US supreme court leans towards striking part of Voting Rights Act
The US supreme court appeared to be leaning toward striking down cornerstone civil rights legislation that has protected African Americans' right to vote for half a century during a combative hearing on Wednesday.
The justices clashed over whether discrimination is still an issue with one, Antonin Scalia, deriding the legislation under dispute as "perpetuation of racial entitlement". They also disagreed over whether it is for Congress or the courts to decide whether measures that discourage or diminish minority votes require federal intervention.
The case was brought by an Alabama county which argued that the state is being singled out by a provision in the 1965 Voting Rights Act, widely regarded as one of the most important pieces of US civil rights legislation, that subjects states with a history of disenfranchising black people, mostly in the south, to US Justice Department oversight of their election laws and procedures . - http://www.guardian.co.uk/law/2013/feb/27/supreme-court-strike-down-voting-rights-act
The exchange between the justices and the justices and the lawyers is interesting. Scalia was predictable as his conservative and Sotomayor as her liberal jurisprudence. The court is indeed very divided on this issue.
Tags
Who is online
106 visitors

I read this the other day. I think it's interesting merely because none of the Civil Rights Legislation to ever come before the SCOTUS was ever decided on anything other than the Commerce Clause. IMHO, the jury is still out, so to speak. While the end result of the legislation may, in fact, anger many, I believe there is a good possibility that these laws DO violate the Constitution and have since their inception.
It is important to remember that the MOST important job of the SCOTUS is upholding the Constitution - which means that we can't look at the end result, we have to look at the laws themselves. People in this country have a tendency to have heart failure at what they perceive to be EVIL SCOTUS overturning a law that they think is "good" instead of looking at the big picture. In the end, laws cannot violate the Constitution. And if the end result of overturning a law is something society just cannot abide, we do have the option of a Constitutional Amendment.
But, every single piece of Civil Rights legislation ever enacted somehow infringes on the rights of others. Two wrongs cannot ever make a right.
You can't legislate morality, and the Civil Rights legislation is morality legislation. The Constitution guarantees the rights of the minority - and sometimes that is (appallingly) the right of the bigoted, racist minority. There is a Constitutional right to be stupid, and bigoted and racist. I'm sorry, but that is reality.
P.S. Where did anyone ever say that the rights guaranteed by the Constitution have to be morally correct (as perceived at this point in time)
That is ridiculous. Nobody in this day and age is trying to prevent black people from voting. Get real.
Think Antonin Scalia needs a history lesson? He calls the Voting Rights Act an entitlement. His father, Salvatore Eugene Scalia, was an immigrant from Sicily who came to America in search of a better life. Scalia, the elder, must have taken advantage of all the entitlementsaccorded an uneducated man new to the US. According to Antonin, he father was an untutored" (man) who become a college professor.
Scalia is a severe, demanding,bellicose man who thinks he is more brilliant than the other Supremes. He has taken SCOTUS to a new low, ignoring the intent of law, interpreting rules narrowly based on his Catholicism. Scalia parses and nitpicks the Constitution. Heres hoping the rest of the court will rein in this toad who is contemptuous ofprecedent (what our Founding Fathers wrote), and a judicial zealot.
@Bruce Tarleton
And, that is the crux of the case. Jim Crow laws(states) kept African-Americans from voting with a slew of laws--poll taxes, guessing how many beans were in a jar,threats by the KKK?
In 2012, NC GOPers redistricted then "stacked and packed" blacks into 1 or 2 districts to dilute voting power. There were Repub poll watchers who challenged people based on what they looked like(older, frail women who grew up under Jim Crow). Right-wing astroturf groups went through cemeteries and death records, hoping to purge the voting rolls.
Black or white felons have the right to vote in NC once they have served their time, finished their parole and probation. Eighteen return the vote like NC.
Scalia got a pass during his selection hearings. The senators had just gone through an absolutely bruising hearing that allowed Rehnquist to become the chief justice. They were tired and not willing to go through another battle again so soon. What a mistake that was eh?
Fly:
I had Scalia as a professor, he was on the DC Circuit at the time. As much as I didn't think all that much of him, no one, no one, can dispute his intelligence. Period.
This has become a game for so many, when SCOTUS rules against their issue, they are political hacks, when they rule for their issue, they are brilliant jurists. Just means that SCOTUS is doing their job.
It must be galling to many that SCOTUS is not sycophantically ruling the way they believe it should.
Scalia was approved by the senate 98-0. Nobody is that good. The senate didn't do it's job
The guy is bright for sure, but his thinking belongs in a different century.... somewhere around the dark-ages would be a good fit.
@Bruce;
Good post, so many, including myself, forget this.
What part of "If it's in the Constitution they have to follow it" don't you understand? John, just because you're so all about "fairness" doesn't mean you're friggin right. Case in point - you believe right now that you are right and all the SCOTUS justices are wrong if they overturn this law. Well guess what? The Constitution does NOT guarantee fairness for everybody. It SPECIFICALLY is there to protect rights of all people, but not FAIRNESS
Boud:
They're fricking asshats.
Like their railing against Citizens United, how the "right wing whackos on the Court" blah, blah, blah, blah.
Totally ignoring (even when TOLD and LINKED) that the ENTIRE COURT, ALL NINE JUSTICES AGREED THAT CORPORATIONS ARE COVERED BY THE RIGHT TO THE FREEDOM OF SPEECH FOUND IN THE FIRST AMENDMENT!
Bunch of hard wired ignorant twerps, who steadfastly fight each day to remain ignornat.
Fly:
Huh? Not sure what you mean. Is there some test that a SCOTUS nominee has to take so as to be "that good?"
Here's a cool site. Note, Kennedy was 97-0 and that leftist weirdo Ginsberg was 97 to 3. CLEARLY folks didn't want to slam her because she was, we believe, female.
...
Even cooler, goes ALL the way back!
Note, some "were that good." Look how contentious it was earlier on in our history.
As to his thinking, well, it's not metrosexual, pants around your ankles thinking, will grant you that. It's more "what did the Founders believe and what does the Constitution say" thinking, and how should it apply to today's circumstances (including pants around ankles metrosexuals).
I disagree with Scalia on many issues, but his reasoning is always, ALWAYS spot on, one cannot ignore that.
Wait, I take that back, ALL biased hacks ignore that!
Note, not including you in that grouping! Though there are many on this site, ....
Well, that's for another day.
John,
If someone was wronged in the first place by these so-called discriminatory laws, they can file a lawsuit, perhaps a Class Action Suit to get these laws put before the SCOTUS to actually get a ruling striking them down as UnConstitutional. One UnConstitutional law does not make it right or even necessary to pass another UnConstitutional law to counter it. All it requires is someone taking what they perceive as an UnConstitutional law and challenging it in court. Granted it may take years, but that is what the court system is mainly there for at the Federal level. Determining the legality of laws based on their Constitutionality.
Just look at that list. Who would have thought, today,that Thurgood Marshall would only have 11 people voting against making him a Justice? Who would have thought that 26 would have voted against Rehnquist to become a Justice and 33 against him being Chief Justice? To me, those were two of the best Justices we ever had.
I read something about this yesterday. I thought it had something to with certain counties in the south.
As long as they are not going to eliminate the vote for the people in this country I have no issue on what they do or not do?
John,
In My Humble Opinion, Boudicea is correct. This is not an issue of right/wrong or moral/immoral, its a matter of Just or Unjust, under the US Constitution. The Court is rightfully and legitimately looking at the constitutionality of the Voting Rights Act itself, or at least the conservative leaning justices are.
The Voting Rights Act , a bill passed by congress and signed into law by the President, has never been the object of Judicial Review by SCOTUS, meaning no one has ever challenged the constitutionality of the law. The Supreme Court cannot just cant go through the law books willy-nilly and pick a law to review. It must be presented to the court as a bona fide legal challenge.
Cases, like this, are decided by constitutional merit, regardless of the good or bad effect they have had. In this page Im linking to from the SCOTUS website, The Court and Constitutional Interpretation it states, in part;
Nowhere is good or bad a factor in making these decisions.
May I remind you, Roe v. Wade was not about abortion, it was about a womans right to privacy, and so to, with this case, it may very well affect laws it was not intended to.
Be careful what you wish for, you may get it.
@Boudicea:
In the fevered imagination of many there is. Even though evidence shows that minorities are not only voting, in some instances they are voting five and six times!
Actually, other blacks were keeping blacks from voting in Philadelphia, but the Obama Justice Department dropped the investigation for the most part.
Voter ID laws are not measures to prevent people from voting.They're about getting the vote accurate and legal. Think about Chicago, every year we hear about how the dead vote in that city aloneabout 10 times each. If that is the case, why shouldn't a person be asked to verify they are who they claim? Why not allow the actual living be the ones who determine how an election turn out. Also, no one has the right to vote more than once. If that is going to be the case, might as well run an online poll for elections instead of going to polling places.
Then if you feel like that is the case, then challenge the Voter ID laws in federal court or convince someone to do so once those laws go into effect. That's what the Federal Court system is there for.
Whites do the same thing to.
Haha Bruce.
Although I do agree that morality cannot be legislated, equality for all(some being more equal than others)is the cornerstone of our Nation.
I would like to think that we have transcended Jim Crow and the like, but of lateI am not so sure. Myself, I believe it is still a work in progress.
You are correct, generally speaking. It's a lot more complex than that though. - Voting rights in the United States - For example, the Nineteenth Amendment does not specifically state women can vote but it says no one can be denied the right to vote because of their gender.
The right to vote is decided state by state. Felons can't vote in West Virginia, I believe, as well in some other states. But, no state can prevent the voting of minorities by race or color. So, your argument that a state can say "no nigras allowed to vote" is BS.
Just read the 15th Amendment:
well you might be right about redistricting in NC, but in Pennsylvania, there is a 5 member commission who handles the redistricting comprised of minority and majority leaders in senate and in House with a fifth member decided by the other four. So, you can't really blame a particular PARTY in Pennsylvania. Also, if you think redistricting is so easy, try this:
Just in case you were under the misguided notion that you can do whatever you want to draw districts
Excellent points AeonPax. I love this in particular:
Cases, like this, are decided by constitutional merit, regardless of the good or bad effect they have had.
@Aeon, yeah, but only if they're democrats!
And lets not forget something - some women HAD the right to vote up until the early 1800's.
@Aeon:
Damn, does that mean all the other genders can vote now?
I see. Would you like that I should post news articles about GOP voter fraud or would you be willing to compromise and say, it's not the problem the that it's painted out to be?
wmolaw yea you and Thomas seem to have a lot in common. You think he is brilliant as well I take it? Scalia is worse than Renquist and that is saying something. Scalia and Thomas are like two peas in a pod.
There is a BIG difference between being able to articulate your position well, which Scalia does, however, when it comes to his jurisprudence , that is extremely subjective and open for criticism. Amongst his legal peers, many would take exception to his "legal" reasoning.
Take one of his infamous decisions, his affirmative vote on the "Citizens United" case. In defending his decision he said; "To separate speech and money" , he said, was utterly impossible. - He has been taken to task concerning his legal logic in this case by scores in regards to this case. As a author for the New York Times put it;
I'm not into hero worship nor into the convoluted ideology of people who place Supreme Court Justice Antonin Scalia on some false pedestal.
Boudicea,
Here is an excellent example of a legal idea that went terribly wrong; the Eighteenth Amendment. In this case. congress didn't just pass a law which could have been challenged on court, it amended the US Constitution, meaning it became part of it. Because of the separation of powers, not even SCOTUS could touch it.
We all know how that turned out. It required another amendment, Twenty-first Amendment, to repeal it. It had the best of intentions but was very short sighted.
I support the Voting Rights Act and believe it has done good. However, I'm also a pragmatist. I have read that the VRA was a poorly written law, complex in design with many exceptions and ambiguities making it subject to the arbitrary and capricious whims of congress. This has the effect of eroding states rights.
This country would have come unglued if there had been any sort of actual or perceived problem with Die Bold or other such voting machines associated with the November elections which muddied the outcome. In reality, the margin of victory/loss went a long way to settle tensions related to the quality of the vote.
@Egliman
That's very nice of you, knock yourself out, but my statement to wmolaw was "rhetorical", meaning my point was that both sides do it. No side holds the moral high ground here.
PS - I've been reading that conspiratorial stuff about Diebold and machine voting fraud for years. When you get some peer reviewed research that confirms that, let me know.
AeonPax, regarding comment:
Question:
Do political parties that control the state, have a right to dis-infranchise voters for partisan political advantage?
If so, then is that Constitutional?
AeonPax, regarding comment:
What is rediculous is that statement.
The evidence from the last 2012 election; of partisan Republican attempts to dis-enfranchise and discourage certain voting demographics that tend to vote Democrtat is abundant.
Your attempt to pretend otherwise is pathetic at best.
Egliman..... Agreed!
The only thing holding this country together is our perception of the validity of our vote. No more, no less.
We can discuss gerrymandering and vote fraud some other time
brightstone,
Reading skills; Use them. If you would have followed the thread, which you obviously didn't do, my comments were NOT based on the merits of the law itself (which is laudable) they were based on the Supreme Courts right to review the Voting Rights Act of 1965, whether you or I like it.
I do not agree with Scalia's legal assessment of the law (another thing you'd know had you read the complete thread) but the way SCOTUS operates and with the bench leaning conservative, there is every possibility they might nullify the law.
In the future, please read everything...not just bits and pieces.
AeonPax, regarding reply:
I did.
My response to you was to the specific statement that you made :
"That is ridiculous. Nobody in this day and age is trying to prevent black people from voting. Get real."
My response was notabout allof the double talk,splitting hair debate that you posted in your response to me.
It was specifically about your pronouncment that no one is trying to prevent black people from voting.
The fact that Partisan Unpatriotic Republicans tried to suppress the votes in 2012 is obviously demonstrable.
Not only were there Partisan Republican efforts to prevent African American citizens from voting but also Young people, older people, people in high density urban areas, all of those demograpics tend to vote Democratic.
The higher the vote the less chance for Republicans to win elections, that is why they tried to suppress those votes see links:
~
I live in Florida and I sawmyself first hand, what that RepublicanGovenor Rick ~ the traitor to American Freedom ~ Scott did to the voters in Florida. I was one of the lucky ones; I only waited 2 hours not eight like in some other florida counties.
Not only do we need to maintain the voter protection laws, we need to strengthen them, that is my point and what Iresponded to; not that legalistic double talk that you replied with.
It looks like you may be the one that has reading comprehension problems.
Prudence dictates that instead of using "ad hominems" to reply to you, which is never a good idea, that I strongly encourage you to follow the thread backwards and find out for yourself who made that comment, as I certainly did not.
AeonPax, regarding reply:
More phony double talk with no real substance or anwers to my points. You did not prove my points incorrect. I stand by my original response :
" My response was not about all of the double talk, splitting hair debate that you posted in your response to me.
It was specifically about your pronouncment that no one is trying to prevent black people from voting.
The fact that Partisan Unpatriotic Republicans tried to suppress the votes in 2012 is obviously demonstrable.
Not only were there Partisan Republican efforts to prevent African American citizens from voting but also Young people, older people, people in high density urban areas, all of those demograpics tend to vote Democratic.
The higher the vote the less chance for Republicans to win elections, that is why they tried to suppress those votes see links:"
~
...
Mike Lonkouski, regarding comment:
Once a citizen pays his or her debt to society, I don't think it is right to continue to take away their Constitutional Rights.
As Free Citizens that have already served their time, their rights along with their freedom should aslo be re-instated.
Could you please provide evidence, or credible sources that show massive numbers of foreign nationals voting in American elections.
In general, "gerrymandering" causes voter disenfranchised voters and is illegal by virtue of the Voting Rights Act, which is a federal law. Whether or not VRA is constitutional is currently being discussed by the Supreme Court.
Gerrymander - When political or electoral districts are drawn with the purpose of giving one political group an advantage over another, a practice which often results in districts with bizarre or strange shapes. Frequently referred to as "political gerrymandering" or "jurisdictional gerrymandering."
You're hopeless.
brightstarone,
I posted a comment that puts up the 15th Amendment further down. No one can be denied the right to vote due to race or skin color. Then there's19th Amendment that prevents people being denied the right to vote based on sex. If you feel you are being discriminated against, sue the state or county elections board in Federal Court.
Then argue right and wrong, no ones stopping you, and I'm sure there are members on the right that will take you up on this.
I am a supporter of the VRA and can testify as to the "good" the law has done. However, I deal in reality and the reality is what this conservative court might do to the Voters Rights Act. When a Supreme Court Justice calls the law a "Racial Entitlement" you best become very aware of the legal ramifications of that. Scalia and his twin, Clarence Thomas, could very well nudge the court past merely striking parts of the act to nullifying it altogether.
Nuff said sir.
Roe v Wade was NOT about abortion, it was about the right to privacy. AeonPax is absolutely correct. I do not agree with you that they invented a right. Basically, the 9th Amendment includes the right to privacy. The 9th is a catch all and nothing is therefore needed to "invent" any rights, Egilman. I believe Roe was actually argued on the 1st, 4th, 5th, 9th and 10th Amendments. (but it's been many years since I did an in-depth study of the case)
John,
We are arguing about this, because like anything the law and Constitution are up for interpretation. Some people are going to look at the law and the Constitution and interpret both based on what they say and only what they say. Others will look behind the words in both and try to find the "spirit" of both. Either way, both ways will determine what is done in theend. I have seen Supreme Court decisions that looked like they were going to strike something down completely and instead reaffirmed the whole thing.
Thomas Craig
Everyone knows that their are laws that establish and protectthe right of American Citizens, in a free Democratic Nation (the United States of America) to vote.
Thanks for telling me the obvious anyway.
But that was not in dispute at all.
My point is that the freedom to chose your government and vote to establish that government with the consent of : THE PEOPLE ; by allowing them to excersize their right to vote, is being threatened by Partisan Republican legislators that miss-use their governing powers to tweak and manipulate election laws to suppress voters that tend to vote democratic so as to skew the electionto their political advantage.
Republicans have unpopular and extreme political agendas which are out of touch with Mainstream American. Consequently they cannot win elections fair and square so they have resorted to tampering with election laws where ever they have governing power,to gain unfair political advantage.
As I've said, my discussion was about the unpatriotic Partisan Republican manipulation of election laws to suppress the popular vote, by making it unreasonably difficult to vote; for people that tend to vote Democratic.
That is a miss-use of their governing powers andthe voter protection laws should not only be maintained but strengthened to protect the American People from voter suppression laws.
btw- their tactic failed in almost all cases because their were successful court challenges that stopped them and the people were PISSED when they saw what those unpatriotic Republican traitors were trying to do.
So they came out in full force with greater numbers then even in '08 to vote. Waiting on line for as long as it took, like I said I waited 2 hours and I would have waited 2 months I didn't care how long it would have taken; I was going to excersize my right to vote and no Tea-pulbican scumbag was going to stop me.
I was ready to confront and fight any TRUE THE VOTE THUG that might have tried to stop or question my right to vote.
@John Russell - the VRA's provision in this case is probably Unconstitutional because it infringes on SOME states' rights to pass voting laws. Not all of them, just some of them. Perhaps if it had been written differently, it might not be facing a challenge today. On the other hand, if it had been written differently it might have been overturned IMMEDIATELY, since the Constitution doesn't give the Federal Government the authority to decide voting issues at all.
seems pretty clear to me: either make all states included, or eliminate the restrictions.
Rights do NOT have to be specifically Stated in the Constitution. The Constitution outlines ONLY the powers of the government and how it should be run. Again, please read the 9th Amendments
9th: The enumeration in the Constitution, of certain rights, shall not be construed to deny or disparage others retained by the people.
Seems pretty friggin clear to me!
Roe v. Wade , 410 U.S. 113 (1973), is a landmark decision by the United States Supreme Court on the issue of abortion . Decided simultaneously with a companion case, Doe v. Bolton , the Court ruled 72 that a right to privacy under the due process clause of the 14th Amendment extended to a woman's decision to have an abortion, but that right must be balanced against the state's two legitimate interests in regulating abortions: protecting prenatal life and protecting women's health.
also,
In a 7-2 decision written by Justice Harry Blackmun (who was chosen because of his prior experience as counsel to the Mayo Clinic), the Court ruled that the Texas statute violated Jane Roe's constitutional right to privacy . The Court argued that the Constitution's First , Fourth, Ninth , and Fourteenth Amendments protect an individual's "zone of privacy" against state laws and cited past cases ruling that marriage, contraception, and child rearing are activities covered in this "zone of privacy." The Court then argued that the "zone of privacy" was "broad enough to encompass a woman's decision whether or not to terminate her pregnancy." This decision involved myriad physical, psychological, and economic stresses a pregnant woman must face. -
Considering I started this thread, that's very magnanimous of you offer to start another thread to avoid going off topic, which you have already done a great job of.
I used Roe v. Wade as an example of how filing on one aspect of the law, can effect others. I allowed myself to get involved in this meaningless discussion.
The abortion topic and it's legal entanglements has been discussed, Ad nauseam, since the decision and to no avail on either side.
Let's get back on topic.
Deleated
AeonPax, regarding reply:
That is not true.
I am very optimistic and hopeful.
AeonPax, regarding mix up:
Dear AeonPax ,
please accept my most humble apology. I went back and saw that you did not in-fact make the comment that I was disputing.
I acknowledge my error, you were correct.
Please forgive me.
I figured out how the error happened, I responded to a comment from another poster and that poster never replied but you did right after my response and so that is where my confusion happened and you did not let me know that you did not make the specific comment that I was disputing until after we had gone back and forth a bit.
So now we know and it is straightened out.
All is right with the world now.
And you said I was Hopless.
PEACE
No apology necessary. Actually, it is I who should apologize. Aside from being a smart-ass at times, I should have taken the time to show you where the problem was. The problem was the "threading" here, it gets vague after a few a replies and without an automatic quoting option, one has to manually address the recipient.
When it comes to politics and religion, as both can get impassioned, I cut people slack. Oh, btw, there's always hope.