“Any white person who brings the elements of civilization had the right to take over this continent,” Ayn Rand proclaimed
Ayn Rand is the patron saint of the libertarian Right. Her writings are quoted in a quasi-religious manner by American reactionaries, cited like Biblical codices that offer profound answers to all of life’s complex problems (namely, just “Free the Market”). Yet, despite her impeccable libertarian bona fides, Rand defended the colonization and genocide of what she called the “savage” Native Americans — one of the most authoritarian campaigns of death and suffering ever orchestrated.
“Any white person who brings the elements of civilization had the right to take over this continent,” Ayn Rand proclaimed, “and it is great that some people did, and discovered here what they couldn’t do anywhere else in the world and what the Indians, if there are any racist Indians today, do not believe to this day: respect for individual rights.”
Rand made these remarks before the graduating class of the U.S. Military Academy at West Point on March 6, 1974, in a little-known Q&A session. Rand’s comments in this obscure Q&A are appearing in full for the first time, here in Salon.
“Philosophy: Who Needs It” remains one of Ayn Rand’s most popular and influential speeches. The capitalist superstar delivered the talk as a commencement address at West Point 41 years ago. In the definitive collection of Rand’s thoughts on philosophy, Philosophy: Who Needs It , the lecture was chosen as the lead and eponymous essay. This was the last book Rand worked on before she died; that this piece, ergo, was selected as the title and premise of her final work attests to its significance as a cornerstone of her entire worldview.
The Q&A session that followed this talk, however, has gone largely unremembered — and most conveniently for the fervent Rand aficionado, at that. For it is in this largely unknown Q&A that Rand enthusiastically defended the extermination of the indigenous peoples of the Americas.
In the Q&A, a man asked Rand:
At the risk of stating an unpopular view, when you were speaking of America, I couldn’t help but think of the cultural genocide of Native Americans, the enslavement of Black men in this country, and the relocation of Japanese-Americans during World War II. How do you account for all of this in your view of America?
(A transcript of Ayn Rand’s full answer is included at the bottom of this article.)
Rand replied insisting that “the issue of racism, or even the persecution of a particular race, is as important as the persecution of individuals.” “If you are concerned with minorities, the smallest minority on Earth is an individual,” she added, before proceeding to blame racism and the mass internment of Japanese-Americans on “liberals.” “Racism didn’t exist in this country until the liberals brought it up,” Rand maintained. And those who defend “racist” affirmative action, she insisted, “are the ones who are institutionalizing racism today.”
Although the libertarian luminary expressed firm opposition to slavery, she rationalized it by saying “black slaves were sold into slavery, in many cases, by other black tribes.” She then, ahistorically, insisted that slavery “is something which only the United States of America abolished.”
Massive applause followed Rand’s comments, which clearly strongly resonated with the graduating class of the U.S. military. Rand’s most extreme and opprobrious remarks, nevertheless, were saved for her subsequent discussion of Native Americans.
“Savages” who deserved to be conquered
In a logical sleight of hand that would even confound and bewilder even Lewis Carroll, Ayn Rand proclaimed in the 1974 Q&A that it was in fact indigenous Americans who were the racists, not the white settlers who were ethnically cleansing them. The laissez-faire leader declared that Native Americans did not “have any right to live in a country merely because they were born here and acted and lived like savages.”
“Americans didn’t conquer” this land, Rand asserted, and “you are a racist if you object to that.” Since “the Indians did not have any property rights — they didn’t have the concept of property,” she said, “they didn’t have any rights to the land.”
If “a country does not protect rights,” Rand asked — referring specifically to property rights — “why should you respect the rights they do not have?” She took the thought to its logical conclusion, contending that anyone “has the right to invade it, because rights are not recognized in this country.”
Rand then blamed Native Americans for breaking the agreements they made with the Euro-American colonialists. The historical reality, though, was exactly the contrary: white settlers constantly broke the treaties they made with the indigenous, and regularly attacked them.
“Let’s suppose they were all beautifully innocent savages, which they certainly were not,” Rand persisted. “What was it that they were fighting for, if they opposed white men on this continent? For their wish to continue a primitive existence, their right to keep part of the earth untouched, unused, and not even as property, but just keep everybody out so that you will live practically like an animal?” she asked.
“Any white person who brings the elements of civilization had the right to take over this continent,” Rand said, “and it is great that some people did, and discovered here what they couldn’t do anywhere else in the world and what the Indians, if there are any racist Indians today, do not believe to this day: respect for individual rights.”
Rand’s rosy portrayal of the colonization of the modern-day Americas is in direct conflict with historical reality. In his book American Holocaust: Columbus and the Conquest of the New World , American historian David Stannard estimates that approximately 95 percent of indigenous Americans died after the beginning of European settler colonialism. “The destruction of the Indians of the Americas was, far and away, the most massive act of genocide in the history of the world,” writes Prof. Stannard . “Within no more than a handful of generations following their first encounters with Europeans, the vast majority of the Western Hemisphere’s native peoples had been exterminated.”
West Point appeared to express no concern with Rand’s extreme, white supremacist views, nevertheless. A West Point official offered final remarks after her speech, quipping: “Ms. Rand, you have certainly given us a delighted example of a major engagement in philosophy, in the wake of which you have left a long list of casualties” — to which the audience laughed and applauded. “And have tossed and gored several sacred cows,” he added. “I hope so,” Rand replied.
More than just seemingly condoning Rand’s comments, the U.S. Military Academy also admirably echoed Ayn Rand’s views. “Ms. Rand, in writing Atlas Shrugged ,” the West Point official continued at the graduation ceremony, “made one remark that I thought was important to us when she said that the only proper purpose of a government is to protect Man’s rights, and the only proper functions of the government are the police, to protect our property at home; the law, to protect our rights and contracts; and the army, to protect us from foreign threats. And we appreciate your coming to the home of the Army tonight to address us.” More thunderous applause followed.
Tracking down the evidence
The book Ayn Rand Answers: The Best of Her Q & A includes Rand’s Manifest Destiny-esque defense of settler colonialism among some of the “best of her” public statements. Ayn Rand Answers was edited by philosophy professor Robert Mayhew , whom the Ayn Rand Institute describes as an “ Objectivist scholar ,” referring to the libertarian ideology created by Rand. ARI lists Prof. Mayhew as one of its Ayn Rand experts , and notes that he serves on the board of the Anthem Foundation for Objectivist Scholarship. The transcript included in Prof. Mayhew’s collection is full of errors, however, and reorders her remarks.
A recording of the West Point commencement address was available for free on the ARI website as early as April 2009 . Up until around October 18, 2013 , separate recordings of the speech and Q&A were still freely accessible. By October 22 , nonetheless, ARI had removed the recordings from its website and put them up for sale.
Some copies of the 1974 recording have circulated the Internet, but in order to verify the quotes and authenticate the transcript, I ordered an official MP3 recording of the event from the Ayn Rand Institute eStore. (After all, I was working on a piece involving Ayn Rand, so I figured it was only natural that I had to buy something.) The quotes in this piece are directly transcribed from the official recording of Rand’s West Point speech and Q&A.

I wish someone would address the issue of the way seeded articles format.
Where do I control the font size in the seeded article? I don't see such a control, so I must be missing it.
But now, as to the Indians, I don’t even care to discuss that kind of alleged complaints that they have against this country. I do believe with serious, scientific reasons the worst kind of movie that you have probably seen—worst from the Indian viewpoint—as to what they did to the white man.
I do not think that they have any right to live in a country merely because they were born here and acted and lived like savages. Americans didn’t conquer; Americans did not conquer that country.
Whoever is making sounds there, I think is hissing, he is right, but please be consistent: you are a racist if you object to that [laughter and applause]. You are that because you believe that anything can be given to Man by his biological birth or for biological reasons.
If you are born in a magnificent country which you don’t know what to do with, you believe that it is a property right; it is not. And, since the Indians did not have any property rights—they didn’t have the concept of property; they didn’t even have a settled, society, they were predominantly nomadic tribes; they were a primitive tribal culture, if you want to call it that—if so, they didn’t have any rights to the land, and there was no reason for anyone to grant them rights which they had not conceived and were not using.
It would be wrong to attack any country which does respect—or try, for that matter, to respect—individual rights, because if they do, you are an aggressor and you are morally wrong to attack them. But if a country does not protect rights—if a given tribe is the slave of its own tribal chief—why should you respect the rights they do not have?
Or any country which has a dictatorship. Government—the citizens still have individual rights—but the country does not have any rights. Anyone has the right to invade it, because rights are not recognized in this country and neither you nor a country nor anyone can have your cake and eat it too.
In other words, want respect for the rights of Indians, who, incidentally, for most cases of their tribal history, made agreements with the white man, and then when they had used up whichever they got through agreement of giving, selling certain territory, then came back and broke the agreement, and attacked white settlements.
I will go further. Let’s suppose they were all beautifully innocent savages, which they certainly were not. What was it that they were fighting for, if they opposed white men on this continent? For their wish to continue a primitive existence, their right to keep part of the earth untouched, unused, and not even as property, but just keep everybody out so that you will live practically like an animal, or maybe a few caves about.
Any white person who brings the elements of civilization had the right to take over this continent, and it is great that some people did, and discovered here what they couldn’t do anywhere else in the world and what the Indians, if there are any racist Indians today, do not believe to this day: respect for individual rights.
I am, incidentally, in favor of Israel against the Arabs for the very same reason. There you have the same issue in reverse. Israel is not a good country politically; it’s a mixed economy, leaning strongly to socialism. But why do the Arabs resent it? Because it is a wedge of civilization—an industrial wedge—in part of a continent which is totally primitive and nomadic.
Israel is being attacked for being civilized, and being specifically a technological society. It’s for that very reason that they should be supported—that they are morally right because they represent the progress of Man’s mind, just as the white settlers of America represented the progress of the mind, not centuries of brute stagnation and superstition. They represented the banner of the mind and they were in the right.
[thunderous applause]
What she said is laughable. To say the Indians did not have any property rights in America is so ridiculous. The WHOLE of America was their property, perhaps in a more communal manner that her "individual rights" required, but that same "communal manner" was carried on by the hippies in the 60s and 70s, so I guess she would have called them savages as well. In fact, I question which is the more civilized system - individual or common rights.
Yeah, she was a beauty. Same old, same old...Indians were savages. She, like many others avoid the truth, but using the term savages. It fits right in with the rest of her lies.
Savages have no rights, don't ya know...
She was a frickin' nut case, and a liar. Why she has followers is beyond me. Since she was so anti government, the last years of her life she lived off Social Security, her husbands.
So much for her and her bs.
Who issued the definition of "Primitive people" - "Civilized people".
Biggest, in my opinion, contradiction of her entire presentation - It would be wrong to attack any country which does respect—or try, for that matter, to respect—individual rights, because if they do, you are an aggressor and you are morally wrong to attack them.
The suppression of individual rights, as espoused by the U. S. Constitution, is the foundation of the U. S. All peoples are entitled to their individual rights =- hence the founding of this country - "We the People of the United States, in Order to form a more perfect Union, establish Justice, insure domestic Tranquility, provide for the common defence, promote the general Welfare, and secure the Blessings of Liberty to ourselves and our Posterity, do ordain and establish this Constitution for the United States."
Total contradiction - but she was too "brilliant" to see that, right???? //s/s/s/
According to many conservatives and libertarians, and liberals for that matter, individual rights are "God given" human rights. We pretty much hear so endlessly.
Of course Rand was a well known atheist.
The fact that the Europeans had to get in a boat and sail for many weeks to get to a land where they found people already living should have clued them in that this "new" land was already spoken for.
Now, there have been conquests throughout history, and the "strong" have overpowered the "weak". Much of the European strength was in sheer numbers, but it was a sort of strength nonetheless.
What gets me about this particular article is that Rand seems to be saying that the natives deserved to be conquered because they chose to be primitive.
"Primitive", especially in 1600, was relative. The Europeans themselves did a lot of primitive things. They knew little about medicine, for example, and willy nilly spread deadly disease they could not control.
But even so, the Indians did not choose to be primitive, they lived and experienced their culture.
It is one thing to say that historical events happened and we cannot rewrite history, it is another to say that the conquest was right and just.
There are a number of out-right lies in her statement which people believe.
First, Indians had property rights, different than the Euro's, but they worked just fine for us.
Primitive and savage. She of course avoided the fact that we were well advanced in medicine, far beyond the euro's. Farming was another area that Indians were far advanced beyond the euro's. As for primitive, how can she explain the great cities of the Americans. A quick study of the great Mississippian city/culture of Cahokia shows how so very wrong she is.
As 1st pointed out she is in direct contradiction with our constitution.
'enuff said about this wacko.
If a culture does not have the use of a written language they can't be called much of a culture from future examinations . That would also include the physical means of recording their culture . The Mississippians may have led enjoyable lives but real culture is about passing the traditions down in writing so that it doesn't get distorted by the oral transmission .
So I guess that advanced medicine, agriculture, building and some of the sciences isn't considered a civilization.
Oh, btw petey, as I proved to you before some tribes did have a written language. Some more than a thousand years old.
Fairly ignorant statement on your part petey.
KVK ,
Feel free to detail those tribes with a written language . That is what I mean when I talk about culture . Did they describe their discoveries in writing ? What material did they write on ?
Anishinaabe, Odana, Potowatomie had a written language. There are scrolls in the Smithsonian proving this.
They were written on Birch bark and slate and they explain our history, travels, medicine etc...
Thanks for the 411 Kavika ,
Hence the name of your private group . Are you indicating 3 different languages ? I don't suppose it is easy to learn their alphabets . Are they any harder to learn than Russian ?
Maybe most important : do they have extensive libraries of their writings ?
petey, it's one language and it's written as mneomic...There isn't an alphabet as such.
There are quite a few of the scrolls, but no one outside the Midewiwin (Grand Medicine Society) are allowed to see them. Linguists and anthropologists are working on the few that they have, to try to interpret them. They are highly complex and show complex thought processes.
There is a reason for this, but would take pages to explain it all.
John - thank you for posting this and for putting your thoughts forward. At least we've been able to discuss and not re-hash - which I enjoy.
Rand was born Alisa Zinov'yevna Rosenbaum ( Russian : Али́са Зиновьевна Розенбаум ) on February 2, 1905, to a Russian Jewish bourgeois [12] family living in Saint Petersburg .
I wonder how she felt about the Nazis "taking over" the Jews and their possessions (while murdering them).
The Nazis were white after all … still are.
They are the "more white" group.
Rand: "If “a country does not protect rights,” Rand asked — referring specifically to property rights — “why should you respect the rights they do not have?” She took the thought to its logical conclusion, contending that anyone “has the right to invade it, because rights are not recognized in this country.”
According to such "reasoning," Anyone has the right to deprive Rand of her breath -- by covering her mouth and nose -- since nobody owns the air.
It would be a long line of suspects.
“the Indians did not have any property rights — they didn’t have the concept of property,”
That is actually accurate . Indians are not the only ones who suffer because of a lack of understanding of the law . Basically anyone who can't afford a lawyer is in the same situation .
As I understand it, most pre-Columbian Indians (a.k.a., native Americans) in North America (a.k.a., Turtle Island) dwelled within tribes which lacked the European sense of personal or familial (a.k.a., private) land ownership. The did belong within (and to) territories -- tribal territories. These territories were often defended as such from potential invaders.
What Rand is saying, in essence, is that property rights with regard to land must be managed as the Europeans did, or they are invalid and irrelevant. This is akin to saying that a culture must measure land in acres and sections and write down the private ownership in English (ink and paper) in a European style of legalized theft.
But it is still theft. Always has been, as all traditional and indigenous cultures held land (if at all) in common -- as commons.
Rand is defending the complete and total and utter destruction (enclosure) of the commons. She is pretending that such theft is perfectly valid, since that's the way '"civilized" people live -- in rabid competition and alienation from one another and the land itself.
If poor Ms Rand were not the victim of such a violent and pathetic culture herself it may make sense to hate her. And if pity were not foolish, she should be pitied. But were she alive today, I'd want to love her and encourage her to heal from such a sick dream.
Anyone who gets his self worth by loudly proclaiming his moral superiority over someone he doesn't understand is merely a jackass .
You're not a jackass, Petey. Your photo clearly shows you as a kangaroo.
Turning this around on me doesn't work . I'm not one for heavy handed moralizing . Get real ...
" I'm not one for heavy handed moralizing "
Poor Petey. He thinks any moral stand at all is "heavy handed moralizing".
Pitiful James ; He doesn't recognize when he is being so heavy handed that he gets called a jackass . Some people are clueless about their own verbal diarrhea ...
Petey is so without a stand that he's laying flat on the floor like a puddle.
Take your ex-lax and get it over with already !
Doing a test here on the posting speed.