╌>

"INDIAN ENOUGH" Who gets to be Native American?

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  1stwarrior  •  10 years ago  •  104 comments

"INDIAN ENOUGH" Who gets to be Native American?

http://fusion.net/story/279637/white-people-claiming-native-identity/

“Inhumane.” “Dishonorable.” “Genocide.” These were just a few of the dozens of Sharpied comments written on the hands of indigenous activists recently, as they launched a grassroots, social-media movement against tribal disenrollment, which is when a tribal government throws out its own members. The campaign, #StopDisenrollment , is aimed at, well, stopping disenrollment, by gathering people’s stories and asking activists to post pictures of what disenrollment means to them.

In recent years, tribal disenrollment has become increasingly routine. An Indian may be thrown out due to a clan rivalry or political in-fighting, or when a tribe  trims members  to consolidate casino revenues. Losing one’s tribal enrollment often means losing jobs, housing, educational benefits, and social services. It also means grappling with the identity mindfuck of being told: “You’re no longer an Indian in the eyes of the federal government.”

Meanwhile, people like  Andrea Smith  and  Rachel Dolezal  have claimed a Native identity as their own, echoing generations of white people before them. Even Senator  Elizabeth Warren  has claimed a Native identity because of “ family stories ” about her Cherokee roots. A recent Pew Research Center  study showed that fully half of all U.S. adults who claimed a multiracial identity said they were white and American Indian. That’s 8.5 million people.

 

Why are so many white Americans claiming to be part Indian, even as Native people are telling each other they’re not Indian enough? Does having cultural pride matter when one is steeped in privilege and the power and access that come with it? The questions of what it means to be Native American in 2016, who gets to decide what “counts” as Native, and how one goes about proving it are enormously complex.

The question is also deeply personal—I’m half-white and half-Native, but I look white. (I tan about as well as an aspirin.) In the rare instances someone guesses I have a non-white ethnicity, I often get Asian or “Bjork.” My mother, however, is Tewa, a tribe that is not one of the 567 federally recognized tribes in the United States (there are 400 to 500 tribes that aren’t recognized), and our family has never lived on a reservation. My mother has worked on several reservations throughout Arizona, but because our family has never been on the tribal rolls, she was often not considered “Indian enough” to live on the reservations where she worked. As a child when I would visit the “ rez ,” the grandmothers called me “little white girl” in Spanish, which was hard to argue with.

“I would love those 8.5 million people to be Native American. But there’s another step to that—that you participate fully in the community you’re claiming.”

Taté Walker, editor of  Native Peoples  magazine and writer/speaker for the online magazine Everyday Feminism,  delineated  how shockingly common it is for white people to claim to be Indian—and not in the way I do.

 

“Natives must have been getting it on with EVERYBODY for this to even remotely make sense,” she wrote, referring to the Pew Research Center study. “[B]ecause of the total U.S. population, about 2.6 million people identified as American Indian/Alaska Native alone, according to  2013 Census estimates .”

The problem with doing this, Walker told me, goes far beyond the seemingly harmless action of checking a box on a form, with or without “family stories.”

“I would love those 8.5 million people to be Native American,” she said. “But there’s another step to that—that you participate fully in the community that you’re claiming.”

One of the biggest reasons it’s been acceptable for white people to posture as Native is due to a certain romanticism about Native culture and people. “If you go back to the journals of Christopher Columbus,” Walker said, “it references [Natives as] these free-spirited nature sprites who dance naked in the moonlight and their kids are running wild, and it just sounds so  savage , but savage was a term for  free .” As colonialism spread across the continent, so did that idea of freedom, and “the idea that ‘Natives have it great, so let’s take it’ has become ‘Natives have it great, so let’s take it as an identity,’” Walker said.

 

Tiya Miles, an African-American scholar of Native American Studies at the University of Michigan, agreed that Americans romanticize Indian-ness more than other groups. “Native people were the first ones on this land,” she said. “And in that standing, they possess an authenticity, an elevated symbolic status, and even a little bit of perceived magic, that the people who came later wish they could have for themselves. Take it from Disney.”

One reason white people claim to be Native is that no one wants to be on the side of the oppressor.

People who claim a Native identity often have not been asked to back it up or validate it in any way. Perhaps this is why many non-indigenous people historically have claimed to be indigenous in order to stake a claim in (i.e. steal) tribal land or resources. This kind of blatant ethnic fraud is changing with the rise of social media and other public outing mechanisms. Walker pointed out that in the last three or four decades, more than a dozen such white people who have staked their careers on being Native have been publicly called out for it, and in some cases—such as with academic and activist Andrea Smith, who attracted national attention for claiming a Cherokee identity—a lot of her work, on violence against Native women, for instance, has been (sadly) invalidated.

Part of claiming an identity is being  claimed in return . “Humans are who we are in large part because of the relationships that we shape and share, and because of how our lives unfold interdependently within families and communities,” Miles told me. “If I stand in front of a mirror all by my lonesome claiming that I am such-and-such and no one around me who is such-and-such embraces me in that claim, what meaning can I really ascribe to that identity?”

 

My mother remembers being on the Yaqui reservation one day and an older man asking if she was someone’s daughter, and if she was Yaqui. “I gave a long explanation about not belonging to any recognized tribes,” she said. “He smiled sweetly at me and said, ‘I recognize you. So if anybody ever asks you, tell them you are my daughter. That should be enough.’”



The author's great-great grandmother


Of course, the idea of proving one’s Native-ness is often far more complicated than that, especially because “proof” often involves documentation like tribal enrollment and  CDIB  (Certificate or Degree of Indian or Alaska Native Blood) cards. CDIB cards and “rolls”  were introduced  to indigenous people by the federal government to break up Indian land (so that settlers could use it) and force tribal communities to assimilate into “American” culture. It’s difficult to imagine, say, an Italian American being asked to prove his or her identity through blood quantum or in any of the other relentless ways indigenous people have been asked to prove who they are for the last hundreds of years.

Ultimately, disenrollment is a spurious issue because the reasons for doing so often go against the traditional ways Native people have determined community, kinship, and belonging. The #StopDisenrollment campaign attempts to bring awareness to the sad irony of Natives imposing the government’s racial categories, which were created to oppress them, and using those same systems to disenfranchise their own people.

Another reason white people claim to be Native is that no one wants to be on the side of the oppressor. Ethnically aligning oneself with a historically oppressed people makes one feel less guilty for the terrible actions perpetrated by the U.S. government. But, as Walker pointed out:


 


“It’s the most colonial mind[E]thnic frauds take away opportunities from legit Native people. That academic post? That job? That conference keynote? That college entrance slot? Someone who deserved it more—in a fair and equitable sense—didn’t get it because of someone like Ward Churchill, Elizabeth Warren [who listed herself as Native American in the Association of American Law School directories from 1986 to 1995], or Rachel Dolezal. And the thing is, all these folks could have done super-powerful ally work just being their awesome white selves.set I can grasp,” Walker continued. “This idea that Native identity can be taken or put on a certificate, almost like a dog breed.”

Unlike identity, skin is something we all understand. The right shade gives you ease and power and visibility.

White Americans, particularly those of European ancestry, often fall into a weird cultural gap, struggling to form a collective identity made up of the places and cultures they left behind and the worlds they live in today. White Americans who ascribe to Native identities take on a “symbolic ethnicity,” a term coined by sociologist Herbert Gans in 1979, which allows people to claim an ethnicity without changing any behaviors or having real social costs.


Witness, for instance, the amount of white people who become proudly Irish for one day out of the year on March 17. These people typically do not belong to Irish-American organizations, participate in Irish causes, or marry Irish folks. It might seem contradictory to think of ethnicity as something that’s not biologically fixed, but as Harvard sociologist Mary Waters has  noted , ethnicity is a social phenomenon.

Complicating the idea of optional or symbolic ethnicity are things like intermarriage, “passing,” and changing social or political allegiances throughout one’s life. The most demonstrable difference is that for white Americans, as the majority group, it is a choice, whereas minorities often don’t have that luxury. A white-looking person like me can check a box on a form that says “Native American” without having to worry about the racial or social injustices faced by those who don’t “pass” as white, such as my mother.

For white Americans, ethnicity has become voluntary, something we can put on or take off at will, rather than something fixed. Unlike identity, skin is something we all understand. The right shade gives you ease and power and visibility. I would never deny that looking like a white girl has shaped the laws of the world in my favor and my place within it. But I am also my mother, shaped by her love and acceptance and belonging.

When I was in preschool, my peers and I were cutting up construction paper for our Thanksgiving costumes. “The boys will dress as Indians and the girls will be pilgrims,” my teacher said. Together we would eat soup in our paper hats and headbands, and genocide would in no way be discussed.

I started to cut out my crude, four-year-old approximation of a feather when my teacher stopped me. “You are a pilgrim,” she said.

“I want to be an Indian,” I said, holding up my tiny feather.

“But you’re a girl,” she said. “So you’re a pilgrim.” She picked up a gold piece of paper and started fashioning a buckle for my pilgrim hat.

I didn’t argue with her, but after she left, I took my solitary feather and glued it to the back of my pilgrim hat. No blood tests or ID cards required.


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   seeder  1stwarrior    10 years ago

“It’s the most colonial mind[E]thnic frauds take away opportunities from legit Native people. That academic post? That job? That conference keynote? That college entrance slot? Someone who deserved it more—in a fair and equitable sense—didn’t get it because of someone like Ward Churchill, Elizabeth Warren [who listed herself as Native American in the Association of American Law School directories from 1986 to 1995], or Rachel Dolezal. And the thing is, all these folks could have done super-powerful ally work just being their awesome white selves.set I can grasp,” Walker continued. “This idea that Native identity can be taken or put on a certificate, almost like a dog breed.”

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    10 years ago

B-b-but I have an ancestor who was a Cherokee Princess!angel

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   seeder  1stwarrior    10 years ago

Funny you say that.  My wife is from Venezuela as is her mother and grand-mother.  For kicks and curiosity, we had her DNA tested by one of the large "ancestry" firms - AND - according to her DNA, she's a direct descendant of Chief Bushy Head of the Cherokee - DIRECT DESCENDANT.

And her family is from Venezuela????

Wow.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient  replied to  1stwarrior   10 years ago

A DNA test done by a reputable lab is quite infallible. So go figure.

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   JohnRussell    10 years ago

I used to be involved in a social club that hosted a fairly large , private , St Patrick's Day party every year (75-100 people). The people who weren't Irish were just coming to drink (green beer) , dance a jig, and act boisterous. Irish folks don't drink green beer, ever, other than to perhaps be polite on occasion. 

I think non- Indians who claim Indian heritage see something exotic in it.

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1  replied to  JohnRussell   10 years ago

I think non- Indians who claim Indian heritage see something exotic in it.

Being trendy for the times?

I'm proud of my German heritage, but that and two dollars will get me a cup of coffee.....

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser  replied to  JohnRussell   10 years ago

As a child, before it was "fashionable", I was always fascinated by my great-great grandmother, who was Cherokee.  I asked a great many questions of my grandfather, and was proud that she was in my heritage.  For me, it isn't something that I think of as fashionable, as my family, (all but Grandpa), was fairly dismayed by my questions and desires to know more about her.

I was reared in the white world, and know little or nothing about my Cherokee heritage-- except what I've read and studied.  Yet, the stories my Grandpa told me, as a child, are very similar to many of the Cherokee folklore.  So, while I have her picture, I have no proof.  I have no desire to jump on the bandwagon, or take anything from anyone.  I simply acknowledge my heritage.

Maybe it is a good thing that people are proud of their heritage, no matter how minute, and will stand in support of our Indian friends, instead of wishing to kill them all.  Maybe it's unimportant that we're not a member of a tribe, but it is important that we stand in unison with our brothers and sisters, no matter how distantly related.  Maybe there are a lot of us out there who desire understanding that we are proud of our heritage, no matter how minute, no matter what other people think...  

Just a thought.  I'm not an Indian, nor do I claim to be-- but I love my great-great grandmother, who was a kind, loving woman, adored by her children.  I'm also not Irish, Scottish, or German, but I have a whole lot more Irish blood, (Strother), and Scottish blood, (Bruce), and German blood, (Scherer).  What I am is a mutt.  Born and reared in KY, and we can all say a giant, "So What?"  

In all honestly, I don't think the amount of Indian DNA is as important as the amount of concern and support we have in our hearts.  We may never understand, but we can empathize.  We may never be able to make a real difference, but each and every one of us that is pleased with our Indian heritage is just one more voice to add to yours.  

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     10 years ago

In my lifetime I've met people who claim to be Indian and are not. I've also met many people that do have Indian blood but are no more Indian than a rock. They do not understand their own culture/history and have no active link to their culture, nor do they want to research that link.

Growing up and for the better part of my life, Indian was something to be avoided. Today it is fashionable to be Indian. Except that those that claim to be Indian don't want to experience what it is to be Indian, the down side so to speak. And depending on where you live, the down side can be quite ugly.

Within the Indian community there are differences, there is the Rez Indian, the urban Indian, the part time Indian and the Indian, Indian.

Robbie Robertson wrote a song entitled, ''In the Blood''. It explains it quite well.

 

 

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1  replied to  Kavika   10 years ago

Within the Indian community there are differences, there is the Rez Indian, the urban Indian, the part time Indian and the Indian, Indian.

Potential marketing for "Action figures"?  Might supplement your retirement Kavika, or help 1st warrior's golf swing.....!

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika   replied to  FLYNAVY1   10 years ago

Good idea FLY. LOL

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   seeder  1stwarrior  replied to  FLYNAVY1   10 years ago

And, just what is wrong with my golf swing - other than it doesn't work.

Actually, not true.  I play military golf - left, right, left, right.  Get my money's worth on green and cart fees.laughing dude

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   FLYNAVY1  replied to  1stwarrior   10 years ago

I bet the you and the grounds keeper are on a first name basis.....

When I was playing, I would beg for golfing tips from the girl driving the beer cart!

Happy Friday to both of you!

Kind of an interesting story... My father grew up in a spit of a town called Carmen, Oklahoma (south of Cherokee) back during the dust bowl years.  He said that in their town of 250 or so, the local NAs were in school with him, and nobody in town gave them a second thought.  A black man and his family came through town one day, and all the doors and windows closed up tight.  Guess they were there to steal all the white women.....

Someday we just might be able to live without ignorance..... long time down the road though.

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   seeder  1stwarrior  replied to  FLYNAVY1   10 years ago

Yeah - I can remember back in the day when I used to beg the Beverage Cart lady if I could ride with her - THAT never happened.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi  replied to  1stwarrior   10 years ago

Yeah - I can remember back in the day when I used to beg the Beverage Cart lady if I could ride with her - THAT never happened.

1stwarrior...

Ironic to know you grew up in Tupelo and had such a hard time because you were Indian, when today the town and surrounding area is embracing and celebrating its Native American heritage, and are building a Chickasaw Heritage Center and Village that will be open to the public since the one that is off the Natchez Parkway is closed except to the Chickasaw in the area.

I'm looking forward to it, if it is completed while I am still mobile.

This is happening all around the South; "Indian" is looked upon with awe and respect by the "common" people. I can't speak for the idiots wearing suits in the South in the middle of summer.thinking

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   seeder  1stwarrior  replied to  screminmimi   10 years ago

Looking forward to it opening - will DEFINITELY be there Wink

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi  replied to  1stwarrior   10 years ago

I'm looking forward to buying you and the family a Coke.... coffee... well, a drink anyway!thumbs up

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser  replied to  screminmimi   10 years ago

I've been saying for years that KY's people have a pride in their Indian heritage...  I mean, it wasn't that way when Grandpa was growing up in the late 1890's/19-oughts, nor in my mother's time, (1930s), but by the time I came along, in the 1950s, everyone was proud of their heritage...  We have a state park dedicated to the Trail of Tears, which I think is a good thing, and you can trace the Trail of Tears through the state on a specially designated "route".  Not that anyone cares, but I'm glad we have it.

That side of the family came here and purchased their land in the late 1820s, near Hodgenville, (according to court records), not far from where Abe was born.  (Spell checker does not like my spelling of the city, nor any variation thereof, so I guess I'm native and don't know HOW to spell it...)  

It makes sense, too.  Even though most web sites say that we're all stupid, and don't know, and that the ONLY Indians that lived in the state were down around Pikeville, or in the Jackson Purchase Area, it makes sense.  The Pikeville area is not at all far, (maybe 25 miles), from the Cumberland Gap, and the Jackson Purchase area is attached to everything else by rivers.  Anyone with any sense can see how people traveled throughout the state, and "mingled", one with another...  We became a state in 1792, at #15, and that's a long time for people to spread out and intermarry...  My great Grandma painted Indians in her pictures in the 1870's and while it is certainly possible that she had never seen a real Indian, they look real enough...  When they built the VA hospital here in Louisville, in the late 1800s, they displaced a huge settlement of Indians.  I somehow can't believe that when the white men showed up, all the Indians in the state turned tail and ran...  Doubtful, to say the least.  

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi  replied to  Dowser   10 years ago

 I somehow can't believe that when the white men showed up, all the Indians in the state turned tail and ran...  Doubtful, to say the least. 

That's my Dowser!!.... ROFL...Big hugs

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser  replied to  screminmimi   10 years ago

Love you, dear Mimi!!!

Why couldn't they have lived together, as neighbors, in peace?  I think that many of them did.  There are many good people who would love their Indian neighbors.  And I bet they helped one another, like any rural community.  They mingled, they lived side by side, and they married each other.   In Kentucky, back in the 1790's to about the 1840s, it was, for the most part, a hard-scrabble existence.  Most of the people had a little bit of land, where they grew their crops, raised their livestock, and struggled to survive.  If I had had an Indian neighbor, I would have beaten a path to their door, Hi, I'm new here-- Can I eat this plant?  I see the deer eating it...  How do YOU get your crops to grow so well?  Say, ya'll want some of this corn?  I had a bumper crop...  Here is some tobacco-- thanks for coming over to help me with my crop.  You want 1/2 this deer?   We can't eat it all, it will spoil...  I mean, that's what neighbors DO.  As far as marrying each other-- Mrs. Brown, you have a lovely daughter, and all that...

I don't know...  It just seems to me, that for the most part, folks got along.  Else, how would any of us be alive today?  I can't imagine denying that part of me that is Indian, just because of some ignorant people.  Why would I even think that she is not a part of me?  She was a good woman, and a loving mother.  Her children adored her-- she had to be a good person, one of love.  We are all the sum of our parts.

Maybe it's different here than in the west-- we've had longer to get along together...  Maybe our history has united us in ways we don't understand, yet.  Maybe part of it was reconstruction, where, no matter who you were, or what you did, you were 'reconstructed' after the war, turning it into an "us" vs "them" kind of thing...  I don't know.  These are all just guesses...  

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi  replied to  Dowser   10 years ago

Again, Dowser...

Right on the nose!I bow to you

 
 
 
Spikegary
Junior Quiet
link   Spikegary    10 years ago

I remember my mom telling me one of my great or great-grandparents was married to an Indian Woman and had children that make up a portion of my bloodline.  I'll have to ask her more about that.  Regardless, I do not nor ever plan to claim any different bloodlines to the government and/or anyone else.

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    10 years ago

I see both sides of this. Years ago, I remember seeing signs in front of establishments out west that said "no dogs, no barefeet, and no indians." Wallace Black Elk (a Sioux shaman) once told me that, when he got back from fighting in World War II, he went into a store while wearing his uniform and bought a pack of cigarettes from a clerk who didn't know she wasn't supposed to sell to Indians. Before he could pay for the cigarettes, the owner rushed in, snatched the cigarettes out of his hand, and said that he would rather throw them in the trash than sell them to him. He was no longer bitter about but simply noted the wonders of the Great Spirit who have led the children of those who oppressed him to now sit at his feet looking for wisdom. Indians who looked Indian, and suffered discrimination, could not choose to avoid it by being something other than Indian. For many of them, the white "cocktail party" indians -- who choose to be Indian because it's fashionable -- would strip Indians of their very identity which is the only thing they have left. 

On the other hand, Indian culture and the notion of tribe was not historically racial. Many tribes accepted non-Indians and, in fact, white captives of Indian tribes (especially the eastern tribes) often returned to their captors once they were freed. 

My family has always said we had Indian blood. I discounted it until I met one of my great uncles for the first and last time before he died. For some reason, he left no photographs of himself so I have only my memory. Unlike his brothers and sisters, he looked very Indian so maybe there's something to the family oral history but, even if I have Indian blood, I wouldn't go around claiming I'm an Indian (my Indian friends are purely coincidental, although the shamen say it's destiny not coincidence).

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   96WS6    10 years ago

My Grandfather told me my family are related to Cherokee Chief "Dragging Canoe".  He and several others separated from the tribe after the knuckleheads signed treaty with paleface.  The group came back during a  "reunification council" in 1809.

For the record.   I am not "Indian enough" as far as the government is concerned.  

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   seeder  1stwarrior  replied to  96WS6   10 years ago

96 - that depends on what you are trying to do with a claim of being "Indian Enough" with the Feds.

The vast majority of Fed agencies accept anyone saying they are "Indian" for their ethnicity classification.  Obviously one that doesn't is the BIA.  I know many, many folks in DoD who claim to have Indian blood and no one questions their claim.

However - for the vast majority of Indian Programs that the BIA/BIE/IHS have, you do have to have a CDIB (Certified Degree of Indian Blood) of 1/4 or more, a tribal/nation card or statement from the Tribal/Nation leader that you meet the qualifications.  

I never really understood the logic behind that until I was taking "Indian Government" in law school and started reading some of the statistics on us.  The past couple hundred years, there has been so much intermarriage between the "Bloods" and non-Indians that the requirement for 1/4 came about mostly for the Indians on the rez, where most of the 1/4's and above live.  The feds believe, obviously erroneously, that by helping/qualifying just those 1/4 and above that they are "helping/assisting" tribal/nation members and that the members helped will stay on the rez as part of a "return on investment".

Does any of that make sense?

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi  replied to  1stwarrior   10 years ago

 The feds believe, obviously erroneously, that by helping/qualifying just those 1/4 and above that they are "helping/assisting" tribal/nation members and that the members helped will stay on the rez as part of a "return on investment".

Does any of that make sense?

As most of us know, anything the feds become involved with regarding Indians becomes FUBAR from the get-go.tough guy

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man  replied to  1stwarrior   10 years ago

1st asked:

"Does that make any sense?"

NO , it doesn't in any context except as a method to separate and divide.

It is one of the conundrums of the American experience, we are all equal.... Until we aren't

One heck of a melting pot we have, isn't it?

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi  replied to  Nowhere Man   10 years ago

we are all equal.... Until we aren't

It is only on a piece of paper that we are equal; even our laws that ostensibly demand we be treated equally do not uphold that piece of paper.

In reality humans are of the animal kingdom, and in the way of all animals, like beds down with like except for extreme exceptions. That is why civilization developed across the continent in pockets instead of congregating in one central spot and spreading out in the nature of a wave instead of a hop-scotch.

We find those whose customs and culture are akin to those we are comfortable with and settle down with them. If we try to impose our own will on an unaccepting culture or they try to force us to remain in their culture which we are not comfortable with, there is aggression and war.

Total equality is a nice dream, but a dream nonetheless, and it cannot be legislated except in the minds of dreamers.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man  replied to  screminmimi   10 years ago

Absolute Agreement Mimi. Absolute Agreement!

Although I will say this...

ANYTHING the Federal Government get involved in on the basis of race is FUBAR from the start.

From concentration camps, to affirmative action and everything in between that our government has done.

The ends do not justify the means.

So much for the application of enlightenment principles.

"It's sad that governments are chiefed by the double tongues. There is iron in your words of death for all Comanche to see, and so there is iron in your words of life. No signed paper can hold the iron. It must come from men. The words of Ten Bears carries the same iron of life and death. It is good that warriors such as we meet in the struggle of life..." --Ten Bears, The Outlaw Josey Wales

Probably one of the greatest movie lines ever written.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi  replied to  Nowhere Man   10 years ago

"It's sad that governments are chiefed by the double tongues. There is iron in your words of death for all Comanche to see, and so there is iron in your words of life. No signed paper can hold the iron. It must come from men. The words of Ten Bears carries the same iron of life and death. It is good that warriors such as we meet in the struggle of life..." --Ten Bears, The Outlaw Josey Wales

I agree... one of the greatest movie lines, and speeches, ever written.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy    10 years ago

There have always been rumors of Native Canadian Indian blood in our family, though I never looked into myself. One of my Great-Uncles traced his and my grandmother's (my father's mother) ancestors all of the way back to a Frenchman who came to Canada in 1662 to become a fur trapper. Though there's many stories of French Canadians (other then being the best hockey players and beer drinkers) inter-marrying with Native Canadians back then, I don't know if he found any in our family.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     10 years ago

Randy, many of the French that came to Canada and into the fur trade in the 1600's 1700's and early 1800's married Ojibwe or Cree women. Today they are called Michif or Metis. They are the largest indigenous group in Canada. The Canadian government have a special category for them.

In Canada there are three groups, First Nations (Indians) Inuit and Metis that are recognized by the Canadian government.

They number around 450,000. It would make them the largest indigenous group in north America. There are Metis in the US as well. Mostly in Minnesota and Michigan.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy  replied to  Kavika   10 years ago

Perhaps I should find out who has my Great-Uncle's research and check it out myself. Might be fun to know. I do know that he was single when he arrived.

I wonder if that's why so many English Canadians looked down on the French Canadians through the years? It's one of the reasons my grandparents on my father's side both left Canada to immigrate to Michigan.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika   replied to  Randy   10 years ago

The history of the Michif is very interesting and totally unique. Louis Riel, the father of Manitoba and Michif is a huge figure in Canadian history.

Check it out Randy.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    10 years ago

My Father and Mother always told us that we were a quarter Cherokee, but MY father always added that that and a penny will get you a piece of bubblegum.

I always took that as it doesn't matter where you came from, your here now in this world. you must be what you decide you are.

I am an American, Born to an American Mother, by an American Father.

I was born in this great nation of peoples that all call themselves Americans, in a nation called the United States of America. That makes me a Native American.

I have never claimed to be anything but an American, born native to this great nation of Americans.

I have no more right to anything than any other person has. If I do happen to have some residual Indian blood or genes from a far off ancestor very well. I have no need to claim any heritage except that I'm American.

Native born.

That the gods honest truth of the matter, no matter who you consider the great maker to be.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi    10 years ago

One thing this article doesn't address is the time in our history not all that long ago when it was dangerous to be "too much Indian."

As was the case with my own family and others, there were those who were hidden from the soldiers by whites, dressed up in European clothes, hair cut and styled or wigs placed on their heads, brows plucked, makeup packed on, and the lie told that they were were "Black Dutch" or "Black Irish" relatives, who could not answer the questions asked of them because they had just arrived and could not yet speak English.

Into the '50s there were still people who were afraid and ashamed to admit they were Indian or possessed Indian ancestors and it has only been the past several decades that people have admitted they "have Indian blood."

The Indian Nations are shooting themselves in the foot by trying to disassociate themselves from American citizens who want to align themselves with the tribes.... there would not be a stronger political or social advocacy in the nation than that of the American Indian if the jackass "Bluebloods" would take advantage of the "non-pedigree" faction to help them obtain their goal of being a force to be reckoned with in Washington and in local and state politics.

They don't have to admit them to the rolls or reservations or the Tribal Councils.... just give them a friendly acknowledgment. Tribal Indians are hamstrung in what they can accomplish with the federal government, by law. "White Indians" are not... they can rant and rave and march and protest without losing their homes and freedoms.

Pride is fine but it won't save the Ancestors nor the culture nor the land, all of which is at the mercy of whomever sits in Congress, the White House, and the Supreme Court.

And as far as the Indians "getting it on" with everyone in the country for there to be so many whites "with Indian blood"..... get real! With so many Indians pretending to be white to escape forced marches and marrying into white communities, hell yes, they were getting it on.

Kavika posted a picture of his brothers in their prime on Anishinaabe some time ago and the females haven't stopped swooning!

The writer of this article sounds a "purist." In fact, somewhat like a snob. Indian enough? Even the "purebred" Indians of the old day accepted white children as full tribe members occasionally, or white women as the wives of Indian men, making them full tribe members.

I don't know how people claiming to have "Indian blood" managed to take employment and educational slots from "real Indians" fraudulently because in my neck of the woods you can't get by with just a claim... you have to give a tribal registration number to receive any breaks or benefits.

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    10 years ago

The Indian Nations are shooting themselves in the foot by trying to disassociate themselves from American citizens who want to align themselves with the tribes.... there would not be a stronger political or social advocacy in the nation than that of the American Indian if the jackass "Bluebloods" would take advantage of the "non-pedigree" faction to help them obtain their goal of being a force to be reckoned with in Washington and in local and state politics.

In my opinion, they're bluebloods among the bluebloods. I had a Sioux medicine man (not Black Elk) stay with me and he insisted on going to the National American Indian Conference even though he is totally apolitical. When I said I wasn't driving him there because I had to work, he said he would catch public transportation and go by himself. Rather than him get lost and waste my time going to find him, I relented and took him to the conference. Once there, he sat in a chair for hours and refused to talk to anyone or attend anything. I asked why come if you're just going to sit there? He just looked and wouldn't answer. I walked off mad and went to see if there was anything I wanted to buy from the vendors.

When I got back, I was intercepted by an Indian delegation who begged me to talk him into giving a speech at the event. Apparently, some "white" Indians were trying to get access to the sacred pipestone quarry (held in trust by one tribe for use by all the others). When the delegation discovered that he was one of the last of the Sioux medicine men, they wanted him to speak against white Indians getting access to the quarry. He refused and they wanted me to change his mind because they thought he would listen to me. I laughed and said he only listens to me if he has no choice but they begged me to try anyway. To my amazement he said would speak but he would only speak on the significance of pipestone and would take no position on "white" Indians. It didn't make any difference to me what he said in his speech because it's an Indian issue and I'm not Indian.

He gave a great speech but no questions afterward made him do what he said he would not do. Afterward, a group of Chippewa came up to congratulate him on his speech and he basically blew them off. I asked why he was so rude to them and he asked if they were real Indians. I said yes, as real as you are, and he just grunted.

Eventually, I discovered why he wanted to go to the conference. He was hoping that another Lakota would show up and he could talk in his language without having to translate it in his head. You drug me all the way over here for that I shouted; he only shrugged in response . . . I just imagined him laying in the parking lot and me running over him again and again.

Later on, a representative from the Smithsonian called me and said that they wanted to repatriate Indian bones that had been in their collection for years. Because he was a Sioux medicine man, she asked me to ask him if he would perform a ceremony (he declined to speak to her directly himself). He asked whether they were Sioux bones. I responded how the hell would they know whose bones they were and what difference does it make anyway. He said if they weren't Sioux bones, then they were just bones and they could do with them as they choose. I tried arguing with him but he doesn't argue; instead, he simply stops talking once he has said what he has to say.

He's not the only Sioux with an attitude toward other Indians. I've heard them snicker when somebody claims to be Cherokee and, just piecing together snide comments, they seem to take it as the person is really telling them he's black but is too stupid to know it.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man  replied to  1ofmany   10 years ago

Yep, there are Nisqually and Chehalis and Puyallup tribal members with the same attitudes here in Washington. I suspect there are many more elsewhere also.

They generally don't get heard or don't want to get involved in the politics of it. But they are very proud of their heritage just the same. (and rightfully so)

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     10 years ago

It's quite understandable that he wouldn't perform a ceremony over bones that he didn't know were Lakota. Different cultures/language/history/customs between the tribes. Not unexpected at all.

Also goes for wanting to speak his own language. Language is the cornerstone of each tribe. Once the language is lost the fabric of the tribe is gone.

In speaking of the Ojibwe, we did adopt non Ojibwe into the tribe, and they were full members. Both Indian and non Indian. Much of this came to an end when the Dawes Rolls and blood quantum became the way to ID whether an person was Indian or not. Another government screw-up.

In the case of the Ojibwe, White Thunderbird who was taken captive in a war with the Dakota as a child became a Ojibwe tribal member (Red Lake) and one of the great leaders of the Anishinaabe.

As far as attitudes among natives regarding other natives it shouldn't be surprising, since the government set up standards as to who is Indian and who isn't. Indians that grew up on the Rez, or those that still live there, look at urban Indians differently. Blood line and knowledge of their own culture seems to be the issue.

The situation about Cherokee is one that in my experience has nothing to do with black. It has all to do with a white person claiming Cherokee ancestry when none exists. This is probably due to the Cherokee being the name that most non Indians are familiar and the ''Trial of Tears''...Some of this may be true since Cherokee women that were forced on the Trail of Tears sometime gave their babies away to anyone so that they would survive. The Cherokee are the most well known of the tribes that were forced to relocate, but far from the only tribe, nor were they the first. The Five Civilized Tribes were all forced onto the ''Trail of Tears''...

There is, of course, the situation within the Cherokee tribe of black Cherokee, but that is another issue.

I don't understand your statement that your friend was one of last of the Medicine Men of the Lakota. There are Medicine Men throughout the various Siouan people.

With the Ojibwe, the term medicine man/women or shaman is not used. Those are names from the Europeans. Within the Ojibwe nation they are Mide of the Midewiwin, also called the ''Grand Medicine Society.''

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   seeder  1stwarrior  replied to  Kavika   10 years ago

If I may add to that Kavika - there are approximately 58 tribes/nations who use the criteria of having an ancestor of the "Rolls" for someone to become/apply for tribal/nation membership.  There are other tribes/nations who frown on those tribal/nation members as, to become a tribal/nation member for them, you have to have blood quantum.

Years ago I was a member of the Native Law thread and we would get into some really heated arguments - which were never "settled".  Some interesting information came from a member of the Kiowa.  The tribe/nation had a referendum up for vote to reduce the blood quantum requirement from 3/4 to 5/8's due to the intermarriages - and I don't mean with non-Indians.  They were ready to fist-fight over persons who were split between two or three or four tribes and the "old-timers" wanted ONLY 5/8 Kiowa blood, regardless of whether the person was 100% FBI - it HAD to be Kiowa.

The diversity of many tribes/nations is between tribes/nation blood - not non-Indian, and many folks ask the question as "Why - regardless of the tribal/nation affiliation, you are still Indian."  Well, like the elder 1ofmany knows - you ain't Lakota - you ain't Indian. 

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika   replied to  1stwarrior   10 years ago

Yes, there are many tribes that have enrollment limits to those of the blood of that tribe.

With the Red Lake Ojibwe, you MUST have a PARENT enrolled on the Red Lake Tribal rolls and you must be 1/4 Ojibwe. Nothing else counts. In another words if your blood line doesn't go back centuries on Red Lake, you ain't getting in.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi  replied to  Kavika   10 years ago

My personal opinion is that no one, not even the federal government, has the right to tell the Tribes who they can admit as a member. Heck, our own government won't allow us to have a say in who we allow to become citizens of our own country so they need to keep their damn noses out of Indian Country and Indian affairs.... well, I can dream.

I am just saying that there are hundreds of thousands of people who want to stand with Indians in their fight to hold onto their resources and their culture and some of them self-identify as part-Indian themselves  based on family stories and oral history; some of us even have letters and pictures that cannot be used to base registration but clearly support the connection.

This "half-breed" (an ugly stigma given to part-Indians from long ago when Indians were not considered human) group of people seek nothing from those registered by the Tribes except a cessation of the disdain and dismissive contempt with which "real" Indians have looked at them. Talk about being told to go to the back of the bus..... "real" Indians don't even want them ON the bus.

They are separate from the Nations, but are of the People. They can be a voice and a powerful political block, and though their blood quantum does not satisfy the Tribes nor the government they feel its call. What was once something to be ashamed of and hidden, or afraid to be revealed, its time has come.

The "real" Indians can continue to isolate themselves and battle the US government and its ever-increasing greed and gluttony, along with that of the encroaching international threats, singly as they have been and continue to temporarily.... maybe.... win one in a thousand cases, or....

they can form a solid political block utilizing everyone... Indian and non-Indian.... who supports them. No one is asking them to give up anything except a little prejudice.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika   replied to  screminmimi   10 years ago

Mimi, it was the government that are responsible for the current ''enrollment'' of tribal members. The tribes adopted the blood quantum and rolls because of the government rules that were in place.

Many tribes have cut the blood quantum required to allow more members on to the rolls. Currently the White Earth Ojibwe are considering cutting the blood quantum and changing other rules to allow new members.

Is it right, I don't know but I can understand the feeling behind the difficult enrollment status maintained by tribes.

Some feel that they have lost everything, culture, language and history. They do not want to loose their identity. Others feel that they will lose what little they get from their businesses, such as casinos. Sadly this have happened to a few of the tribes that were overwhelmed with application as soon as it was found that they had been approved as casino's owners.

The first part of the article about ''disenrollment'' of tribal members is another area that I am dead set against. There, is very very very few things that should result in disenrollment of a tribal member.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man  replied to  Kavika   10 years ago

AS long as pure bloodline is the only basis issue of whether your an Indian or not or there are sufficient of you to sustain a tribe. the Native Americans known as Indians are facing the one thing Chief Joseph feared.

Extinction.

Tribal de-cert is an issue I hate with a passion, in many ways it is saying that a vital (and huge) part of American History and heritage is being written off. It's like the claims of extermination intent by some is coming to reality.

Maybe it is time to accept Americans into the fold, even though they do not claim any bloodline. Because eventually, there will be no pure bloodline left. WE are all brothers/sisters of the spirit.

If we do not unite in the spirit to keep our American heritage alive, then we all will pass into history worse off for our blindness.

“Whenever the white man treats the Indian as they treat each other, then we shall have no more wars. We shall all be alike, brothers of one father and one mother with one sky above us and one country around us and one government for all. Then the Great Spirit Chief who rules above will smile upon this land and send rain to wash out the bloody spots made by brothers' hands upon the face of the Earth.” -- Chief Joseph, Wallowa Nes Perce

It is my fervent wish that someday, this will be the truth.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika   replied to  Nowhere Man   10 years ago

1940, 334,000 American Indians...2010 5.4 million.

We are not disappearing.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy  replied to  Kavika   10 years ago

Is it reproduction within the Native American community or is that more people who claim to be Indian are being accept into tribes?

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika   replied to  Randy   10 years ago

Birthrate Randy. American Indians are the second fastest growing minority in the U.S.

I would imagine that in 1940, there were many Indians that would not claim Indian heritage.

 

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy  replied to  Kavika   10 years ago

That means they are also becoming a small, but very significant voting block and it looks like their political power is doing nothing but growing.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika   replied to  Randy   10 years ago

That is true Randy. If you look at some of the states with large Indian population you'll see how they have changed elections. Most recently in Oklahoma, Michigan and Minnesota, all primaries won by Bernie Sanders.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy  replied to  Kavika   10 years ago

I would have preferred Hillary, but congratulations on the exercising your power. It's been a very long time coming. And very welcome!

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi  replied to  Randy   10 years ago

 congratulations on the exercising your power. It's been a very long time coming. And very welcome

Randy, I agree, but...... had to take out that "prefer Hillary" part....winking

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy  replied to  screminmimi   10 years ago

Well we can't agree every time! It was getting to be a habit! People might have started to talk!blushing

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi  replied to  Randy   10 years ago

Well we can't agree every time! It was getting to be a habit! People might have started to talk!

ROFLMAO....laughing dude

throw me a kiss, you fool!!!! chuckle

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi  replied to  Kavika   10 years ago

I would imagine that in 1940, there were many Indians that would not claim Indian heritage.

Sadly, that is true, as I stated earlier. It also explains the "There is Indian blood in my family" refrain heard around the country from so many people. It was a secret told only on death beds or by elders whose pain at having to swallow the pride of who they were and not pass it on to their grandchildren could no longer be borne, so they whispered it in the ears of very young children who only half remembered the stories.

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   seeder  1stwarrior  replied to  screminmimi   10 years ago

As a kid growing up in Miss., Grandma and mom would tell us over and over - "You're Chickasaw - be very proud of it - but don't tell a soul."  That's the way it was.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi  replied to  1stwarrior   10 years ago

As a kid growing up in Miss., Grandma and mom would tell us over and over - "You're Chickasaw - be very proud of it - but don't tell a soul."  That's the way it was.

And how sad is that?

Blessings on your parents for allowing you to know, and be, Indian. Others kept it hidden from their children all their lives.

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   seeder  1stwarrior  replied to  Randy   10 years ago

They are accepted into the tribes/nations only if there is a direct decendency/blood line.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man  replied to  Kavika   10 years ago

I didn't say Indians were disappearing, I didn't say anything was disappearing. but I guess I could have been saying that pure bloodlines are disappearing.

If one wishes to interpret it that way.

The point being that free open enrollment is not just a cultural thing anymore as time marches on, it will become a needed and necessary thing. Part of the culture so to speak.

But then I'm just an American who knows what it is like being called an Indian lover and what it means coming from someone that has nothing but hate in their heart.

(Same as being called a nigger lover in other parts of the nation, to which I have also been called)

Doesn't Matter to me, everyone who feels the need to disparage anyone else in a false need to elevate themselves to some sort of superior plateau over others that they only know is a sick, sad individual in my mind.

It is still my fervent wish that the bloody spots of history get washed out over time.

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser  replied to  Nowhere Man   10 years ago

I can only hope to be called "an Indian lover".  Because I am!

Happy

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   seeder  1stwarrior  replied to  Nowhere Man   10 years ago

"Maybe it is time to accept Americans into the fold, even though they do not claim any bloodline. Because eventually, there will be no pure bloodline left. WE are all brothers/sisters of the spirit."

And, hence, one of the major issues with the tribes/nations.  Folks have no concept of the culture, traditions, heritage, history, religions of the tribes/nations and actually believe they are "all brothers/sisters of the spirit" which is adamantly not true.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi  replied to  1stwarrior   10 years ago

And, hence, one of the major issues with the tribes/nations.  Folks have no concept of the culture, traditions, heritage, history, religions of the tribes/nations and actually believe they are "all brothers/sisters of the spirit" which is adamantly not true

Which, of course, is the problem with the new world order and the massive invasion of Muslims in Europe, as well as the huge influx of immigrants here in the US.

Governments are not insisting that the incoming learn and adapt the language, let alone the basic societal rules and courtesies that make civilization work; they are bullying and attempting to force the established societies to adjust, accept and pardon the unacceptable behavior of both the invited and the invader.

Even when their children are forcibly raped and prostituted, and the parents threatened with their own murder and the murder of their children, the citizens are told such behavior is the "custom" in the home land of the perpetrator and either no sentence or a ridiculous light sentence has to be borne by the victims and their families.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man  replied to  1stwarrior   10 years ago

"And, hence, one of the major issues with the tribes/nations.  Folks have no concept of the culture, traditions, heritage, history, religions of the tribes/nations and actually believe they are "all brothers/sisters of the spirit" which is adamantly not true."

And I agree that this is one of the major issues facing the tribes today.

Many Indians today are desperately trying to hang on to centuries old cultures and belief systems being lost to the ravages of time and the history re-writers. Which is right and good. No one should ever forget where they came from.

But alas, there is maybe even a little apathy on the part of the young that is making such harder.

History also show us this division in the tribal record, as the quote from Chief Joseph demonstrates so aptly. Sometimes it is hard to separate the wisdom of the elders from the nationalism of anger. That goes for any tribe of man, not just the Indians.

The Indians have to decide if they are separate from society of a part of society in that their cultures are distinct from all others and that shouldn't be lost. But, that being said, one cannot say that such is better than anyone else's culture, and then reject those that want a part of that perfect culture. ESPECIALLY when that culture is founded on the belief that all men are entitled to and gifted to their section of mother earth. And mother loves her children.

There are no perfect people, even amongst the Indians. But being Indian is not something that can be bestowed upon someone that I understand given today's beliefs, But, the historical record says different as has been mentioned right in this article.

I also stand for the belief that all tribes of man have the right to decide who belongs. And the Indians are no different in that respect from any other tribe of man.

So the proposition that all men/women are brothers and sisters in the spirit, is absolutely true, the historical record says as much. But you cannot demand such, for being a member of a family is only something you can be born into, or be awarded by the family.

NO one can claim to be Indian without an Indian accepting such claim is the point. Me, although it was intimated like many others that there is some part back in the family history that relates me to a tribe, has only sought knowledge, not recognition, brotherhood, not kinship.

Why, cause if we believe what Chief Joseph spoke so long ago, one doesn't need recognition nor kinship, cause we all eventually find out that we already have those, if but for our ability to accept it..

 

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi  replied to  Nowhere Man   10 years ago

But, that being said, one cannot say that such is better than anyone else's culture, and then reject those that want a part of that perfect culture. ESPECIALLY when that culture is founded on the belief that all men are entitled to and gifted to their section of mother earth.

Indians have never said their culture is better than anyone else's... they have just said it is THEIRS.

And what 1stwarrior is saying is that there are those who want to CLAIM that culture without LEARNING about it or trying to EXPERIENCE or UNDERSTAND any part of it... such as the man who went around operating sweat lodges he said were based on the Indian culture, until he killed someone in a lodge because he didn't understand the principles of a sweat lodge or the spiritual essence behind it, or that it wasn't merely an "Indian sauna."

And your last sentence of this comment I have copied here is a complete misunderstanding and fallacy... Indians do not and have never, believed that "all men are entitled to and gifted to their section of mother earth." That implies an ownership of a "section of mother earth."

Indians do not believe in owning m other earth; they believe they are stewards of Mother Earth.

There is a lot to learn of Indians. Think of Harry Potter and his friends in their first year at Hogwarts, if you must have a reference. They had to learn calculations, the names of potions, how to mix them... many potions and spells were not even permitted for them to KNOW, until they were third year students, and they could not even practice minimal magic outside the confines of the school, not even at home with their magical parents, and all but simple spells had to have a Spellmaster proficient in that particular Art on hand for them to cast it. Each area of Magic required specific classes.

How many people do you know would have the patience to sit hours at the feet of different Elders in a Tribe to listen to history of ancestors, to learn the proper way to wear certain articles of clothing, how to prepare a body for the Spirit World, how to prepare for a personal Spirit Walk, to find your personal Spirit Guide, which animals are sacred to your Tribe, the ritual for thanking the spirit of an animal you might kill for food, how to behave during the wake of those who have walked on, who in your tribe... and which gender... is allowed to handle the Sacred Pipes...

each Tribe has specific rituals, they are not all the same. Not all the rituals are done today but it does not mean the Indians have forgotten them or their meaning or have stopped teaching them.

(NOTE: The Harry Potter reference is not meant to trivialize Indian culture, but was used as a modern day reference.)

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man  replied to  screminmimi   10 years ago

Please re-read what i said, there is no statement that Indians "Claim" their culture is any better or worse than any others. What I am saying is that their culture is perfect for them and anyone they chose to accept into their culture. Much like Christ is perfect for the christian culture, Mohammad is perfect for muslim culture, Moses for such and such and so on and so forth.

Can a christian become an accepted muslim? Can a jew become an accepted christian?

Can a euro white become an accepted Indian? History says yes they can, but they need to learn the rituals and precepts of the culture before they can be accepted.

So my position agrees with yours

No one can understand a culture, it's good point and bad points, without learning/experiencing it's precepts and beliefs. My personal belief is that one culture is no better than any other.

They all have their spiritual elevations and evil depravities. In this all cultures are alike.

Ergo sum, by extension, we eventually arrive at the ideal that all men are equal in the eyes of whatever gods or spirits they believe in. This explains how one individual can transcend his early life teachings and gain an expansive belief in cultures other than that in which he was raised up in.

Hopefully for the better understanding that no mans culture is any better or worse than any others, just different.

I'm a big believer in that all men want the same things in their lives, they just have different ideals on how to get what they want, need or is important to them.

Indians are no different.

Anyone that claims a heritage they have not earned is a heretic and a fool. Much to the bane of those honest hard working people that are true to who they are.

WE all have a right to live and believe in what ever manner we choose for ourselves, including Indians believe it or not.

the great architect of the universe made us this way, who am I to say he was wrong?

Eventually we all come to the understanding that it is not the culture we were raised up in that makes the man, but the man who makes the culture work for him.

That is the basis of enlightenment thinking. And, Indians understood this long before Europeans rationalized it out for themselves.

We are all one people. someday we will have learned to respect this little bit of knowledge and treat each other accordingly.

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   seeder  1stwarrior  replied to  Nowhere Man   10 years ago

NWM - you keep on referring to everybody having a piece of the rock - ESPECIALLY when that culture is founded on the belief that all men are entitled to and gifted to their section of mother earth. And mother loves her children.

NOWHERE in any of the Native American cultures do they believe they are entitled and gifted to their section of mother earth.  If you believe that is what Chief Joseph is saying, you really need to re-read his complete speech.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy  replied to  1stwarrior   10 years ago

To inject a note of levity, I remember in the movie "Crocodile Dundee" when he was trying to explain the idea that the Aborigines didn't believe in land ownership. He said the best why to understand it is the Aborigines thought of arguing over who owns land is the same as two fleas arguing about who owns the dog they are on.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi  replied to  Randy   10 years ago

Randy,

I had forgot that gem of wisdom from Dundee; you reminding us of it made me spit Coke all over my screen... I have GOT to remember to not drink anything before reading the comment section, especially when I see your avatar or Petey's.anger

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy  replied to  screminmimi   10 years ago

Still makes me chuckle when I think of it. And it makes sense too!Happy

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany  replied to  Randy   10 years ago

To inject a note of levity, I remember in the movie "Crocodile Dundee" when he was trying to explain the idea that the Aborigines didn't believe in land ownership. He said the best why to understand it is the Aborigines thought of arguing over who owns land is the same as two fleas arguing about who owns the dog they are on.

The concept of land as a commodity is a relatively recent development, even in Europe. Indians definitely had a concept of exclusive use of land, which they defended on a tribal basis against other tribes, but private ownership of land was meaningless to them because of how they lived. Nomadic plains tribes followed the buffalo herds and had no permanent dwellings. To them, private ownership of land would be like trying to buy part of the ocean. For the more sedentary tribes, having vast amounts of available vacant land makes it basically worthless as a commodity. Neither European or Indian views of land are superior to the other (which is what I understood nowhere man to be saying); it's just that concepts regarding land develop as people adjust to the world in which they live at a particular point in time. 

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man  replied to  1ofmany   10 years ago

Yes One, that is EXACTLY what I was saying.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man  replied to  1stwarrior   10 years ago

1st, entitled to live upon is NOT ownership. At least the way I am using it. EVERYONE is entitled to their space on this rock we call earth. Also land is not a commodity and never has been under any form of law.

The European model is as a bundle of rights to CONTROL, not ownership. The European model takes that right of control all the way out to the right to exclude.

Now if the Indians didn't ever have any idea of a right to control, then how can they exert a claim to burial grounds? Hunting grounds? ANY Grounds?

The Indians understood the right to control, they did not understand the right to exclude as part of a package of rights to posses and control.

ALL land in this nation is owned by the government, the government grants rights to parties to use said land (this is how they get away with those mining transfers) ALL land in this nation is parceled out by government land grant from there, subdivided even further into tracts, then individual parcels. The only land not covered by US government land grants is much of the New England states and portions of middle and southern states which are parceled out by order of the King of England by royal grant.

No body has ownership of any land in this nation, they have the right to possess. (and through that, the right to exclude, something the Indians of the day couldn't conceive of because of their belief that nobody owns the land we all share it)

Three years a real estate broker in the State of Washington, which in the State of Washington means you have to go to school to learn about the rules and laws of land possession as the practice of real estate in the State is considered the limited practice of law.

The real bitch here is the US government grants reservations to the Indians of certain parcels of land.

WHAT?

What the Indians didn't realize until too late, was once the government laid claim to the land as it's dominion, EVERYONE upon it falls under that dominion. Same as the English lands fall under the dominion of the King. They didn't understand the right to exclude, so therefore they had no conception of what a reservation really meant.

(a prison for all eternity)

Basically, they were screwed out of their rights the moment the Government laid claim to all the land across the entire continent not claimed by anyone else. The Indians had no Ideals of ownership as a bundle of rights including the rights to exclude. So in my opinion they were shafted by lack of understanding being taken advantage of.

But that is where Government domain over the Indian reservations comes from, and all the regulations designed to separate them from everyone else.

Same as the attempts to segregate the German, Italian and Japanese aliens at the start of WWII.

ALL governments claim absolute dominion over the land they claim as their own nation and the people that reside within those walls.

That is what makes this form of government, (known as the great experiment) unique on the face of the earth. Supposedly such government power is specifically limited.

Unfortunately, it doesn't work out like that in real life.

I never said that anyone can own land, but Indians definitely had a sense of control of the land they lived on.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi  replied to  Kavika   10 years ago

Kavika,

I used to watch the TV series "The Glades" before it was cancelled. One of the episodes dealt with the Seminoles disenrollment of many of the Black members who were on their rolls. It was really sad for those elderly who had been enrolled all their lives and whose grandparents had been an active part of the Seminole tribe.

The Seminole, if I remember correctly, were trying to stop automatic enrollment of offspring who had barely a trace of Indian blood, had never been anywhere near the culture or even Florida, yet were receiving proceeds from the Nation.

I don't understand the enrollment process or how someone who has been on the rolls from great-grandparents to the age of 90 could suddenly be disenrolled, but I can understand increased revenue. The episode mentioned the wealth of the Seminole tribe and how so many new people applied daily to be accepted as members yet not a trace of Seminole blood could be found when they were tested.

In Mississippi, there are many, many Black people who obviously have Indian blood and it is a close kinship evident in the skin, bone structure, hair and lips. If you ask them they will tell you it is Choctaw. Yet they are not registered with the Choctaw Nation regardless of the amount of "blood" if their ancestry cannot be found on the rolls.

A side note as to why so many, especially in the South, claim Cherokee blood....

Joseph B. Cobb, who moved to Mississippi from Georgia, described the Choctaw as having "no nobility or virtue at all, and in some respect he found blacks, especially native Africans, more interesting and admirable, the red man's superior in every way. The Choctaw and Chickasaw , the tribes he knew best, were beneath contempt, that is, even worse than black slaves." [3]

Therefore, as time rolled on, no one who had any Indian blood at all would admit to anything other than Cherokee, which was considered a "noble" Tribe. You may be interested to know that Joey Cobb, descendent of this piece of trash, is a judge where I live and is responsible for destroying the lives of many juveniles in this area because of his prejudices and self-importance and buffet-style rendering of the law. He is a man who should be turned over to Randy and me for torture and justice.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika   replied to  screminmimi   10 years ago

Interesting history Mimi, thanks for that.

Sounds like Joey need to have a bit of lesson.

You and Randy are the perfect duo to administer that lesson.Laugh

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy  replied to  Kavika   10 years ago

LOL! See! We've been caught!Laugh

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi  replied to  Randy   10 years ago

LOL! See! We've been caught!

Damn! Is your wife the violent type????stunned

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi  replied to  Kavika   10 years ago

You and Randy are the perfect duo to administer that lesson

We HAVE come up with some interesting ideas... perhaps we should publish a book.

(Do you think the MIB would come for us if we did??thinking )

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika   replied to  screminmimi   10 years ago

Speaking of books mimi read ''Warrior Nation'' by Anton Treuer.

History of the Red Lake Ojibwe.

There is a new short story in Anishinaabe that you might be interested in. ''Downwind from Evil''.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi  replied to  Kavika   10 years ago

Speaking of books mimi read ''Warrior Nation'' by Anton Treuer.

History of the Red Lake Ojibwe.

There is a new short story in Anishinaabe that you might be interested in. ''Downwind from Evil''.

I got so caught up in this particular thread I have spent all my available computer time on it and have neglected Anishinaabe the last several days, I am ashamed to say.

Heading there first thing tomorrow!!! Thanks for the head up on the new story!!!

I do regret that 1stwarrior's thread on the voting rights of Indians didn't get more response. It deserves attention from national media and is a sad commentary on how legislators have failed Indians on the most important of a citizen's right.

It's as if there is a movement to stop Indians from electing proper representation by keeping their votes from the ballot boxes.

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   seeder  1stwarrior  replied to  screminmimi   10 years ago

Ya gotta remember Mimi that there are nine states who "refuse" to help tribal/nation members being able to vote - regardless of the laws.

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser  replied to  1stwarrior   10 years ago

It's really hard to "like" a comment that makes me so mad, but thank you for the information...  

This is NOT RIGHT.  For Pete's sake!

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi  replied to  1stwarrior   10 years ago

Ya gotta remember Mimi that there are nine states who "refuse" to help tribal/nation members being able to vote - regardless of the laws.

Yes, and JUST WHERE is the investigation by the United States Justice Department?

JUST WHERE is the coverage by the national media?

Isn't there a federal investigation in the South because voting places have been closed down in several poor counties and it has been deemed a racist plot to deprive Blacks from voting?

We need a freaking poster and bumper stickers and t-shirts printed with Indians on the foreground and depictions of reservations such as Pine Ridge and other deprived places, merely in a ghostly shadow with well known backgrounds of all the states seen clearly through the Indians, message beneath saying "Indians: The Invisible People." Too many think all Indians are wealthy in the manner of the Cherokee and the Seminole and the Iroquois because they are promoted to keep the common citizen angry and resentful about all the "free stuff" their taxes "give" the Indians.

We on NT are the only ones who use that slogan and it needs to be a nation-wide refrain.

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   seeder  1stwarrior  replied to  Kavika   10 years ago

Add to that "Indian Affairs" by Larry Woiwode, a Mohawk.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi  replied to  1stwarrior   10 years ago

Add to that "Indian Affairs" by Larry Woiwode, a Mohawk.

So many of these books have come out... there should be a movement by the Native American community to demand they be required study in History classes in the areas covered by the books, and wherever the Indian Tribes mentioned in the books are now located.

If we can study European history, Black history, Muslim history, Hispanic history, all as required studies by our schools, TRUTHFUL Native American history should be demanded by the Indian community and taught as well.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy  replied to  screminmimi   10 years ago

My wife is a yeller, but not a hitter, so no problem. And if the MIB come for us at least we'll get to meet Will Smith and Tommy Lee Jones!

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi  replied to  Randy   10 years ago

And if the MIB come for us at least we'll get to meet Will Smith and Tommy Lee Jones!

Will Smith has always been a secret love, but after seeing Jada play "Fish Mooney" in the "Gotham" series, I would be terrified to go for it....Sad

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy  replied to  screminmimi   10 years ago

I'm a big Tommy Lee Jones fan. I go out of my way to see movies just because he is in them.

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi  replied to  Randy   10 years ago

Randy,

I like Jones as well. Read that he is an actor with one of the highest IQs in Hollywood, dropped out of Med school to act though he was doing well.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient  replied to  screminmimi   10 years ago

I, too, have enjoyed watching Tommy Lee Jones act.  At this moment I can think of the movies "The Client" and "Double Jeopardy" (the more recent remake, of course, with Ashley Judd).

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   seeder  1stwarrior  replied to  Randy   10 years ago

Try watching "The Missing" with Tommy - wow - what a performance.  Eric Schweig is an Inuit actor best known for his role as Chingachgook's son Uncas in The Last of the Mohicans and he plays the "evil" Indian abductor.

I worked with Eric in "Broken Chains" and he's a marvelous man.  But until I saw the credits at the end of the film, I had no idea who that bad guy was - absolutely awesome actor.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.  replied to  screminmimi   10 years ago

 but after seeing Jada play "Fish Mooney" in the "Gotham" series, I would be terrified to go for it.... Sad

LMAO, I had the same thought. 

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi  replied to  Perrie Halpern R.A.   10 years ago

LOL..

Perrie,

from your reply I see we have another viewing taste in common...

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   seeder  1stwarrior  replied to  Kavika   10 years ago

If it hadn't been for the Dawes Rolls and the Indian Reorganization Act, "being Indian" wouldn't have been an issue.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika   replied to  1stwarrior   10 years ago

110% agreement on that one 1st.

The Dawes rolls and the IRA where a disaster for Indians.

 
 
 
1stwarrior
Professor Participates
link   seeder  1stwarrior  replied to  Kavika   10 years ago

Kavika - as we both know very well - follow the money - hence the disenrollments and dirty ass politics.

Yeah, they learned the Euro way - really well.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika   replied to  1stwarrior   10 years ago

Yup, always follow the money, 1st.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man  replied to  Kavika   10 years ago

Politics and money......

Whenever someone is fucking over someone else, you always find politics and money. (or better put, the monied interests)

 
 
 
screminmimi
Freshman Silent
link   screminmimi  replied to  1stwarrior   10 years ago

Disenrollments....

I'd like to "disenroll" a lot of the Europeans and their descendents. There are many others, though, who are definitely worth keeping...Big hugs

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany    10 years ago

Also goes for wanting to speak his own language.

If he had told me that all he wanted to do was speak his own language, then I would have gone to work. He was going back home to the res in a week or so and he only says 25 words no matter what language he's speaking. lol

The situation about Cherokee is one that in my experience has nothing to do with black. It has all to do with a white person claiming Cherokee ancestry when none exists.

And that may have been at the heart of the snicker, a point perhaps made even funnier to them by speculating that he's probably black (I know they said something like that).

I don't understand your statement that your friend was one of last of the Medicine Men of the Lakota.

Sorry, I was writing quickly and didn't phrase it properly. He never said that he was one of the last of the medicine men. The leader of the delegation was Sioux and from the same area, although not living on the res. He said my friend was one of the last of the great medicine men (perhaps on that res or in the area) and the others seemed to agree. Honestly, I was just standing there waiting to hear why they're running me down and what his being a medicine man (great or otherwise) has to do with me.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika   replied to  1ofmany   10 years ago

1ofmany, thank for clarifying the Medicine Man comment.

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany  replied to  Kavika   10 years ago

Kavika--

just curious. Have you done sweat lodges and, if so, what was your opinion of them? 

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika   replied to  1ofmany   10 years ago

Yes I have. They are cleansing and renewing. A much needed ceremony to remain on the Red Road.

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany  replied to  Kavika   10 years ago

Yes I have. They are cleansing and renewing. A much needed ceremony to remain on the Red Road.

They can be a challenge. I've done them with the Tuscarora and with the Sioux. Each time, we had to build the lodge ourselves. The Tuscarora sweats were pretty hot but tolerable. The Sioux sweats can be much hotter. A Chippewa friend of mine said he won't do Sioux sweats because they try to burn the hide off you. But Sioux sweats, to me, can force an altered state (my best description). My Sioux friend (now deceased) was a spiritual singer. He and his son would sing/chant as the heat rose and it (and the smell of sage) helped me move to an altered state where the heat didn't burn. At that point, everybody may have different "experiences". 

Talking to you brought back some memories that I haven't thought about in a long time and reminded me that learning comes in different forms, from people that you might think have nothing to teach.

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov    10 years ago

I think these types of issues will eventually go away as humans interbreed and commingle. Given how small the world has become, I think our genomes will be completely blended in a thousand years. We'll have to find new differences to villify.

 
 
 
1ofmany
Sophomore Silent
link   1ofmany  replied to  Cerenkov   10 years ago

I think these types of issues will eventually go away as humans interbreed and commingle. Given how small the world has become, I think our genomes will be completely blended in a thousand years. We'll have to find new differences to vilify

Humanity supposedly began in Africa as one homogenous group and then spread over the earth with incredible diversity to ironically end up two million years later as one homogenous group. 

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy  replied to  1ofmany   10 years ago

And according to "South Park" we'll all be brown. To tell the truth I think they're right on that.

 
 

Who is online

evilone


90 visitors