╌>

'It's ok for homosexuals to do what they want at home, how is this different?' Lawyer defends Columbia professor charged with incest

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  len  •  13 years ago  •  57 comments

'It's ok for homosexuals to do what they want at home, how is this different?' Lawyer defends Columbia professor charged with incest

This article is now closed until Len comes back to moderate.

'It's ok for homosexuals to do what they want at home, how is this different?' Lawyer defends Columbia professor charged with incest

By Daily Mail Reporter

David Epstein is charged with third-degree incest over an alleged three-year sexual relationship with his 24-year-old daughter

David Epstein is charged with third-degree incest over an alleged three-year sexual relationship with his 24-year-old daughter

The lawyer representing a professor charged with incest with his 24-year-old daughter has questioned why the alleged affair has been made public.

David Epstein was charged last week with one count of incest for what was allegedly a consensual three-year sexual relationship with his daughter.

The political science professor at Columbia University, 46, allegedly slept with her between 2006 and 2009.

Epstein, who specialises in American politics and voting rights, is also said to have exchanged twisted text messages with the woman during their relationship.

Matthew Galluzzo, defending Epstein, has said that even though his daughter had emerged as a victim in the case, she could 'best be described as an accomplice'.

He told ABCNews.com: 'Academically, we are obviously all morally opposed to incest and rightfully so.

'At the same time, there is an argument to be made in the Swiss case to let go what goes on privately in bedrooms.

'It's ok for homosexuals to do whatever they want in their own home . How is this so different?

'We have to figure out why some behaviour is tolerated and some is not.'

In an interview with the Huffington Post, he added: 'What goes on between consenting adults in private should not be legislated. That is not the proper domain of our law.

'If we assume for a moment that both parties [involved in incest] are consenting, then why are we prosecuting this?'

Epstein, who has taught at Harvard and Stanford, is currently on administrative leave from Columbia.

He was married to another lecturer at the Ivy League institution but the pair recently divorced.

In an earlier statement Mr Galluzzo called the charges against the professor 'unwarranted and unfair'.

'Professor Epstein is well-respected by his peers and students and he asks that his friends in the Columbia community support him and give him the benefit of the doubt during this trying time,' he added.

Switzerland legislators have proposed decriminalising consensual sexual relationships between first-degree relatives, including siblings and parents and their adult children.

Consensual incest is also legal in China, France, Israel, the Ivory Coast, the Netherlands, Russia, Spain and Turkey, according to a 2007 report from the Max Planck Institute in Germany.


Read more: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-1339108/David-Epstein-Homosexuals-want-INCEST-different.html#ixzz2Pci988NN
Follow us: @MailOnline on Twitter | DailyMail on Facebook


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    13 years ago

'It's ok for homosexuals to do whatever they want in their own home . How is this so different?

LOl...:~)....because one is between family members, while one isn't.

"'We have to figure out why some behavior is tolerated and some is not.'"

The one is tolerated because it is a consensual relationship between adults, that do not result in automatic genetic abnormalities, nor prey on the young in trusting, vulnerable situations.

Even though the specified situation in the article stated that the incest was consensual between adults, incest is never between adults, it starts before adulthood.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

I think it was Dostoyevsky that wrote:

"If there is no God then all is permitted."

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    13 years ago

offspring from incestual relationships does not automatically result in genetically 'damaged' offspring (actually it never does, if continued, it results in recessive genes being more prone to present itself, so if a person has the gene for cystic fibrosis, then their daughter is likely to also have it, and their offspring is more likely to have the disease itself).

Nope.

Eventually it does. Sometimesevenwithin only one generation.

 
 
 
Wheel
Freshman Quiet
link   Wheel    13 years ago

endogamy, consanguinity and community genetics

[Paper] Endogamy, consanguinity and community genetics (Citations: 18) A. H. BITTLES

The population of India is composed of many thousands of subpopulations, divided by geography, language, religion and caste or biraderi (patrilineage) boundaries, with endogamous marriage the norm. The net effect has been the creation of multiple genetic isolates with indi- vidual mutation profiles, but to date the clinical con- sequences of this highly complex differentiation have been largely ignored. In contrast, the topic of consan- guinity continues to attract attention among medical and population geneticists, clinicians and social scientists. The significant progress made in India in improving childhood nutritional status and combating infectious disease means that genetic disorders have assumed ever- increasing importance. In populations where consan- guineous marriage is widely practised, recessive genetic disorders will continue to gain greater prominence in the overall spectrum of ill health. At the same time this increase will in part be negated by urbanization and the move to smaller family sizes, which predictably will result in a decline in the prevalence of consanguineous unions. Developing an understanding of these changes will require a wide-ranging and multidisciplinary investi- gative approach for which community genetics is ideally suited. Published in 2003.

So, fixing bad alleles in a population that marries into itself generation after generation is a possibility.

That said, if the siblings in question are NOT themselves the product of inbreeding and if they are healthy in general the odds are very large that any child will be normal and healthy.

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    13 years ago

So, fixing bad alleles in a population that marries into itself generation after generation is a possibility.

True. Often when it comes to livestock and domesticated species, inbreeding is used and manipulated for desired traits. The studies themselves are interesting in their observations. for instance thecitedexample in india is also illustrated in many other areas globally, and come to similar conclusions. Also though, unlike migration patterns exhibited by..."

At the same time this increase will in part be negated by urbanization and the move to smaller family sizes, which predictably will result in a decline in the prevalence of consanguineous unions."

...other societal migration patterns far differ. There is more of an implosion of movement in many places as well.

That being said, if I had to guess, I would say that in societies where incest is accepted, there would also be manyoccurrencesof trans-generational relationships . While odds are ok in regards to having a healthy baby, there will be an uptick in the percentages of genetic abnormalities. Unless the society is run in a lab, by lab standards, there is no way I see of preventing it.

Just mho.

 
 
 
Polka-san
Freshman Silent
link   Polka-san    13 years ago

While I think incest is wrong and people that do that should kill themselves, as long as it doesn't involve a child, it should be legal.

 
 
 
Shub Orinuj
Freshman Silent
link   Shub Orinuj    13 years ago

Lets throw all out the window and saybestiality,polygamy, and sex with minors are all okay while we are at it. Relgions will have a field day with this.

I understand historically humans have been doing odd taboo's and no problem with it here. Incest is crossing the line is it not? Yes I know AugustusCesar, Thomas Jefferson, and so many great men had incest relationships, but is it okay.

To me incest is crossing the line, and I hope we do not see the government stepping in and making incest marriage legal.

 
 
 
Shub Orinuj
Freshman Silent
link   Shub Orinuj    13 years ago

it is a matter of time before society allows it.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

I know of a family where the father reportedly had an incestuous relationship with his daughter.

She was very screwed up (no pun intended) and commited suicide.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

Today people, even some here, are essentially arguing: "What is wrong with that?"

If you are familiar with Bioethics Prof. Peter Singer of Princeton, you would know that he is the prophet of this revolution.

QED!

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

That signifies that Prof. Singer is actually advocating what you are sardonically fantacizing -- all except toasters that is.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

It is about defining deviency downwards in Sen. Moynihan's phrase.

More so year by year with no end in sight.

Actually, instead of going forward we are going backwards to what civilization was like before Judaism conducted a sexual revolution to heterosexual marriage of one man/one woman.

All about this in Dennis Prager's article in the other thread. I respectfully suggest thatyou read his article containg chapter and verse about the Jewish revolution now being undone.

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   Aeonpax    13 years ago

Attention ye boys and girls, David Epstein has a couple powerful allies backing him up on this incest stuff, like God and the Bible. Now hear me out.

In the beginning ( according to some Christians; about 6,001 years ago ) there was Nothing. Then for lack of anything better to do, God said Let there be light. Now, there was still Nothing but now you could see it. Pretty cool I think.

Anyways, on the 2 nd day, 24 hours later, God started really cooking so by the 4 th day, she actually created a source for that light she made on the first day. Confusing, eh? Too bad.

On the last day she created Adam and Eve and put them in this place called the Garden of Eden. Some Christians have long wondered where the Garden of Eden was, most think that it was somewhere in the Middle East, while others believe it existed in what we now call New Jersey.

They eventually got evicted and settled down in Hawaii and started making babies. Their first two, Cain and Able, were disappointments. Able ODd and Cain split to start a ranch, training dinosaurs to allow humans to ride them.

Now, many believe that Adam and Eve are responsible for populating the world. If that is true, that must have been one massive incest orgy going on for at least 500 to 600 years. Mom/son, Dad/daughter, brother/sistera literal ongoing baby making operation, all in the family.

Its fairly obvious to me that God condoned this. So David has a point about incest, unfortunately, not a legal point despite his credentials as a political science professor. That defense had already been tried and shot down in LAWRENCE V. TEXAS in 2003 ( )

So boys and girls, this entire train of false logic provided by Mr. Epstein is just a legal red herring. However, religiously speaking, the facts back him up.

 
 
 
pat wilson
Professor Quiet
link   pat wilson    13 years ago

Polka -san

Your comment is absurd. What exactly are you trying to say ? So, incest that does not involve a child is okay but in the same breath "incest is wrong and people that do that should kill themselves"

And what in the hell does this mean ?

" as long as it doesn't involve a child, it should be legal ".

Are you really saying that incest should be legal as long as children are not involved ?
 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    13 years ago

While I personally find this to be utterly abhorrent, if his lawyer doesn't say something , he is not providing his client with a defense-- and perhaps, the case could be thrown out on a technicality and have to be re-tried.

As just a person, not an attorney, I don't think I could defend him.

Hope you are well, today, Len! Smile.gif

 
 
 
luther28
Sophomore Silent
link   luther28    13 years ago

To the best of my knowledge it is rather impossible for members of the like sex to impregnate one or the other. In the case of these two the opposite is the case and we all well know what the result of such a pregnancy may produce. Hence the difference from my perspective. Along with it is kind of creepy.

 
 
 
Polly Cooper
Freshman Silent
link   Polly Cooper    13 years ago

Just simply none of our business. Two consenting ADULTS. As far as the other comments about bestiality, minors, etc - you're forgetting - animals and children can't CONSENT. Weird and twisted, but in the long run, none of our business

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   Jonathan P    13 years ago

"Hey dad, get off me!! You're crushin' my cigarettes...."

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    13 years ago

LOL, Robert! Smile.gif

 
 
 
Strangerthanfiction
Freshman Silent
link   Strangerthanfiction    13 years ago

Say what now? Not the same thing at all! Ridiculous 102.gif

 
 
 
brightstarone
Freshman Silent
link   brightstarone    13 years ago

'It's ok for homosexuals to do what they want at home, how is this different?' Lawyer defends Columbia professor charged with incest

A homosexual relationship between two consenting adults, is not the same as a father or mother; manipulating their child so as to use them as their private sex toy.

To say otherwise is a false equivalency.

 
 
 
brightstarone
Freshman Silent
link   brightstarone    13 years ago

Len, regarding qoute:

"If there is no God then all is permitted."

Yeah right ... and when there is a God alot of things are also permitted like:

... do as I say; not as I do hypocrisy, Un-holy Wars, The suppression of womens rights, Child Rape, Torture and inquisitions, slavery.... etc

 
 
 
brightstarone
Freshman Silent
link   brightstarone    13 years ago

Shub Orinuj, regarding comment:

Yes I know Augustus Cesar, Thomas Jefferson, and so many great men had incest relationships,

I don't agree that they were great men.

They may have had some skills:

Jefferson as writer Ceasar, as a military leaderbut being clever or having paticular skill sets does not make one great, at least when it comes to moral qualities.

Men like those arenarccassitic and driven. They will take any mean opportunistic advantage to exploite their flaws and Thus: satiate their gross appitites, with out care about whom it hurts or the morality of their behaviour.

Accomplished men, maybe; but great?

I don't think so.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

Gotta agree with that Suz.

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   Jonathan P    13 years ago

So we've spiraled into a misandristic screed.

Great.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

This whole thing is creepy. Incest is almost universally a taboo, with the exception of Ancient Egypt , which was done to keep royal families.

Homosexuality occurs in almost everyspeciesof animal on earth. Some animals likehyenas are almost hermaphrodites, while others, like frogs and star fishes can even change their sex as the population needs.

This whole discussion is just gross.

 
 
 
evilone
Professor Guide
link   evilone    13 years ago

Sorry Perrie, it's inbreeding has happened in many cultures including Europe...

From wiki -

Among European monarchies Jean V of Armagnac formed a rare brother-sister relationship. Also other royal houses, such as the Wittelsbachs had marriages among aunts, uncles, nieces and nephews. The British royal family had several marriages as close as the first cousin, but none closer.

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   Jonathan P    13 years ago

Right flameaway,

And by the same token, there will always be women and blacks that will perpetually push the victim card, regardless of the level of advancement.

And we have to listen, and placate, and "reparate".

Forever...

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

Are you endorsing incest?

Perrie may not have been perfectly accurate but she took a stand as did Einsteinian.

 
 
 
evilone
Professor Guide
link   evilone    13 years ago

I guess I shouldn't besurprisedthat you can equate quoting history as an endorsement. That's some pretty twisted logic Len, much like this whole article.

You want me to take a stand? I don't give two shits what consenting adults do in privacy. I don't condone there actions, but it's none of my business.

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   Jonathan P    13 years ago

So, in other words, this is expected in red states, but comes as a great shock in the "enlightened" blue states.

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   Jonathan P    13 years ago

You mean like

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   Jonathan P    13 years ago

sends a bear to rip a crowd of children to shreds for making fun of a prophet's bald head?

That must be N.T.

May I have an O.T. reference, please?

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

Evilgenius,

I stand corrected that it has happened in other royal families, but still, it is not the norm.

As for them being adults, well, it's a slippery slope. When does it become not OK? When the kid is 16, 14, 12? Do children magically become adults when they are 18? Can they be under undoinfluence? Or is this the Humbert, Humbert defense?

But for the most part, I don't believe that the government has a right into our bedrooms. There is just a different dynamic between father, daughter... that takes it out of therealm.

 
 
 
ArkansasHermit
Freshman Silent
link   ArkansasHermit    13 years ago

May I have an O.T. reference, please?

2 Kings, 2 Chapter, 23 & 24th Verse

The Prophet Elisha;

23: And he went up from thence unto Bethel: and as he was going up by the way, there came forth little children out of the city, and mocked him, and said unto him, Go up, thou bald head; go up, thou bald head.
24: And he turned back, and looked on them, and cursed them in the name of the LORD. And there came forth two she bears out of the wood, and tare forty and two children of them.
25: And he went from thence to mount Carmel, and from thence he returned to Samaria.

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   Jonathan P    13 years ago

Well, yeah uh...

Stop being such a misandrist, and pay attentioin

24.gif

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

perrie I would be just as creeped out if it was his stepdaughter, where there is no possibility of genetic impact. It's the relationship itself that makes it strange, that father daughter dynamic.

I totally agree which is why I boycott Woody Allen movies.

That doesn't mean that there should be legal intervention here. She wasn't complaining, he wasn't, they were both consenting adults. Lets just say, I would not choose to associate myself with them, and be done with it.

Look there is a whole lot we don't know about the nature of this relationship. Maybe the sleeping together started when she was an "adult", but there was a time when he was just dear old step dad. to a kid.. this relationship didn't just pop into being... it was years in the making, which means he abused his parental relationship.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

Thanks Suz. I think I need a shower.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

Everyone has their own line and, as the culture war progresses, the lines will be replaced with new ones as has been happening. So those whohave their old lines will either go along, as has been happening with homosexual marriage, or be disappointed.

As for me, I consider the most sensible line that in the Bible wherein adultery, homosexuality, bestiality, incest and child sacrifice (now called abortion) are prohibited.

The only exception I would make is for abortion in cases of rape, incest or where the mother's life is at stake.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

A little learninng is a dangerous thing. Your and Einsteinaian's scornful trashing of the Bible are based on ignorance, hostility and bigotry. It is authentic hate speech.

What you accuse religious people of doing you do in spades.

May God have mercy on your souls.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

Proselytizing is trying to convert someone. Where did I do that?

What I wrote was: "As for me, I consider the most sensible line that in the Bible wherein adultery, homosexuality, bestiality, incest and child sacrifice (now called abortion) are prohibited."

That would be just as true if I had quoted from the National Review.

You could just as well say that American justice proselytizes because if forbids murder, the Sixth Commandment, and theft, the Seventh. More "moral depravity" I suppose.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    13 years ago

This is only my opinion.... The professor is a child abuser you can bet and he has done irreparable damage to his daughter. Don't try and tell me she's of legal age either. This isn't something that starts at 23 and we know it.

I don't care how many other countries this sort of thing is legal. In this country I would prefer it not to be legal.

Talking about something that is not good for the moral of the members, this isn't good for society. Just my opinion and this is something we need to take a close look at. I wonder have so many people lost any sort of moral character at all.

In my opinion there are things you can promote for the good of society and there are things you can promote for the destruction of society and this isn't one of the good things.

I don't want to go to the new improved 21st century if this is what it is all about.

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

Good sourcing but you should quote it in context.

19. And the people of the city said to Elisha, "Behold the city is a good place to live in, as my lord sees, but the water is bad and the land causes people to die

20. And he said, "Take me to a new jug and put salt therein," and they took to him.

21. And he went out to the source of the water and threw salt there; and he said, "So has the Lord said, 'I have cured these waters; there will no longer be death and bereavement from there.' "

22. And the water became cured to this day, according to the word of Elisha that he spoke.

So Elisha saved a city from repetitive death and was belittled by a crowd of scorners for his trouble. According to the exegete, Rashi:

"Go away, baldy: Go away from here, for you have made the place bald for us, for until now we would hire ourselves out to bring sweet water from a distance, and we would earn our livelihood thereby. And when the water became sweet, they lost their livelihood. Thus it is explained in [Talmud]Sotah (46b).

"and saw them: He saw that neither in them nor in their descendants would there be any sap of good deeds."

The Bible contains much more severe punishments than we see today in order to teach the seriousness of willful error. That is why irredeemablescorners today are spared (for the time being).

 
 
 
Len
Freshman Silent
link   seeder  Len    13 years ago

>>When I think of all the murders committed at God's behest, as told by the divinely inspired (some say Holy Ghost-written), "good" book, it makes me glad that I don't actually think that guy exists, or ever did.

God did not "murder" anyone. But everyone dies so you could blame Her for that.

The paradigm is God's telling Abraham that He is about to wipe out Sodom and Gomorrah.

Gen. 18:20. And the Lord said, "Since the cry of [the victims of]Sodom and Gomorrah has become great, and since their sin has become very grave,

21. I will descend now and see, whether according to her cry, which has come to Me, they have done; [I will wreak] destruction [upon them] ---."

22. --- and Abraham was still standing before the Lord.

23. And Abraham approached and said, "Will You even destroy the righteous with the wicked?

24. Perhaps there are fifty righteous men in the midst of the city; will You even destroy and not forgive the place for the sake of the fifty righteous men who are in its midst?

25. Far be it from You to do a thing such as this, to put to death the righteous with the wicked so that the righteous should be like the wicked. Far be it from You! Will the Judge of the entire earth not perform justice?"

26. And the Lord said, "If I find in Sodom fifty righteous men within the city, I will forgive the entire place for their sake."

27. And Abraham answered and said, "Behold now I have commenced to speak to the Lord, although I am dust and ashes.

28. Perhaps the fifty righteous men will be missing five. Will You destroy the entire city because of five?" And He said, "I will not destroy if I find there forty-five."

29. And he continued further to speak to Him, and he said, "Perhaps forty will be found there." And He said, "I will not do it for the sake of the forty."

30. And he said, "Please, let the Lord's wrath not be kindled, and I will speak. Perhaps thirty will be found there." And He said, "I will not do it if I find thirty there."

31. And he said, "Behold now I have desired to speak to the Lord, perhaps twenty will be found there." And He said, "I will not destroy for the sake of the twenty."

32. And he said, "Please, let the Lord's wrath not be kindled, and I will speak yet this time, perhaps ten will be found there." And He said, "I will not destroy for the sake of the ten."

33. And the Lord departed when He finished speaking to Abraham, and Abraham returned to his place.

End quote!

Incidently, the sin the Bible gives as an example of the cities' evil nature is attempted homosexual gang rape.

 
 
 
brightstarone
Freshman Silent
link   brightstarone    13 years ago

Soosalah (Suz), regarding comment:

Everything you list is carried out by men -

Yeah that's obvious Suz.

You know what else men have carried out?

The invention of God Concepts that cater to their self-serving ego-centric needs.

not God.

The porpose of the God construct invented by men; is to make lots of money and give cover to those that hide behind it when they commit their crimes, while at the same time Presumingabsolute moral authority over the entire world, using the God concept that they themselves invented in the first place.

How convenient.

Place the blame where it belongs.

That's exactly what I have done.

Men have dominated this world of ours and have done a piss poor job of it.

Yeah they have done a piss poor job, that was never in dispute.

One of the piss poor things (of many) that they have done, is to invent a God construct that is totally made up and that serves their needs at the expense of everyone else who dosen't have the right genitelia or skin color to belong the their exclusive club.

Then theyuse fear and violence to shove it down everyones throat and dominate the social structure.

Again; how conveniently self-serving.

 
 
 
brightstarone
Freshman Silent
link   brightstarone    13 years ago

Einsteinian Insanity,regarding comment:

moral qualities vary depending on the time that you live.

Moral qualities evolve and in the case of the United Stateseven with its massive diversity itadvances and is still advancingto a higher standard, more so then anywhere else in the world.

Using your standard, nobody can EVER become great, because the standard of what great is changes.

My standard is simple:

Is what one does helpful to oneself and others or is it only helpful to oneself alone.

If one subscribes to the morality of only helping one self alone with out regard tothe moral imperatives that impact ones surrounding society, then it becomes possible to use mean tactics andselfish behaviours to achieve the ignoble goal of:

~ I gotta get mine fuck everybody else ~

That is the morality that drug dealers, merchants of child pornography, corrupt politicians, hypocritical religious leaders that break their own commnadments and the colonial slave owning masters of yesterday or the invading armies of empires built on military murder... etc

In such a civilization there would naturally be fragmentation and divisivness and consequently a weaker unsustainable society.

Like the Roman Empire.

So in my view conquering unoffending people to exploit, rape and en-slave them for one's own pleasure and benefit, or selfishly amassing opulent luxurious monetary wealth through corrupt business and political practices that hurt millions and benefits the tiny few is not great at all.

 
 
 
brightstarone
Freshman Silent
link   brightstarone    13 years ago

Len,regarding comment:

As for me, I consider the most sensible line that in the Bible wherein adultery, homosexuality, bestiality, incest and child sacrifice (now called abortion) are prohibited.

What else in the Bible do you consider sensible?

talking snakes, and people that live hundreds of years and burning bush's and slavery and incest and murder and a woman coming out of a mans rib and ... and ...and ...etc

There are a lot of choices in the bible Len,one can pick and chose what it is that they like:

an eye for an eye or a tooth for a tooth or turn the other cheek and forgive those that tresspass against us ...etc

The first Bible, the Bible that all Christian Bibles are derived from; is the Jewish Bible.

Then over a span of thousands of years, there were revised Bibles written by numerous other authors who got their material from the original Jewish Bible but with their spin on it.

And that is why there are a lot of mixed messages and convoluted story's in the Bible, Len. It is not as simple and cut and dry as you might think.

Of course I don't care because I understand that ancientmen made the whole thing up, to established their limited and primative concept of creation and how we all got here.

But those ancient men who are now dead and who invented this God Concept, told us thatifwe didn't accept and believe theirMALE GODversion about how we all came to be here then:

BAD THINGS WILL HAPPEN TO US.

Funny thing Len, I don't buy into it at all.

 
 
 
evilone
Professor Guide
link   evilone    13 years ago

it is not the norm.

A logicalfallacy.

As for them being adults, well, it's a slippery slope.

Another logical fallacy.

When does it become not OK? When the kid is 16, 14, 12? Do children magically become adults when they are 18?

At one time in the US, and in some cultures still, a woman was of marring age after her first period (usually around 13). We have enough evidence to show that this wasn't a good idea and we changed our definitions of youth and adult to protect people. There still is a debate on what that cut off age should be. We can try a 15 year old as an adult and send them to prison for a lifetime. We can send an 18 year old to war. We can't give a beer to a 20 year old.

Can they be under undoinfluence? Or is this the Humbert, Humbert defense?

If you can prove undo influence, that I would believe, would constitute harm.

But for the most part, I don't believe that the government has a right into our bedrooms. There is just a different dynamic between father, daughter... that takes it out of therealm.

Again unless we can point to a specific harm, the "it's icky" test isn't really a good reason to punish people. I would agree with EI, these are people I wouldn't want to be associated with personally and professionally. Which brings up the point that shunning was, in some old cultures, the worst form of punishment.

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   Aeonpax    13 years ago

Pragmatically, I have nothing against those who consensually want to involve themselves in a sexual relationship with a relative. I see it as more of a social taboo than a harmful act. Nonetheless, it is still illegal in all states, to varying degrees. See: Incest Laws in ALL 50 States

I have seen no researched or statistical data that states a) There is irreparable harm is caused when adult relatives mutually consent to a sexual relation or b) That adults who do enter into this kind of relationship were otherwise involved (consensually or non-consensually) when they were minors.

I do see a difference between incestual sex for the sake of personal intimacy and mutual satisfaction and such sex with the idea or open possibility of producing a child. Also, even if it were legalized, it has been such a long standing human taboo, I just don't see anyone rushing out to take advantage of it. Perhaps Hallmark might market a whole new line of cards.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    13 years ago

I have seen no researched or statistical data that states a) There is irreparable harm is caused when adult relatives mutually consent to a sexual relation or b) That adults who do enter into this kind of relationship were otherwise involved (consensually or non-consensually) when they were minors.

You may be correct. As I said in my first sentence

This is only my opinion.

After all in this case, he is a professor who has been respected by his peers and it is my opinion that a lot of these statistics are derived from the studies made by people like him.

 
 
 
brightstarone
Freshman Silent
link   brightstarone    13 years ago

Einsteinian Insanity, regarding post:

more so then anywhere else in the world.

What's the matter Einstein?

Do you have a reading comprehension problem?

Or are youintentionallytakeing what I saidoutof context?

To think that the US is more moral than say, Canada, Japan, the UK, Spain, France, Italy etc.. is flat out offensive, especially when the US has the highest murder rate in the world, among other not so proud facts.

Yeah... what the HELL dose any of that have to do with what I said?

Here is what I said in context:

"Moral qualities evolve and in the case of the United States even with its massive diversity it advances and is still advancing to a higher standard, more so then anywhere else in the world."

Obviously I did not say that America is more moral then ~ Japan, France ...etc

I was talking from a historical perspective,taking into account the veriable of an evolving diverse populationon a vastContinentandit's Constitutional Democracy.

The United States in its beginnings when George Washington had the chance to become Dictator for life said NO.

Andafter he served asPresident hedid not then make a grab for power either, he went back home to his farm in Virginia.

Traditionally it was expected that when you win a revolution the victorious military leader makes a grab for absolute power like Napoleon did.

That did not happen in America and so it established the foot print of this brand new fledgling Democracy, and it was a big deal at the time because it had never happened before.

America is a country where in the begining there was accepted slavery, and it evolved beyond that through the blood and death of a civil war;that in the end freed an entire race of people,that had beenen-slavedfor hundreds of years.

Even after that; there was segregation and jim crow laws to seperate and discriminate against those former slaves, whowereforcedto fend for themselves in a hostile land,with the Majority White Supremacist Hand turned against them.

America evolved further to right those wrongs and establish civil rights and equal protection under the law.

America was not perfect, never has been never will be.

But it has shown the capacityforchange and become better then before. Today America has evolved to the point where we have an American man of mixedAfrican and Europeonheritageleading the free world. Even with all of the White Supremacist Hatred from the minority of mal-conents throwing vitriol at this new leader of the free world;Americas moral standard still advances slowly and painfully,it is not neat or perfect but it is evolving and becoming better with time and will continue to do so.

Yes, it really is offensive.

The spin that you put on my words was flatly simplistic and cartoon-ishlyout of context from what I meant, and I find you offensive for doing that!

If you find my postings get your panties in a wad, then don't read my postings.

I stand by my words completely and I reject your dis-honest attempt to miss-represent what I said out of context.

That is the morality that drug dealers ...

And most of america has at the current time.

No country on Earth is perfect that is obvious, this is not a:~my country is better then your country debate~Einstien, it is avalid observation that I made in historical context about a good country that is trying to become that more perfect union, and it may never become perfect, but it will as it has over and overagain try to become a:

~more perfect union ~thenit was before.

You need to open your eyes, or maybe take a trip outside of your country.

You need to stop trying to look for reasons to be offended where no offense was intended,so that you can have your little small minded "my country is better then your country"PhonyBullshit Debate.

 
 
 
brightstarone
Freshman Silent
link   brightstarone    13 years ago

Einsteinian Insanity, regarding post:

sorry, the statement:

more so then anywhere else in the world.

is VERY SELF EXPLANATORY!!!

No because you isolated that sentence from the entire text of what I said and so you miss-represented it out of context the first time and after I correctly pointed that out you did it again in your latest post to me and so it confirmed what I suspected about you.

Comment removed for CoC violation .35.gif

The United States was one of the last major countries to ban the practice of slavery (though some might argue that the serfdom that existed in Russia was akin to slavery, so it wasn't the last).

SO what? I wasn't speaking to who was first or last,I was clearly speaking to the point that the United States has demonstrated a capacity to change and improve over time, to TRY and Become that more PERFECT UNION.

What's even more telling is that the other countries that practiced it, didn't need a bloody civil war to ban it.

Yeah what that tells us is that the United States and other countries had different circumstances and variablesand so events played out differently, and that Americans are willing tofight and die for freedom,and thatyour making a false equivalency with your lamepoint.You makestraw-manarguments because you are determined to have a stupid andchildish ~ "my country is better then your country debate"

And I just called you out on it.

You missed a word, 'further to THE right'. Sorry, racism is rampant in the US, the reason why the CRA was even needed was because of it.

Even today, we still have so many people that bitch and complain about the president, pretty much for the sole reason that he is black.

The sweeping civil rights laws were enacted in the mid - 1960's because of inequality; that is not even in dispute, I said so myself in my post to you but of course you ignored it and continued with your dumb we're better then you rant.

Here it is again to remind you Princess:

"Even after that; there was segregation and jim crow laws to seperate and discriminate against those former slaves, who were forced to fend for themselves in a hostile land,with the Majority White Supremacist Hand turned against them."

And sorry, that isn't just a small minority, it isn't a fringe, it's become mainstream on the right. The rational on the right have become the fringe.

My statement still stands you've offered nothing to disprove that the majority of mainstream America is NOT extreem right wing, and the fact that the extreem right wing has taken over the Republican party was never in dispute so you said nothing of substance that proved my points wrong just another of your phony straw-man arguments.

You need to stop trying to look for reasons to be offended

Not offended, more gobsmacked than anything else. It's an example of an inward looking nation that quite honestly has lost track of the message that it tries to project.

Yeah ... a stupid sweeping generalization about an entire Nation of 300 millionplus, based on an incorrect and miss-leading interpretation of what I posted so that you can postmore predictable and boring my country is better then your's rehtoric.28.gif

The US isn't about equality, never really has been.

Oh really professor, so I guess that's it then. If a brilliant Genius like you decidedAmerica is not and never was about equality then that must be the way it is then.77.gif

-----<{{[[((( NOT!!!! )))]]}}>>>------68.gif

George Bush really was right when he said 'the constitution is just a piece of paper', because quite frankly, the way it's treated, it is.

Yeah the Constitution was written on a piece of paper but guess what Genius , mostAmericans understand what the Constitution is and appreciated it for what it is : the soul of American Democracy.

But to George Buffoon Bush and a Genius Einstien like you it's all together something else entirely, a piece of paper.

Comment removed for CoC violation

You might want to take a listen to the opening rant on 'The Newsroom', because that little tidbit has more truth in it than anyone can imagine.

No thanks, your meanderingchildish rants are enough for me.107.gif

Now go away Princess and have a nice cup of TEA & COOKIES.

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   Aeonpax    13 years ago

After all in this case, he is a professor who has been respected by his peers and it is my opinion that a lot of these statistics are derived from the studies made by people like him

Trusim.

 
 
 
brightstarone
Freshman Silent
link   brightstarone    13 years ago

Einsteinian Insanity, regarding post:

yeah yeah buttercup,

Comment removed for CoC violation

keep on thinking that the US is the greatest country in the world, you are definitely deluding yourself there.

There you go again putting words in my mouth that I never said or meant. Showing once again that you are the dis-honest Comment removed for CoC violation
that I thought you were.

(see abouve sentence inBOLD)

The country has NEVER practiced the principles that it preaches, nor does it seem that it ever will, or that it even wants to.

And there you go again with the dumb my country is better then your country rehtoric.

It was off topic and stupid the first time you said it and guess what ... it is still off topic and stupid the second time.

I guess it's the best you can do huh missy.

Now go away if you can Comment removed for CoC violation
.

 
 
 
brightstarone
Freshman Silent
link   brightstarone    13 years ago

iarnuocon, responding w/ question:

I was curious about something, I am not as familiar with the set up here on newstalkers and I was wondering if you could help satisfy my curiosity.

Are you a Moderator on this website? Is that why you interceded in theexchanges between Einstien and myself?

I was wondering where your coming from with your postings regarding the back and forth between Einstien and me.

 
 
 
brightstarone
Freshman Silent
link   brightstarone    13 years ago

Einsteinian Insanity, regarding reply:

Sounds like you can dish it out, but you can't take it.

Typical.

Putting things out of context again.

Sounds like your full of shit as usual.

Again with the oddness, you like to boast how your country is so great,

I know that my country is not perfect and I never said that it was, and I have my own criticisms about my country's flaws and I see plenty of room for improvement.

But that is true for any country on Earth, that isunless you knowof acountry where everything is always correct and perfect. If so then please do share that information.

But as far as how I feel about my country, well PRINCESS .

I love my country and I don't apologize to you or anyone else for that, and if my love of country offends you so much then you know what you can do with yourself ... right Princess?

Hint: just change one letter.

You can figure it out can't you Genius ? ------>D UCK Yourself .

but you can't take it when the tables are turned.

Making phony straw-man arguments and spinning what I said is not the same as turning the tables, it's you being a phony Troll.

I can take criticisms and legitimate points.

What I can't take is having my words taken out of context and distorted with phony straw-man arguments and non-sequiturs, that is dishonorable Troll behaviour and I will always call it out when I see it.

Just like I did with you Missy .

Again you have miss-represented what I said and meant, because your points are weak and so you have to ignore my counter points and distort out of context my argument to make yours seem correct by comparison.

A simple reading of the exchanges between us easily shows this.

(and note, I have not stated any single country, it's you that did).

Another pointless non-sequitur, I'm blinded by your brilliance.

I only need to go back to this comment to prove the point:

You have no point except to act like a dis-honorable Troll,instead of an honest debater.

more so then anywhere else in the world.

Yet another pointless non-sequitur that says nothing of value.

How typical of you.

Now read carefully Genius.

It should be obvious Comment removed for CoC violation that I don't like you because of the way thatyou twisted my meanings and distorted what I said. You areonly interested in having an extended back and forth with me aboutcomparing country's so that you can use your America suck's rehtoric.

There is nothing productive that will happen between us because I detest you, I tell you this plainly and with complete honesty, from what I've read in your postings to me, it is obvious Comment removed for CoC violation I have absolutely no respect for you.

We cannot play nice. So further postings between uswill bepointless and unproductive.

Please feel free to ignore me, I will not mind one bit. If you can't help yourself and must post to me, then be advised that any more phony dis-honorable debate tactics that you use will be noted and I will call you out on it.

Now go away Comment removed for CoC violation .Tongue.gif

It is my suggestion that you both keep a safe distance from each other from this point on. No good can come from any exchanges you two have. [ph]

 
 
 
retired military ex Republican
Freshman Silent
link   retired military ex Republican    13 years ago

Ouch I didn't do it. I've tried to be fair and treat everyone equally until they hurt someone else or myself. But yes MEN DID IT.Only because women wern't in charge like say Bauchman or Palin. Just for instance.

 
 

Who is online






111 visitors