╌>

US Policy on Egypt - Standing Logic on its Head

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  jonathan-p  •  13 years ago  •  28 comments

US Policy on Egypt - Standing Logic on its Head

In order to be respected amongst your fellow nations, you do not necessarily have to stand in agreement on everything, but you do have to be consistent in your policy. The Obama Administration has shown support for the ousted Muslim Brotherhood government of Egypt, in contraventiontoprevious policy. The MB candidate was democratically elected, but that's where the democracy ended.Morsi very publicly attempted to wrest power from all other sources in Egypt in order topermanently install anIslamist government.That's when our responsibility to uphold Morsi's rule ended. Wedid not need to insert ourselves in the intramural conflict, but it was a clear signal and opportunity to distance ourselves from Egypt.

Let us pause for a moment to review who we stand against in the Middle East:

1)Iran - Islamist government, installed in 1979

2)Hamas - Islamist rule of Gaza since 2006

3)Hizbollah - Islamist control of much of Lebanon, gaining power since the 1990s

4)Tunisia - Islamist government, installed in 2011

The Muslim Brotherhood is an ISLAMIST organization, committed to ruling countries under ISLAMIC law, and a foe of the US in every quarter.

The logical choice in response to the military's taking back control of Egypt should have been one of tempered satisfaction. No need to celebrate in the streets and hand candy out to children; there was no need for anything more than a muted response of concern for the citizens of Egypt, and the hope that bloodshed would be kept to a bare minimum. Instead, we came out in support of the MB. The red herring of labeling Morsi the "democratically elected leader of Egypt" was paraded to the public as if it had meaning. After all the moves and machinations he orchestrated in order to take supreme power of the country. After disbanding the Supreme Court. After imprisoning political opponents. The "democratically elected leader" was not in favor of democracy, and he did not mask his intentions in any way.

Under military rule, Egypt was the quietest place in the Middle East. They had a peace treaty with Israel that has endured. They had more economic freedom than most Arab countries. They had full access to the outside world, which is more than can be said for most Arab countries.

If there's one thing we've learned about democracy in the last few years, it's that it's not for everyone. We've also learned that, when you attempt to push democracy on countries, it may reduce the stability of that country, while increasing the level of resentment against us.

This is yet another example of how we can't tell the difference between our friends and our enemies.


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
JoAnne Odel
Freshman Silent
link   JoAnne Odel    13 years ago

US Policy on Egypt (under barry)

give a speach, get a prize

issue apology memo

blame attack on a you tube video

support muslim bro's to oust ally

decline to define as ally/enemy

replace what difference does it make hillary with our soldiers caused atrocities heinz

...who the hell voted for this rodeo clown?

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   seeder  Jonathan P    13 years ago

We seem to be bogged down in America, in our inability to have the courage to identify our worst enemies. The Islamist doctrine is clear in it's opposition to Western values.

There is nothing Islamophobic about being opposed to the Muslim Brotherhood.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

Jon,

Gonna agree with everything you said here, including that democracy isn't for every people. Even when you remove Islam from the equation, just look at Russia. They reverted back to a dictatorship and love a strong man. And if anyone thinks that Putin isn't a dictator in nice clothes, is out of their mind.

Democracy is a mindset. Not every culture has it, nor can every culture achieve it. So the best remedy is sometimes the least appetizing.

 
 
 
JoAnne Odel
Freshman Silent
link   JoAnne Odel    13 years ago

as soon as your enemy stops fearing you, you have surrendured.

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   seeder  Jonathan P    13 years ago

JR,

This is not a cut and dry situation. Therefore, there is no ideal outcome. As a result, we need to choose which direction we feel will take us closer to the proper destination.

The U.S. is not in the business of recognizing military takeover of governments, or shouldn't be.

Absolutely correct, John. But the US is also not in the business of recognizing democratically elected presidents who then attempt to seize absolute power. When we take the case of Egypt, the particular ideology of the perpetrator was already an adversarial party to the US. This makes the decision of whom to support almost clear.

There is a pre-existing relationship between the US and the Egyptian military. This gives the US an edge in continuing to have influence in the country. The military said they'd hold elections within a year. The US is in a position to help and duly influence them to reach their goal.

As far as a partisan position is concerned, I have seen members of both parties standing on both sides of this issue. Not sure what you mean.

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   seeder  Jonathan P    13 years ago

Let's not forget why the Egyptian people love their military:

There is virtually no incidence of abuse or exploitation of the civilian population. It's a steady job for many; most families in Egypt have someone who has or is serving.

And, as you said, the Egyptian people have made clear their position on the MB.

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    13 years ago

...the US is also not in the business of recognizing democratically elected presidents who then attempt to seize absolute power. When we take the case of Egypt, the particular ideology of the perpetrator was already an adversarial party to the US. This makes the decision of whom to support almost clear.

Absolutely; no question.

Yet, that is not reality. I'm really not sure why, other then to place the blame on sheer ineptness, or a gross misalignment of values, and thus priorities.

Standing logic on it's head, and then kickin' it in the teeth.

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   seeder  Jonathan P    13 years ago

And yet, the Egyptian military did not rule the country with an iron fist. There was economic freedom, and wide open lines of communication. The Egyptian man on the street knows what's going on in the world. His internet is not being jammed by his government. The truth is out there for them to see.

As far as non-democratic regimes, there was not a great amount of discomfort in the populace.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    13 years ago

It is pretty clear from looking at this thread that is expressed from a pro-Israeli viewpoint.

Actually, I would characterize this as a "pro-Egyptian" viewpoint. (Hopefully Fada will re-surface here soon-- she can explain to you what's going on in Egypt better than I can).

Sure, Israelis and their current government have opinions as to what events in the region are is in the best interests of their country. But so do various Arab, Turkish, and Iranian groups.

Turkey's Erdogan was particular close to Morsi and the MB-- he's freaking out now that they were overthrown, and has been spouting some really extreme criticsm of the new Egyptian gov't. So does that mean that if someone expresses support for the Egyptian MB-- that they are expressing things from a "pro-Turkish" viewpoint?

The U.AE.and Saudi Arabia strongly support the new gov't-- Turkey strongly opposes it. So while you say that this is a pro-Israel viewpoint, according to the criteria you use, you could also claim that this is a "Pro-UAE or pro-Saudi viewpoint!

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    13 years ago

Hopefully the U.S. hasn't reached the point yet where our ideals will be cast aside in order to benefit a partisan position.

You mean we may suddenly start to cast aside the ideals we had in the past-- like when we started the war in Iraq? Or are you referring to the ideals we stuck to when we started the war in Afghanistan?

Perhaps you are referring to the "ideals" our govt expressed by opening the prison at Gitmo? Or-- by refusing to close-- despite promises by our President? Continuing drone strikes-- especially after promising to stop them? Or maybe you are merely referring to the Obama administration ideals expressed by having the NSA spy on American citizens? (And then-- lying about it!!!)

OK-- so much for sticking to those ideals (examples in the previous paragraphs). Well, at least you have been open-minded & fair- you are a stellar example of someone who is non=partisan--you gallantly refuses to argue base on benefitting any partisan position!

Heh Tongue.gif Tongue.gif Tongue.gif

(lol.... Grin.gif )

36.gif

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    13 years ago

Hopefully the U.S. hasn't reached the point yet where our ideals will be cast aside in order to benefit a partisan position.

Are you advocating that we attempt to meddle in the internal affairs of an Arab country? To impose our "ideals"on the Egyptians? How well has that sort of thing worked out in the past?

It seems you have little if any interest in how the majority of Egyptians feel!!

Poll: 67% of Egyptians satisfied about method of ending pro-Morsy sit-ins

Only one quarter of Egyptians think it would have been better if negotiations were extended, while 70 percent believed the negotiation duration was enough.

According to 62 percent of Egyptians, the large number of victims was the protesters fault, while 13 percent blamed it on police.

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   seeder  Jonathan P    13 years ago

There seems to be an undercurrent of pacifist ideology in our government and media.

Pacifism renounces military participation under any set of circumstances...

...which makes it an extremist line of thinking.

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   seeder  Jonathan P    13 years ago

Thus necessitating the need for resolve in a clear challenge to authority.

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   seeder  Jonathan P    13 years ago

Political correctness has an official title now. It's called "multiculturalism". It teaches us to tolerate the intolerable; it serves to hush our protests at the inhumane manner in which some societies operate under.

What has trickled down into our government and the liberal media is an unprecedented level of confusion. But the only people who are absolutely certain of this necessity are the most extreme elements of liberal thinking. Over this period in question, balance in thinking has been hijacked. As a result, we have bent to the point where our backs are breaking. The straw is Egypt. In a direct challenge to left-wing logic, a choice must be made between two less than palatable choices. This is a rare opportunity for moderate elements to take back the discussion.

I welcome this shot over the bow against the illogic of multiculturalism.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    13 years ago

n fact, we have praised to the hilt the ultimate superiority of Islam as the final arbiter, the basis of law in these countries.

Exactly! Frown.gif

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    13 years ago

I have no use for the Muslim Brotherhood, and I don't think anyone in the US government including the President does either.

'Is everybody blind?'

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   seeder  Jonathan P    13 years ago

There are many ties between the government and the MB. You only need take note of the official government visits to the incarcerated Morsi after the coup to verify that. Beyond that, there has been a significant amount of "outreach" to the MB on the part of our President.

I'm not much for conspiracy theories, but that relationship has caused me to give pause on more than one occasion.

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    13 years ago
I welcome this shot over the bow against the illogic of multiculturalism....

Political correctness has an official title now. It's called "multiculturalism". It teaches us to tolerate the intolerable; it serves to hush our protests at the inhumane manner in which some societies operate under.

What has trickled down into our government and the liberal media is an unprecedented level of confusion. But the only people who are absolutely certain of this necessity are the most extreme elements of liberal thinking. Over this period in question, balance in thinking has been hijacked. As a result, we have bent to the point where our backs are breaking. The straw is Egypt. In a direct challenge to left-wing logic, a choice must be made between two less than palatable choices. This is a rare opportunity for moderate elements to take back the discussion.

I welcome this shot over the bow against the illogic of multiculturalism.

The Sultan agrees.

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   Aeonpax    13 years ago

Political intrigue aside, you make some pretty good logical points BUT, you haven't gone far enough.

What really sustains the so-called Arab uprising is MONEY...lots of it....and where do you think that money comes from? Saudi Arabia and their Eremites.

Where do they get their money from? From the oil sucking sheeple in the US.

Just follow the money.

 
 
 
TTGA
Professor Silent
link   TTGA    13 years ago

The MB candidate was democratically elected, but that's where the democracy ended.

Yep, I believe that's what is known as "One Man, One Vote, One Time".

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   seeder  Jonathan P    13 years ago

Oil has indeed colored the way American government views the Middle East. It's about 40 years since this phase of patronism to the Emirates began in earnest.

On a positive note, we've ramped up the domestic drilling to the point where we are actually exporting energy. Our dependence on OPEC oil is now waning.

I hate to derail my own article, but you know, we are degrading our environment to rid ourselves of this dependency. This is another situation where we have to choose a lesser evil.

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   seeder  Jonathan P    13 years ago

You are correct sir/madam.

And the combination of a still strong military, and a civilian population that was aware of what was about to happen stemmed the tide.

Good for them.

 
 
 
JoAnne Odel
Freshman Silent
link   JoAnne Odel    13 years ago

you mean its NOT because of a disgusting youtube video?

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    13 years ago

...which makes it an extremist line of thinking.

And dangerous. Legitimizing the MB in such a way makes US foreignpolicy look pitiful, reduces our allies' stances, and jeapordizes existing assets.

It's as if nobody wants to admit who the MB are!

The Society of the Muslim Brothers ( Arabic : , , the Muslim Brotherhood , transliterated : al-Ikwn al-Muslimn ) is a transnational Islamic political organization. Founded in Egypt in 1928 [ 1 ] as a Pan-Islamic , religious, political, and social movement by the Islamic scholar and schoolteacher Hassan al-Banna , [ 2 ] [ 3 ] [ 4 ] [ 5 ] by the end of World War II the Muslim Brotherhood had an estimated two million members. [ 6 ] Its ideas had gained supporters throughout the Arab world and influenced other Islamist groups with its "model of political activism combined with Islamic charity work". [ 7 ]

The Brotherhood's stated goal is to instill the Qur'an and Sunnah as the "sole reference point for ...ordering the life of the Muslim family, individual, community ... and state." The movement is known for engaging in political violence, claiming responsibility for the installation of Hamas . [ 8 ] Muslim Brotherhood members are suspected to have assassinated political opponents like Egyptian Prime Minister Mahmoud an-Nukrashi Pasha . [ 7 ] [ 8 ] [ 9 ]

The Muslim Brotherhood started as a religious social organization; preaching Islam, teaching the illiterate, setting up hospitals and even launching commercial enterprises. As it continued to rise in influence, starting in 1936, it began to oppose British rule in Egypt. [ 10 ] Many Egyptian nationalists accuse the Muslim Brotherhood of violent killings during this period. [ 11 ] After the Arab defeat in the First Arab-Israeli war , the Egyptian government dissolved the organization and arrested its members. [ 10 ] It supported the Egyptian Revolution of 1952 , but after an attempted assassination of Egypt's president it was once again banned and repressed. [ 12 ] The Muslim Brotherhood has been suppressed in other countries as well, most notably in Syria in 1982 during the Hama massacre . [ 13 ]

The Muslim Brotherhood is financed by contributions from its members, who are required to allocate a portion of their income to the movement. Some of these contributions are from members who work in Saudi Arabia and other oil-rich countries. [ 14 ]

~WIKI~

 
 
 
TTGA
Professor Silent
link   TTGA    13 years ago

Ah, but that would be the sensible thing to do. Remember that this is the U S State Dept. The sensible thing is not their method.

 
 
 
retired military ex Republican
Freshman Silent
link   retired military ex Republican    13 years ago

New Religions were initially designed to wrest power and acceptance from another religion or group of people. Their very existance has morphed over theyears to subvert other religions politically or by force. Christians wrestled power from the Jews. Jesus was a Jew and created his own following. It did not really gain much strength until the story of a resurection was added. This made Christianity unique with the stroke of the quill and ink. The older religions still remain many have massive similarities but will gladly fight to the death over the even smallestdifferences. Religious Faith cannot be proven or disproven therefore it is because of faith taught in schools and religious buildings Churches, Synagogues, Mosques (what ever they are called) that the wedge is driven ever deeper between Religious factions.

 
 
 
JoAnne Odel
Freshman Silent
link   JoAnne Odel    13 years ago

little did we know what obama really meant by "arab spring"

 
 
 
retired military ex Republican
Freshman Silent
link   retired military ex Republican    13 years ago

So true but with alternative energy being fought and often derailed by Graft and deceit the devistation of our ecology is increasing at a madening pace. Nuclear power plants are being proven not infallable as we had been told. Carbon energy is destroying the environmet it's destroying the air, soil, waterand atmosphere. Wind and Sun and Hydro electric are being avoided as big money drives the process.

 
 

Who is online





CB


106 visitors