The Bible Believers’ speech, though protected, was far from harmless. Their demonstrations ruined the nation’s largest public Arab American event
http://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2015/11/first-amendment-troubling-shadow/413611/
Examining the record independently, the en banc majority concluded that the sheriff’s office had enough officers on hand to protect the Bible Believers, and should have done so:
The Bible Believers attended the Festival to exercise their First Amendment rights and spread their religious message. The way they conveyed their message may have been vile and offensive to most every person who believes in the right of their fellow citizens to practice the faith of his or her choosing; nonetheless, they had every right to espouse their views ... When the message was ill-received, the police did next to nothing to protect the Bible Believers or to contain the lawlessness of the hecklers in the crowd. Instead, [they] accused the Bible Believers of being disorderly and removed them from the Festival. On this record, there can be no reasonable dispute that the [sheriff’s office] effectuated a heckler’s veto, thereby violating the Bible Believers’ First Amendment rights.
Bible Believers displays vividly the underlying strength of the American commitment to free speech—and the troubling shadow that commitment inevitably casts.
Only a few things that public speakers say can be punished. “Islam is bad” isn’t one of them, even when said to a large, angry crowd of Muslims. A speaker who said, “Kill some Muslims now!” could be punished for incitement. A speaker who said to a specific person, “You are a disgusting infidel and your religion stinks and you are going to hell” might be punished for “fighting words.” A speaker who brandishes a pig’s head—or any other object—to convey a physical threat can be punished as well.
Otherwise, police can’t arrest a speaker for saying something awful.
The civil-rights era cases show why this is good. All too often, the police want to silence this world’s Irv Feiners because they don’t like what they have to say, and the “angry crowd” is a handy excuse.
But we pay a price for this freedom, and not everyone pays the price equally. The First Amendment imposes on us all the duty to maintain the peace even when our deepest beliefs are denounced. But that duty is doubly onerous for minorities, because they must endure such abuse more often and longer.
In a country that is 70 percent Christian, Muslims account for less than one percent of the population. Since 9/11, powerful religious and political figures have been openly campaigning to strip this tiny population of the protections of the Constitution.
In that context, the Bible Believers’ speech, though protected, was far from harmless. Their demonstrations ruined the nation’s largest public Arab American event—after the arrests in 2012, the Arab American Chamber of Commerce, sponsor of the festival for nearly 20 years, cancelled it.
The more I study the First Amendment, the more I think our system protects free speech not because it is harmless but precisely because it often does terrible harm. We may like to imagine that American society is at heart a kind of sunny Norman Rockwell small town; but it is not and never has been. Like all other societies, it embodies at its core a constant bitter struggle for cultural, religious, and political dominance. The Constitution makes a judgment that speech is the least bad way for that deadly competition to take place—not car bombs and bullets, but vicious images and words.
I wish I could talk to Irv Feiner about Bible Believers. He was a better lawyer than many who took the bar, and a better American than those who tried to ruin his life. His imagination, I think, would have room for concern about both the Muslim people of Dearborn and the aggressive bigots who destroyed their peaceful fair.

"In a country that is 70 percent Christian, Muslims account for less than one percent of the population. Since 9/11, powerful religious and political figures have been openly campaigning to strip this tiny population of the protections of the Constitution.
In that context, the Bible Believers’ speech, though protected, was far from harmless. Their demonstrations ruined the nation’s largest public Arab American event—after the arrests in 2012, the Arab American Chamber of Commerce, sponsor of the festival for nearly 20 years, cancelled it."
Muslims account for less than one percent of the population.
Are you all actually that afraid of one percent of the population ?
rofl.
I am not afraid of Muslims and that isn't the issue. The issue is the 1st ammendment John. Maybe the question should be are Muslims so afraid of Christians walking through a fair with an opposing view should be attacked.
Yes, I agree that those Christians had an agenda, which was to disrupt the fair. But how is that different from the Westboro Baptist church protesting outside of Funerals with "Rot in Hell" signs or Neo Nazis marching through the Jewish area of Skokie? The answer is it isn't. These acts are meant to provoke. The only difference is that our courts found in favor of these provocations when it had to do with Christians and Jews, but makes special exceptions for Muslims. That is not right. We should all be treated as equal under the law. Jews are a minority, and yet they had to deal with Neo Nazis. How are they any different from these Muslims?
As I told you Perrie, the Christians at Muslim street fair were not denied their rights. They were not prevented from entering the area of the fair (which does consist of specifically designated blocks) nor were they prevented from beginning their hate speech proselytizing. They had their free speech. It was when "violence" ensued in the form of some small items thrown at the Christians, that the police chief told them they had to leave.
You like to talk about Skokie. What if at Skokie, violence broke out between the Nazis and the Jewish neighborhood they were in? Would the police have told the Jewish residents to leave, or the Nazis who provoked the violence ?
You've got Nazis on the brain John . That is a symptom of your beliefs and attitudes . Go on . Say it out loud : you hate Jews ...
Petey, I think that's an unfair statement. I don't think John hates Jews, but I think he loves Muslims. He loves them to the extent that he is blind to any fault.
As much as I'd like to agree with that Buzz , I have never seen him say anything good about muslims . There isn't much good to say about a religion which is unchanged since the 7th century . All you can do is point out repeatedly that muslims are only 1 % of the population . That could easily change ... because the others are not reproducing much .
Well, as has been pointed out by those who defend extremist Islam, only 1% (described elsewhere as a "tiny sliver", their view of the percentage, not mine) of the perhaps 200,000 Muslim adults in America (John's estimate of the numbers) could be violent, that means there could be only 2000 Americans throughout the USA who might be killers. Well, one killer can kill more than one person, as 9/11, Fort Hood and the Boston Marathon have established.
Thumbs down on a factual statement. No doubt who did that.
Petey you have a lame brain. I am talking about Nazis no more or less than Perrie was talking about Nazis when we were discussing this earlier.
Go inflict your "off the wall" commentary on someone else please.
The population of the United States is about 320 million I believe. Of those, maybe 200 million are adults.
There is virtually NO "Muslim" violence committed in the United States, so what the heck are you talking about?
Are you saying that every Muslim here is a potential terrorist ? What do you want to do, put them in internment camps ?
"There is virtually NO "Muslim" violence committed in the United States, so what the heck are you talking about? "
Well that statement is a testament to how ignorant on the subject you really are.
Date Location #dead#injured Description of attack
You found 74 violent crimes over the span of 42 years, or less than 2 per year*. I hope you are proud.
* for the whole country
That is virtually NO Muslim crime.
Yep.
Muslim sympathizers should go to the same camps as the Muslim scum themselves, see how far they get when imprisoned with their favorite extremists.
I figured you would be screwed up enough to site the whole period and ignore the fact that 546 of the deaths happened in the last in the last 15 years. Nice attempt at defending your ignorance with more of the same.
The Muslim percentage of the U.S. population is 1%, so the percentage of radical Muslims in the U.S. must be less than that. But we'll call it one percent. You say they are responsible for 548 murders over the past 15 years, or 36 per year.
There have been 235,935 murders in the U.S. in the past 15 years. http://www.disastercenter.com/crime/uscrime.htm According to you, 546 of those have been "Muslim" murders. That is a little more than ONE FIFTH of ONE PERCENT (546/235935). Or appx 5 times less murders than expected from the one percent Muslim population.
Now that I take another look at the chart, I have no idea where you come up with the 546 figure. There is no way to add up any of these figures and come up with 546.
Oh well, that was a wasted 15 minutes.
You're right if you start counting from 2011 it should actually be 571. My bad, didn't give them enough credit.
What in the world are you looking at ?
Internment camps, great idea! At least until the work camps are ready.
Every year Chicago has the largest African American parade in the country , the back-to-school Bud Billiken parade in August. They have held it since 1929 and it goes down Martin Luther King drive through the heart of black neighborhoods.
Should the Bud Billiken parade be required to allow the KKK or some confederate flag waving group march in their parade or even stand on the side protesting it ? If white supremacists and racist groups are allowed to participate, and there is trouble, and the parade is cancelled after 86 years, who is to blame ?
Everything is not a matter of constitutional rights. What about right and wrong ?
Everything is not a matter of constitutional rights. What about right and wrong ?
Actually John, everything IS a matter of Constitutional rights. How do you define right and wrong? Who's right? Who's wrong? When does your "right" become my "wrong"?
This is the heart of the problem with liberal thinking NOW. You think that something offensive must be stopped, because it falls in your catagory of wrong. But you fail to remember that you do not have a right to not be offended. It's just not there.
You know you've hit a nerve when John has to post a counterpoint article.
It is a badge to be attacked by you and Bruce. I know then I am doing something right.
Your attempts to put words in my mouth are as lame now as they are every other time you try it.
Everything is not a matter of constitutional rights. What about right and wrong ?
Who's right and wrong, yours? Someone's version of right and wrong superseding the Constitution, is no different than using the Bible or the Koran to do so. In the US, how we apply law to interpret right and wrong, is formalized by the Constitution.
Larry, the Muslims didn't go to a Christian festival and try to start a riot, the Christians went to a Muslim festival and insulted the religion and the culture. It is not surprising there was some minor violence.
What the hell were they doing there? Preaching on behalf of Jesus ? rofl.
On the groups website they have anti-Islam articles and say they are unabashedly pro Jew and pro Israel.
What does that have to do with religion ?
Nice deflection John, why don't you try to answer his question?
He did answer the question. If you can't figure out who's right and who's wrong from this comment, you have issues.
"...the Muslims didn't go to a Christian festival and try to start a riot, the Christians went to a Muslim festival and insulted the religion and the culture."
Actually the issue wasn't figuring out who was right or wrong. The issue was (is) do we allow someone's version of right and wrong to supersede the Constitution?
No, the question wasn't answered. Instead John responded by reminding me of his reasons for determining right and wrong as it pertains to this particular issue.
Larry, the Muslims didn't go to a Christian festival and try to start a riot, the Christians went to a Muslim festival and insulted the religion and the culture. It is not surprising there was some minor violence.
What the hell were they doing there? Preaching on behalf of Jesus ? rofl.
On the groups website they have anti-Islam articles and say they are unabashedly pro Jew and pro Israel.
What does that have to do with religion ?
the Christians went to a Muslim festival and insulted the religion and the culture.
Some cultures are awfully touchy about what they find insulting . Look what happened at the Charles Hebdo offices in France . A death sentence for posting cartoons of big Mo ? What happened to freedom of speech ?
What happened to freedom of speech ?
The concept of free speech is embodied in the Constitution of the United States of America, they pretty much don't pay any attention to our constitution in the Middle East.
Huh ? This festival was in Michigan , not the middle east . Wake the fuck up !
@ Jerry:
"The concept of free speech is embodied in the Constitution of the United States of America, they pretty much don't pay any attention to our constitution in the Middle East."
As established by Pamela Geller's championing free speech in Garland, Texas? - at least the armed attackers were killed before they could kill anyone.
As established by Pamela Geller's championing free speech in Garland, Texas?
Pamela Geller was not "championing" free speech, she was abusing free speech, and she almost got people killed in the process.
We as Americans are blessed with many Rights and privileges not afforded to people in many other countries, but along with those Rights and privileges comes the responsibility of respecting and protecting them, not misusing and abusing them.
Then she proved that "free speech" is extremely limited when Islam is involved in some way. America seems to have a fractured view of its First Amendment - there are more limitations to it when Islam is involved than any other circumstances. If the KKK had a conference wherein they disparaged Judaism, I'll bet no Jew would have walked in with a gun to try to kill the speakers.
Huh ? This festival was in Michigan , not the middle east . Wake the fuck up !
I think that comment is in response to something I said. You need to learn to use block quotes so people will know what you're talking about.
If you're referring to my response regarding your Charlie Hebdo comment, that happened in France, but the Islamics in both incidents are from the Middle East.
And, if you would wake the fuck up you would see that I posted the following comment in response to your post;
Did you see the story from today's news about the woman stoned to death in Afghanistan ? No ?
"This event happened in Dearborn Michigan Petey, not in Afghanistan. I don't think they're going to be stoning anyone in Dearborn real soon."
Nah, the muslims dont go to Christian festivals. They go to Christian countries and kill those who wont convert.
They go to Christian countries and kill those who wont convert.
They're clearly following the Christian model of the Middle Age and the Crusades.
I thought the Middle Ages were behind us. Either we are civilized or we're primitive savages.
I thought the Middle Ages were behind us. Either we are civilized or we're primitive savages.
The Middle Ages are behind us, as far as Christianity is concerned. However, Christianity is 1,500 years older than Islam. Making Islam at about the same place in its' development as the Christians were during the Middle ages. Actually Christians were burning people at the stake over religious issues in this country as late as the 17th century.
Now the morbid history of Christianity does not justify the barbaric behavior of todays' Islamist Extremist, but it should give us a better perspective into why these people are acting the way they are.
It is important to understand as much about a problem as possible in order to resolve that problem.
Sorry Jerry, but am I mistaken to think that Islam was about 1400 years old. ???
I think the point is that the world has matured generally. The terrorists carry around smart phones and drive vehicles, use guns instead of sabres, watch TV and see how the rest of the world live. I really don't think they are so far behind us other than the unbelievable philosophical restrictions and edicts of the Q'oran they venerate.
That's bullshit Jerry.
If they are THAT retarded and unable to keep up with modern education they are not capable of associating with civilized societies and need to be left to their own devices until they develop on their own to the point of being acceptable.
Round them up and take them back to their primitive villages.
Please read Gene Roddenberry's "Prime Directive." It can be found under "Star Trek." It should be the guiding principle for the United States and every country on the planet trying to "develop" what it considers a backward nation. Just leave them the hell alone and allow them to come into modern centuries on their own.
Jerry,
ELIMINATE the problem.
Gee another reference trying to excuse violence being perpetrated today by citing violence others carried out hundreds of years ago. I guess that never gets old Huh?
Hell's bells, Jerry, if the Crusades is the best you can do, give it a rest. It's disgusting the way people like you apologize for the murders these asses commit by dragging in the Crusades. The Crusades??? These aren't tapestries you're looking at in the daily news, these are real people who were alive and breathing yesterday, this morning, until they were burned alive in cages, or had their heads chopped off by the people you are excusing because of actions taken by the pedophile church of centuries long past.
Read my comment above, John.
The real "Arab heritage" of Dearborn is Christian, not Muslim. The festival was a mockery and a lie if it was being defined as only "Dearborn's Arab Heritage."
They need to rename it as "Dearborn's Arab Muslim Heritage." Because there are two distinct Arab heritages in Dearborn. The Muslims haven't even been there long enough to really have a "heritage" in Dearborn. They should leave out the "heritage" aspect and just call it an Arab Muslim Festival.
Quoting from the majority opinion: "[I]t is also easy to understand Dearborn's desire to host a joyous festival celebrating the city's Arab heritage in an atmosphere that is free of hate and negative influences. But the answer to disagreeable speech is not violent retaliation by offended listeners or ratification of the of the heckler's veto through threat of arrest by the police. The adults who did not join in the assault on the Bible Believers knew that violence was not the answer; the parents who pulled their children away likewise recognized that the Bible Believers could simply be ignored; and a few adolescents, instead of hurling bottles, engaged in debate regarding the validity of the Bible Believers' message. Wayne County, however, through its Deputy Chiefs and Corporation Counsel, effectuated a constitutionally impermissible heckler's veto by allowing an angry mob of riotous adolescents to dictate what religious beliefs and opinions could and could not be expressed. This the Constitution does not allow."
Dearborn's Arab heritage is an Arab CHRISTIAN heritage. The Arab Muslims didn't take over Dearborn until around 2003. Dearborn is an American city in an American town in an American state in the country of the United States of America, which happens to contain a large majority of transplanted Arab Muslims.
I would be interested to know if the "celebration" included the Arab Christians who really settled Dearborn along with the Arab Muslims, or if the Arab Muslims have overwhelmed the Christians with intimidation of Islam. In just a very short time of being there, the Muslims built the Islamic Center of America , the largest mosque in North America, [25] and the Dearborn Mosque . There are often comments about Dearborn being "Muslim" but never any articles about the Arab Christians who first settled there and built the city up. It would be enlightening to see an article on the subject.
You know it is funny how articles about this incident I read that try to insinuate the Christian group was being insulting but I have seen no proof to back up any of these accusations and there is no proof of this in the video(s), and the article making the accusations never offers proof.
The Arab American event was cancelled because the attendees have a hard time controlling themselves and the organizers knew there would be violence in the future. Simple as that. They know their own my friend, and they don't believe in free speech.
That is the "Christians" walking through the Muslim festival carrying a sign that reads
Muhammad Is A Liar
False Prophet
Murderer
Child Molesting
Pervert
Is it your opinion 96W, that such language is not "insulting"
You guys are something else.
You guys are something else.
Yeah they are, I think they call it bigotry.
Like assuming Jews are KKK members...
Since the descriptions are all accurate they should [in theory] not be insulting . Big Mo was no angel in the way he lived his life . Using him as an example of exemplary behavior will inevitably lead to bad decisions in life .
And the Judeo Christian god murdered the earth. What's your point, Petey?
The way you keep repeating that bible myth you are starting to sound like a believer . Mo really did exist . He really did raid caravans to make money . And he really did marry a 9 yr old girl . And we haven't even gotten to the murder and rape !
The way you stated that makes it sound like an admission that god/Jesus doesn't exist. Dr. Lujah makes a breakthrough with Petey!
Yeh!!!!
Yeh!!!!
The way comments move from their original location as additional responses are added to a comment, makes it imperative that we always post a "quote" to insure the readers know who and/or what we're referring to with our responses.
I do that, but I also suggested that we use a technique I saw elsewhere:
@ Jerry:
That way everyone will know to whom the comment is directed.
@Jerry
That way everyone will know to whom the comment is directed.
But they won't know what comment is being answered. Especially if that person had posted multiple comments on the thread. What was said is more important than who said it.
@ Jerry:
"But they won't know what comment is being answered. Especially if that person had posted multiple comments on the thread. What was said is more important than who said it."
Okay, agreed. The quotation being addressed should also be entered.
I'll repost it.
The way you stated that makes it sound like an admission that god/Jesus doesn't exist. Dr. Lujah makes a breakthrough with Petey!
Yeh!!!!
Hal ,
You will never figure out what I believe or don't believe . Haven't you ever even considered the possibility that some of the bible is rhetoric designed to subdue the ignorant masses ?
You will never figure out what I believe or don't believe
Either will anyone else on this site Petey. Personally I haven't been able to figure out anything about you.
I mean I have some ideas, but the CoC constrains me from expressing my assessment.
You could figure out a lot more if you just took your head out of your ass ...
"You will never figure out what I believe or don't believe ."
I doubt if you will ever figure that out either.
"Haven't you ever even considered the possibility that some of the bible is rhetoric designed to subdue the ignorant masses ?"
Wow, have we met? That that an atheist axiom.
Notice that I used the word "some" . An atheist would have said "all" .
So, you are a Buffet Christian? Picking and choosing elements from the Christian doctrine to create the best little Christian offshoot for your personal tastes? How original ... not.
buffet Christian
Your attempts to discredit me are getting more complex and less powerful . Frankly your arguments are boring and only worthy of scorn . Here's one for you Hal : atheists are the absolutists in their beliefs ... at least you are . It's hard being you ... ain't it ?!
Lol - discrediting you is about as effortless as it is to be me. For example, your simple claim that atheists have common beliefs (plural) is wrong by definition alone.
The earth seems pretty un-murdered from where I type. Having hallucinations?
Petey , is it insulting or not for the members of one religion to say extremely disparaging things about the other religion ?
Or are you even capable of giving the question thought ?
Or are you even capable of giving the question thought ?
(?!)
How many comments of Peteys' have you ever seen that contained any evidence of him putting any thought into them?
Is it insulting ? Maybe . So what ? In the west we have learned to shrug those insults off :
BTW how about the factuality of those comments ?
Interesting no one was killed over this. I wonder what wold happen if it was the profit Mohammad instead of Jesus.
Well that is the first time I have seen proof. Regardless, countering free speech with violence is unacceptable.
The sign behind says "Every Knee Shall Bow, Every Tongue Shall Confess That Jesus Christ Is Lord".
I think if Muslims paraded with similar signs through some festival filled with Christians in Tennessee or Georgia, the results would be similar to what happened in Dearborn.
I think if Muslims paraded with similar signs through some festival filled with Christians in Tennessee or Georgia, the results would be similar to what happened in Dearborn.
I think nothing would happen and therefore we would hear nothing about it.
I believe all of those slogans are supported by the Koran.
They know their own my friend, and they don't believe in free speech.
"They know their own"?! That's a defense?!
Give me a break, The 1st Amendment Right to free speech does not grant the Right to use that speech to harass, provoke and to incite a riot. The Christians clearly abused the 1st in deliberately provoking the Muslims to react violently.
We also have the Right to carry a firearm, but if you use a firearm to threaten of intimidate your're breaking the law, just as using your Right to free speech to incite a riot is against the law.
It's time people stopped assuming the 1st allows them to say anything they want. Try using the 1st amendment as a defense for filing a false police report.
I find it interesting that Right Wingers advocate and often resort to violence to resolve issues and to protect their own, but when they encounter someone that responds them in that same manner, like a bunch of crybabies, they run to authorities looking for protection.
The facts remain that the organizers decided to cancel it because they thought there would be more violence. Spin that any way you want.
Deleted to due to personal attack You really hate to lose and just can't handle the embarrassment you cause yourself.
The MUSLIM's were in the wrong - physical violence - period.
1st - the courts decide what they do. I don't have any issue with the court decision as such.
The "Christians" went there with the intention to incite trouble, not preach Christianity. The police and the mayor knew that, because they were aware of the people with the signs and the pig's head.
There is a question of right and wrong beyond the "free speech " issue, as the seed demonstrates.
All this thread shows is how anti-Muslim this site is.
blah blah blah blah blah - my way, my way, my way - blah blah blah blah - my way, my way, my way, my way.
You and Jerry both were born doing absolute nothing wrong and I'm sorry the rest of us get in your way while you both walk on water.
blah blah blah blah blah - my way, my way, my way - blah blah blah blah - my way, my way, my way, my way.
John - the court ruled YOU'RE WRONG - this thread has shown YOU'RE WRONG - and Jerry - under the 1st Amendment I can and am telling both of you to STFU. Your issue with that?????
Your issue with that?????
Are you a comedian ?
I have only said about 10 times today that I am not objecting to the court decision. The "Christians" were in the wrong, but not because a court said so , or not. They were in the wrong because it is wrong for one ethnic or religious group to go to another group's party and try to crash it with offensive signs and speeches.
Besides that, no one infringed on the Christian's free speech. They expressed themselves, provoked violence (as they planned) , and were sent home.
Funny how an atheist can't even put a sign on a bus that says one word ("atheism") without Christians objecting, but a group of Christians can waltz into a Muslim community and run their mouths in as degrading a manner as they wish ... and then have the gall to perpetuate their crusade about Christians being persecuted in the US. Fucking ridiculous.
Of course.
That makes no sense. In both cases, people were expressing free speech. You just can't see the difference because of your bias.
Funny how an atheist can't even put a sign on a bus that says one word ("atheism") without Christians objecting,
Atheists are too damn cheap to spend money on bus advertising .
Then why are you still mouthing about it? The court was right. The people exercised their free speech and they were beat up. Whether they intentionally started to agitate isn't the issue. They are guaranteed the right to voice their opinion as long as it doesn't violate another person's basic Constitutional rights. Fighting because you're angry is not a Constitutional right - freedom of speech is - "if" . . . . . .
You and Jerry both were born doing absolute nothing wrong and I'm sorry the rest of us get in your way while you both walk on water.
Thanks 1st, I appreciate the compliment, but you don't have to worry about being in the way, you're fairly easy to ignore.
"....under the 1st Amendment I can and am telling both of you to STFU. Your issue with that?????"
No issue at all, I mean it's a little contrary to your position as an advocate for free speech, but when I see you saying things like that I just consider the source.
All this thread shows is how anti-Muslim this site is.
This site? I think that's a little disingenuous John. For sure there are a lot of anti-Muslim Islamaphobic bigots signed on here, but I don't think they represent the tone of the entire sight.
Did you see the story from today's news about the woman stoned to death in Afghanistan ? No ?
Here it is ... enjoy !
BTW she was not Islamophobic . But she should have been ...
Did you see the story from today's news about the woman stoned to death in Afghanistan ? No ?
This event happened in Dearborn Michigan Petey, not in Afghanistan. I don't think they're going to be stoning anyone in Dearborn real soon.
I don't think they're going to be stoning anyone in Dearborn real soon.
Would you like to see some news items about beheadings from that region ? Just as dead as being stoned to death !
Would you like to see some news items about beheadings from that region ?
Would you like to see some of the more abhorrent of the 5,158 articles we collected in the NV Child Abuse & Abductions group? They contain everything from beating infants to death, to starvation, to rape. One story was about an infant found burned alive in a oven.
Those stories were crimes committed by Americans! Every culture has it's criminals.
Some American Muslims;
Kareem Abdul-Jabbar
Chicago Bulls' Craig Hodges
Shaquille O'Neil
Casey Kasem
Cat Stevens
Actress Ellen Burstyn
Dr. Oz
David Bowies' wife, Iman
George Clooneys' wife Amal
Mike Tyson
Muhammad Ali
David Chapple
Snoop Dog
There's a lot more.
To be anti-Muslim is the same as being anti-Semitic, it's bigotry.
@ Jerry
"To be anti-Muslim is the same as being anti-Semitic, it's bigotry. "
When, oh when in God's name, are people like you and John and others going to stop accusing members of NT, including myself, of being Islamophobes, and of articles we post that show horrific acts caused by radical Islamism as being bigoted. NOBODY HATES INNOCENT MUSLIMS!!!!! Who I hate, and I know I speak for others, is radical Islamists, jihadis, actual terrorists. I don't hate the people on the list you publish, unless THEY are anti-Semitic or intent on injuring or killing or just inflicting pain on people who are not "believers". As well I have neither love nor respect for those who wish to destroy Israel and annihilate its citizens. I have said before, and I say again, I would put my life in the hands of a Muslim like Dr. Jasser ( ). When I was touring Laniado Hospital in Netanya immediately after the Passover massacre, where most of the victims were treated, I was witness to and spoke with the wonderful Muslim doctors and nurses who treated Israeli Jews with loving care, who on the Sabbath and Jewish Holidays were trustingly left in total control of that Orthodox Jewish hospital.
Now that anti-Semitism is being brought into the picture here, I am reminded about the many times pro-Israel speakers have been invited to give lectures at American universities, and the pro-Palestinians heckle and shout and prevent the speaker from being heard. Nothing is done to prevent it or to punish the perps, because it's considered an exercise in the First Amendment right of free expression. Do I see a parallel here?
Some animals are more equal than others.
Buzz,
NOBODY HATES INNOCENT MUSLIMS!!!!!
I do. They are just as much to blame as their terrorist allies.
They are the enablers, the payers, the concealers... just as guilty, and just as deserving of the cruelest forms of justice.
@ The Stranger
"NOBODY HATES INNOCENT MUSLIMS!!!!!
I do. They are just as much to blame as their terrorist allies.
They are the enablers, the payers, the concealers... just as guilty, and just as deserving of the cruelest forms of justice."
So you are saying you hate Muslims like Dr. Jasser ( ) and Ayaan Hirsi Ali ( ) and Salmann Rushdie (3 examples of persons I would consider innocent Muslims). I am certain there are many more whom I don't know about. Again I say, it's wrong to generalize.
Every culture has it's criminals.
It is not the "culture" that has the criminals . It is the anti-culture that has them . But in the case of islam [especially in the middle east] the violations to life and liberty are culturally approved .
No, it's not. You claim to be against Bigots because of what they believe. How is it different of someone is against Muslims for what they believe? Leftist illogic.
No, it's not.
Who are you talking to?
Kareem Abdul-Jabbar
Chicago Bulls' Craig Hodges
Shaquille O'Neil
Casey Kasem
Cat Stevens
Actress Ellen Burstyn
Dr. Oz
David Bowies' wife, Iman
George Clooneys' wife Amal
Mike Tyson
Muhammad Ali
David Chapple
Snoop Dog
All expendable.
Casey Kasem
He already dead...
Randy,
Feel free to remove him from the list.
Unethical for a moderator.
@ Jerry:
"This event happened in Dearborn Michigan Petey, not in Afghanistan. I don't think they're going to be stoning anyone in Dearborn real soon."
But you cannot deny that "honour killings" are carried out in the USA. How about slicing off the clitoris of young girls?
But you cannot deny that "honour killings" are carried out in the USA. How about slicing off the clitoris of young girls?
We know honor killings occur in the US, but when the perps are caught they're charged with murder.
As far as the mutilations go, yes that is an abhorrent part of Muslim culture, but it's their culture, not ours. Anyway what does that have to do with the Christians in Dearborn Michigan inciting the local Muslim population and blaming the Muslims for reacting?
The article has to do with the type of reaction expected from that particular crowd, and that is based on their culture. My comment refers to their acceptable culture - which is NOT acceptable in civilized countries.
The article has to do with the type of reaction expected from that particular crowd, and that is based on their culture.
That's a bit of a stretch Buzz, but I get your point.
You are defending that as "culture"? Have you heard of "inalienable" rights?
How would you know, Jerry? If it happened, who in Dearborn would report it?
Islamaphobes: people against systematic oppression, murder, and genocide.
John - why don't you STFU, go home and grow up????
That's great 1st! During a discussion regarding the 1st Amendment and free speech, you tell to someone to shut up!
If either one of you needs a little growing up, it's you.
Since the deletion notice did not contain the ID of who made it , it can be safely ignored . Randy needs to get his act together .
"Since the deletion notice did not contain the ID of who made it , it can be safely ignored . Randy needs to get his act together."
How do you know it was Randy? Randy has already posted a comment on this article so he does not have the right to moderate it.
The more I study the First Amendment, the more I think our system protects free speech not because it is harmless but precisely because it often does terrible harm.
Speech was never protected because it was harmless. Quite the contrary, it is a potent weapon. It was the spark that led to the American revolution and the most important protection in the constitution's Bill of Rights. I find it ironic that so many have given their lives to protect this freedom yet some of us would now give up our freedom to protect our lives . . . and now some suggest that freedom should be further eroded to protect the "feelings" of others. The very purpose of free speech is to be able to say what others don't want to hear. People have a right to be rude and insensitive to others, even on the subject of religion and even if it's in bad taste (as the Christian protest surely was). No it's not "right" to insult others but it's legal and I'm glad it is. Rather than expect us to curb our liberties to accommodate the thin skin of those from other cultures unused to having their beliefs mocked, I think the new comers should grow a thicker skin or just find somewhere else to live.
Preferably the latter.
Muslims are scum, I can't wait until we start solving them as a problem.
Good point.
What's a good point?
Come on guys. Comments don't stay where they're originally posted. Is it really so hard to highlight, italicize and indent a quote?
The rest of seem to understand threading.
"Muslims are scum...."
There may be some that are, but then there are Christians, Jews, Buddhist, atheist and others that sometimes fit that category.
But one group of people that always fit that category are the Bigots.
Bigots are often less dangerous than Islamacists.
I have no idea how the YouTube videos I removed from this article showed up here in the first place. I put them on my Homepage and somehow I saw them here this morning. They're gone now.
Round them up for deportation, place them in camps, arrest them on sight.
Purge them.