Why, as a Moderator, I Rarely Remove Comments … Not Even Some of the Most Stupid, Ugly or Offensive
"Better to remain silent and be thought a fool than to speak out and remove all doubt." _ Abraham Lincoln
I was recently criticized by a member of NT for a caveat I left in one of the threads, namely
"A generic reminder to all; keep it from getting personal".
Fair enough criticism; but there are reasons why I rarely use the "hammer," and those who may be critical of what appears to be indifferent moderation, are entitled to an explanation. As follows:
There is a value in "giving someone enough rope to hang himself." It often lets us know in most telling ways, who that person is, what he is, how he thinks or, IF HE IS EVEN CAPABLE OF WHAT AN INTELLIGENT, REASONABLE PERSON WOULD DEEM AS THINKING.
Frequently, those who post the most vile, hateful, insensitive, mean-spirited, borderline sane or "over-the-border" comments, will include propaganda and similar vitriol from various sources as "validation" and "verification" and "justification" for their own warped sense of reality and dark vision. And when I see such propaganda and/or outright lies, I will do my best to address them by providing the ACTUAL, FACTUAL corrections.
Two reasons:
1) Some might otherwise simply and naively buy the lies without questioning and become inadvertent carriers of those lies
2) Those who willingly spread the propaganda will know that there are those of us who will confront them.
As a newspaper editor (now retired), even in my most emotionally-driven editorials, I felt it a matter of character and integrity to be clear about what was my opinion and what was verifiable truth.
As a representative of individuals cited for and charged with various forms of misconduct, when I felt strongly or knew for certain that my client was wrongly accused and could find assertions by a plaintiff that revealed a weak case or a pile of shit, in the course of an arbitration, I would refer to that shit pile early and often so as to get it on the record. By doing that, without overtly attacking the plaintiff's ineptitude or character, I made sure all involved could see for themselves.
"There's no law against being an asshole," an attorney friend once declared. "Beat the assholes with their own sticks by giving them every opportunity to be themselves!"
And that is exactly what I do as moderator on NT early and often. I let them reveal the worst in themselves while correcting their wrong-headed assertions and bad "information"; I let them spew their hatred, flaunt their macho-insensitivities, allow them to project their own character flaws, and do it all for the ultimate objective of proving Honest Abe correct in his postulation
"Better to remain silent and be thought a fool than to speak out and remove all doubt."
Tags
Who is online
122 visitors

"Better to remain silent and be thought a fool than to speak out and remove all doubt."
Happy that you posted this. I was thinking that some of the threads are way out of hand. Now that I see your take on it, I have a better understanding of your rules.
FYI
Symptoms
By Mayo Clinic staff
General symptoms of a personality disorder
Personality disorder symptoms include:
Specific types of personality disorders
The specific types of personality disorders are grouped into three clusters based on similar characteristics and symptoms. Many people with one diagnosed personality disorder also have signs and symptoms of at least one additional personality disorder.
Cluster A personality disorders
These are personality disorders characterized by odd, eccentric thinking or behavior and include:
Paranoid personality disorder
Schizoid personality disorder
Schizotypal personality disorder
Cluster B personality disorders
These are personality disorders characterized by dramatic, overly emotional thinking or behavior and include:
Antisocial (formerly called sociopathic) personality disorder
Borderline personality disorder
Histrionic personality disorder
Narcissistic personality disorder
Believing that you're better than others
Cluster C personality disorders
These are personality disorders characterized by anxious, fearful thinking or behavior and include:
Avoidant personality disorder
Dependent personality disorder
Obsessive-compulsive personality disorder
Obsessive-compulsive personality disorder isn't the same as obsessive-compulsive disorder, a type of anxiety disorder.
When to see a doctor
If you have any signs or symptoms of a personality disorder, see your doctor, mental health provider or other health care professional. Untreated, personality disorders can cause significant problems in your life, and they may get worse without treatment.
Helping a loved one
If you have a loved one who you think may have symptoms of a personality disorder, have an open and honest discussion about your concerns. You may not be able to force someone to seek professional care, but you can offer encouragement and support. You can also help your loved one find a qualified doctor or mental health provider and make an appointment. You may even be able to go to an appointment with him or her.
If you have a loved one who has harmed himself or herself, or is seriously considering doing so, take him or her to the hospital or call for emergency help.
If you have an erection for more than four hours
Invite some people over.
Have it bronzed BadFish. No, on second thought, not a good idea. Take a photo of a once in a life time experience.
Mac,
As a mod, and a person who believes that folks should "speak their mind", I think that it's also important to recognize when the line has been crossed and direct moderation is needed. Sometimes and article can grow far to acidic and too hard to reel in. I realize as moderators, that call is made differently for each of us. But the one thing that we should be unified in, is a breach of the CoC. Otherwise the CoC means nada. Just my take. Disagree if you will.
Fire his sorry ass, Perrie!!
Now, Now Jon... I am not the boss here. But I think it is an interesting discussion and one that may be needed, although it caught me off guard today.
I agree that at some point, when the CoC is clearly violated, it should be enforced -- no argument. I tend to be slow to remove violative comments for the reasons I listed and explained. There are times when perpetrators of varying degrees, in my opinion, should have to own their words and be vulnerable to "slings and arrows."
If a cheap shot or ugly comment is immediately deleted, its author ironically may get to take his shot, offend the intended target but suffer no "public" scorn for doing so. It's analogous to the kid who smacks his brother on the head, quickly turns the other way in order to defy detection and appear innocent -- then, when his brother retaliates and kicks the shit out of him, cries to his mother, "Mom, Mac just beat the shit out of me for no reason -- aren't you going to punish him?!"
Of course, this ain't mom and brother and, as I myself have urged in the past, "be civil to one another lest we drive away members." But that does not negate the "value" of allowing there to stand, a period of negative light to be projected on negative people. There is value in allowing the crime to be graphically revealed so that we may know the identity and mind of the criminal.
"All that's past is prologue." The Shakespearean phrase means that "history influences, and sets the context for, the present."
"Forewarned is forearmed" -- Those who know that something is coming are better prepared to face it than those who do not know.
What about the rest of me?
wow,..this morning Iwoke up feeling good about myself,...after all I am the LoneRanger01....now I read this from AMac and I now have doubts about myself,....
I guess generally speaing I have a disorderly personality,....
LR,
I just put the shoes on the shelves -- I work in the stock department; only the customers can determine which ones fit.
Excellent article, dear A Mac! Thanks for posting this-- it makes a lot of sense!
This is true. But when things goparticularlysour, it becomes a reflection of the group. But bottom line, authors call.
Fair enough outlook, in my opinion.
Long ago I learned not to ctritique volunteers. While standing line one day at a function, a fellow was complaining to another as to how he should be doing this or that. The fellows response was "You do not pay me enough to listen to this crap", the others response was "But we don't pay you, you're a volunteer". The afronted fellow just grinned and said " Yup".
End of conversation. Just keep doing what you're doing.
BadFish, excuse my ignorance but I am a New Englander. What the hell is a drum circle?
In some ways it does; but it also affords the same group an opportunity to collectively castigate ugly, ignorant and dishonest posts. In that sense it makes it more difficult for the offender to blame the moderator for playing favorites or acting arbitrarily. We have members who attack moderators as such EVEN WHEN THEY'RE NOT MODERATING!
The "court of public opinion" can be an effective adjudicator and render "decisions" with the power of its numbers behind it!
Sounds like a neighborhood I hang out in occasionally, every time I go to meet my friend at his store I pass a drum circle!
Don't be silly, Mac. Jonathan is having a go at you.
True all the way around Mike.
Yes, this is a problem. I think some have a hard time with the concept that when a mod isn't in purple, then they are just like any other member. Also that mods are not top dogs here. They arevolunteersjust doing a thankless task.
LOL Luther.. my thoughts exactly!
LOL John, no it wasn't.
Ricky Ricardo where are you?
That is the funniest thing I have ever seen.. looks like fun or a head ache.
Wait.. I thought that Texas had Mexicans not Cubans.
You have mysympathies
.
Damn.. I never noticed them. We had a sax player screeching away... and a drummer with him.. but hardly a drum circle.
I agree A. Macarthur that has always been my attitude as well on moderation. Such as on Newsvine when I used to have power of moderation on my articles in the Old Newsvine I rarely exercised that power even when a lot of my friends were upset with me for not exercising that power. They wanted me to delete comments that were way over the line on reason, tone, appropriateness etc... and more then 9 times out of 10 I would let them stand. It was a bit anarchistic on the comments on my articles at times. However I preferred that over tight control and censoring of free speech. Usually the only time I would delete a comment when I offered a warning and they didn't get the hint the first time or if they were especially cruel to another member. As for me I could care less what they thought and said about me I could take it.
Damn, AMac! So sensitive.
We've never had a "moderation moment". I thought on that basis alone you'd have taken it as a chide...
Alan,
You, and I and Mac were in the minority on that at NV. I was on articles where my presence alone got deleted. It is why we don't have that capacity here at NT. The code is there and if someone likes their article to remain in a certain tone, the mods will gladly oblige so long as it isn't arbitrary. It must be a CoC violation, or it stands.
Mike,
It's not meta if it isn't tagged so. LOL!
BTW.. I count 2 pussies, 2 bitches and 2 fuck em's. Do you have something on your mind?
I am that much more happy to be in New England. Funny thing is one day they will become moderates.
And I believe I have made clear the reasons for my judgements, actions, and my slow-to-action moments as moderator.
Jonathan, I confess, I thought you were serious. That's on me and I owe you an apology.
I apologize. In fact, let me go back and delete my related comments.
Now THAT'S MODERATION.
So, I can stay?
Stop holding back Mike, tell us what you really think.
Being a moderator is a lot like being a cop. If you encounter an argument (which seems to happen quite often), you calm the situation and, at least to some extent, try to separate the combatants. Physical action shouldn't be taken unless somebody tries to use actual violence. Removing comments is the internet equivalent of physical action. Shouldn't be used unless the offending comment is a blatant, egregious violation. I saw Mac's comment on the article he referenced and think that he did it exactly right. He let the parties know that things were getting a bit too extreme and that they should step back a couple of paces. If they don't follow through with that, other actions can be taken as needed.
Seed a pro-rightwing article, and I'll think about it.
I'll take my chances and in the meantime, look for other employment.
Unless of course you can give me an easier assignment.
Free knowledge.
Bring your own containers.
Well, I do accept your apology.
As far as an easier assignment, that involves a bit more consideration...
A few years back, I owned and operated my own forum, on my own server on my own domain. It was for females only, deepnet and password protected. The idea was a web site/forum that could not be accessed by any spiders, crawlers, indexers or basically any internet bot. You had to know the exact IP# to get there. It worked well, technically, for a year and a half before I shut it down.
#1 reason for shut down? Lack of dependable monitors . I wanted absolutely nothing to do with being a mod in a forum or chat room. As the only rule the site had was you had to tag in/out 2x a month to stay active, mods ended up doing nothing and when arguments broke out, got into the bad habit passing it to me. Everyone wants to be a mod BUT would rather not deal with the emotional fallout that happens when you are forced to make a decision.
Having said that, 4-Chan has the best mod system around. In their rules: moderators cannot post in the forums or otherwise contact anyone who posts there. They are absolutely anonymous.
A. Macarthur, regarding article:
A lot of info there Mac.
I'm confused, did you say you were a: newspaper editor - now retiered, or a doctor of human phsycological disfunction?
I got a great deal of enjoyment from reading this and appreciate the work you put in. Thanks for letting us make an ass out of ourselves.
Damn all i did was wake up my roommate....
I said I was a retired newspaper editor; the list comes from the Mayo Clinic. I posted the list in anticipation of the almost inevitable barrage of comments regarding my article, comments that would likely try to:
psychoanalyze me for posting the article
psychoanalyze people who post offensive, inaccurate, overtly false, mean-spirited, ugly, insensitive and/or stupid stuff or,
make excuses for times they're called out when they post offensive, inaccurate, overtly false, mean-spirited, ugly, insensitive and/or stupid stuff
Having been an editor, I had years of posting information from endless sources for my readers.
That's the kind of guy I am. I'm sure you'll find me somewhere in the Mayo Clinic list.
Do you expect people to swallow that?
I agree that there is more value in letting stupid or over the top comments stand, as it allows readers to see just how much of an asshole some people can be. I moderated over 3,400 of my own articles and seeds at Newsvine, (a requirement on that site) and I don't think I deleted more than a dozen or so of the many thousands of comments those articles generated, all of those I deleted were direct attacks on other members, and in most cases they were not deleted without at least one prior warning. (Unless of course, the comment was a blatant CoC violation)
The 'generic reminder' Mac is referred to was posted on an article written by another member, that article in itself was a vile insult to those that lost life and limb in the Boston Marathon bombing, but the vitriol and grenade throwing that developed in the thread was even worse. Actually, Mac tried a couple of time to calm things down by posting other similar 'reminders'. However, the author of the article, rather than attempt to get control of his own thread, elected to fan the flames and respond to comments critical of his position, with personal attacks and insults.
Now I'm aware that Perrie established NT with the intent of giving members a little more reign than is being allowed at Newsvine and some other sites, however I am under the impressionthatcomments that are directpersonalattacks like the following, are NT CoCviolations;
"(NT member) save your falseindignation for those on newsvine. It won't fly here as I know you well there and how you post. You say a whole lot of nothing and think you contributed somethingintelligent.
The only BS on this article is your self delusion of having anyintelligence. you only like to spout hatred of an ideology you have no clue about with your ramblings about right wing nuts and the like. take it elswhere."
And,
"Why would I want to take this to heated discussions so you can think your superior to everyone with your single braincell? ................ I know how limited your intellect actually is."
If those comments were made on a thread from an article of mine they would have been deleted, but, in this case, they were actually made by the author of the article. Imo, rhetoric likethat renders a discussion meaningless and diminishesthe overall quality of NewsTalkers as a discussion forum.
Btw, there is a fine line betweencriticizinga member and attacking a member. For instance, accusing someone of being delusional regarding a comment they made or an article they posted is a criticism, but saying someone is delusional to think they have any intelligence is a personal attack. Or, to tell someone they think they are superior to everyone for one reason or another, is a criticism, but to tell someone they have a single brain cell is a direct attack.
It has merit. I will always question the fairness, impartiality and judgement of any mod who posts....always.
If the word "anonymous" in this case, gets you conspiratorial minded, that is its own punishment
.
Out In Seattle that had a group called the Peace Heathens who put on this camping weekend festival in late August called the Starlight Mountain Festival. Had a lot of people at their drum circle, coming and going, weaving in and out of each other rythmically, some playing, some dancing and some just watching the full moon crest over the Cascades. It was quite wonderful.
What's "First of all" here, is understanding what Moderated threads are all about. They are about civility, and you Mr. Lonkouskin are obviously oblivious the the meaning of that word.
Your entire comment is fucked up because you obviously have no clue as to what moderating a thread is about. Moderating a thread is not about scolding, rebuking or correcting comments. Opposing opinions have nothing to do with site moderation. Moderating is all about keeping the rhetoric civil, and that's all it is.
That is ALL moderating is about, it has nothing to do with "protecting" anyone.
Yes you do, if you don't care what anyone thinks why do you bother posting on these sites?
People who think they have to tell people how strong they are, usually are more trying to convince themselves,becausethey know inside they aren'treallyall that strong. Keep in mind that "strong willed" is often confused with "stubborn ignorance".
Then you won't mind me pointing out that you never ask anything to be moderatedbecauseyou want to be allowed to continue being an obnoxious asshole.
Don't flatter yourself Lonkouski, nobody whines about you because you don't cower (more self reassurance?), it's just that after a while you become a total boor.
Do I detect a bit of paranoid personality disorder here?
I have a great trinket I keep on my desk that displays much of what you have described. It is a brass model of the three monkeys, housing a magnifying glass. You will note that these monkeys are: Look for evil, listen to evil, and speak evil loudly.
Best I can do...
Sorry Jerry that I am late to this party, but it isn't my article.. so I didn't feel the need to respond until now.
I established NT for several reasons. The first was that the concept that the members make a site. Otherwise it's just some odd coding in cyberspace. Something I felt the site I left had forgotten. With that in mind, the first issue was what the Code of Conduct and of course would would make for a good community. Most of us wanted a degree of civility, but also wanted to maximize freedom of speech, hence our tag line "Speak your mind". It is a tricky line to walk. There is a level ofinterpretationthat each of us mods brings to the job. Unless it is wildly out of line with the CoC, most calls are respected.
Also, we all chose which article to enter. If I don't like the way an author runs an article, I don't go there. And while I disagree with Mike when he says:
Since I view it as not allowing attacks on people rather than ideas... I usually just remove the offending part of a remark with a simple "Comment removed for CoCviolation"which is a more aggressive form of moderation that Mac does... I'd rather nip it in the bud and not give them rope, it is my opinion that often means they don't hang alone.
But hey, that is what makes us all different.
There may come a time when you would like tovolunteerto be a moderator. You will find that it is a thankless job. But it will also give you a new perspective on what we do here.
Perrie, couldn't send a contact author, couldn't report an issue, and know you're busy today! The site keeps spinning and is having loading issues for me-- maybe it's just me!
I keep getting the message in the lower left-hand corner, waiting for www.mmadsadgadget ... And it spins some more.
Again, it may just be me.
Whatever it was it's fixed!
Late?You'renot late, sometimes I can't get back to my articles for 2 days!
I think you have accomplished that, whereas the other site still doesn't get it.
That's what makes it fun, walking the fine line that separates the snark from the insults.
Imo, that's the way it should be.
You mean, you don't stay there, you have to go there in order to find out you don't like the way the author is conducting their thread.However, when an author post a highly controversial article and then elevates the vitriol the article generates by responding to criticism with name calling and insults, it causes the thread to degenerate into a cesspool of vile nonsense, and IMO, reduces theintegrity and qualityof the entire site.
I might do that, I moderated over 3,400 articles and seeds thatgeneratedover 23,000 comments when I was at Newsvine, but they were all my own threads, I suppose it's different whenyou'remoderating the threads for someone elses articles.
What you said was (exact words); "And by "moderated" I mean "scolded, rebuked, corrected", and /or told something like "You can't talk to him/her that way"."
ME?! say "yeah, your right" to you?!! Please!!
You said (exact words); " .......moderation is nothing but a shield for "the weak".
Whatever Mike.
It has nothing to do with "these days", it's something I learned from apsychologymajor almost 50 years ago. ("utter nonsense;" rhymes with "stubbornignorance")
Now? You've beenthatway for the entire 5 years I've known you. Ithoughtyou knew that, everybody else seems to know it. The difference with you is, there is something about you that people like, which makes you a tolerable obnoxious asshole. (I guess that;s why we've been "frenemies" for so long.)
Did I say there was something about you people like? I think it must bebecauseyou have such aweirdsense of humor.
Yeah, it sounds like something you would say.
Don't include me in that group. For me your easy pickin's, you have a tendency to walk around with a constant "foot-in-your-mouth" posture.
I'm glad to see you have thedescriptionof you and your Right Wingnut friends downpat.
What's that suppose to mean? A "screed" issomethingused when you pour concrete. Are you saying my comments are as solid as concrete?
Well, yes.
Well, those are the articles I was referring to. It was something that Krishna taught me in my early days on the vine. If you don't go to those articles, the wither away and die. By choosing not to support those authors you are also choosing to support a higher level of discussion. It's the same reason why we read certain Op Eds in papers and not others.
You have wonderful credentials.. but as for moderating someone else's article's.. one only knows when brought to the task.
perri , i have moderated chats MSN and others , Was a national and state level moderator with oathkeepers here on ning for a time , i can attest that moderation AND participation in discussions is a hard line to walk ( been compared to herding chickens and cats at the same time ) and that moderation itself is a thankless job . beiing one who has been in those shoes , i can safely say that the moderation team that has been assembled here on NT is one of the very best i have seen in my time on the net . yes individuals will have their own personal beliefs and it is good to see that the assembled crew , though it might be hard at times , follows the ground rules you all have agreed on for this place to function as it does . my hat is off to you all for creating and maintaining such a space here . and this coming from one that likes to to be a crumudgeon , cantacorous , sarcastic , and sometimes attempts to be humourous participant . and yes , i just like being a general all around asshole , i was born one , i just grew bigger.
remember the moderators prayer : remember the definition of stress, it is the result of theminds overcoming the bodys natural urge to bitchslap the living dogpiss out of some asshole that truely deserves it .
I knew i was taking you out of context on that one, but I wanted to see if you were paying attention.
I accept your concession.
I'm glad Mac decide have an open discussion in responsed the criticismhereceived, because I have learned a lotaboutthe way threads are moderated on social news sites.
For one thing, I was not aware of the importance of a moderator to refrain from commenting on a thread they are moderating,whichapparently is not the practice here.
It could become difficult for a moderator to remain 100% if objective if they areparticipatingin the debate. Even if the moderators are being completely objective, it leaves open the appearance of a conflict of interest.
IMO, NT should change it's policy regarding moderator participation in discussions. But that's just me, I'm curious as to the opinion of other members regarding this issue.
I prefer the Proverbs quote:
"Even a fool, if he keeps silent, is deemed wise.
Intelligent, if he seals his lips. (Prov. 17:28)"
But I notice that,more commonly,the Right gets criticized for intemperate speech while the Left's speechis accepted as truth.
Have a nice weekend.
Len
I think Perrie made her opinion on that pretty clear the other day on another discussion:
Reply by Perrie Halpern 5 hours agoLen, can you show us a couple of examples to clarify just what you mean?
The problem is, I have never come across a non-partisan, non-partisan independent, and I've been doing this stuff for over 50 years.I use the slogan, "Trying to stay in the middle of the issues", but I can never seem to find the "middle",becauseit just will not stay still!
I totally disagree with that idea.
One of the things I like about NT is the moderators can enjoy the ability to post just like anyone else and have their opinions just like anyone else.
Another thing I like is you have both sides, so to speak, of the isle covered with moderators that even disagree with each other in political matters. This helps promote free expression from everyone on NT without feeling like you can be oppressed so easily.
There are many more things I like and will probably put on here by the time I arrived on the last page, but it isn't tied to a bunch of looney newscasters that promote the division of the participants.
I think what Mike is trying to say is.......
I think what Jerry is saying is......
I personally like it just like it is.
I find the "Mail Room" is a good way to get to know the other members. Some of my best conversations, jokes and all have been in the "Mail Room" if you want to work on that psychological inability to socialize.
If you want to have a more private conversation and not tie the "Mail Room" up with it then you just click on the members name and have a private conversation. I've had just as many good conversations with people that completely disagree with my politics in the "Mail Room" as I've had with people that see things the same way I do.
This was something we were unable to do at NV. There was no way to get a little closer to the other person. I think when you get to know people a little more personal it works in a positive manner for the next time you are involved in a political debate to lend them a little less aggressive reply in the debate.
Now I like the fights and sarcasm as long as it doesn't come to hardcore blows with demeaning comments toward that person. But if that is your style then you are allowed to stretch it out a little here and enjoy yourself.
Some of us are a little more thick skinned and a little less offended.
You Know What I Say?
Let me say one more thing. There are so many Groups that offer so many opportunities to get to know each other on NT and enjoy good music, photos, learn things you have never done before in you life that will definitely enhance it.
Not a thing wrong with your style of moderation, Mac!