Israel Bars Book From Schools Due To Its Discussion Of "Intimate Relations Between Jews and non-Jews"
Israel Bars Book From Schools Due To Its Discussion Of "Intimate Relations Between Jews and non-Jews"
We recently discussed the concern over the criminalization of speech in Israel. Now there is an added concern after Israel’s Education Ministry disqualified Dorit Rabinyan’s award winning “Gader Haya” (literally “Hedgegrow,” but known in English as “Borderline”)from being used in high schools. The reason? The novel describes a love story between an Israeli woman and a Palestinian man. The Education Ministry decided that the novel threatened “the identity and the heritage of students in every sector,” and the belief that “intimate relations between Jews and non-Jews threatens the separate identity.”
It is a truly disappointing decision from a nation founded by people who survived book burning and censorship laws. The Education Ministry insisted that “young people of adolescent age don’t have the systemic view that includes considerations involving maintaining the national-ethnic identity of the people and the significance of miscegenation.” Wow. Miscegenation?
Recently published in Hebrew by Am Oved about a year and a half ago, the novel tells the story of Liat, an Israeli translator, and Hilmi, a Palestinian artist, who fall in love in New York. The couple eventually moves back to Tel Aviv and the West Bank city of Ramallah. It is now the romance that the Education Ministry dares not speak its name.
The decision reverses the view of a professional committee headed by Prof. Rafi Weichert from the University of Haifa and including academics, Education Ministry representatives and career teachers. The panel recommended the use of the book. The panel’s role is to advise the ministry on various educational issues, including approval of curriculum.
I have long admired Israeli educational standards and its remarkable educational system. It is therefore particularly disappointing to see such anti-intellectual and intolerant views emerge over the assignment of such books. It is ignorance and intolerance that threatens Israel not concepts considered by some to be offensive like miscegenation.
Ironically, the effort to block the book has led to a surge in sales in Israel.
Source: New York Times

Back to the 50's ?
Back to the 50's ?
No doubt.
In the US schools have banned classics like Huckleberry Finn by Mark Twain and Catcher in the Rye by J.D. Salinger . What is our excuse ?
The topic is Israeli views on "mixed marriage" or "mixed religion sexual relations", not Huckleberry Finn.
The topic is that the education minister has an issue, not Israelis
Naftali Bennett, chairman of the right-wing religious Zionist Jewish Home party, heads the ministry.
Read more: .
Okay, but doesn't the education minister have a constituency ? Or is he just "off the reservation" ? I get your point though.
"Catcher in the Rye" was also about sexual relations ... Huckleberry Finn was about racial relations in the old south . Are you a racist ?
Are you a clown ?
Are you dense ?
From The Forward:
The Education Ministry last month rejected an advisory panel’s recommendation to include the book, about a romance between an Israeli woman and a Palestinian man, in the curriculum for advanced literature students.
Meanwhile, Haaretz reported Sunday that Israeli Attorney General Yehuda Weinstein will investigate the ministry’s decision to ban the book from high school reading lists.
The decision to open the investigation came after a letter sent by the Association for Civil Rights in Israel, which called on the ministry to change its decision.
Read more:
It wouldn't have caused so much interest if they had just placed the book quietly int he school library and let it hibernate on the shelf; it's not as if they were being instructed to place it on the "Required Reading" list. Any time a book is "banned" it only generates unholy excitement and interest.
When I was in high school, Robert Rimmer's "The Harrad Experiment" was banned from my school. Three of my girlfriends and I promptly drove into town to the library and checked it out. We had a weekend sleep over where we took turns reading the book out loud to get it finished, took it to school on Monday and charged $1 per person to rent it out, two days max. (Farm community, twelve miles into town, not everyone had a car or library card back then.)
This is no big thing; the Jewish community has always pushed for Jews to marry Jews. Catholics do the same, and forcefully... they insist on converting and if you have children from a previous marriage they are considered bastards by the church. (Don't argue with me, John, it's true unless things have changed, because I turned down marrying a French Catholic years ago when I was told this by a priest.)
My friend in Boston, an Italian, in love with a French cop, spent six years with both of them trying to convince their respective families that she wouldn't go to hell if she didn't marry Italian and he wouldn't go to hell if he didn't marry a nice French girl from the neighborhood, and good grief, BOTH of them were already CATHOLIC!
I'm like Petey here, it's more egregious for America to ban Huckleberry Finn and Catcher In the Rye than for the Israelis to ban this book, given the religions and histories involved. The only reason it's a big deal is because Israel banned it. Had the Palestinians banned it, the author would have written a favorable opinion of the action.
I won't let the fact that you are anti-Catholic intrude on your fantasies Mimi.
LOL, John...
Heading into 2016, you remain the Master of Evasion!
Were you in command on a battlefield and taking heavy loss, instead of shouting for your troops to retreat you would be forcefully instructing them to "Advance to the rear!" And in your waning years, as you relive the glory days you could truthfully say that never in your entire career did you ever call retreat from the enemy! LOLOL
I wasn't bashing Catholics this time, John, merely pointing out that they, too, are adamant about marrying within the faith. The only real difference between the Jews and the Catholics in this regard is that the Jews are also an ethnicity as well as a religion. I should have known I was headed for trouble with my Frenchman when he told me once, quite seriously, that when he was growing up both his parents and his priest told him many times never to play with the Protestants.
The story about my friends Maryanne and Paul was included to demonstrate that it is not only religions that show prejudice but nationalities as well. While both Italians and the French are considered "white" it did not stop both families from the parents down to aunts and uncles from pressuring the young people to "marry their own kind." This was in 1978, and it seemed as though I was watching a modern (at the time) version of "West Side Story."
Religion can be an anchor, a cornerstone, for a person's life. When it becomes a choke-hold that suffocates the joy of living from that life, it's time reassess the value of that religion. Maybe there is a misunderstanding about the tenants of the faith and a talk with the local leader of the faith will help; maybe you just can't reconcile personal belief with the hard core belief of the faith and it's time to move on.
My problem with organized religion is that each one claims to be the "only" correct one and they all seem to have more "dont's" than "do's," along with too many prejudices. But that's me.
Mimi, your comments about Catholics are ridiculous.
Dear Friend John Russell: The best way to stimulate sales of a book, movie, or any other work is to ban it.
In High School, anything which was not allowed as fair game for a book report automatically got read by students.
Censorship is the last refuge of a weak mind.
Our good friend Perrie Halpern has a point. This government agency was pandering to a base.
You are correct that there is a base to which this group of political hacks can pander.
She is correct that the existence of a base, in a democratic republic doesn't reflect the majority of the population's views about bans and intolerance.
This point may seem off topic. I use it to make an example of something local, not in Israel.
I am proudly an Orthodox Rabbi. The Seminary from which I was ordained (Smicha) in three ways (Yoreh Yoreh, Dayan Dayan, and Maggid) and earned my Doctor of Divinity is an Ultra Orthodox (Chassidic) Yeshiva and Talmud Torah.
In the Congregation in which I presently serve, as I all I served in the past is one in which all are welcome. About a third to two fifths of those who attend Services I conduct are not Jewish, or are in mixed (Jewish and non-Jewish) partner marriages. I say marriages, whether or not the State recognizes them as full fledged marriages. I do for purposes of membership and attendance.
When I say all are welcome, I mean it. Genetically, we are all made from the same stuff. Spiritually, it is our ability to be inclusive and respectful, rather than exclusive and marginalizing that elevates us from purely animal to human status.
Are there some in Ultra-Orthodoxy, Orthodoxy, Conservative. Reconstructionist, and Reform Judaism who do not share my views? Certainly!
In every collection of humanity, mine included we will see a full spectrum of human heights and depths. The existence of one depth doesn't reflect fairly or fully represent the whole.
That said I share your concern about this regrettable pandering move of exclusionism. I see it as a Chillul Ha Shem (Desecration of the Holy Name). Such an Aveyrah (ethical offense, moral lapse) seeks to diminish fellow members of humanity as less than some because they are different.
Shy an existential, discriminatory, prejudicial or violent threat, there is no reason to fear diversity. Not of people, views and interactions of a positive nature. Falling in love is more biology than theology.
We are all children of the same G-d. All members of the same human family. It isn't the ones who fall in love and journey life together in warm, nurturing and sustainable relationships that bother me. It is those with hatred in their hearts bent on killing people they never met, refuse to meet, understand or get along with that grinds my gears.
Love, thumbs up. censorship, thumbs down.
Painting with too broad a brush, misleading. Diversity of view points, a good way to get to the bottom of the truth.
Good article John. Raises some points of universal concern.
Peace, Abundant Blessings, Inclusion, Mutual Respect and Understanding, and Advancement of the Common Good to One and All.
Enoch.
Can't have the chosen ones buggering the riffraff. No religion, know peace.