What's the difference between anti-Semitism and anti-Zionism?
The UK Labour Party has been at the centre of a row over anti-Semitism, including its relationship to anti-Zionism. What do these terms actually mean?
- Anti-Semitism is "hostility and prejudice directed against Jewish people" (OED).
- Zionism refers to the movement to create a Jewish state in the Middle East, corresponding to the historic land of Israel - anti-Zionism opposes that.
- But some say "Zionist" can be used as a coded attack on Jews, while others say the Israeli government and its supporters are deliberately confusing anti-Zionism with anti-Semitism to avoid criticism.
Former London Mayor Ken Livingstone was suspended from Labour following a series of remarks about Israel, including the suggestion that Hitler supported Zionism before the Holocaust.
It follows the suspension of Bradford West MP Naz Shah after it emerged she had once suggested, among other things, that Israel should be moved to the United States. The new president of the National Union of Students, Malia Bouattia, has also been heavily criticised for remarks she made about Zionists.
Many in the Jewish community say the use of "Zionist" as a term of abuse reflects a rising tide of bigotry and racism directed at Jews.
The Labour peer Lord Levy told the BBC's Newsnight: "There can be criticism of the state of Israel, but anti-Semitism - using the word 'Zionist' as another form of anti-Semitism - frankly can no longer be tolerated."
Others - including Livingstone - argue anti-Zionism is not the same as anti-Semitism, and that it's wrong to mix up anti-Jewish prejudice with legitimate disagreement with the actions of the Israeli state.
However, critics of anti-Zionists point out that sometimes particularly harsh criticism of Israel goes further than disagreement with policies, but rather denies the right of the Jewish state to exist.
Speaking on The Daily Politics, the former London Mayor said: "Don't confuse anti-Semitism with criticism of the Israeli government policy and treatment of the Palestinians."
It's a debate around which emotions run high. It's also obviously true that being a Zionist and being Jewish are not the same thing.
There are Zionist critics of Israeli government policies, such as the occupation of the West Bank, the route of the separation barrier (which Israel is building in and around the West Bank and which it says is for security against Palestinian attackers, though Palestinian supporters see it as a device to grab land) and the building of settlements.
Equally, there was Jewish opposition to the Zionist movement, which sought to establish a Jewish homeland, long before the state of Israel was declared in 1948. Today fringe ultra-Orthodox groups such as Neturei Karta oppose the state of Israel because they believe the true Jewish state will only be established with the coming of the Messiah.
Likewise, some make the point that Zionism is a political project supported by plenty of non-Jews, including Western governments and many US evangelical Christians.
But it's been widely argued that the term "Zionist" has, in some circles, become a code word for "Jew" and that bigotry against Jewish people has been expressed using the language of anti-Zionism.
What is Zionism?
- Political movement which emerged in 19th Century Europe aimed at countering anti-Semitism, and establishing a Jewish homeland
- In the Hebrew Bible the word "Zion" refers to Jerusalem, hence the movement's identification with the city and the land that surrounds it
- Balfour Declaration of 1917 gave British support to the establishment of a Jewish national home in Palestine
- Chaim Weizmann, the president of the Zionist Organisation, was elected the first president of Israel in 1949
Khadim Hussain, a former Lord Mayor of Bradford, was suspended from Labour after he shared a Facebook post that referred to "the six million Zionists that were killed by Hitler". Alex Chalmers, a former co-chair of Oxford University Labour Club, said some members regularly used the word "zio" - despite it being regarded as an ethnic slur.
Bouattia was attacked after it emerged that in 2011, she co-wrote a blog for a Friends of Palestine campaign group saying that "the University of Birmingham is something of a Zionist outpost in British Higher Education". She has also attacked "Zionist-led media outlets" - which critics said reflects anti-Semitic myths about Jewish conspiracies to control the media.
On the other hand, it's regularly claimed that accusations of anti-Semitism are deployed to silence criticism of the Israeli government or to further other political ends.
Pia Feig, of Manchester Jews for Justice for Palestinians, told BBC Radio 2's Jeremy Vine programme that "anti-Semitism has been used to quieten down and suppress my concern and the concern of other people for Palestinians".
In a statement after Livingstone's suspension, the Jewish Socialists' Group said accusations of anti-Semitism were being "weaponised" to attack the leadership of Jeremy Corbyn.
On the other hand, supporters of Israel ask why it's the Jewish state that is so widely singled out for criticism and not Iran, Russia, China or any other state attacked for their human rights record.
Baroness Julia Neuberger told the BBC's Jeremy Vine show that anti-Zionism implies "Jews have no right to self-determination, unlike other people". Mark Wallace, writing for Conservative Home , said in practice it would mean either allowing Israel to be wiped out by its enemies or "denying millions of Israeli Jews their home and deporting them".
Some anti-Zionists say Zionism itself is a racist ideology, because of how, in their view, the Palestinian people have been treated by the Israeli state. The Palestine Solidarity Campaign says it opposes all racism, including anti-Jewish prejudice and the "the apartheid and Zionist nature of the Israeli state" - although the PSC has itself been accused of racism for its anti-Zionist stance.
Bouattia said she rejected claims of prejudice, adding that "for me to take issue with Zionist politics is not me taking issue with being Jewish" and that "Zionist politics are held by people from a variety of different faiths, as are anti-Zionist politics".
Accusations of anti-Semitism continue to dog Labour. Vicki Kirby was forced to stand down as a parliamentary candidate after tweeting that Hitler was a "Zionist God". She was re-instated and then suspended again. Gerry Downing, who was expelled from the party, described "Zionist politicians within the ruling classes of America and Europe".
Livingstone was accused of "rewriting history" over his remarks about Hitler supporting Zionism by Labour MP John Mann, chair of the All-Party Parliamentary Group against Anti-Semitism.
Few would deny there are anti-Semites who call themselves anti-Zionists, or that it's possible to criticise Israel without being a racist or a bigot. But agreement on how exactly the two relate appears elusive.
http://www.bbc.com/news/magazine-36160928

The Labour peer Lord Levy told the BBC's Newsnight: "There can be criticism of the state of Israel, but anti-Semitism - using the word 'Zionist' as another form of anti-Semitism - frankly can no longer be tolerated."
Others - including Livingstone - argue anti-Zionism is not the same as anti-Semitism, and that it's wrong to mix up anti-Jewish prejudice with legitimate disagreement with the actions of the Israeli state.
Pia Feig, of Manchester Jews for Justice for Palestinians, told BBC Radio 2's Jeremy Vine programme that "anti-Semitism has been used to quieten down and suppress my concern and the concern of other people for Palestinians".
In a statement after Livingstone's suspension, the Jewish Socialists' Group said accusations of anti-Semitism were being "weaponised" to attack the leadership of Jeremy Corbyn.
I too think that there can be legitimate criticism of the Israeli government, without be anti-Semitic. I also think that some people, Jews and others, have "weaponized" anti-Semitism and that some people, Jews and others, often conflate being critical of the current Israeli government and it's polices and in fact being very, very, very strongly opposed to them, with a form of anti-Semitism and use that term far too freely to try to suppress criticism of Israel. To them to be against anything the Israeli government does is to be an anti-Semite, when that is simply not true.
Being strongly in favor of justice for Palestinians, being strongly in favor of the two state solution and being strongly opposed to Israeli settlements on the West Bank is legitimate criticism of a foreign government's actions and not a condemnation of a religion or the people who practice it and live it.
First I would like to address something that crept into the lexicon that is part of the issue here. Zionism, is nothing more than the belief that there should be a state of Israel. Somehow, it became a dirty word. There are loads of Israelis who are of course Zionist but don't agree with their government. That is no different than an American not liking their own government.
Then there is the blending of the word, Zionist, with words that have negative connotation, like Zionism=Nazism, or when David Gillmore flies a giant pig with the star of David on it. The message is meant to be negative and to create antisemitic feelings.
That all being said, one can speak out against the government of Israel and not be an antisemite. I too believe in a two state solution and I am no antisemite.
That all being said, one can speak out against the government of Israel and not be an antisemite.
Unfortunately there are many examples right here on NT and in the real world where any criticism of the actions on the part of the government of Israel instantly earn you the title of antisemite. I find it to be pretty much an autonomic response from quite a few. Human nature I guess.
I have talked to Buzz about this and I have said that, quite honestly if I had been in the UN in 1948 I would have voted against establishing a Jewish state where it was, simply because I think it would be impossible not to see all of the wars and fighting and violence to come and I wish that it could have been avoided and that it can be stopped. That said the State of Israel does exist and is an ally of the United States. I don't agree with the actions of the current government of the State of Israel by building more and more and more settlements in the occupied territories because I think they are in the way of the only chance for a peaceful settlement between Israel and the Palestinians, a two state solution. A genuinely free Palestine that I believe can, through negotiations, co-exist peacefully with Israel and I honestly don't believe that the Likud party running Israel want that. I believe they want to keep the occupied territories as part of the state of Israel and eventually even name it Israel also.
There simply is no other way to stop the fighting then a two state solution and I certainly am not an anti-Semite either for supporting it.
And what has Buzz said?
And what Buzz said that he agreed that I'm not an anti-Semite. However my feeling on the Israeli government did lead to an exchange that turned unpleasant, to say the least.
confirmed.
I don't know but if you can't eat lobster I'm against it.
Damn it all I LOVE lobster, but now I can't eat it because all seafood raises my uric acid level over the roof and causes gout (which is a pain I don't recommend to anyone). Goodbye shrimp, goodbye oysters, goodbye escargot, goodbye calamari...
How about moderate levels of shellfish Buzz, with a healthy dose of citric acids like lemon juice or lime juice to counter the purines? Any help?
Anti-semitism and anti-zionism are not the same at all, but there is an aspect (hostility toward Jews) where they overlap. One can be anti-semitic without referencing or even thinking about Israel. Anti-semitism in everyday life in, for example, the US, has little or nothing to do with Israel.
Zionism in the end connotes ownership of land based on religion. "God gave this land to me" is the lyric from the theme song to "Exodus" which depicts the return of the Jews to Israel after WW2. Obviously there are those who dispute the idea of God at all, let alone a God that assigns land to groups.
As for Hitler being a zionist. In the most cynical sense he probably was. If he wanted to shoot the Jews into outer space, some people would call it his desire for interplanetary exploration.
Did America not grab land from others who had been occupying and caring for it long term? Americans barely even acknowledge that anymore. Why is there not a word for that?
Why is there not a word for that?
Because English came from Europe. The same part of the world that determined that the indigenous peoples of the Americas were sub-human thus they didn't want to see them as anything other than vermin to be exterminated. I guess denial might come close if genocide doesn't fit.
There simply is no other way to stop the fighting then a two state solution and I certainly am not an anti-Semite either for supporting it.
I believe in a 3 state solution . Obviously 2 states will never happen ...
I believe in the two state solution myself: the state of ecstasy and the state of euphoria.