the electorate.
so go ahead, pretend they dont exist.
and if you like the efficiency and solvency of the postal service, your gonna love irs-care.
and some thought it bad when we discovered the irs asked what we pray, what books we read...soon the dems will be able to use personal medical information against any of their apponents as well.
cant wait to have to tell my dr how many guns i own, or a helpful obamacare rep when my last gyno check was.
yup, its GONNA BE JUST WONDERFUL
thanks libs, thanks
These kind of republican/conservatives are the lowest, most vile form of humans in existence. This goes way beyond politics and ideology to a class hatred.
This Republican Right Wing Party and supporters will be recorded in the History books as the worst, lowest forms of human behavior, the idea of putting out lies to prevent citizens from obtaining health care for themselves and their families should (in my opinion ) be a criminal offense, the idea of scaring young people into believing lies, which could cause them harm, should be punishable to many years in prison, when an organization, intentionally puts out false information and causes the harm of another human being, should that organization not be held accountable for perhaps thousands if not millions of young people's well being?? young people who are not yet fully aware of corrupt intentions?? Goodness, they are lucky I am not in charge and we live in a democracy, these are moments when freedom or speech should have its limits...
Is it good politics? No
Is it 100% accurate (or close to 100%)? Probably not
Is it funny? Well a lot of the folks that I have talked to about it say they laughed like hell when they first saw it but agree that the information level is low
A couple of the guys said it is the image of Creepy Uncle Sam is what they think of when an IRS audit is on tap......
But it is funny
You know that this big headed Uncle Samwith a girl in a hospital gown will be the next husband and wife Halloween costume craze.
Hal
I think you can see the future
Well done!
CM
If stretching the truth on policy and politics was a criminal offense the Capitol and the White House would be vacant as all who work in both places would be incarcerated.
Well, not a bad idea, I wouldn't mind seeing some being locked away starting at Wall Street and working its way up..Fannie Mae, Lehman Brothers, Goldman Sacks, Gov. Corzine, too many to remember at the moment...
CM
If you think distortion of the facts in promoting policies is solely a republican problem you are sorely mistaken
It is a political trait that knows no party affiliation
Rescue..... I understand you have this difficulty in putting links up to back up your assumptions.
I did mention Corzine, the name that comes to my mind, and Fannie Mae, these were Democrats to my memory, I wont exclude the Clintons, but I must also mention the Bushes..too many to recall at this present time...
Yea.... they are probably the same ones who were going to throw Granny off the cliff.
I say "Take the government's hands off my welfare."
NO arguments form me on any of the names you mentioned and add to it Gingrich, Boehner, Pelosi, Reid, McConnell et al
The IPAB will be able to stop certain treatments its members do not favor by simply setting rates to levels where no doctor or hospital will perform them, Dean wrote in The Wall Street Journal .
Read more:
Follow us: @thehill on Twitter | TheHill on Facebook
the house should have passed it on Christmas eve, at midnight, without reading any of it first.
Where in the world you get the idea thats its Liberals want your medicaal records and that would instead be the Republicans so they can go back to denying health care to those with a previous illness. Obama Care stopped that and apparently you like the idea of no insurance for the sick. Why in the world would you agree with the Capatalist right wing agenda.
Rescue couldn't have said it better myself.
I'm trying to figure out what she is even trying to imply. What, is the IPAB going to say hip replacements can only cost ten bucks? Or are they going to set reasonable rates for hip replacements, but only if the patient is under a certain age? What a ridiculous attempt at fear mongering - calling such a blatantly discriminatory tactic "simple", without getting into howitcould actually ever be accomplished.
Rescue
You seriously need a sense of humor, the storyline of the ad is piss poor I agree but as I said the character was funny
Did you read the comment I made saying I disliked the ad's content and intent but that it was funny?
Lighten up
Rescue
You know if you think back a bit the advertisement that the Democrats ran that showed a "republican" pushing granny off a cliff was equally disgusting if not more so but there was a lot less whining and bitching about it
Interesting
Rescue
Always enjoy reading comments from folks who are (in a written form) showing their a$$e$
My advice to Americans: "Don't get sick."
Go ahead, prove they do.
Prior to the PPACA, the health insurers who stopped the coverage on women who were diagnosed with breast cancer were the death panels.
You're the prototypical ill-informed right-winger who spouts the misinformation foisted on the willing-dupe base.
Learn what's actually in the law before you spread what isn't.
But Nancy said they had to pass it before they could see what's in it...
Well now that the rest of us have, it's time for you and the Tea Party and the willingly-duped right-wing base to not just learn what's in the law, but stop lying about it and unconscionably frightening people in order to try and negate Obama's legacy.
Better to misspeak and say something that sounds stupid than to create a well-funded pack of bullshit lies.
Well Rescue can make statements without any proof and Raven ask a stupid question as to where my links are and JW thinks YouTube links are useless. Personally I think anytime you can prove your point it is beneficial to expose the truth and that is why it must take some mighty dumb useful idiots to keep on supporting this fellow who is occupying the White House after all the proof he has spun right out of his lying mouth continuously for over 5 years now.
Just some of the latest useless examples that evidently goes right over the useful idiots heads
Now if anyone has any problems understanding these videos I'm sure someone with a little intelligence will be happy to try and help you out.
I have problems understanding the videos because I can't open them. Now, is there someone with a little intelligence who will be happy to try and help me out? I won't use proxy servers, so I guess it might be necessary for someone to have enough "little intelligence" to paraphrase in text form what the videos indicate.
Tell you what; list one "lie" at a time and I'll address each one.
In another thread, I exposed the "Generation Opportunity" ad, its origin, its financiers and the President of that organization. The ad has no factual information about the PPACA except the inadvertent message that no one is compelled to buy insurance under "Obamacare."
I also explained that no one pays a penalty/tax unless he tries to game the system by (i.e.) showing up uninsured at an E.R. or clinic.
The ad is a potentially deadly piece of propaganda in that it uses dishonest implications to frighten college students into not being insured. Some may get seriously ill, die possibly or get themselves into deep, inescapable debt should they become sick or injured and have to pay out-of-pocket for treatment.
I think it's BF's article that posts the video; that's where I gave the specifics. The video is insidious.
As for the second video you posted, Obama is correct; the debt ceiling is not about spending more money; it's about paying the debt that Congress has already approved! By defaulting, the U.S. credit rating tanks and the interest on our debts gets increased by our creditors costing us more money -- the market will tank, 401ks will tank as well.
And Reid is correct in his video because he's referring to how defaulting will increase our debt via creditors increasing the interest on that debt. That information wasn't included in the video -- wonder why?
You're being conned but not by Obama my friend. Do you think I simply make up my rebuttals? I do my homework, offer specifics to back what I contend and invent rebuttal from all who can do so with specific counter points, not rhetoric or bumper-sticker arguments.
video #1 is Obama criticizing Bush for raising the debt ceiling during 2008 campaign.
Video #2 is Obama saying raising the debt ceiling doesn't raise the debt yesterday.
Video #3 is Reid condemning the Republicans for wanting to raise the debt ceiling in 2006.
I don't know if this worked or not.
Sixpic,
You misunderstood what Obama was saying; raising the National Debt is to raise the amount of borrowing the U.S. does from China, etc. . Raising the debt ceiling is paying the debt that Congress has already approved. Big difference.
The United States debt ceiling or debt limit is a legislative restriction on the amount of national debt that can be issued by the Treasury . Because expenditures are authorized by separate legislation, the debt ceiling does not actually restrict deficits. In effect, it can only restrain the Treasury from paying for expenditures that have already been incurred.
The United States public (national) debt is the outstanding amount owed by the federal government of the United States from the issue of securities by the Treasury and other federal government agencies. US public debt consists of two components: [ 1 ]
Public debt increases or decreases as a result of the annual unified budget deficit or surplus. [ 2 ] The federal government budget deficit or surplus is the difference between government receipts and spending, ignoring intra-governmental transfers. However, some spending that is excluded from the deficit (supplemental appropriations) also adds to the debt.
I guess in the first video the criticizing Bush for raising the debt limit to nearly $9 Trillion and how he is putting everyone in the country in debt for $30 thousand plus isn't what I heard. I have longer versions of the recordings as well, but when you hear it from the horse's mouth I think that should be sufficient to see he is criticizing Bush for raising the debt limit when he has nearly doubled the debt limit and then turns around and says it isn't raising the debt. The first video certainly indicated that to be the case, don't you think? I am aware it is covering what has already been spent as you've indicated, but the misleading of the public by Obama is the point and then nearly doubling the debt since he has been president is hypocrisy and plain out lying to the people by misleading them.
The third video is Reid not wanting to raise the debt. I have an entire video of it, so I know what he is doing as well.
We disagree.
I'm still your friend.
I wouldn't have it any other way. Thank you.
Will it go Round in Circles????
Billy Preston:
And There is Another:
Al Green - A Change Is Gonna Come:
Rescue
The meaning behind what Ms. Pelosi meant has certainly been distorted over time but she did say the bill needed to be passed before people could see understand) what the bill actually entailed -
Pelosi misspoke -- it was a poorly chosen set of words; Republicans on the other hand have run an endless, well-funded campaign of lies about the PPACA -- prioritize the indignation for heaven's sake!
A MAc
Perhaps you are right, she misspoke but nonetheless she said it which is the point I was making and that others have made
A person in her position should not misspeak on an item of this importance wouldn't you agree?
I agree; but we all make embarrassing statements. Naturally, the more significant the issue, the more embarrassing and potentially damaging the statement.
Making a mistake is not the equivalent of lying.
A Mac
Ever hear of the false equivalence strategy?
That George W said a lot of stupid things does not excuse or give license to others to say stupid things
Robert in Ohio,
I neither implied that one gave license to the other nor excused bonehead comments. My intent was to show that we are all human regardless of our status in life.
Bring something of substance instead of rehashing what has become a tired substitute for refraining from saying something when there's nothing new to say.
A Mac
Isn't that exactly what you are doing by simply discounting the fact that she said what she said and parroting the party line that it doesn't matter and she didn't mean it and bringing nothing new and of substance to the discussion?
Just wondering
rescue
Good points
A question for you
How much in dollars has the national debt increased under Pres Obama in comparison to the other presidents you mentioned?
I didn't raise the Pelosi quote did I? I responded to the comment that did, acknowledged that Pelosi misspoke and illustrated that other important individuals do the same -- and that we all, as fallible, imperfect human beings do as well.
I find that those who knock "Obamacare" either offer no specifics as to why they knock it, or, more often, knock it by citing false information they get from the Tea Party/Ted Cruz/Koch Brothers misinformation campaign. When I challenge a detratctor to cite specifics about the law so that I may address them, they don't.
So they go to the Pelosi thing instead.
So now, you need no longer wonder.
These bumper-sticker mentality, oft-repeated gaffes come from those who wish to make a partisan point have little or nothing else with which to make it. Some merely raise Pelosi name, make some crack about her face and get a rise from the sycophant crowd.
It's weak and without substance.
A Mac
The subject of the article is Obamacare, a pronouncement concerning the legislation by the Majority Leader at the time is a logical point to be made.
As I said you may be right about her misspeaking or not knowing what she was talking about or simply saying something stupid, but you use the same clichd responses tot he point being brought up that have become bumper sticker/campaign speak themselves.
So you are doing what you complain about others doing.
That was the point
Have a good day
She did say it, and it's true of all legislation. Like, when will we know what the budget Congress will be?
The Legislative Process: Resolving Differences
"The receiving chamber may also respond with a counterproposal, and so on. This back-and-forth trading of proposals by the House and Senate is called amendment exchange, or sometimes simply ping-pong. For the bill to have a chance of becoming law, one chamber must eventually agree to the proposal that the other chamber sent it. Sometimes, the resolution of differences between the House and Senate proposals may instead be accomplished through a conference committee ."
As the House had already passed its bill, we were waiting for the Senate to act when Pelosi said that.
Cletus
And I am sure that is what she was referring to when she said it /s
As I have said a number of times, what she said and what she meant are a matter of debate and have been distorted and characterized by both sides but the bottom line is that she said it.
Robert -
agreed.
Cletus
The question was
Now, let's look at the DEFICIT (caused to a great extent by the Bush Tax Cuts that killed revenue while necessary spending continued
Last week the Congressional Budget Office (CBO) reported that, through the first 11 months of fiscal 2013, the budget deficit was down 35 percent from the comparable period of 2012.
Thats a pretty steep decline.
The federal budget deficit has fallen faster than we expected a few years ago, wrote CBO director Doug Elmendorf on his blog .
Robert in Ohio asserted,
Can you cite my "cliched responses"?
By "bumper sticker" I refer to what is also known as "dog whistle" or "buzzwords" used by those who don't bother to cite facts as a basis of their argument. That's not a cliche, IT'S ABOUT CLICHES USED BY ZEAL-WITHOUT-KNOWLEDGE SYCOPHANTS!
You have a good day yourself.
Take it up with the CBO. Not all simplistically asked questions have simple answers.
That graph provides a brief overall examination of the general issue.
I know what the question was you can't go by dollar amounts because economies change what you want to know is expressed by percentages.
Debt will usually increase even when spending is level if revenue declines because of the Bush Tax Cuts (which extended into Obama's first term), more borrowing from China, et al was done. And, when the Republicans fucked with the debt ceiling, the U.S. had to pay higher interest on its debt -- thus adding to the debt itself.
He knows, that's why he wants to look at dollars rather than % of GDP.
I've explained that; the value of the dollar fluctuates so the most "objective" barometer is percentage.
A Mac
The national debt has increased more under President Obama than under any other president.
Period - end of sentence
That is a fact!
You and the rest of the Obama apologists can spin and deflect and explain all you want but that is the fact.
No one is saying that there are not unusual circumstances involved in the increase and no one is personally blaming Obama but the facts are the facts
I know you are too intelligent to not understand that
rescue
That is a factor but it does not detract from the fact that by the time Pres Obama is out of office the national debt will have increased far more during his administration than under any other president in history.
Fact without spin or deflection.
Raven
Thanks for getting ignorant and personal
I made up nothing I asked a question which all the Obama apologists are loathe to accept the answer to
You choose rather than to debate the topic to attack which is becoming more and more typical around here
Cletus
You and A Mac are spinning away
The fact is that during the Obama administration the national debt will have increasedmore (far more) than any during any previous administration.
You should either disprove that fact or accept it
Or you can continue whining, spinning, deflecting and apologizing
rescue
A Mac
Cletus
None of you have answered the question of how much, in dollars, the national debt has risen during the Obama presidency?
Another question, at the current pace by the end of the Obama administration in 2016 will the national debt have risen more, in dollars, than under any other president in history?
The second one is a YES or NO question so you will have to work real hard to continue your apologetic spinning
Robert,
I try always to explain my positions -- for several reasons:
1) It's the only legitimate way to make one's case
2) While it should deter redundant questions regarding any given position, if it does not
3) It puts the one(s) asking redundant questions in a light that reveals them to be either not knowledgeable enough to debate the issue at hand, unable to mount a viable rebuttal and/or appear to be so biased as to be blinded by that bias.
If some arsonist sets a forest fire during the term of Fire Chief X and, on the tenth day of the fire, Chief X retires and Chief Y takes his place, are the ten days of damage to the forest the result of the actions/inactions etc. of Chief Y?
And because the arsonist is no longer at the scene of the fire he started, does that make him not culpable or negate his guilt?
Like it or not, George W. Bush was both the "arsonist" and "fire chief" when the U.S. economy began to burn. Obama has to put out the "fires." Analogously, he's reduced the fire's footprint by 50% since taking office.
Don't talk down to me regarding intelligence; rebut if you can and refrain from over simplifying realities and then declaring victory.
Let's get one other point on the table; the cost THE DEBT for Bush's Iraq war was never placed on the books by his administration; Obama, upon taking office, reported that previously unrecorded cost/debt and guys on your side of the fence tie that to him! Exaccerbate that by recognizing the mounting deficit caused by revenue shortfalls from the Bush tax cuts and the interest!
That piece of the National Debt and the interest on the money borrowed to fund it were properly included under Obama! BUSH HID THEM!
A MAJOR PORTION OF THE DEBT WAS ACCRUED BY GEORGE W. BUSH BUT IT DID NOT APPEAR ON THE LEDGER BECAUSE HE HID IT! You cannot justifiably put both the deed and its obfuscation on Obama.
Is that clear now? And now that you have the facts, on this topic if no other, you and I are of equal intelligence, so, don't blow it going forward by trying to prove that 2+2=5.
A fact that you fail to explain as to why it may be so. A misattribution of cause and effect. That's either disingenuous or, the result of a lack of knowledge. Either way, your conclusion fails to incorporate its reasons.
Read my explanation and "forest fire" analogy.
Robert in Ohio wrote,
You mention an EFFECT but you mis-attribute its CAUSE! When you are corrected and accuse those correcting you for being "Obama apologists," you compound your positions faults and bring attention to a fault of your own.
Your question is simplistic and predicated on a wrong assumption. It implies that the dollar amount is entirely Obama's doing.
He didn't start the fire. Do you understand the metaphor?
A Mac
YOu are not as intellectual as you think you are
Of course I understand he metaphor and if you read back through the damn comments you will never once see where I say that the events that cause the debt to rise were all Obama's fault.
but you are too bust apologizing for him and defending him, even when he is not being blamedfor anything to answer a simple question.
Your idolatry of Pres Obama blinds you to facts and to actual discussion
The points yu and others have made about outside factors causing the debt to rise and economic factors playing a role in the actual dollar increase are valid but so is the point that I made and you and others refuse to acknowledge as a fact.
That is
When the Obama administration ends the national debt will have increased more during the Obama administration than under another president in history.
You call a simple question simplistic but the fact is the question and the answer are simple and easy to understand they just do not paint your hero in the best light so you spin whine, deflect and change the focus.
You should be careful getting on and off your high horse that you do not injure yourself.
Keep digging the hole, Robert.
Even after I explained that a significant portion of the National Debt was accrued by Bush and not placed on the books (WHERE IT SHOULD HAVE APPEARED ALL ALONG) until Obama reported it, you still come back with
That's only so because Bush's debt was finally added in instead of hidden from the total! That portion of the National Debt was there before Obama took office.
Your overtly expressed disdain for Obama betrays you as a non-objective blame-layer. Presenting you the facts is not apologizing for Obama -- it's explaining to you the inaccuracy of your argument. Had you said the following, you'd be on solid ground.
"Because Bush's debt and its continuing interest/penalties were not added to the National Debt during the Bush years, rather, combined with any debt incurred after Obama took office, if in fact the National Debt DURING OBAMA'S TWO TERMS WILL HAVE INCREASED BY THE LARGEST AMOUNT UNDER ANY PRESIDENT, THE ACCURATE CONCLUSION WILL BE THAT THAT AMOUNT WILL REPRESENT THE DEBT ACCRUED UNDER TWO PRESIDENCIES -- Bush's and Obama's!
As for
And
Your frustration is showing.
I'm embarrassed for you.
Raven
I expect that everyone sould be able to do their own google search for facts but if that is too much for you folks - here you go
The Bush years
February 1, 2001 5,703,346,472,448.65
January 31, 2009 10,632,005,246,736.97
Increase = 5,692,714,266,711.68
The Obama years (so far)
February 1, 2009 10,632,005,246,736.97
September 21. 2013 16,738,503,812,337.79
Increase = 6,106,498,565,600.82
So with two plus years left to increase the debt, it has already increased under President Obama by $ 413,784,298,889.14 more than the debt increased under President Bush
I put the numbers in bold so that it would be easier for you to see them
A Mac
You are being more obtuse than usual today
Please look at the numbers above and let me know if they prove the point I made or not
Please look at the numbers (the facts) and do not spin or play word games with them
Did the debt increase more under President Obama than any other President? Yes or No?
J F T
No one thinks that
I asked a simple question and the President Obama fan club lost their mind apologizing and protesting that it was not his fault when I in fact did not say it was his fault.
J F T
NO explanation is needed you agree that the answer to my question is YES
Thank you very much
Raven
I am ignoring nothing
I didn't say it was Obama's fault I merely stated a fact and the Obama didn't do it brigade" lost their collective minds.
A Mac
You should be embarrassed for yourself
You were asked a simple question pages ago that you have failed to answer because you do not like the answer
No one says Obama is at fault and yet the debt will increase in the magnitude that I stated under his leadership
You should be embarrassed but for your own spinning, deflecting and whirling anything to ignore and avoid an uncomfortable fact
Sorry
Your conclusion may be correct -- that has not been refuted -- what's been refuted is the way you attribute the conclusion to Obama alone. Bush came into office with an inherited surplus -- so, to reach the debt level he reached, he had to eat up the surplus to get to a flat line then go from there.
Your conclusion will probably be accurate but the implication you place upon it is deceptive and disingenuous.
Yes but a significant portion of that increase is the debt that Bush accrued on a credit card but never included in the debt total while he was in office.
And let us not forget the bailout of the banks that were necessitated because of the failures of the Bush regulators and the stimulus package needed to keep the U.S. and world economy from going into recession and/or depression.
According to a team at Bloomberg News, at one point last year the U.S. had lent, spent or guaranteed as much as $12.8 trillion to rescue the economy. The Bloomberg reporters have been following that money. Alison Stewart spoke with one, Bob Ivry, to talk about the true cost to the taxpayer of the Wall Street bailout.
Oh had you mentioned any other names?
Back-peddling has begun.
Did you write this gem, Robert?
"Under his leadership" -- meaning what. Not quite the same thing as (i.e.) "For a number of reasons including circumstances and actions that occurred before Obama took office, the National Debt will increase more while he was in office than under any previous President."
That would have been an honest description.
But you've bashed us "Obama apologists" every step of the way, another way of implying that Obama is completely culpable.
And your latest
Are you implying he "did do it" -- that he is 100% responsible for the increase in the National Debt?
A Mac
Again you are in error when you say
you attribute the conclusion to Obama alone
that is simply a false statement
I stated that the debt would increase during the Obama administration and under Pres Obama I did not say it was his fault.
SO to use a word you like you either misspoke or intentionally misstated my position
Raven
In a word BULLSHIT
Where did I blame President Obama for the debt increase
Please show us all
I said it rose under his leadership and during his administration
I did not say it was his fault
It is you and your pack that are spinning and misrepresenting the truth here
A MAc
Thank you very much for acknowledging the fact that I stated and that is all that I stated
I did not say it was Pres Obama's doing or fault
It took a while but you finally answered the question and for that I thank you
I am sure that we will cross verbal swords again soon and until then I will bid you adieu and hope you enjoy the remainder of your weekend
A Mac
Try not to be obtuse
Under his leadership is simply another way of saying during the Obama administration or during the Obama presidency and you are well aware of that.
It is a far cry from saying that it is Pres Obama's fault which I have not said
J F T
I play at nothing
I presented a fact and you and the crew lost your collective poise and minds trying to refute a charge that was never made
No one said it was Obama's fault though many of you have had to point out that it was not when the only question presented was whether the debt would rise as I suggested during the presidency of Pres Obama
Careful that may be a mirror in front of you when you think you see someone playing stupid
That was predicated on a pair of Republican lies that preceded the ad:
1) Death Panels under PPACA
2) The lie about Obama taking $715 billion from Medicare to fund the PPACA; the $715 billion was taken from insurers overcharges to Medicare and placed back into coverage for seniors making Medicare solvent for an extended number of years.
You wanna' talk deceptive and ignorant claims I give you the Intelligencia of the Tea Party!
And do you acknowledge that the Bush unreported debt is a significant part of the National Debt and that it belongs in a fair explanation?
Also yes or no.
NOTE: No bad feelings Robert; an emotional, spirited debate.
Economic Downturn and Legacy of Bush Policies Continue to Drive Large Deficits
Economic Recovery Measures, Financial Rescues Have Only Temporary Impact
Robert G, I thought you'd never ask!
My man! I knew you knew that the debt and the deficit are inseparable.
I don't know how much acceptance I would have in that graph A Mac . The data points seem to be all projections .
As Yogi Berra once said : Predictions are very hard ... especially about the future .
That kind of personal insult is uncalled for; I can't moderate here because I've commented but as one member to another, please -- that's not good for our site.
He also said, "If you come to a fork in the road, take it."
So, provide a prong of your own. Anyone can disagree, but providing a more reliable alternative is what makes a dissenting opinion viable.
I can't provide a more reliable alternative . I am expressing the opinion that a predictive graph without confidencelimits could easily be useless ...
Then again, in the absence of anything specific in the way of an alternative, let the record show that the graph might just as well be deemed "useful" particularly in that it bases any implied "predictions" on that which is documented prologue.
However, your opinion is so noted and it too shall appear on the record.
Can't you translate that into English ? I was not a liberal arts major in school ...
I was in the gifted slow track myself.
Hmmmm. "Documented prologue."
"Written stuff about shit that happened earlier."
Perhaps a less prejudicial and more objective manner of describing the debt would have been to indicate it by spans of years (even though they differ) rather than by respective presidents, and providing the caveat that there are factors included in the more recent time span that were not included previously which makes a comprison between them illogical.
However, I confess I know little about the economics of the matter, but only can detect the prejudicial manner in which it has been described.
Obamacare itself is outrageous and is killing both jobs and the economy.
Even before going into effect it is responsible for the increasing income disparity between rich and poor.
The Fed's QE, being perpetuated by continued high unemployment, is making rich stock investors richer while Obamacare is leading to hiringmainly low-wage, part-time workers so employers can opt out of participation..
The graphs are accurate but Blodget's interpretation is dissembling nonsense. First, let us see the author's background:
If he is blaming Obama's mismanagement on Bush, should he be similarly blaming Bush's far lesser "mismanagement" on the recession he inherited from Clinton? Do you remember Clinton's dot-com boom, the Enrons and Worldcoms that burst just as Bush entered office, and whose pieces he had to pick up?
Let's compare apples and apples. Obama's mismanagement is his own; not Bush's.
One way to compare the severity of what I will call the Clinton and Bush recessions (leaving Obama out of it for now)is by the stock market declines. For the Dow-30 Industrials, the Bush decline was worse; 54% (2008-2009)vs. 37%for Clinton's(2000-2002).
But for the NASDAQ-100, the Clinton decline was far worse; 83% (2000-2002)vs. 54% for Bush (2008-2009).
On this basis, Bush inherited at least as severe a downturn as did Obama. Instead of twisting facts, as did Blodget, the most straightforward way to compare Obama and Bush is by the outcomes. On this basis, Obama has been a disaster in his non-management notwithstanding Bush-appointee Bernanke's (and Blodget's)valiant efforts to rescue him.
A Mac
No doubt - the debt increased by nearly 6 trillion during the Bush administration and the policies of prior administrations are always complicit in the early years of a new administration's fiscal gains or losses.
No worries on my feelings I have a thick skin and I sense that you do as ell
The verbal dust ups are a fun challenge for me and I bear no one any ill will
See you and the others around
Robert G
If your questions are for me,
I don't know.
I believe you are correct the debt is serviced monthly (interest is paid) and sometimes a little is paid on the principal (bout not very often in past decades)
J F T
Congratulations I did not know you had a child here on NT
Actually we do pay the interest on our debt on monthly/quarterly/annual basis that is called servicing the debt and it is part of the operating budget of the federal government,
You are right though we are operating at a deficit and are adding new debt continually in order to do that, but we are indeed paying the interest on all of the debt, sometimes incurring new debt to pay the interest on the old.
J F T
Those are the numbers from the US Treasury so your beef is with them not me
It is a fact, and a complete sentence. It is also true of most Presidents. (see my following post)
Many use the debt to GDP ratio.
For example, from the Heritage Foundation:
How Much Debt Is Too Much?
U.S. Debt by President
President Barack Obama: First Term = $5.073 trillion
President George W. Bush: First Term = $1.267 trillion. Second Term = $2.027 trillion. Total = $3.294.
President Bill Clinton: First Term = $496 billion. Second Term = ($559 billion surplus). Total = ($63 billion surplus).
President George H.W. Bush: First Term = $1.03 trillion.
President Ronald Reagan : First Term = $733 billion. Second Term = $679 billion. Total = $1.412 trillion.
President Jimmy Carter: First Term = $253 billion
President Gerald Ford: Three Years = $181 billion.
President Richard Nixon: First Term = $64 billion. First Year of Second Term = $6 billion. Total = $70 billion.
President Lyndon B. Johnson: Two Years in First Term = $7 billion. Second Term = $35 billion. Total = $42 billion.
President John F. Kennedy: Two Years in First Term = $11 billion.
President Dwight Eisenhower: First Term = $3 billion surplus. Second Term = $19 billion. Total = $16 billion.
President Harry Truman: First Term = $1 billion surplus. Second Term = $4 billion. Total = $3 billion.
President Franklin D. Roosevelt: First Term = $13 billion. Second Term = $11 billion. Third Term = $172 billion. Total = $196 billion.
etc.
(Source: OMB, Table 1.1Summary of Receipts, Outlays, and Surpluses or Deficits: ... )
This also answers your initial question, about the debt in raw dollars under President Obama.
Well, philosophically speaking, not everyone has a place in eternity.
Otherwise, disagreeing with you is not to be confused with being confused.
NOTE: Yes -- those are you know; those Q things.
And as that site's administrator, you do a heckuva' job Brownie!
Did you think there would be no accolades?
Keeping a debit off the ledger, whether secret or overt results in an inaccurate record; that Boobus americana is ignorant of certain political shenanigans, that, or willingly playing along, is irrelevant.
It is disingenuous to attribute the manifestations of a multi-faceted phenomenon to only a selected portion of those facets; in plain-speak, adding Bush's war, etc. debts to Obama's tally and then contended the debt is entirely Obama's doing to coin a phrase
is a fucking right-wing bullshit lie.
Other than that, I'm just proud to be a part of this discussion (except for the inaccurate and/or dishonest segments).
BF, I don't recall addressing you, but, since you crayoned the above
Rest assured, I have no intention of getting anywhere near you.
My apologies for ganging up on you and Robert G.
Robert G, this one's for you;
At the top you see Wars in Iraq and Afghanistan. During the George W. Bush presidency those costs were financed through supplemental spending that was not part of the appropriations process. In short, the funding was kept off the books.
But in a speech to a joint session of Congress in 2009, a newly inaugurated Obama announced the end to that deceptive budgetary practice.
But in a speech to a joint session of Congress in 2009, a newly inaugurated Obama announced the end to that deceptive budgetary practice.
But in a speech to a joint session of Congress in 2009, a newly inaugurated Obama announced the end to that deceptive budgetary practice.
But in a speech to a joint session of Congress in 2009, a newly inaugurated Obama announced the end to that deceptive budgetary practice.
Need to see it again?
Bush Deficit vs. Obama Deficit in Pictures
I would add, on the other side, that much of the 'Bush era tax cuts' President Obama has promised not to change, i.e. cuts for the bottom 95% (or so).
quandry: the liberal gives obama a pass for his exempting his buddies - mostly uber rich 1% - from parts of obama care, but says -------- to the rest of us.
why is that?
That's like supposed to be a rebuttal right?
I certainly can see the butt part
unfortunately, the factual part of your refutation seems to have been left in the butt
And yet, I have every faith that you'll pull it out.
All you need to do to make that comment viable, is to add something that will make it
viable.
Easy huh?
This is the Most Outrageous, Immoral Attack on Obamacare Yet:
Read more:
This is the Most Outrageous, Immoral Attack on Obamacare Yet:
if you like the delays our veterans are subjected to by a good example of fed medical efficiencies - the VA - your gonna love obamacare!
That's Tucker Carlson bullshit; the $35 billion would by not for the first year -- it would be over the course of TEN YEARS!
You and Karl Marx care about everyone.
It is self evident. $85 billion a month of newly printed moneygoing to banks who use it not for business loans, but to buy stocks. These goup out of proportion to a weak economy and sick job market.
Why? Companies have been increasing earningsby cutting laborcosts rather than increasing sales. Smaller businesses are limiting the number offull-time employees to 50 to avoid having to participate in Obamacare. Instead they hire part-time workers and limit them to 34 hours a week.
The rising stock market is enriching investors, and corporate moguls whose compensation is dependent on the firm's stock price, while unemployment, even absent a recession, is stuck above 7 % while discouraged applicants are leaving the labor force in record numbers. The major reason unemployment is as low as 7.1 % is because of the labor-force dropouts:
So Obama and Bernanke arethe unwitting reasons the rich are getting richer and the poor getting poorer.
And you Obama-haters and Groucho Marx are comedic.
We've seen all the incessant bullshit about Obama being a Communist/Socialist/Marxist from the right-wing hypocrites
who just last week were kissing Putin's ass!
How's that work?
'Bout time for that Social Security check huh, Len?
Got Medicare?
I wish Republicans would just opt out of America all togeather take their money and get the hell out.
Wait a second, they're a form of human?
Who knew?
Excellent. Robert is a racist thru and thru. Also a anti labor union and anti minimum wage and anti womens rights and may more anti's. Robert has always wanted the poor to pay their fair share in taxes when they are already in deep poverty.
Robert G and I disagree endlessly. He has expressed his disdain for unions and a number of other things, but I don't believe him to be a racist.
He's far from one of my favorites -- I think that's well known around NT -- is he misguided on a number of issues -- I think so, but I'm not convinced he's a racist.
Perhaps time will tell one way or another.
I'm a Dem who finds these sort of comments offensive, from either side.
We need at least two political parties. Right now the Republicans seem to me to be moving further to the right, thinking that will help their cause. Someday they'll realize how wrong they are and move back to the center.
The Health-Care-for-Prophet industry is the problem; it wants you to get sick and stay sick but not to die; it's about paying doctors based on the volume of patients they see, NOT HOW EFFECTIVELY THEY TREAT PATIENTS.
I DARE EVERYONE WHO HAS COME TO THIS THREAD TO DOWNLOAD AND WATCH THIS VIDEO -- I DARE YOU. Then I dare you to come back to the thread and LET'S HAVE A NO BULLSHIT DISCUSSION.
I DARE YOU!