President Obama and the War Powers Act
In 2007, Barack Obama was asked when Presidents have the authority to launch a military strike without congressional authorization.
He had a precise answer at the ready.
The President does not have power under the Constitution to unilaterally authorize a military attack in a situation that does not involve stopping an actual or imminent threat, Obama told the Boston Globe.
As intervention in Syria is pondered (actually some sources report that it is all decided and will occur tomorrow), we see the beginnings of another discussion of the president flip flopping(or perhaps his views have evolved over time) on amajor policy issue.
Should we intervene in Syria, there are pro's and cons on that question with both sides presenting convincing arguments on their points in my view. If recent history is to be a preview of the future then the ongoing violence and civil instability in Libya, Egypt, Iraq, Afghanistan and other locales where we have intervened in one manner or another should factor into the conversation.
The use of chemical weapons is to be abhorred and not allowed by the world community, but it is not the responsibility of the U.S. to police the world and get involved in civil conflicts better to allow the U.N. to take action and to support that action once other members have committed forces and weaponry to the effort.
The U.S. does not have a good track record in choosing and supporting new leaders when regime changes are orchestrated by our intervention into the civil unrest of a sovereign nation (e.g. The Shah in Iran and then when we facilitated the exit of the Shah the Ayotollah, Mubarack and then Morsi and now who knows in Egypt,Karsi in Afghanistan and notsure who is in charge in Libya, etc) and we certainly do not know what the rebels in Syria will bring to the country.
The matter should be debated and decided in the Congress before the U.S. takes actions and the presidents views in the past certainly support this approach.
In 2007, Obama was adamant that the President did not have the power to authorize an attack if there was no imminent threat to the U.S., PolitiFact wrote at the time.
But now he seems to have decided that informing the Congress of his intention to take action is sufficient involvement
The growing instability in Libya could ignite wider instability in the Middle East, with dangerous consequences to the national security interests of the United States, he wrote in a letter to Congress. Officials pointed to the possibility of an imminent massacre of rebel forces, but no immediate threat to national security.
So get ready for the debate of President Obama's flip flop on a major policy issue.
Stopping the use of chemical weapons is certainly important, but if that is accomplished and a regime change occurs which brings government equally bad or worse than Assad who will the world and the people of the U.S. look to as responsible.
Time will tell.
Source of cited material
http://swampland.time.com/2013/08/27/syria-intervention-would-reaffirm-obamas-biggest-flip-flop/#ixzz2dGYoHcW1
Read more: http://swampland.time.com/2013/08/27/syria-intervention-would-reaffirm-obamas-biggest-flip-flop/#ixzz2dGVecXVf
Tags
Who is online
88 visitors

To bomb Syria or not to bomb Syria (without the advice and consent of the Congress) that is the question.
My answer would be, do not bomb Syria, with or without the consent of Congress.
''America has no problem murdering civilians'', nor is their a concern for the troops in our ''Peace Keeping'' missions. How soon we forget Beirut and the 200 plus Marines and 50 French troops that were killed while on a ''Peace keeping'' mission.
Stay the hell out of Syria.
Despite his lies on the campaign trail( I'm going to be charitable and assume he understands the simple concepts taught to first year law students), the president clearly has the power to bomb Syria. The issue is one of duration. If we are still lobbing cruise missiles in 6 months, congressional authorization will be required. If the bombing is as limited in scope as is hinted in the press, congressional authorization is completely unnecessary if still a good idea.
Hopefully he realizes acting as al Qaedas Air Force is not in the best interest of the USA and walks away from the red line he stupidly created in a desperate attempt to talk tough. His totally unnecessary carelessness has put the country in an untenable situation. Either walk away and admit he was bluffing about "red lines" with all the implications that has for other rogue dictators or attack Assad and help al- Qaeda.
Kavika
I tend to agree based on the fact that it is virtually a civil war, which is an internal matter to a sovereign nation but the use of chemical weapons must be stopped thus the dilemma
Thanks for the perspective
Mike in Ga
The very important point
President Obama should not be making a decision to intervene or not intervene but should rather be supporting a UN intervention once the security council makes that decision
Thanks for the feedback
John
We are either a member of the U.N. which abides by the decisions of the U.N. or we are a rogue nation inserting ourselves into the internal affairs of sovereign nations
Mike in Ga
That is the bottom line
If we support the concept of the then we should be a member who abides by its decisions and does not act unilaterally.
There is no direct threat to the U.S.
BAdFish
Good points and an excellent perspective
I agree that our past track record I fixing nations that are having internal struggles is a "0 for"
The UN should step in to preclude the use of chemical weapons by either side and other than that the internal struggle should be settled internally
Robert, ''the use of chemical weapons must be stopped''...Agreed, but it is not the mission of the U.S. to act on it's own.
If the U.N. authorizes a strike, it will be the U.S. that leads the pack. This, I am totally opposed to.
Let the ME countries lead the pack. It's their problem and it's in their back yard. In other words the ME countries should ''put up or shut up''...
Kavika
I agree
Sean
If there is an imminent threat o the U.S. which is why I think this should not be an executive decision but one made through debate and consultation with the Congress
Any president should seek congressional approval before undertaking a war of choice, its just not required that he do so.
Sean
I merely provided what the War Powers Act says about committing the country to military against a sovereign nation without the Congress deciding on the action
But as you surely realize the rules and lawshave little to do with how governing is conducted in Washington these days
M C t y
If he uses the War Powers Act as justification it states that there needs to be an explicit threat to the U.S. and that is the rub at this point in my view
Getting in is not the issue, getting out is and more importantly effecting positive change by intervention is rare for the U.S. (e.g. Viet Nam, Iran, Iraq, Afghanistan, Libya, Egypt......)
Actually Bob, what we are dealing with here is the 1972, " War Powers Resolution " which expanded the War Powers act of 1941 and it does legally give the authority for Obama to interfere in the internal affairs of Syria and prolong the death and suffering of millions in that region.
The Legislative branch has been giving away it's authority, little by little, to the Executive branch for decades.
Not good.
Let the Arab League take care of it and it doesn't matter if Congress agrees or not, Obama will do exactly what he is ordered to do. He's a good comrade of the oil companies and Industrial War Complex. Whoops.....forgot the big banks of the world.
AeonPax
The intent of bot was that an imminent threat must exist
ut that is generally ignored I agree
About which Robert in Ohio warned
So let's see -- Obama writes a letter to Congress discussing the Syria situation BUT ROBERT CONCLUDES THAT WE SHOULD GET READY FOR AN OBAMA FLIP FLOP WHICH WOULD ENTAIL HIS NOT GOING THROUGH CONGRESS!
Did I get that right?
The hatred of Obama is such that virtually every event is exploited by the right, either speculating what Obama might do, and/or outright lying about what he did do or, failed to do.
What have we seen for six years got specifics?
Great specifics.
I can't argue with that.
I asked for specifics and you gave me generalities.
Mission accomplished.
A Mac
You are so busy apologizing for Pres Obama that you did not read what the president said
And if you sharpen your reading comprehension you will note that I said the decision would prompt a discussion of another flip flop by Pres Obama
I did not say that I viewed it as a flip flop just that the discussion would ensue - I do not think we should become involved but that is beside the point of the article.
You should read what is said before you try to rebut and whine about it
More generalities; I always ask for specifics and offer to address each, one-at-a-time, with either counter-points or agreement.
Anyway none of that here.
A Mac and Mr. Crazy
Let's all take a deep breath and relax
The article is about the likelihood of another debate on whether the President has flip flopped on an issue
Will there be one or not?
Let's discuss that point and not hold a hate party or a pep rally for the president or anyone else
Here's the sequence
You -- "The matter should be debated and decided in the Congress before the U.S. takes actions and the presidents views in the past certainly support this approach."
Followed by
Then
You -- "But now he seems to have decided that informing the Congress of his intention to take action is sufficient involvement"
NOW "HE SEEMS to have decided" -- HE SEEMS?
You subsequently talked down to me with
When you actually wrote initially
You -- "So get ready for the debate of President Obama's flip flop on a major policy issue."
You subsequently wrote
Don't talk down to me; you want to debate/rebut -- no problem, otherwise, the condescension makes you look defensive.
I agree; Mr. Crazy/Gunny etc. and I disagree politically all the time -- and friends can disagree and still be friends and respect one another.
I stand corrected.
A Mac
I never hid or denied my view that the congress should be involved
But the point of the story was whether people thought this would be viewed as a flip flop by Pres Obama.
Don't skirt that issue it makes you seem defensive
well okay then!!
A J K
Thanks for sharing your perspective
You make some good points but the fact is that he was pretty clear in hi statement when he was a candidate but alas that means little for any politician once elected
Thanks again for sharing your views
It is not the mission of the US to act at all. Arabs have been killing Arabs for centuries. There is no positive outcome for the US no matter who wins. However if Assad falls, mark my words, the peace that Israel has shared on the Syrian border for 40 years will be gone and the Christians will flee from persecution like they did in Iraq.
Robert,
Until such time if any Obama takes action against Syria, all talk about a"flip-flop" is speculative. It's one thing to speculate and question what might happen, but
implies that a so-called "flip-flop" is imminent; that's rather disingenuous.
And when a regime uses chemical weapons against civilians, is not that kind of unconscionable act egregious enough to speculate about what imminent threat Syria poses to the world.
Right-wingers speculate about what Obama might do and imply that he'll "flip-flop;" yet Obama is not afforded the benefit-of-the-doubt regarding his responsibility to speculate as to what imminent threat Syria holds for America and the world!
By the way; although we often have opposite political views, the same way I consider Gunny/Mr. Crazy a friend, I likewise consider you a friend as well.
Should we not have stopped Hitler?
96WS6
I do not totally agree, intervention could be justified if there is demonstrable threat to the U.S..
In my own, personal, humble opinion until then we have no business in a civil war, though steps to preclude the use of chemical weapons as a part of a UN effort (not a U.S. effort) would be more acceptable (at least to me)
A Mac
I could be wrong but I am pretty sure that there was a declaration of war related to WWII and the struggle to stop Hitler which makes it a little different from this situation.
A Mac
I believe that as the approach I took in the article when I said
You are right it is not a flip flop on the issue until and if the president takes action with debate and a resolution in the Congress, then the discussion can begin
You note what "right wingers" do and I sometimes note what "left wingers" do to defend the president no matter what the situation is - both approaches are done I the spirit of spuring debate.
I too have great respect for you and enjoy trading "verbal jabs" with you on most issues and be assured that not all of our political positions are "opposite". I wrote an article a long time ago about my political views (on NV) perhaps I will revive it as I am sure I will get thumped by both sides of the aisle on that one.
I hope that I did not come off as disagreeable, as I disagreed because that was not my intent.
Until later
My question was one of morality and conscience not of law or Constitutionality.
Agreed there are apologists on both sides.
And we are friends in my book; we all say things in the heat of debate that we should not have said I include myself in the "we."
Of course if we are directly threatened we must defend ourselves. This is not the case with Syria.
We had proof of what Hitler was doing. There are too many reasons for Assad not to use chemical weapons and I still have not seen concrete proof it was Assad and not a faction of Rebels that did it. I HAVE seen proof that AlQuida factions are working with the rebels and especially with Al Nursa Front which is the fighting group that is already much stronger than the Free Syrian Army (Rebels) and they are losing fighters to them every day.
...
there is a reason most people have not heard the name Mac. You have to look hard in our media. If Americans were as aware of this group as they are the Free Syrian Army (these guys are sketchy as hell as it is by the way) there would be no support at all for a strike, and that is why you have to look so hard.
I agree; but if incontrovertible proof materializes, then, even though a case against immediate imminent danger might be made, what do we do?
Hypothetically, had there been no U.S. declaration of war during WWII, if we had proof of what Hitler was doing -- what should we have done?
We should have gotten involved. it is unacceptable to indiscriminately execute people and commit genocide. I don't think that is the case in Syria, I honestly think it was Al Narsa and it was done to get US to do exactly what it looks like we are going to do.
A Mac
The question is about lawful action of the president and how they are perceived by the Congress and the people that is what this is all about
Using your logic we should be bombing N Korea and Iran and should have bombed Myanmar for years
Well it looks like "we the people" want to see more involvement and debate by the Congress before an intervention is Syria occurs -
But what the people think doesn't matter anymore or does it?
Nonetheless, the War Powers Resolution was a power grab by the Executive branch with congress's approval.
If my memory isn't mistaken, it was the sinking of a U. S. freighter, that was not carrying any military cargo, by a German sub that got us into WWII.
John McCain On Syria: 'We Can't Stand By And Watch This Happen'
And then there's
Rand Paul: War in Syria has no clear national security connection
A Mac
Nice to know what one person (Sen McCain) thinks but the poll data I cited was a cross section of the electorate
More important in my view
Not my point Robert; my point is that two prominent members of the right-wing can't agree on what's correct regarding American actions towards Syria -- but the righties are pretty single-minded that Obama's decision, whatever it will be
will be a wrong one.
same with the Democrats...
So what was your point?
Exactly. I was addressing my comment to a conservative in conjunction with his comment.
A Mac
I think, in this case, you are a little to quick to assume that all "rightes" feel the same way about this issue.
Just as there is split opinion on the right about what should be done and how the decision should be arrived at, there is an equally apparent divide among the "lefties" as to whether we should or should not get into another mess in the middle east.
So perhaps some public debate on he issue (ala the British parliament) might lead representatives and senators to advise the president based on how their constituents feel a to a course of action. You may find this hard to understand, but just as all Democrats do not blindly follow Obama neither do all conservatives think the same as Sen McCain
A Mac
One more thought
If the president goes it alone and things turn out as they usually do when the U.S. gets involved in an internal struggle then President Obama alone will bear the responsibility for the consequences - civilian deaths, escalation, spread of hostilities, etc
Another good reason for open consultation so that members of Congress are on the record with their support or opposition to intervention (regardless of party affiliation)
I'm referring to those here who bash Obama relentlessly, often with quips and one-liners, blanket criticism and seldom if ever with specifics. He has not made a decision on Syria but the usual Obama-detractors have accused him of what he might or might not do and editorialized on their own speculations.
If my grandmother had had testicles she would have been my grandfather.
And I agree that Obama should not act without Congressional approval -- BUT WE'RE STILL TALKING ABOUT CHILDREN WHO ARE BEING MURDERED! It's a dilemma but sometimes someone has to take the moral high road.
A Mac
Always appreciate an intellectual response to a serious comment
I have never disputed that action needs to be taken
A Mac
And that is a diversion from the topic we are discussing here
Whether it is prudent for Pres Obama to act on his own or to consult more fully with Congress and to allow for a vigorous public debate
I have not bashed Pres Obama yet you seem to be defending him in every comment
Did your article not bash Obama in advance of his taking any definitive action?
The (alleged) premise of the article is to discuss Obama and the War Powers Act; but the actual agenda is to castigate by innuendo, what he HAS NOT YET DONE, NOR, THAT WHICH HE MAY NEVER DO -- NAMELY "FLIP-FLOP".
And even if he acts contrary to a previous position, is it sometimes not prudent for any human being to reconsider what he once believed? Are we all so perfect as to never have changed our minds as time and circumstances dictate.
Show me where I have defended Obama in my every comment. Challenging those who prejudge is not the same as defending the actions (of someone WHO HASN'T TAKEN THE VERY ACTION HE'S BEING PREJUDGED FOR TAKING)!
If I'm defending anything, it's the philosophical concept of "innocent until proven otherwise."
In discussions, sometimes the tangents that arise are relevant; I didn't divert from the topic, I responded to the comments made along the way.
If I'm defending anything, it's the philosophical concept of "innocent until proven otherwise."
Except in the case of George Zimmerman.
IF you're alluding to my "If" response -- it was in conjunction with yours.
If Obama should do X,Y or Z, then it's subject to praise or criticism; but to imply that he'll do something for which he should be criticized is pretty much how the right-wing has treated Obama even before day one of his administration -- "innocent until charged."
As long as the unanswered questions continue to be unanswered, while the "verdict" may be "not guilty," the reality may be otherwise.
The JURORS have stated that the SYG statute was the reason they acquitted Zimmerman -- that they had no other choice. THAT'S THE JURORS! Zimmerman, based on the evidence was not proven "not guilty," that verdict was based on the technicalities created by a bad law.
FROM AN ANDERSON COOPER INTERVIEW:
COOPER: Even though he got out of the car, followed Trayvon Martin that didnt matter in the deliberations. What mattered was the final seconds, minutes when there was an altercation and whether or not in your mind the most important thing was whether or not George Zimmerman felt his life was in danger?
This is my son, Bright Star. This photo was taken in Beirut a few days before the suicide bomber struck the Marine Corp barracks, killing over 200 Marines and wounding many many more. We were a ''Peace Keeping'' force at the time. My son was one that survived, with TBI and right arm and leg paralyzed for life.
Yes, I have very strong opinions on this latest ''action''...Stay the hell out of it. The pain never leaves John, neither for him, me, his mother or sister.
Already explained that Mike and if you read my comments, you'll see exactly what my position is and the specifics.
As long as there are WAR PROFITEERS/THE MILITARY INDUSTRIAL COMPLEX who buy legislators, there will be wars fought, not only on principle, but for the $$$$$$$$!
And as long as Boobus americana votes on the basis of race, religion, gender and special interests instead of principle -- it will continue.
An end to both as we know them yes, or, an end to the way the base of both parties traditionally vote.
It look like Pres Obama has decided the best course of action is to get the authorization from the Congress to commit military force in Syria.
I hope that the debate and vote are swift by the House and Senate
Mike in Ga
Hard to disagree with the point you make
This needs to be a resolution to authorize the president to act and nothing else save the scope if any of that action which they are endorsing
A Mac
All I can add is a hearty "damn right" to that
The primary reason I'm a liberal/democrat is because I prefer my elected officials to lie and manipulate on behalf of the poor and middle class instead of that of the 1% folks!
Honest enough for you?
A Mac
Well I am an independent because I prefer that elected officials of either party not lie or manipulate at all but then I am disappointed quite often with that expectation.
I prefer people that vote for issues and values rather than for the party line and platform.
Not many of them on either side of the aisle any more
Hitler wasn't stopped because he was trying to wipe out world Jewry - in fact there were lots of countries and people (and still are) that would have cheered him on, Britain included. He was stopped because he was conquering other countries and was not going to stop until he ruled the world - including the USA.
Agree
AeonPAx
Hard to argue with that
A Mac
I wasn't alluding to anything I was openly mocking your comment
I have an appreciation for people that use absurdities in lieu of reasonable argument and always try to acknowledge in a subtle manner
Not sure if that's a compliment or a knock; my "IF" comment was intended to show why hypotheticals are not necessarily good arguments.
A Mac
Actually it was meant as a little of both and I hope and figured that you would discern that, but also that you would acknowledge that your "what if" was absurd while that posed about this situation is a logical possibility.
Hope you are having a good holiday weekend
Robert in Ohio,
We're cool I consider you a friend (in fact, I'm going to your home page to make sure of that); feel free to (figuratively) kick my butt any time you think or know I'm in error. Friends can disagree -- even heatedly -- and still be friends.
Same wish to you on the weekend.
A Mac
I have the same expectation of you - I learn little if people jut agree with me or tell e to screw off
It is the back and forth that enables a look at another point of view which is what I am always seeking.
My sarcasm gets the better of me sometimes but feel free to point that out as well
Me too. And you do the same when you think I need to be reigned in.
As a observer I call ''sarcasm'' on both Mac and Robert.
Kavika
I must plead.......guilty as charged!
Always good to get a bit of a laugh after a ''strong'' discussion.
Enjoy reading both your and Mac comments...
Here is alocal (sort of Cleveland is the closest city to our place in the country about an hour away) look at what people are saying doing in regards to the situation in Syria.
Remember the ''Free Speech'' movement, lead by Mario Savio'' at Berkley in 64..Which lead to the Vietnam protests a few years later. I wonder how many remember James Rector, who was killed by the police protesting the war at Berkley.
Or Eldridge Cleaver, ''Soul on Ice''.
Kavika
From all reports around here no violence at all at the protests, lots of speeches and yelling from people on both sides of the issue but good healthy public debate is what the country is all about in my view.
Sorry, that wasn't my point, it was the protest themselves, which lead to the end of the Vietnam war.
Protests are the thing that changed the war in Vietnam, perhaps if the protests get large and strong enough, the same will happen with Syria.
My adding Rector, was just a warning that the government is capable of anything when it comes to protests.
I'm sick of seeing our military in an endless war that does nothing but get Americans killed.
Kavika
Sorry the point flew so easily over my head
You are right of course that the involvement of "we the people" is a great motivator of change though in the age of tweets and social media sites actual physical gatherings of folks expressing their views are sometimes under valued