Amanda Carpenter is Right. Blackball the Trump Endorsers.
Amanda Carpenter has a brave and important post today at Conservative Review. She has compiled a list of every Republican elected official and every prominent conservative pundit who has endorsed Donald Trump before he officially clinched the nomination. Her argument is pretty simple:
It’s time to make a list.
A list of those so-called conservatives and Republicans endorsing Donald Trump, the meglomaniac who regularly threatens his opponents and the press, raves about making members of our military adopt ISIS-like tactics, has funded Obamacare and Gang of Eight Democrats, promises to forcibly relocate American companies to his liking, and has demonstrated again and again he intends to govern as a tyrannical King rather than a President.
Call it a boycott, call it a blackball, call it blacklist, call it whatever you want. I’m done with these folks and other conservatives should be, too. Anyone who will defend a man condoning random acts of violence at his rallies has lost their morals; they will defend anything at all.
So, I’d like to remember who supported Trump so I never give any kind of credence to their judgment. “Never Trump” means never those who support him as well.
This isn't just a political disagreement. I have never been a huge fan of Rand Paul but I would not say that anyone who supported him can never be trusted again. I think I've made my feelings about John Kasich pretty clear on the pages of this august website, but people who support Kasich have at least defensible reasons for doing so, even if I disagree.
But the people who are endorsing Trump, while other Republicans are still standing, have forever forfeited their right to have their opinion taken seriously by conservatives. And when Trump's train finally wrecks, before or after November, it will wreak untold destruction on this party and this movement, and it will have been eminently foreseeable from day one of his campaign by anyone with even the slightest shred of judgment in their brain.
The only complaint I have with Amanda's list is that it does not include the media pundits and conservative thought leaders, who have been far more damaging in this regard - the Ann Coulters and Laura Ingrahams of the world, who have given the Trump boomlet the pseudo-intellectual backing that allows his followers to falsely believe that they aren't just part of a not-very-bright mob led by a not-very-bright mobster. http://www.redstate.com/leon_h_wolf/2016/03/18/amanda-carpenter-right.-blackball-trump-endorsers./
It’s time to make a list.
A list of those so-called conservatives and Republicans endorsing Donald Trump, the meglomaniac who regularly threatens his opponents and the press, raves about making members of our military adopt ISIS-like tactics, has funded Obamacare and Gang of Eight Democrats, promises to forcibly relocate American companies to his liking, and has demonstrated again and again he intends to govern as a tyrannical King rather than a President.
Call it a boycott, call it a blackball, call it blacklist, call it whatever you want. I’m done with these folks and other conservatives should be, too. Anyone who will defend a man condoning random acts of violence at his rallies has lost their morals; they will defend anything at all.
So, I’d like to remember who supported Trump so I never give any kind of credence to their judgment. “Never Trump” means never those who support him as well.
This isn't just a political disagreement. I have never been a huge fan of Rand Paul but I would not say that anyone who supported him can never be trusted again. I think I've made my feelings about John Kasich pretty clear on the pages of this august website, but people who support Kasich have at least defensible reasons for doing so, even if I disagree.
But the people who are endorsing Trump, while other Republicans are still standing, have forever forfeited their right to have their opinion taken seriously by conservatives. And when Trump's train finally wrecks, before or after November, it will wreak untold destruction on this party and this movement, and it will have been eminently foreseeable from day one of his campaign by anyone with even the slightest shred of judgment in their brain.
The only complaint I have with Amanda's list is that it does not include the media pundits and conservative thought leaders, who have been far more damaging in this regard - the Ann Coulters and Laura Ingrahams of the world, who have given the Trump boomlet the pseudo-intellectual backing that allows his followers to falsely believe that they aren't just part of a not-very-bright mob led by a not-very-bright mobster. http://www.redstate.com/leon_h_wolf/2016/03/18/amanda-carpenter-right.-blackball-trump-endorsers./

I think this goes a little too far. It reminds me of the unamerican liberal boycotts.
Boycotts are an expression of free speech. Are you against free speech? That would be unamerican.
What I am against is the invasion of private events to shout Trump down. Then you are violating his free speech.
Donald Trump could do like EVERY OTHER politician does, and ignore the protesters while security removes them. HE chose to make the interaction with the protesters a key part of his rallies and interact with them and the crowd. It is ALL his fault Perrie.
What is his fault is inciting the crowd to be violent and responding to them like a classroom bully. Hecklers are trying to deprive someone else's free speech.
No, the hecklers don't stop the speech, Trump does. He pauses to goad and heckle and narrate their interaction with security. No other politician does that.
How about the scumbag liberals that block the roads to the events?
Blocking roads is a crime. The police should deal with it... and your assumption that they are all liberals is probably wrong. There are a lot of middle of the road Americans who Trump freaks them out.
How about the scumbag liberals that block the roads to the events?
How about the scumbag liberals that destroyed an entire shipment of tea in Boston?
Protesting is in our Countries DNA and has often included civil disobedience as well as boycotts.
All this feigned outrage at the Trump protestors, who are just matching their 1st amendment rights against the same right held by Trump and his supporters.
If only the D's had realized years ago that to way to get 35 / 40% Republican support for the ACA was not by trying talking reason with them but rather to just beat down those rowdy Tea Party protestors.
The ones that shouted down and abused all the other folk that went to those town hall meetings hoping to hear from their elected officials some details about the new law.
Bloody a protester win a few Republican votes. Who Knew? (s)
How about the scumbag liberals that destroyed an entire shipment of tea in Boston?
Excellent point Ark! Never thought about it that way.
That's because there is no connection between the two events. Look into the history of the tea party and you will see it was something completely different. It was the people turning against the government the same thing Trump and his supporters are doing.
Spin what they did as it suits your world view Dean but the simple fact is, theirs was a criminal act of civil disobedience done for the purpose of political protest.
Oh, fun fact, what they did caused a million dollars worth of damage, in today's terms.
It took nearly three hours for more than 100 colonists to empty the tea into Boston Harbor. The chests held more than 90,000 lbs. (45 tons) of tea, which would cost nearly $1,000,000 dollars today.
They weren't liberal at all . They were TAX protestors .
Lol. Protesters regularly prevent people from speaking.
No, the hecklers don't stop the speech, Trump does. He pauses to goad and heckle and narrate their interaction with security. No other politician does that.
Completely right! The hecklers have never shouted him down. They get accused of something they don't do. Yes, they are loud, but Trump either has the removed (which is his right if it's done non-violently) while he incites violence against them or he just cancels.
Hecklers are trying to deprive someone else's free speech.
Hecklers have the same right to free speech too and every candidate has to learn to put up with them in one way or another. HOW they deal with them is a great way to judge the character of the candidate. George Wallace and Donald Trump handle(d) them the same way, by inciting violence from their supporters. That says a lot more negative about them then the protesters. If a Presidential candidate can't peacefully handle hecklers (at least most of the time), then they surrender their right to be President.
He's campaigning as the 'un-candidate' and the 'un-politician'. Why would he do what the other candidates do? His approach obviously resonates amongst those who follow him. He has seized on the fact that the vast majority of Americans are sick and tired of the political correctness foisted on us by the left and their media lap dogs. As the saying goes, your roosters are coming home to roost.
I think he's not the guy I want in the White House, but the PC crowd has made him the candidate he is right now. He's just following the script that those folks made possible for him
Gary,
I think he's tapped in to a lot of feelings. Yes he is anti PC, and he's anti establishment, and that taps in to a lot of frustration with our current state of affairs in Washington, but some of his rhetoric is nasty, and that appeals to a more base crowed.
Oh yeah, I agree. He is basing his campaign on all the things he sees around him. Make no mistake, he's not stupid and he plays to win. SO, if he parrots everything that people are saying, they listen to him. Especially when those that people despise tell you he's the wrong one. People make the distinction that well, he the best of a bad lot.....and those kinds of voters? He's got a shot at winning.
Why would he do what the other candidates do?
Then why did he spend this morning at The Heritage Foundation begging GOP establishment Congressman and Senators to help him? His days of being an "outsider" taking on the "establishment" are long past. He is just another GOP politician and candidate now, bowing the establishment's feet. And not a very good one either. Even if he gets what he is now doing his best to win, the backing of the Washington establishment of the GOP he's going to get slaughtered in November.
And yet, the establishment GOP is seeking any way to kill off his candidacy. Doesn't sound like either of them are embracing the other. I would think Trump (being the blusterer he is) is telling the GOP establishment to get on board or be left behind (at least that's the way I read how he would act towards them, based on his personality). I seriously doubt he's begging anyone for anything, though that might be how certain types would spin it.
Witch hunts and destroying careers over political opinions are or shoukd be very unamerican.
I agree Cerenkov, but both parties are guilty of that.
To equate Donald Trump with any other candidate , with the assessment that "both sides do it", is just bizarre. If we cannot isolate and quarantine a phony, con man candidate of this magnitude and hold him up for UNIQUE ridicule, when would we ever possibly be able to do that?
I was not equating Donald Trump to anyone. The comment was made that:
Witch hunts and destroying careers over political opinions are or shoukd be very unamerican.
To which I replied that both parties do it. The topic was witch hunts, not DT.
Perrie,
I agree that both sides are guilty.
What I am against is the invasion of private events to shout Trump down. Then you are violating his free speech.
I disagree. The ones shouting him down have as much right to loud speech as to soft speech. It's their right as much as his.
I don't remember you liberals feeling that way when Michelle was booed at the NASCAR race.
I don't remember you liberals feeling that way when Michelle was booed at the NASCAR race.
I don't remember The First Lady screaming at them and inciting violence either. She is a lady, not a goon like Trump.
Bwah ha ha!
On this we disagree, Randy. I think that shouting down a speaker is contrary to not only the spirit of but also the legal meaning of the first amendment. The acceptable limitation is deliberately contravening the amendment in a situation where harm to people is likely to be caused by it, such as the proverbial shouting "FIRE' in a crowded theatre.
Was the government asserting its right to free speech to prevent peaceful protest at Kent State?
Protesters inside the events do not shout down Donald Trump. That has never happened yet. It might have happened in Chicago, but Trump never showed up and the rally was canceled.
I do not approve of protesters blocking traffic though. That is dangerous to public safety.
Was the government asserting its right to free speech to prevent peaceful protest at Kent State?
Horrible comparison!!! The National Guard was the GOVERNMENT at Kent State murdering protestors. Have any protestors tried to murder Trump or his supporters? The people protesting at Trump events are private citizens with a right to free speech every bit as much as Trump and your comparison would be much more apt if local law enforcement were shooting the protestors!
I used Kent State as an example of trying to shut up free speech only. Can you address the first point i made?
I used Kent State as an example of trying to shut up free speech only. Can you address the first point i made?
In the first place no one has shouted Trump down. Hasn't happened. In the 2nd place these are political rallies and unless Trump is going to have attendees stick their right arm out at a 45 degree angle and swear allegiance to Herr Trump at the door, protestors are going to get in and they have a right to protest, to free speech as much as Trump does. As John says all he has to do is to ignore them while they are being escorted out, instead of what he does is to mock them, insult them and incite his followers to beat the hell out of them, which no other candidates do. Thirdly, it is not the same as shouting fire in a crowded theater because it is not intended to cause panic and does not do so.
It is not causing panic specifically that is the point, it is the deliberate intent to cause harm that is caused by that panic. How do you feel about Palestinian supporters succeeding to block pro-Israel speakers from making their case on campuses? (Do you need examples of that? because they are available.) Is that not preventing free speech to be made, i.e the telling of a side of the story (one they disapprove of) that they are preventing others from hearing?
It is not causing panic specifically that is the point, it is the deliberate intent to cause harm that is caused by that panic.
There is not and was not intent to cause harm or panic. If that were the standard then all protests in America would be illegal and no one would be able to express THEIR rights! There is intent only to exercise their freedom of speech. The only people endangered are the protestors themselves as they know Trump has a history of inciting his supporters to punch and beat the protestors. The comparison to it as shouting fire in a crowded theater is only slightly less wrong as the Kent State one, which by the way was incredibly heartless and offensive..
Don't call ME heartless and offensive, it was your beloved government that committed the atrocity. I used the example only as an example of one side of an issue preventing the free speech of another side of an issue.
They were not my beloved government at the time. Besides it was an undercover FBI operative who fired 4 shots in the general direction of the National Guard, setting off the shooting. And it was still a shitty way to make a comparison of the type you were reaching for. YOU are capable of doing better! Even after all these years Kent State and Jackson State are still very sore spots to every one of my age and older. Murdering unarmed students has nothing to do with free speech. It was just plan murder.
I think we are looking at the point I have been making in different ways - interpreting it differently, so there is no sense continuing with what I tried to say. I declare an impasse, because for sure I don't want it to escalate into another issue we have difficulty agreeing upon.
Kent state was not just a horror for you, it was for any person of intelligence and morality. It was as horrible an incident to us in Canada as it was for you.
Kent state was not just a horror for you, it was for any person of intelligence and morality. It was as horrible an incident to us in Canada as it was for you.
Thank you. Impasse accepted. Still friends?
Of course. Why else do you think I stopped the discussion? I enjoy following everything you write.
You're right - typical bullshit thread/seed. Needs to die a quick death.
NT is NOT the negative board, but you are trying really hard to make it one. Where's your positive threads?? Do you have any?
I think boycotting is part of asserting your support or disagreement. One thing we've learned is that money is a powerful tool. The problem in boycotting is with who is doing the promotion of the boycott and why they're pushing it. I have a list of items on my refrigerator that I won't purchase that are manufactured by the Koch brothers. I won't shop at Walmart and my husband doesn't want us spending our money at Burlington or JC Penny (okay.....sometimes I sneak and get something from JC Penny but phffft what he doesn't know won't hurt me! hehehehe).
I don't pay any attention to people who promote boycotts that are politicians or easily bought and paid for like Ann Coulter. I know they are only promoting it because it benefits them personally. They've been compensated in some manner to get the message out to their base or those who follow them.
Boycotting can be a useful tool. We just need to be cautious and find out the real reason for the boycott.
So, you also don't allow you or your family any interaction with any Union Member of the SEIU, correct? Of course, you can't even eat at the Dinosaur BBQ (which has some really good food) because it's owned by Soros, correct? I mean if you are being 100% in accordance with your beliefs, there's no way......I'm going to link a list of the people that have bought and still own politicians:
You'll notice that Koch Industries is 49th on the list of the Top 100. These are things that a true 4th Estate would freely publish, but we don't really have one of those anymore.
I have never been to the Dinosaur BBQ. I make an effort when it's possible but sometimes it's not possible and I'd be lying if I said I was 100% in accordance.