Ben Carson Just Instantly Silenced Everyone Calling Him A ‘Traitor To His Race’
Watch: Ben Carson Just Instantly Silenced Everyone Calling Him A Traitor To His Race"Id say they need to actually listen, not only to what Im saying, but..."Randy DeSotoAugust 13, 2015Presidential candidate Ben Carson responded to critics from the left on Wednesday who have accused him of being an Uncle Tom and traitor to his race by running as a conservative Republican.Id say they need to actually listen, not only to what Im saying, but look at my life and look at whats been done, the retired neurosurgeon told TheBlaze. It is the things that are done that elevate people, not things that impress people and make them dependent.Carson was asked why, traditionally, Democrats have gotten most of the African American vote and what the Republican Party can do to change that.Well, I think its because the Democratic Party has ascribed to the Lyndon Johnson philosophy. I dont know if you know, but Lyndon Johnson said, If you give those N-words such and such, theyll vote for us for the next 200 years,' the candidate responded.What the Republican Party needs to do is come out and discuss more the kinds of relationships and the programs that will actually bring people out of poverty, that will give them the ability to use their God-given talents to rise, rather than to simply be satisfied in a dependent position in society, Carson added. As reported by Western Journalism, Carsons reference to Lyndon Johnson was cited by conservative commentator Bill Whittle last month in his popular teaching video regarding the racist past of the Democrat Party. Whittle quotes President Johnson as saying that the social welfare programs instituted during the Great Society in the 1960s would have ngers voting Democratic for the next 200 years.The commentator also notes it was the Democrats who supported slavery and Jim Crow laws in the south and founded the KKK. Further, it was Republicans who passed the post-Civil War amendments ending slavery, guaranteeing equal protection under the law, and giving African Americans the right to vote. Republicans also supported the Civil Rights Act of 1964, ending Jim Crow, in a far greater percentage than Democrats in Congress.Also reported by Western Journalism, PJTVs Alfonzo Rachel released a video in the spring encouraging his fellow African Americans not to be trapped by the Democrats on the victimization plantation. In his video, he recounts much of the history Whittle does. Now instead of using blacks to farm cotton, [the Democrats] use you to farm votes, says Rachel. And you have been suckered into believing that this off-balanced circle of dependency is Democrats doing something for black folks.Rachel contends the Democrat Party is using taxpayers money to seek to buy the black vote and make them believe they are entitled to certain benefits. In the end, he argues, this creates another form of slavery of African Americans. The Republican philosophy of a restrained federal government, he believes as Ben Carson does offers people healthy choices and gives them the opportunity to live free and pursue their dreams. http://www.westernjournalism.com/watch-ben-carson-just-instantly-silenced-everyone-calling-him-a-traitor-to-his-race/

Who has called him an Uncle Tom or a traitor to his race? Reads like a strawman article to me.
Good article but it needs a link .
I also think that it is more then a little disingenuous to compare the Republican party of the Civil War era and even as close as 1964 to the party of today. They are the complete opposite of what they used to be after Nixon's "Southern Strategy" in 1968. Though by today's GOP standards even Nixon would be considered a raging liberal.
Nope. The racists that fled the Democratic Party kept their racism, mostly in the rural areas. Your statement is just an opinion, just the same as mine.
"The Lyndon Johnson Philosophy." - There is no such thing.
There was at one time . But a youngster like you wouldn't know about it ...
Prove it.
I have personally debunked this idiocy about 5 times on Newstalkers. People like the rwnj writer of this article, and XX, keep reviving it . The misrepresentation is just too tempting for the conservatives. When one simple , but telling adjustment is made to the analysis of the Civil Rights Act vote totals in Congress, we see that a higher percentage of Democrats than Republicans voted aye in both the north and the south.
Civil rights was voted up or down on a simple basis in 1964, whether you were a northerner or a southerner. Northerners voted overwhelmingly for it and southerners voted overwhelmingly against it.
XX, pin this article to your forehead so we don't have to go through this again some time.
...
Seven percent (7%) of senators and representatives from the former confederate states (the south) voted for passage of the Civil Rights Act of 1964.
Ninety percent (90 %)of senators and representatives from the union states ( the north) voted for passage of the bill.
Number of southern Republicans who voted for the Civil Rights Act ? ZERO.
XX, kindly stfu about this in the future.
As for the general idea that republicans have always been the benefactor of blacks, that has to be put in perspective of the Civil War era. After reconstruction, the Republicans had so offended the south that for generations the white racists of the south remained steadfastly Democrat. The New Deal began to change the Democrats from a conservative to a liberal party, but didn't really change the racial attitudes of southern Democrats. That is something that changed in a gradual way. Meantime Republicans grew more conservative and reactionary post the Goldwater revolution of the early 60's and post Civil Rights Act.
I lived through that era . There is a lot of material . I can summarize a few of the salient points . Above that it would take a major research project ...
Here's a thought , Read up on the "war on poverty" .
In other words, you have no proof. Just say so.
You can't get Petey to do any work. It's not possible.
It is true that Lyndon Johnson really did say that. It was the Democratic party that adopted the "philosophy".
FULL QUOTE:
Here's another beauty:
AND IT HAS BEEN THAT WAY EVER SINCE!
The answer to the last question is that most teachers are liberals and teaching the truth does not fit their mantra. The Dems were the majority against freeing slaves too. Sorry John but you can't re-write history to fit your liking.
I dedicate this to Aeon, Petey and John:
You really are twisting this to fit your narrative.
XX said:
From the article YOU offered:
Granted it may be an argument as to whether the Republican numbers were "far" greater (17% in house and 13% in congress), but they were greater by 13% in both case none the less, weren't they?
Pointing out the differences between Confederate and Union state positions in this case is irrelevant.
If you are going to try to argue the total numbers that is just silly as there were many more Democrats in both the house and congress.
Higher number total is not the same as higher percentage . This statement was disproved by your own link and the chart above. XX's statement is correct and yours is the one that is bullshit.
Turnabout is fair play, I expect you to STFU regarding this in the future.
It is not irrelevant at all, it is the utter heart of the matter. No one voted for the Civil rights Act because they were Republicans ( or Democrats for that matter), they voted for or against it because they were from the north or the south.
Not a single southern Republican voted yes. How can anyone in their right mind say it was a "Republican" intiative ?
90% of northerners voted yes.
7% of southerners voted yes.
Obviously it was geography , and not political party, that dictated the vote.
Do you think the Guardian newspaper went to the trouble of parsing the demographics for fun ?
lol
As Dowser has said in so many words on another article "No one has clean hands concerning slavery or Racism" and I will expand on that and say to continue to live in the past and not center our attention on the future is detrimental to our country.
But a Higher percentage of Republicans still voted for it. Now you are just trying to distract from your FOS /incorrect statement about percentages. LMAO!
You are still ignoring the fact that a higher percentage of Republicans voted for it and that...
The real question to anyone truly considering all the facts so how can anyone say it was a democratic initiative. You ARE a funny one. LMAO!
Haven't you learned by now that when you try to make a point of voicing your opinion as fact I am going to hand you your ass?
The ONLY reason the Democrat percentage was lower is because so many southern senators and congressmen at the time were Democrats.
The implication of the statistics is painfully obvious. I am not a kindergarten teacher on this site, although that would be helpful at times.
That's right John. People vote for people with the same views. In this case people in the South voted for RACIST DEMOCRATS...and were rewarded by the people they voted for because the southern DEMOCRATS did their best to try to stop it. It was also for this reason that..
Looks like you aren't qualified for kindergarten yet.
If , and it is a gigantic IF, the percentages in the north showed more Republicans than Democrats favored the CRA , XX might have a point. But that was not the case.
In both the north and the south, a higher percentage of Democrats supported the bill than Republicans, and in fact NOT ONE southern republican voted yes.
I can't help your deluded self any further.
You've proven he SAID that. That's not at dispute. What you have NOT PROVED is that there was actually collusion between LBJ and the Democratic Party in actually planned ad executed such a thing.
You have one of two things here;
a) Another "Post Hoc" fallacy;
A - LBJ used the N word in a rhetorical statement
then
B - he came out with civil rights legislation,
therefore;
they must have plotted to captive the black population to vote Democratic.
b) A conspiracy theory.
No smoking guns. No dots to connect. Just speculation.
Once again this is bullshit. Once again I will point out the percentages are different than the total number and there were a lot more Dems in office than republicans.
Here is a grade school lesson for you
percentage
/prsen(t)ij/
noun
1. a rate, number, or amount in each hundred
How the hell can you look at this chart and keep posting lying bullshit?
The percentage of democrats is lower in each instance. Get some help from your kindergarten teacher if you can't understand it for crying out loud.
96w, you do not understand, I don't know why.
Here are the numbers and the percentages for the north and the south, by party.
This graphic CLEARLY shows that in both the House and the Senate, and in both the north AND the south, a higher percentage of Democrats voted for the Civil Rights Act than Republicans.
Yeah, let's help "elevate" African Americans by screwing with their voting rights, Ben!
Supreme Court stops use of key part of Voting Rights Act
And since conservatives bitch about the hight percentage of Blacks who voted for Obama (presumably because he's Black and for no other (alleged) reason, how intelligent is Carson to align himself with conservatives?
Hey Ben, even if you get the nomination as the Republican presidential candidate for 2016 many of those black affinity voters won't be able to vote (for you or anyone else).
Duh it ain't brain surgery, Dude!
As for Carson telling TheBlaze anything enjoy any/all of the following Blaze articles about "elevating" Blacks
Teacher Says Black People Cause of Racial ... - TheBlaze
Civil Rights Icon's Tough Message to Black ... - TheBlaze
'Don't Judge Blacks Differently': Black Student ... - TheBlaze
It's Time for Black America to Blame Black ... - TheBlaze
Black Woman's Unexpected Racial Rant During ... - TheBlaze
'I'm a Black Man': ESPN Commentator Stephen A ... - TheBlaze
'Black Lives Matter' Chanting Drowns Out Jeb ... - TheBlaze
Civil Rights Activist Who Marched With Martin ... - TheBlaze
'Blacks, Whites, Latinos, and Everybody Else ... - TheBlaze
Young Black Man Takes President Obama to ... - TheBlaze
You seem to have missed this comment:
These Negroes, theyre getting pretty uppity these days and thats a problem for us since theyve got something now they never had before, the political pull to back up their uppityness. Now weve got to do something about this, weve got to give them a little something, just enough to quiet them down, not enough to make a difference. LBJ
and judging by this comment:
You must have missed this fact:
Republican President Eisenhower who sponsored both Civil Rights Act and Voting Rights Act and it was a LBJ lead Senate who fought tooth and nail against them
What you don't understand is the last graphic's numbers don't add up. Totals of all that voted yea int he second graphic don't match the first one on the Repub or DEm side. (note the broken down graphic shows 243 total for dems and total graphic shows 244...the yea votes if added are off by one as well on both the Dem and REP sides.)
Why the hell would you look at anything other that all overall votes and try to break it up anyhow? (Other than to fudge the numbers that is.)
Since there is an obvious discrepancy in the two graphics ...Let's forgo the graphics and crunch the ACTUAL VOTING NUMBERS.
If you take a look at the correct total numbers :
The ACTUAL VOTE NUMBERS shows that the PERCENTAGE of republicans is higher that the PERCENTAGE of Democrats that voted FOR it. PERIOD!!!
Forgo the graphics and use the real numbers.
total yea 289...GOP YEA 136 DEM YEA 152 unknown 1
PRESENT 4 (2 GOP, 2 DEM)
NOT VOTING 12 (GOP 5, DEM 7)
Total Nay 126 ...GOP NAY 35 DEM Nay 91
so that gives us 243 dems that actually voted...152 voted yea and 91 voted nay=62.55% vote yea for the Dems
out of 171 total Repubs that voted 136 voted yea (35 Nay) that means 79.53% of the total votes were yea votes for Repubs
79.53% is higher that 62.55% so that means a HIGHER PERCENTAGE OF REPUBS VOTED FOR IT THAN DEMS.
Have your teacher check the math.
I think this figure is worth repeating:
Total Nay 126 ...GOP NAY 35 DEM Nay 91
It seems there are many sources the ore off from one another by one vote but even so the PERCENTAGE of Republicans that voted Yea is substantially higher (repubs rounded to 80% and dems at about 60%)
you totally miss the point
Yeah! All the racism is gone so there's no longer a need to prevent it through legislation.
What frightens me most about conservatives is that they believe their own bullshit and once more, I am reminded as to why I comment in these articles less and less.
Presidential candidate Ben Carson responded to critics from the left on Wednesday who have accused him of being an Uncle Tom and traitor to his race by running as a conservative Republican.
I'm still waiting to find out who called him those names? I mean it's easy to say someone did, but specifically who did? I'm on the left and I haven't and no one on the left that I know have called him those names? Seems to me that this Randy DeSoto is using a classic straw man argument.
Oh, well, if he CONTENDS that, it must be so!
And it so fits the right-wing stereotype/red-meat racist "justification" to label a race to suit a political base comprised heavily of old white people, religionist purists, bigots and plain damned fools!
No evidence. All hypothesis.
This happened (A), then that happened (B) resulting in this (C)
Do you even know why Johnson enacted his "Great Society" initiative? Back then, the race riots were going on. Him and his administration were scared to death the blacks were going "communist". He was convinced these race riots were communist inspired. This had nothing to do with garnering black votes for democrats.
I haven't missed anything. The POINT is your liberal source is trying to slew the numbers. The facts are that republicans voted yea at a a higher PERCENTAGE of almost 20%.
Any first grade teacher would tell you that in order to find the true percentage you add them together and divide. Go back to school. It's never too late to learn.
BTW I noticed you weren't foolish enough to to try to rebut my numbers, calculations, or any of the other resources I provided.
No one voted for the Civil Rights Act because they were a Republican, or against it because they were a Democrat.
The vote hinged on the geographical location of the congressional members. Southerners of both parties voted overwhelmingly against it and northerners of both parties voted overwhelmingly for it.
THAT is BY FAR the most important factor in the vote.
But if we do have to break it down by party, both in the north and in the south a larger percentage of Democrats voted for it than Republicans.
You lose.
If you don't want to believe me, ask the Guardian newspaper.
No YOU lose. The guardian is a liberal BS source that has a history of distorting facts. Only a complete dumb fuck would believe half the crap they print. Not surprised you read it.
I also noticed it is the only source you can provide to back your opinion while I have provided neutral sources like govtrak and politifact. Both of which have taken the percentage from the total to provide a true OVERALL percentage figure.
BTW you are still trying to rebut first grade mathematics. Like I said before...
The other sources have done it this way because they are not some screwed up liberal rag that it trying to re-write history.
queue at 2:05 mark
Right. As usual, you've got nothing. Can't rebut when someone calls out your only source as left-wing bullshit. What a surprise.
Was the 90 - 7 ratio of yes votes related to Republicans vs Democrats, or Northerners vs. Southerners ?
I was more than patient with you and your inability to understand the issue. Now we are done.
LMAO!
I understand that by rearranging the overall factual numbers of total votes that you can come up with bullshit figures just fine.
Let's impeach Thomas Jefferson for being a slave holder !
It is true he said both the things I posted. Too bad we can't re-write history eh?
So ... the great journalist can't use google ? Thanks for producing a waste of bytes .
Nice Hypothesis. No I can't prove mine any more than you can prove yours. I can only provide some facts. We are both connecting dots to some extent.
More than that; I lived through this one as a Philly resident. And one of the main causes continues to this day.
I guess Philly fixed that problem by bombing civilian centers that were home to the Black Panthers ...
Apparently reading comprehension is not one of your strengths, and/or, it's just your usual doubling down on a premise after it has been debunked.
And consequently, once again, I will leave you.
Having read the article, I'm still searching for ''who'' called him a traitor to his race. Do you know XX?
I would think that would be an important part of the story.
liberals, could be any of them
No wonder ! You can't have a conversation with a brick wall.
Stick to what you know, Petey. You guess wrong.
That situation occurred in 1985 and had nothing to do with the Black Panthers; it was a "terrorist" group that called itself "MOVE".
OK , I accept the fact that those were different incidents in different time periods . Unfortunately the conclusion about the effectiveness of extreme measures seems to hold ...
You brought it up I didn't.
Good night.
Thanks! Great article!
That's a very good question....
Coming from National Report , such is to be expected.
What else is there?
That comes from Terry Mattingly at Get Religion.org
Then there is this...
Poorrichardsnews.com Where this has been brought up as much as 6 months ago.
So I would say that there isn't any democrat or liberal "NAME" saying such things, there is the undercurrent amongst the political liberals of such going around, just like there was last time for Herman Cain.
It has been known by any that really knew Dr Carson that he was a conservative all along. Even when the liberal side of the aisle was pushing his inner city minority rags to riches story for their own ends.
What it illustrates is that being a black man, you are entitled to your beliefs, as long as you don't express them publicly, or at least express them in a way that doesn't damage the group think ideology.
For all these years the NAACP has been touting the efforts and achievements of a black conservative, a solid conservative BTW.
Kinda puts the spotlight on why they don't directly attack him doesn't it.
It's hard to claim that one of the icons for black success, who got there cause of conservative principles, is a demonstration of the success of liberalism, in fact he represents the failures of liberalism.
So the underlings are not happy with him...
Hence complaints of "House Nig***", Uncle Tom" and the like.
It was something he had to address, if anything to expose those that are doing it as the shameless ideologues they are.
Tough.