Manning: 'Life, Liberty, Pursuit of Happiness' Was Not Intended for Native Americans
http://indiancountrytodaymedianetwork.com/2015/07/04/manning-life-liberty-pursuit-happiness-was-not-intended-native-americans-160958
What exactly does life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness mean to a Native American?
As a teacher of high school tribal government, I am tasked with guiding students to think critically about this question, among many other provocative questions.
A typical high school government class is designed, in many ways, to accomplish two overarching objectives: 1.) to inform students about the overall United States governmental system (which should encourage them participate in American politics), and 2.) instill a sense of national pride. For Native students of U.S. government, accomplishing either objective is rife with complexity and contradiction, especially when it comes time to study the Declaration of Independence, the founding document of this Great Nation.
Here is the most celebrated line of Americas founding document:
We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable rights, that among these are life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness.
However seemingly profound the sentiment in this expression, it is impossible for a Native person studying the Declaration of Independence to overlook a phrase that comes later, referring to Native people as merciless Indian savages, whose known rule of warfare, is undistinguished destruction of all ages, sexes and conditions.
Loose translation: Indians are savages who kill everyone in their path, and they do not stop, or at least this is what the founding fathers wanted you to believe.
The fact that this anti-Indian sentiment was and still is published and circulated en masse, has sanctioned a collective disdain for the original people of this land, thereby justifying the destruction of the Indian race, the theft of Indian lands, and meanwhile, Americans pursue their own American dream.
For any student of colonial history and federal Indian policy, as my high school government students are, this statement alone of the merciless Indian savage, is among the greatest falsehoods ever told. But Americans bought it, and the political poison went down with ease.
Far too many Americans today still buy this prejudicial lie, because the most quoted and highly touted American document encourages them to. This racist lie is permeated by everything from white-washed American history books, to Hollywood Western films, Halloween costumes of the wild savage, racist Americana on store shelves today, and Indian mascots like the University of North Dakota Fighting Sioux. This lie justified centuries of oppressive federal Indian policy, forced removal, reservations, Indian boarding schools, the involuntary sterilization of Indian women until the 1970s the list goes on.
It becomes clear, then, that life, liberty, and pursuit of happiness, was absolutely not intended for Native people. There is no way to gloss over this glaring truth, yet acknowledging this historical fact is immediately offensive to many Americans. But acknowledging this truth is necessary.
So, back to the objectives of a typical government class. How are native students expected to value, or at minimum, participate in, a political system that was built upon the continuous dehumanization and disenfranchisement of our ancestors? How is any truth-seeking human being expected to take pride in such a contradiction?
Clearly, it is much easier to take pride in ones nation if the shameful truths are ignored and swept under the rug. Out of sight, out of mind. But what also gets swept under the rug with the glaring truths of American colonial racism, is the prospect of native communities healing from centuries of historical trauma. There is no healing without first acknowledging the abuse. For America, this must happen collectively. Collectively acknowledging the racism of the Declaration of Independence is just the beginning.
Such shameless acknowledgement is a vital baby step toward not only a reconciliation of a strained and oppressive relationship between the United States government and tribal nations, but it is also a crucial step toward rightly living up to the lofty idealism that this nation boasts.
As an educator, I have the responsibility to purvey knowledge as accurately and objectively as possible. But aside from a strong understanding of factual information, I must also endeavor daily to instill my beloved students with an even stronger sense of hope. Fortunately, our ancestors have left behind the most compelling legacies of resilience to draw upon.
Past and present stories of strength inspire native students to look beyond the injustices of a nation built on their oppression, still with hopeful eyes set on the future. Native people have risen to the ranks of virtually every profession in America, infiltrating American systems in order to have their own influence upon them. Grass roots community efforts have maintained many treasured life ways and cultural teachings, even despite numerous efforts to erase them.
Native students who courageously face the bitter truths of this countrys past are moved to create a better future for their children, as they have a firm footing grounded in truth, and an understanding of our present realities as a colonized but extremely resilient people. Armed with this compelling truth, they are all the more prepared to heal themselves, their families, and their nations. This is the power of courageous education, and all Americans should be able to enjoy the benefits of our collective American truth.
Sarah Sunshine Manning (Shoshone-Paiute, Chippewa-Cree) is a mother, educator, activist, and an advocate for youth.
Tags
Who is online
76 visitors

I have pointed out that portion of the DOI many times, and usually get little or no response.
Kudos to Ms Manning.
We're starting to get more and more educators begin to speak out about the "untruths" in the history books being used in the schools. More needs to be said.
Actually, more needs to be listened too.
You are in a country consisting largely of single family immigrants . If you choose to live instead in a tribe don't be surprised if you are treated differently .
Yes we know according to the history re-writers of AIM, the United States has and always will be a racist nation.
AIM is a political movement, an ideology in and of itself. They proclaim themselves as the perfect people and demand all to feel pity for them as the white man destroyed them.
They didn't have a thing to do with it.
Just like the Jews were destroying the Aryan people.
Race hatred has no bounds.
However white as I may sound, one of the major attractions at New Stalkers NewsTalkers is a Native American perspective. I see it so infrequently online. Agree/Disagree does not matter to me, perspective does.
The framers of the Declaration of Independence may not have intended it to apply equally to Native Americans, but the fact is that it DOES apply. If "All men are created equal" is a truth, then what follows is also the truth. Whether the framers felt that way or not, they put it in language that brooks no argument. Ergo: ALL MEN are created equal. Of course, they left women completely out of the picture, but that is a separate argument. Frankly, I am embarrassed to be a descendant of the kinds of people who ran roughshod over the innocent, beautiful Native Americans. I am NOT "proud to be an American," especially when I see quite clearly how we are perceived by most of the rest of this planet. I'd like to think that other peoples, other races, other countries don't think all of us who were born in this place to be identical to the corrupt and inhumane government under which we toil... because most humans are basically decent. And most of us, once we have discovered the unpleasant truth about this "great" country are embarrassed and angry that we are seen as part and parcel of it. That our history books are nothing but lies is only the beginning of our awakening. It is a RUDE awakening, a nightmare to have discovered in my seventh decade of life that I have been lied to since before I was born. However long I have remaining on this planet, in this body, I will never forgive my government for what it has done and is doing in my name to people all over this globe. No, I no longer celebrate "Independence Day." I am embarrassed that we even have to call it a holiday. We, the People, stopped mattering decades ago. So, yes, I do feel what Native Americans must have felt when they, too, realized that in the eyes of the rich and powerful, they meant nothing. They didn't then, and they don't now. I think it is merely a matter of time before their (the ruling class) chickens come home to roost and they will receive their "just rewards." Wherever I am, in this life or another, I know I'll laugh my butt off when that happens! Meanwhile, I'm with the Native Americans who all got the short end of a very short stick. At least you have your honor. That's a lot more than your conquerors will ever have. And, it means more. Native Americans are the "real deal." That is something the rich and powerful have never been and will never be. It is also the one thing those bastards can never take from you. So: hold your heads high and smile your secret smile in the full knowledge that you, in fact, have won the one thing the idiots never thought worth defending. Honor. REAL honor. That's one heckuva legacy, dear souls. One heckuva legacy!
At the inception of this country, Petey, Indians had no choice about where or how they lived... unlike the white people who took their land.
Indians were not welcomed into the towns, the stores, the saloons, the churches, or anywhere a white man wanted to stand or sit or lie down. They were not even allowed to be buried in the same cemeteries as white people... even on Boot Hill where notorious outlaws, drunks, and other dregs of society were relegated to upon death.
Even today in many towns and cities with heavy Indian populations nearby, the Indians are told they are not welcome in the establishments that white people take for granted they themselves can go to hang out. They are told rudely and vocally and by beatings which the local law enforcement throws THEM in jail for asking what they did to start the trouble.
If you think things are not equal between Indians and whites just because the Indians are being stubborn and hanging on to tribal culture you need to make friends with an Indian who will allow you to play native for about a week or so, dress you up in disguise, and turn you loose on a town in rural CA or somewhere in MN or Michigan or the Dakotas or AZ or Maine, or... well, you get the picture, I hope.
Please give specifics, not generalities, on how AIM rewrote history, Nowhere Man.
That sounds like an interesting experiment . But I would have to go west to try it .
I don't think so Petey - try NC, SC, GA, NY, OH, PA - west enough for ya????
Agree mimi - wanna bet none comes forward?
Thank you bitemore - holding our heads up is easy to do - healing our hearts and souls is not.
We will continue to be proud of America - but we cannot and will not be proud of her leadership nor history.
Aeon - what would be your perspective on this thread/seed/topic?
Is it true that Indians do not have facial hair ? If that's the case I would not be able to pass myself off as Indian .
NWM the article isn't about AIM, but I will address that later in my comment.
This is one of the main points of the article. ''However seemingly profound the sentiment in this expression, it is impossible for a Native person studying the Declaration of Independence to overlook a phrase that comes later, referring to Native people as merciless Indian savages, whose known rule of warfare, is undistinguished destruction of all ages, sexes and conditions.
Are you saying that AIM re-wrote this section, or that it really isn't in the DOI. Or even better that it's alie. Which is it NWM?
Now, on to AIM and your comment.
Asper your M.O. you make comments as if they are fact, and you are the arbitrator of the facts and truth. Simply put, your not, nor never will be.
In fact AIMdoesn't re-write history.Our objective is to further the cause of American Indians, and to confront injustices. There arenumerous other objectives that I could list, butthe two mentioned will do fora start.
Would you please give specifics on how, where or when AIM has re-written history? I'd like to address each one.
I found one part of your comment to be quite telling. Anyone, with a modicum of knowledge of AIM would know that AIM would never ask for or accept pity.Your really reaching for straws to support your bogus comment with that NWM.
Another part of your comment that I found to be more than interesting was, ''Race hatred has no bounds''. I completely agree with you on that one NWM, since it was you that called me a, ''crazy Redskin''....Did your race hatred just slip out of your mouth?
You present yourself to be knowledgeable on many subjects, in this comment, AIM being another to add to your PhD. in ''Indian knowledge''. The fact is that your a pompous, pontificating know nothing when it comes to this subject.
These are not insults NWM, they are ''just the facts''.
BIG dittos here, 1st! I'm with you on this one! I wish that Native Americans were in charge... I really, really do.
Depends on the tribe and the region of the country.
Good response Kavika - thanks.
Before progress can be made on a problem, it first has to be recognized as a problem of sufficient pressing magnitude that action is perceived as needed to be taken.
Professor Manning and Others (including our good friends Kavika, First Warrior, Screminmimi, Raven Wing, Larry Hampton and other Native American activists help us to get beyond historical distortions and out of ignorance.
Wallowing in ignorance never leads to happy endings.
Seeing things for what they are, and taking corrective action brings progress.
Here is to progress through education, long overdue.
Enoch.
What is really ironic is that it is quite possible that many of the concepts of what America was founded on, and stated in our constitution might have been learned by colonists from the NA tribes they interacted with at the time.
First of all Kav, point out where I called you a crazy redskin?
I don't believe I did.
I don't have a PhD in anything. Don't need letters to be knowledgeable or educated.
Unless your stating that only those with such can be educated, at which point I would like to see yours.
When I talk of AIM I talk of the AIM that participated in the Rainbow Coalition organized by the civil rights activist and urban leader Fred Hampton, who was Deputy Chairman of the Illinois Chapter of the Black Panthers shortly before he was killed by the Chicago police in '69.
That AIM?
The same AIM that is on the FBI's extremest list? the same AIM that is known for assinating members of it own when they don't go along with the leaders?
That AIM?
I would say the goals would be good, but the methods are a little autocratic or even a little bit Marxist. At the least they have a VERY corrupt history.
Oh and BTW isn't this the AIM that has declared war on America?
That AIM?
The facts are not just what you claim them to be.
I'm all for dealing equitably with the injustices of the Native Americans, But, I do not go along with the methods or goals of AIM.
BTW you all are aware that Red Elk passed away. in case you don't know who he was, he was an native American that called for the unification of all races as brothers the great spirit intended them to be.
No mention of him around AIM though.
I don't, not as long as they seek revenge or retribution or keep claiming that they are better than everyone else that is born in this country solely based upon heritage.
I was born in this country, I am a Native American, I have known no other country and call no other country my own. I will defend this country and everyone in it and their right to be free and equal.
I will not pay for what people hundreds of years ago did. I didn't do that, and I resent being held accountable for people that have no relationship to me soimply becasue Of my heritage.
I"m sorry that the NA's would rather that we all just go away or knuckle under to threat and intimidation.
Their problem is not my problem. But they want to make it mine, justly or unjustly, but they still have to explain how I am responsible for their misfortunes.
Until then, and they drop the militancy, I will not support AIM. Although I do emphasize with the Native American plight, AIM does not represent all Native Americans and I have no sympathy for them.
Dear Enoch, you are wise enough to know that it cannot be selective education from only one viewpoint either. The Education has to be honest, not distorted views of reality based upon prejudiced motives.
Yes progress is long overdue, and keeps getting longer overdue with no end in sight.
Man are we ever on the same page!
You know you did call me that NWM. You can deny it all you want, but it came out of your mouth.
As for AIM and participating with the Rainbow Coalition, yes we did.
And yes we were listed as a extremist organization by the FBI. At the height of the civil rights movement, the FBI was labeling everyone extremist or subversive.
Also this AIM, that is still active throughout the country today.
1968 MINNEAPOLIS AIM PATROL : created to address issues of extensive police brutality.
1969 ALCATRAZ ISLAND occupied for 19 months. AIM was there when United Indians of All Tribes reclaimed federal land in the name of Native Nations. First Indian radio broadcasts--Radio Free Alcatraz--heard in the Bay Area of San Francisco.
INDIAN HEALTH BOARD of Minneapolis founded. This is the first Indian urban-based health care provider in the nation.
1970 LEGAL RIGHTS CENTER : created to assist in alleviating legal issues facing Indian people.(In 1994, over 19,000 clients have had legal representation, thanks to AIM's founding of the Legal Rights Center).
1970 AIM takeover of abandoned property at the naval air station near Minneapolis focuses attention on Indian education and leads to early grants for Indian education.
CITIZEN'S ARREST OF JOHN OLD CROW: Takeover of the Bureau of Indian Affairs' main office in Washington D.C. to show improper BIA policies. 24 arrested for "trespassing" and released. BIA Commissioner Louis Bruce shows his AIM membership card at the meeting held after the release of those arrested.
FIRST NATIONAL AIM CONFERENCE: 18 chapters of AIM convened to develop long-range strategy for future directions of the movement.
TAKEOVER OF DAM: AIM assists the Lac Court Orieles Ojibwa in Wisconsin in taking over a dam controlled by Northern States Power which flooded much of the reservation land. This action leads to support by government officials and eventual settlement, returning over 25,000 acres of land to the tribe and actually providing significant monies and business opportunities to the tribe.
1972 RED SCHOOL HOUSE : the second survival school to open, offering culturally based education services to K-12 students in St. Paul, MN.
HEART OF THE EARTH SURVIVAL SCHOOL: a K-12 school established to address the extremely high drop-out rate among American Indian students and lack of cultural programming. HOTESS serves as the first model of community-based, student-centered education with culturally correct curriculum operating under parental control.
TRAIL OF BROKEN TREATIES : a march on Washington, DC ending in the occupation of BIA headquarters and resulting in the presentation of a 20-point solution paper to President Nixon.
1973 LEGAL ACTION FOR SCHOOL FUNDS: In reaction to the Trail of Broken Treaties the government abruptly canceled education grants to Heart of the Earth Survival School, Red School House and the Indian Community School of Milwaukee. Through successful legal action, the US District Court orders the grants restored and government payment of costs and attorney fees.
WOUNDED KNEE '73: AIM was contacted by Lakota elders for assistance in dealing with the corruption within the BIA and Tribal Council, which led to the famed 71-day occupation and battle with the US. armed forces.
1974 INTERNATIONAL INDIAN TREATY COUNCIL (IITC): an organization representing Indian peoples throughout the western hemisphere at the United Nations in Geneva, Switzerland.
WOUNDED KNEE TRIALS: Eight months of trials in Minneapolis resulted from events which occurred during the 1973 Wounded Knee occupation. This was the longest Federal trial in the history of the United States. Many instances of government misconduct were revealed with the result that US District judge Fred Nichol dismissed all charges due to government "misconduct" which "formed a pattern throughout the course of the trial" so that "the waters of justice have been polluted."
1975 FEDERATION OF SURVIVAL SCHOOLS: created to provide advocacy and networking skills to 16 survival schools throughout the US and Canada.
LITTLE EARTH OF UNITED TRIBES: HUD chose AIM to be the prime sponsor of the first Indian-run housing project.
1977 MIGIZI Communications founded in Minneapolis. The organization is dedicated to produce Indian news and information and educate students of all ages as tomorrow's technical work force.
INTERNATIONAL INDIAN TREATY COUNCIL: establishes Non-government organization status within United Nations in Geneva and attends the International NGO conference and presents testimony to the United Nations.
AMERICAN INDIAN LANGUAGE AND CULTURE LEGISLATION: AIM introduces legislative language which is adopted, recognizing State responsibility for Indian education and culture. This legislation was recognized as a model throughout the country.
1978 FIRST EDUCATION PROGRAMS FOR AMERICAN INDIAN OFFENDERS:
AIM establishes the first adult education program at Stillwater Prison in Minnesota. Programs later established at other state correctional facilities modeled after the Minnesota program.
CIRCLE OF LIFE SURVIVAL SCHOOL established on the White Earth Indian Reservation in Minnesota. The school receives funding for three years of operation from the U.S. Department of Education.
RUN FOR SURVIVAL: AIM youth organize and conduct 500-mile run from Minneapolis to Lawrence, Kansas to support "The Longest Walk."
THE LONGEST WALK: Indian Nations walk across the US from California to DC to protest anti-Indian legislation calling for the abrogation of treaties. A tipi is set up and maintained on the grounds of the White House. The proposed anti-Indian legislation is defeated.
WOMEN OF ALL RED NATIONS (WARN): established to address issues directly facing Indian women and their families.
1979 LITTLE EARTH HOUSING PROTECTED: an attempt by the US Department of Housing and Urban Development to foreclose on the Little Earth of United Tribes housing project is halted by legal action and the US District Court issues an injunction against HUD.
AMERICAN INDIAN OPPORTUNITIES INDUSTRIALIZATION CENTER (AIOIC): creates job training schools to attack the outrageous unemployment issues of Indian people. Over 17,000 Native Americans have been trained for jobs since AIM created the American Indian Opportunities Industrialization Center in 1979.
ANISHINABE AKEENG Organization is created to regain stolen and tax forfeited land on the White Earth Reservation in Minnesota.
1984 FEDERATION of NATIVE CONTROLLED SURVIVAL SCHOOLS presents legal education seminars for educators of Indian children at colleges and law schools in Minnesota, Wisconsin, California, South Dakota, Nebraska and Oklahoma. National conference held in San Jose, California, concurrent with the National Indian Education Association Convention.
1986 SCHOOLS LAWSUIT: Heart of the Earth and Red School House--successfully sue the U.S. Department of Education, Indian Education Programs for unfairly ranking the schools' programs below funding recommendation levels. The schools proved bias in the system of ranking by the Department staff.
1987 AIM PATROL: Minneapolis AIM Patrol comes full circle in restarting the Patrol to deal with the serial killings of American Indian women in Minneapolis.
1988 ELAINE STATELY INDIAN YOUTH SERVICES (ESIYS): developed to create alternatives for youth as a direct diversion to gang-involvement of Indian youth.
FORT SNELLING AIM ANNUAL POW WOW: With the 20th Anniversary of AIM, an annual pow wow is established at historic Fort Snelling. The event becomes the largest Labor Day Weekend event in any Minnesota state park.
1989 SPEARFISHING: AIM is requested to provide expertise in dealing with angry protesters on boat landings. Spearfishing continues despite violence, arrests, and threats from white racists. Senator Daniel Inouye calls for a study on the effects of Indian spearfishing. The study shows only 6% of fish taken are by Indians. Sports fishing accounts for the rest.
1991 PEACEMAKER CENTER: with an American Indian spiritual base, AIM houses its AIM Patrol and ESIYS in a center in the heart of the Indian community.
SUNDANCE RETURNED TO MINNESOTA. With the support of the Dakota communities, a great spiritual rebirth took place at Pipestone, Minnesota. Ojibwe nations, too, have helped make the Minnesota Sundance possible. The Pipestone Sundance has since become an annual event.
In 1991, leaders of the Oglala Lakota, Cheyenne and other nations declared independence from the United States. The group established a provisional government and began the other work of developing a separate nation.
NATIONAL COALITION ON RACISM IN SPORTS AND MEDIA: organized to address the use of Indians as sports team mascots. AIM led a walk in Minneapolis to the 1992 Superbowl. In 1994, the Minneapolis Star-Tribune agreed to stop using professional sports team names that refer to Indian people.
1992 THE FOOD CONNECTION: organized summer youth jobs program with an organic garden and spiritual camp (Common Ground) at Tonkawood Farm in Orono MN.
1993 EXPANSION OF AMERICAN INDIAN OIC JOB TRAINING PROGRAM: the Grand Metropolitan, Inc. of Great Britain, a parent of the Pillsbury Corporation merges its job training program with that of AIOIC and pledges future monies and support.
LITTLE EARTH: after an 18-year struggle, HUD secretary Cisneros rules that Little Earth of United Tribes housing project shall retain the right to Indian preference.
WOUNDED KNEE ANNIVERSARY: Gathering for a twentieth anniversary of the Wounded Knee action, Oglala Sioux tribal president thanks AIM for the 1973 actions.
1996 April 3-8, 1996 - As a representative of the American Indian Movement Grand Governing Council (AIMGGC) and special representative of the International Indian Treaty Council, Vernon Bellecourt along with William A. Means, President of IITC, attended the Prepratory Meeting for the Intercontinental Encounter for Humanity and Against Neo-Liberalism hosted by the Emiliano Zapata Liberation Movement (EZLN), held in LaRealidad in the Lancondone Rainforest of Eastern Chiapaz, Mexico
July 27 - August 3, 1996 - The second meeting for the Intercontinental Encounter for Humanity and Against Neo-Liberalism was again hosted by the EZLN and was attended by delegates of the International Indian Treaty Council and the American Indian Movement.
1998 February 27, 1998 - 25th Anniversary of Wounded Knee, an Oglala Lakota Nation resolution established February 27th as a National Day of Liberation.
July 16-19, 1998 - 25th Annual Lac Courte Oreilles Honor the Earth Homecoming Celebration to celebrate and honor the people of Lac Courte Oreilles and the American Indian Movement who participated in the July 31, 1971 takeover of the Winter Dam and the Birth of Honor the Earth.
August 2-11, 1998 - 30th Anniversary of the American Indian Movement Grand Governing Council; Sacred Pipestone Quarries in Pipestone, Minnesota. Welcoming Feast and Celebration/Conference commemorating AIM's 30th Anniversary.
February, 1999 - Three activists working with a group of Uwa Indians in Colombia kidnapped by rebels. Ingrid Washinawatok, 41 (Menominee), a humanitarian, Terence Freitas, 24, an environmental scientist from Santa Cruz, California, and Laheenae Gay, 39 of Hawaii were seized near the village of Royota, in Arauca province in northeastern Colombia on Thursday, February 25th while preparing to leave the territory of the Uwa after a two week on-site visit. Ingrid, Lahe and Terence were kidnapped on February 25th by armed gunmen in Uw'a Indian Territory of northeastern Columbia. On March 5th, their brutalized and bullet-riddled bodies were discovered across the border in Venezuela.
July, 2000 - AIM 32nd Anniversary Conference on the Lac Courte Oreilles Ojibwe Nation Reservation in northern Wisconsin
October, 2000 Commission to seek justice for Ingrid Washinawatok and companions established.
March 2001 Representatives of the American Indian Movement Grand Governing Council attend the Zapatista Army of National Liberation March for Peace, Justice and Dignity, Zocolo Plaza, Mexico City.
July 2001 11th Annual Youth & Elders International Cultural Gathering and Sundance, Pipestone, Minnesota
August 2001 Civil lawsuit for false arrest brought by five anti-wahoo demonstrators against the city of Cleveland
November 2001 The American Indian Forum on Racism in Sports and Media, Black Bear Crossing, St. Paul, Minnesota
August 2002 12th Annual International Youth & Elders Cultural Gathering and Sundance, Pipestone, Minnesota
May 2003- Quarterly Meeting of the AIM National Board of Directors, Thunderbird House,Winnipeg, Manitoba
August 2003 13th Annual International Youth & Elders Cultural Gathering and Sundance, Pipestone, Minnesota
August 2004 - 14th Annual International Youth & Elders Cultural Gathering and Sundance, Honor Your Grandparents: Wisdom Keeper of Tomorrow, Pipestone, Minnesota
May 2005 First Annual Clyde H. Bellecourt Endowment Scholarship Fund and Awards Banquet, Minneapolis Convention Center
July 2005 15th Annual International Youth & Elders Cultural Gathering and Sundance, International Prayer Vigil for the Earth, Pipestone, Minnesota
May 2006 Second Annual Clyde H. Bellecourt Endowment Scholarship Fund and Awards Banquet, Minneapolis Convention Center
July 2006 - 16th Annual International Youth & Elders Cultural Gathering and Sundance, Pipestone, Minnesota
In the ensuing nine years since the last entry, we have set up additional immersion schools for native youth. Started programs to fight diabetes on Indian people.
Currently we are participating in the protests against the XL Pipeline, and the recently approved pipelines across northern MN and ND.
Those are the facts NWM.
The list goes on and on NWM.
The facts are not what you claim them to be NWM.
I am aware that Red Elk died, as are a number of the AIM members.
LOL...
I love you, Petey, my friend, but you are running out of cop-outs!
As an American and a part of this government, Nowhere Man, you are held by the laws and treaties signed by this government and ratified by it. That makes you responsible, as well, for this government's utter failure to abide by one single promise made by treaty to swindle Indians out of their land in the effort to stop the fighting between Indians and white men.
Do you even understand that? This land was given over by the Indians in return for concessions made by the US government and placed in writing, entered into by treaty. They have not, to this day, been honored.
Indians, looking for pity? Have you seen them marching in the streets, rioting, burning businesses and personal property, shooting local law enforcement... how many news articles and TV news stories do you read and see that feature Indians as criminals who have robbed, assaulted, murdered other citizens on the streets? How many have featured Indian teens on a rampage, doing "beat downs" on random strangers that result in brain damage and sometimes death? How many Indian teens are featured in the stories about flash-mobs in malls?
How ironic! My constant complaint with Kavika and 1stwarrior is that Indians are too stoic and self-contained, always trying to work through the system to effect change and to obtain what their treaties with the "Great White Father" promised. I'm always saying it's the Indians turn to flood the streets with marches and actions that the news media will HAVE to report across the nation.
Do you know how many people in this country appear to be proud to have even one drop of Indian blood, who self-identify as "part Indian?" Now imagine the political influence should they all become aware of the true plight of Indian children, the elderly, and the circumstances on many reservations, the high number of missing and dead young Indian girls and women that law enforcement won't even look for?
Talk about "pity!" Outrage, and a just cause... FINALLY!... they can embrace with true righteousness. All brought together by that real or imagined drop of Indian blood.
And imagine the egg on the government's face as it tries to force Israel or any other country into "peace" talks or "treaties" or agreements with their neighbors, or tries to take the high ground in sanctions against a country it says is guilty of humanitarian crimes after media cameras... especially foreign ones... get a load of places such as Pine Ridge.
Aren't the Amish, Hassidim, and Italians of Howard Beach living in a tribe?
Excuse me, I'll be just like an NA member discussing the founders.
Doesn't matter all the good done today, the one misstep when you started, given the nature of the times, destroys any legacy they may have today and forevermore.
AIM is bad cause they started out that way, but given the times (which I was a part of BTW) may have been justified.
The founders are bad cause they viewed the Indians as savages given the times probably with very good reason may actually been justified.
Guess what, I just did to your legacy what you have done to the founders legacy.
Where's the difference?
Should we condemn all Indians involved with AIM because of their actions at the beginning? the things they wrote the things they said the things they did?
Where is this great Indian wisdom?
You're not supposed to ask come-backs like that Perrie
"The founders are bad cause they viewed the Indians as savages given the times probably with very good reason may actually been justified."
Protecting your homeland from invasion, encroachment, having your wives/children taken/raped/killed because they wouldn't give the whites everything they had, pushing religion down their throats, killing off all the game, stealing their crops - yup - I'd be a savage too to protect my home, family and property from the greedy pathetic whites.
(which I was a part of BTW) You were one of the founders of AIM or just a flower-child grabbing some girls breasts on the sidelines??????????????
Of course I do Mimi. It absolutely is abhorrent what the Great white father (some of them at least) did to serve the corporate ends.
Yes, I'm well aware of how many attempt to claim a heritage that isn't theirs to claim, probably as a way to deflect guilt. It disgusts me.
I have nothing but respect for my native american (indian) brother citizens. We wouldn't be us without you, same as our southern brethren, and our black slave brethren, our Japanese brethren who fought with great gallantry in the service of this nation against their own fathers and brothers.
Personally I believe in the words of Chief Joseph, wise words contained within his "I shall fight no more forever" speech. Ennobling words, and tragic words all at the same time.
His message was that we all need to live together on this land for times have changed. The old ways are gone forever never to return. WE must hold on to the good things and forgive the bad if we are to survive.
Seems like a message I hear a lot, but at the same time a message that many will not acknowledge.
YES the Native American (Indian) deserves better treatment at the hands of their non-Indian brethren. If anything to establish and maintain the legacy of our founders and preserve the legacy of the nations.
WE are either one, or we are nothing. and no amount of angst or demonstrations or media prodding is going to change that. WE must be able to forgive each others history.
If we cannot we are doomed to repeat it.
"not distorted views of reality based upon prejudiced motives." which is EXACTLY what the history books of today in all of the schools have done. The Indian is listed/touted as the BAD GUY in every dealing with the white guy.
Look at Custer'd - he got Siouxed and wore arrow shirts for massacring THOUSANDS of Indian women and children and elders and the history books are making him and COLUMBUS out to be heroes when, in fact, they were mass murderers - approved by their governments.
Oh, you mean THAT distorted view???
{Chuckle},
Child of the '50's and '60's, I don't remember any flower children at the pentagon trying to get our boys back home from the meat grinder that was Vietnam. I was trying to save lives. Yours was one of them. (if you served there) I marched with the the freedom riders I did a lot of things to stop the absolute bigotry of that time. Put my own ass on the line to stop the horror of a government that only paid lip service to the citizens it was charged with serving. I took the risk of facing down those sons of the confederacy that would have easily put my head in a noose and burned a cross on my lawn.
You think it's fun being called a nigger lover and spit on without retaliating? Save your outrage, been there done that.
Yeah thank you for easily disposing of all the good this nation has done because of what people thought and believed hundreds of years ago.
Take the log out of your own eye before trying to take the splinter out of your brothers.
If you are justified is disparaging the white man as the destroyer of everything good and right in the world, and refuse to recognize how the white man could conceivably see the Indian as a savage given their behaviors.
Then you do have a log in your eye. And are rewriting the plain factual narrative of history to glorify your race as all good until the white man came and destroyed it all. Your people had a role in your own destruction.
I will never forget that, even though some of my Native American (Indian) brethren wish desperately too.
Yeah, I was there - two tours - mud-clinger, machine bullet thrower on the ground and in helos. Got to get the egg, tomatoes, cabbage, lettuce, rocks, spit and other things thrown at me, be called a baby killer, hit in the face by young punks, denied airfare and denied service in a dineron my return home from the 2nd tour - in LA, of course.
Sorry - haven't seen a lot of good disposed of by this country a couple of hundred years ago. All I saw then and see now is the desire for total domination of how people think, act and live by greedy politicians and the government (who is supposed to be protecting "We, the People" from the greedy politicians). Yeah, I've got a biased point of view having lived, and do live,the life.
Let's get you to live five days with what we have too without all the wonderful support systems you seem to be so proud of - that we don't have. That log will move quickly - and forcefully to where it belongs.
Not only quite possible FLY - but quite factual.
John - excellent points.
Small clarification - "They were on the defense throughout" should be extended to "They were and still are on the defense throughout." Each SCOTUS decision dealing with Indian tribes takes away another treaty guaranty/granted right. We are NOT protected by the U. S. Constitution as are all other U. S. citizensand have our own, governmentally provided, Bill of Rights, circa 1968.
No, U. S. citizenship Act of 1924gave us nothing other than the right to call ourselves U. S. citizens. The Voting Act gave us the right to vote and many states still objected to that until 1962.
I don't agree, one whit, with the exclusion of Native Americans. Does the use of the word "man" mean that women don't have that right as well?
YES, we need to correct the history books to reflect a much more balanced viewpoint!
I used that same logic in my response. Actually, as written, the Declaration of Independence really does include everyone, at least in the way it is interpreted today (supposedly); but there is still a large faction of racists who refuse to allow any but white males of European descent to have full equality. Yes, to them women are also excluded (never forget Women's Suffrage in which we finally got the vote, more than 100 years after the Declaration of Independence was written). We actually were excluded at the outset. Today, the excluded parties are getting fewer, but they are still excluded by a comparatively small faction of skinhead types whose opinions, quite frankly, don't mean squat to me or to anyone with a beating heart and a functioning brain cell. In this day and age, we should all be done with the idea that there are inferior humans who somehow don't deserve full equality with supposedly "normal" (or superior?) white-skinned, blond-haired, Aryan human males. But, there are enough isolated cesspools dripping with those types that we must all continue to do battle to the end that every human being is treated equally under the law and by all of society: every human being: black, white, red, yellow, blond, brunette, male, female and anything in between that is born of a homo sapiens woman. Yes, that would also include the redneck, skinhead Neo-Nazis who must learn that they are equal to, but not better than, everyone else.
As the NE tribes, specifically the Iroquois, got Msr's Franklin, Jefferson, Adams, Tremaine and others to concur and include in the U.S. Constitution, all men, which very vehemently includes women, are created equal and have certain rights.
The tribes/nations firmly believed in equality. Many tribes/nations had women leaders/rulers back then - and even today. Too bad mainstream American hasn't advanced to that point.
John and 1st: you are both examples of how humans should behave and interact... and how many humans actually do behave and interact, in spite of our flawed SCOTUS (excuse me, I should have said extremely-flawed), and poorly written Constitution. You are the kinds of humans from among whom I would choose my friends; life is too short to waste time on haters. You two have just illustrated perfectly one small way in which humans can and should behave in order to bring about peace and understanding. Thank you. Both of you. My world is better because humans like you are on this planet.
Sigh... I only wish my ancestry was Native American, instead of European. Your dignity is far and away greater than that of any lily-white male who thinks he is God's gift to the universe. I just wish we humans would learn to get along, and to stop putting our faith in politicians and their shills! From the American Revolution right up to today, it has always been about white males and their supposed superiority. Shameful, and even worse that not one of them sees it in himself. The epiphany will come, someday... would that you and I could witness it.
Thank you for standing up when the rich pricks peaceniks and flower children ran away and hid. I never burned my draft card, I was never called, but if my number came up, I would have been right there next to you without hesitation.
If I could shove it up their ass I would brother, just do me a favor, not all white people are against you. Even if we still have our ideals of what should be.
The log moved for me in '65, walking with the freedom marchers I learned what unadulterated hate was. Been fighting it all my life ever since. I don't give one whit in the world for those so called support systems you think I'm so proud of, never used them never had a need for them. I won't subject myself to others judgments that are inherent in using such governmental devices of slavery.
We all learn at different times what is right. Much like I agree with the supreme court in it's recent Marriage ruling but hate the way they got there, I agree with what needs to be done, but disagree with the way it being gone about.
But I can recognize your position on it. Trust me, as a piece of white trash from the wrong side of the tracks growing up, I've had to earn everything I have, what respect I have is from giving respect, not demanding it.
I read a lot of statements of native americans (indian) on how they celebrate the fourth, and I can respect every single one of them. In my view they have earned the right to celebrate it any damn way they choose to.
AS Cheif Joseph said, we have to learn to live together in respect. We are all americans after all. Otherwise we will destroy each other eventually.
A very intelligent thing to say. Extinction is neither desirable nor honorable.
That was Red Elk's position one I very strongly agree with.
Lets not allow the mistakes of the past to destroy the future.
There has to be room for everyone.
NONE of them were heroes, and in fact with Custer specifically there was a concerted effort to clean up and disguise his actual conduct of his campaigns with the Indians.
Custer was a fool. Disobeyed orders and got two thirds of his command butchered. only he bears responsibility for that. And current historical investigation has revealed that the written history is not what the government at the time claimed it was, It was no noble "Last Stand" against the savages, and there is no truth in what was recorded.
So no that is not a distorted view, Custer was brave no doubt, but it was a foolish bravery based upon vanity and an overbearing ideal of himself as inviolate.
A human titanic. who found his berg in the hills of Dakota territory.
Colombus was no hero either, just another person vying to get wealthy off the efforts of others. The destruction he wrought wasn't his own, it was by opening up the new world to those that came after him. Who were looking for dominion rather than wealth.
But let me ask a question.
WHY am I responsible? The distorted view is that white people today are responsible for what was done 100, 200, 400 or 700 years ago.
That just doesn't equate for me. I cannot accept that I am responsible.
Simple fact.
One persons love, can easily be another's hate.
It's all a matter of perspective.
Bite - all people have a right to their voice and their opinion. It is the other person's responsibility to remember and accept those rights - something mainstream U. S. citizens do not do.
Lets examine the statement that Thomas Jefferson wrote as was approved as edited by the Continental Congress....
He Has Excited.... WHO has excited, why King George of course. This was a document of the colonists grievances with the sovereign of Great Britain wasn't it?
domestic insurrections amongst us,..... Yes the king had a vested interest in stirring up dissent in the colonies against revolution, stationed troops in citizens homes, used armed troops to put down vocal dissent and jail revolutionaries. Hired spies to report back on the colonists.
and has endeavoured to bring on the inhabitants of our frontiers, ...... Is there any question of the ferocity of Indian warfare on the frontier? Didn't the colonists learn of it first hand during the French and Indian war where Indians fought right next to the white europeans as allies on both sides? where the French especially learned to use Indian tactics against european military formations and the normal rules of civilized warfare were out the window? Really anyone going to challenge those facts? King George did instruct his agents to engage his Indian allies in the effort to put down the rebellion. Historical fact.
the merciless Indian Savages, whose known rule of warfare, is an undistinguished destruction of all ages, sexes and conditions...... Like I showed above the colonists were well aware of the Indian tactics in battle of giving no quarter. there are many examples of both the French and British officers writing in their journals of the pure unadulterated ferocity of an Indian attack and the absolute terms of victory in an Indian battle. It is fought until it is done and the enemy runs away and escapes or is annihilated. There is no niceties of Indian warfare in the 18th century, there are no rules, and there is no quarter given or taken. The journals of the times record the absolute savagery of an indian attack, and the indian allies disdain at both english and french calls for giving quarter to surrendering enemy forces.
Surrendering enemy were to be dishonored, tortured and killed.
Savage warfare to say the least given european rules of warfare.
Today Indian people claim this is a racist statement. When in reality is it a statement of the absolute vicious violence that King George was willing to bring down on the colonists.
They didn't fault the Indians, or blame them, they faulted and blamed the King.
So this is claimed as a vile racist statement by the founders of this country, when in actuality they were making a very truthful statement of the conditions the King has wrought on the colonies.
That my friends is a monumental re-write of history. Imparting something that was not contained within said document unless you take the document completely out of it's historical context and purpose then apply today's moral code to the situation back then.
Nuff said.
Thank you 1st, on this point we are in complete agreement.
Didn't say you were - said the "government" is responsible.
BUT, if you totally support all actions by this government - you are then responsible for their futch ups.
Yup.
"The journals of the times"
"It's all a matter of perspective."
The Brit/French/Euro's perspective on how the Indians fought???
You're right - 'nuff said.
Good enough brother, peace...
" Futch ups ?" Oh, I LOVE it!!!!
Do you ever write to your representatives and ask them to stand up for legislation to fund the programs promised by treaty to the Indians, especially to the poor reservations like Pine Ridge?
EEEYYYuuuppppp.
I'm a libertarian, you think the government supports me any more than they do you?
There hasn't been a decent pres since Bill Clinton. There hasn't been a great one since Reagan.
Futch ups, now that's a damn good way to put it.
See.... I am trainable 1st!
Keeping 1491 & 1493 under my pillow has eliminated my neck pain too. (and you thought all I was going to do was chew on the covers!!!!!)
It has been fascinating to read how Franklin, Adams and Jefferson had all interacted and were influenced by the NA of that period.
Think we will ever see a decent rewrite/representation of NAs in the history books in public schools?
I gave up writing congress people a long time ago, they just take what you write and put it in the trash. They could really care less.
I used to go to their offices until I got tired of waiting in the entry way all day.
They do not want to hear from the common person. It's not in their job description.
The last time I saw any actual serious law passed to help the Indians was the Indian Gaming Act. 1988. (And I know for a fact that it was signed by Ronald Reagan himself, happily)
1st: Oh, boy, do you ever have THAT right!!!!! BIG time! Sadly.
Government "shills" (aka elected representatives) will say whatever they must in order to be elected. Once elected, their hands may as well bear only one finger, and that's the one they show you if you ask them to represent YOU. If it wasn't so tragic, it would be a joke, but no one is laughing. Congressmen KILL people, by their greed and corruption. Their attitudes are simple: "Vote for me, then do me a favor and DIE!"
Grrrr... gotta stop this. My BP is shooting to the moon...
I'll concur with you on Clinton - the jury's still out on Reagan (and will be for a long time).
Tribal Law and Order Act of 2010
Violence Against Women Reauthorization Act of 2013
You've got a very inquisitive mind FLY - and I look forward to helping you in ways that I can
I believe we'll have to have a complete change in governmental policy for that to trickle down to the history buffs.
Think that'll happen?
We have a cruise around the British Isles planned for August. That's when I plan to crack 1493.
It keeps coming back to me as to how fortunate to have grown up in Lawrence, Kansas. Thinking back, I don't ever recall any of our lessons related to NA history ever coming out of textbooks. I want to say most of them came from special speakers, from either Haskel, or the history museum there at the University of Kansas.
What I don't understand is - why is it so difficult to write "history" accurately - as it happened? Not just with the Native Americans, but with all history. Can you imagine the things that may have "actually" happened and how it might have changed the mindset of society if they knew???
I have two reasons for you.....1) Arrogance. 2) Ego.
We all "know" that history is written by the victors - but, history is also written by those who may be considered as the "losers". Their history is just as important, if not more so, because it gives more balance to the actual occurrence.
I hope you don't mind me chiming in here.
I was a "History Buff" many moons ago. My interests in History went way beyond the casual almost 50 years ago.
I am considered an amateur historian, only becasue I never went and finished the formal education requirements to be recognized by the academic culture of historians.
To me that has given me a freedom that many in academia don't have. Most Historians are in actuality investigators. we have to sift through many thing that at most time conflict on any historical account.
In investigating a particular battle even participants in the battle at different locations see it differently. Each and every account has to be juxtaposed against the other accounts. this is why the best accounts are the journals of the participants immediately after the events but you have to be cautious even with those lest your investigation become stilted in one direction or the other.
I see this a lot in history professors who write today, they are lees involved in revealing accuracy than opinions.
Such approach disgusts me, all that education and learning down the drain. Personally I don't care for historians that offer their opinions I prefer historians that come to conclusions based upon fact that takes into account all sides and every scrap of info available no matter what side it came from.
This is the only way one can view history and gain anything from it. You have to understand the context of the time and society that engendered the history in the first place other wise you risk losing the truth of the issue.
That is how history "evolves" over time. It is when it "evolves" to the point where it ignores already proven facts that I get upset.
Such 'historians' do more damage to learning and understanding the truth than they help.
There is no winner and loser when investigating history, there is only truth. Both sides have their story and their truths. and if we fail to include all sides and be able to accept the truths from both sides we are doomed to repeat the errors of history.
Which are many.
The truth always lies in the middle. Your viewpoint has a lot of truths, but so does mine. The art is in reconciling those truths for a better understanding of what brought the incident issue or act into being and not make the same mistakes again.
Both sides have their arrogant and egocentric exponders wishing that theirs are the olny accepted history. Much like the soviet historians post WWII or the Government archivists and academicians post Little Bighorn.
They all want to write the history that justifies their horrors.
When you make the jump from history buff to historian, you have to make the decision that there are no wrongs and no rights. just facts and truth.
Many cannot make that leap. I hate having arguments with people over history, they usually happen cause one side or the other refuses to accept the othersides knowledge or experience, when in reality they need to enjoin their knowledge for the greater understanding of all.
Now I'll get off my stump.
All I wish is to seek the truth, which in my experience always lies in the middle.
Now I'll let you two go back to your very interesting conversation, one I happen to agree with.
Goes along with what I've always been told - there are actually three sides to every story/history - yours, theirs and the right.
Wish I could stay on the "right" side more often
This is why you have to read from multiple sources, and stay open minded enough to evaluate some other piece of information that might come along.
The myths that support accepted history may be written in stone, but eventually they crumble away one by one to yet to be discovered truths.
Very true Fly, but one does have to learn to discern opinion, from fact.
Lest the truth gets distorted in the fantasy.
There is a point where in the interests of raising his status in the world of academia a historian will offer his opinion then try to justify his opinion with selected facts all written in a way to justify his opinion as the "Real" truth.
Sometimes it is difficult to separate the truth from the desired reality of those that write it.
This is Mr Ellis's problem with his novellas of opinion on the Founders. Mr Ellis didn't become a historian of note until he wrote and sold his books. To great book reviews but to the serious criticism of his colleagues.
People who have studied the factual history in the depths most don't laugh at his opinions passing off as conclusions. but to the general public, he's using his credentials to tell a story invented in his own mind to make money.
True historians fight this all the time.
It is difficult to turn a career in history into any real financial gain or security. Many good historians fall victim to that and give in to the greed of popular propaganda.
It is hard for the average person to devise the truth out of the miasma that ensues and can take decades or even centuries to correct.
This is the real issue with the histories of the west, the Indian wars, and the expansion of this nation. Most of it is a lie created to sell books and make money.
Which is exactly what the "Dime Store" novella's were - Kit Carson - Indian Fighter - sold thousands and thousands and made big bucks.
BUT - the Declaration of Independence was not a novel nor a novella nor a "history" book. It was a legal document written and submitted to the King of England stating the Colonial view of why they wanted and deserved Independence from England and, in which, they stated the Indians were savages whose only concern was warfare and killing.
Not acceptable from any side of the story.
The highlighted portion above is an absolutely incorrect interpretation of what they founders said.
AS I laid out here...
Comments on savage Indians in the DOI
They sent a message to King George that they resented his agents stirring up the Indians on the frontier. The king was well aware of the tactics used by Indians in war (which all acknowledge were savage based upon the European rules of war) And they were expressing that as one of their grievances against the King.
The language is plain, the meanings haven't changed since then either. There is no factual basis for claiming that the Founders were calling the Indians savages when they were clearly stating that (Indian) ideals of warfare were what was savage. And his provoking such was also savage.
I don't care how you cut it, or want to twist it. The meanings were and are still plain, and agree with the known facts of Indian warfare. And the crowns communications with it's governmental agents at the time.
Anything else is a re-writing of plain unambiguous and inarguable history to suit a political end.
I don't buy that argument, mainstream historians don't buy that argument, It represent a re-write of plain history and a re-defining of the Founders that neither complies with history nor is an honest representation of history.
You can believe anything you want. But answer this, If the Founders believed that the Indians were nothing but mindless savages as you claim, why would they go to great lengths to write all these treaties and make alliances with them, discuss stratgey and tactics with them, incorporate Indian raiding parties in their attacks on British units and forts for the prosecution of the war on the frontier?
So I guess it must have been only certain Indians that were savages and other were intelligent cooperative Indians. But if this is true, it destroys the arguments that the Founders of this nation thought of Indians as savages in general.
Your argument just went right out the window brother. You cannot say the founders called all Indians savages on the one hand, and then on the other having them making treaties and cooperating with them in war.
The arguments are inopposite of each other. Meaning one has to be right and the other wrong.
Since all sides (British, Colonial and Indian) in the war admit to having Indian allies involved on both sides, I do believe that mine is the appropriate interpretation from the plain undisputed facts of proven admitted history from all parties.
The only reason I can see to attempt to establish that the founders were racist towards Indians is to establish and argue that this is a racist nation from it's inception.
Which is what you seem to be arguing.
Is that what you are arguing?
Corrupt politics. No more, no less. Or, as FLYNAVY put it, arrogance and ego. Combined with the average person's total lack of interest, it is easy to write fake histories because no one will notice, because no one pays any attention.
1st answer is simple - " why would they go to great lengths to write all these treaties and make alliances with them ," - the Indians held the land and, by international law, the colonists could not get that land without treating with the Indians.
2nd answer would take way too much space and time to respond - something in the neighborhood of 261 pages, just from a few law books that I've got that I had to "muddle" through these past two years to obtain my degree in Federal Indian Law. Felix Cohen, in American Federal Indian Law, Chapter 2, goes into great detail as to why and how the colonials screwed the pooch through "incorporating raiding parties to 'protect the frontier'" and numerous other tactics to get the Indians to believe the colonials actually liked them.
How 'bout Jeffersons famous reasons for wanting to get rid of the Indians. Jefferson advocated for the militarization of the Western border, along the Mississippi River . He felt that the best way to accomplish this was to flood the area with a large population of white settlements. [3]
Still recovering from the American Revolutionary War , the U.S. federal government was unable to risk starting a broad conflict with the powerful Native American nations that surrounded their borders. They were worried that this would cause a broader Indian War, and which would perhaps be joined by the other European nations. [4] In his instructions to Meriwether Lewis, Jefferson emphasized the necessity for treating all Indian tribes in the most conciliatory manner. [5]
Jefferson wanted to expand his borders into the Indian territories, without causing a full-scale war. Jefferson's original plan was to coerce native peoples to give up their own cultures, religions, and lifestyles in favor of western European culture, Christian religion, and a sedentary agricultural lifestyle. [1] [2] Jefferson's expectation was that by assimilating the natives into a market-based, agricultural society and stripping them of their self-sufficiency , they would become economically heavily dependent on trade with white Americans, and would thereby be willing to give up land that they would otherwise not part with, in exchange for trade goods or to resolve unpaid debts. [3] [6] [7] [8]
In an 1803 private letter to William Henry Harrison , Jefferson wrote:
To promote this disposition to exchange lands, which they have to spare and we want, for necessaries, which we have to spare and they want, we shall push our trading uses, and be glad to see the good and influential individuals among them run in debt, because we observe that when these debts get beyond what the individuals can pay, they become willing to lop them off by a cession of lands .... In this way our settlements will gradually circumscribe and approach the Indians, and they will in time either incorporate with us as citizens of the United States, or remove beyond the Mississippi. The former is certainly the termination of their history most happy for themselves; but, in the whole course of this, it is essential to cultivate their love. As to their fear, we presume that our strength and their weakness is now so visible that they must see we have only to shut our hand to crush them, and that all our liberalities to them proceed from motives of pure humanity only. Should any tribe be foolhardy enough to take up the hatchet at any time, the seizing the whole country of that tribe, and driving them across the Mississippi, as the only condition of peace, would be an example to others, and a furtherance of our final consolidation. [8] [9]Jefferson believed that this strategy would "get rid of this pest, without giving offence or umbrage to the Indians" . [10] He stated that Harrison was to keep the contents of the letter "sacred" and "kept within [Harrison's] own breast, and especially how improper for the Indians to understand. For their interests and their tranquility, it is best they should see only the present age of their history." [11]
Yes - toward the American Indian - the colonials were racist from the very beginning. There was no other race that they swindled out of millions upon millions of acres of land all the while prefacing it with "all men are created equal".
Bullshit.
I don't disagree with the idea that the American government took advantage of the Indian.
Also by the time the Revolution was over the Eastern Indians were already dependent on European goods through the fur trade. So, it is not something the American government started but the British government did. Not that the Indians weren't aware of it either...
Indians in the Revolution
I will say that the Indians weren't aware of the extent of the desires of the fledgling government, but your own linkage disputes that also. So what your claiming is that the American Government took advantage of the Indians on a racist basis rather than an economic one.
Ok, same bullshite argument John and Bob promote about black slavery.
And I place it in the same category as their arguments, divisive racist bullshit created to drive a political agenda.
I'm done here. I know you will claim that you won the debate, but in reality, not hardly. You have only revealed that history to you is a tool to be used in furtherance of divisive political aims.
I will never claim to have "won" - I wish/like to discuss.
So, what would you call the illegal gaining of Indian lands - with no other ethnicity involved? Others "owned" lands that they had "borrowed" from the Indians - free blacks, non-indentured Euros - but only the lands of the Indians were taken.
What would you call that?
Mexican lands were taken, Spanish land was taken, French land was purchased but also taken, British lands were taken. Russian land was taken.
Where is the race hatred?
Seems to me that the US government didn't care one whit about race, only value.
And they would gain that value any way they could, by swindling, annexation, theft, by force of arms even blackmail if necessary.
The US Government was and is run by the same economic forces that ran the British empire back then. the chase for the almighty gold dollar.
And if you get in it's way they will destroy you. Everything else is simply justification for their heinous actions. Including the racist proclamations.
The world runs on hate and fear running to alliances of hate and fear. Just like the schoolyard bullies will use any advantage to get people to do what they want.
This is why Chief Joseph surrendered, he realized that the pursuit would never end until they were completely destroyed and that making it to Canada would not stop it. As Sitting Bull, Crazy Horse, Red Cloud and the rest of the Sioux soon learned.
The Government wasn't racist one iota, but they were the greedy bastards we see today, even if the leaders had higher morals, it's the people just below that do the actual running of the government that are the issue.
Government will take organized advantage of others, every chance they get.
That is the lesson of liberty. That is the lesson of organized government without morality.
It wasn't just the Indians....
You got a lot of history there but kinda mixed up - Sitting Bull, Crazy Horse, Red Cloud - were before Chief Joseph.
The British, French, Spanish - took the land from the Indians and then "sold" it to the U.S.
The concept is the same - the Declaration of Independence stated what the U. S. thought of the Indian tribes - their thoughts were carried out in following years - as noted in my quotes.
As hatred and bigotry are learned traits, is it really possible to reverse that learning?
FLY - technically, as learned in foundational courses in college, yes, that learning "could be" reversed.
BUT - dominant society has had hatred and bigotry as their driving force since the annals of history have been recorded - "Somebody" has to be better than "Everybody" and the "Somebody" hates/dislikes/belittles/ridicules the "Everybody" because they are not good enough to be "Somebody".
Why did Creator put that gene in humans - and, for that matter, in animals? He's not talking to me lately 'bout his reasons for doing things, so I don't know.
Divisive????
Damm good thing it ain't cheese, eh?
Then that gives wonder to why he allowed the invention of firearms the great equalizer now doesn't it.
Or is that mans only answer to hubris?
Yeah they were no doubt about that. But I'm sure you got the point despite my bad elucidation of it.
Jefferson's Letter to Captain William Henry Harrison, lets expand on that for a minute.
Personally I believe that Jefferson's letter was one to express the real point of where he wished to go with Indian affairs and what would be the best course. although it admonished Harrison to comply with all official government directives as his duty demanded.
Lets examine another part of that letter, more an expanded part of that you took from Wikipedia....
As you can readily see, Jefferson's guidance in the situation was one of fealty, to incorporate the native into American citizenry. Not drive him to extinction.
He definitely did not want corporate America to deal with the Natives and wanted the government to drive those greedy bastards out of the business of dealing with Indians. A very noble sentiment.
But Jefferson's idealism got the better of him thinking that the Native would not fight for his freedom and would see the wisdom of assimilation as citizens of the new nation. (not seen or accepted until Chief Josephs surrender, and by that time it was too late, Americans were looking for retribution over a fallen enemy) He for some unexplainable reason did not see that the Native would view the government magnanimity as oppression. Much like the colonist's did with King George's magnanimity.
A huge error on his part.
Another error? his view that the Natives would give up and move west on their own accord. Of course they wouldn't, who would. For all the history of tyrannical government and their reasons for being and eventual destruction and his explainations that we should not make the same mistakes as, he fails to realize the Natives would react the same way.
And fight.
So although he understood that assimilation was inevitable, he could not see beyond his own ideals.
Jefferson for all his genius, was human and had the typical faults of humans particularly when it came to his own view of his own genius.
But no matter how it turned out, Jefferson supported the peaceful bringing of the Nations into the union of states. That was the point of his letter to Harrison.
Full letter here if you wish to read the complete letter it in it's full context.
He was not bigoted against the Indian, and didn't believe the nation was, or well, at least it shouldn't be and should treat with the natives with love and magnanimity.
Can't help what Jackson did with Jefferson's philosophy. Jackson, the way he twisted it, has his own prejudices to pay for. You can hammer him all you like, I'll actually help ya with it.
Jackson is a great example of a general that shouldn't have been a president.
And this is where that word you love comes into play - perspective - you can read what you wish into Jefferson's words.
How 'bout reading the links below and see other words of his and of others regarding their designs against the Indians.
Ok, I'll take them one by one.
That work for ya?
It has always been my experience that when you take a quote like those and research the full passage of where the quote appears, the context is entirely different than what is being claimed.
It is not only perception, but context also.
The first on in the first link is from Ben Franklin. It comes out of his autobiography, Page 57.
The quote is indeed accurate (in bold above) But when you read the WHOLE passage in context, you see it is a commentary about what rum has done to the Native, not that rum could be used as a weapon against the Native.
Want me to do another one?
Ok
Here we go again, Orders issued as the Commander in chief of the Continental Army, during the Revolutionary War for effectuating the northwest campaign. These arders were issues against HOSTILE indians probably allied with the British against the colonies. As enemy allies, this is an absolute fair order given within a military campaign against an active hostile ally of your enemy.
For example, it was ok to bomb Germany during WWII cause they were a declared enemy, but we can't bomb Romainia cause they didn't declare war against us, even though they were an active ally of our enemy.
So orders to bomb the Ploesti Oil fields in Rumania were illegal orders and were given cause we hate and wished to exterminate the Romanians. Not destroy their ability to fight or support the enemy we were at war with.
AS a military man, you know this is an allowable tactic.
CONTEXT is everything when you are judging perception in historical matters.
So now I ask again, you want me to do more? I'll do them all if I need to.
I made a career over on NV doing exactly this with a HUGE audience. Just waiting for another out of context quote used to justify inanities.
And I played no favorites I hammered Republicans just as much as Democrats. Don't use the founders to justify your own prejudices or attempt to sully their names or make them out to be what they are not to justify your cause.
Men,for the "Founding Fathers", meant white men who owned land. Most Native American tribes had no concept of owning land.
The removal of Native Americans began with Jefferson's expansion of the empire of liberty. It left no place for them. They were to assimilate or die. (sounds rather like the borg collective).
Perhaps we should use something like Howard Zinn's "A People's History of the United States" as a text book.
Not a re-write, but a fuller understanding of all that was happening during that time. I was taught, back in the 70's, that the British and the French paid Indians to bring them the scalps of their enemies. Apparently, the age or sex that was once a part of the scalp mattered to the British or French.
But let me ask this, how nice are you going to be to the ones who invade your home and point a gun at you?
Links to the first two quote I junked above...
Franklin Page 58
Washington The 1779 Sullivan Campaign
A Little-Known Offensive Strategic To The War Breaks The Indian Nations' Power: by Stanley J. Adamiak
Ok, I finally tracked down the third quote from William Henry Harrison, the Governor of Indiana Territory, 1810. Prior to the war of 1812.
HARRISON: MESSAGES AND LETTERS pg 487 thru 493
I highlighted the quote within it's original document.
Clearly is does not mean what the implication is by those pulling it out of it's full context. Harrison, (Implementing Jefferson's policies) is telling the territorial legislature of the difficulties in implementing the treaty of Fort Wayne cause of outside interference. Probably by the British of which he has Indian reports of. Also reports of the appearance of "The Prophet" (I believe this was Tecumseh An ally of Britian during the war of 1812) who claimed that no Indian land could be sold cause no Indian tribe owned any land, it was owned by all the tribes on the continent. Which he proclaimed that the US government needed the permission of ALL Indian tribes on the entire continent to purchase anything. Thereby all treaties were null and void because all the tribes did not agree. Ludicrous.
So I guess what happened with this quote is it contained the word savages so that makes it a racist quote. When it is hardly that at all.
So much for quote #3, on to quote #4.
I love putting these blind quotes back into their original context, it displays the subterfuge better than anything else could.
Damn.... Nicely done NWM.
Obviously you don't suffer from Sesame Street induced ADD. Nice to see the details.
You think I should continue? or have I made my point?
I have quotation #4 almost ready to go...
I never put a price on an opportunity to learn.... HIT IT!
People keep saying that Indians had "no concept of land ownership" and leave it at that, as though that gave the Europeans an excuse to displace them and take the North American continent without any twinge of conscience.
Better to say Indians had no concept of ownership in the way Europeans did. There was the concept of territorial tribal grounds. The tribes followed the buffalo herds and other game but they stayed within their own territorial hunting and camping grounds, knowing if there was trespass there would be fighting and war. Sometimes it happened and consequences were paid. The tribes had burial grounds upon which other tribes did not trespass, grounds considered sacred and off limits. These were the concept of "ownership" to Indians of which Europeans had absolutely no respect of care to consider.
As to the unique savagery of an Indian attack... where the hell did THAT come from??
Where does it say that Columbus and his European contingent made any concession to the women and children of the natives they encountered? Have you ever heard of Desoto? And by the way, wasn't there a mighty Aztec civilization that I'm sure consisted of women and children who were enslaved and slaughtered by Europeans in the almighty greedy grasp of gold?
Should I mention the Crusades, which was before the time of the Revolutionary War and the War of 1812 when the savages of the New World were shocking the Europeans with their battle tactics?
We can go back to the 1300's with the treatment of the Scots and Irish at the hands of the English and find barbarism the American Indians never dreamed of.
I call horse manure on this baloney about the Indians "shocking" Europeans with their "unique" brand of savagery. The comment that Indians tortured then killed all who surrendered is blatantly false. Many tribes kept prisoners as servants, some adopted them into the tribes as members, especially young women, girls and boys.
Good grief.
Revenge, a dish cooked up hot, but best served cold...
Good quotes, kind puts the issue in it's proper juxtaposed positions doesn't it?
In the eye of the beholder Freonia, in the eye of the beholder..
I wouldn't say they had no concept of "Ownership" or as the Europeans viewed land as a bundle of rights. But they absolutely did understand "Rights" to an area that they called home.
Value is the issue. I don't believe Natives valued land in the same way Europeans valued land.
There is nothing "Unique" about the savage brand of warfare the Natives employed. It was savage not only in the specific practices, tactics and personal techniques used. It was a shock to the europeans that there were none of the "Rules" that made warfare civilized.
Now that's an oxymoronic combination of words, "Civilized Warfare"
Like one can take pride in the efficiency of killing people and breaking things as efficiently as possible.
One of mans biggest failings is the pride he takes in being superior to other men, and demonstrating that so readily.
The problem with the Native European issue is efficiency of value.
The European system of the time was much more efficient at creating what the society valued than the Native system.
Competing societal systems, the much more organized and efficient system usually outstrips the less efficient one.
But let me ask a question?
I consider myself a Native American. I was born here, lived all my life here, and will die here. Just like my father before me and going back quite a few generations.
The same goes for every Indian. You are also Native Americans. you were born here, you have lived your life here and will die here, just like your fathers did for many many generations.
So we are talking about ancestors, mine came here over the floating bridge, yours over the land bridge.
What difference does it make at this late date of the direction we came and the conveyance we took?
Is one superior to the other?
Does one route make people who took that route better than other people that took other routes?
Are the first people that choose a route better than those that chose later or different routes?
I would say that the answer to all those questions is no.
Then what is the problem?
Value is the issue. I don't believe Natives valued land in the same way Europeans valued land.
Of course they didn't value it in the same way. Natives saw themselves as stewards of the land, protectors of it; Europeans saw themselves as procurers of it, with the right to extract every ounce of value from it regardless of the cost to the land itself or to surrounding neighbors or to the future.
The two civilizations were and are incompatible, as the clash over the XL Pipeline is proving. The problems have come with the Indians not having any power even over their own land; it has been used with permission of the feds to private corporations for decades as a dump for toxic waste, drilling and mining without having to follow the EPA standards, .. the result being toxic pollution of land and water on the reservations...
and now this pipeline, which Indians say they will meet with armed resistance. I pray they stand by their word. If they do, once again America will have the shot fired that is heard round the world. The government won't be able to have the media suppress the story the way they did when AIM was formed.
Good Reference Steve. I'd add to it "1491" by Mann.
NWM - you don't know nor do you understand American Indians so the difficulty you're having trying to "see" what some of us are telling you is huge. You are a history buff - of history written by dominant society - hence your one-sided view of "why it can't be".
I, and others on NT, have lived and taught the history of dominant society and of the Indian peoples so we have a much broader and specific perspective on what occurred than those who have not - of which, you are one.
You don't ask questions to learn - you ask questions that will lead to the answer you want- something I was taught to do in law school - but you're not very good at it because you broadcast your intent from the very beginning and, like a hound dog, you won't let go 'cause you know no better.
Until you learn how to open your mind and see more than one side to the story, you will continue with a losing argument - yours as being the only way.
My discussion with you has to end as the circle keeps getting narrower and narrower instead of broader and broader.
You say you have an open heart - if so, open your mind and note the beautiful meld of the two.
History Buff, {Chuckle}
I see a man so imbued with his truths he refuses to see facts that contradict his view of truth.
One sided view? In your opinion.
Like I've said of many who cannot counter the facts or the truths inherent in such facts, they usually resort to insults, cause they have no other way to defend their position.
Your last, this which I am responding to, is nothing but an insult. That surprises me from someone who wishes to discuss. It may be couched in very respectful tones and words, but it is still nonetheless, an insult used to claim moral superiority cause you have no other tactic left in the debate.
To an intelligent debater, I made my point, thank you for confirming it.
What you have illustrated here is you can only teach those who agree with your view. Those who YOU deem have an open mind. Which statement really truly reveals a closed mind in fact.
I disagree with the American Indian Movements ideology and purpose. the same as the Black Panthers purpose, (both organizations arose in the same period of time in the '60's and have verifiable ties with each other) Which automatically causes you to state I have a closed mind.
But then again, I do not wish to be taught things I have to understand before they can be explained. The issue with AIM is all have to understand that the Indian is superior, in everything he has done, every thing he will do. Everything good about this nation comes from Indians, down to and including our form of government, which was stolen from the Indians according to your version of history, A lot like Lenin ordered in 1918 that all school textbooks reflect that Russia was always a communist nation that was being repressed by the ruling class of bourgeois.
You can teach the history you want, I couldn't care less. You can claim whatever you want, I couldn't care less. Anyone that wants to know the truth will seek it out and find it. What AIM is attempting to create is the same thing Tecumseh tried to do amongst the peaceful tribes in the early 1800's, A separate nation. Doesn't matter to me, if either one of us would be alive when what is being created comes to pass, we would be standing on opposite sides of the battle line.
In AIM's view White Europeans and their descendants have always brought hate and suffering everywhere they have gone.
That is what AIM preaches, that is what they re-write plain history over, and I'm afraid it is what your preaching.
And it is exactly what the NAZI's preached about the Jews, what those Southern Gentleman always "KNEW" about the black man without having to be explained to anyone.
Something I fought against in the '60's and '70's.
Thank you for the discussion. You are entitled to your beliefs as we all are. But just like I don't go along with John's racist beliefs, I will not go along with your Native American take on things either. For the same reasons.
And what about my question?
Aren't we all Native Americans?
Does it really matter how we got here? Which foreign race (non native) we sprang from?
Does the date really matter? cause if it does then your arguing the same thing Chief Justice John Marshall did. (and that you Indian news site article quoted) You (Indians) had ownership by right of conquer. (Indians attained title to the land the same way the white man did)
So if we are all brothers as the great spirit claims, then why is there a difference?
Case in point to your lack of understanding - "You (Indians) had ownership by right of conquer"
There was no one here - who did we conquer??
Dominant society? 128 million people who had lived here for thousands of years before dominant society arrived were "conquered/massacred" - HUGE difference.
So, we are not all brothers as the great spirit claims.
Somehow I already understood that. (and it's implications)
Conquer, take possession by force.
I'm not going to demean the good conversation we have had by bandying words with you.
WE disagree and I'm happy to leave the interpretation to whoever wants to read it.
I personally believe factual history will carry the day over wanna be history to support a political agenda.
But that is just my uneducated opinion. (compared to an educated opinion)