Man Vs. Machine Is The Defining Issue Of Our Age
Technology f*cked us all: The anxiety driving Donald Trump and Bernie Sanders is really about machines taking our jobs
excerpt
"...what is ailing America’s working and lower-middle classes, is the way machines have fundamentally reshaped the work undereducated workers do. Advances in technology are gradually draining the skill and human judgement from every kind of working-class labor, from weaving a bolt of cloth to frying a hamburger, giving companies free rein to transfer once reasonably well-paid skilled and semi-skilled American jobs to unskilled foreign workers, both here and abroad. At the same time, advances in communications and transportation have enabled companies to build truly global supply chains, opening the way for them to shop the world for the cheapest and least powerful workers to do the job.
Together these forces, the de-skilling of human labor and the shrinking of the world of commerce, are helping corporations grow ever larger and more powerful and shifting ever more earning power from the assembly line to the executive suite. The more money and power the elite amasses, the more they can game the system to amass more money and power, until you’re left with a situation like ours, where a typical CEO makes 330 times more than the average worker and the top 1 percent of Americans hold 40 percent of the country’s wealth.
The growing gap between rich and poor in America is morally appalling and politically unsustainable, but many of the forces driving the disparities are systemic and irreversible. No wall we can build will stop the seepage of jobs overseas in a fully globalized and technologically mobile world, and a shift to a democratic socialist model that worked for highly homogenous northern European countries in the middle part of the last century is unlikely to work in our own fractious, racially diverse country facing 21st century problems. Whether we like it or not, we are stuck with the world we have made, along with the deep problems it is causing us, and we have no choice but to innovate our way out of it. The thing is, we did it once before. In the 1930s, when mechanization finally pushed America’s small farmers and sharecroppers out of the fields and into factories, we saw a profound shift in the role of government in people’s lives.
When poor people could no longer feed themselves from their own plot of land, however meager, governments had to step in to find new ways to feed the hungry and care for the sick and elderly. The Soviet Union responded to this crisis with Communism. Central Europe responded with Nazism. America responded with the New Deal. Then, 10 years later, we had a war to see which system worked best. America won that battle, and in the process set off the longest and most prosperous economic boom in our history. But now that boom has run its course, and we must reinvent ourselves once again, this time for a very different world.
As was the case in the 1930s, when the developed world at last felt the consequences of a century-long shift from an agrarian society to an industrial one, our present challenges have a long history. As early the 1950s and ’60s, global markets were pushing good union jobs overseas and technological advances were turning skilled jobs into less lucrative semi-skilled ones. But today, when robots build cars and the digital revolution is tossing entire job categories – office assistant, taxi driver, newspaper reporter – into the trash heap, the sheer rate of change is starting to have political ramifications.
So far, though, America’s political class, including the current crop of presidential contenders, hasn’t begun to grapple in a serious way with how machines are changing the nature of work, especially at the economic margins. In part, this is because American political elites are themselves creatures of the knowledge economy and don’t feel the pain of the shift from an industrial economy in the personal and direct ways so many of their less educated constituents do. Then, too, there is the problem of mounting a coherent campaign against technological progress. People love their gadgets, which bring them things they want cheaply and instantaneously. Digital communication may be picking clean the lower rungs of clerical workers, from receptionists to mailroom employees to inventory clerks, but try coming up with a political slogan denouncing email.
More troublingly, forces like technology and globalization are faceless abstractions, and in the heat of a campaign, efforts to combat their ill effects often devolve into scapegoating and demagoguery, as this year’s presidential contest has shown us all too well. A crowd that might sit on its hands for a lecture on the changing nature of work in a globalized, digitally connected world will cheer lustily at crude denunciations of Mexican immigrants or crafty Chinese businessmen stealing American jobs. This fury, while it turns out voters, can also send us tilting at windmills, chasing solutions that are wildly impractical, morally objectionable, or just plain counterproductive.
Still, as a society, we must learn to rage against the machines, not in the destructive sense of the industrial-age saboteurs who threw their wooden shoes into their machines to break them, but thoughtfully and creatively. In every past burst of technological progress, the jobs that were rendered obsolete by the new machines were eventually replaced by new kinds of work made possible by the new machines. But that doesn’t simply happen by natural law. We have to make it happen, the way Franklin Roosevelt did when he started experimenting wildly with the levers of government to stop capitalism from devouring itself. And we have to start making it happen now.
The longer we allow machines to shape our work lives unchecked, the more we will see wealth concentrate in the hands of those who design and finance those machines. Already, technology and the globalizing effects technology makes possible have hollowed out American factories and sucked the economic life from a few select knowledge industries like journalism, and now even workers in solidly upper-middle-class professions like law and medicine are starting to see their work de-skilled and outsourced to other countries. Man vs. machine: It’s the defining issue of our age.
Tags
Who is online
147 visitors

Finally someone gets it. I wish we would have seen some of these points brought up at the presidential debates.
Well, there is the fall campaign.
Looks like you got religion John....... And I do not have an answer for this. All I know is that somehow, humanity is going to have to evolve socially to where financial wealth is not what is coveted, but knowledge.
In short, what is it going to take for us to get to a Gene Roddenberry sort of existence? If that even exists, getting from where we are to there is going to be VERY painful!
The "masses" are not inclined to look at the big picture, but unless we start now, the future looks bleak and dystopian to me, and from what I can gather from your comments, to you too.
And of course, "the future is now" . Present and future shrink together more every day.
It's going to get worse for every generation.....
As I have said before, we have now kids graduating from universities that are "unemployable" through no fault of their own. Diagnostic doctors are going to be made obsolete, dentists, paralegals, taxi drivers, long haul truckers, heavy equipment operators, all are in the path of computerized automation. The abilities of silicon based systems is growing at a pace at which we meat based systems cannot.
Self driving car issues :
Self-Driving Google Car Hits a Bus
6 Simple Things Google's Self-Driving Car Still Can't Handle
Yep one time out of a million trips. The accident rate for the self driving cars so far has been 1/100th of that for people driven cars. Of course that will increase the more of them there are, and BTW that accident wasn't the result of an error by the SDC, it was an error by the human bus driver.
If I'm not mistaken the blame for the accident has not been assigned to the bus driver . The 1st sentence in the video assigned it to the computer .
The accident rate for the self driving cars so far has been 1/100th of that for people driven cars.
Yup . These cars do OK in perfect weather etc .
Actually, the responsibility is shared, it was assumptions on both sides. And of course the assumption of the computer is at fault, cause the computer should assume the other vehicle has the ROW. That is the way it is programmed.
So yes it is a technical error on the computers part, for a very minor "Bump" of an accident. First time it has happened in over a million miles of running when under complete computer control.
And I understand the weather conditions were clear. It was a fault with the decision logic programmed into the computer. (I'm sure it has been analyzed and corrected by now)
Two humans driving? it was the fault of the bus driver for failing to pay attention to the cars around him.
6 Simple Things Google's Self-Driving Car Still Can't Handle
it was the fault of the bus driver for failing to pay attention to the cars around him.
I remain unconvinced .
Nice that you leave out the defining part of the statement.
TWO HUMANS DRIVING......
Then re-posting the same thing is being densely argumentative rather than derivative of good expansive debate.... It's easy to argue when you dismiss the relevant point of a statement.
Kinda like choosing to be in an unconvinced state of mind.
But then maybe your looking for another POV, which is alright too. MPTY! (and BTW, MPTY stands for More Power To Ya)
Speaking of being densely argumentative ... you are . Are you planning on explaining why or how the bus driver was at fault ?
Predictable, very predictable....
But of course I already did. That was the point of your dissent, and why you left it out to formulate your pointless argument.
Go ahead and press a worthless argument. That is what usually happens around here and passes for debate.
Still no explanation . Do you believe your arguments are godlike ? Then make some or STFU ...
like most everyone else with a very narrow viewpoint, resort to insults or bully tactics to cover up their lack of cogent discussion skills....
Have a nice day.
If this is your idea of discussion I'm informing you that its not working .
{chuckle}
If you really wanted a discussion we would have had one. Dictating the discussion contrary to popular belief is not discussing.
Tit 4 tat is also not a discussion . But it [& you] are being childish .
I didn't restart this, you did, so what was that about tit for tat?
Nice advice, you might want to follow it.
Like I said before you have a good evening.
I restarted it, for Pete's sake! Scheeeesh!
God, will you furl that flag!
The race is over, the pits are closed and everyone has gone home.....
Time to turn out the lights......
Who won?
Beats me, I was too busy to notice. (and too happy to care)
I got stoned and I missed it.
Can't top that.... (no excuses)
Good one brother...
I would like to watch one parallel park between two cars. Better yet, watch it encounter a bridge on a day when the roads are just wet but the cold air under the bridge freezes the water on the bridge.
They are still coming Petey....... and faster than people think.
They don't have to be perfect, they just have to be better than humans, and they already are in many ways.
They are already better than Human drivers, given the accident rates.
What is at issue is for the first such system being implemented in a city say replacing the bus or light rail system, they have to be almost bulletproof. Right now accident rates are,
100 times lower than automobiles with human drivers,
35% lower than buses with human drivers and,
3% lower than light rail with human operators.
The last one is the turning point for city government if the statistics hold.
The current rates of bad outcomes for autonomous vehicles already surpasses the current rates for all other mass transit, that is why they received permission to street test. This is actually old tech that is finally reaching the actual street. They have been researching, engineering and testing autonomous driving now for over 35 years on test tracks worldwide.
What your seeing is the tech has caught up to the ideal. And, automobiles are the last to get the autonomous treatment. it happened to Airplanes first, Ships second, Trains third.
The common citizen is always the last to receive new tech. The first to see it? long haul trucks and city buses.
Yeah, but ll it takes is one successful lawsuit to put a company out of business by saying the accident was caused because there wasn't a person controlling the whatever.
And that won't really happen until someone, some governmental entity puts it into operation somewhere. I suspect they will have all kinds of administrative rules covering everything they think can go wrong.
I agree, it is nice to see the dawning of understanding in people to what the real danger is.
In all of the other societal revolutions, where the world has changed fundamentally like what is happening today (and has been for at least the last 40 years) War has come before a viable course has been discovered.
Yes we may be headed for an altruistic world where no one has any real needs that are not met automatically by the devices we love so much.
there is a point of nexus coming where seemingly disparate unrelated technologies are reaching the point where they can work together in a more efficient way making each other more efficient in the process. It is not only work in the work place it is in the manner in which we travel, across the planet and across the neighborhood.
Just imagine getting groceries, today just get in your car and drive to the supermarket.
In the near future, log onto a website, select your needed items, which are automatically loaded into an electric self driving delivery vehicle and deposited at your door. the value transfer covering the goods is already taken place before the first item is pulled from the super warehouse racks.
What are people going to do when the very fabric of their understanding of the world is changing right before their eyes?
Become very afraid.
But before we get there, we have always gone thru a period of self extinction based upon those fears.
And we are overdue.
Karl Marx was afraid of the greater efficiencies of the industrial factory system overtaking mans desire to make things by and for himself and his little hamlet. His argument was that greater efficiency makes for a weaker, less social man.
The funniest thing is, history may prove him right.
I believe FlyNavy has from time to time, when this topic has come up, talked about the need to diminish the importance of the "profit motive". I agree with that wholeheartedly. As long as profit, and more profit is the be all end all, we won't come to grips with the reality that profit motive is driving this dystopian future.
Not everyone is cut out to work all day with computers, yet neither are they artistic or creative. Many many people are in fact worker bees. Since the profit motive will put such people on the ash heap, the government will have to step in and provide them with a means of making a living, or pay them to do nothing. We are talking about tens of millions of people at any given time. And this is a reality that will come within the next 50 years or so, in other words within the lives of our grandchildren, if not children.
It's not so much profit, cause profit can be defined in many different ways.
The real issue is accumulation of wealth, and the power that excessive wealth brings.
ME, buying a house is a purchase that could and will change my life.
For some others, buying a house is like picking up a penny candy from the five and dime.
The rules of life that apply to me don't apply to them and vice versa.
With massive wealth, profit is irrelevant, power becomes all important.
"...the government will have to step in and provide them with a means of making a living..."
They could always pick fruit, and that could have the additional effect of retarding illegal immigration.
No fruit grower will pay them enough. Now if we re-direct some taxes so fruit pickers make a minimum of say $20 per hour, then it might work. Of course that would only cause more illegal immigration.
"Of course that would only cause more illegal immigration."
You're right - I didn't think of that. However that would cause mini-wars between local and immigrant workers, which makes the words "Stand your ground" more meaningful for me.
I think it will just cause more companies to invent machines that automatically pick fruits and vegetables.
At least robots won't do what I do when I pick fruit. Two for the basket, one for my mouth, two more for the basket, another one for my mouth.....etc. Wasn't imodium a wonderful invention?
With massive wealth, profit is irrelevant, power becomes all important.
Isn't this how wars get started from time to time......?
AS history so aptly teaches us.....
As long as there are legislators who are supported by, and, who pander to "The Marketplace is God" ideologues …
… the preponderance of new wealth will continue to go to the already wealthy.
Too many Middle Class fools cut-off-their-proverbial noses to make their demagoguery-targets marginally effective …
… to quote Forrest Gump … "stupid is as stupid does".
I'm convinced that you haven't got a clue of any solutions to the problem . Ranting about the evils of big business is NOT a solution ... it is only a distraction .
I'm convinced that you haven't got a clue of any solutions to the problem . Ranting about the evilsof big business is NOT a solution ... it is only a distraction .
And ranting about my rant is even further from any specifics regarding a solution.
But allow me to translate my comment for you; "Worshipping the marketplace over the value of viable jobs for human beings and their families -- that, by supporting the legislative pimps and whores who represent the wealthy –- is the ultimate perpetuator of the problem; electing populists is step one towards a solution."
Let's have your solution.
Yup ... as usual you MUST bring up pimps & whores on a topic that is about economics ... one track mind . Since you are determined to find fault with "evil big business" it is incumbent on you to describe a solution using smaller business or big government . Have at it !
electing populists is step one towards a solution.
I can easily see problems with populists who are mostly impractical dreamers ... They only see one side of almost all issues .
Good news the middle class is shrinking and the upper class is growing. More people are moving up than down and it's a more diverse group than in the past.
What world do you lie in?
The American Middle Class Is Losing Ground
No longer the majority and falling behind financially
In at least one sense, the shift represents economic progress: While the share of U.S. adults living in both upper- and lower-income households rose alongside the declining share in the middle from 1971 to 2015, the share in the upper-income tier grew more.
Over the same period, however, the nation’s aggregate household income has substantially shifted from middle-income to upper-income households, driven by the growing size of the upper-income tier and more rapid gains in income at the top. Fully 49% of U.S. aggregate income went to upper-income households in 2014, up from 29% in 1970. The share accruing to middle-income households was 43% in 2014, down substantially from 62% in 1970. 2
The study shows that as the number of middle-class Americans fell (from 61 percent of the population to 51 percent of the population), the percentage of Americans who are upper income surged from 14 percent of the population to 20 percent of the population.
Yes the middle class is shrinking because more people are moving up.
Engineering used to be much more of an art form. Even if you had bad handwriting and no artistic skills, you used drafting tools and intelligent planning to produce neat, professional drawings. Then came CAD, which sped up production tremendously, at the cost of quality drawings. Over time, CAD platforms improved such that you could create the same quality drawings if you took the time to learn and use it effectively.
Now CAD platforms have 'smart' modules, where items drawn can have variable input capabilities for design calculation purposes, but you have to be extremely careful how the information is entered, and it can be very inflexible in terms of what the output looks like. I hate that I ultimately end up spending the same amount of time to create drawings that aren't as high of quality. I notice that the younger draftsmen just have no concept of what old school quality drafting looks like. It's becoming a lost artform.
Our survey department is investigation a survey drone. I have little faith that it's going to be a good investment at this stage. The drone is $60k, and I'm certain that its output is going to be a sloppy mess that will take much time to clean up and make serviceable. The physical survey may take 1/4 the time, but the processing will be extensive and the end product will be low quality. Automation in the design department doesn't always result in higher quality results.
At the start no it doesn't, but thinking of it as a system. A system that can be adjusted to give known results as long as the parameters are known.
And within the basis of engineering, your always moving from the known towards the unknown. Automation is simply a much more efficient tool.
Much like the machines that made routine manufacturing decisions every day in the mid 1800's the machines we have today are much more efficient and autonomous in making those decisions. (and usually much more accurate and consistent)
Human labor is always looking for the easier more efficient way.
Paper Tape CNC for instance. (1st generation CNC, 50 years ago) Make one mistake in the input to the tape puncher (transpose a number off the print for example) and you have to completely re-do the input and make a new tape wasting much of the setup time where a human Machinist wouldn't make such a mistake setting up the machine manually cause the mistake is readily observable right there on the machine. But, when done correctly that tape is a single instance of setup for a dozen machines where the tool room machinist has to go to each machine and set it up individually.
Huge efficiency improvement there and that is just getting the machines ready to produce parts.
Add three or four cutting heads to the machine? so who cares if your tape takes three days to produce with the appropriate accuracy when your going to be producing parts at 50 times the rate you otherwise would. The loss of two days work time is easily made up by the gain from 20 days production reduced to 5 days.
And as time moves forward, they improve the input machine to the point where you don't need a tape puncher, to the point where you don't need an operator, to the point where the machine can directly read from the computer controlling it.
You don't need a man anymore to produce the product.
Only to keep the machine running. Now one man is doing the work of 40 men.
That is very valuable to industry. Who cares about the two days lost in setup...
No argument with any of that, but I'm a civil engineer, and every project I do is unique, so the automation isn't saving me anything.
One good thing is that it won't displace you. Automation means repetition and robotics cannot think creatively.
Not quite Buzz..... Software engineers are designing software that can design itself. Call it self teaching. The US stock market is very much now controlled by computers that taught themselves how to trade. Medical diagnostic computers are doing that now as well, and will be more accurate than any human doctor can be simply because of the data bases they can access for drug interaction, and probability factoring of diagnosis from symptoms. Diagnostic doctors have a big bulls eye on them. Nurses are in good shape for some time if I see things clearly as are surgeons.
I recall from way in the past reading a SciFi story about robots who subjugated humans and took over control of the Earth - can't remember the name or the author.
Nurses are in good shape for some time if I see things clearly as are surgeons.
And a decent RN make 6 figures fairly easily.
Automation cannot make everything more efficient. just the repetitive tasks. There are some thing in civil engineering that can be automated, but not as many as in some other fields.
Surveying by Drone? given time it will be a reality I suspect.
Whether that is good or bad is yet to be seen.
I would think that, as drones are used more for commercial use, the court will have to decide just how high up does the airspace above your private property go? One hundred feet? Two hundred? Certainly 10 feet is too low, so then what is the limit? If Amazon is going to deliver packages by flying them over my yard, then they are either going to pay me for the noise and invasion of my personal airspace or I'll buy a pellet gun (maybe through Amazon?) and shoot them down as a test case. Only over my yard, of course.
As I mentioned on a couple of other seeds of this nature. A year ago when visiting the Kuka robot company, I saw robots making other robots. Machining, assembling, testing, all of it. The humans that were there were responsible for loading the raw steel components that the robot was to machine. The humans then ensured that the finished robot was secure on it's shipping skid, and loaded on the truck. Humans made the wooden skids.
Bottom line, the robots did all of the precision work.... Even for someone like me that had been around robots for decades, this was a real eye opener.
Been around some sort of machine tool at various times my entire life also. I've been seeing it coming for generations.
It is shocking when you finally see the whole system in operation. Makes one think....
Likewise....I've been around injection mold construction since the late 1980s. Man have I seen changes in that industry.
I had to laugh about your comments on paper tapes. The first Okuma CNC machines I programmed had paper tape readers and then the original "floppy discs" followed on.
When I first started in computers in 1973 in the USAF we were just stating to phase out paper tape machines and going completely with card decks. Of course our card punch machine could create hundreds of punched cards a minute, but not write along the top what they said for security reasons. So if we wanted to read the words we had to run them through a card interpreter machine that read the holes and wrote on top what they said, which came in handy if you wanted to avoid "golden flow" drug tests.
the one I learned on was a standard Bridgeport with an IBM computron 1110 tape puncher. Man the buttons and switches were all retro industrial grade 1" tape with 8 rows of holes. The reader was a selectric 7940 (toshiba) it read the tape by blowing air throu the holes onto microswitches which actuated the stepper motors on whichever axis needed moving. Four axis machine 8 rows of holes which established the direction/distance the table or quill was supposed to move. It was covered in heavy clear vinyl to keep the chips away from it and all the handles were removed from the machine. Luckily they had power feed on it so you could index the table before turning it on and setting the zero point.
I remember the foreman telling me that is was the future of machining.
Little did he know.
I'm retired. Automation is just a matter of convenience to me and I decide what parts of it is convenient and what parts are not. As a rule I like convenience.
IMO it will take an apocalypse or at least a genuine popular revolution to reverse the trend towards individual massing of wealth. I had a friend who had an extremely successful factory where individual production was a virtue, and that was caused by a genuine and substantial profit-sharing plan. Without such morality, the western world is on a fast track to disaster. Wall Street lives by the motto: "Greed is good".
Of course, individual stupidity can destroy even what is a good thing for the employees. Even in the face of the fact that my friend had made it clear that if his factory ever became unionized he would sell out to a conglomerate, one individual talked a large group of employees into seeking unionization. My friend then did what he promised and sold out. The individual said later what a terrible mistake he had made - he shot himself and all the other employees in the foot.
Wall Street lives by the motto: "Greed is good".
It's just not Wall Street.....
Do you remember who made this statement?
"It doesn't matter whether a cat is white or black, as long as it catches mice."
no
???
Easy...
It doesn't matter whether a cat is white or black, as long as it catches mice. —Deng Xiaoping
And they said commies didn't understand capitalism...
The Chinese Communists are a rare breed-- in their heart they are all capitalists.
(They can't help it, they're Chinese!)
From my experience, many of them are more capitalistic than Americans.
And they said commies didn't understand capitalism...
They are more ruthless about it than we Americans are....
And they said commies didn't understand capitalism...
They do...their culture has been around a lot longer than ours.
But here's the problem: they are trying to balance two opposing forces. Culturally they are true Capitalists*. And they have other values too that would tend to lead to a prosperous country-- respect for learning.
And tremendous respect for their elders. (Which can result in not having to "re-invent the hell"--its takes a long time for a person-- and a society, to learn important stuff. So their ancient wisdom learned over centuries is passed down by their elders.
(cont'd from a previous comment):
But then came the so-called "Cultural Revolution" which did away with a lot of that. And Communism, which sounds great in theory, does not make for happy campers.
So its a sort of a pushme-pullyou country. Their business instincts & other wisdom gained over centuries would make for a fantastic country-- but their Communist form of gov't f*cks everthing up!
_______________________________________________
*Capitalism per se does not have to be a bad system, any more than Socialism does. Or even religion (I know, its not politically correct to say that here).
And they said commies didn't understand capitalism...
They are more ruthless about it than we Americans are....
But I don't think that's due to their capitalist tendencies.
IMO, they are try to have two systems at once-- Communism and Capitalism. So if they're ruthless, it may not be their capitalistic tends that's dong it, but rather the Communism.
Communism is, & has to be, by its very nature, inherently evil. (With the exception of some very small communities where it can be fine-- & indeed even very democratic).
Good observation, and I concur with it.
It can only be fine and democratic if they give up the need for control and the power needed to implement control.
Communists gain control at the point of a gun
Capitalists gain control at the issuance of the loan.
What's the difference. Both methods establish power and control.
And, I agree very good point.
Small communities like the kibbutzim in Israel.
In any event I can tell you as a fact that one can live pretty comfortably in big bad China on very little income, and as long as you don't make noise and mind your own business, nobody is going to bother you.
"It doesn't matter whether a cat is white or black, as long as it catches mice."
Confucious say:
At night all cats are black.A bulldozer company knocked down the wrong house, and it's blaming it on Google Maps
Neither Google nor its inventions is infallible ...
True-- technology is not infallible. And of course, neither are humans
At least it won't be like (I Love) Lucy at the conveyor belt.
Like Lucy-- or even like Chaplin in Modern Times!
The Factory Scene From Chaplin's Last Silent Film "Modern Times" (1936)
___________________________
Modern Times is a 1936 comedy film written and directed by Charlie Chaplin in which his iconic Little Tramp character struggles to survive in the modern, industrialized world. The film is a comment on the desperate employment and fiscal conditions many people faced during the Great Depression , conditions created, in Chaplin's view, by the efficiencies of modern industrialization.
Now this is really prescient: " . . . conditions created, in Chaplin's view, by the efficiencies of modern industrialization.
(OMG, this movie was made way back in 1936!!!).
And of course, neither are humans
Indeed . But humans rarely claim infallibility ... unless they are the Pope or Donald Trump .
Indeed . But humans rarely claim infallibility ... unless they are the Pope or Donald Trump .
LOL.
Indeed . But humans rarely claim infallibility ... unless they are the Pope or Donald Trump .
And also a few people in some online discussion forums . . .
And also a few people in some online discussion forums . . .
Ooops! Perrie told me I should try to behave myself...
Don't worry about it....... we'll cover for you Krish!
Be warned though.... don't stand too close to me as I'm a natural lightning rod for trouble. It might miss me and hit you by accident!
Happy Monday!
Same to you!
But humans rarely claim infallibility
I used to be infallible, but the pay sucked and I couldn't set my own hours.. Plus there was a lot of heavy lifting.
Here is another situation in which automation did not perform well :
Useless robot waitstaff force the closure of two restaurants in China
We've built robots that can walk , talk , play incredibly deep board games , and even run hotels just like us, but there's apparently one human skill the machines have yet to master — pouring drinks. Chinese chain Heweilai soon found out that robots can't be trusted with simple restaurant tasks after it bought several $7,000 units to serve as waiting staff in three of its locations. Two of the restaurants were forced to close after the robots' uselessness was discovered, with the third only remaining open after it consigned all but one of them to the scrapheap , replacing them with traditional meatbag waitstaff.
Those who sing the praises of globalization, automation, outsourcing, the "bottom line" -- and, who support the legislators whose political power is purchased by the beneficiaries, essentially foment, to one degree or another, the obsolescence of the human-being-worker!
Apparently blind to the ultimate destination of what economists term "the race to the bottom," it is no coincidence that the proponents of a "marketplace-as-God" are ultimately responsible for the dissolution of the American middle class, the family unit, and, the preponderance of crime -- which come bundled together.
The disgusting irony of this, is that those who support such greed-driven insanity, blame the working poor for needing assistance while failing to make the connection between unemployment and crime -- or, who conveniently look the other way. And there are those among these supporters who believe that more guns in the hands of "good guys" TRUMPS more decent-wage jobs for desperate would-be "bad guys".
Anyone who thinks that the age of automation is a solution to such "problems" as a "hair in his salad" -- is denying an inconvenient truth.
_______________________________________________
NOTE: Feel free to rebut/object/dislike … but explain specifically the reasons. Insulting me personally is not a rebuttal.
Reminds me of the brilliant Milton Friedman story.
At one of our dinners, Milton recalled traveling to an Asian country in the 1960s and visiting a worksite where a new canal was being built. He was shocked to see that, instead of modern tractors and earth movers, the workers had shovels. He asked why there were so few machines. The government bureaucrat explained: “You don’t understand. This is a jobs program.” To which Milton replied: “Oh, I thought you were trying to build a canal. If it’s jobs you want, then you should give these workers spoons, not shovels.”
Oh, I thought you were trying to build a canal. If it’s jobs you want, then you should give these workers spoons, not shovels.”
When the would-be spooners are out-of-jobs, there won't be many of them around to consume whatever cargo is transported over the canals.
RACE-TO-THE-BOTTOM.
Naw they're doing the work US unions priced themselves out of.
Naw they're doing the work US unions priced themselves out of.
A dismissive comment that fails to address the realities of eroded consumerism.
Please; no more dismissive comments. Either address the specifics, admit you don't know or understand the realities, or remain silent.
Correlation is not the same as causation . In the case of those 2 variables there are other things that cause both . This should be obvious but you conveniently ignore the logic .
Correlation is not the same as causation . In the case of those 2 variables there are other things that cause both . This should be obvious but you conveniently ignore the logic .
Not always, agreed. But you haven't identified any other variables … consequently, your failure to do so defies the obvious logic of the correlation.
When employees are not represented, their ability and power to effect their own working conditions, logically diminish or disappear.
Why do you think the anti-union lobby and their legislative shills are anti-union?
Logic!
You want a cause ? How about the global supply & demand for labor ... simple !
Petey should working people just stop their belly aching and accept that their life is fucked because of globalization?
And please don't suggest that everyone in their late 40's and 50's should go back to school and take up computer or robot repair.
When did I say I had a solution ? I know better than to tell you to stop your "belly aching" since its what you live for ... In any case Mac is simply wrong about unions . They are not the answer for this era ... unless they are started in mainland China .
When did I say I had a solution ?
Very true. You have quirky non-sequiturs.
You don't even know what that means ... Non-sequiters are your specialty !
Non sequitur logic
You don't even know what that means ... Non-sequiters are your specialty !
And some would say that being "quirky" is as well.
Petey needs your help so I think he is glad you showed up.
In any case Mac is simply wrong about unions . They are not the answer for this era ... unless they are started in mainland China .
The answer is to do whatever it takes to maintain consumerism at a level that sustains its 70% component of the American economy. As long as the American worker continues to lose representation in the workplace and outsourcing goes on, the standard of living for middle class America will further decline and the emerging oligarchy will rule … LITERALLY!
Dismissive comments are not viable arguments.
As long as the American worker continues to lose representation in the workplace and outsourcing goes on
Yakety yak . How about addressing the economics that are preventing the reshoring of American labor ? Apparently you are not interested in that ... odd .
Simplistic.
Thanks for the useless quip with no logical value ...
Yakety yak . How about addressing the economics that are preventing the reshoring of American labor ? Apparently you are not interested in that ... odd .
Your usual allusion to expertise via innuendo; I've give cause and effect in logical sequence throughout the thread.
What prevents the restoration of American jobs and labor are legislators in the pockets of "Organized Wealth" … and their zeal-without-knowledge supporters.
Senate GOP kills measure to curb job 'outsourcing'
WASHINGTON – Senate Republicans on Thursday killed a measure backed by President Barack Obama that would encourage companies to bring overseas jobs back to the United States.
I'd start by eliminating all taxes on business including payroll taxes. Until we can compete in a global marketplace we will not boost manufacturing. Look for growth in countries that embrace free market economics.
I'd start by eliminating all taxes on business including payroll taxes. Until we can compete in a global marketplace we will not boost manufacturing. Look for growth in countries that embrace free market economics.
27 giant profitable companies paid no taxes - USA Today
• The way to go re: Payroll Taxes is to lower the rate and broaden the base … no ceiling … everyone pays on all earnings and income; why should the worker who makes $ 50,000/year pay on every dollar while the CEOs who makes millions pay only on roughly $ 105,000/year?
• Since "Corporations are PEOPLE my friend," let them pay into Social Security LIKE ALL OTHER PEOPLE!
Everyone should be able to opt out of SS. Wealthy people don't need big brother to do their saving for them.
Everyone should be able to opt out of SS. Wealthy people don't need big brother to do their saving for them.
Disagree. Wealthy people don't need the SS benefit but they need not-so-wealthy seniors to remain consumers … lest their business interests decline and the become less wealthy.
But, if the wealthy don't need big brother, let the passed-on inheritance be taxed fairly … otherwise the wealthy receive protections not granted the working stiff.
The insulated wealthy get lots of help from BIG BROTHER! They write portions of the Tax Code via lobbyists and campaign contributions, they get to buy elections thanks to CU … don't whine to me about the "disadvantaged wealthy".
Inheritance tax is another that should be eliminated in its entirety. That money has already been taxed. I also believe in the elimination of capital gains tax.
Inheritance tax is another that should be eliminated in its entirety. That money has already been taxed. I also believe in the elimination of capital gains tax.
So that only the middle class pays a fair share? Is that it?
There is a commonly overlooked tax benefit that can seriously help to minimize taxes that might otherwise have been owed when inheriting assets — a step-up in basis.
I assume you are knowledgable and know about stepped-up value, Dean … so I won't go into detail unless you or another member asks. The wealthy benefit from this tax provision because … they or their family happen to be wealthy in the first place.
THE GAME IS RIGGED!
You want a cause ? How about the global supply & demand for labor ... simple !
Simplistic.
Outsourcing to cheap labor markets kills both American middle class jobs and thus the number of workers.
When the jobs go so do the unions … that's where the logic comes in. Those who applaud the demise of American unions consequently applaud the loss of American job to globalization.
PRECISELY the embodiment of the RACE TO THE BOTTOM.
It's destroying the "America" we have known.
The situation in which companies and countries try to compete with each other by cutting wages and living standards for workers, and the production of goods is moved to the place where the wages are lowest and the workers have the fewest rights. [1]
and thus the number of workers.
Not globally . In China they now have a larger middle class [based on raw numbers] than we have in the US
Not globally . In China they now have a larger middle class [based on raw numbers] than we have in the US
What is China's population?
There are 109 million Chinese with wealth of between $50,000 and $500,000. Since 2000, twice as many Chinese as Americans have joined the middle class.
Jobs outsourced to China have diminished American employment opportunities and have helped contribute to wage erosion since 2001, when China entered the World Trade Organization, new research shows.
Between 2001 and 2013, the expanded trade deficit with China cost the U.S. 3.2 million jobs, and three quarters of those jobs were in manufacturing, according to a report released Thursday from the Economic Policy Institute, a left-leaning Washington think tank. Those manufacturing jobs lost accounted for about two-thirds of all jobs lost within the industry over the 2001 to 2013 period.
By increasing the number of jobs and the level of wages … CHINA HAS CREATED A LARGER CONSUMER BASE … AT AMERICA'S EXPENSE!
Scott Paul, president of the Alliance for American Manufacturing, on a call with reporters Thursday said one of the ways to get the economy back on track is to fortify the U.S. middle class.
“Rebuilding the middle class starts with a robust and growing manufacturing base,” says Scott Paul, president of the Alliance for American Manufacturing.
“The key to a robust and growing manufacturing base in the U.S. is to be exporting more (goods), to have a balanced economy between production and consumption and to have reciprocal trade with our major partners including countries like China and Japan.”
We've been sold out by literally and figuratively exporting to other countries, what was America's model. Consumerism represents about 70% of the American economy … and our elected officials have sent it away in exchange for the benefits of a corrupt campaign finance system.
Jobs outsourced to China have diminished American employment opportunities and have helped contribute to wage erosion since 2001, when China entered the World Trade Organization, new research shows.
Between 2001 and 2013, the expanded trade deficit with China cost the U.S. 3.2 million jobs, and three quarters of those jobs were in manufacturing, according to a report released Thursday from the Economic Policy Institute, a left-leaning Washington think tank. Those manufacturing jobs lost accounted for about two-thirds of all jobs lost within the industry over the 2001 to 2013 period.
By increasing the number of jobs and the level of wages … CHINA HAS CREATED A LARGER CONSUMER BASE … AT AMERICA'S EXPENSE!
That's sounds like one of Trump's main talking points.
I'm certainly no fan of the Drumpf-- but on that point I do agree.
The real culprit is people in the US who shop at Walmart ...
I don't like Walmart. The stuff they sell is shitty quality, their selection is just as bad and the food is not cheaper if you figure in the loyalty card discounts at Ralphs or Vons and they don't have a store brand to discount. And their Meat Department is terrible! What herd of horses do they get their burger from? I do go there for glasses though because they have a good selection of frames that Medicare and my HMO will pay for.
Walmart is determining the quality of what many consumers can buy.
I have said it for years that I hold Walmart responsible for the loss of thousands manufacturing jobs in the US. But the US consumer that forever wants less expensive products is also responsible for their own demise.
True. We're not rich and in fact live on a fixed income, but we believe that paying less for garbage is no savings at all.
OK so since you are talking about outsourcing.. today my hubby came home in the middle of the day. The reason? His company outsourced to India all their tech, and since they are on a different time zone, and they don't check the systems over the weekend, there is not a single computer function that is up and running. It's been over 48 hours now and still counting.
Sometimes you get what you pay for.
Sometimes you get what you pay for.
The race to the bottom is on … and there are those who don't want to know, or, who don't understand the phenomenon and consequences, and/or who will vote for legislators that promote the agendas of the corporate interests causing the phenomenon.
Zeal-without-knowledge is a cancer among the electorate as is laziness and one-issue-voting.
Mass production requires mass consumption. As each workforce, corporation, and country lowers wages, then less money is available for consumption and economies become stagnant, leading to recession. "As each country tries to solve its own problems by producing and exporting still more products still more cheaply, the result is a 'downward spiral.'"
Globalization has depressed the real earnings of low-wage workers, which has increased gaps between rich and poor. This gap is increasing worldwide.
Zeal-without-knowledge is a cancer
I agree . For example : zeal for unions without knowledge of basic economics ...
Zeal-without-knowledge is a cancer
I agree . For example : zeal for unions without knowledge of basic economics ...
I have more than explained the connections and benefits to the American economy … you're the one without the direct knowledge and/or willingness to acknowledge when you're handed an inconvenient truth.
Your one-line dismissive comments offer nothing substantive.
Not accepting the laws of supply & demand is far more serious ...
Not accepting the laws of supply & demand is far more serious ...
Demand is seriously diminished when the consumer is paid shit-wages, Petey.
Then supply increases precipitously which kills profits and the resultant jobs which further erodes demand because the poorly-paid worker consumer is not viable enough to support the 70% consumerism that sustains the American economy.
Another manifestation of the Race to the Bottom.
But I'm willing to hear you out; how can diminishing jobs and wages maintain a balance between supply and demand? Don't just throw out terms, explain your premise.
Obsessing about US based unions in an era of globalization makes any abstract discussion a moot point ...
Obsessing about US based unions in an era of globalization makes any abstract discussion a moot point ...
TRANSLATION: Another dismissive comment intended to evade validating anything you posited to this point.
Argument by collective dismissal is an especially severe form of this, in which multiple points are dismissed as a group without any of them being addressed.
Obsessing about past union issues is not an excuse for you to dismiss what's going on . If you could take off your union blinders that would be obvious . This "discussion" is not one . Dealing with your constant dismissals of what I said while you claim I am being dismissive is a transparent attempt at evasiveness .
Bye .
Obsessing about past union issues is not an excuse for you to dismiss what's going on . If you could take off your union blinders that would be obvious . This "discussion" is not one . Dealing with your constant dismissals of what I said while you claim I am being dismissive is a transparent attempt at evasiveness .
Bye .
Petey, stop tossing terms into discussions then running off without explaining how or if those terms make the case you imply you have to make. I don't merely dismiss what you say, I do so by explaining why they either do not apply, or, are applied arbitrarily without placing them in context.
How can the subject of supply and demand be intelligently discussed without mention of the viability of the consumer base?
Supply is product/service generated for the consumer, and demand is solely based on the consumer.
When consumers (a.k.a. "working people) are strapped for discretionary cash, demand is correspondingly weak, supply inflated and or credit default is on the horizon. The worker is the consumer and unions represent that worker/ consumer.
How can the subject of supply and demand be intelligently discussed without mention of the viability of the consumer base?
When are you going to stop avoiding the topic of reshoring US businesses ?
Sometimes you get what you pay for.
Yes you do, but in this case...
YOU GET WHAT YOU VOTE FOR! With that in mind.......
Lemme ask one question......
Does anyone hear that giant sucking sound now? Nope, just the remnants of the gurgling around the drain from an almost empty basin.
Ronald Reagan was dead set against it, George Bush the first wanted to know how we would keep the jobs here before he would sign it, Ross Perot campaigned directly AGAINST it telling everyone what would happen if it was ever signed into law.
NAFTA
Bill Clinton signed it as one of his first acts in office.
Globalism, they were for it before they were against it.
You get what you vote for.
Yes you do, but in this case...
YOU GET WHAT YOU VOTE FOR! With that in mind.......
That's what I said … but we see it somewhat differently.
NAFTA and similar trade agreements are not in the best interests of America … rather … they benefit corporations and low wage countries.
When Clinton was pushing NAFTA, my union and many others were fighting it! Recall the mantra, "NAFTA, do we hafta?"
And let us not forget …
In 1993, for example, the highly controversial North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA) passed the House with far more Republican than Democratic support, despite the energetic advocacy of then-President Bill Clinton. While Democrats voted 102-156 against the agreement, Republicans voted 132-43 in favor. Republican members likewise turned out en masse to support the Dominican Republic-Central America Free Trade Agreement (CAFTA), which gained just 15 Democratic “yes” votes in the House, and, more recently, the Korea-US Free Trade Agreement, which only 21 Republicans opposed .
And Bush I was no friend of the American worker.
NEW WORLD ORDER … a euphemism for … " certain types of organizations, globalists, and people in and out our government that want to destroy our US Sovereignty and get rid of our constitutional rights."
As long as the Citizens United decision stands, if you are a middle class American, in the vernacular …
… you're fucked!
100% percent agreement Brother...
psst: that Libertarian streak is showing it's head again.....
Politics aside, you cannot take a high end economy and run it on slave wages without reducing the cost of goods in said economy. And, when you do thus, you lower the standard of living for those in the economy you are opening up to free trade/globalism. (and yes you raise it in the lower echelon economy that is the beneficiary of such largess)
I'm pretty sure at this point everyone that has tried to get an education and is forced to get work way below his qualifications understands this simple point now.
It will be impossible to turn the clock back.
Look what happened to Japan? What has happened to us is now happening to them as heavy industries in Japan are losing out to heavy industries in Korea and Vietnam. (actually been going on for the last 20+/- years)
A tidal wave knows no national boundary.
A tidal wave knows no national boundary.
INCOMMING!