7 Muslim engineers at a Boston reservoir at midnight?
Shortly after midnight on May 14, 2013, five men and two women, all of Middle Eastern decent, were arrested for trespassing within the boundaries of the Quabbin water reserve just outside Boston, Mass. The seven, who are from Saudi Arabia, Pakistan, and Singapore, are recent chemical engineering grads and cited their education and career interests for being at the reserve, according to local news reports . The seven individuals currently live in various Massachusetts towns including Amherst, Cambridge, Sunderland, and Northampton, and one of those arrested lives in New York City.
Tags
Who is online
96 visitors

A bit suspicious, dont' ya think? Chemical engineers, Muslims, water reservoir serving a major American city, midnight. I guess we shouldn't be concerned. The FBI and the Massachusetts State Police say they have no connection to terrorist activity.
I did not claim they were guilty of anything, merely very suspicious.
Hmm, because they are foreigners and Muslims you mean?
That is exactly what I mean. I have suggested that since 9/11 no one from Muslim nations should have been issued visas of any kind (excepting diplomats) to enter the U.S. and that persons from those countries with expired or questionable visas be immediately deported.
Yes, I wish for all U.S. citizens to have freedom and safety from the activities of Muslim terrorists (foreign or domestic) who wish to do us massive harm. I made no mention of limiting any of the rights of U.S. citizens.
Radical Islamists have declared war on the U.S. for over 20 years now. Muslim-Americans who sympathize with our enemies and aid them in any way should be under surveillance and dealt with the methods and laws currently in place.
I'm not necessarily disagreeing with mik, but how 'bout folks with a history of mental illness, domestic abuse and other acts of violence, drug abuse history purchasing or owning firearms?
All nationalities, all races -- aren't they a potential safety threat by virtue of their histories? Shouldn't they be under surveillance?
Shouldn't we have laws monitoring things like when they try to by guns?
My suggestions are related to one specific problem, Muslim terrorism in the U.S., not domestic abuse, gun control etc. You are free to address those issues on your own seed.
When the FBI goes after the Mafia, obviously they are targeting criminals within the Italian-American community. Not Germans or Swedes or Cambodians. If we all agree Muslim terrorists are an ongoing threat, it makes perfect sense to engage extra scrutiny on those within those communities.
I am not suggesting internment camps or anything of that sort, but for 80 years anyone who was a Communist or from a Communist country was either denied entry into the U.S. or watched closely by the FBI while they were here.
What would happen if they put 87 tons of LSD in the reservoir?
First, some facts:
The Quabbin Reservoir is only one of two reservoirs providing water for the City of Boston, and some 40 communities in the Greater Boston Area. It is quite large, with a capacity of 412 billion gallons. From the Wikipedia article:
Also re the article, there is a watershed protection plan in place. Y'all don't know what that means, but I do, as the Wellhead Protection Coordinator for Louisville Water, which is the same thing as watershed protection, but only in the square miles area that feeds the well field. That means that 1) security is in place, 2) the reservoir is tested daily for raw water quality, and 3) since it is a reservoir, thereare boocoos of water there, reportedly 412 billion gallons. (see picture in article.)
I can think of nothing that could be easily put in the water, in the quantities needed, to wipe out the reservoir. Nor would it be easy to dissipate a chemical in a reservoir that size. After all, one can't take a large spoon and just stir it in. Simple things, like gasoline, would require a giant tanker truck, or two or three, and by the time they even began to dump something in there, it would certainly be noticed and dealt with by security. Things like viruses and micro-organisms do not easily survive the treatment process, which is a complex process, because it is a surface water supply, which has a MUCH more rigorous treatment regimen.
Chemicals, while measured in ppb, or ug/l (parts per billion or micrograms per liter), are tested for daily, hourly, etc. While water supplies must test for a wide variety of chemicals down to parts per billion, one would still need gallons and gallons of whatever to actually do something that would be noticeable in the normal sampling regimen. And even with tanker trucks dumping something in there, it wouldn't be enough to actually kill fish, although it could be expensive for the water company to treat to get the chemical within Drinking Water Standards.
The people were very likely doing exactly what they said they were-- it looks like a nice place to go, at night, and have some fun. Here, we call it going down to the lake to have a Whoop-on Good Time. You know, sit with friends, watch the moon come up, drink a few beverages...
Security worked, as it caught them, after hours, and they were charged with trespassing.
I realize that after the Boston Marathon bombing, people are very "antsy" about Muslims but that doesn't mean that all Muslims are up to doing bad things, and in this case, it would require a LOT of a material to do something bad. You couldn't just empty a vial of something icky and expect it to wipe out thousands of people. For one thing, the person emptying the vial would likely die first, and for another, one vial out of 412,000,000,000 gallons is not going to have the concentration necessary to do anything.
This article's discussionis taking a tact that is racist, derogatory to a specific ethnicity, and takes everything right up to the edge of the CoC.
And how does someone living in Singapore be counted as Middle Eastern Descent? I thought Singapore was near Malaysia? Granted, they may all be Muslims, but so are the guys at work, and by golly, I'm fortunate to know them. So what? I could not find nicer people to work with. We have Jewish people, too, at work... Also Hindus, Buddhists, Daoists, Atheists, Agnostics, and lots of plain old wide variety of Christians. So what?
It would be great if everyone could just calm down and get their facts straight about water quality, watershed protection, and chemistry.
They probably don't want to hear that..... But then, people think that they are soooooo important to the world and have drastic effects.....
Think Geologic Time Scale and suddenly we become more humble.
Lol! We're hardly a dot on the landscape, geologically speaking...
Do you want to have a serious dialogue or make a mockery of a serious question by posing a stupid one?
And you are free to try and grasp analogous situations regarding the monitoring of potentially dangerous profiles.
Or not.
Individuals who appear to you and others, "terrorist-like", based NOT on their previous behaviors, RATHER THEIR ETHNICITY -- EVEN IF NEVER CITED, CONVICTED OR OTHERWISE CHARGED WITH ANY AGGRESSIVE OR ILLEGAL ACTS, are what's called "being profiled."
These guys at the reservoir should have known better than to act stupidly, I wholly agree, but being a Muslim, an African American, a Native American, a Jew, Catholic, Irishman, etc., is not a crime.
Your, "if it walks like a Muslim, quacks like a Muslim and looks like a Muslim then it must be a terrorist" is what precipitated my analogy. An abusive spouse with an AK47 is potentially more dangerous than a guy who looks like he prays in a Mosque!
Bingo, A. Mac.
Besides, what could they do? If they want to blow up something, I can think of a whole lot of other things to blow up...
I believe this was discussed when it happened here on NT.
Something to remember , look at the date , not even a month after the boston marathon bombing , another little known tidbit , on the grounds of the res , there is a closed observatory for viewing the stars and space built back in the early part of the 1900s away from what would today be considered "light pollution" from the more habituated areas, not many people know about it unless they look it up or are native to the area and have been told by their older relatives that use to visit the place ( which is how I know about the observatory).
Well, maybe they just wanted to look at some of the stars, then...
The time is suspicious, isn't it? Plus, they were tresspassing.
OvO,
Possibly I'm misunderstanding your point, or, it's possible we're actually in agreement to a point.
My issue is the profiling of a religion and concluding that all who even look like they are of that religion, or indeed practice that religion, are deemed "terrorists" on that basis alone. This is particularly baffling when the same ilk that does this, rejects things like background checks in conjunction with the purchase of firearms, even if known violent or unstable individuals might be the purchasers.
Are you seriously comparing "running with scissors" to the potential and real dangers associated with the verified violent and unstable members of society buying guns?
I understand using extreme examples to make a point, but some examples are so extreme as to be beyond reasonable or serious.
I neither advocate summarily rejecting/making to feel unwelcome, entire groups of foreigners, nor do I go to the other extreme, that being accepting all with no protocol or scrutiny.
Disagree. Your questions use examples that understate the implementation of quantification and well-know statistical levels of potential for dangerous outcomes under given circumstance -- to begin with exceeding speed limits by 1 mph or running with scissors starts well below the realistic.
If I failed to understand the meaning of your questions, I apologize.
Peace to you.
OVO, I don't think the point here is so much "foreigner," as it is time of day and trespassing. I would feel the same no matter who it was...possibly more so if white. My community well has a lock on the ground access (which could be broken), prison-style fencing directly surrounding the well and holding tank, and is fenced-in with more normal looking fencing at the perimeter. It's too bad that level of security has to be in-place, but it was paid for by the residents that deemed it's better to be safe than sorry.
One might take up swimming, but the boat ramp might be crowded the day the 87 tons needs to go in.
This was an earlier article on this.
Massachusetts: Seven Muslims caught trespassing at large public water supply; patrols stepped up statewide
...
Yes it was Mark. I put the link a few comments below.
The only non-immigrant coworkers around are Native Americans, when you really think about it.
We stepped up our patrols, too, here in Louisville. Just for general safety. Not about any one group, but it was a general, nation-wide thing, I think.
OvO,
Many rules, policies and even laws are formulated based on relative risk probability or the lack thereof; so are many of the moments and decisions in our lives. We do or fail to do many things based on how we assess/perceive the probability of outcomes -- 1mph over the speed limit isn't driving at double the speed limit and I dare say the risks increase in a directly proportionate manner.
It's a pleasure debating with you.
I agree, but i still think 'anyone' would be at that time of night.
I'm not too familiar with LSD. Peyote and mushrooms? Yeah.
Who would have thought the Boston Marathon bombers would do what they did? BUT THEY DID!!!!
The system should verify their identities and that in fact they are telling the truth about who they are, and obtain a reasonable explanation for why they were there - in other words more information than "satisfying their career interests". I agree with Dowser that it makes no difference whether they were white, black, yellow or green, Muslims, Baha'i or aliens from Mars - the whole thing to me is pretty damn fishy (so to speak).
Hi, Buzz.
Muslims around the country are making noises about being profiled. They have been denied the spotlight too long, you know.
As Muslims, even if what they were doing was totally innocent they would have known better than to be hanging around the reservoir at night. Heck, even white Christians would have known better. It was suspicious and they deserve to be thoroughly checked out.
It may all boil down to the fact that they did it so they could be caught, they could protest that they were being profiled, they could file a lawsuit, it could be quietly settled to avoid a tussle with the Muslim faction, and they could have some pocket money. It's being done, you know.
That is the tactic of the Westboro Baptist Church freaks. It is primarily a family of lawyers who go to funerals of soldiers and children with vile inappropriate signs. They seek to provoke distraught and angry people into violence and then sue for damages. Nothing but a racket.
By the way, there is an ongoing police investigation into these Muslim engineers. This matter has not yet been closed. It may not be a simple case of trespassing after all.
Yes, OvO, but you can damn well look it up yourself. Muslims, Hispanics, Blacks, White people who refuse to conform to the rules of the place they work then cry discrimination, atheists who apply for and win employment at places that follow Christian practices then claim discrimination because they have to view religious symbols in the work place....
it has become a method of getting both media recognition and a payday if you have a clever attorney or a group behind you.
What if you have the Constitution behind you?
I hope you post any updated information you discover.
At midnight - on private property, when there are plenty of public places to view the skies, they couldn't have been up to 'anything' good.
Well said, scremin, and an unfortunate fact that the media and the right lawyer can supersede ethics and individual control of their business or organization.
I also agree with you that I don't have to spend hours backing up 'everything' I say. With some things I provide links, because I want them to help make my point; but with other things, where a reader could just as easily look up bias Journalist talking points as I could, I see no point -- because it's an issue that will always be viewed from one 'side' or the other - even tho it shouldn't be.