Why We Don't Have More Responsible Muslims.
Only Hard Choices for Parents Whose Children Flirt With Terror
By MATT APUZZO APRIL 9, 2016
“My God, I just destroyed Adam,” thought Sal Shafi after the F.B.I., with whom he had collaborated, arrested his son last year.CreditGabrielle Lurie for The New York Times
FREMONT, Calif. — The banging on the door jolted Sal Shafi awake. F.B.I. agents were looking for his son. “Where’s Adam?” they yelled. “Where’s Adam?”
Terrified, Mr. Shafi led the agents, guns drawn, up the stairs toward his son’s bedroom. He watched as they led his 22-year-old son away in handcuffs, backed by evidence of Adam Shafi’s terrorist ambitions.
He had come to the attention of officials not by a well-placed informant or a sting operation. His father, concerned and looking for help, had simply picked up the phone and led the government right to his son. For months, over the objections of his lawyer, Mr. Shafi had been talking to the F.B.I., believing he was doing the right thing.
“My God,” he thought, soon after the arrest in July. “I just destroyed Adam.”
Had things been different, Mr. Shafi, 62, a Silicon Valley executive, might have become a much-needed spokesman for the Obama administration’s counterradicalization campaign. Who better to talk to other parents about the seductive pull of terror organizations? Trust the government, he would tell them. They do not want to take away your children.
Despite nascent efforts to steer young people away from terrorism, the government’s strategy remains largely built on persuading people to call the F.B.I. when they first suspect a problem.
“Alert law enforcement,” Attorney General Loretta E. Lynch said in December. “It could simply be your neighbor having a bad day. But better be safe than sorry.
The bedroom of Adam Shafi, now 23, in his family’s home in Fremont, Calif., where F.B.I. agent’s took him into custody last year. CreditGabrielle Lurie for The New York Times
For parents, particularly those who see their children as misguided but not dangerous, the decision to make that call can be agonizing. Do you risk sending your son to prison? Or hope things improve and he does not hurt anyone?
The Justice Department praised Mr. Shafi’s efforts to save his son, but said in court that his son was living a “terrifying” double life. Prosecutors said Adam Shafi was “such an unpredictable threat” that he was too dangerous to be anywhere but a jail cell. Mr. Shafi and others, though, say the case shows that there were never any alternatives.
“This is an abject failure, that there is no system in place that doesn’t result in spending 20 years in jail,” said Seamus Hughes, a former National Counterterrorism Center official who once helped implement the Obama administration’s strategy for countering violent extremism.
The Justice Department’s campaign against American supporters of the Islamic State is rife with examples of family members acting out of desperation. Mothers have hidden passports and money to keep their sons from traveling. In Minnesota, a fight broke out as relatives tried to keep a young man from flying out of the country. In Texas, a family lured a 19-year-old home from Turkey by tricking him into thinking his mother had fallen ill.
Mr. Shafi chose a different route. He did what the government asked. His story is a desperate search for someone to help his son.
A Frantic Call
The Shafis were vacationing in Cairo in the summer of 2014, visiting extended family, when they awoke on a Saturday to find Adam gone. He sent a text message to a younger brother, saying he had left “to protect Muslims.”
Mr. Shafi has never been deeply religious — “don’t do bad things,” is how he describes his faith — but his son had embraced religion. Outwardly at least, that meant charity. He made sandwiches and delivered them to San Francisco’s homeless. He talked about opening a free health clinic. Perhaps, Mr. Shafi thought, Adam, who was 21 at the time, was at a mosque working on a social cause.
But when he did not come home, Mr. Shafi became frantic. A protective father of five, he had installed tracking software on his children’s phones. But it did not work overseas. On Sunday, he called the American Embassy in Cairo. An official there was polite but dismissive and told him to wait another day.
“Maybe he’s been recruited,” Mr. Shafi said. That grabbed the man’s attention.
Mr. Shafi now says he was merely trying to prod the embassy into helping his son. But he acknowledged that, at the time, he was also thinking about the parents on the news who discovered that their children had fled to join the Islamic State.
Mr. Shafi, with his son Adam in a photo on the phone of Mr. Shafi’s wife. When he spoke with the authorities, Mr. Shafi had proposed an intervention to set Adam straight.CreditGabrielle Lurie for The New York Times
At the embassy later that day, Mr. Shafi told officials that he worried that his son might be following extreme imams online, according to court documents. His son, he said, had been “grieving about what is happening to Muslims” abroad. “Maybe he is in Syria? Iraq? Gaza?” Mr. Shafi said.
It turned out that Adam Shafi was in Turkey, a common gateway for foreign fighters to Syria. Not long after the embassy meeting, he texted his family that he was on his way back. He told his family he had gone to witness the plight of refugees there.
“Why didn’t you let us know?” Mr. Shafi demanded. He remembers his son’s response. “He said, ‘You wouldn’t have let me go.’ Which is true. You say you’re going to visit refugees by yourself? No.
Back home in California, Mr. Shafi’s lawyer ordered him not to talk to the F.B.I. But when two agents arrived at the house a few weeks later, Mr. Shafi invited them in.
“We don’t have criminal minds,” Mr. Shafi said later. “Maybe I’m naïve. I’ve never dealt with the authorities before. I wanted to cooperate.” He arranged for the agents to interview Adam at a coffee shop.
In conversations over many months, court documents show, Mr. Shafi told the agents that he worried about his son’s depression and said he had encouraged counseling. Sometimes, when the television showed people suffering in war-torn Syria, his son would leave the room and cry, Mr. Shafi said.
“This is an abject failure,
that there is no system in
place that doesn’t result in
spending 20 years in jail.”
SEAMUS HUGHES, FORMER NATIONAL COUNTERTERRORISM CENTER OFFICIAL
With his son under F.B.I. investigation and facing few options, Mr. Shafi arranged for him to visit a suspected terror financier, Armin Harcevic, in a nearby jail. Mr. Shafi told the F.B.I. that he hoped it would help him “see the error in his ways or at least the grave consequences,” according to court documents.
Once, Mr. Shafi said, the agents mentioned the Boston Marathon bombing and said they believed his son had been radicalized. Mr. Shafi laughed. “I don’t think so,” he told them. “I can assure you that Adam is not violent.”
The F.B.I. had good reason to doubt those assurances — agents had been secretly eavesdropping on Adam Shafi’s phone conversations.
“I just hope Allah doesn’t take my soul until I have at least, like, a couple gallons of blood that I’ve spilled for him,” he said in one conversation last June, according to court records. He also mused about killing American soldiers.
In another call, he said the Islamic State killed too indiscriminately, but he admired the Nusra Front, which is linked to Al Qaeda. Nusra, like the United States, is fighting both the Islamic State and the Syrian government of President Bashar al-Assad. But it is a designated terrorist group, and supporting it is illegal. “I am completely fine dying with these guys,” he said, according to court documents.
Then, on June 30, 2015, Mr. Shafi’s phone-tracking software alerted him that his son was at the San Francisco airport, at a gate for Turkish Airlines, trying to go to Turkey again.
A whiteboard in the room of Adam Shafi, with Scripture written from the Quran and a note from his younger sister. CreditGabrielle Lurie for The New York Times
Sent Home From Turkey
Mr. Shafi scrambled to contact overseas relatives to intercept his son in Istanbul, but F.B.I. and Homeland Security agents had met him at the gate and were interviewing him at the airport. He told them that he no longer wanted to live in the United States and that he wanted to help the refugees in Turkey.
“Adam claimed that some people helped by building a house, while others picked up a gun,” Christopher Monika, an F.B.I. agent, wrote in court documents. Adam Shafi told the F.B.I. he was not going to pick up a gun. Eventually, the agents sent him home.
But days later, the F.B.I. went to the Shafi home with a warrant for attempting to support a terrorist organization — a charge that carried up to 20 years in prison — and led Adam Shafi away in handcuffs. His case was kept under seal while his family and his lawyers tried to negotiate a way out. Normally, that means a plea deal and a hope for leniency. Mr. Shafi pitched something else — a program in which counselors, mental health experts and religious leaders worked with Adam to set him straight. If all went well, Mr. Shafi hoped, his son could avoid prison and a criminal record.
Though the White House and a congressional task force have endorsed this concept, no such program exists. So Mr. Shafi tried to create one. He flew to Washington in November to attend a Brookings Institution seminar on radicalization. There he met Daniel Koehler , a German de-radicalization expert who offered to help.
“There have simply been too many cases of families who didn’t have any help,” Mr. Koehler said in an interview. “I thought back then that this could be a good test case.”
The F.B.I. has quietly and slowly embraced the notion of interventions. In a few cities, agents work with parents, mental health experts, community leaders and sometimes religious figures to help minors or mentally ill people who agents believe have the intent, but not the capability, to hurt people. Though civil libertarians — and some F.B.I. agents — are skeptical of what they see as blurring the line between social work and law enforcement, supporters say interventions are an alternative to long-term surveillance, which strains F.B.I. resources.
Law enforcement officials said they have offered interventions to only about a dozen people, and they acknowledge that it is too soon to say whether they work.
At 22, Adam Shafi was not eligible for such an intervention, but his father and lawyers remained optimistic. The government did not dismiss the idea out of hand, they said. Then came the attacks in Paris and San Bernardino, Calif. “You see these events that narrow the universe of what’s possible,” said Joshua Dratel, a New York lawyer representing Adam Shafi. There would be no deal.
“Every minute, I just
imagine him in that
solitary confinement,
facing 20 years, because I
cooperated with the government.”
SAL SHAFI
In December, the Justice Department unsealed the case and prepared for trial. In court documents, prosecutors said that neither a well-intentioned father nor the threat of an F.B.I. investigation were enough to steer Adam Shafi away from terrorism. Mr. Shafi’s efforts aside, prosecutors said, his son was simply too dangerous to remain free.
The process has shaken Mr. Shafi’s faith, both in his decisions as a parent and in his government.
“Every minute, I just imagine him in that solitary confinement, facing 20 years, because I cooperated with the government,” he said, adding, “It’s a horrible feeling. I can’t get rid of it.”
Less than a year ago, he had offered to quit his job and help build support for government counterterrorism programs. His message now to parents of troubled or confused children? “Don’t even think about going to the government.”
Tags
Who is online
92 visitors

I often have read people complaining where are the responsible moderate muslims when it comes to terrorism... well here might be a clue.
Hi Hal,
Here is a link to the article:
I just checked about the formating issue and I can see what you are talking about and I will put in a ticket about that. My other functions are working fine. Check your email.
Test post
I can edit this postAnd I just voted up
This is a case of damn if you do and damned if you don't. This dad tried to do the right thing, and ended up having his son go to prison. This will not encourage parents and family members to go to the authorities. There has to be some way to deal with this situation better than this, like a deprogramming center.
If the dad can't have a discussion about the issues the son is concerned about the battle is already lost . The kid was already "hip" to the father's position and wanted no part of it .
The discussion needs to happen B4 the kid gets radicalized ...
Of course Muslim families are going to have to have family discussions about radicalization, but even when a child seems radicalized, (most parents know what their 18+ year old kid is doing), so there needs to be a middle ground if we want family members to help prevent these kids before it's too late. Yes, the kid needs to be arrested, but 20 years? Who is going to turn in their kid with that being the possible outcome. They might try to handle it themselves unsuccessfully.
Best way to save your kids from becoming hate-filled religionists, is to not have a religious household.
Broken record.
The fact remains - this and countless other tragedies will not happen under my roof, because they can't.
Just noticed that Petey gave JR's comment a thumbs up for referring to me as a broken record, when I'm commenting on an article about Islam that doesn't even mention Christianity. I didn't even mention Christianity myself. I'm glad that Petey finally agrees that I am a broken record when it comes to negative comments on religions other than Christianity.
I think he's changed his mind since then, LOL!
You are a broken record Hal . If you could see yourself the way others do you would agree ...
The difference here Petey is that Hal is right on this point. The truth is, and always will be the truth. The choice to not accept the truth isn't Hal's problem.
To quote A Mac on this : "simplistic" .
Great article; we need more of these type of "real" accounts as they help us learn what is going on in the heads and hearts of families like Mr. Shafi's.
So which is worse....
20 years in jail; or, causing harm, terror, death, and even one's own death, for the sake of religion?
So which is worse....20 years in jail; or, causing harm, terror, death, and even one's own death, for the sake of religion?
Let's say your son is threatening to commit suicide by cutting his own throat. You rush outside to get a cop to help prevent it. The cop comes in, sees your son with the knife and immediately shoots him in the head because he's not trained to deal with suicidal people armed with knives. The cop says "thank you for bringing this to my attention and helping to reduce suicides in our community." Which is worse . . . death by suicide or death by gunshot when, either way, you couldn't save your son and you were actually the one who brought the cop in to shoot him?
The Government failed this man and his family. This is something you'd expect from a 3rd world country. How horrifying. I don't know that I can blame this man for encouraging others not to make the same mistake he did by trusting is government.
Very true PJ.....
Our system is not broken down into shades of grey on this matter, but simply black and white. There will be no funding for "halfway houses" for deprogramming. In America, we fund prisons. Our protective entities like the FBI, or the police have no middle ground, only safe or sorry.
I don't even know if it can be moderated. Given the fear being installed in to the American people by press and politicians, I don't think it's possible.
Very true PJ.....
Our system is not broken down into shades of grey on this matter, but simply black and white. There will be no funding for "halfway houses" for deprogramming. In America, we fund prisons. Our protective entities like the FBI, or the police have no middle ground, only safe or sorry.
I don't even know if it can be moderated. Given the fear being installed in to the American people by press and politicians, I don't think it's possible. Doesn't mean that we shouldn't try, but be ready for a long slog.
Generally speaking, I don't think the father's initial co-operation with the FBI should necessarily get the young man off the criminal hook and into a "deprogramming" program.
On the other hand, this does not look like the case of someone who was anxious to kill Americans.
I would think a couple years in prison with "de-programming " taking place behind prison walls might be the way to go.
The young man lied to the FBI when they asked him why he was going to Turkey, and admitted such in a secretly wire tapped conversation. That is at least some consciousness of guilt.
Here is the story from last Dec. in the San Francisco Chronicle.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
http://www.sfchronicle.com/news/article/East-Bay-man-indicted-for-trying-to-join-Syrian-6705641.php?
(I enlarged the one paragraph)
"A Fremont man who told friends that America was his enemy and that he was “content to die” for an al Qaeda-linked group in Syria has been charged with attempting to provide material support to a terrorist organization, federal prosecutors said Thursday.
Adam Shafi, 22, was arrested July 3, four days after federal agents stopped him from boarding a flight to Turkey, and has been in jail since then, prosecutors said. He pleaded not guilty to the terrorism charge Thursday in federal court in San Francisco and is scheduled for a hearing Tuesday on the government’s request to hold him without bail.
In court papers unsealed Thursday, an FBI agent said Shafi told a friend in a wiretapped phone call in June, 2½ weeks before his arrest, “I just hope Allah doesn’t take my soul until I have at least, like, a couple gallons of blood that I’ve spilled for him.”
Shafi is charged with attempting to provide material support or resources to al-Nusra Front, a hard-line Sunni Islamic faction aligned with al Qaeda that is fighting the Islamic State in Syria and is designated by the federal authorities as a global terrorist entity.
In a statement Thursday afternoon, his lawyer declared Shafi innocent.
Lawyer: ‘No evidence’
“There is no evidence that he was planning to do anything but fly to Istanbul, which is where he had been the year before for two days where he attempted to help the refugees and returned home,” said Joshua Dratel, a veteran criminal defense attorney. “There is no statement by him that he was intending to go to Syria or join any designated terrorist group. ... His intentions were never criminal nor violent.”
Shafi was stopped at San Francisco International Airport on June 30, while trying to board a flight to Istanbul, a common entry point into Syria for foreign fighters hoping to join terrorist organizations such as al-Nusra Front and the Islamic State, officials said.
Against gay marriage
Questioned by federal agents, Shafi said he no longer wanted to live in the United States because of its politics and direction — citing the recent Supreme Court decision legalizing same-sex marriage — and preferred to live in a nation of like-minded fellow Muslims, FBI agent Christopher Monika said in a court affidavit. But he said Shafi denied intending to join a terrorist organization and said he wanted to help Syrian refugees.
Later that evening, in a secretly recorded phone call, Shafi said he had lied to the agent, Monika reported. “What kind of idiot would say yes” when asked if he planned to join a militant group, Shafi told another person, believed to be one of his relatives. “Yes, that is exactly why I was going.”
Asked about that conversation Thursday, Dratel, Shafi’s lawyer, said the remarks were taken out of context. He said Shafi’s frame of mind could be understood better from another recorded conversation later the same evening, in which he told another friend that the agent had asked whether he intended to join a terrorist organization.
Remarks misconstrued
“Even if I was going to do that, what the hell?” Shafi replied, according to the lawyer in an interview. He meant that no would-be terrorist would ever admit his intentions to the FBI, Dratel said.
In his statement, Dratel said Shali’s case “represents a perfect opportunity for the government to make good on its professed commitment to finding another way, other than criminal prosecution, to address instances of young Muslims being motivated by the humanitarian crisis in Syria to act in some way to alleviate that suffering. That is what motivated Adam Shafi.”
Shafi’s family lives in a large two-story house on a street corner of a residential subdivision in Fremont. Several cars were parked there Thursday, including a white Toyota Prius registered to Shafi. An unidentified man who answered the phone there referred all questions to Dratel.
“They just seem like they’re a good, quiet, traditional Muslim family,” with parents in traditional Muslim attire and six or seven children, said Rakesh Sharma, who lives down the street and is president of the local homeowners’ association. He said the family had lived there for at least 20 years. “Just learning the news is a surprise and a shock.”
Shafi graduated in 2011 from Mission San Jose High School, a high-achieving campus in an upscale area of Fremont, said Principal Zack Larsen. His father, Sal Shafi, is president and chief executive officer at ESG Consulting in Santa Clara, an international computer consulting firm that does extensive charity work providing technical training to underprivileged people.
Monika said the government first became aware of Adam Shafi in August 2014, when he disappeared during a family trip to Cairo. Sometime thereafter, officials began following his movements and monitoring his phone calls.
America the enemy
A few weeks before he was stopped at the airport, in a June 5 call to another friend, Shafi said he considered America to be the enemy, Monika said. He also drew a distinction between al-Nusra Front and the Islamic State, or ISIS, which he considered too bloodthirsty, the agent reported. Monika quoted Shafi as saying that ISIS blew up markets and had beheaded an al-Nusra leader, while al-Nusra fought only those religious groups that fought al-Nusra.
“I am completely fine dying with these guys,” Shafi said in the recorded call.
Disappeared in Cairo
After his disappearance in Cairo, Shafi’s father and another relative contacted the U.S. Embassy, and the relative relayed a text message in which Shafi said he had gone to “protect Muslims,” Monika said. He said Shafi’s father was concerned that his son may have been following “some extreme imams online,” in the agent’s words.
Shafi returned to his family the next day, Monika said. He said a friend of Shafi, described by the friend’s brother as a possible terrorist recruit, told the FBI later that he and Shafi had traveled to Turkey but decided to return because Shafi “wasn’t feeling it.”
He is among hundreds of Americans whom the U.S. government has accused of joining or financially supporting terrorist organizations since the attacks of Sept. 11, 2001. They include John Walker Lindh, a Marin County man captured in Afghanistan in November 2001 after joining Taliban rebels. Facing a potential life sentence on terrorism charges, Lindh pleaded guilty to aiding the Taliban in 2002 and received a 20-year sentence.
If convicted, Shafi faces a maximum sentence of 20 years in prison and a fine of $250,000.
Al-Nusra, the organization he allegedly was attempting to join, is an al Qaeda affiliate dedicated to overthrowing the Syrian government and establishing an Islamic state in the country. It has also fought the Islamic State, which has declared its own religious caliphate in the region. The U.S. government classified al-Nusra, Arabic for “the support,” as a terrorist organization in December 2012."
San Francisco Chronicle staff writers Kevin Fagan and Peter Fimrite contributed to this report
John,
The father went to the FBI for help. I am sure he didn't think his son would end up in jail for chatter. No actual crime was done. All the FBI had to do was step in. The family seems that they would be more than willing to work with them.
Actions like this, will discourage families with out of control children from asking for their help. In this case, the Feds were on to him, but I am sure there are hundreds more just like this young man that they do not know about and the families could be the first line of defense, if they don't think that they are damning their kids as criminals. They are looking for hard core intervention, not hard time.
So we can't be indignant when Muslims have a fear of our government and are not forthcoming with information. Kind of case and point.
I don't entirely disagree with you, but there was a crime committed according to the US Dept. Of Justice. I understand that the crime occurred after a year of the young man being monitored. But that year was also the opportunity for the family to do their own intervention.
According to the stories, the government doesn't have deprogramming alternatives to the criminal justice system. Maybe they should, but the father knew they didn't and still "allowed" the young man to continue his immersion in jihadist beliefs.
Yes, he was 22 years old and beyond his parents control to a large extent. But if the father was so sure his son was down a bad path, why didn't he act unilaterally without waiting for mercy from law enforcement.
For parents, particularly those who see their children as misguided but not dangerous, the decision to make that call can be agonizing. Do you risk sending your son to prison? Or hope things improve and he does not hurt anyone?
The Justice Department praised Mr. Shafi’s efforts to save his son, but said in court that his son was living a “terrifying” double life. Prosecutors said Adam Shafi was “such an unpredictable threat” that he was too dangerous to be anywhere but a jail cell. Mr. Shafi and others, though, say the case shows that there were never any alternatives.
“This is an abject failure, that there is no system in place that doesn’t result in spending 20 years in jail,” said Seamus Hughes, a former National Counterterrorism Center official who once helped implement the Obama administration’s strategy for countering violent extremism.
The Justice Department’s campaign against American supporters of the Islamic State is rife with examples of family members acting out of desperation. Mothers have hidden passports and money to keep their sons from traveling. In Minnesota, a fight broke out as relatives tried to keep a young man from flying out of the country. In Texas, a family lured a 19-year-old home from Turkey by tricking him into thinking his mother had fallen ill.
Mr. Shafi chose a different route. He did what the government asked. His story is a desperate search for someone to help his son.
His story is a desperate search for someone to help his son.
Maybe I'll start up a business to provide waterboarding services to children in similar circumstances . That might help ...
I'm sure you will need proper training and instruction on waterboarding. Send me an address, and I will be more than happy to provide an interactive class for you to participate in for minimal charge. You can then decide if this is the right startup business for you......
I should do that . I don't want to get results that are "all wet" ...
Good, I've been told that you need to experience it first hand to truly understand the benefits of it...
I was never waterboarded because I was never part of a flight crew that might get captured. I did make through USAF Winter Survivors school. That was real fun. It was voluntary and I liked to volunteer for stuff. I don't think I'd volunteer to be waterboarded though. I don't know how to swim and have a fear of drowning.
The survival part of SERE school was fun Randy. I had a country boy from Georgia that I helped through the academic part of aircrew school, and he helped me with the Boy Scout part. The POW side though, while some of the most useful training I received, way anything but fun by design.
By all means......Afterwards you all go out for beers and laugh about it Petey. /s
Two or three days later after you have found your brain.
Canada and Canadian Imams take the lead in dealing with the problem.