THE LEFT’S WAR ON COMMENT SECTIONS
THE LEFT’S WAR ON COMMENT SECTIONS
computer keyboardAP Photo/Damian Dovarganes
by ALLUM BOKHARI
27 Oct 2015
4,338
The internet was born open but is becoming closed everywhere. Nowhere is this more apparent than in the rush to shutter readers’ comments sections at major news organisations. Cheered on by intolerant, snobbish cultural elites, news organisations from The Verge to The Daily Beast have, in recent months, informed their readers to take their opinions elsewhere.
Dozens of progressive blogs and news outlets are following suit, citing “abuse” and “harassment” as the primary reasons they no longer want to hear the opinions of their readers. But that’s not what is really going on.
There was a time when comments sections were seen as the next step in a golden age of democratised communication, particularly by the political Left. “For the first time ever, we are thinking aloud, unfiltered by mass media gatekeepers,” wrote a former Hillary Clinton advisor in 2008. “Never before has the global discourse been so accessible, recursive, and durable.”
In 2009, the former online editor for the Washington Post wrote that despite their problems, readers’ comments allowed readers to “complain about what they see as unfairness or inaccuracy” and remind editors that they “do not always agree with journalists about what is important.”
The late Georgina Henry, former editor of the Guardian’s online commentary pages, wrote in 2010 that “journalism without feedback, engagement, dispute and opinion from below the line no longer feels complete to me.” Indeed, the Guardian was once so enamoured of its comments section that it ran a weekly feature, Below the Line, in which “delightful, prolific, or controversial members of the Guardian comment community” were invited to profile themselves.
The rise of comments sections coincided with the rise of another high-minded idea: the Crowd. If TED talks from the early 2010s are to be believed, the Crowd was set to revolutionise government, end poverty, and cure cancer. In an age when the Crowd was going to fix the world’s problems, it stood to reason that they should fix public discourse as well.
But the era of Silicon Valley-led optimism is over, at least for the journalists and publications that once eagerly reported on it. Today, the tone is misanthropic, not utopian, and the Crowd – at least as it appears in the comment boxes – is portrayed not as saviour, but as a sort of barbarous horde at the gates of politically-correct progressive society.
“Vibrant online communities? Or cesspits of abuse?” asked the BBC in a recent feature on the closure of comments sections. “Alongside shouting, swearing and incivility, comments sections can also attract racism and sexism,” the article continued.
This refrain can be found in almost every left-leaning publication these days. The Pacific Standard: “Even if [comments sections] aren’t vile and psychologically damaging, most of them aren’t worth your time.” Brooklyn Magazine: “Most comment sections are vats of poison, filled with grammatically questionable rants at best and violent hate speech at worst.” The Atlantic: “Online comments are often ignorant, racist, sexist, threatening, or otherwise worthless. But you knew that already.”
At the risk of sounding too self-congratulatory, here at Breitbart we embrace our readers’ opinions. We love hearing from you guys! And there are a lot of you: 1.2 million comments, not including Facebook, are left on Breitbart.com each month. We are in fact one of the most enthusiastically commented-upon sites anywhere on the internet.
There’s a gross double standard in what’s going on in the progressive mediasphere, of course. Many of the columnists who complain the loudest about spiky comments are themselves professional provocateurs. Consider Guardian columnist Jessica Valenti, the most recent commentator to complain about the “noxious thoughts” and “sea of garbage” in the comments section.
But Valenti is paid to write deliberately inflammatory columns, with titles like “Feminists don’t hate men, but it wouldn’t matter if we did.” She is also notorious for wearing a shirt bearing the slogan “I bathe in male tears.” Valenti is a great example of what one savvy blogger called an “above-the-line troll.” She may write columns rather than comments, but, like any troll, her words are designed to inflame and antagonise.
It’s no accident that so many of the loudest voices against online comments sections are also political zealots. Jessica Valenti, Arthur Chu, Tauriq Moosa, Anita Sarkeesian: all have come out against comment sections. This isn’t an accident, of course. Psychologists have long been aware that political extremists have the most negative reactions to contrary information. Combine that with a disdain for free speech, a core cultural authoritarian value, and you get a frantic rush to remove the opinions of ordinary people.
But there are also more sinister, elitist motivations. A study conducted by The Washington Post and USA Today found that readers who viewed articles with comments sections were more likely to develop a negative opinion of the news media. Curiously, this effect was seen even when commenters praised the article in question. In other words, when the opinions of journalists and the opinions or ordinary members of the public are placed close together, it leads readers to question the competence of the mainstream media. What horror!
Another study found that reading assertive, aggressive comments could actually sway the opinions of readers. “Don’t read the comments,” warned Ars Technica, “they can make you mistrust real experts.”
It’s a piece of advice that captures the war on comments sections perfectly. Having initially cheered on the death of the “gatekeepers of information,” cultural elites are now scrambling to reinstall those barriers. Too late, they have discovered that people don’t always agree with them – and now they want to push that disagreement into the wilderness of the internet.
For a while online, authoritarian progressives forgot that vanishingly few people in the real world agree with their feverish and silly “hot takes” on current news and their bizarre ideas about racism and sexism. Now the whole population is tech-savvy enough to have their say, authoritarians are scrambling for a return to the era of broadcast news, in which viewers were left with calling up the station and ranting down the phone as their only means of robust criticism. http://www.breitbart.com/tech/2015/10/27/the-lefts-war-on-comment-sections/

The article comes from Breitbart. Breitbart is easily one of the worst offenders when it comes to racist and otherwise offensive comments. They have closed articles to comments numerous times because there was so much racism and hate on them.
So we can assume they are not changing anything.
I've stopped reading articles I can't comment on. If it's one that interests, I look it up on another news feed that allows comments.
If I'm going to put the article up here, I may go back to the news feed that doesn't allow comments for some reason or other, for instance if that article has a better picture to copy.
NBC used to have news from Mexico. About four years ago the Mexican government asked reporters in Mexico to filter their news reports through the government because Mexico was receiving a lot of "misunderstood" bad press that was affecting its international image and damaging tourist dollars. Most reporters agreed but two or three of them were highly upset and indignant about it; they refused. In the long run, NBC dropped its section of coverage of Mexico, two of the reporters who refused to cooperate with the news ban were killed by "the cartel," and the third fled to the US for sanctuary.
Dozens of progressive blogs and news outlets are following suit, citing “abuse” and “harassment” as the primary reasons they no longer want to hear the opinions of their readers. But that’s not what is really going on.
It's a joy you people are paranoid …
What do you mean by "you people"?
What do you mean by "you people"?
Which word(s) in the sentence don't you understand?
I'll give you some assistance.
The seeded article rails against … (from the article) …
" … intolerant, snobbish cultural elites, news organisations (article author's misspelling) from The Verge to The Daily Beast have, in recent months, informed their readers to take their opinions elsewhere."
" … TO TAKE THEIR OPINIONS ELSEWHERE.
So, some of us come here to BRING OUR (dissenting) OPINIONS … and WTF do the defenders of the seeded article do … they bad mouth and insult us for bringing our opinions!
From badfish …
Evidently Dumb and Dumber have arrived to complain about the seed instead of offering any resemblance of an argument to dispute anything in the article.
With a pile on from Woodie …
Of course they did, BF they are famous for that kind of shit.
Those on the left here at NT will always try and shut down opinion speech. They cannot stand someone with differing opinion. In fact they don't like opinions.PERIOD.
Yeah those that gripe about some of the articles and a lot of the people on this site are the ones that really bring it down to the gutter. Now we know why many of our members do not comment any more. Shut down freedom of their spoken opinions and you have anarchy.
From XX …
The left hates free expression and freedom of speech on social media. For them it's all about content control and limiting what others can say. To the left, no speech is better than tolerating speech they disagree with. To them it's all about control and they get their little feelers hurt when they are exposed to a contrary point of view. Closing comment sections? Simply ridiculous!
Is this how the right encourages bringing one's opinion?
THESE PEOPLE, Bloody Bill … these people … these people who view dissenting opinion as trying to "shut down freedom of spoken opinions."
Possibly the irony and hypocrisy will not escape your scrutiny.
I have answered your question.
“A hypocrite is the kind of politician who would cut down a redwood tree, then mount the stump and make a speech for conservation.”
― Adlai E. Stevenson II
(With noted disregard to Matthew 7:6)
Evidently Dumb and Dumber have arrived to complain about the seed instead of offering any resemblance of an argument to dispute anything in the article.
Brilliant....
Talk about discouraging/trying to close discussion. You support an article objecting to an alleged stifling of dissent … while simultaneously insulting those who come to enter the discussion!
Dumbest.
Where's the semblance of your "argument"?
Don't bother … I won't return to this.
We've had wars on drugs, women and now comment sections. I say we should declare war on convenience store corn dogs. I got one the other day and it upset my tummy. Someone has to do something!
This article is a mess and full of ironies. The first thing to address is calling out an entire class of people for doing something... in this case censorship. But since the topic was censorship, I found it hard to regulate what was going on, in the article. During the course of the discussion, there were many nasty comments made, most just within the CoC. Quite clever. Kept my hands tied. Also the subject matter did that, too. And to be honest, I saw insults from both sides of the political fence. More like kids taunting each other in a playground. Really sad. No one gets points for taking the high ground here and in fact, I am at a crossroads as to behavior on the site. Being rude to one another, I don't regard as censorship. I regard it as being decent. My feeling is that no one would talk to anyone like this in real life, and if you did, you might have some consequences. You become keyboard warriors here, and that is floating with me less and less. This site should be a new beginning, and I have to figure out where the cut off should be. And for the record, all of these "Call Outs" are out of line.
There is one big problem with y'all. When I comment and give my opinion on a subject it is just that. My opinion. I DO NOT have to provide facts for my opinion. You do not like it tuff shit. But you can't even respect a person for giving their opinion. Thus no conversation or discussion can ensue. All you can do is denigrate and name call, and for some of you troll someone.
This individual regularly contradicts proven facts with his "opinion". It is one thing to contend whether or not Obama is a good president , it is another to contend whether or not he is president. This is the level of falsity that is often brought to this forum. Some people spend a good amount of time providing factual or at least truly debatable information to this forum in the form of links , quotes, expert opinion etc. then you have someone like Woodie, who insults people who "copy and paste" , as if he would fare any better if they didn't. ROFL.
There are some people on this forum , mostly on the conservative side but it could be either conservative or liberal, who demand the right to argue from a position of misinformation and ignorance. This will never be a recipie for peace on a site, and I think you know that.
And why are people on NT so doggedly insistent about having urinary Olympics with their name calling and debasement of other members?
And why are people on NT so doggedly insistent about having urinary Olympics with their name calling and debasement of other members?
Most likely because, although NT is unique in many ways as a social news site, its' membership represents a cross section of your typical bloggers and political pundits.
It's these personal attacks like this that slow new member enrollments.
"That is one of the most ridiculous things I've seen written here and it's no surprise that it comes from you"
Wow Randy you are working for a better Newstalkers....Impressive!
I guess it is just a matter of perspective. And also it's a guessing game as to who or what you are referring to in this comment BF put up. The site is confusing to me in that respect, not necessarily because of the site, but it is always nice to see the comment a person is referring to when replying to it. Your comment may be completely applicable, but I've found all you have to do is copy the comment, use the indent and even you the italic, then put you comment under it and don't indent. Sometimes you have to indent another time to get the one you are referring to be a little more to the right, but I think this helps verify who or what a person is replying to