The First People
If you don't find the subject palatable, don't read this article. If you don't read it, don't comment on it. If you don't agree with what is stated, say so in a respectful manner and allow it to be discussed by any of the Indian members on NT. Some here were raised on reservations; some were not. Some were raised knowing of their heritage, some were not. If you want to know, you can learn. If you just want to throw darts and run, you may do that as well, branding yourself for what you are.
There are articles written and documentaries made about the sad and dismal state of the Indian life on reservations; the alcohol, the drugs, the low rate of high school graduates, spousal abuse, the high rate of suicide among young teens. Last year a group of psychologists were sent to one such reservation to spend time talking and "researching" a group of teens to try and determine what it was that drove Indian youth to such despair that they would take their own lives rather thantry to reach out to someone for help. Each and every one of these professionals returned to the Federal agency that sent them with an admission of total failure... their usual guidelines and markers did not apply to Native American children and they were at a complete loss as to what to do. Not a single one of them wanted to make a guess or go back.
While a Black youth has no problem looking a White counselor in the face and telling him/her, "The White man is my problem, Dude! You want to know what's wrong? How much time you got?" it's much more complex and difficult for an Indian child to convey centuries of "what's wrong" to anyone outside. From the beginning of the European conquest, the Indian was ripped from his land, language, family, spiritual path, home, his manner of dress, his entire culture down to the way he wore his hair and the medicine he was allowed to use. That's historical fact and well known. The less well known, and what is so hard for Whites to accept is the boarding schools, run by churches, which were in fact houses of horror... nothing in the news today is more disgusting, pitiful, or sorrowful than what happened to those Indian children who were ripped from their family's homes at the age of five and six years old, taken hundreds of miles away so they could not run back home, stripped naked in front of strangers, their clothes burned, their traditional long hair chopped off to their ears, beaten until their little bodies were bloody if they spoke one word of their own language, thrown into dark and damp cellars without food as punishment, many of them dying from the treatment, raped and sodomized, sold as labor to surrounding farms...
Their families never saw them again until they were eighteen, if they came back at all. Through the door walked strangers, who spoke no word of their language, had no knowledge of the Way, could not survive a day in the wilderness alone... their children were total strangers to them. The worse part was that the grown children did not remember the parents and resented them for the treatment they received in the long years they had been away, for not being able to protect them and allow them to stay home. Are not parents the strongest hero a child knows? Are not parents supposed to chase away the monsters? Where, then, were the parents in all the agony and pain of the Indian child's life.
This was a way of life for Indian children until the mid-1970's. It was a perpetuating sick, evil wheel of life. The abused children became parents whose children were taken away, and they sat for years knowing what was happening to their sons and daughters. Self hate is an insidious thing; it always lashes out at the wrong victim. Even though the boarding schools are no more, the shame and humiliation of those years are still close and the Indian youth of today have access to the history of it at long last. There are parents and grandparents who lived through it and the taint permeates every tribe. Indian children are still being stolen today, through the legal channels of Child Services; it is quite profitable to become a Foster Parent of a Native American child, and quite easy to take an Indian child from its mother if you live in certain states such as SD. A lot depends on the governor of the state and the Indian Nation and Tribal Council, and how energetic they will be in helping the mother to keep her child.
The Nations are slowly coming back, teaching histories of the tribes, the languages, trying to instill a sense of pridein the youth of who they are and what their ancestors were. But the Indian has a distinct disadvantage with which other minorities in the US do not have to contend, and that is that they are at the mercy of the United States Congress. At the swipe of a pen, Congress can declare a tribe.... not a tribe, taking away all Federal status and everything that goes along with it. Indians cannot come together against the United States Government, but Blacks, Hispanics, Neo-Nazis, and Tea Party groups may organize and march until they fall on their face. Indians cannot cut and sell timber on their land without permission from the government, but the government may "lease" the Indian's land to a corporation that is a shell company for a foreign entity for them to cut.
Tags
Who is online
87 visitors

The history of Indians and their experience in this country is unique.
I generally have never gotten involved in commenting on the "Indian threads" on Newstalkers. As a broad stance about it, I wish them well , I do believe Indians have been victimized historically in the US and that victimization has never been brought to closure, and continues to this day in many ways. I try not to talk much about topics I don't have a real good handle on, and I am not that conversant with Indian issues.
I do think that NT has been good for the American Indians here, giving them a platform and an audience you would not find on most other general current events discussion forums.
I believe we are just now learning how our DNA can lead certain races to be more susceptible to drug and alcohol addiction. In the future we my be able to alter our genetic makeup reducing the likelihood of addictions. Here is a good article discussing the Indians genetic link to drug and alcohol addiction.
What are WASPs addicted to, fucking people over ?
As we learn more about genetic links to behavior we will know more.
Dear Friend Mimi: Thank you for putting this out there.
I concur and support everything you advocate.
While I am certainly no expert, all you have written about here is true and correct.
The question is, even if there is no quick fix, what actions can people of good will, from whatever group(s) they belong, due to make the present and future better for Native and First Americans than it has been to date?
This is an educational article. Perhaps a follow up with a call to action, presenting specific things people can do for progress may help. Certainly, it cannot hurt.
Peace, Justice, Equality, Fairness and Abundant Blessings to One and All.
Enoch.
Dean, yes that is a good article. There have been other as well. It seems that certain genetic make up from some groups of people make them much more likely to become addicted to alcohol. The last study that I researched showed that Indians, Irish and Russian people all had a lack of a specific enzyme which they believed caused this addiction. It is a field well worth extensive research.
If I remember correctly, Perrie has done a lot of investigation into this and could probably speak to it with much more authority than I can.
I've tried to fix the article so the paragraphs are separated and it would be easier to read but it doesn't seem to take for some reason.
Enoch, there are several young people who are talented in music.. contemporary music.. who have taken their talents on the road and are reinvesting their profits in their reservations in helping the young people who are left behind.
They want to see their people retain their culture and heritage, give the young pride in who and what they are while helping them find a future as well.
Dean is correct when he mentions the heredity of addiction, the gene that causes that addiction. It is evident in families of other ethnicities as well. There are many white families where you can see the evidence of a heredity of alcoholism or tendency toward drug abuse, even if the addictive parent was not a part of the child's life during the years the child was growing up.
For myself, I have a strange reaction to alcohol. I can sniff a wine cork and be as high as a Georgia pine. I love really dry white wine, can't stand fruity red, and both give me such a headache I think I'm dying. The only thing that doesn't make me sick as a dog is tequila and I can drink it straight, get a nice high and after my first trip to the bathroom I'm sober again, and my skin itches so bad I have to take Benadryl.
Mimi - excellent "Reader's Digest" version of the history of our people and the issues we're confronted with daily - that no one "wants to hear it" or they tell us to "get over it".
Thank you Mimi - thank you.
The reason this article came about was because of the article 1stwarrior posted about the voting bill.
The most important thing Indians can do to help themselves is to vote.
The most important thing others can do to help Indians is to push their legislators to approve legislation that helps Indians realize opportunities for better education, infrastructure, employment, and even voting rights, especially if these situations can be achieved on or near their reservations.
Another more subtle attack on Indian culture is still the theft of Indian children by the dominant society through adoption. There have been two high profile cases over the last year and a half concerning this but they were by no means the only two taking place. Any time these cases come to light, legislators need to be bombarded by emails and calls that, unless you have a truly heart-felt reason for approving taking the child from the family, support keeping the child with the mother and tribe.
The opposite of me, my mother could drink a fifth of Scotch (on the rocks) and you would never know she was drinking unless she tried to stand up. No slurred speech, mind as sharp as a tack.
My Dad never touched alcohol and could smell it coming a mile away. The only thing he considered worse than firewater was a damn Yankee.
I think trying to educate non-Indians is not only a great idea, but much needed. I have learned quite a bit about Native Americans, but, I still have a long way to go. I never, ever realized how oppressed they were ,and still are., or...the talent they possessed and now possess.May this situation change very soon.
There is a lot of talent on the reservations, Nona. The young people there walk with a foot in two worlds; they are interested in and want to honor the Old Ways and the Ancestors, but they are also interested in Out There and everything a normal young person is interested in. Some of them feel they are betraying the People if they embrace anything except education and business.
You could compare it to the Amish community. Their young people are allowed a time to leave the enclave and among "the other" and experience the call of sin. When the time is over they must make their decision, whether to return to the Amish community and forever forego life in the modern world or to stay on the outside and forever give up family and friends and life with the Amish. If they return to the outside, they will never, ever speak to or see their parents, siblings or other family members again. It is as if they are dead to the Amish community.
Some of the young Indians feel that same sense of breaking off, within themselves, if they want to embrace rock or rap music, or study classical piano or violin, or things of that nature. It's almost as if they feel the need to stay on the reservation, that it's their duty to suffer for the things their ancestors could not prevent from happening and their parents could not change.
This is the attitude that has to be turned around, to let them know they can be Indians AND American youth. They can speak their Native tongue AND English, there is nothing wrong with knowing both, and by knowing both it makes them richer and prepares them for leadership in their Nation and tribe. They don't have to give up the Old to be part of the New.
This is the attitude that has to be turned around, to let them know they can be Indians AND American youth. They can speak their Native tongue AND English, there is nothing wrong with knowing both, and by knowing both it makes them richer and prepares them for leadership in their Nation and tribe. They don't have to give up the Old to be part of the New Very well said, and it's wonderful that they can experience both worlds
Here is a good starting point:
It has to do with how alcohol is metabolized. The defects are different for different groups. This does not include cultural reasons, which is also a factor.
My dad never drinks, but he is a Yankee, Brooklyn born and raised and a member of the Canarsie Indians.
I fixed it for you Mimi.
Which is one of the reasons people like Sherman Axlie and Arigon Starr and Vine Deloris, Jr. and others similar to them keep trying to work with the youth - in, oh, so many ways.
Wonderful article Mimi. It is a good introduction to why things are the way things are on the Rez.
For many, it is hard to understand what it is like to go through generations after generation of being an outcast in one's own country. Of being brainwashed into hating who you are. Of returning to your family not knowing who or what you are.
I hope that this article will help people get a better understanding of what it is like to be Indian today, yesterday... the past. It is all intertwined together.
LOL... Daddy never crossed the Mason/Dixon in his life. He tried to join the Army like his brothers during WWII, but had a heart defect, and when he joined the CCC he was stationed in the Smoky Mountains.
His prejudice against the North was deep and abiding, and his word for Yankees was "Carpetbaggers." He died twenty-seven years ago at the age of eighty-four, so he was raised with first hand stories from his grandfather about The War.
He was a gentle, quiet man who never raised his voice, and in all my years I never heard him curse; but he was the middleweight boxing champion in the CCC and he always stood his ground. And in his mind, no Indian, wherever they lived, were technically Yankees; they were just Indians....
Thank you, Perrie.
People are always asking why the young adults don't move off the reservations.
I wasn't raised on one, yet it makes the breath catch in my throat and my stomach clench up to think that all the Indian youth would leave the reservation land, abandon the tribe legacies and the grounds where the Ancestors walked, hunted, fought, died. To think that one day perhaps there would be no Indian at all on Indian land....
There has to be a way to bring the culture of the past together with the reality of the present, to balance the two. In interviews I've seen with the young Indians, they don't want to leave their heritage behind; they want to embrace it, to learn more about it and the old ways even as they move toward the future and successful lives with families and viable income.
Ironically, we were raised on opposite sides of the fence. When my great grand dad stepped off the ship from Ireland (he was really from Austria), not speaking a word of English, he found himself being handed free clothing only to find himself next in Penn fighting in the Civil War. Clueless he was, as to what he was doing there, but he learned English really quickly.
My dad's personal experience being indian down south, and in the navy, wasn't positive. He was told to get to the back of the bus. He refused and the rest of the Brooklyn service boys made the bus driver see the evil of his ways. So, how hard was it for your family to be Indian down south?
My dad ran into many Cherokee down south, and despite normally they would be at odds with each other (dad being Algonquin and theCherokee, Iroquois,) they were friendly indian faces when not at home.
My family was pretending NOT to be Indian. My mother's family was working really hard at it, calling themselves "Black Dutch" and on my Dad's side they were calling themselves "Black Irish."
It was the grandmothers who were so adamant about it
My mother's dad was pure Choctaw, and he would just laugh about it. Anyone who looked at my mom and her sisters and brothers would know right away what they were. My dad's mother was Lakota Sioux and his father was Scots/Sioux; my two sisters were born with deep auburn hair but mine is black, and my eyes are so dark brown people would always say they were black. My mother would go shopping and leave me at home with my Dad while she took my two sisters with her because she said I was too Indian-looking. Now, in the South, it's fashionable to say one has "Indian blood." Of course everyone says they are Cherokee... lol. My mom's mother actually was pure Cherokee.
"Reader's Digest" version is correct.
I want to hear it. But I never will, nor have, on NT. That was made clear to me after the treatment of Ellie Reynolds, deemed not good enough to speak for Indians by the Indian Times and the Pine Ridge Reservation, because they were and are angry that Reynolds didn't think that Indian tribes should be able to nullify free speech in the sale of t-shirts that might have a Cleveland Indian logo on them.
Seeing, and stunned by the problems on Pine Ridge, I couldn't and cannot imagine why anyone there has two seconds to waste on supporting or bothing with the political thugs at "Indian Times."
And then I see this;
Really?
REALLY?
Ben...
So the problem is... VOTING???????
Now, when you have that much abuse, and that many problems just who and where do you find find places to put the abused, while avoiding the charge that you are "subtly" attacking the minority culture, through the "theft" of Indian children?
Unfortunately, not enough theft is going on, as the Indian child is guaranteed to be uneducated, to be a victim of drugs alcohol, and to die young. But that's ok, because his culture is preserved.
One "high profile" case that NT's NA's claimed as an obvious affront to justice was a little girl who was adopted by a South Carolina couple. The little girl was fractionally related to Indians. It was a case where NA's THINK that their superior race should end any discussion, but demonstrated nothing except the logic of bigotry.
Robert - I don't know how many times your "highs" have to be explained to you before you quit using them as your main points.
No, it is not the NA's on NT who have the issue - it is the NA's throughout the U.S. who have the issue. How many times do we/any NA need to explain to you why there is so much alcoholism/drug addiction with NA's? How many links do we need to give you for you to read before any of it begins to sink in? You quoted "ben" above but you didn't dwelve into the REASON for Ben's addiction to alcohol. Despondency ring a bell? How 'bout severe depression? How 'bout frustration at lack of opportunities? How 'bout loss of culture? How 'bout loss of ability to practice religious ceremonies because of Fed/State restrictions? How 'bout Indian children being taken from homes 'cause white folks think they can raise them better? How 'bout crooked/corrupt tribal politicians? How 'bout Fed/state police/LE's ignoring crime 'cause they don't have the manpower/money? How 'bout inability to attend a decent school and get a decent education? How 'bout being able to get a job with a decent salary? How 'bout not having to travel 100 miles A DAY, ONE WAY, to get to a job because no employers are close to where you live? How 'bout not having any means of transportation to get to a job? How 'bout no medical care? How 'bout no grocery stores to buy food? How 'bout no food in the grocery stores/7/11's?
I can and have given you over 100 reasons why there is alcohol/drug abuse among Indian people - and you will/have ignored each and every one and attempted to place the blame on the Indian themselves.Robert - you're somewhat an educated person - remember the term/phrase "Cause and effect"? Think about it.
VOTING???? - Cause and effect - you're not allowed to votebecause you're not covered under the U. S. constitution and guaranteed the right to vote so you get frustrated because you can't elect/vote for the candidate you would approve of because you are not allowed to vote because you're not covered under the U. S. constitution and guaranteed the right to vote BECAUSE YOU'RE INDIAN - so you get frustrated, angered, mad, delusioned, despondent, depressed. You begin to take your anger out on others - you start drinking MORE, and you go deeper into your hole of hate against the world.
Why should voting be such an issue to you??? Well, by not being "guaranteed" that right as are the rest of the U. S. citizens and many foreigners, you are being told that youare NOT the same as anyone else - you are different - you don't mean anything to anyone - GET OVER IT you're told - you're ONLY an Indian. You're right Robert - voting shouldn't mean anything to the Indian people.
I, nor anyone else from the NA part of NT, am not going to waste my/our time on senseless discussions with you that continually wind up following the same track - you refuse to learn nor to accept the education available to you regarding NA's. You prefer, IMHO, to denigrate NA input as lacking to your lofty thought processes.
Mimi - sorry for "talking" as such on your thread.
Great article Mimi. I have always been interested in Native American History.
Mimi...how terribly sad that people feel the need to hide their heritage for their safety and acceptance! Shame on people that oppress others, and don't allow then the same Rights as everyone else,especially the NA. who were here first!
Not allowed to vote??? In their own Country? Absolutely outrageous!!!
RG, as usual, learning for you is truly a ''bridge to far''.
Mimi's article was explaining the how and why's of the situation on some reservations. You of course, choose to attack anything Indian.That really does say a lot about you as a person. Low or no self esteem comes to mind.
Your inability to comment in a constructive way has come to be expected on NT, and you never fail to fulfill that.
Please go back to your own world, and stay there until you have something other to say,than denigrating Indians....Of course, you may never get out of your world, because that would require a thought process.
Thanks for the article, Mimi. Very good stuff, good links. These are all things we need to be reminded of now and again. Suffering and hardship of any race of people shouldn't be ignored.
I can certainly understand why alcohol and drugs could be a problem. When people feel hopeless, it's an escape, and a way to forget about oppression and bigotry and povertyfor a while.
It's prettypathetic when people are "driven' to drink and do drugs. very sad. It's just wrong that people are made to feel that way.
And, you're absolutely correct Nona - the NA's are "made" to feel that way.
Thank you, Grump. So good to see you.
Thank you for taking the time, 96.
Both my Dad's family and my Mom's were hidden by white Southerners, given a "make-over" and claimed as relatives who could not speak English when the soldiers came looking for Indian escapees to place on the forced march out of the area. Thus the "Black Dutch" and "Black Irish."
Both families took as their own the last names of the families who harbored them; this is another thing to add to our many "duh" moments.. that many of us don't even own the last names we carry as my family were not the only Indians to do this.
I am sorry for your loss, Ambi.
The Nez Perce were brilliant horse people, breeding and perfecting the Appoloosa horse. Many of them were shot by the US Calvary when the Nez Perc surrendered, in an effort to further humiliate and destroy the spirit of the Nez Perc, who loved their horses.
Fortunately, a good number of them broke away and fled, and managed to breed and thrive until astute horse people recognized their value and protected them.
I posted a reply to your comment, Nona, don't know where it went.
Both my Dad and Mom's families were taken in by Southern white families and claimed as family members, just off the boat who could not yet speak English, when the US troops came looking for Indian deserters to place on the forced march out of the rich territory of the Tennessee and Mississippi valleys. They gave them clothes, hairstyles and cuts.. makeup "do-overs."
Another thing many Indians do not own, especially those not registered on the Dawes Rolls, are their last names. Both sides of my family, as did so many others sheltered from the forced marches, took on the last names of the families who took them in.
1stwarrior has more knowledge of this than I, but the path for this situation is to remove the child from such a situation and find a relative of good character who can raise him/her while help is secured for the family, if there is a possibility to turn the situation around.
If there is no relative available, the child is adopted by a tribal member so that it is kept within the cultural boundaries of its heritage. If there is no member of the tribe who is willing to take the responsibility then the child is available for adoption outside the tribe.
My cousin and his wife adopted a Cherokee girl twenty years ago under such circumstances; Kenny and Brenda live in Hawaii and have raised Susan to know who she is and what her ancestry is. She lives the life of a normal white child (whatever that is) and Kenny brings her back to Alabama three times a year to visit her birth mother and other relatives.
In Susan's case it was the best solution. Kenny's mother was my mother's sister and his father a "registered" Cherokee (doesn't that sound awful), though Kenny's wife is an Irish Catholic.
No one expects a child to stay in an abusive home.
No problem. Brick walls are not my forte.
mimi......I"m so glad to hear that there were people kind enough and willing to take in these families. I didn't know about families taking in families. I just learned something today....Thank you!!
Yes, Robert, the root cause is not being able to vote.
If they had, many of them would not have voted for that liquor store to be located so close to the reservation. Many of them would have voted for liquor not to be sold to residents on the reservation. Many of them would have voted for alcohol and drug rehab instead of an overnight or weekend in county jail where the Indian youth are beaten up and worse.
Many of them would have voted for members of Congress who would pass legislation to improve conditions on the reservations so they might open their own schools there and keep their children at home instead of sending them away during school months because the round trip every day is too far.
This entire article was written because of the one posted about the voting bill. Voting is important. Being ABLE to vote is important. Being able to have a say in the people who run this country is important when the people who run this country make the critical decisions affecting your life on a day to day basis.
If you are an Indian and you live on a reservation, you are the only one who should have a say about what happens on reservation land. There are alreadyenough non-Indians on reservations than Indians, they don't need people outside them telling them what they should do
We had a difference of opinion about Ellie Reynolds, who portrayed herself as a registered member of a tribe when she was not. You have turned it into a full-blown war here and refuse to countenance any civil discussion. I'm truly sorry about that and I wish you all the best going forward.
In our case, we had to have approval from the Cheyenne tribe before we could adopt our children. As a matter of fact, after all the hoops we jumped through, all the money we spent, and all the prayers we raised up, the tribe ended up having the final say. We are so grateful for our kids, and the family that they adoptedus into. We often say to one another that we aren't exactly sure some days, who adopted who!
:~)
Kenny says the same thing, that the tribe had the final say and that he and his wife were adopted by them.
I understand, Feronia.
This article's main purpose was to try and point out some of the "why" it is so hard for Indians to move forward.
They cannot just start from "today, this point." There is history, culture, ancestry, abuse, racism, pride, family honor, tribal honor.. and most of these are elements the average person just cannot relate to in any sense.
An Asian probably can relate to parts of it; perhaps a Scotsman or an Irishman who is steeped in the lore of Clan. But the average American will be at a complete loss if all he/she wants to do is employ base logic and debate points.
Well, let's see
'Fraud': Conservative Blogger Claims She is Oglala, But Oglala Nation Says She is Not
I am not sure, but I think that some tribes require more oversight than others. It's a good question and worthy of research. We felt, and still feel, highly honored. What a precious gift...truly so.
The purpose of the Indian Child Welfare Act (ICWA) is "...to protect the best interest of Indian Children and to promote the stability and security of Indian tribes and families by the establishment of minimum Federal standards for the removal of Indian children and placement of such children in homes which will reflect the unique values of Indian culture... "(25 U.S. C. 1902).
I wrote an absolutely gorgeous missivethathas just disappeared - so, now the best I can do is to try to recap it.
Tribes/nationsfollow all avenues available to them to ensure that the welfare of the child comes first and foremost. They will take children from abusive/alcoholic/drug addicted families and attempt to place the child with someone within the "family" - aunts/uncles/cousins/brothers/sisters/grand-parents/nieces/nephews - the WHOLE family including extended family such as in-laws, out-laws, ex-laws. If they're not available, the tribe/nation with then check with other tribes/nations - in other words, all Indian resources will be investigated.
If none are available, the tribe/nation will then, in accordance with the law, go to the state CPS agency for assistance in the placement of the child, but, supposedly, only for the maximum benefit of the child - again, as the law requires.
Those requirements in the law are the result of tribe/nations demanding tribal/nation involvement, coordination and cooperation. It don't always work, but that is how/what is intended.
Helpful?
Thank you, 1stwarrior, for your information.
Mimi, this is a wonderful article, and thank you for publishing it!
All of us need to learn more, so that we may understand how we got here today-- and how we can move forward in the future.
There are questions I still have about a lot of things, Dowser. I'm pretty ignorant of the inner workings of a Tribal Council, for instance. Some of the tribes are wealthy enough that they could surely fund a program to help Indian youths who are having emotional/mental health issues dealing with balancing old ways and modern society. If there are any I haven't heard of them.
Classic Amac. Clueless.
Reynolds IS Sioux, by ancestry, and the Pine Ridge tribe cannot change that. However, as I stated, the Pine Ridge tribe is to be applauded for taking time out from massive dysfunction, destruction, and failure to address how upset they are that Reynolds doesn't think that Indians should control speech in America.
Good start to a debate point get right to the personal crap.
Otherwise
Note the disparities, Robert?
_________________________________________________
By the way, Robert G, even though I deem you a colossal PIA, I'm glad you're back and hope you are well.
I "believe", the way the laws are written, that the tribe/nation has primary decision-making on who is/isn't a tribal member.
That would be something really good to do-- and I agree: Why hasn't this been already done? Are the adults struggling with it as much as the children?
I just hope that everything gets better for the people!
One of the major concerns of the tribes/nations is how 9 states are "watering" down the ICWA requirements - almost to the point of tribal involvement being non-existent - ND, SD, WY, ID, CA, AK, MT, NC, SC. Those states are very firm believers in states rights superseding any/all tribal rights. They will go to a reservation without warning, walk into a house, take the child/children, and require court attendance the following day. Tribal/nation sovereignty? BS.
SD lost a big case last year, filed by the ACLU, for violation of ICWA and decided not to appeal. They were slapped with some pretty big penalties - but, will anything be done???? ...
But, in a surprising move, the judge of the SD 7th Circuit court was stripped of his title by the SD Supreme Court - . He says it wasn't over the ICWA case - even though 100% of the ICWA cases before him involved removal of the child from the family, which he approved, and he wouldn't allow expert witnesses nor witness testimony of any sort in support of the familes.
I think it's important to know why ICWA was passed. It gives the background to help many understand why and than further discuss it knowing the history.
It's also important to understand that there is NO PENALTY, if the state does not comply with ICWA.
LINK...... ...
This is mind-blowing, 1stwarrior.
One hundred percent of the cases had the children being removed from the family? With no witnesses allowed in support of the family?
What is even more astounding is that the judge was removed of his title. An absolute miracle.
If there is no penalty for refusal to obey the law, what good is the law?
Where would an Indian go for redress?
Isn't this an example of why voting for legislators who would give decent representation in Congress for Indians would be a high priority?
I saw this today on FB and copied it to put here. I hope you don't mind...
"THE LAW" is, and has been rigged against minorities from "Day One".
As we've said all along, Dowser, and are ridiculed and hated for mentioning it at all.
Thank you for the pic.
That's true, Mac.
But Indian children are still the only ones you can openly steal from their families without expecting any law enforcement to come after you.
More nonsense. Non-stop.
You should be ashamed.
In South Dakata, one should be grateful, an HOPE that someone removes their child from Pine Ridge.
The Reservation should be shut down, and the leadership jailed.
I think you guys should go a little bit easier on the "everyone hates Indians" rhetoric, especially on this website where you appear to have overwhelming support. Just a thought.
Guess we felt it went without saying that those supporting us here were not included in negative comments directed at the government body, Congress, that refuses to put any teeth into laws ostensibly meant to "protect" tribes, John.
The comments are meant, also, to be directed at governors and other state legislators who refuse to honor the laws protecting Indians.
Which brings us back to 1stwarrior's article about the importance of legislation that guarantees Indians the same rights and protections pertaining to voting that other citizens of this country have.
You may call it, rhetoric, John, but look closely at the picture Dowser posted, and read it again. There isn't a single word in it that is a lie.
Are you seriously suggesting that screminmimi's statement is a falsehood ?
Thank you, Pat.
Your debate abilities are endless
'Course, they're also beginningless.
Have you read about minorities in America?
Interesting read give it try.
Yes it is mimi. Representation of their constituents should be paramount in their minds. Sadly it isn't.
I googled "indian children removed from their families". Do you know there were 95,000,000 articles ?
As devestating as the past has been, I believe there is something just as devestating coming. Our destruction of the earth, our destruction of her gifts to us, our scarring of that which sustains us all.
For the most part, we have placed the First Peoples on that land which is least able to sustain life, even in the best of times. Now we are even destroying that land and habitat. It seems that we have found an even more insisdious way of destroying the soul.
Students who attended the Genoa Industrial School for Indian Youth in Nebraska in 1910, when this photograph was taken, were mostly Sioux, placed off the reservation and away from their families. The Indian Child Welfare Act reacted against this long history of diplacement as well as against the Indian Adoption Project of the 1950s and 1960s.
In 1978, Congress took a giant legal step toward consolidating group rights to children by passing the Indian Child Welfare Act. ICWA is unique in several ways. First, most laws governing adoption have been passed by states. In this case the federal government overcame its reluctance to legislate because of a long history of displacement of Native American children, significant and systematic enough to be considered a genocidal policy by many tribes. In the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, Native American children were often placed in boarding schools in hopes that education would speed their cultural assimilation, much like the theory of the orphan trains . In the 1950s and 1960s, the Indian Adoption Project placed hundreds of Native American children with white parents, the first national effort to place an entire child population transracially and transculturally.
ICWA reversed this policy. By defining children as collective resources, essential to tribal survival, it stands as a significant exception to the rule of individualism in American law, where childrens best interests are invariably assessed case by case. ICWA made the adoption of Native American children by non-native people extremely difficult by erecting significant barriers to their adoption by anyone without tribal affiliation. It remains a source of ongoing controversy among civil rights and childrens advocates.
Robert - -why the non-sensicle, denigrating comments?
Your statement makes sense, but you are lumping all tribes, through implication, with Pine Ridge. There are a number of tribes/nations who fit the mold of Pine Ridge, but it is up to the people on Pine Ridge to correct - not others. Until they come to grips with their issues, the issues will continue.
In total agreement with you John. Having worked on both sides of the wall, I know not everybody hates tribes/nations. As mimi sez, it is the government bodies who cause the problems and create the barriers. The trick/goal of those of us not in government is trying to help government understand the need for making the changes "for the people", not against the people. That is what all of us should be doing - not just a few.
Good comment though.
Steve - you are discussing the effects of the cause without actually addressing the cause. "We" did not place the First Peoples on that land - others placed the First Peoples on that land as a means of attempting complete/total control of all things, not just the people.
I wasn't using "we" as applying to the First Peoples. I meant it as "my" people, although I seem to identify with "my" people less and less.
Contrary to what a lot of people may say Steve, "your" people are not all bad - just as ou people are not all bad. We just have some compatibility issues that need serious work and it's going got take very seriously open minds to work the issues - together. That is the key Steve - "together".
Steve,
Many people don't know the full truth of what happened to Native Americans, or that much of it is still going on thanks to Congress.
A lot of people think Indians have it made, living for "free" off the government; they have no idea the terms of treaties or that none of the treaty terms have been honored... ever... by the US government, or the true conditions under which many of those on reservations live.
The conditions under which many Indians live on the poorer reservations is a very well kept secret in this country and there is no doubt in my mind that should the real truth ever be revealed, the tide of public opinion for the Indian and against Congress for the limbo in which they force the Nations to exist would become a tsunami.
We can't fault people for lack of action if they don't know action needs to be taken.
Three of the phrases at the bottom of many treaties that the Indian folks joke about are - "As long as the grasses shall grow, the rivers shall run, and the sun shall shine", the conditions/agreements of this treaty shall never be broken.
Later Congressional people, in a joking matter, have said words that should have been added were - or 'til we change our mind, or 'til the cows come home, or 'til the next 30 minutes are up, or 'til . . . . .
The government is allowing corporations to take care of those three conditions quite handily, 1stwarrior.
Look at all the places the grass no longer grown, and the rivers either no longer flow or may as well not since the waters are so toxic nothing can live in them or drink from them.
As far as "and the sun shall shine" .... well, looking at the smog and other pollutants over the cities where you can no longer get a true beam of sunshine, I'd say they are taking care of that, as well. (All said with a bitter smile)
Pretty soon, Indians won't have anything to point to as enforcement for their treaties because the conditions will not be able to be met.
The same political ideologues and the legislators they support, are the enablers, and thus part of the greed-driven, corrupt agenda of Organized Wealth; and for the most part, they are also the enablers of the exploitation and denuding of, and, the polluting-for-profit of the environment. Add to the plague they sew, the institutionalized rigging of "the game" against minorities, the middle class and working poor -- an inherent component of their agenda.
It is no coincidence it is by design; it's all about Money and Power as it panders to the insecure, the ignorant and the hater who looks the other way as long as his scapegoats are vilified and "verified" by the well-funded ministry of propaganda of the almighty dollar!
I await the one-liners of feeble rebuttal.
LITTLE BIG MAN (1970): And the Strangeness of the White Man
I can't rebut, Mac, when I'm so busy agreeing.
Don't see the potential for "one-liners", but I'd like to see some good discussions based on your comment.
While that is so true, Raven, many people are hesitant to speak up because they have jobs that depend on those corporations that are killing the environment.
I honestly have no idea how to come to a compromise on this subject because the corporations answer to stockholders, who in essence are people who don't want their profits via quarterly checks rolled back into the company in an effort to try and find more ecologically-friendly ways to operate.
People such as us are demanding more consideration for the environment while also clamoring for higher wages.
Where are we going to meet along this line of opposite goals? Yes, the companies can afford to get by with fewer profits... but they are not going to do that.
So would I, 1stwarrior. Some real discussion, not antagonistic mud-slinging.
By the way, if anyone is a member of the Science Fiction group, Petey has a truly fascinating article up about a 3-D printed violin that actually plays. It looks like something out of Star Trek.
What if we didn't spend millions, billions, trillions on weapons, and tooka percent of that and invested in the environment. Ways to better use what Mother Earth has for us, by doing it the ''right'' way, instead of the cheapest without regard to the damage we are causing in the name of profit.
It can be done, it that it's takes a commitment. Something that we are unwilling to do, because it will take longer and cost a bit more.
Dear Friends Mimi, 1st Warrior and Kavika: I want to address a post in this discussion thread. Specifically, I want to focus on some ideas raised, not on any personalities involved.
Issue One: The sale or non-sale of tee shirts with Mascots offensive to Native Americans is not the central them of this article. It is a re-railment attempt to bring it up. No need to expend any time or effort on this here. It is a topic dealt with on other discussions. The person who brought it up is quitefree to generate their own article on it. Let's keep our attention on the main point.
The article is about the dismal state of affairs on reservations for Native Americans. The conclusion of the author is that by mobilizing, and block voting the most effective and efficient route can be taken to improve the quality of life for those people living there.
No where inthis essay do I see that taking this route will end every last problem faced, and right every injustice ever to take place for this segment of the population. What is concluded is not a panacea to correct all injustice, and prevent any future difficulties. Of course, that never happens for anyone anywhere. It is an extraneous point to make.
Regarding that main point, I concur with Mimi. There is a large body of historical evidence in American politics that block voting does deliver results in ways the lack of any collective action, or other forms of action doesn't. Structurally, that makes sense.
Politicians who are out of office want to be in office. Those in office want to prolong their stay, and increase their power and influence. That is how politics is played.
To obtain and grow power and influence politicians need money and votes. Block voting addresses voting. Groups who block votealso represent economic interests. These interests can support candidates who favor causes which allow mobilization of block voters.
All Mimi is saying is that the primary response to getting fair and meaningful representationis to organize, and vote in numbers to get what government can provide to help groups with unique needs and causes.
The right to assemble, to organize are bedrock American rights and strategies in the legal and political arenas. I see nothing to indicate any mention or thought of Native Americans being a superior race in that.
What I do see is that if implemented, Native Americans can utilize tried and true proven ways to advance their interests and agendas working within the system.
I support this analysis andtactical plan of action for improvement.
I also remain steadfast in my support of indigenous (First) Americans in gaining justice and equality. Not because I believe they are better than anyone else. Rather because I believe no one of us is better or worse than any other. There fore, equality of opportunity for the good things of life, andequal treatment by the law and societyis something every one of us should support for every other one of us.
We are all related.
Peace Equality, and Abundant Blessings to One and All Alike.
Enoch.
Thank you, Enoch.
There is so much that can be done for Native Americans and so many different tangents I sometimes find myself going off-track in my own discussions. But it is my firm belief that voting, and voting in a power block, is the first step for Indians in achieving parity with other groups in gaining the attention of Congress to have them take notice of what is best for Native Americans.
As hard as it is for separate Nations to come together and for a voting coalition that will make lawmakers/politicians sit up and take notice, they have to do it or continue to be picked apart separately, inch by inch until there is nothing left of Indian land or Indians but their stubborn pride.
They can make a tremendous difference if they come together. It's frustrating that they see that and won't act on it.
One encouraging sign is that the last election cycle, the Indian vote was the largest ever.
That's encouraging news; here's sincerely hoping the trend continues.
In support of your comment mimi - here in NM, there are 24 Pueblos/tribes/nations - all are different. The Pueblos/tribes/nations formed a coalition called the All Indian Pueblo Council in 1586 (so the history goes)( ) and, during the past 20 years, have been holding at least two meetings each year, working together, to support the AIPC. But NO INDIVIDUAL PUEBLO/TRIBE/NATION represents nor speaks for the others - never have and never will. They have learned to work together to care for the "peoples".
Other tribal/nation entities can/could form the same type of organization/group and work together - talk about making a power statement.
Brother Enoch, as always, your words bring meaning and truth to a muddled world. I am not even attempting to speak for anyone but myself when I say - "Thank you".
And, did you know that, surprisingly, there are a number of companies who WILL NOT produce anything unless it is actually part of the environment in a positive way. I like that.
Sez a lot to those who listen.
I like it as well 1st. They are a small percentage of the overall number, but it seems that they are growing. I purchase my wild rice, syrup and jam's from the Ojbiwe on line store in MN. All produced in the traditional way. No damage to the environment.
Very well said Enoch.
Many thanks.
My mother's baby sister, now in her eighties, is just now beginning to come forth with information about the family and its Indian roots.
On my Dad's side, it has been harder, as he was twenty years older than my Mom and his immediate relatives are all gone now. We are finding old Bibles and piecing together bits and pieces as we talk among ourselves.
This is one reason I say if Indians would organize into a voting block, and had a PR arm representing the basic needs and points of the Nations (yes, I really said a PR arm), I feel there would be a huge response from the body of Americans across the country.
There are literally untold thousands of Americans who proudly self-identify as Native American and have no proof whatsoever that it is true... but they believe it to the roots of their soul. They don't care about being on a register, and I believe if Indians got their story into the mainstream media these people would stand with them in their fight for fair representation in Congress.
One of the most popular Native Americans on stage, whose appearances are consistently sold out is John Two-Hawks; he self-identifies as a Sioux. The registered Native Americans do not stand alone and they don't even know it... or if they do know it, they don't realize how powerful a movement they can instigate if they just take that first step forward.
You hit on a subject that, IMO, requires a lot more discussion. And yes, action mimi.
BTW, John lives just over the Arkansas border from me. Quite the interesting man. I love the songs that he did with the group, ''Nightwish''. Sold out all over Europe..Creek Mary's Blood and the Stone People from the album, ''End of an Era'' are both outstanding songs. He is one hell of a showman.
There is a song, done by Walela called, ''I Have No Indian Name''. Outstanding and quite meaningful.
What? What?? WHAT????
You've met him??? You've MET HIM???
I love his music!!! Even watching him on video, he is mesmerizing!!
Exactly, Raven.
And the Nations could tap into that "Native pride" to add to their voting base so easily. They just need to find a way to get the message out as to what they want and need and they would find so many people willing to join their voices and votes with the Indian concerns.
Calm down mimi,
Yes I've met him a couple of times. Did you know that he plays a dozen instruments?
Alsoknow Keith Secola, he's a cousin. Do you know the song NDN Car?
Yes, I know the song.
Say, Kavika.. Is John into politics in any way?
Not really, except to promote the First People.
Because of all the negative comments and articles on Pine Ridge, I thought that I'd post an article on all of the GOOD things that are happening on Pine Ridge. It's a couple of years old, but the progress is still going on.
...
Do you have a link or a name of the store, Kavika? Thanks!
Here it is Dowser.
That's too bad, he could swing a vote or two or three.
(Ever get a selfie with him, send it to me...)
Thanks for the link. Again, lack of knowledge about the way Nations/tribes are set up has most people thinking that all reservations share equally in profits and resources.
I wasn't joking yesterday when I said the tribes need their own PR arm.
Piggy-backing on your comment mimi - wish more media would publish information similar to Kavika's.
Tie this into the history of our people/nations - True map - no changes nor photochopped.