╌>

A Question of Free Speech

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  perrie-halpern  •  13 years ago  •  199 comments

A Question of Free Speech

We Americans take our first Amendment rights for granted, until something ugly happens; A Koran burning in Florida or Neo Nazis marching in Skokie. We debate what defines "Hate Speech" and what is just freedom of speech. But what most people really take for granted, is that our freedom of speech guaranteed to us. That is something that no other nation has.

This weekend Giorgos Katidis, a 20-year-old Greek soccer player celebrated a game-winning goal by giving a Nazi salute to fans in Athens. His punishment was that he has been banned for life from playing professional football. He initially claimed that he was not saluting but pointing at a friend in the stands, said later that he had no idea what the gesture meant. He issued a statement after the ban and called his salute totally unacceptable, adding, I feel terrible for those I upset with the stupidity of my act. Giorgos Katidis, a midfielder for AEK Athens, celebrated a goal on Saturday with a Nazi salute. Now judging from his general posture I personally find it hard to believe that he didn't know what he what he was doing, or that he's "not fascist or neo-Nazi or racist" given that the game was also playedas Greece marked the 70th anniversaryof the deportation of thousands of Greek Jews to Nazi death camps. Given the information that has come forth, I do believe he knew exactly what he was doing.

But that is a moot point for this discussion.

The point is, he was banned for life for his freedom of speech, no matter how offensive it is. Greece doesn't guaranteefreedom of speech. In fact, like most other European, not only is freedom of speech notguaranteed, they have strict "Hate Speech Laws" that make such acts an actual crime. Most of these countries, are dealing with a long history of hate and the fall out of WWII. But even while they don't allow hate speech, many of these countries have blossomingfascist or neo-Nazi movements, which is a disturbing trend. So issuppressionof speech the way to handle such situations? Maybe it only serves to push these people into a position where they can claim that they are being discriminated.. and gaining public sympathy? One would thing that speaking out against such behavior would be enough. On the other hand, their culture and history has shown that this kind of behavior only grows, when not countered with such laws. In this case of our football player, Giorgos Katidis, his team mates, either sided with him, or tried tosuppresshis action, pushing his arm down in order for him not to get into trouble. None of them spoke out against his actions.

But here in the US, we are safe from suchinfringement. Again, one could argue that our very unique history makes our freedom of speech, part of our culture. The Koran burning lead to counter protests. In Skokie, the Neo Nazis marched and werecounteredby crowds that protested them the whole length of the march. Maybe we are just unique as a people and a nation, with our history making such freedoms work. It might be that E pluribus unum, is the very thing that makes us a more tolerant society.

But then again.... we are not Europeans. Maybe they know the company they keep.

http://thelede.blogs.nytimes.com/2013/03/18/greek-soccer-player-banned-for-nazi-salute/


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   Aeonpax    13 years ago

Laws to suppress tend to strengthen what they would prohibit.

 
 
 
Shub Orinuj
Freshman Silent
link   Shub Orinuj    13 years ago

America is lucky for the 1st amendment. We could be like Canada or Europe countries that suppress it.

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   Jonathan P    13 years ago

Hate speech is troublesome in all Western democracies. The problem lies in where the line is drawn.

When is zero tolerance applicable?

When must we examine context?

When is someone a threat, as opposed to just being boorish?

Is it like porn? "I'll know it when I see it"?

Ya got me. But history has proven that, left unchecked, the problem gets bigger.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

I tend to agree with you Aeon, but Hitler was given a lot of free speech... it didn't end well. Maybe there is somethingfundamentallydifferent in our cultures?

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

Well, I am not sure if the tattoo culture is so much aboutnarcissismas it is about expressing one self through art.... but that aside...

I think America has it pretty right about free speech.

I do too, but is it for every culture? Is it uniquelyAmerican?

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

America is lucky for the 1st amendment. We could be like Canada or Europe countries that suppress it.

Yes we are. But maybe it's anintegralpart of who we are as a people? And Canada and Europe don'tsuppressit. They just have more restrictions on it. It could be based on their past (Europe that is)

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

LOL Great clip EI!

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

Fundamental Freedoms

Marginal note:Fundamental freedoms

2.Everyone has the following fundamental freedoms:

  • (a)freedom of conscience and religion;

  • (b)freedom of thought, belief, opinion and expression, including freedom of the press and other media of communication;

  • (c)freedom of peaceful assembly; and

  • (d)freedom of association.

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   Jonathan P    13 years ago

madbrnnr,

That's a good example of how things SHOULD work. Slavery and racism against the black community are taboo in America. They were, and to some degree, remain sore points in our nation's consciousness.

Unfortunately, there are other topics where victims around the world are encouraged to "chill out", and stop being so sensitive. Anti-Semitism and hate crimes against Jews has reached the highest levels since before WWII. And yet, we are encouraged to "examine context", and "not be so sensitive".

You're right. It's not so simple. Not when governments refuse to prosecute hate crimes due to their obvious biases.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

In practice, Canada today actually has MORE freedom than the US does, in most areas.

Please explain.

It's just in a few where some americans might take offence, like the un-infringed right to bear arms. Most of the guns that you can buy in the US you can buy in Canada. But that right does have significant limitations in Canada compared to the US, but other rights have a higher precedence in Canada.

But that is our Second Amendment... which isn't what we are covering here. The very last thing I want is another gun article... if you catch my drift.

BTW I just infringed on your freedom of speech ;-)

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

Jonathan P, you just hit got the crux of the discussion. And it is problemsome. I think that there are a few things we can define.

When is someone a threat, as opposed to just being boorish?

A threat means that you somehow feel endangered. In the case given above, that would not be the case.

When must we examine context?

Sometimes there is no context there. In this case, given the date, there was.

Is it like porn? "I'll know it when I see it"?

Yeah, I can agree with that.

 
 
 
LoneRanger01
Freshman Silent
link   LoneRanger01    13 years ago

Free speech, or freedom of speech in America is just like any other of our rights. It comes with limits but more importantly it must come with responsibility.

as for "hate speech" well thats seems to have a double standard in my opnion. Its hate speech if a white man uses the N word yet its acceptable for blacks to use it. Its considered hate speech for a straight person to use derogatory words like queer or faggot to describe gays yet even here on NT there is a group called "queer folks"....if that isnt a double standard i dont know what is.....the old saying Practice what we preach comes to mind...if a person or goroup of people are gong to cryabout thenames they are called or labled with then they themselves shouldn't use the words or names to describe themselves either.

And just so you know,..in the past I have fought for our rights and will always defend EVERYONEs right and freedoms,..just please don't pee down my leg and tell me its raining.

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    13 years ago

This guy was free to do what he wanted to do, just as the soccer federation is free to ban him for life for probable personal misconduct that he signed an agreement to in order to allow him to play.

Play this another way. Say someone in the NFL did the exact same thing. I can't show you line and paragraph in the NFL players union contract, or a team contract, but as you can imagine, there are rules of conduct that will fall hard on someone that violates them.

Bottom line, if you sign on the dotted line, you can limit some of your rights as a condition of employment. A person that takes the oath of enlistment agrees to laws outlined in the UCMJ, with in some instances are more restrictive than those for civilians. Same thing is true of confidentiality agreements.

 
 
 
V J Keller (schnoz4news)
Freshman Silent
link   V J Keller (schnoz4news)    13 years ago

More than likely, as with most athletes, he signed a contract with PRIVATE owners that stipulates conduct. The league itself may have a code of conduct.

Here in the U.S he could be banned for conduct that violates a contract. Freedom of speech means he couldn't be charged with a crime. He would be free to violate his contract.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

IE,

I tend to agree with you. History always plays out in how a people express themselves. I guess the issue is, despite all their hate speech laws, Europe still does have a very activefascistmovements. Do they know themselves better, and therefore inhibit free speech to a level that wouldn't be accepted in the US since they know their past, or are they making it worse by not having a national dialog?

 
 
 
V J Keller (schnoz4news)
Freshman Silent
link   V J Keller (schnoz4news)    13 years ago

LoneRanger, I understand what your saying. But just because something is called "hate speech" does not make it illegal. It can have consequences in the private relm but is not a crime punishable by law.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

It is true that this case is a bit different because it also has to do with team terms and conditions. The same could not be said about Geert Wilder, who was not allowed into England for his views on Muslims.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    13 years ago

Looking at his picture, I actually believe him when he says he had no idea he was doing something offensive. He just doesn't look all that bright. I should think the shame of being outed for his stupidity would have been punishment enough. Pretty sure it won't happen again.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

Then it is very selective. Explain Geert Wilder not being allowed into the UK because of his views on Muslims?

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

UN rankings has canada about ten spots higher than the US when it comes to overall freedoms, which includes economic freedom, freedom of speech, etc...

I'm not sure how ones ranks freedoms to that extent, especially the UN.

There are SO many restrictions on the freedoms of americans that go way beyond what is in the constitution. A lot of that is related to the Cold War where so many laws which were specific to it, but now that the cold war is over, those restrictions are still present, in fact they are getting more strict as time goes on.

There I agree. But I think that most of the Cold War ones are long forgotten. It laws like the Patriot Act that I find more intrusive.

Hell, the whole situation during the McCarthy years, and the still on the books laws banning the communist party

I would have to debate that with you:

Which kind of nullifies the rest of that.

My intent there wasn't to create another gun article, which I try to avoid myself, but just to state that the rights we have don't exist in a vacuum, they have to coexist with other rights, and where one right would tend to infringe on another right, a decision has to be made where one right ends and the other begins.

I totally agree.

The constitution isn't about what you can do. It's your board, not mine, but you aren't the government. Therefore you have not done any such thing.

No. It's my article..the scope of which any author can determine. The board belongs to the group. I make this constant reminder, so that people understand that I am not the law. I only represent the CoC that the group decided upon.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Even under the Constitution, not all speech is protected; terroristic threats, libel, slander and perjury are potentially punishable.

But considered ONLY philosophically, assuming the gesture was to promote Nazi dogma, does that warrant a lifetime ban from professional soccer? In-and-of-itself I'd say "no."

But, if the gesture, under Greek law is deemed "hate speech," then possibly, the player could be banned or suspended for committing a crime or misdemeanor provided professional soccer has stipulated that in it's by-laws, personal service or collective bargaining agreement. Kind of begs the question, however.

Here's a better solution; Greek media should conduct a poll the question to be directed at the Greek public in general with a separate poll for soccer fans. The poll question

If Player so-and-so is not banned by professional soccer, will you boycott future games and the game's commercial sponsors?"

In that way, the public and the fans are tried in the "court of world public opinion."

It's almost poetic that way.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

OK, VJ, but lets say that it had nothing to do with the team contract. Actually, upon doing some research, Greece is one of the few European Countries without Hate Speech laws.Ironically it seems that Greece has beensuppressingfreedom of speech as of late:

 
 
 
Shub Orinuj
Freshman Silent
link   Shub Orinuj    13 years ago
my bad einsteinian . Quickly typed it up. Meant to say I heard a lot of attacks in Canada compared to U.S.freedom of speech.
 
 
 
V J Keller (schnoz4news)
Freshman Silent
link   V J Keller (schnoz4news)    13 years ago

Was he arrested and charged with a crime by Greek authorties? No. He was banned by a private business. I don't see how the two can be compared. Greece didn't do anything to him.

I have no idea if his contract had anything to do with it. If it didn't, perhaps we will see this in the Greek courts... An entirely different issue.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

There are other issues in europe thought that serve to push the extreme right though, and a huge part of that is the massive influx of immigrants from countries like Turkey. It's more Xenophobia than it is 'radical right wing philosophy'. They don't like the 'dirty muslim turks' so we have to support a party that expresses that same opinion.

To a certain degree I agree with you. But each of these fascist movements seem to take into them a degree of other hate, along with xenophobia. Take the BNP (British National Party). There xenophobia is easily fed by what immigrants get from the government for free. Free food, free homes, free transport, all on the working joes back. And these immigrants are not only Muslim, but African, Slavic and Middle eastern. Yet here is Nick Giffin at his best:

It's similar to what is happening in the US regarding the undocumented persons from mexico, except without the religious component, which complicates matters. What do you think would be happening in the US if mexicans were muslim rather than catholic. That's what is going on in europe.

I'm going to disagree. Every immigrant group that has come to these shores (or boarders in the case with Mexicans) has had a level ofdiscrimination. And according to the FBI stats on hate crime Muslims face less in the way of hate crime than Jews. So I really don't see any type ofcomparisonto Europe.

  • Anti- Black 2,876
  • Sexual Orientation 1,297
  • Anti-Jewish 1,013
  • Anti-Hispanic 561
  • Anti-Islamic 130

It's a very complicated issue that goes far beyond the simple political bend.

Oh for sure! But that is why I just started on Freedom of speech.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

LR,

Free speech, or freedom of speech in America is just like any other of our rights. It comes with limits but more importantly it must come with responsibility.

I totally agree!

I'm inclined to agree with you that if you don't want a term used about your ethnicity, don't use it yourself. I have always found that odd. But it is a practice that is as old as the hills. I have known many Poles who tell Polish jokes or bust on one another and call each other a dumb Pollock. BTW I can say that... since I am part Pole.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

VJ and LR,

The only thing that constitutes real hate speech is if you are encouraging violent acts or destructive and threatening acts to private property. Other than that you can scream you hate this or that, and it's not hate speech.

 
 
 
Pedro
Professor Quiet
link   Pedro    13 years ago

I havent read through all the posts yet, but as a rule, freedom of speech doesnt apply to athletes. There are almost always clauses in their contracts that detail press obligations, including in many cases what to say and how to say it. Players get fined and or banned every year for various infractions. Remember John Rocker, for instance? Or Tim Hardaway?

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

There is a lot of animosity towards mexicans in the United States right now. Does it border on hate crimes, probably not, but the sentiment only needs a nudge to push it in that direction. What has happened in many countries of europe is that the nudge has happened

Again I am going to disagree. Large populations of new immigrants have always gotten this warm welcome in the US. All you have to do is look into the history of the Irish, Italians or Jews, so well documented they even made a movie about it, "Gangs of New York" We just don't seem to get nudge quite like the Europeans do.

The radical right has been, and this is very unfortunate, VERY successful at recruiting those that feel disenfranchised, and that is unfortunate.

It's more like the middle class in those countries are being killed by high taxes which then is being used to subsidize these immigrants. That isn't what is going on here to the extent that it's going on there.

Now, my comment about muslims and mexicans was to point out the numbers aspect. Say there are 30 million illegal aliens in the US, that were 'muslim mexicans', so not only do you have the 30 million illegals, but they are muslim. Those FBI figures more than likely won't be the same. That number would go up.

I'm not sure. The Muslim population here is about the same as the Jewish one, yet here is a tested FBI link that shows an oddity:

Of the 1,480 victims of an anti-religious hate crime:

  • 63.2 percent were victims of an offenders anti-Jewish bias.
  • 12.5 percent were victims of an anti-Islamic bias.
  • 5.7 percent were victims of an anti-Catholic bias.
  • 4.4 percent were victims of a bias against groups of individuals of varying religions (anti-multiple religions, group).
  • 3.4 percent were victims of an anti-Protestant bias.
  • 0.3 percent were victims of an anti-Atheist/Agnostic bias.
  • 10.5 percent were victims of a bias against other religions (anti-other religion).

How does one explain that?

And as for our Mexians... well Blacks still have it worse:

Racial bias

Among the single-bias hate crime incidents in 2011, there were 3,645 victims of racially motivated hate crime.

  • 71.9 percent were victims of an offenders anti-black bias.
  • 16.3 percent were victims of an anti-white bias.
  • 5.2 percent were victims of a bias against a group of individuals in which more than one race was represented (anti-multiple races, group).
  • 4.8 percent were victims of an anti-Asian/Pacific Islander bias.
  • 1.9 percent were victims of an anti-American Indian/Alaskan Native bias.(Based on Table 1 .)

So I am not seeing any great fear of Muslims or Latinos. Just the twotraditionallyhated groups... blacks and Jews.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

Yes and probably.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

Well, I happen to agree with that in the US. I am not so sure in Europe wherefascismis thequickestgrowing political movement.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

That's more than a poor gesture. If he was just pointing to a friend, then he wouldn't have all of his fingers out,

But the ban isn't a law, it's a sports federation clause. Probably too severe, but we don't run the league (whether it be the greek league or the european one).

Agreed and Yes.

 
 
 
AmericanDreamsShattered
Freshman Silent
link   AmericanDreamsShattered    13 years ago

I remember when the neo-nazi's came to my high school, it was for a class called American
Problems, anyway I was in that class along with my very long hair and i was instantlysingled out by the "neo-nazi" twits that i was an American problem. To which i replied that they were going to have a lovely time in Skokie the following week and that they were lucky that they lived in America. Freedom of speech protected them as it protects me, that being said they were very lucky that they did'nt hang around until the end of the day.

 
 
 
V J Keller (schnoz4news)
Freshman Silent
link   V J Keller (schnoz4news)    13 years ago

Responsibility... That's the key word! Citizenship in our free society is hard work.

As to groups of people using derogatory terms themselves that they scorn others for using. It's a classic defense mechanism. By using the term and even more, embracing the term. One attempts to dis-arm their haters.

In some measure I would agree that this type of defense becomes a moot point when younger generations forget why they use the terms. That's where the whole responsibilty aspect comes into play. Sadly, it's lost on a large number of people from a vast array of backgrounds.

 
 
 
Aeonpax
Freshman Silent
link   Aeonpax    13 years ago

That was my enlightened opinion. My real opinion on this incident is that where it may seem like a Freedom of Speech issue, I see it as stupid people doing stupid things to get their 15 minutes of fame on TV....and the media obliges him.

 
 
 
Jonathan P
Sophomore Silent
link   Jonathan P    13 years ago

Actually, it means "raise your hand if you're tired of the Jews getting all the good jobs, even if you didn't do your homework in school, and they did".

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    13 years ago

I wonder what his tattoos say?

I'm not excusing either his "salute", nor the "ban"-- but Greece is likely very touchy when it comes to the Nazis, anyway. Here is a brief article on Wikipedia about the Nazi occupation of Greece, in which 300,000 civilians died of starvation, and tens of thousands more died via reprisals, collaboration, etc.

The Greek Jewish people were murdered right along with everyone else... and the country suffered for years. I can't blame them if they don't want a hero socker player giving a Nazi salute, even if he was pointing to a friend in the crowd, (did it look to you like he was pointing at someone? Didn't to me...)

Anyway, it is up to Greece to decide what to do, as in none of our business. I don't blame the European soccer federation, either. They have had a lot more trouble with Nazis than we have... Although we've had enough, now that you think about it.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

Here let me help you:

Heben Sie Ihre Hand, wenn Sie der Juden immer alle gute Jobs sind mde, auch wenn Sie nicht machen Sie Ihre Hausaufgaben in der Schule, und sie taten

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

In some measure I would agree that this type of defense becomes a moot point when younger generations forget why they use the terms. That's where the whole responsibilty aspect comes into play. Sadly, it's lost on a large number of people from a vast array of backgrounds.

I'm not sure I am buying that. I have twin 18 year olds who could cite the English linage. If what you say is true, then we are living in dangerous times.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

LMAO!

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

Gene,

I think we have more freedom of speech than in many other countries. I think also that if we are notvigil, we could loose them to our government. They are there, but they are also ours to protect!

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

True Peter, and it wasn't something that I had considered when I wrote the article. But it has made for an interesting springboard to a discussion. And apparently, Greece is having major problems regarding freedom of speech regarding their press. So all in all, kind of applicable even with my error.

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    13 years ago

Well, most people wouldn't mind a tattoo that said, Get Rich, for sure...

But being banned from the national team, isn't that pretty much a given that he can't play for Greece? Like at the Olympics?

I don't know, I'm asking... Smile.gif

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

Well I know that it has limitations like slander and libel and that you can't endanger the public welfare, but I don't think we have gotten to that point, yet, Charles.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

Actually Bob, I might see Robert's point here. We don't actually get rid of the hate. We just push it underground where it grows andfesters. And our freedoms are only tested when we are affronted by something. Remember "Piss Jesus" as art? Was it really art, or justprovocative? And it was the ACLU who fought for the right of the Neo-Nazis to march in Skokie. Their reasoning was clear. Our freedom of speech is only tested when someone finds it offensive. I don't like the Westboro Baptist Church or what they do, but they have the right to do it.

As for European style hate speech laws, well they haven't done wonders in England. Grew up between here and there, and I have to say, that the only thing that has happened is a fake PC.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

I doubt that many Americans would want to have a guy who makes Nazi salutes in public to represent the nation in the Olympic Games...

This is true Bob.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

Anyway, it is up to Greece to decide what to do, as in none of our business. I don't blame the European soccer federation, either. They have had a lot more trouble with Nazis than we have... Although we've had enough, now that you think about it.

For sure Dowser.. the main issue being that Greece is having a huge increase infascism. Had economic times bring out the worse in people.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

I'm not sure, Dowser. But today interesting enough... The FDNY Commissioner's sonreignedhis position, because of anti black and antisemtic tweets.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

Wow ADS. So you actually lived through that mess.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

Bob,

Did you read my post? I think not. When we chip away at our freedom of speech we chip away at the Constitution. So no I am not parroting.. I'm not even sure who you think that I am parroting either.

Piss Jesus and The LastTemptationof Christ offended people. Where do you draw the line? And there is the rub.

And BTW saying that I am parroting, is kind of saying that I can't think for myself, which at this point, Bob, I am pretty sure you know that I can even if we disagree.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    13 years ago

I was waiting for something on Westboro Baptist Church as I thoroughly have enjoyed this discussion. I absolutely despise this group and their protest. My grand daddy would have taken his shotgun out there they would have scattered like ants and I would like to do the same thing, but "Freedom of Speech" doesn't allow us to do such things and even as much as I despise these folks, I'm glad it doesn't and happy I or anyone else would arrested for doing such a thing as what my grand daddy would have done.

"Freedom of Speech" is not worth a dime if when you say something and are shut up. There are places where "Freedom of Speech" isn't allowed such as the "Fire" in the theatre example or saying things that will cause people harm.

I don't even know if I totally agree with "Hate Speech". No, I don't like it, but when you start dictating what people can say there's always the possibility you lose a little of your "Freedom of Speech" each time until it has accumulated into a meaningful reduction of what you can and can not say.

I believe as a society we must promote ideas that bring us together instead of tearing us apart. Often when "Freedom of Speech" is enacted some people become more resentful and it divides us to a point where some say to hell with "Freedom of Speech" and some say screw your "Freedom of Speech".

I'm so thankful I was born in this country and have the rights I presently have. As quite a few of us know, we have experience lack of "Freedom of Speech" recently and I can tell you from a personal perspective, it didn't work for me.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    13 years ago

One more thing.... I suggest everyone expressly goes out and tries to make friends with someone from a different ethnicity and learn a little more about that person and his/her beliefs.

I think, if you just be friendly and accept people as just another human being initially, you will find that most people are just that and they react according to the way you treat them.

You'll find they are not so much different than you are.

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    13 years ago

I'd be FURIOUS.

It was ill-advised, at best.

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    13 years ago

That's not Nazi-- I'd say that was more of a "Black Power" thing.

Sorry, but to me, that's a HUGE difference. Hitler murdered millions of his own countrymen-- Not these guys. Smile.gif

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    13 years ago

Fire Department?

Well, he should have been fired, but he resigned, so that's good. There is no place for this in today's society-- it keeps rising up out of the sewers like a bad gas... Frown.gif

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    13 years ago

Which is exactly why the Germans followed Hitler... He gave them a sense of pride and nationality-- and helped their economic conditions. Then, it got to be dangerous to take a stand against him-- one would either be murdered in one's bed, or fired, or collected by the Gestapo.

I don't blame Greece at all... Plus, their laws are different. We may not like that his 'free speech' was violated, but it is their country. Smile.gif

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    13 years ago

Bob....your analogy doesn't even relate to what I have said. Would you go out on the street and start telling everyone who came by the Holocaust never existed? What would happen to you? I don't know. That's why I'm asking.

I don't care what your "Freedom of Speech" entails. As far as I'm concerned you can have all the anti-hate-speech laws you want. I have nothing against a person minding his own garden.

As for me.....I'll mind my own if you please.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    13 years ago

Alright!

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago
Of course I read your post -- I cited it several times.

Yet, you said you were raised with the ACLU in your life, but avoided the discussion of them defending Nazis marching in Skokie. Why do you think they did that? It's because of thejustificationof:

When we chip away at our freedom of speech we chip away at the Constitution.

So... I ask the same question I did of Mike: Is it then OK to shout "Fire!" in a crowded theater? If not, what's the difference? To me, both cases present at least a danger of harm. Why is it OK to ban one, but not the other?

It is not OK to yell fire in a theater. It is a danger to the public welfare and that is why it's not allowed.

Allof the rights recognized by American law have limitations. The subject here is not really "should there be limits?", but rather "where should the limits be placed?".

Yes it is about where it should be placed and where it should be placed is where you maximize freedom.

I see absolutely no reason to protect hate-speech like that of the Westboro Baptist Church.

Why? Because it'soffensive? They are not telling anyone to kill anybody. That is hate speech. And what someone finds offensive whether most people think so, or just a smaller group does, shouldn't dictate what affects our Constitution. Piss Jesus is offensive to Catholics. When I went to see the LastTemptationof Christ, protesters were crying. But none of these acts, be it the Westboro Church or Piss Jesus, incite people to hurt another person or people. That is hate speech.

I didn't answer your question about "Piss Jesus" because it is not pertinent: that wouldn't meet the criteria for "hate speech" since there is no incitement against a target group. Hate-speech laws are carefully crafted to avoid the slippery slope...

And the Westboro Baptist church has never said to go out and kill anyone. What they have said is that very sad events are a direct punishment from god. How is that hate speech? That is their opinion.

... saying that I am parroting, is kind of saying that I can't think for myself...

Not exactly... but kinda. I of course know youcanthink... but at the same time... That doesn't necessarily mean that youhavethought.

Believe me, I think about ethics all the time. Many times I don't have an hard opinion. I carefully craft an article to have a discussion to bring in different POVs so that we may grow form different POVs.

I do indeed believe that Americans often do not reallythinkabout rights. They presume that their way is the right way and the only way thinkable. Re-read your first post: you did not give any explanation forwhyWestboro must be protected. You didn't present any "thinking". You presented a slogan. That's kinda "parrot", isn't it?

No. It just wasn't required at that point in the discussion. And I don't find Americans any different than most people in that once they grow use to something, they tend not to think about it.

Even now, your "chipping away at the Constitution" is a pretty shallow argument. Do you really think that forbidding the $hit that Westboro did would somehow do damage to the Constitution? Really? How?

Once again, the Church isn't saying that anyone should die or be killed but that god is punishing the US for our stance on gay marriage. Are they not allowed theiropinion no matter how offensive I personally find it?

Do you not think that the world would be a better place if such $hit didn't happen? So whyprotectit??

Sure I find it offensive. I also find half of what I read on FB offensive? Should I ban that too? The basic rule has always been, your rights end when it steps on my toes. They are offensive for sure, but in no real way are they stepping on anyone else's toes.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    13 years ago
I do not know what events you are referring to. Could you be more explicit, please?

One the Newsvine, I never cursed. I never called anyone names. I only expressed my opinions. My opinions differed than the majority of the people on the vine and some even put me on ignore and I was banned for nothing other than expressing my beliefs by speaking out about them, nothing more.

I became resentful the more times I saw the freedom of others to have that right as well. By the time I was banned, all they wanted to do to me was shut me up and they did.

I am glad to be here and have the ability to express myself even though many will disagree with me. Even I, as you may not be aware of, don't always agree with what I have said, but it is "Freedom of Speech" I realize I value more than anything.

I still have a handful of friends over there and every now and then I check out what is going on. It seems the biggest complaint I see is the missing "ignore" button.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    13 years ago

Canada does NOT suppress free speech except for hate speech which is meant to cause harm. Personally, I see nothing wrong with that.

  • Canadian Criminal Code

    • S ection 318 - Every one who advocates or promotes genocide is guilty of an indictable offence and liable to imprisonment for a term not exceeding five years.
    • Section 319 - Every one who, by communicating statements in any public place, incites hatred against any identifiable group where such incitement is likely to lead to a breach of the peace is guilty of ........

    • Section 320 - A judge who is satisfied by information on oath that there are reasonable grounds for believing that any publication, copies of which are kept for sale or distribution in premises within the jurisdiction of the court, is hate propaganda shall issue a warrant under his hand authorizing seizure of the copies.

    A person whose intention is to break those laws might be considered a model citizen in the USA, but not in Canada, and I'm quite satisfied to live with the limitation.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

Bob,

I know you didn't mean to uspet me with your comment, but this is something that I have been trying to explain for the longest time.

Yes I pay the bills at NT, but the concept of the group, has always been that the members are the group. There is not a rule or policy that the group didn't have full input in. My title was carefully chosen. I am not the group owner, but it's creator. I am not the boss, but the Resident Adviser. This is an important difference. My job here is to make sure that every members needs are met, mediate problems, moderate and community adviser. That was the whole point of NT right from the get go, and why Dana and I went our ownseparateways. I am no better than any other member here. I have been called out by other mods, if Imisinterpretthe CoC. If I changed my mind tomorrow about how this site functioned other than the way it does now, I would be a sell out, anunethicalhypocrite.

I hope that clears up this very off topic comment. I just felt that it had to be said.

 
 
 
bitemore Gfotwo
Professor Silent
link   bitemore Gfotwo    13 years ago

Glancing at some of the comments, I think everyone is pretty much on the same page regarding this issue. My own attitude is simple: let people say whatever they want, whenever they want, to whomever they want. Those who hear what is being said are free to form opinions of the speaker based on what he said. Those opinions may be good or bad, but they spring quite naturally from the original speech. Under no circumstances do I think freedom of speech or expression should be legislated against, because, frankly, the best way to know someone's mind is to hear him SAY, aloud, what he thinks. The best way to know your enemy is to hear him say he hates you... this gives YOU the upper hand. The ones who are sneaky are the ones who are most dangerous.

As for the football player and his "Heil Hitler" salute, well... the league has every right to ban him. His friends will likely stick with him and he has learned a sad lesson. Most of all, he has revealed something about himself that the rest of the world is better off knowing, regardless of what it cost him. And maybe he will learn why people resent his behavior and will then make some serious amends.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

We enjoy the "freedom of speech" that we have on this site, not because of any Bill of Rights, but because Perrie Halpern decided that it would be so.

Well, being that this is a private it doesn't fall under "freedom of speech" protection. That would be correct. And it is an important distinction.

And that is why we are all in awe of you: because we are all deeply confident that Perrie will never change the way the site runs because Perrie is truly bound by ethics. That's pretty amazing!

I am and thanks!Grin.gif

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

Under no circumstances do I think freedom of speech or expression should be legislated against, because, frankly, the best way to know someone's mind is to hear him SAY, aloud, what he thinks. The best way to know your enemy is to hear him say he hates you... this gives YOU the upper hand. The ones who are sneaky are the ones who are most dangerous.

Keep your friends closer and your enemies closer. But I agree.

When I started teaching, I had a mentor teacher, Mrs. Bosley. She was a tallstatuesque black woman that had a commanding presence in a room. Over time, I grew to admire her, befriend her and love her. She shared with me many stories. Seems she was one of the first little girls to be desegregatedin Mississippi. She was terrified and she heard hate like most of us never hear in a life time. As an adult, she thought that she might like it better if she moved up north thinking that there would be less hate there. She soon found out, that there was every bit of hate here for her. The difference is that northerners keep it to themselves or say remarks like "you're unusually educated for a black woman" and mean it as a compliment.

Hate can't be legislated. It's in the hearts and minds of those who have it. It is taught from generation to generation. You've got to be carefully taught.

 
 
 
bitemore Gfotwo
Professor Silent
link   bitemore Gfotwo    13 years ago

Hate can't be legislated. It's in the hearts and minds of those who have it. It is taught from generation to generation. You've got to be carefully taught.

Oh, how true! I was so lucky to have been taught to respect everyone, regardless of race or religion! My mother was as anti-bigot as anyone this side of Sainthood, which amazes me to this day, because HER parents wore bigotry like a badge of honor! As she explained it to me, she grew up knowing that the LAST thing she wanted was to be like her parents. My grandparents made no secret of hating anyone who wasn't a WASP. Thus, when they discovered that my best friend was a Catholic, she was never allowed into their home. They openly hated blacks, and even Italians! Italians, for Pete's sake! Too bad they'd both passed away by the time I was married (to an Italian), but they both were alive when my sister married a Catholic! I still giggle over that!

So, I grew up differently from my mother... she went out of her way to be kind to everyone, and that really did make a difference in my own childhood because I saw both sides of the coin: the bigotry of my Grandparents and the total acceptance by my mother. She may have made mistakes, but she sure did that one thing right!

 
 
 
AmericanDreamsShattered
Freshman Silent
link   AmericanDreamsShattered    13 years ago

Yes and it was a mess!

 
 
 
pat wilson
Professor Quiet
link   pat wilson    13 years ago

Female Athlete Kicked Out of Olympics for Racist Tweet About Africans

The greeks don't fool around.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    13 years ago

Thank you for serving and glad you made it back from wherever you served. I was really referring to my own personal garden, not the the country as a whole. But you can come over some time.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

That salute doesn't represent genocide,

If the salute is in deference to and/or in sympathy of, and/or in advocacy of the Third Reich ideology or its crimes against humanity/war crimes, then indeed by virtue of its documented history and ideology, it represents genocide!

How ironic that millions were murdered because of what they believed, or, which womb they emerged from and yet there's an issue over whether or not someone has a right to pay it tribute.

I don't know the laws of Greece, etc., but, be it verbal or written or spoken or gestured, an overt indication that a criminal regime is revered, in my opinion constitutes a veiled or terroristic threat.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

Lincoln and Bush and Andrew Johnson?

 
 
 
pat wilson
Professor Quiet
link   pat wilson    13 years ago

How long are we going to hold the Nazis as the embodiment of evil?

Forever?

In a word "YES".

We copy plenty of things from previous, and more recent despots, killers, etc.

Example:

The "Che"

What have we copied from Che ?

Yes, there have been plenty of despots, killers, etc. But most don't hunt down and kill people of a specific ethnicity. There have been some thru history that did but most did not.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

... then again... I am hopelessly optimistic...

It's good to behopelessly optimistic...

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Forever INDEED.

Because the criminal is gone in no way diminishes the significance of his crimes, the consequences of his actions upon his victims or the taint on the ever-potential-to-do-evil so-called "human" race.

"Those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it"

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

We can all say "forever", but that isn't true, and we all know it.

In our society, where people barely know history at all?

Forever?

You cannot logically conclude that those who are ignorant of a particular set of facts can therefore forgive and/or forget the facts themselves nor the perpetrators when the facts are about heinous crimes (or anything else as ignorance is bliss).

If you think "forever" is impossible with regard to how a society or the world encapsulates evil deeds, you need only consider the death penalty or even a sentence of life in prison. For the perpetrators, and the society, such sentences are in fact, forever, and, for the society that imposes such punishments, there is no more powerful statement about the length of time our "collective" memory is manifested.

 
 
 
Polka-san
Freshman Silent
link   Polka-san    13 years ago

We aren't safe even in America from those that want to silence us. Look at OWS for a prime example of Iran style crackdowns on peaceful protestors. Or go back to the 1960's. The state can and will attack people and imprison them for speaking out. We are no different from Europe or the middle east or even the old Soviet Union. The state is a threat to freedom.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   seeder  Perrie Halpern R.A.    13 years ago

The state is a threat to freedom.

All you have to do is look at the Patriot Act to know that.

 
 
 
Polka-san
Freshman Silent
link   Polka-san    13 years ago

We are being shot at already. But know that the state is arming itself domestically with great arms. It is readying for total war against the people.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

But know that the state is arming itself domestically with great arms. It is readying for total war against the people.

The NRA recently debunked that myth which it once helped perpetuate.

L ast year, the Social Security Administration put out a procurement request for 174,000 rounds of .357 Sig 125 grain bonded jacketed hollow point pistol ammunition, prompting a few on the Internet to work themselves up into something of a frenzy. Its not outlandish, claimed Paul Joseph Wilson, one of a team of professional paranoiacs on the Infowars website, to suggest that the Social Security Administration is purchasing the bullets as part of preparations for civil unrest. Something strange is going on, harmonized Breitbart s William Bigelow. Even Mark Levin was concerned. I know why the governments arming up, he deduced. Its not because theres going to be an insurrection; its because our society is unraveling.

The Social Security Administrations purchase was by no means an anomaly. A year earlier, the unlikely pair of the Department of Agriculture ( 320,000 rounds ) and the National Weather Service ( 46,000 rounds ) had both put out tenders for ammunition. And slightly less odd, but still staggering, were the FBIs professed intention to purchase up to 100 million hollow point rounds and the Department of Homeland Securitys concurrent request for 450 million rounds. The Department of Education got in on the weapons-supplying spree, too, purchasing 27 Remington Brand Model 870 police 12-gauge shotguns.

The first question: Why? The second: Should we be worried?

The appeal of this story is obvious, and that some citizens keep track of such things shows an admirable vigilance. But while a healthy suspicion of government serves these United States better than critics presume, facts remain the stubborn things that they always have been, and skepticism is no virtue at all when it proves impervious to reason. Those who are vexed that the state is stocking up on ammunition and troubled by fears that this might be a step toward D.C.s assault on the citizens for whom it works can relax for now. Whatever the federal government has become, it is not yet plotting violence against the people.

Nonetheless, one could reasonably ask why the Social Security Administration would need any ammunition at all. Are the elderly especially unruly these days? Jonathan L. Lasher, in the SSAs external-relations department, explained to the Huffington Post that the ammunition is for the 295 agents in the outfits office of inspector general who investigate Social Security fraud and other crimes. Divide the rounds by the number of agents, and you get about 590 per agent; in a given year, thats about ten rounds a week. Most will be expended on the firing range, Lasher continued.

Okay. And why does the USDA need 320,000 rounds? Because it runs the Forest Service, which covers 155 national forests and 20 national grasslands on a total of 193 million acres of land. As well as agents in the field, the outfit has a law-enforcement unit based in Washington, D.C., whose responsibility it is to enforce federal laws and regulations. In context, those 320,000 rounds look a lot less threatening: If the U.S. Forest Service were to distribute ammunition at the same rate as the Social Security Administration, they would have enough for just 542 agents not bad for an organization that covers an area the size of Pakistan (or twice the size of Japan or Germany).

Its all about scale. Forty-six thousand rounds also sound like a lot for the National Weather Service. (Actually, the ammo was requested by the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administrations Fisheries Office of Law Enforcement, which is overseen by the same department.) In reality, its not that much. The service has only 63 armed personnel, which brings the purchase out at around 730 rounds per officer. This, suffice it to say, does not present a great threat to the Republic. As the NRA has noted , more than a few NRA members would use that much ammunition in a weekend shooting class or plinking session. There are enough risks to the right to bear arms and to American liberty in general, the NRA continued, without inventing threats.

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   Neale Osborn    13 years ago

Free speech no longer rules in the US. We require permits to assemble, we allow the FCC to tell us what may be said on television and radio, we increase the criminal penalties for a crime if we say certain things during the commission of that crime (hate crime laws), we have "politically correct speech" rules, and we blindly accept "Codes of Conduct" that limit free speech as acceptable and good. Of course, we also no longer have a free press. Instead, we have two propaganda machines. One huge one supporting the political left, and one smaller one supporting the political right. Thankfully, the internet allows us to exchange the truth, despite the prevalence of said "Codes of Conduct" limiting some of the discourse.

No, the First Amendment, like the 2nd, 4th, 5th, and 10th, are honored more today in the breaking than in the supporting.

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   Neale Osborn    13 years ago

Note the lack of a right to keep and bear arms....... Why I'll never become a Canadian!

 
 
 
bitemore Gfotwo
Professor Silent
link   bitemore Gfotwo    13 years ago

Sadly, you are correct, Neale. We are no longer "the land of the free." In reality, we never were. From first-grade on up, we have been propagandized to march in lockstep with those in control. It is very disillusioning. Very. The Constitution? It looks good on paper, but it falls apart in practice. It only works for those in power. The rest of us just cross our fingers and pray a lot.

 
 
 
bitemore Gfotwo
Professor Silent
link   bitemore Gfotwo    13 years ago

Well, I only know that we have been legislated into a corner... and those Constitutional "freedoms" are merely lip-service. The Bill of Rights? It's become a Bill of Goods... and not in our favor. Look at Congress and how hamstrung it has become... the only laws it can pass are the ones that grant more to the wealthy and powerful while taking more away from us "little people." Pffft. The joke is on us. And I, for one, am NOT laughing.

 
 
 
Polka-san
Freshman Silent
link   Polka-san    13 years ago

I am glad to see Neale around here. The implications of the destruction of Constitutional law is staggering. We now live in a land devoid of freedoms.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

We now live in a land devoid of freedoms.

Please list the freedoms you've lost

And the years in which you lost them.

Thank you.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    13 years ago

If these things are all true, and affect you as greatly as you profess, I wonder why anyone in the USA criticizes China.

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   Neale Osborn    13 years ago

Let me see.... Forced abortions. Murdering babies as they are born. Virtual slave labor. Three reasons to criticize. I can understand that you love your new home. At least HERE, if I protest the government, it doesn't sick tanks on me.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

But Mike, if no one remembers, to whom are you addressing the comment?

Would it be those of us who have in fact said "we should never forget?"

You can't accurately state that no one remembers; many do remember (or have read, etc.) about the Holocaust (just from the images you post -- there's an education), many have never known and wouldn't be interested in learning (about anything but video games).

There are very few survivors from the Resurrection of Christ but look how many celebrate Easter ('course, there's the Easter Bunny).

But you get my meaning.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

shhh I don't want it to be known that I am one of the last survivors of the resurrection of Christ.

Your secret is safe with me, although I DOUBT IT

Just call me "Thomas".

 
 
 
bitemore Gfotwo
Professor Silent
link   bitemore Gfotwo    13 years ago

Actually, I think most of us were extrapolating (and comparing) there to here. I know the story occurred in Greece and has no bearing on what happens here, but it is quite natural for people to see what happens elsewhere and think about what happens in their own particular locations (countries).

In terms of how "risky" an occurrence in Greece is as applied to us in the USA, well... we can assume that our lawmakers pay some attention to events elsewhere in the world and may even decide that they want what happened in Lower Slobovia to apply equally here... legislation and ideas thereto do not originate out of thin air, so what happens in Greece, or Turkey, or China DOES influence what happens elsewhere. The globe has shrunk, and we are NOT in isolation.

As for the Constitution, it is a constant challenge for everyday citizens to keep and maintain the rights guaranteed to them on that piece of paper, because at every turn there are those who WILL take away those rights if we do not remain vigilant. Freedom of speech is being chipped away a syllable at a time... and the Supreme Court is constantly hearing challenges. We are presumed innocent until proven guilty in a court of law, yet the average citizen can be arrested for standing on a street corner holding a sign, and then must spend a fortune in court costs in an effort to prove he had the right to be in that public place holding that sign. The Constitution would be better served if those who would interfere with the guaranteed rights first had to pay through the nose to show why they are right, but it doesn't work like that in real life.

In most places, it probably does work out okay... we see and hear only those cases that make the front page of the news or the major story in broadcast media, but the fact is that although we are all supposed to be equal, some are more equal than others, and what really matters is how much money you have.

Don't even get me started on HOA's and the way they control every single aspect of their captives' lives...

 
 
 
Kara Shalee
Freshman Silent
link   Kara Shalee    13 years ago

We have a lot of freedoms on paper, but as someone on this article pointed out (was it you, Bitey?), they are just that...........on paper. Challenging those freedoms to be put in place for your particular situation will more than likely cost you an attorney, which you cannot, of course, afford. So it amounts to a Catch 22.

I believe we live in a great Country, here in the USA. But, I will stop short of saying that it is the greatest. There are plenty of European and other Countries in the world which enjoy a lot of freedoms.

"Freedom isn't free", in so many ways.

 
 
 
bitemore Gfotwo
Professor Silent
link   bitemore Gfotwo    13 years ago

I think a few of us, including me, have pointed out the fallacy of this "freedom" thing... someone also mentioned the censorship, by the government, of language used in broadcast media. As far as I am concerned, no word or words should be forbidden by the government. Instead, let the marketplace determine what is or is not acceptable. And the censorship of certain words is not the only censorship we have. How about nudity? What's with that? We're all born nekkid, yet we treat the nude body like some foul word... we are biological beings, yet our biological functions are prohibited from mass exposure. Then we go around wondering why so many people are all hung up on what should be so natural as to be not even noticeable.

I'm sure there are many examples that could be added to this, but I'm getting ready to call it a night. So... I will leave it to someone else to finish this line of thought.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

92% of Americans polled want background checks for all gun purchases the marketplace has spoken so why do Republicans resist?

Which is it, the marketplace or the legislator-pimps for the NRA?

Same goes for increasing taxes on the wealthy vs. cutting Medicare and Social Security; same for the Jobs Bill the Republicans just killed again.

So, define what is meant by the "marketplace." If it's not the will of the majority, then what is it?

Really straight answer, please.

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   Neale Osborn    13 years ago

This will be a group response to everything from Kara's comment on down to here. We do happen to live in the greatest experiment/country mankind has tried so far. We started out with the highest ideals. We started out flawed, with slavery and a limited "citizenry", but we created the mechanism to correct those flaws. Some we corrected relatively painlessly, others took bloodshed and a huge chunk of time. Many here have told me "If you don't like the way things are done here, you damn anarchist/libertarian/republican/whatever, move somewhere else!" (usually, they want me in Somalia, because they think Somalia is a volunary anarchy..... but I digress). my response is always the same. "No. America may not be perfect, but unlike any other country in the world, we have two things going for us. We deliberately set this country up so that We, the People, providing we want to work at it, can change the direction of this country at any time. And the other thing we deliberately did was ensure that We, the People, had the physical power in our posession to forcibly change the direction ofthat government should that government ever became so tyrannical that it decided to ignore our voices."

I believe this with all my heart, soul, and intellect. I believe that we have lost our way, but the path is not that far away or too hard to reach. It will take some work. Some pain (not from violence, but rather from self-discipline causing us to deny ourselves some things until we can afford them without debt), Thus, I will never abandon this experiment. I will fight, with thought, word, and example, for the restoration of that dream of our forefathers. The dream they were too flawed to see completed, but laid the groundwork for. It is why I am so damn extremist in my defense of our right to keep and bear arms. It is why I speak my mind, and explain what I think and feel, and even more importantly WHY I think and feel that way. It is why, with rare exceptions. I will argue with some people till my face turns blue, rather than walk away from the fight. Because I believe that only by doing so can my country, flawed though it is, still be the shining beacon it has always been. People do not illegally enter ANY other country in numbers of over 1 million a year because America sucks. The freedoms we bitch about being diminished are so much more than most of these "illegals" ever had. Some bitch about illegals "taking our jobs', while ignoring the fact that they take jobs no American wants to do. These "illegals ARE the American dream. They ARE our future, if we can only stop fighting over them, and learn from them what America is really about. Freedom.

People want our guns. To be able to take our freedoms away. People want to restrict our speech. To be able to take our freedoms away. People want to force upon us a "politically correct" form of speech. To be able to prevent our disagreeing with their taking our freedoms away. And they can only succeed if WE, the PEOPLE, surrender those freedoms. They cannot take them without our co-operation. We must be convinced to don the chains of slavery voluntarily. We must give up our final, dreadful, defense against tyranny in order for them to succeed. We must decide to stop fighting ANY oppression, even oppression that purports to be for our own good, our own safety, our own convenience. This is something we cannot do if we wish to remain free. We must KEEP these freedoms in order to be Americans.

Freedom isn't necessarily comfortable. Freedom MUST include the right to fail. To starve. To make bad choices. To do bad things (and to defnd AGAINST those who would do bad things!) To succeed beyond our wildest dreams, and keep what we earned. We must be free to be human beings. Flawed, but ever-striving to change. To grow. To be better. Or fail in the attempt. Freedom isn't free. In fact, it isn't even cheap. It can ONLY be achieved by sacrifice, pain, and sometimes failure. It can hurt. And it is the most wonderful thing in the world to be free. I am free. No man, no government, will ever take my freedom. The most they can do is kill me. Again, I say that beautiful phrase, that so many have told me is trite and outmoded. But it is true "To this, I pledge my life, my fortune, my sacred honor."

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   Neale Osborn    13 years ago

When the marketplace responds by following the Constitution, meaning ratifying an Amendment that removes or overrides the phrase "the right of the people to keep and bear arms shall not be infringed" THEN AND ONLY THEN can background checlks be Constitutional. Does THAT answer your question, my friend?

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

If the Republicans would let it come to a popular vote (not the entire Amendment even -- just the magazine-ammunition limits and background checks), damned right I'd wager!

Put it on every state ballot in 2014 ... but tally the popular votes as a nation and you'd lose that vote.

But such a vote won't happen because the NRA owns too many legislators ... both sides of the aisle.

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   Neale Osborn    13 years ago

NO! It is a violation of the Constitution to infringe upon our right to keep and bear arms. Without an amendment, you CANNOT do this. The fact that our government WILL do it does not change the fact that it has no right nor power to do so.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

When the marketplace responds by following the Constitution,

Amending the Constitution would be a Congressional action, not that of the marketplace (the people). The fact that the polls on background checks are being ignored by Republicans means they don't respect the "marketplace".

So no, that does not answer my question.

But tell me, in what way would background checks violate the 2nd Amendment? Assuming such checks would reduce the number of sales to criminals, unstable individuals, etc., explain the violation of the 2nd Amendment.

Do you take it mean "The right (for criminals, known domestic abusers, and the insane for everyone in America, no exceptions) to keep and bear arms"?

I ask you in all seriousness.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Do you take the 2nd Amendment to mean "The right (for criminals, known domestic abusers, and the insane for everyone in America, no exceptions) to keep and bear arms"?

I ask you in all seriousness.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

in all seriousness, background checks won't reduce the number of sales in any measurable quantity.

Until they are implemented and there is some empirical information, that's purely speculative.

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   Neale Osborn    13 years ago

DO you REALLY want that answer? I guessc so. Yes, it does. Unless a person is stripped of their Constitutional rights (for which there is no Constitutional process, I might add), they have a right to keep and bear arms.Except for while inprisons, which the Constitution permits (shall not be placed in jeopardy of life nor liberty twice for the same crime), people have a Constitutional right to free speech, freedom from warrantless searches and seizures, AND to keep and bear arms. Once that quaint little phrase "Their debt to society is marked paid in full", they have their rights back.

Now, back to the marketplace. The majority, even supposed 92% that support background checks, do not have the right nor the power (Constitutionally speaking) to violate the Constitution.Just as even 92% of Americans voting to allow any other Constitutinal violations would not be Constitutional. Or are you saying that if 92% of Americans voted to, for instance, outlaw free speech on the internet, you'd be fine with having a monitor placed on your computer that would alert police every time you used the word "fuck" online? (Just picking a word 92% of America might choose to ban for illustrative purposes)? What you are advocating, whether you think so or not, is giving the camel the first inch of your tent. Setting a precedent, and a very dangerous one. There is one, and ONLY ONE, way to "violate" any portion of the Constitution, including any Amendment. And that is by a new Amendment.

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   Neale Osborn    13 years ago

Bite bite bite. Rip and tear. And now, I'm off to bed. I have an early day tomorrow, and will continue biting you tomorrow!!Grin.gif

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

DO you REALLY want that answer? I guessc so. Yes, it does. Unless a person is stripped of their Constitutional rights (for which there is no Constitutional process, I might add), they have a right to keep and bear arms.

Disagree and I'll be specific.

New York State just passed a law with restrictions and background checks and incidentally, did it in conjunction with gun dealers and NRA members. I'd say that, if nothing else allows it, STATES RIGHTS does.

The 2nd Amendment contains ONE WORD the implies, if not stipulates that certain restrictions may abide, I'll give you one guess at which word that is.

Question: If a nine year old goes to a gun shop or gun show with the cash to buy a handgun, AR-15, shotgun ANY firearm, does the dealer have the legal right to sell to him?

REALLY I want you to answer.

The majority, even supposed 92% that support background checks, do not have the right nor the power (Constitutionally speaking) to violate the Constitution.

I didn't say they did, I was responding to Mike's hypothetical of "the marketplace" and putting a question to a popular vote. As for amending the Constitution, just curious -- when the Tea Party wants to put on a ballot, Constitutional Bans on i.e. Gay marriage, etc., where do you stand on that (on a ballot question)?

There is one, and ONLY ONE, way to "violate" any portion of the Constitution, including any Amendment. And that is by a new Amendment.

Where we differ here, Neale, is on what constitutes a "violation." If you answer my questions and address the "States Rights" (also a Constitutional item), we'll likely continue this.

One other point re: "The right to keep and bear ARMS"

By definition "ARMS" = weapons and ammunition. Flamethrowers, hand grenades, tanks, bazookas? if any or all of these are not permitted to be legally owned and borne by citizens, that implies that not all ARMS are fall under the language of the 2nd Amendment. To take this to the extreme (for emphasis), Nuclear Arms? Obviously not, so, what about certain categories of fire arms? If one classification of ARMS is not 2nd-Amendment protected, could others not be restricted based on destructive-efficiency? What are the upper and lower limits?

________________________________________________

NOTE: I think it's significant to point out especially to new members, that you and I have serious political differences yet can debate respectfully and remain friends.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Mike wrote,

The "insane"? Of course not.

Moreover, you know I don't disagree about keeping guns away from felons, and people that have proved themselves "violent" offenders.

But your camp, NEVER stops with that.

You have people that want a total ban, and so, you force us into a position of total resistance.

So there are some caveats in your mind? And how would a legally, medically evaluated "insane" individual be identified to a gun dealer if not by background check?

I am NOT in any camp; I don't want all guns banned; I want a restriction on ammunition clip capacity, I want background checks and gun safety courses or tests mandated within a reasonable period of time upon first purchase, and real kick-ass prison time for individuals who commit crimes with guns.

That's it.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Yeah, right, what was I thinking?

Thanks for setting me on the right path.

Put one of those signs around my neck for thinking I could have a serious dialogue.

Locking up the steak knives as I type.

 
 
 
Polka-san
Freshman Silent
link   Polka-san    13 years ago

I would have to list the Bill of Rights nearly in its entirety. First, 2001 was the year of the patriot act...removes fourth amendment protections. Also we have had no real first Amendment protections for the nation's existence since many people have been attacked or even killed for exercising it under various regimes. The state also was either the aggressors or were compliant with other aggressors. Next, the NDAA removes themajorityof the Bill of Rights protections including the Fifth, Sixth and Eighth Amendments in the year 2011. The second has been under attack for a long time. Since the 1930's, machine guns have been heavily regulated. When was the first time a state regulated a federal law? That was the year the second was lost.

The fact is that we need "permits" to protest. "permits" to own firearms in most places. The state can tell us what to eat. What to think (in schools). How to dress (nudity laws). There are so many anti-freedom laws. To find a list a series of dates for them would take a long time for research. The USis about as far removed from a free nation as it could be. We are as free as the state "allows" us which is always limited since an authoritarian state fears losing power over all other things.

 
 
 
Polka-san
Freshman Silent
link   Polka-san    13 years ago

No but it may drop a missile on your house or kidnap you under the power of the NDAA.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    13 years ago

Negatives? Do people still use film cameras?

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Negatives? Do people still use film cameras?

Some still shoot film and since the subject came up I have a scanning service 35mm slides and negatives, color or black and white. Robert G got it on the nose; most people toss their old slides and negatives in a box or drawer or put them in the attic and forget them. Their survivors when cleaning up and selling the house usually just trash the negatives and slides.

I was recently given almost 1000 Magic Lantern slides from an estate; no one knew of any use for them. Anyone who has slides or negatives and is going to trash them, please, e-mail me before doing so.

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   Neale Osborn    13 years ago

You feelthy liar!! We NEVER AGREE politely!!Grin.gif Grin.gif Grin.gif Grin.gif Grin.gif

Obviously, we can and do! BTW- gotta get together privately sometime to discuss an impending trip towards your neck of the woods.

Now to the meat of this particular argument!

First to states rights. States have no right to violate the Constitution. Other than that, they have to right to be free of federal interference in their laws. Case in point- Montana recently told the ATF to fuck off. Montana will no longer enforce ATF rules and regulations regarding manufacturing of firearms within the state's borders, nor will they follw ATF guidelines in the sale and transfer of firearms to Montana residents, as the federal government has no Constitutional control over commerce within a state's borders. ONLY firearms manufactured for sale outside of Montana will be required to comply with ATF rules and regulations. Nor will Montana consider it their duty to enforce ATF rules with regard to Montana residents leaving the state, temporarily or permanently, but rather consider that the problem of the ATF and the citizen.

The 2nd Amendment does NOT contain a single word that permits restrictions on the right to keep and bear arms. And any English teacher can tell you why!Grin.gif As an English major, I shall now fill in for that teacher. From my article on the Bill of Rights, and the 2nd Amendment thereof- " Well Regulated- The phrase "well-regulated" was in common use long before 1789, and remained so for a century thereafter. It referred to the property of something being in proper working order. Something that was well-regulated was calibrated correctly, functioning as expected. Establishing government oversight of the people's arms was not only not the intent in using the phrase in the 2nd Amendment, it was precisely to render the government powerless to do so that the founders wrote it. ( source ) ( another source ) Both these sources cite definitions of the day, including, in the second link, a 1789 North Carolina law AND the words of Alexander Hamilton in Federalist Papers #29. So this term does not mean "controlled by laws and licenses", but rather well-trained and in good order.
"Something that was well-regulated was calibrated correctly"

And thus, the "Regulated" argument is relegated to the trash can!

Next, the 9 yr old boy at the gun show. With parental permission, yes. Oh, you'd like clarification? Sure! AS I have said elsewhere, Every man, woman, and responsible child has an unalienable
individual, civil, Constitutional, and human right to obtain, own, and
carry, openly or concealed, any weapon rifle, shotgun, handgun,
machinegun, _anything any time, any place, without asking anyones
permission. The Atlanta Declaration of the Libertarian Party, written by L. Neil Smith. The author of this article is a signatory to same.

A "responsible child" is one trained by his/her parents in marksmanship, safety, and gunhandling. If the father is present to certify the child's responsibility, then yes, he can buy that weapon. If, however, the dealer feels the child is not acting responsibly, he has an inherent right to NOT sell the weapon. As he does with ANY purchaser. As I have done a time or two myself when running a gun shop. Responsibility DOES go both ways. Just as a bartender must not permit an obviously intoxicated person to leave the bar via his car, a gunshop owner will never sell a gun or ammunition to an obviously drunk or impaired individual. Now did I sell a gun to a man who,a customer informed me,had struck his wife ten minutes earlier in the parking lot. He ws impaired by anger. the fact that she hit him first was irrelevant. He'd just been in a physical altercation, I denied the sale. Dealers have the right to complete a sale to that child. They do NOT have the obligation to do so if they feel there is a reason not to. ANY reason.

I know the marketplace topic is hypothetical. I also know, beyond a shadow of a doubt, that you, personally, are not in favor of balloting to remove a right. Neither am I. I believe that NO VOTE, not matter how large the majority, has the right to strip rights from individuals. I'll even go so far as to say that IF you were to get the amendment to remove the 2nd amendment passed, I would cheerfully and with malice of forethought violate that new amendment in every way possible. I consider it an inherent right of every individual to posess, carry, and use in time of need, any and all tools necessar to defend themselves against ANY attacker, male, female, or governmental.

On the TEA Party and gay marriage ballot initiatives, I do not support them. I feel that human beings do not need the government to define marriage, outlaw sexual behavior other than rape and pedophelia, and that to do so is to deny civil rights. again, even if 92% of the vote passes that initiative.

Last, but not least, Arms are arms. PERIOD. In the Revolution, many of the cannon were privately owned. Many more were bought by militia groups or town militias, using private funds. the government, in my fairly radical opinion, may not own any weapon it chooses to deny me the right to own. But you knew that already!Grin.gif

Well, you liberal pain in the butt (Joking, my friend), my fingers are tired and I have a mother in law to pick up. later, gator!!

 
 
 
bitemore Gfotwo
Professor Silent
link   bitemore Gfotwo    13 years ago

My definition of "marketplace" is "will of the majority." No if's, and's or but's. And no finagling and shenanigans and cover-ups and asterisks. And whether you are a billionaire or don't have two pennies to your name, you get only ONE vote. One. No more, no less.

Maybe then we'd end up with a government somewhat different than the "best money can buy." As if the current regime would ever relinquish its stranglehold on the country without one hell of a fight. But, wishes are still free and legal. For now, anyway.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

The 2nd Amendment does NOT contain a single word that permits restrictions on the right to keep and bear arms.

Disagree, the word is "regulated" and although it refers to militias, if I were arguing the case on the basis of Constitutionality regarding specific weapons and ammunition capacities, I'd argue

"Since the Founding Fathers included regulation within the language of the 2nd Amendment, it is certainly reasonable to apply "regulation" in any/all matters 2nd Amendment. Further, since there are in fact ARMS that citizens are prevented by law from owning and bearing, it is therefore not necessarily unconstitutional to consider the banning of certain other ARMS, etc."

Every man, woman, and responsible child has an unalienable
individual, civil, Constitutional, and human right to obtain, own, and
carry, openly or concealed, any weapon rifle, shotgun, handgun,
machinegun, _anything any time, any place, without asking anyones
permission. The Atlanta Declaration of the Libertarian Party, written by L. Neil Smith. The author of this article is a signatory to same.

That's an interpretation/opinion, not a law.

Last, but not least, Arms are arms. PERIOD.

So I can own and bear a flamethrower? Molotove Cocktail?

The reality is

What are Illegal Weapons?

Each state has broad latitude to determine what weapons are illegal within its borders. A few common examples are:

  • Ballistic knifes,
  • Belt buckle knifes,
  • Cane swords,
  • Billy clubs,
  • Large-capacity ammunition magazines,
  • Ammunition with or containing an explosive agent,
  • Camouflaging firearm container,
  • Any gun not immediately recognizable as a firearm, or
  • Metallic knuckles.

What Acts Violate an Illegal Weapon Law?

Each state is free to choose, and most illegal weapon lawsmake a variety of activities illegal. They can range from:

  • Manufacturing or causing illegal weapons to be manufactured,
  • Importing illegal weapons into a state,
  • Selling or keeping illegal weapons for sale,
  • Giving or lending illegal weapons, and
  • Possession of an illegal weapon.

Are There any Exemptions from Illegal Weapon Laws?

Each state has its own exemptions for violations of its illegal weapon law, but most include:

  • Police departments, the Department of Justice, the Armed forces, or any of their authorized agents,
  • Licensed self defense schools,
  • Antiques, relics, and instruments used in a collection,
  • The use during motion pictures, television or video production, or
  • Forensic laboratories.

What are the Consequences for Violating an Illegal Weapon Law?

If you violate an illegal weapon law, you have generally committed a felony and could face criminal punishment that can range from:

  • Jail time, from 1 to 5 years,
  • Fines, from $100 to $10,000,
  • Community service, or
  • Loss of driver's license.
 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

That is addressed to Neale, correct?

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   Neale Osborn    13 years ago

They can only wear the sign voluntarily. Nor can their doctor report them. It's called a violation of theirHIPPA rights. (Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act) ANY doctor who releases patient information without either the patients written consent or a duly authorized court order WILL lose their license to practise medicine. Already, the VA has refused to report to the NY background check any such info because if they do, then patients will no longer seek help for dealing with PTSD or other problems. Our beloved masters....er... elected SOBS keep passing laws that contradict other laws, then prosecute you no matter which way you go.

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   Neale Osborn    13 years ago

The wife is a nurse. According to her, ALL privacy issues are now rolled into HIPAA. There are written HIPAA compliance posters all over work. They warn, among other things, of the penalties that accrue if you pass any private records to anyone other than your central records archive (usually electronic these days), the patient, or the insurance company IF that info is relevant. Again, according to her, it is a violation of HIPAA, in addition to standard doctor-patient confidentiality to pass on medical information, psychiatric evaluations, the content of therapy sessions, and anything other than a specific threat of suicide or impending murder. Legally speaking, if the patient reveals they have engaged in sexual acts with children, they are prohibited from passing that on. Please note that I do not support that one! IF there is an error in how I describe this, my guess is I misunderstood my wife.

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   Neale Osborn    13 years ago

I do take it to that extreme. There is NO Constitutional method to deny a felon, once released from his punishment, his Constitutional rights, including the RTKBA.

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   Neale Osborn    13 years ago

(Sigh) One more time for old time's sake, then I am taking a break from this thread- my BP is rising, and I've already had one stroke.

I have said repeatedly, without reservation, that it is irrelevant what states have done in the past, IF THAT ACTION VIOLATED THE CONSTITUTION. For many years, states allowed slavery. It was unConstitutional. But it WAS a precedent. Does that make it okay? I mean, many states actually forced free men INTO slavery just for crossing the state border. It was legal. So, are you fine with that? Of course not. Many states have had laws on the books prohibiting certain sexual acts between consenting adults. They were laws. So, you're fine with that? So what makes you think that a state declaring a weapon "illegal" means that it is Constitutional? The fact that the Supreme Court has ruled that certain types pf weapons can be limited or banned does not mean that it is Constitutional. They also have ruled unConstitutionally before, and will again. One of the most famous is Dredd/Scott. People love to quote Scalia's assertion that guns can be controlled, and point out he's a conservative, so somehow that means I take his word as final. Nope. He's a human. He can be wrong, he can be intimidated, he can just cave in to public opinion.

Now, I am taking a break. Be back later tonight.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    13 years ago

A flash drive, i.e. memory stick, which is tiny, can hold a lot more photos than a cardboard box, and I assume they don't deteriorate. They can be taken elsewhere in a shirt pocket to show (and bore the hell out of) others. There's a reason why Kodak went out of the film business.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    13 years ago

EF, I think you have one of the finest cameras ever made. For me, the dream of owning a Hasselblad was like the dream of buying a Rolls Royce.

 
 
 
Another Fine Mess
Freshman Silent
link   Another Fine Mess    13 years ago

The same could not be said about Geert Wilder, who was not allowed into England for his views on Muslims.

The banning of a fellow European Parliamentarian was a disgrace, he was later tried and acquitted of Hate Speech in 2011, there are very few things I admire about the US but their almost complete freedom of speech is one of them.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Neale,

It does not require a Constitutional Amendment, etc., to restrict certain aspects of gun law.

...

Gun laws in the United States regulate the sale, possession, and use of firearms and ammunition . State laws vary, and are independent of existing federal firearms laws , although they are sometimes broader or more limited in scope than the federal laws. For instance, some US states have created assault weapon bans that are similar to the expired federal assault weapons ban .

State level laws vary significantly in their form, content, and level of restriction. Forty-four states have a provision in their state constitutions similar to the Second Amendment to the U.S. Constitution . The exceptions are California, Iowa, Maryland, Minnesota, New Jersey, and New York. In New York, however, the statutory civil rights laws contain a provision virtually identical to the Second Amendment. [ 1 ] [ 2 ] As well, the Supreme Court of the United States has held that the protections of the Second Amendment apply against state governments and their political subdivisions (see: McDonald v. Chicago ). [ 3 ]

Writing for the majority, Justice Alito held that the Due Process Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment incorporates the Second Amendment right recognized in Heller . [ 21 ] Writing a concurring opinion, Justice Thomas reached the same conclusion regarding the incorporation issue on different grounds: Privileges or Immunities Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment . [ 22 ] The plurality decision also reaffirmed that certain firearms restrictions mentioned in District of Columbia v. Heller are assumed permissible and not directly dealt with in this case. [ 23 ]

Such restrictions include those to "prohibit...the possession of firearms by felons or mentally ill" and "laws forbidding the carrying of firearms in sensitive places such as schools and government buildings, or laws imposing conditions and qualifications on the commercial sale of arms" [23]

Firearm owners are subject to the firearm laws of the state they are in, and not exclusively their state of residence. Reciprocity between states exists in certain situations, such as with regard to concealed carry permits. These are recognized on a state-by-state basis. For example, Idaho recognizes an Oregon permit, but Oregon does not recognize an Idaho permit. Florida issues a license to carry both concealed weapons and firearms, but others license only the concealed carry of firearms. Some states do not recognize out-of-state permits to carry a firearm at all, so it is important to understand the laws of each state when traveling with a handgun. [ 4 ]

In many cases, state firearms laws can be considerably less restrictive than federal firearms laws. This does not confer any de jure immunity against prosecution for violations of the federal laws.

However, state and local police departments are not legally obligated to enforce federal gun law as per the U.S. Supreme Court's ruling in Printz v. United States . [ 5 ] [ 6 ]

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   Neale Osborn    13 years ago

Well, she works for a therapeutic foster care company, but I get the point. here in NY, though (or at least my county) ALL privacy issues are considered HIPAA issues, and addressed as such. Maybe it's CYA, figuring the strictest rules are the safest ones. I'm a plumber, gunsmith,and blacksmith. I'll deal with shit, guns, and hot metal!Grin.gif

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   Neale Osborn    13 years ago

Again, I refer you to my previous statements, with an addition. See Marbury v Madison. While it resulted in teh SCOTUS arrogating unto itself more power than it was originally granted, it also pointed out that ANY law that violates the Constitution is automatically null and void. Soooo, those fine laws you sited, if actually compared to the written Constitution, are null and void. The fact that the SCOTUS has failed abysmally in it's job to strictly read the Constitution and determine whether a law complies or not (only if the law is brought to them, I might add) does not render them magically Constitutional. It simply, like the rest of the Bill of Rights, (and as my NV avatar states)

VOID WHERE PROHIBITED BY (UNCONSTITUTIONAL) LAW

And I feel the same way about any law that prohibits gay marriage, restricts free speech, or permits warrantless searches and seizures. Take that TSA and NYPD!!!

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Do you think the insane are only a problem with a gun in their hand?

Do you think they might be more of a problem with a gun in their hands? Reality dictates that because all aspects of a problem can't be solved, common sense dictates nevertheless that we try to solve as much of the problem as possible.

Some individuals with cancer will accept an alternative like losing a body part if it spares them death for a period of time.

Would you issue a drivers' license to someone with a record of homicide by vehicle/DUI? You would not if you were aware of his record.

All kinds of shit falls through the cracks in the scheme of things

So we seal up as many cracks as we can. That's just common sense.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Resolved: "Insane" people cannot drive, work, have kids, go to public places, or possess any weapons of any kind, be in the presence of weapons, and can never be unattended around children.

Registered sex offenders (i.e.) have legal restrictions imposed upon them must register, etc., there are precedents if someone has lost his right to hold a drivers' license because of numerous DUI convictions, because he can still get in a car and drive illegally, should we just say, "what the hell may as well not take his license?"

Are you mocking me?

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   Neale Osborn    13 years ago

I hope not, because that is the way to end civil discourse. Ennyhoo, MY take on DUIs is a bit different. I consider stepping out of a bar drunk, getting into the car, and starting it up premeditated attempted murder. And I get more draconian from there. When I lived in Ft Collins, all the college bars had a simple procedure. Walk in and either have a designated driver (who was hand-stamped "DD" and got free soft drinks and bar snacks) or surrender your car keys at the door. In BOTH cases, when you (or your party) left, the DD blew into a breathalyzer, and the party was escorted to their car. If no DD, YOU blew into a breathalyzer in order to get your keys. Blow within a point of the limit (I forget what it was in 1989), and the bar put you in a cab, free of charge. You got a voucher for a cab back, good the next day. They had a bouncer on duty all day to return your keys when you returned. This was not cheap. Most of the bars that did this also had a fairly high cover charge. And they were PACKED every Friday and Saturday. People loved the security. I doubt they still do it. But they should.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Are you mocking me?

That was directed at Mike's comment (in block quote) not you, Neale.

We seem to be on the save wave length re:drunk drivers.

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   Neale Osborn    13 years ago

I knew dat, Mac. I was trying to lighten the mood a little. You know I'd never mock you. But since I like both you AND Mike, I don't wanna see my friends get TOO intense with each other.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

No problem with Mike and me, Terry (wmolaw) and me or you and me the debates and differences of opinion don't affect the friendships. I'll add Bruce to that list as well. Pat N too.

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   Neale Osborn    13 years ago

I knew it with you and I, but since I do not follow you guys around, I like to be sure. People I like are easyto find. But people I like AND disagree with without rancor are far harder to find, and worth a little extra effort to keep.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

it doesn't define or state any limitations.

Nor does the First Amendment stipulate limitations on speech/expression, but in fact, not all forms of speech are protected by the Amendment. Libel, slander, perjury, terroristic threats

And in fact, every state in the U.S. has its laws regarding weapons and their uses.

Writing for the majority, Justice Alito held that the Due Process Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment incorporates the Second Amendment right recognized in Heller . [ 21 ] Writing a concurring opinion, Justice Thomas reached the same conclusion regarding the incorporation issue on different grounds: Privileges or Immunities Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment . [ 22 ] The plurality decision also reaffirmed that certain firearms restrictions mentioned in District of Columbia v. Heller are assumed permissible and not directly dealt with in this case. [ 23 ]

Such restrictions include those to "prohibit...the possession of firearms by felons or mentally ill" and "laws forbidding the carrying of firearms in sensitive places such as schools and government buildings, or laws imposing conditions and qualifications on the commercial sale of arms" [23]

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

We have empirical evidence that printed photographs, in a closed (dark, dry) box, can last decades with little degradation.

No argument; prints hold up especially if they're kept that way and no one exposes them to light, handling or even

looking at them.

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   Neale Osborn    13 years ago

And that is precisely why I have paper books coming out the wazoo- when civilization grinds to a halt, I will still be able to read my Robert heinlein collection while listening to my vinyl collection on the hand-cranked phonograph.

Shit, Bob! I did it too. (washes typing fingers in alchohol, trying to wash away the guiltGrin.gif )

 
 
 
JoAnne Odel
Freshman Silent
link   JoAnne Odel    13 years ago
when a sr senator feels insulted when a collegue discusses the bill of rights, we have a problem.
 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   Neale Osborn    13 years ago

Well, I can actually (sorta) agree with you- limitations ARE crazy.

Here's the problem. You want a limitation on an enumerated right. Fine. No "Fire!!!" in a crowded theater unless you see flames. But then,Joe comes along and decides "Robert successfully proved that we can limit free speech, as long as it is reasonable. Well, saying "God doesn't exist" is just as bad, so we'll use his precedent to justify banning THAT phrase." Yeah, I know the phrase "Slippery Slope" is a joke to a lot of you, but it is a fact. The INSTANT you tolerate one exception to an absolute (SHALL NOT be infringed) some asshole will come along and say "This was reasonable, because we did it, so why ISN'T that also reasonable. just as you are doing here.

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   Neale Osborn    13 years ago

Pretty good, actually. You see, I actually can present facts to back up my assertions. And when I do, some people, the intelligent ones, check what I say, and think about it. They do not always agree, at least not 100%, but they see a glimmer of the truth. And it sinks in.

200 years ago, most people "knew" blacks were not human, and were barely able to follow orders. They had no souls, and no rights. Some people thought this belief wrong, and fought against it. Thomas Jefferson, slaveowner though he was, and even slave screwer that he was, saw this truth, and tried to write it into the Declaration. He was denied. But eventually, more and more of America eliminated slavery. Then ALL of America was slave free. But those blacks still didn't have rights. And people like YOU insisted it could never happen. They told those advocating for black rights that "We have laws to prevent that, and they have been upheld time and time again. how's this belief that YOU are right working out for you?" Today, it's working out pretty damn good for them. We have a black president, even if I happen to think he's a lousy president, I'm proud we elected one. And it will continue to inprove.

200 years ago, women were little more than baby-makers and home-maintenance people. They could not vote, hold office, buy homes, or do almost anything else a man could do. They were not citizens, could not serve in the military, they were one step from chattel. And some few people thought this attitude was wrong. That women are as smart, capable, and steady as men. That they could be citizens, vote, hold office, and serve in the military. They were laughed at by people just like YOU for that, and asked "How's that working for you?" in sarcastic ignorant tones, just like yours. But slowly, over time, their voices grew louder, and more people listened to them. And now, women are poised to break through the final two barriers- the "glass ceiling" of truly equal pay and to hold the highest office in the land. They already run huge businesses, run states, cities, and government offices.

So, when an ignorant person like you asks me "So how's that 2nd Amendment battle going for you?" in your smarmy self-righteous voice, I answer honestly. "Pretty damn good, thank you." And it will go right over your head, and probably get a sarcastic answer back (if any at all). But that's alright. Because I'll still be fighting the good fight. winning some, losing a lot, and slowly chipping away at your attacks on freedom.

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   Neale Osborn    13 years ago

Yes. Laws that do not conform to the Constitution are not legitimate. The federal government can tax and interstate trade. So they cantax the airways if they so choose, and control the movement of food and drugs from state to state. But they cannot decide what is legal to sell INSIDE a state. They have taken state's rights away. And have been since before Lincoln abused state's rights to justify destroying people who no longer wished to associate as a Union.

Is that blunt enough for you?

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   Neale Osborn    13 years ago

Please tell me what part of the 2nd Amendment, for example, is not very specifically addressed IN THE TERMS OF THE DAY IT WAS WRITTEN IN? Here's the problem I have with "exceptions". The list keeps growing. No matter where you look, exceptions breed like rabbits. And each one is used to justify the next.

Should a man who flipped out, tried to eat his daughter for breakfast, ran naked out into the streets, then tried to catch a bus by jumping in front of it scrfeaming "I got it! I got it!!" own and carry a gun? Of course not. But when we pass a law to prevent that, the next law is written to prevent a man who admits to an occasional bout of depression being denied that right. This statement has pissed off several here, but I am going to make it again.

Freedom and liberty are not free. Sometimes, bad things happen that are a penalty of being free. When a bad thing happens, like Sandy Hook, the response can not be to ban or restrict a right because some few people abuse that right.

The children at Sandy Hook, the staff, and the shooter's mother, were all victims. not of guns, which are merely tools. Not of gun rights, which are part of individual freedoms. But of one sick individual. They didn't die because of high capacity magazines or AR15s. They died because a crazy person chose to kill them. punishing me by restricting my right to self defense against ANY enemy because one man went crazy is wrong. And I'll tell you, it is STILL my firm belief that IF those staff members were permitted to be armed rather than prohibited from being armed, there is a possibility that some of those children would not have died that day.

The Constitution will not go "up in flames" because we follow it strictly. Nor will society. But SOCIETY will go up in flames if we fail to follow it strictly. And all the signs are there. Sadly, too few people read the signs.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

a restriction on ALL the people, virtually ALL the time, is NOT allowed by the 2nd Amendment.

It was not my contention that "ALL people, ALL the time would be restricted" in total as (i.e.) a ban on ALL guns. But because the words "WELL-REGULATED" appear, albeit with reference to militias, my contention is that REGULATION can be applied throughout provided that the letter and spirit of the law is not violated.

Possibly the Founding Fathers believed that the inclusion of phrases such as, " exceptions apply for the insane, the duly convicted felon, children under the age of ", etc., were rhetorical, understood by reasonable individuals and thus unnecessary to be rendered to writing.

Although we do not undertake an exhaustive historical analysis today of the full scope of the Second Amendment , nothing in our opinion should be taken to cast doubt on longstanding prohibitions on the possession of firearms by felons and the mentally ill, or laws forbidding the carrying of firearms in sensitive places such as schools and government buildings, or laws imposing conditions and qualifications on the commercial sale of arms. 26

I take this to mean that there can be local and even Federal laws that function as "provisos" as they apply to the right to bear arms, that the right is, as with speech, not absolute nor without certain restrictions.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Then, the box of photos is fun. Figuring out who is in the picture, taken in 1925, obvious to the people who took the photo. But the quantity encouraged and enabled by digital technology, can make it impossible to find or retrieve a particular one, and LESS likely that future descendents will go through them to find the gems. Now, we treasure the few old pics that we have.

Actually, the opposite is true. In Photoshop and other image editing applications, keywords, captions and other information can be embedded in the image file. Type in a key word and every image that has the word in the "INFO" field comes up as a thumbnail on the computer desktop. Want the full-size image double click. Want to make a hundred copies, click "make duplicate."

I have roughly 20,000 images in my database backed up on each of several external hard drives. I can locate any one in seconds by typing in a keyword and doing a search. Of course, the key to keywording is embedding well-conceived search terms.

7286_discussions.jpg Here's a shot of my Adobe Bridge application (part of Photoshop Elements); Lately I've been researching 100+ year old slides, hence all of the dates you see in the key word list. If I click on any one (or more) of the key words, every applicable image thumbnail appears to the right; if I click on a thumbnail (see the dinosaurs, etc.), a full-size image appears to the right of the thumbnail.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

when a sr senator feels insulted when a collegue discusses the bill of rights, we have a problem.

When the colleague is a newly-elected pompous ass who hasn't even learned where all the mens rooms in the Capitol are, and he doesn't "discuss" but rather pontificates to put on a show for Tea Party NRA-pimps-for-gun-manufacturers, THEN we have a problem.

TED CRUZ --if that's who you're referring to, was a big-time "BIRTHER" until someone at Fox News pointed out

Birther Hypocrisy- Right Wing Has No Problem With Canadian Born Senator Ted Cruz Running For President

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   Neale Osborn    13 years ago

When the Senior Senator has made a career out of trying to ban ALL guns (as she admitted to 60 munutes in 1995), she NEEDS to be schooled. As to Cruz and birthers, irrelevant. I can say "That dude would be a great President!" all I want. Once I find out he was born in Canada, my answer would be "Oh well! Guess not!" While he may not know where all the men's rooms are, he certainly has much better grasp on the Constitution than thesenior senatorhas. He ALSO successfully got her to admit her hypocrisy.

Good job, Ted.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

When the Senior Senator has made a career out of trying to ban ALL guns (as she admitted to 60 munutes in 1995), she NEEDS to be schooled

Not so; a Breitbart and Fox misrepresentation; Feinstein was talking about ASSAULT WEAPONS, not ALL guns!

Watch the CLIPPED CLIP notice the beginning of the clip Feinstein was showing and talking about ASSAULT WEAPONS and that's what she referred to in the clip. The clip conveniently omits what was said before the "ban them all" comment. Check the search engines, this story comes from the right wing usual sources.

Proposed Weapons Ban Exempts Government Officials?

...

Lots of stories about Feinstein cominf from the Tea Party but are any true?

TheTeaParty.net falsely claims in an email that Sen. Dianne Feinsteins proposed assault weapons ban would exempt all government officials from the ban. While the bill would exempt military and law enforcement officials, it would not exempt legislators or administrative staff.

The email further misrepresents the proposed bill, claiming that she [Feinstein] wants to take your handguns, rifles and other weapons away from you. In fact, the proposal would grandfather in all of the existing weapons owned by Americans, so no weapons will be taken away from anyone.

Feinstein, a Democratic from California, and Rep. Carolyn McCarthy, a Democrat from New York, unveiled their proposed legislation at a press conference on Jan. 24. The bill, called the Assault Weapons Ban of 2013 , seeks to reinstate and expand on the 1994 assault weapons ban, which was allowed to expire in 2004.

According to an email blast from TheTeaParty.net , under the Feinstein-McCarthy proposal, We are not all equal under the law.

TheTeaParty.net email, Jan. 30 : It is bad enough that Democrat Senator Diane Feinstein (CA) has proposed a national attack on our gun rights. Today, it has been revealed that although she wants to take your handguns, rifles and other weapons away from you, she wants to exempt all government officials from her proposed gun ban! If you needed any more evidence that in our government officials eyes we are beneath them in stature and should bow down before them in reverence, then this is it. Their message is guns are bad for you, but they are good for us. Their message is we are entitled to protect ourselves and our families with firearms if necessary, but you cannot.

The message that Senator Feinstein and all who support her bill are sending is that their lives, families, and property are valuable and worth defending; yours, however, is not.

The claim appears to originate with reporting from the Huffington Post and the Washington Times . Both vaguely referred to government officials being exempt from the ban, without explaining which government officials. That reporting was then worked into headlines by Fox News , the Weekly Standard and numerous conservative blogs.

TheTeaParty.net takes the claim one step further, though, asserting that the Feinstein proposal would exempt all government officials. The law spells out a number of exemptions, but none of them include a blanket exception for all government officials.

According to the bill , t hose exempted from the prohibition against having an assault weapon or large-capacity ammunition magazine would include a qualified law enforcement officer (whether on or off duty, and sometimes even if retired), a campus law enforcement officer for purposes of law enforcement (whether on or off duty), as well as those transporting nuclear material. (See pages 15 to 18).

The bill also would exempt the United States or a department or agency of the United States or a State or a department, agency, or political subdivision of a State. Officials in Feinsteins and McCarthys offices say that phrase refers to the military. Nearly identical language was included in the 1994 assault weapons ban, which was enacted as part of the Violent Crime Control and Law Enforcement Act of 1994 . (See Title XI, Sec. 110102)

1994 : Paragraph (1) shall not apply to (A) the manufacture for, transfer to, or possession by the United States or a department or agency of the United States or a State or a department, agency, or political subdivision of a State, or a transfer to or possession by a law enforcement officer employed by such an entity for purposes of law enforcement (whether on or off duty);

2013 : Paragraph (1) shall not apply to (A) the importation for, manufacture for, sale to, transfer to, or possession by the United States or a department or agency of the United States or a State or a department, agency, or political subdivision of a State, or a sale or transfer to or possession by a qualified law enforcement officer employed by the United States or a department or agency of the United States or a State or a department, agency, or political subdivision of a State, for purposes of law enforcement (whether on or off duty), or a sale or transfer to or possession by a campus law enforcement officer for purposes of law enforcement (whether on or off duty);

We asked Shams Tarek, a spokesman for McCarthy, if the proposed law exempts government officials.

If by government officials you mean law enforcement and military, then yes, Tarek said. But absolutely not if you mean lawmakers or administrative staffs Just soldiers and cops.

One other point, TheTeaParty.net email claims that she [Feinstein] wants to take your handguns, rifles and other weapons away from you. In fact, the proposal would grandfather in all of the existing weapons owned by Americans, so no weapons will be taken away from anyone.

The l aw clearly states that the prohibition against the import, sale, manufacture, transfer or possession of assault weapons shall not apply to any semiautomatic assault weapon otherwise lawfully possessed under Federal law on the date of enactment of the Assault Weapons Ban of 2013.

Robert Farley

Posted by Robert Farley on Monday, February 4, 2013 at 1:04 pm Filed under The FactCheck Wire . tagged with assault weapons ban , Carolyn McCarthy , Dianne Feinstein , Guns .

Even in this clip where she directly states she never wanted to ban all guns, the CLIPPED CLIP was added. It's dishonest!

Mr. and Mrs. America, turn em all in. Thats the line that has gun owners up in arms. In the last couple of weeks, theyve used that statement by DiFei as evidence that the senior Senator from California really wants to ban all firearms, all guns, every last one of them. The problem with that evidence, however, is that the word all is ambiguous if one does not consult the entire interview, especially before that interview with 60 Minutes Leslie Stahl. Heres what happened before Stahl cut to DiFei:

...

In context

They and em refers not to all guns, but assault weapons, especially those covered under the 1993 assault weapons ban signed into law by then President William Jefferson Clinton. Follow the interview with Perkins, Leslie Stahl sat down with DiFei, who used the word all to refer assault weapons, not all firearms. Did CBS do a poor job of conveying that? Possibly. But the NRA, the gun lobby, the gun manufacturers, and gun extremists should have also watched the report in its entirety. Not just a clip, one that can be pasted into another clip to essentially put words in DiFeis mouth that she did not say.

California Senator Dianne Feinstein is not anti-gun. Shes not out to ban all guns. Senator Cruz and all his supporters, including the gun lobby and NRA, have played upon the ignorance of the American public to portray DiFei in such a light. Shes not anti-gun. Shes simply pro-child, and pro-man, pro-woman, and pro-innocence. And theres a reason for that and its coming up next.

<Commercial break.>

I dont know Dianne Feinstein. Ive never met Dianne Feinstein. Ive never voted for Dianne Feinstein. But I know that Dianne Feinsteins intentions are true and they come from the heart. Moreover, they come from experience. Dianne Feinstein is from California, specifically the wonderful city of San Francisco. And before she was a United States Senator from California, DiFei served as a member of the Board of Supervisors of the City of San Francisco. In fact, she eventually became the President of that Board. Does that Board sound familiar to you? It should, especially if you are a student of history or at least have seen the Oscar-winning film Milk . You see, DiFei served with Harvey Milk and Dan White, two other famous Supervisors of San Francisco. On November 27, 1978, Dan White shot Harvey Milk and the Mayor of San Francisco, George Moscone. DiFei found Harvey Milks body. And she did the brave act of announcing to the world that George Moscone and Harvey Milk had been shot, meeting their demise at the end of a gun barrel.

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   Neale Osborn    13 years ago

I watched the whole thing- in 1995, when I was busy opposing the Bill Clinton Ugly Gun Ban and last week. Say what you want about DiFi, she does not want us to have the same rights SHE was so quick to turn to. I have never followed Breitbart, I don't watch ANY of the mainstream media including Fox, CNN, ABC, CBS,NBC, or MSNBC very often. and I NEVER accept anything they say as gospel. I read the record. The record is why I was against both Obama AND McCain. THe record is why I was against Obama AND Romney. And the record is why I KNOW what Feinstein wants. I believe you. Yo do not want more than what you consider "reasonable". You, AMac, would never push for total ban of firearms. And you are a good soul, so you tend to think the best of everyone. Hell, you see a good side to me! But you do not see the bad in people who are putatively on your side. It is a common human failing. We never want to see the bad side of fellow travelers. Diane Feinstein opposes the 2nd Amendment despite having turned to it in her time of need. So seeing her get schooled, seeing her admit her hypocrisy, those are things I enjoyed. As you would enjoy seeing Rush get trashed over something.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

But you do not see the bad in people who are putatively on your side. It is a common human failing. We never want to see the bad side of fellow travelers.

For 16+ years I made a good living representing '"the good, the bad and the ugly" at adverse action hearings and arbitrations." I saw first hand and hundreds of times the bad side of both some I represented and some who brought charges against those I represented.

I cannot read what's in a person's heart; but I can read what they post in a document, and with politicians, what they propose in writing, "ON-THE-RECORD" as we say, is all I can read.

It troubles me when a video or document is clipped or edited in such a way as to portray it FOR WHAT IT IS NOT. This is the case with the clipped video and the fact that Feinstein never called for a ban on ALL weapons, never introduced a bill calling for that - but that's the lie trying to be sold by the various right-wing sources running the same clip and same false information.

Feinstein may or may not be a hypocrite in one respect or another, but to portray her as such via a LIE puts any/all adverse comments about her in suspicion.

The reason I raised the birther issue regarding Cruz was to show him to be an unreliable source for truth; because he questioned Obama's citizenship when his own citizenship could be wrongly questioned in the same manner, verifies on at least one count, HIS HYPOCRISY.

When I had a defense to make, if I could DOCUMENT a flaw in the individual making an allegation, and/or in the allegation itself, I went at it mercilessly. The SOURCE of an allegation has at minimum the requirement of satisfying a burden-of-proof and, if his credibility in similar instances can be viably challenged, as a SOURCE, he is vulnerable.

 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   Neale Osborn    13 years ago

Questioning Obama's birth is not a sign of unreliability. I happen to be VERY reliable. And NO, I still do not accept Obama's story. his own grandmother said he was born in Kenya, his own bio in the back of one of his first books said he was Kenyan born, and his refusal to provide a Birth Certificate for over 2 years, when it should have been so easy to shut us up shows me he couldn't. The BC shown is from a hospital that didn't exist for 4 years after his birth. The SSN he uses belongs to a dead man, according to some sources.

I ACCEPT that unless we get a smoking gun (time stamped video os his mother leaving the hospital in Kenya, displaying her newborn son MIGHT be enough to end debate) the topic is now a waste of time. I fully expect, sometime in the 15-20 years after he leaves office, for him to admit the truth in order to set a precedent for overturning the requirement. And I'm not sure that won't be a good idea. But I do not believe he qualifies for the post he holds UNDER THE LAW AS IT STANDS TODAY. Though it doesn't seem to matter any more.

As a reminder to all- I like Mac, I think he is one of the most honorable men I have dealt with here on the internet. I may be philosophically opposed to him in some areas, but I trust him and will NEVER dismiss his views even if I believe him wrong. I have been proud to call him friend for well over 2 years now.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

his own bio in the back of one of his first books said he was Kenyan born

That bio was placed in error, but Breitbart et al ran with it anyway.

7287_discussions.png ...

A possible source of the so-called "birther" issue--or at least a potential cause of the rumors that have dogged President Barack Obama--has been identified.

Obama's former literary agency misidentified his birthplace as Kenya while trying to promote the then-Harvard Law grad as an author in 1991.

According to a promotional booklet produced by the agency, Acton & Dystel, to showcase its roster of writers, Obama was "born in Kenya and raised in Indonesia and Hawaii."

Miriam Goderich edited the text of the bio; she is now a partner at the Dystel & Goderich agency, which lists Obama as one of its current clients.

"This was nothing more than a fact checking error by me--an agency assistant at the time," Goderich wrote in an emailed statement to Yahoo News. "There was never any information given to us by Obama in any of his correspondence or other communications suggesting in any way that he was born in Kenya and not Hawaii. I hope you can communicate to your readers that this was a simple mistake and nothing more."

A copy of the booklet was published on Breitbart.com , under the headline: " Obama's Literary Agent in 1991 Booklet: 'Born in Kenya and raised i... It was part of the "vetting" of the president the site's late founder, Andrew Breitbart, had promised.

NOTE: Thanks for the kind words Neale. Friends can disagree without being disrespectful or disagreeable.
 
 
 
Neale Osborn
Freshman Silent
link   Neale Osborn    13 years ago

Whattaya mean, you old fart? (Grins evilly limps away slowly, laughing maniacally. Halfway into the escape, forgets why he's running)

Again with the Breatbart. Is he who "broke" that story? I thought he died before it broke?!? Well, either way, the point is doubt exists. At least for many of us. keep in mind, I do not believe that we'll ever know UNLESS Obama personally 'fesses up after he leaves office. I would be far happier if Obama just failed to get any more of his agenda passed in the next three years, then goes on to follow in Jimmy Carter's footsteps and do good to make up for being a crappy president. Grin.gif once he leaves, I just hope America is so tired of the Democrat/Republican screwing of America we pick ANY other party to put in his place.

 
 
 
Eric
Freshman Silent
link   Eric    13 years ago

It used to be an offense here to create a public disturbance but the idiots on the courts thought that was an infringement on the first amendment. You see, we are not so bound by liberty that we can't kill an enemy during a war because it violates his rights but lunacy begins one second after the declaration of peace and he continues unabated in his behavior while you must suffer it without recourse but to protest. I suggest people start getting their list of bad things out and looking at how many have died that you could be free of them before you call in the liberty blanket to cover up those deeds.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

I'm going to put this out there one more time in the hope of generating actual "thought."

Those who insist that the 2nd Amendment be taken literally and without interpretation or room for gun-related regulations as would apply to 2013, I offer the following:

The ratified language of the 2nd Amendment states thus

A well regulated militia being necessary to the security of a free state, the right of the people to keep and bear arms shall not be infringed.

"Keep" and "Bear." Not one word about "shoot."

So let's hypothetically challenge those who take this to "mean," to "imply" -- TO BE INTERPRETED TO MEAN, "Keep and bear and shoot" arms."

My challenge is this; if one accepts the idea that shooting a firearm is a right under the language of the Second Amendment, DESPITE THE FACT THAT THERE IS NO SUCH STIPULATION IN THAT LANGUAGE, THEN I CHALLENGE THAT INDIVIDUAL(s) TO MOUNT A REASONABLE ARGUMENT AGAINST THE IDEA THAT IT MUST ALSO BE ACCEPTED THAT OTHER NON-STIPULATED PROVISOS BE ALLOWED -- provisos regarding regulations such as universal background checks, magazine capacity restrictions, etc. .

One cannot have it both ways.

If arms can be discharged without specific constitutional language to that effect, if common sense implies that premise, then common sense must also logically imply THE NEED FOR CERTAIN REGULATIONS PARTICULARLY THOSE THAT ADDRESS SAFETY AND THE PROTECTION OF INNOCENT LIVES -- albeit no such 2nd Amendment language stipulates that.

________________________________

I request that my challenge be addressed directly and specifically. No attacking the messenger, no rhetoric my argument is clear and specific. I invite rebuttals and serious debate.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Were the bearers intended to hit people over the head with their guns?

So then you agree that interpretation of the Amendment is acceptable?

Exactly the point of my challenge; that which is not stipulated can be logically implied. "Arms" being inherently lethal and dangerous (as pertaining to the innocent) if/when imprudently, if not illegally discharged, implies that some forms of regulation be applied.

And the issue in not about shooting, rather about allowing for reasonable interpretation in the absence of a proviso.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

I think the position that no regulation is allowed is held by a very small number of people.

And those would be the ones to whom my challenge is leveled.

However, there is no regulation that opens the gates automatically, allowing ANY regulation because one was allowed. Such as, 'we prohibit speech which calls for the killing of president, therefore we can prohibit any speech."

I do not imply that just ANY regulation for regulation's sake is the issue -- I used the word "reasonable". And I think your speech analogy is backwards ... it should state i.e. "Not all forms of speech are protected by the Constitution libel, slander, terroristic threats, et al are not while others are. You went from a specific single prohibition to a generality. Logically, I think you begin with the general rule then stipulate the exceptions.

The constitutional right is the reference. Not the prohibition. A proposed prohibition is not automatically reasonable, and not automatically constitutional, just because another might have been.

I believe I made that clear; the 2nd Amendment stipulates specific rights and only implies others -- I'm positing consistency in the need to infer what is only (if at all) implied in "the right to keep and bear."

That is why the DC laws were overturned by the SC.

However

The DC law banned The Court of Appeals had struck down provisions of the Firearms Control Regulations Act of 1975 as unconstitutional, determined that handguns are "arms" for the purposes of the Second Amendment , found that the District of Columbia's regulations act was an unconstitutional banning, and struck down the portion of the regulations act that requires all firearms including rifles and shotguns be kept "unloaded and disassembled or bound by a trigger lock ." "Prior to this decision the Firearms Control Regulation Act of 1975 also restricted residents from owning handguns except for those registered prior to 1975." [ 5 ]

But there was more

Scalia's opinion for the majority provided 2nd Amendment protection for commonly used and popular handguns but not for atypical arms or arms that are used for unlawful purposes such as short-barreled shotguns.

Scalia stated: "Whatever the reason, handguns are the most popular weapon chosen by Americans for self-defense in the home, and a complete prohibition of their use is invalid." "We think that Millers ordinary military equipment language must be read in tandem with what comes after: [O]rdinarily when called for [militia] service [able-bodied] men were expected to appear bearing arms supplied by themselves and of the kind in common use at the time. 307 U. S., at 179." "We therefore read Miller to say only that the Second Amendment does not protect those weapons not typically possessed by law-abiding citizens for lawful purposes, such as short-barreled shotguns." "It may be objected that if weapons that are most useful in military service M-16 rifles and the like may be banned, then the Second Amendment right is completely detached from the prefatory clause. But as we have said, the conception of the militia at the time of the Second Amendments ratification was the body of all citizens capable of military service, who would bring the sorts of lawful weapons that they possessed at home to militia duty." [ 73 ]

So clearly, INTERPRETATION is a validated phenomenon re:the 2nd Amendment.

 
 
 
Eric
Freshman Silent
link   Eric    13 years ago

The purpose of owning a gun to remain free requires it not be fired ? What "actual thought" did it take to come up with that Idea?

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

The purpose of owning a gun to remain free requires it not be fired ? What "actual thought" did it take to come up with that Idea?

You either intentionally by-pass my question or don't understand it.

The issue in not whether arms may be fired, it's how the language of the Constitution fails to stipulate it and consequently, because it is implied rather than stipulated, other aspects of the 2nd Amendment are also subject to interpretations as to what may additionally be implied.

Now that the "actual thought" has been reiterated for you, possibly you'll address the idea of interpreting on a consistent basis, that which may reasonably questioned/interpreted in the 2nd Amendment and the legal process for doing so.

 
 
 
Eric
Freshman Silent
link   Eric    13 years ago

The problem you have is you're misconstruing the intent of the constitution. What is enumerated in it are the powers delegated to the government. Did the founders want government control over arms ? No. They rightly viewed government as a necessary evil and giving it control over the public's arms would be suicidal. The reading of the tenth amendment should clarify the rights of the people remain with them unless they grant specific parts to the states. The second amendment does exactly that.

If you doubt that then look up the NY Constitution of 1777 ; " XL. And whereas it is of the utmost importance to the safety of every State that it should always be in a condition of defence; and it is the duty of every man who enjoys the protection of society to be prepared and willing to defend it; this convention therefore, in the name and by the authority of the good people of this State, doth ordain, determine, and declare that the militia of this State, at all times hereafter, as well in peace as in war, shall be armed and disciplined, and in readiness for service."

To discern what might be a proper check on arms one must refer to the qualifications to be a militia member. All able bodied men aged ... has been the standard. Since NY has had five Constitutions of which the latest is nothing more than a perfection of class rule I suggest reading all of them before implying there is some other limit on ones right to protect himself from tyranny, like which is pubescent in NY.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Mike wrote,

When the time comes to "fire a gun in defense of Freedom", none of the other laws will matter anymore, including the nuances of the Second Amendment.

"The time for war has not yet come, but it will come, and that soon; and when it does come, my advice is to draw the sword and throw away the scabbard" -Thomas Jackson

No argument; but shooting 154 rounds in 5 minutes into 6-year-olds and their teachers is not an act performed in the "defense of Freedom." Consequently, prior to such time/if any, the application of the law is implemented in "the defense of Freedom," what does the law imply about protecting the lives and FREEDOMS of innocent children and their families?

In a so-called "Nation of Laws," what metaphorical "sword" and scabbard" does the parent of a child shot 11 times at close range have to draw and discard if not a judicial system and populace that understands the distinctions and implications prior to "The time for war (which) has not yet come?

That's where I am, Mike.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

The problem you have is you're misconstruing the intent of the constitution.

That then implies that it is subject to interpretation which is why we have a judicial system; the implementation of laws are frequently in dispute.

The reading of the tenth amendment should clarify the rights of the people remain with them unless they grant specific parts to the states. The second amendment does exactly that.

So then "States' Rights" allows for each state to implement its own gun laws.

And whereas it is of the utmost importance to the safety of every State that it should always be in a condition of defence;

As in "defense" (to whatever degree possible) against mad men who easily attain assault weapons with 30-round clips and use them to kill children?

To discern what might be a proper check on arms one must refer to the qualifications to be a militia member.

Adam Lanza et al mass murderers are/were not part of any well-regulated militia. And the children murdered by them were not part of any tyranny.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

And while I am sympathetic, why should I, a 43 year old professional, with no criminal background, and a veteran of the USMC, have my rights infringed because some crazy ass freak killed his mother and then went on a kill crazy rampage that he planned for months or years?

Law must be applied evenly; it is a condition of REALITY that even those who pose no threat to innocent individuals, abide by laws. Universal background checks for gun purchases and a restriction on ammunition-clip capacities limit your rights but do not totally abrogate them. Free societies understand the rhyme and reason of compromise, even when it comes to freedoms, which are not absolute. And, I cannot imagine, nor do I believe you can, Mike, that in an absolutely free society, soon after anarchy would not follow mayhem, chaos and eventually, the perceived realization that the human animal cannot survive with any degree of quality-of-life, without law.

"Society has the criminals it deserves." _ Emile Durkheim

___________________________________

Good debate going here, Eric, Robert G and Mike!

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

Wrong. Start with the constitution. You do not start with the prohibitions.

Disagree; the Constitution does not override laws prohibiting all sorts of behavior as it recognizes that one individual's freedoms cannot legally infringe upon those of another -- murder, theft, assault, fraud, taxation without representation law libraries are virtually endless with caveats, restrictions and outright prohibitions.

I haven't found anyone, even on NT, who believes that there should be no exceptions.

I believe regarding the 2nd Amendment, we've seen an anarchistic reference or two.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

In other words, if you are going to balance my rights, with the existence of the Adam Lanzas of the world, what laws would we have?

Since I have not asserted a contention that "laws=perfection", I would say that making it more difficult for the "Adam Lanzas" of the world to do what they do, is an ounce of prevention both philosophically and in reality.

Look at what was known (among other things) about Adam Lanza prior to Newtown

The holiday card to Mr. Lanza from his mother contained a check that specified that the money was to buy a C183 (Firearm), the documents say.

The date and amount of the check are not listed. It was not clear if the reference to C183 contained a typographical error and was intended to mean a CZ83, which is a semiautomatic handgun.

The Hartford Courant previously reported that investigators had found news articles about the Norwegian mass murderer Anders Behring Breivik in a bedroom of Mr. Lanzas. Mr. Breivik killed 77 people in two attacks in July 2011, most of them teenagers who were attending a summer camp.

How about a law that states "It shall constitute a felony when any individual aids and abets any other individual(s) having a documented history of emotional illness, anti-social and other such behaviors, in the acquisition, possession and/or use of firearms."

That wouldn't compromise your rights, Mike but it might have stopped Lanza's mother from taking him shooting, encouraging his affinity to firearms, etc. .

Some of the items taken from the home and car of Adam Lanza:

...

Source: Search warrants issued by superior court of Danbury, Conn.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

but I suspect that Adam Lanza's mother never suspected that he would use the guns available to him, to kill her, and then go on a rampage. I dare say that if she had, she would have made some different choices.

She too may have been somewhat delusional but nevertheless, she had to know that her son was no "normal" young man. Poor choices notwithstanding, some border on benign or criminal negligence, aiding and abetting. Off the top of my head, I can't think of any crimes that exemplify "good choices."

Had he gone on his rampage, without killing her, we could then do what? Prosecute her? That might bring us some measure of comfort, although I suspect, not very much.

No point in prosecuting the mother for the purpose of punishing her, BUT, I'd be very surprised if, strictly based on law, she was not guilty of some level of negligence. The point is not to prevent what's already occurred (that's not possible), but to address via law, the prevention of what future such occurrences.

Can you argue against the following in SPECIFIC TERMS?

Criminal negligence is negligence which requires a greater degree of culpability than the civil standard of negligence. The civil standard of negligence is defined according to a failure to follow the standard of conduct of a reasonable person in the same situation as the defendant.

To show criminal negligence, the state must prove beyond a reasonable doubt the mental state involved in criminal negligence. Proof of that mental state requires that the failure to perceive a substantial and unjustifiable risk that a result will occur must be a gross deviation from the standard of a reasonable person.

Criminal negligence is conduct which is such a departure from what would be that of an ordinary prudent or careful person in the same circumstance as to be incompatible with a proper regard for human life or an indifference to consequences. Criminal negligence is negligence that is aggravated, culpable or gross.

If Lanza's mother was deemed "sane," then she would also be deemed "reasonable." If not, she, herself should not have been in the (legal) possession of firearms. Take your pick, someone in that house constituted a need for smarter laws regarding gun ownership. Again, I'm not looking for perfection, just the prevention of as many lives being lost to guns as possible via intelligently written and enforced laws.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

But even as he believes that passengers on a plane have the right to have a gun, he believes that the gun should be of a certain type, and the ammunition of a certain type, to prevent damage to the structure of the plane.

Let's not deal with names, but on the above

If there are no guns (or other lethal weapons) on a plane, the possibility of shootings, stabbings, being slashed with a boxcutter, bludgeoned with a baseball bat, etc., is infinitely less likely than if any/all were permitted. Can we agree on that?

On the purpose of the constitution, you believe that the constitution should be consulted to find ways of limiting freedom.

I don't.

No, that's not what I believe it's how the laws work. That which is not stipulated, be it in law, contractual agreements, etc., is potentially subject to litigation and adjudication when a set of facts are in dispute. That's why we have a judicial system. Laws are added, redacted, amended, repealed constantly.

Even in documents/contracts/laws etc., that stipulate in great length, you will find provisos, conditions that define other conditions. It's not the Constitution that is flawed nor by beliefs about it ... it's

The quote, from Julius Caesar, Act 1, scene 2, is by Cassius:

"The fault, dear Brutus, is not in our stars,
But in ourselves, that we are underlings."

Cassius here is speaking about the stars as controllers of destiny, and expressing the idea that men themselves are responsible for their actions, not some preordained fate.

Human nature and its weakness are why we need laws, and no set of laws, not even the Constitution, can address perfectly the ways to mitigate their potential consequence upon the quality of life.

 
 
 
A. Macarthur
Professor Guide
link   A. Macarthur    13 years ago

But I just don't think we can do anything but trim around the edges of a type of criminal behavior that defies the rational mind.

If we did everything you espouse, at best, we might lower the body count, or reduce the rampages by 10%.

That means two of those children at Sandy Hook might still be alive. Ask the parents of any of the children if they'd like that. And several more at Columbine, Virginia Tech, the movie theater in Colorado pretty soon those lives start adding up.

What I can join you on, is enforcing our fucking laws as they stand, and punishing the in-bred morons that break the law with impunity.

Yup!

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    13 years ago

Guns on airplanes? Have the proponents of that lost their minds? It is reassuring to see that wisdom can still prevail in some people. Otherwise the stubborn single-mindedness of others is bound to lead towards chaos and anarchy.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    13 years ago

Where is Gort when we really need him?

7288_discussions.jpg It's pretty obvious to anyone with a modicum of wisdom that mankind is incapable of controlling itself from self-destruction.

 
 

Who is online






166 visitors