╌>

US blocks attempts by Arab allies to fly heavy weapons directly to Kurds to fight Islamic State

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  buzz-of-the-orient  •  11 years ago  •  73 comments

US blocks attempts by Arab allies to fly heavy weapons directly to Kurds to fight Islamic State

US blocks attempts by Arab allies to fly heavy weapons directly to Kurds to fight Islamic State

Middle East allies accuse Barack Obama and David Cameron of failing to show strategic leadership in fight against Isil, as MPs could be given vote on whether to bomb Syria

By Con Coughlin, Defence Editor, The Telegraph, July 2, 2015

982_discussions.jpg

President Barack Obama pauses speaks at Taylor Stratton Elementary School in NashvillePhoto: AP

The United States has blocked attempts by its Middle East allies to fly heavy weapons directly to the Kurds fighting Islamic State jihadists in Iraq, The Telegraph has learnt.

Some of Americas closest allies say President Barack Obama and other Western leaders, including David Cameron, are failing to show strategic leadership over the worlds gravest security crisis for decades.

They now say they are willing to go it alone in supplying heavy weapons to the Kurds, even if means defying the Iraqi authorities and their American backers, who demand all weapons be channelled through Baghdad.

High level officials from Gulf and other states have told this newspaper that all attempts to persuade Mr Obama of the need to arm the Kurds directly as part of more vigorous plans to take on Islamic State of Iraq and the Levant (Isil) have failed. The Senate voted down one attempt by supporters of the Kurdish cause last month.

The officials say they are looking at new ways to take the fight to Isil without seeking US approval.


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   seeder  Buzz of the Orient    11 years ago

Since the Kurds are the only ones who are effectively defeating the ISIL scourge, I would like someone to explain to me the logic in their not being armed to wipe those bastards off the map. Please please don't tell me that the supply of arms has to go through proper channels, which means they're never going to get it. I cannot believe how much harm that idiot is doing to the world.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   Robert in Ohio    11 years ago

There is little reason to trust that anyone in Baghdad is qualified and motivated to effectively get arms to the Kurds or anyone else - how many of the weapons that we have sent to Baghdad have ended up in the hands of ISIS?

Who re we to tell Arabs how to manage affairs between the nations in the middle east?

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     11 years ago

The weapons sent for the Kurds through Bagdad have never reached the Kurds, nor will they in the future.

ISIS is using those same weapons that were sent to Bagdad against the Kurds and others.

This decision is beyond belief for me.

There was a story, with photos a while back where one unit of Kurds is using a WWI cannon, andhad to use it with great care, since there is very little ammo for it. They keep the cannon it excellent working order.

In addition, the refugees that are now in Kurdistan are taxing the Kurds to the extreme, yet they keep taking them in irregardless if they are Arabs, Yazadi's, Christian Assyrians...

Get them the help, both military and relief in helping the refugees NOW.

If the Arab countries want to arm they, then keep our frickin' noses out of it.

 
 
 
jennilee
Freshman Silent
link   jennilee    11 years ago
Now this I find offensive. To vote against the ones who are actually fighting ISIS is unbelievable.
 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    11 years ago
Why would anyone doubt Obama' strategic leadership. ISIS is winning aren't they?
 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    11 years ago

When you take in the alliance with Turkey/NATO, then you understand the the ramifications of why the US isn't supplying the Kurds. Look at a map. Turkey is NATO's southern bullwark against Russia. This isn't rocket science.

If you arm the Kurds, they just might take their weapons into Turkey and start fighting their too. So pick your poison.

Try this....

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    11 years ago

Why would anyone believe that you would provide unbiased analysis of the situation Six? You know the deal between the Turks YPG/PKK as well as anyone. Ankara has been fighting an internal civil war with the PKK for over thirty years now.

 
 
 
Chucky Stuart
Freshman Silent
link   Chucky Stuart    11 years ago

This is an easy one. Turkey is in NATO; Turkey does not like the Kurds. Even though the Kurds are the only folks effectively fighting ISIS, well-armed Kurds are a threat to Turkey. Right or wrong (and I definitely fall on the "wrong" side) as long as a NATO ally is against arming the Kurds, this will be the norm. Why do you think Turkey isn't doing squat against ISIS? Hell, ISIS is fighting their battles for them.

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    11 years ago

This comes down to the US administration not wanting to piss Turkey off, and attempting toapply policyin Iraq. Turkey currently resides at number 10 in the world, in military might; and, would be such a helpful partner in battling the Islamic State. They are quite worried about the Kurds being supplied arms of any size, as Turkey and they have been at each other for sometime now as well. Turkey sees armed Kurdis as a national security threat. At the same time the US would seemingly like to continue to push for the idea of a whole, unified Iraq, ignoring the practical realities in place there. They figure that transporting weapons via the Iraqi government may help to show faith in that administration, and help set them up as the center of power.

This is far from being over.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   Robert in Ohio    11 years ago

Kavika

Get them the help, both military and relief in helping the refugees NOW.

If the Arab countries want to arm they, then keep our frickin' noses out of it.

Totally agree!

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    11 years ago

Thank you Chucky.....

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

I find it odd that Turkey can't reach some kind of concordance with the kurds to deal with the far more serious problem of ISIL . If they don't like the kurds that much then deal with ISIL themselves . What is NATO's position on ISIL ?

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    11 years ago

You can't fix stupid.

And it is plain stupid that Cameron and Obama don't just jerk Turkey up by its wobbly neck, look it straight in the eye and say, "Look, Fool! ISIS is the enemy here and they HAVE to be defeated. If it takes the Kurds to defeat them, so be it.. the Kurds get the weapons to help them do it. You can fight your personal war with them AFTER we take care of the filth we know as ISIS who seems to be growing in numbers while you sit here with your thumb up your ass moaning about the Kurds. Now get with the program! because if you wait until ISIS is knocking on YOUR throne, we'll just drop a bomb and take you out with them!"

 
 
 
Chucky Stuart
Freshman Silent
link   Chucky Stuart    11 years ago

That's the problem. From the Turkish perspective, ISIL isn't a threat. In fact, they are probably secretly rooting for them to crush the Kurds.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   seeder  Buzz of the Orient    11 years ago

41.gif 113.gif

Let it be known that I have no love for Turkey and don't give a shit what happens to them. Their involvement in supporting the Mavi Marmora and then their bullshit complaint about how the terrorists on board got killed while attacking Israeli soldiers who had NO PROBLEM in boarding the other boats attempting to stop them from trying to break through a LEGAL blockade is just a move by Turkey to ingratiate itself among Muslim nations.

If the Kurds try to use the needed weaponry on Turkey, I thought Turkey was a member of NATO and the rest of NATO would come down hard on the Kurds. Surely the Kurds are aware of that, so the arguments about Turkey fearing the Kurds is just a lot of bullshit.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     11 years ago

From a geopolitical point of view, I believe that some of the reasoning are as follows.

1. Turkey is a NATO member, more importantly is that the U.S. maintains TWO air bases in Turkey.

2. From a military point of view, with the bases in Turkey, the U.S. has Iran completely surrounded.

3. PKK has been named a terrorist organization, 15 to 20 million Kurds live in Turkey

4. The US want to keep Iraq as one country.

5. Turkey is the linchpin to the Black Sea. Which means with Turkey being a NATO member, the Russians are bottled up in the Black Sea. For them to get to the Med and the open ocean, they would have to pass through the Bosporus Straits,which is Turkey. Turkey has imposed restrictions on warships passing through the straits, dating back to 1936.

Now, all that said, LET THE GULF COUNTRIES SUPPLY THE KURDS WITH ARMS.

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov    11 years ago
I choose the Kurds.
 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober    11 years ago

Turkey is part of the larger group of NATO countries . But when it comes to certain issues they go their own way ...

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    11 years ago

If the Kurds try to use the needed weaponry on Turkey, I thought Turkey was a member of NATO and the rest of NATO would come down hard on the Kurds. Surely the Kurds are aware of that, so the arguments about Turkey fearing the Kurds is just a lot of bullshit.

It is considered and internal insurgency to Turkey, and nothing that NATO would respond to.

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    11 years ago

Five for five with that post Kavika.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   seeder  Buzz of the Orient    11 years ago

It would be a real "Thanksgiving" to see Turkey roasted, as far as I'm concerned.

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    11 years ago

I'm not a huge fan of Turkey either, but one look at a map and you understand why the Kurds take a backseat to the Turks.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   seeder  Buzz of the Orient    11 years ago

I'd like to see them get a seat, even a back one.

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    11 years ago

Fly.... I'm not here to provide an unbiased analysis. I know who the bad guy is. He's the one who has not taken even the best opportunities to fight ISIS, like when they were in the middle of the dessert between towns early on, you know the JV team, the one who couldn't make up his mind to go and get Foley until enough time had passed for them to move him. Yea, he's the bad guy and I have no use for him.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

Turkey isn't the issue as far as the Kurds getting an independent state....

From IBT: Turkey Ready To Accept Kurdish State in Northern Iraq

The ideal is to get a kurdish state (Kurdistan) back on the map as an independent nation. Turkey's war on the PKK has subsided as talks with the separatist political party have eased tensions over them wanting to seperate from Turkey proper.

The real issue is how much this administration wants to hold onto a complete Iraq. Probably because of deals made with the interim government of Iraq since they were first formed.

Turkey does not want into the fight against Isil because all it will do is inflame an already tense situation in their own country which is cooling off right now.

Turkey is foremost a US ally. Forget about Nato, when the defecation hits the rotary oscillator, Turkey will fall on the side of the US, NATO be damned. Turkey is puzzled at why the US wishes to maintain an Iraq in one piece. They can instantly bring resolution to at least a third of the area if they would drop that one part of the issue.

At that point Turkey WOULD get involved against ISIL. Their only objection would be removed. Turkey doesn't care if there is a Kurdish state, as long as it does not take any Turkish territory.

It's a problem where there is a plain settlement available, but someones throat is going to get cut.

Who's throat are you going to cut to get a concerted front against ISIL?

Answer that one please.

Turkey would quickly put down ISIL, if we would only get out of the way and let them...

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    11 years ago

Your objectivity is clouded by your hatred, and has been for many years now Six.

You make this statement.... "has not taken even the best opportunities to fight ISIS"

So just what would you do differently? Lets see how quickly we can get to the root problem that is Iraq, and ISIS while we dissect your plan. Toss in Iran for good measure if you want.

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    11 years ago

Since the current government in Iraq can't seem to get their collective shit together..... Split the country up. That will make the Kurds, the Saudis, an Turks happy. I'm sure Iran wouldn't argue against it too much either.

The three way split has been suggested before. Time to look at it again.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

Lets take this out a bit further.

Lets say we drop support for the Iraqi interim government and push for an independent Kurdish state. Easily done and the Kurds would love us for it. Turkey would say wonderful and would be able to form a peaceful resolution to it's own internal troubles.

I feel that the Turks would actually help the fledgling Kurdish nation blow ISIL back into whatever is left of Iraq. The problem now becomes Syria and it's three way civil war. The Turks and the Kurds could care less about Assad's regime and it's survival or not. But they would want the ISIL forces eliminated there. Problem is ISIL is wrapped up in the overall Syrian resistance which has the support of the US. WE would like to see the Assad regime gone as would our Israeli friends.

WHY?

Syria (all by itself) is not a threat to Israel, although they do make life difficult for the Israelis.

I would say give up on Assad to defeat the greater evil of ISIL.

This would leave the two main Arab powers in the ME as Arabia and Iran. (Egypt isn't a real issue anymore) Iran cannot directly attack Saudi Arabia a that would be a direct attack on the US. Iran would be even more bottled up than they are now. Allow the remainder of Iraq to determine it's own fate, which probably would not be US friendly anyway.

The worst would be that remaining Iraq fall to being annexed into Iran. The Saudi's wouldn't like that at all. Probably Iraq would reformulate as it's own nation with portions under the influence of either side.

This is probably the best outcome we could hope for given the current situation.

But it would force the Iran-ISIL connection out into the open. And bring relative stability to the region with most of it in the US camp.

Which would be a good thing.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   seeder  Buzz of the Orient    11 years ago

You want to just about die laughing? Read this:

The Brits simply don't believe there is any connection. Maybe that's why they're being overrun by Jihad. With Obama's attitude, the USA is next.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    11 years ago

If you arm the Kurds, they just might take their weapons into Turkey and start fighting their too

Actually, I think the opposite is true. The Kurds are now occupied with fighting ISIS.

But if Turkey invades Syria and starts massacring Kurds, the Kurds will be really pissed--and that's when many will prhobablybegin to infiltrate urkey and fight the Turks where they're most vulnerable-- on their own soil. there. That's what I see as a potential consequemce of the Turks once again attempting genocide of the Kurds.

While much ofthe rest of the world might not care about massacres of the Kurds, the Kurds will. And they do have a tendency to defend themselves-- even without adequate weaponry.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    11 years ago

There is little reason to trust that anyone in Baghdad is qualified and motivated to effectively get arms to the Kurds or anyone else

Actually in the situation of the Kurds, its not so much a case of the Baghdad government not being motivated. It goes beyond hat-- genocide of the Kurdish people would make them only too happy.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    11 years ago

Ankara has been fighting an internal civil war with the PKK for over thirty years now.

Kinda like the Indians, the Jews, and several other minorities. Despite numerous attempts to exterminate them, they've all managed to somehow survive.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    11 years ago

Even though the Kurds are the only folks effectively fighting ISIS, well-armed Kurds are a threat to Turkey

I disagree. Giventhat ISIS, ISIL (Iraq), the Sunni Arabs, the Shia Arabs, Iran and Turkey would like to see them exterminated-- and have for years-- I think that right now the Kurds have other priorities besides starting a war with one of the world's strongest military powers.

If ISIS and friends are trying to kill them in -- why should the Kurds suddenly decide to attack Turkey? Why should they leavetheir wives in children in iraq and Syria (who are vunerabe to IS attack) and go on a foreign adventure-- by invading Turkey?

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    11 years ago

If they don't like the kurds that much then deal with ISIL themselves

What makes you assume the Turks don't like ISIL?

The two groups the Turks hate the most are the Kurds..and Assad. And ISIS is one of the main groups fighting Assad's forces! (Probsbly the most effective one at that).

Turkey want Assad out-- why should he destroy the group doing the most to oust them?

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   seeder  Buzz of the Orient    11 years ago

Resiliance is an common trait among them.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    11 years ago

If they don't like the kurds that much then deal with ISIL themselves

Yup-- just as they see ISIS as a de facto ally. (ISIS gols are aligned with the Turks-- ISIS wants to destroy Assad and the Kurds-- Erdogan loves both those goals!)

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    11 years ago

If the Kurds try to use the needed weaponry on Turkey, I thought Turkey was a member of NATO and the rest of NATO would come down hard on the Kurds.

Bound by treaty obligations-- an attack on any NATO member is considered an attack on all! The kurds mah be brave fighters, but do they want to use their rifles and light machine guns again st all of NATO?

DUH!

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    11 years ago

LET THE GULF COUNTRIES SUPPLY THE KURDS WITH ARMS.

Sounds all very well and good-- but the problem goes beyond the US not supplying weapons. The problem is that the U.S. is applying pressure on Europe not to arm the Kurds-- and if the Gulf states wanted to, there's no doubt that the U would pressure them as well!

Obama doesn't want the U.S. to meddle in other countries affairs-- except when the meddling suits his own agenda.

(Remember how he criticized Netanyahu's attempts at meddling in US affairs? I the time I thought-- sarcastically-- why should Israel be allowed to meddle in US affairs-- we certainly would never meddle in Israeli affairs! ..../sarcasm).

And the outrage that allies would spy on us..followed by the uncovering of U.S. spying on Germany...boy was Angela Merkel ever not amused!)

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    11 years ago

Turkey does not want into the fight against Isil because all it will do is inflame an already tense situation in their own country which is cooling off right now.

And partly because ISIs/ISIL is fighting Turkey's main enemy-- Assad!

They havve some similar goals.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    11 years ago

Since the current government in Iraq can't seem to get their collective shit together..... Split the country up. That will make the Kurds, the Saudis, an Turks happy. I'm sure Iran wouldn't argue against it too much either.

The three way split has been suggested before. Time to look at it again.

I totlly agree.

Only one problem though-- one of Obama's main policy objectives is to keep Iraq united-- come hell or high water! (Or should I say com even more hell and high water?).

Heck, he wants that even more than he want to kow-tow to his Turkish masters. Even more than he thinks that the U.S. should stop meddling in other countries affairs-- even more than he wants the U.S. and not Israel should decide when and where they build their homes.

Making sure that three groups that have hated each other for decades are forced to be part of the same artificial country is one of Obama's top foreign policy objectives!!!

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    11 years ago

The Turks and the Kurds could care less about Assad's regime and it's survival or not.

I love it! Great concept. Totally false of course-- but a really cool idea!

So, if anyone is interested in the actual facts, here's the relevant fact. (Of course looking at the actual facts is not nearly as much fun as making things up..heh Grin.gif ).

One of the top priorities of Turkey now is the overthrow of Assad!

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    11 years ago

Lets say we drop support for the Iraqi interim government and push for an independent Kurdish state. Easily done and the Kurds would love us for it.

True.

Turkey would say wonderful .

Sure they would. (That's probably why they are trying so hard to prevent anyone from shipping arms to the Kurds to defend themselves from when the Turks invade and try to massacre them). Yep-- the Turks and the Kurds are extremely fond of each other-- in fact, Erdogan stays awake nights having wet dreams about his hope for a Kurdish state).15.gif

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

Link? Lets see the proof.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

Did you even read the link I originally posted? Turkey, would love a Kurdish state, as long as it isn't in Turkey.

(although it would probably spark a campaign to get all the Turkish Kurds to leave Turkey for Kurdistan, that would be a better resolution to killing them all now wouldn't it?)

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

Links? I'm all wet behind the ears? haven't a clue? prove it.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    11 years ago

Syria (all by itself) is not a threat to Israel, although they do make life difficult for the Israelis.

Yeah,. Every once in a while they shoot something at Israeland murder of few of them-- but hey, why do the Israelis get so upset? I think their just over sensitive abut their friends and families being murdered in cold blood-- wouldn't you agree?

Iran cannot directly attack Saudi Arabia

Yes they can. In fact, they currently are-- their Houthi proxies are currently on the Saudi border and I believe they've murdered a few Saudis in just the last few days..

that would be a direct attack on the US.

24.gif 24.gif 24.gif

Err-- no it would not. (A quick question-- who is it who writes your material? Most of it is totally false of course-- but on one level it is quite funny).

The worst would be that remaining Iraq fall to being annexed into Iran. The Saudi's wouldn't like that at all.

Probably the Iraqis wouldn't b too happy about that either. But hey-- who's counting?

Probably Iraq would reformulate as it's own nation with portions under the influence of either side.

Or neither side. Or both. Or maybe even the Brazilian women's beach volleyball team. (Hey, when you're writing fiction, anything's possible, eh? Why limit your imagination by being artificially hemmed in by the facts?

But it would force the Iran-ISIL connection out into the open.

But that so-called "connection" is already "out into the open".Its no secret.Iran and ISIL are bitter enemies. In fact, ianian forces have actually inaded iraq and are engaged in battle with ISIL as we speak. Yup-- that's how much "out in the open it already is".

And bring relative stability to the region with most of it in the US camp.

Of course. But wait-- don't most Of the Arabs already love us? And the Iranians.And the Syrians. And the Egyptians?

BTW, I totally enjoyed your humorous monologue-- its was one of the better attempts at comedy I've seen in quite a while.

One question though-- where can I gt some of the stuff that you are smoking?15.gif 15.gif 15.gif

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    11 years ago

The BBC has rejected demands by British lawmakers to stop using the term "Islamic State" when referring to the jihadist group that is carving out a self-declared Caliphate in the Middle East.

Lord Hall of Birkenhead, the BBC's director general, said that the proposed alternative, "Daesh," is pejorative and using it would be unfair to the Islamic State, thereby casting doubt upon the BBC's impartiality.

Prime Minister David Cameron recently joined the growing chorus of British politicians who argue that the name "Islamic State" is offensive to Muslims and should be banned from the English vocabulary.

Great link Buzz!

These people are really, really hilarious. Almost a match for Nowhere Man's sidespliting humor!. (Well, not quite that hilarious-- but almost). Unfortunately it might take quite a few more terrorist militant attacks before the Brits wake up.

And there does seem to be some disagreement over whether using the term "Daesh" of "Islamic State" would be the better solution to keep UK Muslims from being offended. And which one woud effectively keep the UK totally terror-free.

But I think I know a good way to get to find out. let's have a NT poll (whether the use of the term "Daesh" or "Islamic State" would be the one that would totally stop terror militant attacks. A NMT poll-- that would tell us for sure!

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

Ridicule? Insults?

That's all you got? You pulling a John on me now? Grin.gif

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    11 years ago

as Prince Alfred in a Can

Alfred-- or Albert?

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna    11 years ago

Links? I'm all wet behind the ears?

Yes.

haven't a clue?

You have plenty of clues- but they're all the wrong ones.

prove it.

No.

I think it would be more fun to leave everyone in suspense!Grin.gif

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

That's fine, I'll wait. Grin.gif

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    11 years ago
I thought Bush was a boob but Obama is giving him a run for his money. Obama backed the Arab spring and stood back with his hands in his pockets to see whether the pro democracy forces or jihadists prevailed. At the same time, he fueled the Syrian rebels to topple Assad even though the rebels included ISIS, known psychopaths. He also turned s blind eye to the Iraqi Shia dominated government oppression of the Sunni until it drove them to revolt. ISIS (a Sunni group) moved into the forefront of the US backed Sunni rebellion in Syria and to the forefront of the Shia government defense against the Sunni uprising in Iraq -- effectively putting himself on both sides of a regional sectarian civil war. Really stupid.The players in this war have different intersts. Iran supports Assad in Syria and hopes to extend its influence through Iraq, Lebanon and Syria. The Sunnis led by the Saudis and the gulf states want to curb Iran's influence. ISIS, the former Sunni attack dog, has gone mad and needs to be put down but Sunnis smile whenever the dog mangles the Shia. Due to the Arab spring, Egypt is paralyzed and not a regional player right now.Turkey wants to extend its influence as well through Muslim brotherhood parties but is opposed by the Saudis and gulf states. The Kurds pose more of a threat to Turkey because they make up 20 percent of the population and Kurdish terrorist groups make clear that their objective is to create an autonomous Kurdistan out of pieces of Turkey, Syria, and Iraq. In Turkeys opinion, Kurdistan would be a threat to Turkish borders and, depending on the Turkish party in power, Turkey could invade Kurdistan should it ever be established. The Turks strongly oppose providing the Kurds with heavy weapons that could, one day, be turned on Turkey.The Saudis remain annoyed that the U.S. focus is on defeating ISIS and strengthening the Kurds rather than toppling Assad. Iraq doesn't want the Kurds armed to the point that they can secede from the country. Iran agrees with Iraq. So basically, nobody wants the Kurds armed to the point that they become a major player. If we arm the Kurds, then we may have replaced one conflict with another as Turkey, Iran, Iraq, and the Saudi/gulf states take action to protect their respective national interests.This is all quite complicated and is a lot like being in a small china closet such that every time you bend over to pick up something you dropped and broke, you knock over something else and break that too. To me, the simplest direct solution to stop trying to pick sides in this food fight and send in US ground troop to crush ISIS (at the request of the Iraqi government). Execute an agreement to maintain forces in Iraq to ensure stability (which I'm sure they'll agree to rather than have their heads on the end of a stick); stop trying to topple Assad and let him and Iran take care of ISIS in Syria; refrain from emboldening the Kurds and inflaming Turkey; and broker a meaningful peace between the Sunni and Shia in Iraq using Iran and the Saudis.Arming the Kurds directly is a bad shortsighted idea and will just break something else.
 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   seeder  Buzz of the Orient    11 years ago

As for your poll, Krishna, what do the terrorists call themselves? They think they are practising GENUINE Islam.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

OR,

We can just get the fuck out and let them settle it themselves....

(which would be the best solution of all)

 
 
 
Larry Hampton
Professor Quiet
link   Larry Hampton    11 years ago

US forceswould decimate isis in short order. They wouldn't stand a chance.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   seeder  Buzz of the Orient    11 years ago

I agree with a lot of 1ofmany has to say here, save for two things. I believe the Gulf States should be allowed to defend themselves if it means nipping the problem in the bud by their sending adequate heavy weapons to the Kurds so that they don't have to fend off ISIS on their own lands. Somehow I think that's something the USA has always done. And secondly, I think the Kurds deserve to reinstate their own nation state, the one that was taken away from them, even if it omits the Turkey portion.

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1    11 years ago

To me, the simplest direct solution to stop trying to pick sides in this food fight and send in US ground troop to crush ISIS (at the request of the Iraqi government). Execute an agreement to maintain forces in Iraq to ensure stability

Do you think this can be sold to the American people? I would bet no. And I would also bet that it would be a campaign killer at this time. Americans are tired of sending their kids off to die. The other worry I have is that with ISIS defeated, it will only sew the seed for another as bad or worse organization to fill the vacuum.

 
 
 
Robert in Ohio
Professor Guide
link   Robert in Ohio    11 years ago

Fly

I gotta agree with you that a permanent presence in Iraq is not an option politically, though it is starting to look like a reality without official policy.

I think you would get more support for Nowhere Man's idea to get out and let them settle it themselves, since some of these groups have been fighting among themselves for centuries.

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    11 years ago

OR, We can just get the fuck out and let them settle it themselves....(which would be the best solution of all)

That would be my preference in an ideal world but that's not the world in which we live. Our meddling to topple Qaddafihas created a failed state in Libya and provided ISIS (and others) with a foothold to export terrorism into Europe. We toppled Saddam and Iraq is now on the verge of being a failed state. It will fail and/or become a puppet state of Iran if we leave. Syria could collapse and become another failed state controlled by ISIS. These countries sit on or around a major part of the oil resources that fuel the global economy. ISIS would be able to export terrorism backed by tremendous oil resources and/or manipulate the world economy. We're not there out of altruism but rather self-interest. We can no more let them sort this out themselves than we cold let a rattlesnake pit sort itself out in the middle of the New York Stock exchange.

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    11 years ago

I would agree with Buzz except the Kurdish solution is, in my opinion,a recipe for creating another problem.Turkey sees the creation ofKurdistanalong its border as a serious threat and may respondmilitarily. This would make a dangerous regional situation evenmore unstable.

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    11 years ago

Do you think this can be sold to the American people? I would bet no. And I would also bet that it would be a campaign killer at this time. Americans are tired of sending their kids off to die. The other worry I have is that with ISIS defeated, it will only sew the seed for another as bad or worse organization to fill the vacuum.

I have no doubt that the idea is political poison but Obama's solution is no solution at all and the situation is getting worse. A war cannot be won from the air and the Kurds are an inadequate ground force. Plus, the Arabs don't trust the Kurds and accuse the Kurdsof pushing Arabs out of Kurdish occupied areas so the Kurds can have it for themselves. The Iraqi army is dysfunctional. The Sunnis tribes don't want to fight for the Shia government (that oppresses them) and/or the Shia oppose arming the Sunni to the point that they present a greater threat to the Shia government. The Shia militias (formerly called death squads) are not welcomed by the Sunni that they have killed.

Another terrorist group will no doubt fill the vacuum left by ISIS but it won't be marching as an army when they see what US forces can do to ISIS in a properly orchestrated campaign. This could be done quickly with minimal loss of American lives.

I don't want to pull-up poison ivy but I'd rather pull up a patch ofit nowthan a forest of it later.

 
 
 
Enoch
Masters Silent
link   Enoch    11 years ago

Dear Friend Buzz: I cannot explain this policy failure.

ISIS (ISIL) is not a direct threat to the USA, Canada, and for the most part Europe. It can be if we send troops on the ground. That is precisely what they want.

The recruiting wing of ISIS is heavily sectarian Jihadist and extreme in its violence. Most of their military success comes from ostensibly secular former Baathists who were dislocated by US policy after the fall of Saddam Hussein.

Their cause is local. Their appeal international, but Arab and Farsi world centered. Their goal is a Caliphate on what they opine is their soil not ours.

The biggest enemy they have is not us. It is the people whop live there, and do not want to live under any brutal theocracy (Sunni or Shia).

The Kurds are, you are most correct, the most effective at fighting them now. to under support them and prevent others from assisting them in fighting the good fight will sooner or later devolve into yet another policy failure of sending in US and allied western troops into Iraq and Syria to fight them. That will only focus local attention on us as foreign invaders.

Throughout the middle east, as globally, it is best for us to back those allied with our interests who care more about their freedom and future to fight for it. We are not the world's police force. We cannot care more about the fate of locals than do they.

Isn't it about time we gave the Kurds what hey need, and let western and more importantly middle eastern allies join in backing alocal winner on our side for a change?

E.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

I can agree with most of what your saying firstofmany, Except the kurdistan issue. Turkey has already announced that they wouldn't have a problem with a kurdistan nation as long as it doesn't involve Turkish territory. Whether the Kurds take the fight to the Turks in the future the turks feel that is the safer course.

Advocating for the break away of the kurdish autonimous region is the position Turkey has taken. I think they are hoping that it would turn into a kurdish israel.

Not that it would eliminate the kurds from turkey, but it takes away the argument of breaking away from Turkey. Except we have this ungodly reasoning that Iraq should stay together. Iraq was a "Created" country in the first place. Created by international fiat. (much like Yugoslavia was a created country) If we are thinking about resolving the inherent religious and nationalist issues in the region. Why not start where it all began.

Lets fix the errors of imperialism and all the horrors that created.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     11 years ago

Turkish President announced that they will never allow a Kurdish state in Syria, and earlier said the same about Iraq.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   seeder  Buzz of the Orient    11 years ago

Erdogan is the problem.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     11 years ago

Erdogan is a big problem. The Turkish army is hesitant about deploying addition troops to the Syrian border as ordered by Erdogan.

Turkey may have no choice but to accept a Kurdish Syria and this will IMO link to a Kurdish Iraq. The YPG now control almost the whole length of the border between Turkey and Syria. The are now with in 30 miles of the de facto capital of ISIS, Raqqa.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

I agree Erdogan is a huge roadblock to resolving the Kurdish issue and the Syrian problem also.

Where his hate for the Kurds comes from I don't know but it sure has stopped any progress.

I think that Turkey, the government proper and the army has reconciled the need for a kurdish state. It makes the ethnic issue easier to deal with. Why Ergodan can't see that is beyond me.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     11 years ago

Erdogan is a problem, but the hate for the Kurds has been inbred in Turkey for hundreds of years. Read the history of Turkey and the Kurds. So this is nothing new, nor is it only Erdogan.

Actually is was Erdogan that agreed to peace talks with the PKK, but in the ensuing couple of years there have been many set backs due to Turkish attacks on PKK and Kurds in Turkey. That, and Erdogan increasing hostile attitude towards the peace talks.

The recent elections in Turkey opened up a whole new front for Erdogan to battle. ...

Turkey will never allow a free Kurdistan on Turkish territory. Remember this was once Kurdish land.

The Turks may have no choice but to accept a Kurdistan in Syria and Iraq.

The Syrian Kurds along with the FSA and Assyrians (Christians) have virtually shut down the border between the two countries, thus stopping IS men and supplies from crossing in Syria from Turkey. They are now advancing on Raqqa, the de facto capital of the IS.

Yesterday, the heaviest coalition air strikes took place outside of Raqqa.

The area now controlled by the Syrian Kurds, (YPG) Assyrians, and FSA is expanding, as is the area controlled by the Peshmerga (Kurds)in Iraq.

Those are the facts.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   seeder  Buzz of the Orient    11 years ago

I guess I should change my comment to "Erdogan is a problem" rather than "the problem".

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

The way I read that article, The AKP's hate is manifesting itself in the election results. The Turkish people are saying no in larger and larger numbers. I don't believe that the kurds will ever have sufficient votes to form a government, but attitudes are shifting more towards a more androgynous Turkey driven by it's people.

I mean clearly, a lot of ethnic Turks had to vote with the Kurds to upset the AKP's absolute majority.

It's not the Kurds that would be the destruction of Ergodan, it will be his own policies which appear to be angering more and more ethnic Turks than ever before.

Absolutism tends to do that to absolutists. The Turkish citizenry aren't stupid and realize that to have peace, one has to allow all people the right to be.

The vote was a vote for peace.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     11 years ago

''Although the party still earned a plurality of votes in the election, the result has all but doomed President Recep Tayyip Erdogans ambition to rewrite the Turkish constitution and transform his office into a super-presidency, consolidating his grasp on power.''

That is the main reason for their losses in the election. Combine that with the spending and corruption in his party, the slowing big time of the economy, the slumping of their currency against the U.S. dollar, and that the Kurds used an outreach to other small groups contributed to the losses suffered by APK.

The message was that they do not want Edrogan to become a Super President with unlimited power.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    11 years ago

Yes they don't want an absolutist to become even more absolutist.

The fact that all the other parties are publicly stating that they will not form a coalition with his party tells a tale also, especially given the fact that the Kurdish party is now one of the three primary parties in Turkey given the results of this election.

That is a monumental rejection of Ergodan and his policies and a monumental statement of support amongst the people for the Kurds.

Times are a changin in Turkey.

 
 

Who is online


Gsquared
CB


79 visitors