╌>

(History) Scopes Trial

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  flynavy1  •  10 years ago  •  78 comments

(History) Scopes Trial

The Scopes Trial , formally known as The State of Tennessee v. John Thomas Scopes and commonly referred to as the Scopes Monkey Trial , was an American legal case in 1925 in which a substitute high school teacher, John Scopes , was accused of violating Tennessee's Butler Act , which made it unlawful to teach human evolution in any state-funded school. [1] The trial was deliberately staged to attract publicity to the small town of Dayton, Tennessee , where it was held. Scopes was unsure whether he had ever actually taught evolution, but he purposely incriminated himself so that the case could have a defendant.

 

Scopes was found guilty and fined $100 (equivalent to $1,349 in 2015), but the verdict was overturned on a technicality. The trial served its purpose of drawing intense national publicity, as national reporters flocked to Dayton to cover the big-name lawyers who had agreed to represent each side. William Jennings Bryan , three-time presidential candidate, argued for the prosecution, while Clarence Darrow , the famed defense attorney, spoke for Scopes. The trial publicized the Fundamentalist–Modernist Controversy , which set Modernists , who said evolution was not inconsistent with religion, [2] against Fundamentalists , who said the word of God as revealed in the Bible took priority over all human knowledge. The case was thus seen as both a theological contest and a trial on whether modern science should be taught in schools.

Continue the learning here:  https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scopes_Trial

....Trust me, this is worth the time to read....... FLYNAVY1

 


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  FLYNAVY1    10 years ago

The Scopes Trial from 1925 is as valid today as it was back then.  I would be curious to know how many here on NT know of the Scopes trial.  The proceedings of the trial were brought forth in one of my favorite movies... Inherit the Wind

This trial, and the movie clarify to what lengths the religious right will ignore, deny, obfuscate, and outright fabricate lies against the truth that science brings to light.  Worse yet, that they are willing to ignore others rights to learn the truth to protect their beliefs.  It is this very thinking that makes presidential candidates that say: "....I'm a Christian First, American Second..."  http://christianfighterpilot.com/2016/02/01/i-am-a-christian-first-ted-cruz-and-christian-priorities/ 

beyond dangerous to the future of the United States.

It is this sort of thinking that has to be kept away from our government as we by our constitution are a secular government.  The desire of the religious right to dump a ton of nonsense into the US Constitution is great.

" Fanaticism  and Ignorance is  forever busy  and needs feeding"

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy  replied to  FLYNAVY1   10 years ago

I love "Inherit the Wind" with two double academy award winners, Spencer Tracy and Frederich March. The other actors (Harry Morgan, Gene Kelly, Dick York, etc.) did some of the best acting of their lives to try to keep up with the two giants. Filming it in B/W was an inspiration. A lot of the courtroom dialog was right from the real trial and that made it special. Watching the two of them play off each other was acting magic. Oh and of course Florence Eldridge, who played Frederich March's wife in the film and was his wife in real life.

Scopes lost the trial, but science won the war. And I know what you mean when I hear some say they put their religion or their faith first and America second. They are traitors to America and should never hold public office, let alone the Presidency. We are a secular nation and our "guidance" is the United States Constitution. Not the Catholic bible or the KJV or the Torah or the Koran or any other book based on fairy tales. The Constitution is real and is what guides this country above everything and anything else.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man    10 years ago

Unfortunately Fly, neither side has the right to claim absolute integrity in the Scopes trial.

That is the main problem with Religion vs. Science

The faith that both demand is too much to give and remain rational.

There is validity in both, but when we apply our sense of absolutism to either is when we fool ourselves about being right or intelligent.

Most scientist believe in a Creator, but they don't believe he/she created everything.

Some things happened on their own and we may never know the true answer. But I find it hard to believe that everything happened on it's own.

So I can justify the existence and value of both. It's part of the conundrum of being human.

WE can never lose sight of the fact that we live in this world, and the spiritual world is the one we aspire to.

The problem is some see it the other way around.

 

 

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  FLYNAVY1  replied to  Nowhere Man   10 years ago

While you and I tend to agree on many things NWM, this is one where I have to stand up to the threat of religious fundamentalism creeping further into our government which has lost so much to it already.

You make the statement: The faith that both demand is too much to give and remain rational.

There in lies the problem:  Faith based on non-truths does not make fact.

Like you I do believe that there is room for both.  Religious teaching can help us be better people as we relate to one another if we really embrace their true meanings.   But I will not substitute religious teachings/beliefs for the facts that come from a slide rule, or periodic table.  To do that would be to deny truth, which is all I really care about.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man  replied to  FLYNAVY1   10 years ago

Don't forget one thing, TJ is my personal hero.

The Genius of the Declaration of Independence, given that knowledge I cannot possibly be supportive of religion in government in any way shape or form.

So not surprisingly we agree here also.

But to explain my statement above, I was aiming at the individual, not the state.

Does that make my statement a little bit clearer?

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  FLYNAVY1  replied to  Nowhere Man   10 years ago

 Sure does boss.... Thanks for the clarification.

Why the hell are we able to agree on so many things, when we are suppose to be so far apart?  Temperment?  Willingness to listen?  Both really moderates in thinking?  

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man  replied to  FLYNAVY1   10 years ago

To be honest, I don't know. I can speak to what I do know.

Neither one of us accept the labels others would like to assign to us. We are both introspective, meaning we are aware of self and it is incumbent upon self to hold our own counsel, make our own judgements so to speak.

We both believe in facts over suspicions, truths over opinions, and that everything we do is a choice. Such thinking is axiomatic in our lives.

In our lives we both view ourselves as men of action, but that there is no room for blind action. (which is worse than no action at all) It is important for people like us to understand rather than be understood. And the way to get understanding is to listen first and respond after. Hence neither of us suffer fools well as a fool represents a waste of time, his time, and we don't waste ours and refuse to get drug into his.

We both understand that ideals are more important than dogma and rules are important tools to serve an end but wise enough to know that rules do not work all the time.

And, the ends NEVER justify the means. ie. the outcome I want or believe in is never worth compromising our personal ideals.

These things are the height of personal independence and individuality. We know that we are but a small part of the whole. And without us there is no whole but understand the whole is bigger than us the individual. We choose to be members of the whole and are not forced into compliance.

In the respect above we are free. Free of the external control that the whole places everyone in or likes to think they have everyone in or attempts to force people into.

Freedom is a personal state of mind. (TJ's greatest belief)

Understand one thing my friend, I couldn't give a damn what you label yourself as, you are a friend.

And that is what counts.

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  FLYNAVY1  replied to  Nowhere Man   10 years ago

I'll second the motion...

Let see how many others we can drag kicking and screaming into viable exchanges of ideas and opinions so we can call them friends too....!

Hope you're having a good Monday!

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man  replied to  FLYNAVY1   10 years ago

I'm having a great Monday sir,

And I'll third the motion above (to hell with parliamentary procedures)

As far as the sentiment expressed above goes.... (of which I am more than willing)

"I think we are going to need a bigger boat"

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient  replied to  Nowhere Man   10 years ago

How I LOVE seeing references to classic movies. I use them all the time.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah  replied to  Nowhere Man   10 years ago

"Most scientist believe in a Creator, but they don't believe he/she created everything."

I'm not sure what that is supposed to mean, but my instinct is that it's very much false.  In fact, the statement itself creates a vicious circle of logic.  To be a creator, you must be created.  

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.  replied to  Hal A. Lujah   10 years ago

That is a limited assumption based on our limited understandings . Something might have always been. 

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man  replied to  Perrie Halpern R.A.   10 years ago

Bingo! I knew someone would eventually answer. (with the correct answer first out the gate!)

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna  replied to  Perrie Halpern R.A.   10 years ago

Something might have always been. 

On the Internet, derailing discussions by use of personal attacks (in order to divert attention from the fact that you are losing the argument) has always been! 

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna  replied to  Perrie Halpern R.A.   10 years ago

Something might have always been. 

But that might be unknowable in our lifetime.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna  replied to  Perrie Halpern R.A.   10 years ago

Something might have always been. 

Some people call that thing "God".

(I'm not one of those know it alls who are sure they know whether or not God exists. I guess I'm just not as smart as they are Sad ).

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   JohnRussell  replied to  Hal A. Lujah   10 years ago

This existence, as detectable by human beings, consists of the laws of nature, including those we may not have yet discovered.

What if there is something outside of this existence and this nature, a super-nature not detectable by our understanding and our application of the laws of nature?

This is where God enters the picture, in my opinion.

The existence we know of may have been begun by a force that exists outside of our nature.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man  replied to  JohnRussell   10 years ago

Same answer as Perrie's just expressed from a different POV.  EXCELLENT!

A bingo for you too!

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna  replied to  JohnRussell   10 years ago

The existence we know of may have been begun by a force that exists outside of our nature.

Or perhaps another way to put it is that it exists outside of our current ability to know.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man  replied to  Hal A. Lujah   10 years ago

"I'm not sure what that is supposed to mean, but my instinct is that it's very much false."

Actually Carl Sagan was one scientist that actually made that statement in public. (to a standing ovation at a scientific conference I believe)

There is an order to the universe and everything in it, you study such long enough you begin to understand that everything runs in cycles. Cycles that are very similar to each other and proceed from start, to middle, to end.

Doesn't matter if it is a star a billion light-years away, or a microbe in the caldera of a volcano. The same pattern emerges even if their individual cycles are totally different.

Sagan put his faith into the ideal that somewhere, somehow, something created all this perfect harmony of cycle, Birth, Life and Death in the universe was no accident and then, disguised it very well as randomness. He couldn't prove it, but his gut instinct said it was true so it is what he believed.

Now is that god, no one knows.

But I'm sure for some it is.

I'll go with Carl on this one.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah  replied to  Nowhere Man   10 years ago
So the universe may experience an endless repetition of Big Bang followed by Big Crunch.  I fail to see where a creator fits into all of that.  It's an insideous concept that's been hijacked by millions of people, getting taken to extremes, all the way into your bedroom.  Those two versions of a creator are so wildly different, that they shouldn't even be allowed to be compared to one another. But to believe in one is to lend credence to the other, so all forms of organized religion get to share a little bump from your insistence that there has to be an intelligence that kicked it all off.
 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man  replied to  Hal A. Lujah   10 years ago

Hijacking concepts and twisting them into your own private reality is something that man does very well.

No matter what a persons occupation is. Concepts can be hijacked for profitability also, as long as one can convince others that the concept is fact without actually having to prove it.

And scientists, the last time I checked, is an occupation. And as employees most of them are in academia or government, but all of them are looking for acceptance/acknowledgement in the community in which they practice, which means that some of them will jump the gun so to speak about proof. (meaning conclude without the required proof)

I mean, some scientists operate in a faith based way just like the religionists do. Their god, science that lacks proof.

Religion from the opposite point of view.

".....forms of organized religion get to share a little bump from your insistence that there has to be an intelligence that kicked it all off."

Don't assume what I'm saying, I do not agree with organized religion. and all people that have faith are not of an organized religion.

Stop lumping us together with those that need to be directed in what to believe. And where did I say anything about an intelligence kicking anything off? Much less an insistance?

Please do not put words into my mouth with your inflections of emotion.

If you want to continue the discussion, I'm willing, but the conversation needs to happen without the prejudicial assumptions or I'm outta here..

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah  replied to  Nowhere Man   10 years ago

NM - if you are a deist, or a pantheist, or you lean towards a Spinozan or Einsteinean concept of creation and order in the universe, then I have no argument with you.

I definitely don't lump organized religion in with those who recognize that this existence isn't about a personal relationship with a creator that will ultimate judge your life and determine what's in store for you after you die.  Organized religion is all about controlling adherents to conform to agendas, by pretending to know the unknowable, and preying on the fear that they can generate with said unknowable knowledge.

As far as intelligence kicking off creation, you will have to explain to me how something can be responsible for creation, yet lack intelligence.  I don't see how you can have one without the other, if you're going to insist that the order in the universe has a source.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man  replied to  Hal A. Lujah   10 years ago

What I'm saying Hal is the order of the universe IMPLIES a source, cause no one has any actual proof. There are some who through their faith believe that there is an intelligent source, others through their own faith that are just as certain that there isn't.

THERE IS NO PROOF ONE WAY OR THE OTHER.

We were either created intelligently or we just existed. Both beliefs are faith based because there is no scientific fact that proves either.....

AS far as religion? Religion attempts to explain the explainable at times and that which it can't explain it says believe anyway. It also preaches that only the moral person is a righteous person and teaches the concept of responsible individuality. WHY? Cause left to his own choices, man is an animal and since he is the highest order animal on the planet, he is also the most vicious deadly animal of all.

By choice we rise above that animal instinct. Religion is the path way. Science gives us the tools.

Without either, we would still be living in caves afraid of each other. The fight is about the perversions of organized religion of which I agree with you. but just because we reject others controlling what we believe, doesn't mean we don't believe.

The point being you reject religion and have convinced yourself that is a rejection of faith based anything. But the old adage applies, without specific knowledge all you have left is faith.

No one knows how the universe started, haven't any clue whatsoever, they have theories and speculations based upon observations and known facts. The universe started with the Big Bang, but what caused there to be a Big Bang? What item was Big Banged?

For you to adamantly conclude from provable knowledge that there was a big bang, you have now stated from the scientific facts of explosions that there actually was something out there that was big banged. And something that Big Banged it.

That is faith cause there is no provable fact of either item that the Big Bang implies, that something existed and something did something to it. If Science is known fact and the search for more, And your argument states that implicitly, then faith is an extension of the scientific search for fact.

Religion (rules of faith) then becomes the rules for non-provable facts.

Ergo sum, Science and Religion are inextricably intertwined, without some organization of thought according to the rules, neither can exist in a useful form.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah  replied to  Nowhere Man   10 years ago

"We were either created intelligently or we just existed."

No, we evolved.  There is PLENTY of evidence for that.

"Cause left to his own choices, man is an animal and since he is the highest order animal on the planet, he is also the most vicious deadly animal of all."

Now who's lumping people into categories?  That the broadest brush stroke you can make.  Sure, humans can be vicious and deadly, but we wouldn't have evolved to the point where we could even invent religion, had we not had an innate propensity to work together.  Interestingly enough, religion was a driving force in viciousness once it was created.  Religious wars have been happening since religion was invented.

But the old adage applies, without specific knowledge all you have left is faith.

Why are you conflating religious faith with the instincts that drive the scientific mind?  The two couldn't be further from one another.  In fact, religious faith should have its own name, to keep it from being confused with the perfectly acceptable secular definition of 'faith'.  I have faith that the sun will rise tomorrow.  I have faith that when I roll out of bed in the morning, the floor will be there to support me.  When a scientist expresses faith in a hypothesis, it is because there is some kind of evidence that supports it.  Religious faith is absolute hogwash in comparison.  Religionists get very confused by this false equivalency.  Sometimes they will even use scripture quotes to try and prove the validity of other scripture quotes, in an effort to make the process seem like scientific faith.  The two couldn't be more different.

"No one knows how the universe started, haven't any clue whatsoever, they have theories and speculations based upon observations and known facts."

You just contradicted yourself.  Observations and known facts ARE clues to how the universe started.  The nice thing about scientists is that they live for disproving theories.  They want the answers, but aren't so hung up on the process as to deny future evidence that contradicts older evidence.  The same cannot be said for religion, or even for the single belief that there is an intelligent designer behind the order in the universe.  Either you accept it, or you reject it, but there is no wiggle room at the base of this concept for alternate theory.

"That is faith cause there is no provable fact of either item that the Big Bang implies, that something existed and something did something to it."

Yes, it is the secular version of faith, which is backed up with an enormous amount of empirical evidence gathered here on earth, as well as the seemingly infinite well of observations in the sky.  To try and relate this to religious faith is silly.  The universe is billions of years old, and mankind has been around for roughly 200,000 years.  To say that the evolution of building blocks of matter turning into tangible matter was precipitated for the express purpose of humans evolving billions of years later is beyond self serving and egotistical.

"Ergo sum, Science and Religion are inextricably intertwined, without some organization of thought according to the rules, neither can exist in a useful form"

I couldn't disagree more.

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man  replied to  Hal A. Lujah   10 years ago

Everything you have stated here agrees with the precept I laid out, the difference being semantics. Semantics is the difference in how we choose to believe, or in this case better stated, the difference in how we choose to describe how we believe.....

And as is commonly known semantical arguments go nowhere, they are just arguments.

But the one thing we have established is faith, standing alone, is not religious in and of itself.

And we both have some.

Good discussion, as far as it went. And I'll still agree with Carl. (And, TJ, Max Planck, Albert, Robert Oppenheimer and the various other great scientists that thought the same)

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy  replied to  Hal A. Lujah   10 years ago

So the universe may experience an endless repetition of Big Bang followed by Big Crunch.  I fail to see where a creator fits into all of that.

I agree. I fail to see where anything close to what could be called intelligent creation fits anywhere in science. I disagree with Perrie that it's possible to correlate science with any of the major religions or faith. There is simply no way to shoehorn Genesis into any science class. If some people want to practice a religion or hold a faith of their own, that's fine as long as there no attempt to force it on me or to insert it into the United States Constitution. People are free to believe in any faith they choose, as long as they don't try to put it in public school or as part of what America is all about. I am an American first and foremost and above anything else. As for "faith" I know there is no god, so the only way anything resembling religion or faith enters my life is a constant effort to keep it out of public doctrine and out of the public school system in anything but philosophy class and certainly out of any science class.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient  replied to  Randy   10 years ago

Try to think of the Old Testament as being allegorical only, not literal. I can think of the 7 days as consisting of billions of years. I can think of Noah's Ark as being a spaceship bringing Man and animal life to this planet from one that was doomed (as in the Supeman story). If taking the bible as being literal is important for persons who do not have the capacity to question it, let them live with it so long as they don't try to impose their beliefs upon others.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy  replied to  Buzz of the Orient   10 years ago

Which is what the movie and the trail were all about of course. The state trying to force teachers to teach only a literal interpretation of Genesis as the only creation of Earth and humans on the Earth.

I have tried to interpret Genesis as allegorical and that days were billions of years and such, but I still can't understand that, if that's what they believed then why not write it as having taken billions of years? To me, even to the illiterate of the day, that would be just as believable as the Adam and Eve story, especially considering that it would cover up the huge number of holes in the Adam and Eve story. Adam and Eve meant that they either had a daughter too or Cain and Abel reproduced with their own mother. A big no-no. But the bible says that after Cain killed Able he went and dwelt in the land of Nod and met his wife there. But where did she come from? And what happened to the first Adam and Eve? There are two stories of the creation of Adam and Eve in Genesis but that's never explained and it's never explained where the first Adam and Eve went? Also God created light and divided it from darkness on the first day and the Sun and Moon on the fourth day. Why create them twice? alternatively what was the source of the light the first 3 days? I mean putting it in the terms of billions of years would have taken care of all of that.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient  replied to  Randy   10 years ago

I am not at all concerned that totally free thinkers interpret the bible in whichever way they wish or simply consider it fiction. I have no argument with how others feel, save for those who take the bible or the Q'oran or the Torah so literally that they use it as a weapon or a justification to cause discomfort or pain or death upon others. Let the fundamentalists live in their self-imposed blindness so long as they don't try to impose their beliefs upon others.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   Randy  replied to  Buzz of the Orient   10 years ago

Amen Happy

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah  replied to  Buzz of the Orient   10 years ago

"Try to think of the Old Testament as being allegorical only, not literal."

And what say you about a loving God that extinguished virtually all life on earth?  That includes human, animal, plant, bird, fish, microbial, etc. - all because of a temper tantrum. What is the acceptable allegory for the one thing that is worse than anything else that could ever happen to the planet as a whole?

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient  replied to  Hal A. Lujah   10 years ago

If that is not a hypothetical, then please identify the catastrophe to which you are alluding. After all, even God him/her/itself could well be allegorical as well.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah  replied to  Buzz of the Orient   10 years ago

The great flood.  Ever heard of it?  It's in the book.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient  replied to  Hal A. Lujah   10 years ago

Yes, I heard of the Great Flood. Perhaps you should be more careful with what you write - when you said it destroyed virtually all life on Earth, since Noah and his family and pairs of all the animals, etc. were not destroyed, according to the story, I assumed you meant some other catastrophe or a hypothetical.

IMO there could still be the greatest catastrophe yet to come - all life on Earth being destroyed by an atomic war. Think of the movie "On the Beach".

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah  replied to  Buzz of the Orient   10 years ago

I was careful in what I said, since I said it extinguished 'virtually' all life on earth.  But if you were to express it as a percentage of life that was spared, it would be just about as close to zero as you can humanly describe.  It would make the odds of winning the power ball and mega millions in the same week seem quite plausible by comparison.

Now tell me how such incomprehensible and purposeful devastation could possibly have a silver lining through allegory.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient  replied to  Hal A. Lujah   10 years ago

My apology, you're right. "virtually" means ALMOST everything - I always thought it was an absolute.

Anyway, who said anything about a silver lining? As I said, the worst is yet to come. I fully believe that all life will be VIRTUALLY extingished because of a proliferation of atomic weapons, in particular to certain people who believe that suicide martyrdom is the path to paradise.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah  replied to  Buzz of the Orient   10 years ago
A silver lining implies that something good came out of the heinous act of murdering 'virtually' the entire earth.  If there's allegory involved, then it certainly must be for the purposes of expressing something good about the Great Flood - otherwise it would be nothing more than the most horrific crime against humanity in human history.  So again I ask, what could possibly be good about murdering every innocent person on earth just to punish the behavior of a few malcontents?  And this wasn't a simple case of painless euthanasia, this is like throwing a mother and her newborn into deep water and watching them succumb to a terrifying death - times a million.  It is absolutely horrific, and there can be no way to make that act comport with the concept of a loving god.
 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient  replied to  Hal A. Lujah   10 years ago

Hal, I don't have an answer for you. I really don't give a shit about explaining or justifying what I wrote. It's not an issue that matters to me. I never said anything about silver linings - YOU did. You're welcome to your opinion but I'm just too tired to joust about it - it's 10 p.m. here and I'm going to sleep. You'll have to find someone else to challenge.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna  replied to  Nowhere Man   10 years ago

my instinct

And that is completely different than "science" (which many in the west absolutely worship  I bow to you ).

Some people use these terms to differentiate between the two modes:

-"Left Brain" (scientific, using analysis and "reason" to arrive at conclusions, the predominant modality in the West)

as opposed to

-"Right Brain" (the ineffable [ def 1 ]), using synthesis and instinct/intuition to arrive at conclusions, predominant in the East & in the west & by "mystics".. as well as other highly creative people!!! )

 

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    10 years ago

I took your advice, Fly, and read the whole Wiki article about the trial. I must say that I learned much from it I did not previously know, having only had knowledge of the trial from watching the movie "Inherit the Wind". It was a great movie, nowithstanding. Every time I think about it, the song "Give Me That Old Time Religion" runs through my mind.

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  FLYNAVY1  replied to  Buzz of the Orient   10 years ago

Good read isn't Buzz....  You are/were a lawyer were you not?

The movie was special too.  With a movie with so many quotes, it's hared to pick, but I liked this one:  

    “Don't have any opinions. They're bad for business.”

 

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient  replied to  FLYNAVY1   10 years ago

Another movie that deals with this issue is "Contact", being a screenplay based on Carl Sagan's book of the same name. Three views are indicated: Rob Lowe is the fundamentalist, Jodi Foster the scientist, and Matthew McCoughnahy comprehending that there can be two views (although leaning towards fundamentalism).

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.  replied to  Buzz of the Orient   10 years ago

Buzz, 

Loved the book, and loved the movie. I love the interaction between what seems like opposing views. 

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    10 years ago

As a science teacher who often taught children of faith in the public school system, this was a common challenge to me and my students. It ended up being the basis of my master's thesis. What I proposed was showing children of faith, that they need not give up their faith, to believe in science. I didn't challenge the bible, but showed them that it actually followed evolution. Now this was a long time ago, and now my thesis would be almost called "Intelligent design", although I would argue not exactly. But for those of deep faith, you will never, nor should you try to take that away from them, yet you must keep their minds open enough that they can accept the possibility of science. 

Then came one year, when the teachers who were religious, took out a petition to stop me from teaching evolution (yes, this was a public school and yes, it is part of NYS curriculum). A mass hearing was held by the teachers and the parents they had gotten to sign on. My principle was of course in attendance and gave me his full support. I heard their grievances and asked them if they would give me the due fairness of hearing what I taught their children. They agreed and I proceeded to give a lesson. By the end, I had won most of them over. 

Often, what we don't understand scares us. I think that science does that the most. I mean who can discuss string theory without Brian Greene?

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man  replied to  Perrie Halpern R.A.   10 years ago

Very much so sweets. Most science is considered to be above people, but unfortunately it is people that make that decision for themselves.

No faith ever overrules a fact.

And science deals with facts.

Where science gets into trouble is with theory, old scientific theories are sometimes quoted as science fact, and most do not have the education to understand the difference and some just don't care. (which is doubly troubling when it is purported trained scientists that don't care)

Science has rules that must be followed. and too many are ignoring that part for their own benefits I feel.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober  replied to  Nowhere Man   10 years ago

And science deals with facts.

Science does but do scientists ?

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man  replied to  Petey Coober   10 years ago

Not taking the bait. Sorry.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober  replied to  Nowhere Man   10 years ago

Thanks for chickening out . Your opinions are without merit if you are unable to back them up . Not sorry ...

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man  replied to  Petey Coober   10 years ago

To you.

I prefer to express my opinions with people who may value them or at least have cogent ability to argue a different POV.

You don't have such ability and to mask it you constantly change the debate parameters so there can never be a conclusion ie. argument for arguments sake.

If someone is going to be flagellating me, I prefer it in a manner in which I can enjoy it. And you just don't cut it in that area of ability.

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober  replied to  Nowhere Man   10 years ago

You don't have such ability

Your main comment motivation is repeatedly about my lack of abilities . Guess what . You don't know me well enough to base such an opinion on anything . You are boringly repetitive this way . I am not motivated to give you enjoyment . And you are still too chickenshit  to give real arguments to prove your point . Yawn ...

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man  replied to  Petey Coober   10 years ago

{chuckle}

Just what I though, No contest.

Way too easy.

You have a good evening.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna  replied to  Nowhere Man   10 years ago

But hey-- what would a discussion here be like without people attempting to derail the discussion by reverting to a nasty personal attack or two?

Heck-- without them it would no longer feel like the Newstalkers we've all come to know and love! Party

 

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna  replied to  Nowhere Man   10 years ago

And science deals with facts.

Unlike religion, Science is true. I bow to you

They deal with actual facts which are always true (well, until those facts are debunked each time Science discovers new "facts" that debunk their previous "facts").

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  FLYNAVY1  replied to  Krishna   10 years ago

Even if science, in its efforts to learn the truth gets it wrong from time to time, it is still willing to reject that which is found to be wrong in it's search of the truth.

Religion can't make that statement. 

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna  replied to  FLYNAVY1   10 years ago

it is still willing to reject that which is found to be wrong in it's search of the truth.

Sometimes ...

But often scientists (I bow to you ) are not the godlike figures we tend to make them out to be. Why? Because many Scientists  I bow to you  themselves oftimes worship "false gods"-- specifically, the $$$ grants they need to pursue their research. 

In fact, there's an insidious type of "political correctness" that exists within many academic/research institutions-- if your research isn't aimed  at "proving" the point that those with the money want, you may find yourself lacking the necessary funds to continue.  (Remember all the research in the past that was conducted that scientifically  I bow to you  proved that there were no health risks associated with smoking cigarettes. That was only possible by huge monetary grants from . . . guess who?)

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  FLYNAVY1  replied to  Krishna   10 years ago

Please... I'm talking true science, not corporate, for profit science like pharmaceuticals.

High energy physics at CERN, or Fermilab.  Space exploration like the Hubble space telescope, and the International Space Station.  Toss in the mapping of the human genome for good measure.

Answer me this Krish.  Have there been any advances in religion that have benefited people in the last 100 years as much as biological research into unlocking DNA?   

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah  replied to  FLYNAVY1   10 years ago

The last 'advancement' of religion was when Kim Davis was authorized to remove her name as County Clerk from marriage licenses in Kentucky.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient  replied to  Perrie Halpern R.A.   10 years ago

Okay, I admit. I've never heard of the "string theory" or Brian Greene, and I loved science - in what you would term second year university (at that time Ontario had a grade 13 which was the equivalent of a Freshman university year.) I took four 3-hour lab sciences: Botany, Zoology (now, I think, combined into a subject called Biology), Chemistry and Physics. We did semi-micro qualitative analysis in the Chemistry course.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna  replied to  Buzz of the Orient   10 years ago

 We did semi-micro qualitative analysis in the Chemistry course.

Me too!

In high school I was a real "nerd"-- plaid flannel shirts with horrendous plaid ties that clashed with the shirt-- pocket protectors-- the whole nine yards!

Oh,  and I was never seen without that leather case hanging from my belt . . . for my slide rule! (never leave home without it).

When I started college (undergrad) I was a highly motivated Chem major. But naive as I was back then, I had enough smarts to realize what total horsesh*t having to take semi-micro qualitative analysis was. It was just like having to take History courses where you had to memorize meaningless sets of facts (such as all the Kings of England & the dates of their rule). Without ever looking into the actual significance of all those facts.

 

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient  replied to  Krishna   10 years ago

Really? Ours was a lab course.  We were given a solution or solid substance in a test tube and had to determine what it was by adding substances, heating it over a flame, putting it in a centrifuge, etc. It was actual experiments.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna  replied to  Buzz of the Orient   10 years ago

I've never heard of the "string theory"

A theory which some individuals are apparently trying to squash.  Laugh

256

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.  replied to  Buzz of the Orient   10 years ago

HI Buzz,

String Theory otherwise known as the Theory of Everything is the unifying theory between Einstein's physics which was macro and contemporary physics , which is mirco. Brian Greene, is one of the leading physicists of today, and did a series of shows for PBS, called "The Elegant Universe", to explain string theory to the masses.

I found it for you on Chinese youtube. Here it is:

http://v.youku.com/v_show/id_XNDMxMzQxMjA=.html?from=s1.8-1-1.2 

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   JohnRussell  replied to  Perrie Halpern R.A.   10 years ago

There is no doubt whatsoever that our religions as human beings developed as cultural expressions. There was a time when Judaism , Christianity, Buddhism, Hinduism, Islam, Shinto, and in earlier times Greek and Roman and African religions were more or less confined to geographically defined areas. These beliefs did not arise concurrently around the world, they developed within specific cultures. The same for religious beliefs of the western hemisphere peoples.

Almost all groups of people dispersed throughout the world have a creation myth, what Christians and Jews call Genesis. Great flood myths also developed in far flung places that had never been exposed to the Bible.

All proof that religion stems from culture.

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna  replied to  JohnRussell   10 years ago

All proof that religion stems from culture.

By its very nature religious beliefs cannot be "proven". And they are not meant to be! They must be taken on faith.

That is a notion that doesn't sit well with a lot of us in the West . because our society is so ego-involved & judgemental-- we tend to be so predominantly "Left-brained" . 

Which is also why in the west we tend to be so arrogantly condescending, self-righteous and judgemental. Especially about other people's belief systems (whether they be religious, scientific, or political belief systems).

But in the East it tends to be more "right-brain". (That's more about using intuition and less about self-righteously using  analysis and ego-- might less self-righteousness and judgementalness).

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  FLYNAVY1  replied to  Perrie Halpern R.A.   10 years ago

You're not going to like my comments very much Perrie, but they will be honest ones, and very tempered.  I have to be careful because I don't know the age group that you were teaching to.  You you well know my thoughts on the education investment.

I'm sure you did quite a bit of soul searching on how to teach science, but the science classroom is just that.  Bible class is just that.  Throughout their lives people will have what they believe, challenged by facts.  A failure to teach that facts take a backseat to beliefs early in a child's development can't be good as they grow into adults.  I would suspect that a number of our NT members are of the mind that facts are expendable when in conflict with their beliefs.  

One of the most important things to learn about any and all sciences is that we have to have the mental dexterity to take in as many pieces of data, and fit them into the picture properly to achieve clarity.  This means that when something doesn't look right in picture, you examine the detail of what isn't fitting, adjust how it fits, or discard it for that which fits better.   As such, faith and belief are poor diagnostic tools when searching for the truth.  I feel that they are an excuse for intellectual laziness.  

For the record, I was raised, and confirmed in the Episcopal Church.  At the age of about 12-13 I started to question what the church was teaching me.  By 17-18, I found that with the exception of "Just be nice", what religion was teaching was detrimental to humanity. 

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna  replied to  FLYNAVY1   10 years ago

You're not going to like my comments very much Perrie

That's quite an interesting assumption on your part, eh?*

______________________________________

*Although Unicorns are actually not found in Canada, sometimes we like to pretend that we are, eh?

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  FLYNAVY1  replied to  Krishna   10 years ago

That's quite an interesting assumption on your part, eh?*

It would be an honest assumption given the topic of all the work and thought that she put into her masters thesis.  She should be proud of that work.  Based upon her brief reference to her topic though, I feel that my thoughts would be in opposition to her position.

I like Perrie quite a bit, even so, both of us have managed to bruise each other a bit over the years based upon our discussions. 

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna  replied to  FLYNAVY1   10 years ago

 I would suspect that a number of our NT members are of the mind that facts are expendable when in conflict with their beliefs.  

I would even go a step further & say that most peoples' beliefs are not based on the so-called "facts". Actually, most peoples "facts" are actually shaped by their beliefs. 

 

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna  replied to  Krishna   10 years ago

I would even go a step further & say that most peoples' beliefs are not based on the so-called "facts". Actually, most peoples "facts" are actually  shaped by their beliefs.  

As well as which Internet sites they frequent to find out their "facts". (or TV stations). 

So, assuming like most westerners you try not to be ruled by silly superstitions like faith & religion-- or any beliefs . Rather, you are committed to finding the actual facts. So you want to be "objective"-- you want to be SCIENTIFIC (I bow to you )  in pursuit of the REAL TRUTH. 

So, naturally, you turn to Fox News to get the real facts. Someone else would turn to MSBC to get the real facts. And then one of you has the REAL FACTS! And the other guy is just plain wrong.

Then one of you is not only wrong, but BAD AND WRONG!

 So then who has the REAL FACTS? Being totally objective here, which one of you is "right" & which one is wrong"?

And more importantly, rather than taking it on FAITH-- & wanting to be totally rational and SCIENTIFIC I bow to you  of course . . .    HOW DO YOU KNOW???

 
 
 
FLYNAVY1
Professor Quiet
link   seeder  FLYNAVY1  replied to  Krishna   10 years ago

In dealing with the "he said...she said of politics, or biased reporting" you have to check multiple sources.  Then you have to check the data if they tout statistics, again multiple sources and the statistical method used.

But in this article we are talking about factual evolution up against faith based religion in the Scopes Trial.  Evolution is the way of life on this planet, and it is a science supported by the other sciences and mathematics.  What does religion support itself with?  Under what decimal point is Cain's wife described?   

 
 
 
Nowhere Man
Junior Participates
link   Nowhere Man  replied to  FLYNAVY1   10 years ago

Everyone has faith that what they choose to believe is fact is actually fact.

There is plenty of science that lends credence to the Theory of Evolution, but alas, until they find that direct evolutionary link, it is and will forever remain a theory.

Those that claim that Evolution is proven fact are assuming on the basis of weight of evidence without absolute proof.

Now I'm not denying evolution as an educated, logical person I can't see where such assumption isn't valid on it's face. But that being said the level of absolutism given that assumption by some belies it's true nature.

And is a weakness of some.

If science is as absolute as some make it out to be, then by the rule of their own absolutism they CANNOT claim that Evolution is proven fact.

They don't have the facts to back up that assertion.

And that is the truth of the matter. So why do some people exert their beliefs so absolutely? They have faith that the answer, proof mind you, that the theory will be proven true will eventually arrive.

And it would be nicer for it to happen sooner rather than later. But alas, we have no control of such so all we can go on is our faith that it WILL happen.

Doesn't matter what you believe, Faith and Science are inextricably interlinked..

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna  replied to  Nowhere Man   10 years ago

Everyone has faith that what they choose to believe is fact is actually fact.

Yes! 

That was exactly the point I was trying to make-- but you said it better than me (Or, "better than I" if you're into speaking correctly)-- something that my not be very pc on the Internut)/ 

IMO there are basically two POVs

1. People who believe in religion. The more enlightened ones know that what they believe is based on faith and not actually a proveable fact-- so they are the more honest of these two types.

2. People who believe that what they know to be true is based on fact (they believe it is "scientific" rather than be based merely on "faith" or "superstition").  IMO these people are not being honest with themselves. because in reality the "truth" is actually unknowabe. So thinking that they know THE TRUTH is not being honest with themselves. 

All truth, even that that is "scientifically proven" is not necessarily true-- in reality its just another belief these folks have-- but they feel the need to be right, so they justify their delusions by being "scientific".

__________________________________________________________________________________

Scientifically proven "facts" are no more true than those based in faith.

Because if they were truth, those "facts" wouldn't constantly change everytime some scientist does an experiment that "proves" the old facts are wrong. The actual nature of the Universe doesn't change everytime some scientist proves the old fact to be wrong and concocts new ones.

Certain things are unknowable (IMO everything actually-- but that's too big a stretch to discuss now). So the only valid choice we have is to either admit that what we know is actually based on faith (belief)-- or pretend that it isn't. Because we mere mortals believe we actually know the truth. (A rather arrogant position if you think about it).

(Only God knows the real truth-- and she ain't tellin'!)

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna  replied to  Nowhere Man   10 years ago

 So why do some people exert their beliefs so absolutely? They have faith that the answer, proof mind you, that the theory will be proven true will eventually arrive.

And perhaps there's another reason as well. In most schools we are taught that humans have several biologically based needs:  food,  shelter, sex, etc. But IMNSHO they don't mention another one-- the need to be right. (I believe that that  is biologically based BTW-- it developed over the course of evolution).

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna  replied to  Krishna   10 years ago

And perhaps there's another reason as well. In most schools we are taught that humans have several biologically based needs:  food,  shelter, sex, etc. But IMNSHO they don't mention another one--  the need to be right.

Here's one example of that:

256

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

(Source: xkcd/386 -" Duty Calls " )

 
 
 
Petey Coober
Freshman Silent
link   Petey Coober  replied to  FLYNAVY1   10 years ago

Evolution is the way of life on this planet

There are many who don't understand the implications and the timeline involved in evolution . Frankly I would agree more with the statement : Evolution is the way of death on this planet ...

 
 
 
Krishna
Professor Guide
link   Krishna  replied to  Perrie Halpern R.A.   10 years ago

I do not see any conflict betwen religion and evolution. But of course it depends how you interret both those belief systems. Obviously even people in the same religion interpret those teachings differently-- and despite their denials, often different scientists do as well. 

The devil can cite Scripture for his purpose.

--William Shakespeare

That just refers to someone interpreting scripture for evil ends. But of course people can use it to support any agenda, or even just because they perceive it differently from someone else.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah  replied to  Krishna   10 years ago

Maybe you can answer my question then.  What allegorical value does the Biblical account of the Great Flood have?  Considering how many distant, organized civilizations there were throughly the world, that had nothing to do with Christianity, this supposed action of God is more heinous than any other crime against humanity in human history.  What message are we to draw from this story?

 
 

Who is online






92 visitors