Governemnt vs Private Donations
Often bantered about is the concept that charity can be used in place of government
assistance when it comes to the poor or disaster relief. That we should rely less on government intervention and more on religious and charitableorganizationsto help during times of disaster and aiding the poor.Sounds good in theory. Less government bureaucracy, direct intervention with the people who know the victims the best, right? Well, maybe not. Human nature is such, that even charitable foundations begin toexistfor themselves and not for the benefit of those who need them the most; the ones they were supposed to serve.
$14.5 million that wasreceivedfrom around the world for the Oklahoma City bombing from private donations and was put into into Oklahoma City Disaster Relief Fund. The intent of the fund was so that there would be long term care and scholarships for thesurvivorsof the blast. Presently there is $10 million, just sitting in a disaster relief fund designed to help them. People with real needs have actually been refused the money, and told to go seek out all other possible government aid, before they will give it to these victims.
In an interview with Brian Williams, They tell us that there are all these restrictions, said Deloris Watson, whose grandson, P.J. Allen, was severely injured in the April 1995 explosion. In 2005, then-11-year-old Allen needed major surgery on his trachea. Watson, who became his sole guardian after the bombing, said the Oklahoma City Community Foundation refused to pay for the surgery directly, instead steering her toward Medicaid to cover the cost. Why would the state of Oklahoma have to take money from taxpayers when money's been donated to the bombing fund to meet the medical needs of the children? asked Watson.The Ronald McDonald House, the Red Cross and the Oklahoma City Community Foundation all pitched in to cover hospital and living expenses during Allens recovery and rehabilitation after the surgery".
This is not the only case where the charitable fund is nowexistingfor itself and not for the benefits of others and sometimes the abuses just astounding. Rev. Carl Keyes helped himself, through his church to divert money meant for 9/11 and Katrina victims to himself. When all was said and done, 13.8 million dollars from around the world was spent by Keyes.
Just like most things in life, it's are a shade of gray when it comes tocharitable donations. There are times it functions well and others times when it's as bad as many claim the government intervention is. Both need to be carefully monitored, but both are needed.
Visit NBCNews.com for #999;font-weight:normal;height:13px;color:#5799db;" href="http://www.nbcnews.com"> breaking news , #999;font-weight:normal;height:13px;color:#5799db;"> world news , and #999;font-weight:normal;height:13px;color:#5799db;"> news about the economy
Tags
Who is online
137 visitors

We need all organizations that are charitable in purpose to hold to a certain set of standards... what should these standards be?
Think Before You Donate .
Wow, Aeon! Thank you for sharing this! I have given to many of these.
Thank you Dylan for your interest in this subject. We have a member Ben, who actually lives very close to the bombing. I have to send it to him to read.
First here's a link tocharity'sexplanation:
What galls me is that they are sitting on this money and are telling people to go to the government. People gave to these victims in good faith and they are abusing good people.
Also, a good resource forcharitiesto give to, use . They rate most of the charities out there.
It all reminds me of Herbert Hoover's "thousand tiny points of light", and yes, Herbert coined the phrase before George Sr. It did no good-- Government intervention was needed to get the people out of the Great Depression.
Then, everything moved along swimmingly, until Reagan took power and dismantled all the safety nets.
sigh...
Charitable organizations can only do so much-- and I hate to say this, but many of them are more concerned with their own agendas, rather than the agenda of helping others. My own church is one of them. People are hungry and we have a drive to collect money for new hymnals? UGH.
It depends on the purpose of the fund. If it for a specific event, then the money should be used for that event, like the bombing. If it is for an on going cause, say like a disease, it should be that if they are involved in active fund raising, that the bulk of the money goes to the care of these people and that any fund put aside, is only done so to produce more money to be given outconsistently.
Great link-- and thanks for posting it!
Well put Mickey. They both have their place and we should be mindful for the good things life has brought to us and be able to think of those in need.
I agree that both government safety nets andcharitiesare needed. And I saw first hand that FEMA did help here on Long Island. I also know that there is only so much misery in this world, that we also need to take matters in our own hands and give to charities and hope that the money gets to where it belongs.
It's a crime what your church did. I guess that is one minister who doesn't believe in god.
So it's been 18 years, and there's still 10 million in the fund. Sadly, I wouldn't be surprised if the fund comptroller was skimming interest and livin' easy.
Perrie, an essential article.
Thanks Paul!
Yep, every now and then, a good charity might need a makeover , and articles like this are like sunlight.
I am delighted to give to St.Jude Children's Research Hospital, as I know my hard earned money is going directly to the best of human endeavors.
I attempt whenever possible to make my donations, whether they be of labor or a monetary nature directly to those affected. Tough to do and I wish there was a method in place to do so on a regular basis.
It is a noble thought to help through private charities, but there are instances where the scope of needs outstrips the ability to do so through the private sector. Sometimes we actually need the government to intervene.
If you read the funding policies that were put forth in the months following the attack, the idea of the funding was intended from the beginning to be a 'go last' fund. Which means that the instructions have always been to exhaust all other options prior to qualifying for this particularfund. $10 million sounds like a lot but if they simply doled the money out everytime someone demanded it, that money would have been drained in the first year or two and not available for the people who actually followed the guidelines.
I don't know all of the details of PJ Allen or any of the other victims and I suspect others here may not as well. Did the family(s) exhaust all other viable options before tapping into this one?
I'm only pointing this out because it's easy to villify an organization based on emotional input when often there is information that pertains that isn't being acknowledged.
Regarding government, Congress debated recently about funds for Hurricane Sandy victims. 50-60 billion dollar aid package that was loaded heavily with pork, unionand special interest funding that had NOTHING to do with the hurricane victims. But we don't hold anyone accountable for government funds like we do a private company. OK City disaster fund is being scrutinized over $10 million that it appears to be doling out smartly and effectively and that isn't a booger in the nose of a federal aid package that gets wasted and diverted.
Government can examine the books anytime they desire thry the GAO. I've found them to be honest to a fault. Often didn't like what they had to say about programs and decisions but they were still right dam it. Private churches and individuals are as corrupt or more so because there is no independent watchdog who acesses their operation and flag theft or inadaquacy or just poor management. As much as people bitch about Medicare and yes Doctors are caught cheating the system.Medicare isstill has more affordable care and the cheaters are caught and prosecuted.
Churches are presently in many cases barely able to take care of repair on their own buildings more or less take care of any catastrophy in the community other than take donations then the real possibility of the money being syphoned off for personal use is far greater than in a government system. Letting corporations watchdog themselves does not work little company big Corporation or yes even the Church.
Obviously your link has some problems with it, Aeon. First of all Goodwill. Yeah, they pay nothing for their products, but I can tell you, they TRAIN and EMPLOY the disabled. 82% of their donations go to training and education programs. Knowing that, I have to question the rest of the link.
Yet, I do agree, to think before I donate
If you read the funding policies that were put forth in the months following the attack, the idea of the funding was intended from the beginning to be a 'go last' fund. Which means that the instructions have always been to exhaust all other options prior to qualifying for this particularfund. $10 million sounds like a lot but if they simply doled the money out everytime someone demanded it, that money would have been drained in the first year or two and not available for the people who actually followed the guidelines.
I don't know all of the details of PJ Allen or any of the other victims and I suspect others here may not as well. Did the family(s) exhaust all other viable options before tapping into this one?
Sounds like the funding policies were set up to keep the money away from the very people who needed quick and available aid. 14.5 million and they have 10 million of the donations left. It sounds to me like a scam set up to pay those in carge for managing and keep the maximum amount of the money in the coffers to insure the fund could support those who manage it rather than give it to those who were in need. Eighteen years later over 70 percent of the money was not given to those it was intended to help. Fraud these pirates who try to justify their very existance deny the money to those who needed it the worst. Fine examples where donations are just a way to give crooks a cush everlasting job. Prosecute the worthless human beings and the Lawyers who set up the dupe the public scam pretending to help those in urgent need. What they have and are doing is inexcusable.
My church has a large tract of property that is mown and kept nice. I suggested a community garden for those who live in apartments-- it could be done very easily, at a very low cost to the church, AND, it would provide fresh foods for the poor. No dice-- they don't wish to attract those elements to the church.
This is in my hometown, not where I live. The whole mega-church concept is an anathema to me... They are talking out of both sides of their mouths, and it makes me furious! But, since I don't even live there, I can't do much to 'fix' it.
I've seen 1st hand what the Red Cross does, and they were life-savers when my hometown was hit by a tornado. They came in and fixed food for everyone in my mother's neighborhood that was hungry and without power, and offered places to wash their clothes, gave vouchers to those who lost everything for clothing, etc. So, yeah, I don't always approve of everything they do-- but they try, too.
Goodwill does offer education and training for unskilled labor. My sister-in-law worked there for a while, until, with her illness, she became threatening, and was fired. I take a lot of things to them, but I also send items to the DAV and the School for the Blind, which is a local charity.
Goodfellows is another good charity, local to my hometown. I send them $ at Christmas in my father's name. When he was a boy in the depression, they gave him a warm winter coat and an orange. 100% of the money that goes to Goodfellows goes to the poor in my hometown, which is a once a year charity, manned by volunteers.
We all have to be careful with our charity dollars, and it is important that we all help when and where we can. The homeless are the ones that need so much help.
I well remember the homeless WWI vets that sat on the sidewalk in front of Kresge's and Newberry's, without hands, blind, selling pencils. Those poor men broke my heart. How in the HELLO they ended up on the street, I don't know, but our government should have taken care of these disabled vets.
Absolutely! By strict definition, all vets are "takers", and that's not right. We all know better than that. Not to mention the retired persons who depend on Social Security for their income, or a large part of their income-- Money that they paid into for 40 years...
Yes, there are those who abuse the system. Catch the abuse and stop it... but there are many people who are deserving of help, and help THEM. And don't be so dismissive of them!
Ok, and that was never the intention of this particular fund. If you donated money to this fund under the illusion that it was going to get streamlined to the first person who asked for it, then you were either misinformed or you misunderstood what you were donating to.
Luckily the world doesn't operate on how things "sound" to you. If I donate money to a charity that says that the money will be used specifically in accordance with A, B and C and then people like you come in and demand that the money just go to whoever yells the loudest for it or whoever has the most heart breaking story, then why would I donate any more money to that charity? Why do you have such a problem with a charity spending the money exactly as they promised they would since day one?
Did you donate your money to this group with a different expectation? Or are you just making empty, emotional demands of something that you have no investment, personal or financial, in?
since obama took office, irs audits of charities have increased by 70%
just a coincidence, of course.
Much of the information in your link has been debunked by Snopes, AP.
I would encourage people to not take things like the above at face value and do their own research, as this type of propaganda serves only to take donations out of the hands of well meaning...and highly efficientcharities.
Dylan, it seems, as Perrie pointed out, that this charitable organization has begun to exist for itself. I surfed the net and found the following..
The Oklahoma City Community Foundation Website , which is nice, but looks more like a Goldman Sachs bullet point presentation than a specifically targeted community relief fund. At the top of that page is this...
Oklahoma City Community Foundation Statement Regarding March 1, 201... , a lawyerspeak boilerplate of meandering deflection and denial, and from that is this quote..
I have underlined the pertinent subject matter, as it would give the fund a validreason to have sent the grandmother to Medicade, etc., for the funding for her grandsons surgery, but nowhere in the IRS link could I find specific language directing the fund to do such a thing. If anyone else can find such specific language as claimed by OCCF, please point it out.
So, as it stands now, I see a fund that, although it claims to have provided much relief, has actually become a self-sustaining corporate entity that exists to fund its directors, and has morphed into a scholarship fund(noble initself)that does not directlyaid the victims of the bombing for whom the fund was originally formed.
Which begs the questions...
What was the wording/language in the original public appeals for donations to the fund?
Would normal, compassionate human beings who wanted to help, have gotten the impression that their donations would go directly and immediately to victims of the bombing?
I don't have the link but it wasn't hard to find a pdf of the very letter they put outin early 1996 describing the efforts and it's intent which is what I based my reaction here on.
That is the difference between someone who seeks to understand a situtation vs. those who react with what their gut tells them. It's not clever to read about PJ Allen and get upset and then start making ignorant demands. Anyone can do that. But some need to realize that when the outrage is this obvious, there is probably another side to the story and the truth is always more important then our own feel-good misplaced sense of seeking justice that leads us to slander good people and organziations that are doing what they are suppose to do (vs. what we think they should do in our utopian minds).
Hey, Egilman! Love you, too!
I'm at work and don't have a lot of time to spend, but here is an article in the Electronic Journal of Sociology about the mental health and homeless, and here is an article from the NHI about the homeless. Here is just a normal article in Yahoo about Reagan's paradoxyl shift in attitudes towards the poor.
Well, it's a start... I'll keep looking!
This goes back to 2002 following the WTC attack. Rudy Giuliani created the Twin Towers Fund to benefit the families of firefighters, cops and Port Authority police. Rudy wanted to spend more than $1 million of the $150 million raised on administrative costs. From the NYT: Twin Towers Fund officials projected an annual administrative budget of $1.16 million to $2.25 million, including a salary for the fund's president, Laurence A. Levy, of $175,000 to $250,000. Other salaries range from $30,000 for a receptionist to $150,000 for a finance director.
Rudy quickly changed up after the story appeared. But what some may not know is that the families agreed not to go forward with a legal challenge against Giuliani on $15 million the charity raised on its own. He used the death of rescuers to grab $15 million for what?
What I would like to review are the original public appeals to donate to this fund, especially television appeals.The big wording and imagery would be the primary contact with manypotential donors, and they would give because of that,not having reviewed all the lawyerly fine print. Perhaps, because of this, they would be disappointed in the evolution of this fund, and perhaps feel as though they were misled concerning the immediacy of fund tasking and disbursements.
Hmmm. I was kind of hoping that the person who posted the link that slammed these great charities would come back and at least acknowledge that it was an untruthful link that could do some serious damage to some high integrity charities. Especially after 3 people took it at face value.
I guess I was expecting too much. After 3 hours...not a peep.
Boudicea,
There is another good source to find out if the charity is good.. I posted it on top, but here it is again:
Ok, except I don't think it's the donors that are making the fuss. It's the people who want the money. So I'm not sure what the relevance is as to whatthe public appeals were. So who is "they" as in "they would be disappointed"?
I see JoAnne's point...I think, and would add that despite the increase of audits of charities, there has NOT been an increase in prosecutions of those agencies.
I was looking for unbiased links, as much as possible. The NIH, isn't that the National Institute of Health? That has a political agenda? I mean, I'm not quoting Rush Limbaugh or Keith Oberman...
I was looking for articles that were as unbiased as possible. Promise!
It is relevant in that, if the original public appeals had a "sense" to them that the donors would interpret as theywere contributing to a fund that would provide immediate relief to the affected, and the fund was instead a corporate entity with complete control over disbursements, they might feel a tad defrauded, i.e., disappointed.
And there you have it.
There is a need for both, and both should have heavy oversight. Many charities are nothing more than tax shelters. On the other hand, for manyacrossthe nation, local charities are the life line for thousands. Huge disasters need both the government and charitable donation, for sure.
So, they are legit. Good!
The GAO is pretty tough-- and fair. I would trust them to do a good job.
They investigated a geologist I knew, once, and "got him", good. He needed "getting".
I don't believe that was the case when thegovernorwas alive. That became the case afterwards. Furthermore, I don't think that the people who donated to these people (which first went to the red cross), thought that it would end up in such a fund. In times of emergencies, people give for immediate care, and not for applying to the government first.
Once again, the money was donated first to these people and then this foundation was set up by thegovernor Most people would not have donated to these people if they thought it was going to support a foundation.
Well I am a big fan of line item bills, to get rid of the pork. And being a Long Islander, who has seen first hand the suffering that Sandy brought us, I am damn pissed at using an aid package to fund pork and holding up much needed aid because of it.
Quite true.
Being an accountant who defends people from audits, I can tell you that there is so much more abuse of charitable organizations than I can possibly state here. Hence why this story caught my attention.
Oh, I know. Right now I have friends who were first responders, and have hardly gotten a dime from that fund. It's a horror to see these brave men suffering, and not getting the proper care that they could be getting if they had assistance from the fund.
Sure, but this isn't sprung from donors feeling defrauded. This is a result of a victim of the bombing not being happy with what they were told. So again,I fail to see the relevance. The information that the fund put out at the time described itself as a "go last" charity which explains why they had such a relatively small amount of money to dole out in the first place. If they followed the recipe that Allen or hisguardians are demanding, that money would have been gone long, long ago and there wouldn't evenbe anything to fight over today.
Fair enough. Was this information obvious in the original public appeals? If it was not obvious (small print legalese), or released after the original public appeals,then the corporate entity would have collected a tidy chunk of change based on insufficient information. If for example, the information above was obvious, perhaps many donors would have elected to donate elsewhere. I, for one, if fully informed of the "go last" paradigm, would not have donated, since disaster reliefhas a different meaning for me.
On a general note related to this discussion, here is much information at Tulsa World , chock full o' links to even more information. The more information, the better.
Well, you would know-- a lot more than I would! But, it doesn't surprise me.
It would appear to me that the original concept was to do just what they are doing which is milking the money and Morphing the fund into a prive life sustaining income. They set it up that way and nothing short of a miss placed drone will dislodge the funds to be spent for good in any appreciable amount.
Makes you leary on donating to anything not government controlled. Kind of like giving to Social Security and then Politicians want to steal even more. Top 1% has tried to get directly into the Social Securityfund thru the internet which would give Wall Street a chance to milk it dry.
Now, that thought is scary...
Egilman, the Shriners Hospitals for Children , outstanding!
Sorry Perrie. Some how I missed the email and the post in the group.
I go within a few blocks of The OKC Bombing Memorial ever time I have a VA appointment. My first Veteran'sadviserwas killed in the blast; my Wife and my Great-Aunt were supposed to be there that morning and barely missed the bombing. So, yes, I am close to it.
As for this issue, it has been in our local news for some time. The charity has stated that their first priority is to insure there are funds for the LIFE of those individuals who will need constant care.
This makes a certain amount of sense, but the group has been refusing scholarships to the effected children also.
There has been an audit and everything seems "lawful." Still, the group has been trying to divert funds to education about terrorism (at the OKC Bombing Memorial) and issues have been raised that this activity may not be legal.
I tended to tilt in favor of the families who have been refused the funds. Yet, I do know that there are a number of people who were effected by this tragic event. $14 million is not really a lot of money for the number effected: 30 children wereorphanedand 219 more lost at least one parent, plus 500 people were injured.That is 249 eligible for college/vo-tech scholarships and 500 eligible for life time care for those injuries. That is a whole lot of money......