America is due for a revolution
Here’s the good news: The chaos and upheaval we see all around us have historical precedents and yet America survived. The bad news: Everything likely will get worse before it gets better again.
That’s my chief takeaway from “Shattered Consensus,” a meticulously argued analysis of the growing disorder. Author James Piereson persuasively makes the case there is an inevitable “revolution” coming because our politics, culture, education, economics and even philanthropy are so polarized that the country can no longer resolve its differences.
To my knowledge, no current book makes more sense about the great unraveling we see in each day’s headlines. Piereson captures and explains the alienation arising from the sense that something important in American life is ending, but that nothing better has emerged to replace it.
The impact is not restricted by our borders. Growing global conflict is related to America’s failure to agree on how we should govern ourselves and relate to the world.
Piereson describes the endgame this way: “The problems will mount to a point of crisis where either they will be addressed through a ‘fourth revolution’ or the polity will begin to disintegrate for lack of fundamental agreement.”
He identifies two previous eras where a general consensus prevailed, and collapsed. Each lasted about as long as an individual’s lifetime, was dominated by a single political party and ended dramatically.
First came the era that stretched from 1800 until slavery and sectionalism led to the Civil War. The second consensus, which he calls the capitalist-industrial era, lasted from the end of the Civil War until the Great Depression.
It is the third consensus, which grew out of the depression and World War II, which is now shattering. Because the nation is unable to solve economic stagnation, political dysfunction and the resulting public discontent, Piereson thinks the consensus “cannot be resurrected.”
That’s not to say he’s pessimistic — he thinks a new era could usher in dynamic growth, as happened after the previous eras finally reached general agreement on national norms. But first we must weather a crisis that may involve an economic and stock-market collapse, a terror attack, or simply a prolonged and bitter stalemate.
The book, like its author, is conservative but not doctrinaire. Piereson, president of the William E. Simon Foundation and a senior fellow at the Manhattan Institute, uses a scholarly Big Idea template to dissect a variety of examples that at first glance seem to be digressions. Not so — he methodically accumulates evidence for relevant and compelling conclusions.
A chapter on the impact of the JFK assassination is so riveting that I insisted on reading portions aloud to my family. How, Piereson wonders, was it possible that Fidel Castro and Che Guevara became heroes to the American left when it was a committed communist who killed the left’s beloved Kennedy?
Piereson also deftly demolishes the myth of Camelot by recounting how a grieving first lady created the legend on a single weekend after the president’s funeral. Jacqueline Kennedy invited famed writer Theodore White to the family compound on Cape Cod so he could interview her for a Life magazine issue devoted to JFK.
There she told White that she and the president went to bed listening to the soundtrack of the then-popular Broadway show “Camelot,” which was based on a novel. She insisted that JFK loved the music and the story because he, too, was a courageous idealist like the fabled King Arthur depicted in the show. “There will be great presidents again, but there will never be another Camelot,” Jackie told White.
White and his editors resisted the grandiose and sentimental story line, but finally relented to the grieving widow. White later expressed regret for helping to create the Camelot myth.
Other sections trace the changes of liberal and conservative orthodoxy and the rise and decline of American universities.
Piereson also considers possible elements of the next national consensus, including a renewed focus on growth instead of redistribution and a bid to depoliticize government.
But he is ultimately uncertain what will come next because we are far from reaching a consensus on almost anything. There are so many fault lines that the nation seems consumed by a conflict of all against all.
That doesn’t make for a happy ending, but it is an honest one. http://nypost.com/2015/10/17/history-is-repeating-itself-america-is-due-for-a-revolution/

In all the hard times that have faced this nation before, we have been a country of united people, of one culture, and of basically similar values. There have always been the wealthy and the poor with a middle layer of so-so people, and the wealthy have always looked down their privileged noses at those they considered below them.
But in the past, the wealthy who did not truly have religious beliefs, did not believe in a Higher Power, pretended they did, because not to believe in G_d was totally unacceptable to the Americans of those days. No one could achieve public office, even, as the old saying goes, that of dog catcher, if it was thought he did not believe in G_d. While so many people love to say today that we are not a Christian nation, in those days, we proudly said that we were.
We did not say it or live it to belittle the Jews in our country... it simply did not occur to us that they would be offended; we knew they would realize the United States of America had a predominant religion, that we did not begrudge them their faith and we respected it. Their people were allowed the Jewish religious holidays from school and work, which they took without fanfare, and they also took the Christian holidays... there was nothing to complain about.
Though there were little to no Catholics in the deep South at the time, every school and institution in America served fish on Fridays so as not to offend the possibility that there might be even one Catholic student or employee who would have to go hungry or violate their religious belief by eating meat on Friday if there were no fish in a cafeteria. Even public restaurants all over the US served, and still do, fish on Friday.
Now, we are a country that is so divided and at each other's throat kids in some towns can't have a school Halloween party because it offends the religious sensibilities of certain parents. They can't have a traditional Christmas party for the same reason. They can't have the traditional Easter party. They can't pass Valentine cards.
We can't put up the traditional holiday decorations .... of ANY holiday because someone claims it's an insult to their religion. American kids can't wear clothes that bear symbols of the damn country they live in, that their parents fight for, that their grandparents fought, and some of them died, for, because it INSULTS the illegal aliens and immigrant children they go to school with.
Kindergarten kids can't bring GI Joe's to school to play with during recess because it UPSETS some of the children who are not Americans, or the teacher who is not native born, or her helper... sixth grade kids on the playground trying to pull the scarf off a Muslim girls head are EXPELLED from school and charged with a HATE CRIME for the incident... a HATE CRIME, for crying out loud! It's what young kids do!
Yes, we are headed for a revolution. It's inevitable. Because we are no longer a united country. We are a bunch of individual, angry tribes, pushed aside and pushed around, and it's just going to take one incident akin to what is happening in Israel, England, France, Germany, or any of the other countries where people have resorted to violence to try and force their way on their hosts, for the eruption to ignite.
Instant Karma's gonna get you
Gonna knock you right on the head
You better get yourself together
Pretty soon you're gonna be dead
What in the world you thinking of
Laughing in the face of love
What on earth you tryin' to do
It's up to you, yeah you
Instant Karma's gonna get you
Gonna look you right in the face
Better get yourself together darlin'
Join the human race
How in the world you gonna see
Laughin' at fools like me
Who in the hell d'you think you are
A super star
Well, right you are
Well we all shine on
Like the moon and the stars and the sun
Well we all shine on
Ev'ryone come on
Instant Karma's gonna get you
Gonna knock you off your feet
Better recognize your brothers
Ev'ryone you meet
Why in the world are we here
Surely not to live in pain and fear
Why on earth are you there
When you're ev'rywhere
Come and get your share
Well we all shine on
Like the moon and the stars and the sun
Yeah we all shine on
Come on and on and on on on
Yeah yeah, alright, uh huh, ah
Well we all shine on
Like the moon and the stars and the sun
Yeah we all shine on
On and on and on on and on
John Lennon
Mimi,
You kind of don't realize what you said here:
Though there were little to no Catholics in the deep South at the time, every school and institution in America served fish on Fridays so as not to offend the possibility that there might be even one Catholic student or employee who would have to go hungry or violate their religious belief by eating meat on Friday if there were no fish in a cafeteria. Even public restaurants all over the US served, and still do, fish on Friday.
Then you said this:
Now, we are a country that is so divided and at each other's throat kids in some towns can't have a school Halloween party because it offends the religious sensibilities of certain parents.
You are kind of contradicting yourself. I do remember when Catholics got fish on Fridays, and that was because people actually cared not to hurt their feelings and to be considerate. How is that different from being considerate to those that don't celebrate Halloween. When I taught, we had our Jehovah Witness/7th day Adventist/Black Israelites go to other rooms while these celebrations when on. We treated them with consideration.
Isn't that what we all would want? Kind of the golden rule.
The only good thing about fish on Fridays when I was growing up was in the summer time and they were fresh caught Bluegill and Perch!
I don't remember tolerance in the good old days. In fact, I don't remember it at all. We might have gone too much the other way now, but the good old days were not everything they were cracked up to be if you were the other.
But we have gone way too far to the other side, where reparations are demanded and the current politico's are more than willing to accommodate that for votes.
There probably are a few stragglers demanding reparations, but for the most part these days it is a symbolic "demand" and not a literal one. Maybe you are confusing 2015 with 1975.
I'm almost 60 and I agree with Perrie that the good old days were not all they were cracked up to be. Everything looked great on TV shows, but in the real world there were race riots and Jim Crow and the assassinations of JFK, MLK and RFK. Racism was rampant, from the Klan to the Black Panthers to Louis Farrakhan. Yes there is racism and problems today, but they don't compare to what really were years when a revolution was possible and several groups tried it.
To try it today would be a joke. You'll never get the number of Americans behind one idea long enough and dedicated enough and ready to fight a bloody civil war. It's a pipe dream and any group that tries it will be squashed by Law Enforcement like a bug.
See, I lived and grew up in the deep South, and I don't remember it being as bad as some make it out to be.
There are some here who will say it's because of "white privilege" because I was raised as white, but my cousins and sisters and I lived in the rural area and we have black friends and played with them, associated with them all the time, except during school hours. In the winter when we couldn't play baseball or kickball we met in our school gym for kickball and basketball or volleyball.
White kids, black kids, Jewish kids.... we didn't know we were supposed to be mad at each other until the Civil Rights era.
Of course, I didn't live in Birmingham or Montgomery or Atlanta and never traveled to those areas. When we left home it was to vacation in the Smoky Mountains. So I guess my experience was not normal.
I don't see the contradiction. No one minded the fish on Fridays. It just was, and it was okay. I mentioned it as an example of how Americans got along with each other's religions without making a big deal of it or suing anyone about it.
Now there are towns that the city councils and school boards have said no Halloween parties, no decorations, no candy to be passed around, nothing at all to suggest there is a holiday called "Halloween" is allowed any more in the classrooms because there are some parents who object as it is contrary to their religious beliefs.
Since when?
The majority of parents in the school district where this is taking place are demanding the name(s) of the parent or parents who have stopped the tradition as the kids are tearfully upset about not being able to wear their costumes to school as planned or share their candy and home baked goods the way they have done every other year.
The parents/group opposing Halloween don't want their kids to go to a separate classroom with refreshments to read or watch a movie, they want to stop the entire school from enjoying the age-old tradition.... because they can, evidently.
It happened at one school in Conn and the school board reversed the decision and Halloween goes on. Obviously, it wasn't handled right. It should have never been considered.
Here is the story:
Thank you for the update, Perrie.
Schools have made some colossal mistakes over the last couple of years or so in their handling of things from dress codes to ridiculous zero tolerance rules.
I've read that the incident with the boy who made the clock has resulted in a nation-wide wake up call for schools to reassess their handling of how they deal with expelling students for minor infractions and involving police with incidents that can be handled by parents and school officials, without giving students a permanent criminal record.
Perhaps there is hope on the horizon.
When I heard about the Halloween fiasco I was listening to a live broadcast, one of the mini-broadcast deals on the computer news channels. They made it sound as though several schools in a particular district were involved.
Thanks for the clarification.
If we do have a revolution it will likely be started by a false newscast...
If we do have a revolution it will likely be started by a false newscast...
So true... or media made.
I believe the chance of a revolution happening in America is roughly the same as the Earth suddenly crashing into the sun and burning to a cinder.
But if it does happen I want a warning so I can get my coke and popcorn and a good seat ready in front of the TV ready to watch it be completely crushed.
We leave the outdoor lights out (as usual anyway) and the only lights are in a couple of rooms in the back, my wife's bedroom and the family room which is very forbidding and live in a neighborhood where we have never seen trick or treaters anywhere. The local elementary school (about 4 blocks away) has a get together for the kids, so maybe that's why we have no one come to streets. The fact is we don't like kids and don't want trick or treaters. Bah humbug!
Did you like kids when you yourselves were kids?
Nope. I couldn't wait to grow up.
Yes, thought I'd be a kid forever. Peter Pan had nothing on me.
You start it. I'll watch and make popcorn. Or is that I'll make popcorn and watch? Either way works. Save me a good seat.
I am soooo ready for the bullets to start flying. And all you fuckers that keep crying for more gun control, when the shit hits the fan, don't come crying to me to save your ass.
"I am soooo ready for the bullets to start flying."
So, you think bullets are the best solution to disagreements? You think blood solves social problems? How sad.
No, I think bullets are the best solution to an oppressive government. Don't put words in my mouth, asshole.
Comment removed for CoC violation [ph] Let me guess - there are parts of government that you like (like that branch that is ultimately paying your salary, or the one that keeps your roads and bridges from falling down, etc.), and there are parts you don't like too. Welcome to the club, asshole. Your preferred solution to not getting exactly what you want, is to pump bullets into your 'oppressors'. You are exactly the kind of person who shouldn't have access to guns.
I don't think Bruce, or the rest of these people, know what an oppressive government is. They read too much right wing fiction.
They certainly aren't living a life of oppression. They live in a country where they can own virtually unlimited guns and ammo, enjoy true freedom of speech, and pay no taxes on millions of dollars you legally fleeced from gulligible Christians as a successful televangelist ... all at once, if you choose.
But they don't get to kill people at will! That's the final freedom they want! They are ITCHING to use all of that armament they've bought, paid for and have stored in secret bunkers (their basements) that it's killing them! It's driving them even more bat-shit crazy then the already are!
Then again I stand corrected. I think some of them have decided they really can't wait for the bullets to start flying. That they really can kill at will. Such as in Sandy Hook, Aurora, Oakland, Seal Beach, Binghampton NY, Dakalb, Virgina Tech, Red Lake Indian Reservation, Tucson, Honolulu, etc., etc., etc., oh and lets not forget Columbine. I guess some people would rather have the bullets start flying now.
Woof.
You're an idiot.
Randy,
Unless you are a rabid, feral animal coming after my livestock, or someone alone the lines of the two Hispanics who tried to steal my car two months ago then turned on me when I asked them what the hell they thought they were doing, you nor any other person has anything to fear from my ammo nor my rifle.
The two bastards who were so stupid they thought a woman wouldn't really shoot them are lucky they had enough brains to be afraid of my dog when he made his appearance.
The "revolution" has already been going on, in small doses, around the country; politicians just won't admit it, and people who haven't yet experienced it don't believe it's happening.
The "revolution" has already been going on, in small doses, around the country; politicians just won't admit it, and people who haven't yet experienced it don't believe it's happening.
Sorry Mimi, but the idea that there is a revolution happening outside of the usual political sphere is a fantasy. It's just not. It's not there. The idea that there is same sort of people's revolution happening or coming is simply on the same level as the Flat Earth Society. And the the story you posted is not an example of one happening.
That's because you're not living it Randy. More and more people are taking care of things themselves. The law is late, investigation is insipid, trials are trivial, and justice retribution is rigged.
Take care of it yourself and explain it to the LEOs when they chance to arrive. Those still depending on law enforcement for protection live in the cities, and criminals kill them on a daily basis.
Seems to me it's more "revulsion" than "revolution".
Sure you can Randy - you just have to be prepared to pay for the consequences of your idiocy, stupidity and being a liberal. But, you can kill the hell outtta anybody you want if ya got the guns and ammo to do it with.
Okay, Hal...
I had to vote that one up!
Yep.
A few years ago, I used to say, "I read too much Jack Reacher," and no one knew what I was talking about. Now the movie has been made and I don't have to explain.
But, yeah, I read too much Jack Reacher.
OMG - so absolutely true - " I don't think Bruce "
You heard/read the admission first, here, on the FP of NT.
There is a gawd.
Removed for CoC Comment removed. (AM)
That's deep. I'm going to need to let that sink in for a while, to grasp the true meaning of your wise philosophical expression.
Jay,
You had 9 "likes" and when I tried to "like" your comment it went down to 0. Got to get that button fixed...
Thanks Mimi. I appreciate it. But the simple fact is, I'm not here to make people like me.
Conservatives and usual suspects are pretty much the only ones using the like -dislike buttons. I don't put a lot of store in it.
Conservatives and usual suspects are pretty much the only ones using the like -dislike buttons. I don't put a lot of store in it.
I love 'em! They're so screwed up when you hit one there is no telling what's going to happen! I liked a comment that only had one like on it and it went to five! Then I liked one that had three likes on it and it went to zero! They're like a toy that came with the new site. When I'm bored (which seems to be happening a lot easier on this platform) it's fun just to hit them up or down and see what happens. Too bad they're not like a slot machince with a payout.
I hope Perrie never fixes them.
LOL..
I know what you mean, Randy. Your comment had one "Like" and I hit the "Like" button to give it another one and it went to zero...
Seriously, I think one reason the numbers will jump up is because the site doesn't automatically update them for everyone until each individual hits the "like" or "dislike" button themselves. If you are seeing three "Likes" on a comment and you "Like" it and the number jumps up to seven instead of just four, it means three people in addition to you also "liked" the comment previously and it's just now registering along with your "like"... if you follow me.
If you have already "liked" a comment but forgot and "like" it again, it will put the count in a negative, and you will have to "like" it about two more times to correct it.
Sort of like playing Pac Man with a sluggish controller.
So it's that they are slow to show up and then when you click on one is sort of un-sticks the others or hurry's them along? That makes sense. They're not really keep track of anywhere are they? I haven't found a place like that.
ROFLMAO....
I'd say the same thing if I had your numbers, John!
We get numbers? Wow! I'll have to look for them! The should especially should be funny considering every time you click on them many of them go up or down 3 or 4 or 5 points! I love them!
If I'm not mistaken there is only one digit to display the votes . I expect 0 really means 10 in this system ... but who knows ?!
Bruce,
Is that you are prepared or wishing for it?
The Number Of Guns Owned By The Average Ammosexual Has Doubled Since 1994 — To EIGHT
Picture an episode of Sesame Street. The Count does his thing — 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8 — eight guns! That’s how many are currently stored, safely or not, by the average ammosexual in America today. Second Amendmenters have always felt that “one is not enough,” apparently living in a fantasy world where they can grip multiple firearms at once, and because the NRA has injected into them a sort-of god complex where they and they alone can stop every single crime in progress with their magical Freedom Stick, Rambo it up anytime a “bad guy with a gun” rears his ugly head.
Unfortunately, the mythical “good guy with a gun” often finds himself robbed of his weapon at gunpoint , using unnecessary force against a minor threat , almost shooting himself in the head , leaving his boomstick lying around and getting Second Amendmented by a “good kid with a gun,” losing his gun on the roadside , or falling into a fit of rage and murdering a preschooler in cold blood. Despite the NRA’s claims to the contrary, numerous studies have shown that simply keeping a gun in the home increases the risk of a firearm-related death greatly, while the benefit in doing so is minimal, at best.
The number of gun-owning households in America has decreased over the years , but thanks to the NRA’s propaganda, the die-hards who insist on filling their homes with deadly weapons have really stocked up over time. In fact, when compared to 20 years ago, there are now twice as many guns in far fewer hands, according to data from the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives.
Why does the "average" gun lover need 8 guns ? Unless they are hoping /planning for a "war".
Obama Praises Australia’s Gun Ban. The Actual Results…
UPDATE: SINCE THIS ARTICLE WAS WRITTEN, NEW STUDIES PROVED THAT THERE ARE MORE GUN-OWNERS IN AUSTRALIA THAN EVER. READ ABOUT THAT HERE.
In 1996 a massacre in Tasmania left 35 people dead, and caused Australia to establish draconian gun control laws. They literally rounded up, destroyed and banned guns. Now the rumor goes, they haven’t had any mass shootings since, and that crime has decreased as a result. HINT: not quite.
Enter Obama, who said :
I was previously in favour of gun controls, but since your brilliant so-called leader of the free world wants to open up America to a tsunami of Middle East immigrants, then I think every American needs to arm themselves to the teeth, and not venture out of their hopefully secured homes without being armed and ready.
Oh, and by the way, have you built your fallout shelter yet?
Thumbs down? Someone can't handle the truth. (Thanks to Jack Nicholson for that line - LOL)
If I were running for president, I would value Sarah Silveman's endorsement over Hilary's, Carlie's, Michelles's, Oprah's, or all of them combined. She is an icon.
She is an icon for the neurotic
3 hour's worth of anti oil barron propaganda ? No thanks .
There is revolution coming, and there is NOTHING that the Republicans, or Democrats, the Pope, the NAACP, professional wrestling, or anybody else you can think of, can do to change that. We humans are gobbling up the Earth's bounty like there is no tomorrow, wasting life as if it meant nothing, and have proved to be an ungrateful and spiteful species. There will be an end to it, and it will be a revolution that does so. If we are fortunate, it will be a revelation as well.
It won't happen now. It's football season. Maybe plan something after the Super Bowl. Which my Lions won't be in...again.
Randy :
"It won't happen now. It's football season. Maybe plan something after the Super Bowl. Which my Lions won't be in...again."
There's also Halloween, Thanksgiving, Christmas and New Years Day. Maybe sometime in ... I dunno ... August? One has to schedule revolutions carefully to avoid holidays.
Well the Super Bowl is on February 7th, but Baseball's 1st Spring Training game isn't until in Florida on March 1st, so they can have a very short and fast revolution then. Certainly it has to be over by Opening Day of the regular season on April 3rd!!
Unless, of course, ESPN gets the contract to cover the revolution. Then all bets are off. Personally I think it should go to a broadcast type network so everyone can watch it.
Who do the networks go to to buy the exclusive broadcast rights to the next American Revolution? I mean if you make a deal with the losing team their check will be worthless. I'd collect a heavy advance payment if I were them! And no residuals for the winners either.
I'll bet Bud will be the offical beer sponsor! And Frito-Lay will be the official chip/snack sponsor.
That's an excellent picture of how we lost the war in Iraq. Small Arms and IED's defeating our advanced military.
Our advance military had ROI's... An all out war would have destroyed both.
Dean, BF, you both need a lesson in military tactics and ROI's.
Riiight. Guerilla resistance never works... The Soviets sure had it easy in Afghanistan...
Yeah, the Afgans turned the war with ''STINGER'' missiles.
BTW, those Stinger missiles were supplied by the U.S.
Read ''Charlies Wilson War'' and you might get an idea of what your taking about Cereknov
And other weapons that we gave to them.
BF, a couple of things. First you missed the point entirely. The meme is a response to those that think ''their guns'' would stop the US Military, if the US Government became ''gun grabbers''....Read some of the comments. No one suggested that the US Military was killing civilians.
Where the military personal come from doesn't have anything to do with it, neither does Ron Paul.
A ''Red State Army'', WTF does that mean, and what are you suggesting with your last paragraph?
Are you speaking for the military?
What America REALLY needs is not a revolution, it needs EVOLUTION.
I don't know, Buzz, I like myself pretty well as I am, and there are several Americans I can say the same about... some of them even here on NT.
You liberal weenies would be asking your wives and girlfriends to stand up for you while you hang out at Starbucks and stare at each other's mules.
If you're ever in my neighborhood, I'll introduce you to some of the "weenies" in South Philly.
Yeah … Revolution … why would anyone revolt?
Reason 1
Five predominantly black churches in St. Louis hit by arson in the last week
Reason 2
Cry Me a River
Reason 3
If there are any gambling men among you, the DISLIKE totals reveal a close contest; I may start a "DISLIKE/THUMBS DOWN" Fantasy League.
The League Rules are in the process of formulation … the basic logistic will be to
• Submit the NAME OF ANY ONE MEMBER -- JUST ONE (1) -- WHO YOU SPECULATE WILL REGISTER THE MOST DISLIKE/THUMBS DOWN VOTES WITHIN A DESIGNATED RANGE OF DATES (as stipulated per each contest)
• Along with the MEMBER'S NAME, SPECIFY THE TOTAL NUMBER OF DISLIKE/THUMBS DOWN VOTES YOU THINK THAT MEMBER WILL REGISTER WITHIN THE DESIGNATED RANGE OF DATES … and …
• THE NAME OF THE MOST OFTEN-TARGETED RECIPIENT OF THOSE DISLIKE/THUMBS DOWN VOTES
EXAMPLE:
√ DISLIKER/THUMBS DOWNER'S NAME = NT MEMBER "X"
√ DISLIKER/THUMBS DOWNER'S MOST TARGETED MEMBER = NT MEMBER "Y"
√ DISLIKER/THUMBS DOWNER'S TOTAL DISLIKE/THUMBS DOWN VOTES DURING THE DESIGNATED RANGE OF DATES = (i.e.) "46"
Watch for further details …
________________________________________________________
Weekly totals will be posted along with those who have racked them up! *
* In deference to those who always bitch about the "lack of transparency".
{I speculate that this comment will start the ball rolling -- THUMBS UP/LIKE VOTES WILL BE APPRECIATED BUT WILL NOT BE TALLIED AND POSTED}
What bunch of whiny crap that has nothing to do with the article. Congratulations you won my first thumbs down.