Pocohantas , Meh
Donald Trump evidently believes that calling Elizabeth Warren "Pocohantas" , as an insult, is the best way to discredit her attacks on and criticism of him. Trump is, intentionally or not, claiming that was some sort of egregious dishonesty for Warren to have believed family lore as she was growing up in a working class family in Oklahoma. Elizabeth Warren says that she was told as a child that there was Cherokee and Delaware Indian heritage in the family, the Herring clan from Oklahoma City. Warren seems to have 'claimed' at various points in her life that she is 1/32 American Indian.
This became a "thing" during the 2012 senatorial campaign in Massachusetts when the Republican candidate, Scott Brown, accused Warren of "dishonesty" for mentioning her Indian heritage in her autobiography. For some reason Brown thinks such an 'unsubstantiated' claim should disqualify Warren from political office. It is unsubstantiated because Warren can produce no paperwork showing she is Indian, and no names of Indians in her lineage which can be checked against tribal records. In other words, on paper Elizabeth Warren is not an American Indian, not even 1/32.
What I am wondering is why anyone thinks this matters in some important way. Here is a passage from a 2012 article in the Atlantic
" Many more Americans believe they have Native ancestry than actually do (we always suspected this, but can now confirm it through genetic testing)," said Smolenyak in an email. " In fact, in terms of wide-spread ancestral myths, this is one of the top two (the other being those who think their names were changed at Ellis Island). And someone who hails from Oklahoma would be even more prone to accept a tale of Native heritage than most."
She added: "There's also a tendency to accept what our relatives (especially our elders) tell us."
As for Warren, "I can't confirm or refute Cherokee heritage without extensive research," she said. "All I can say is that Ms. Warren's scenario is a wildly common one -- minus the public scrutiny, of course."
When I was a kid I would occasionally hear someone in the extended family talk about the "Indian" heritage in our family tree. As best I can remember now, I think they were talking about 1/32 or 1/64. One of dad's ancestors was supposed to have been an Indian from a tribe in Iowa. It wasn't brought up a lot, but occasionally at a family gathering with the aunts and uncles from that side of my family. I personally never gave it much thought because, while I believed it ( as a kid would do for family lore) I never felt that such a small percentage of my ethnic makeup really merited a lot of thought.
But some people do think it is worth mentioning (" Many more Americans believe they have Native ancestry than actually do ), and evidently Elizabeth Warren is one of them. How can I put this ? Get over it. According to the Atlantic story, and other reporting, Warren never used her claim to Indian heritage as a lever when applying for a job, nor was ever given consideration for a position based on it. The person who hired her at Harvard specifically said that when Warren was considered for a position there the subject of her Native American heritage never came up. Warren did list herself as a minority in a couple professional registries, but there is no record of this having any real world meaning.
So what is up with all this "Pocohantas" nonsense from Donald Trump, except as more evidence that he is an idiot? To call her "Pocohantas" is to assert that her claiming Indian heritage is the defining aspect of her professional and political career. Such an assertion is lame and ridiculous.
Trump is trying, as he always tries, to throw the discussion off kilter. Warren has him pegged as a narcissistic money grubber, so he feels he has to peg her as something, and 'Pocahontas' is, pitifully, the best he could come up with.

There seemingly are millions of people who mistakenly feel they have American Indian ancestry, perhaps more than actually do. This may be interesting from a sociological perspective, but politically, such wishful thinking is not a big deal.
IMO the issue here is Trumps use of the name and how he means it. I would assume that it is meant as some sort of an insult. Which would probably be true since he has a history of insulting Indians.
The true story of Pocahantas is quite different then what is passed off as a true story. And it's not pretty.
His problem with Warren is that she kicks his ass, and as a women doing the kicking, the big baby can't handle it.
I think that Warren should start calling him ''chimook''....and explain to the block head what it means.
IMO the issue here is Trumps use of the name and how he means it. I would assume that it is meant as some sort of an insult. Which would probably be true since he has a history of insulting Indians.
My God man, Trump is Trump. Of course it was an insult and it may not have been polite, but it was warranted in respect to her claim of being an Indian when not one tribe has even given the slightest indication of her being a member of their tribe.
With Trump, what you see is what you get. He isn't selective in his insulting. He has an expressway straight from his mind to his mouth. Sometimes I have that and other times some, but not all have it, but Trump has it all the time.
Comparing Trump to Hillary, with Trump you get what you see, but with Hillary you don't get what you see, that's the scary part for some of us. I would have to vote Trump over Hillary any day of the week, because I can see right through Hillary and I know what and who she is..
Warren is bullet proof. Oh wait ... here comes BF to make a baseless claim that she's a shill for the banking industry - lol. Without ever offering an iota of evidence, of course.
AS a shameless liar who lied about her heritage to exploit affirmative action policies she fits right in with Hiillary.
She's the Senate's own Rachel Dolezal.
Various conservatives allege that Warren used her Indian "identity" to try and advance her legal career. The problem is there really isn't any evidence of that.
For anyone to call her an egregious liar while at the same time they try and defend Donald Trump over any or all of his pathological and continuous lying is a hoot.
Yep. She made up some fake diversity crap and tried to cash in. She eventually got caught.
And you know this for a fact, right? Could it be you denigrate her because she has beat your butt in the working world? Could it be you have a jealousy streak against successful women? Could it be you hate anyone who isn't for "Grump"? Or, could it be that you couldn't think of a good response that it felt good throwing out trash - and then clicking "like" to show how much you think of your comments????
We know it because she got caught.
Exactly.
She got "caught" doing what??????? Show us, some factual information/stats, where she was awarded her job based on her ethnicity. Quit being a rabbit and hopping around - provide some PROOF that she used her claim of heritage to get the advancement.
Nope, I'm happy with my success, which is more valuable and more difficult. I am offended by her use of a fake heritage to get an unfair advantage. Are you angry with me because I'm white?
I don't care what your ethnicity is and that is the issue here. No one should care what her ethnicity is. They should worry/care 'bout her accomplishments - that's what she'd be graded on during her job performances.
That is what is so aggravating 'bout folks today. None of my Native American friends staple their CDIB (Certified Degree of Indian Blood)(Federal requirement) card on their forehead to "prove" that they are "Indians of blood". All of us prefer to be as our elders/mothers have taught us to be - take care of others as you would have them take care of you and never judge a man/woman until you've walked a mile in their moccasins.
Can any on NT say/share how they, themselves, take care of others?? Walk in other's moccasins?? Really kinda doubt it 'cause if they did, they wouldn't be on a gossip blog (myself included).
As a 1/16th Cherokee, I can make no claim to any tribe, nor would I try to "cash in". My family left in the 1820s, and there is no record of them being anywhere-- especially on the Dawson roles, which was taken long after... I have no proof. But why would the kids have teased my grandfather as being a "squaw boy", if everyone hadn't believed he had Native American heritage?
Back in the 1980s, it was very possible to harken back to a lone Cherokee ancestor to claim the heritage for business purposes. If one was a Native American owned business, one had a better chance at government contracts. Many companies did this for business purposes-- I didn't. I didn't feel that I had enough in me to do so... My Grandpa never did, and he was 1/4th... I didn't feel right about it.
Now it has come back to bite her in the tail, when, years ago, it was usual business practice. I feel sure that if she hadn't done a good job, they wouldn't have kept her on in that position. And perhaps they realized that, although the rules for claiming to be Native American have tightened up-- perhaps there is some truth to the matter.
I don't claim to be Native American-- I was reared as a white person. But I certainly respect the Native American heritage and truly treasure the few things I have that were my great-great grandmother's...
Now it has come back to bite her in the tail, when, years ago, it was usual business practice. I feel sure that if she hadn't done a good job, they wouldn't have kept her on in that position.
Dowser, please refer me to a job or position that Elizabeth Warren got because she was American Indian.
Wish I could, but I can't... I'm responding to the calumny that she did.
Even when there is no substantiation that it occurred???
It speaks to her lack of honesty. I don't care if she's an Indian or not.
You don't care, then why push the discussion?
I do care if she's a liar.
What politician isn't? Name one. Just one.
ALL of them "spin" their actions... For that matter, all of us pretty much "spin" our actions, too.
I cannot. That doesn't decrease the need to call them out. Pretending to have special status to secure jobs or tenure is not right.
Read John's insert - she DIDN'T use her heritage to obtain privilege.
Why continue to push the button when you have no substantiation?
What did she lie about - her hair color? Her shoe size? Her dress size? The fact that she slams the banking industries?
Claiming to "believe" you have ethnicity doesn't make you a liar. Using that claim to advance is abuse. If a person, in fact, has no claim to that ethnicity - that is a falsehood and a lie. Can you prove she has no claim to that ethnical heritage? No, you don't. You just believe the media - wrong - wrong - wrong.
Once again, I have no burden to prove her claims are false. She has a burden to claim they are true if she used them to secure employment, tenure, or advancement.
This is what google yielded.
Wonderful link! That is exactly what happened in my family!
As a child, one asks one's grandparents about their grandparents, and what they were like... Or at least I did. The Native American heritage has always been fascinating to me, and I treasure the few family heirlooms that were once hers. I also weep for her life, that was cut short by pneumonia at age 36. That doesn't mean that she wasn't alive and had children, because she did.
Speaking of high cheekbones, my dear Grandpa had high cheekbones, and a nose that could only be described as a HONKER. It was so large and noble, that he had to lean his head back to get water out of a glass. Fine man, by the way. Integrity-- when I think of Grandpa, I think of integrity. And he was reared by the daughter of a Cherokee. Who was a wonderful woman. Strong, too. I've inherited all her cast iron cookware, and let me tell you-- anybody that can cook with that stuff had their buns of steel... I swear that cast iron kettle weighs 30 pounds!
Allow me, please, to repeat myself. In the 1980s, it was much easier to acquire the Native American status than it is now. I could certainly have done it, and I know of many people who were also 1/16th that did it. I never did, because I didn't feel right about it. They have tightened up the requirements since then, and I, personally, think that is a good thing.
Did she use her ethnicity to acquire a job or tenure? It doesn't appear to be so. So what's the beef?
Accomplishments - accomplishments - that's what she's known for.
Note - "Noting that Brown had also questioned Elena Kagan's qualifications to serve on the Supreme Court, Warren wondered: "What is it he thinks it takes for a woman to be qualified?"
"I've worked hard for everything that I have done," Warren said Wednesday. "I am a hardworking teacher. I have won teaching awards. I have written books that have won acclaim. I have gotten out there and done everything I know to do as a law professor."'
No one can question her ability to get the job done based on her ability to do the job. Ethnicity has NOTHING to do with her accomplishments.
Did Warren get the Harvard Law job because she claimed to be Native American?
We don’t know, neither she nor Harvard Law have released her hiring file. But that’s not really the pertinent question. What we do know is that she tried to benefit from the claim, so at minimum there was an attempt to exploit that false claim.
Exactly. She tried to use the claim but we cannot know whether it influenced the decision or not.
Please explain - HOW did she "try" to benefit from her claim???
She made the claim part of her resume, increasing her chances for advancement in hysterically pro-diversity and affirmative action climate.
She made up some fake diversity crap and tried to cash in.
What do you mean by 'cash in'? One doesn't 'cash in' by claiming 1/32 % Native American blood. I don't know of anyone who 'cashes in' by claiming 100%. It's her belief that her family heritage includes at least one NA contribution, and she is proud enough to talk about it. What's it to you?
She manufactured a special status that effectively disadvantaged others.
HOW did it disadvantage others????
Seriously? If you have an artificial advantage in a competitive situation, you have disadvantaged your competitors.
OK - you're gonna keep on coming back that she "took" advantage of her "claim" over others. You, and others, have all been given documentation/substantiation from the school, the interviewing/hiring managers and co-workers that she didn't use her "claim" to gain an advantage over others. Obviously the facts are eluding you or you are totally ignoring them to use the ol' "she did it too" rebuttal - without proof.
Impasse - you evidently don't want to see it as it is, only as you want it to be.
Elizabeth Warren listed herself as white for most of her years of teaching. During the 1990's Harvard was being criticized for its lack of diversity. You know "Whites need not apply". Her hiring records have not been released, but she was listed as "Minority" not "Native Indian" in the directory as everyone else who were in a minority.
If there's a war against anyone, it's against whites and has been quite some time. I know that is not PC to even say that, but it's true.
I mean Obama used evidently to get into Harvard since there is evidence of "Our first Kenyan Student Body President". Can't blame anyone for using any advantage they can to obtain a job.
My gripe with her is the collectivism she adheres to instead of "Congratulations, you were the only student in the class to make a perfect score", she emphasizes "You didn't do that, someone else did it".
And when the chance to share in the suffering of the economy downfall at the university, she opted to let the workers take the hit instead of her.
Thanks, Six. It seems obvious to me.
Warren is just another "Do as I say but not as I do" lying Left Winger. She's so for the poor, but when it came down to doing something, she did the same thing most of the hypocrites do..... nothing.
Warren didn’t stand up for low-income Harvard employees
Who give a crap whether she is Indian or not except it was used until she became tenured and then removed.
She a hypocrite as well as a fake minority.
Your proof?
Her hypocrisy with respect to wealth is on the record. With respect to her illusions of being an Indian princess, she has the burden of proof.
Drop the "Princess" talk and I'll concur with you.
Sure.
That is a pathetic claim that reeks of desperation. Like the Warrens had the power to save a bunch of low income jobs at an Ivy League university with tens of billions in endowments, but they didn't because they didn't want to be the only ones to sacrifice their own private earnings. Give me a fucking break.
You know what's a hoot? Warren was a Republican until 1995, and during all the years she was supposedly being unethical in using her 'ethnic' background.
Warren was a registered Republican into her 40s.
Warren was a registered Republican into her 40s.
I'm a registered Democrat, but I'm not a commie.
I'm not a commie.
Yes, but they hide under your bed.
I'm a registered Democrat, but I'm not a commie.
I've said this before Six, I find that reference extremely offensive. My dad and hubby are both registered Dems, and my dad served in both Korea and Vietnam, so he is hardly a commie.
Frankly, it is better to treat his claims as a joke rather than give them a serious response. This is someone who has said on this forum that President Obama is a communist, and the administration is a communist conspiracy to end freedom in America. There is no good reason to humor such nonsense with serious replies.
I'm a registered Republican, but I'm not a member of the Tea Party, or otherwise part of the "far right".
If there's anything that I would make a CoC violation, it's this constant labeling of people.
A very good point, Jonathan. I hate the political name calling to. But there is no rule in the CoC so we would have to update it.
Being called tea party is a compliment not an insult.
I admit to agreeing with some of the planks in their platform.
I also espouse a number of the principles of that other party.
No labeling.
Perrie, my favorite uncle was in 5 different invasions in WWII with a machine gun. I was in the Air Force. He wasn't a Commie. I'm not a Commie. Do you need a safe space?
Of course if you notice any of them searching out Marxist professors, hanging out with Communists or wearing all black and red clothing to important polit al events.
Use the same logic you would if you see you children hanging out with thieves a lot.
Forgot...... my uncle was a Democrat.
Oh goody for your uncle. Hope he wasn't a commie.
No he was a Democrat. He wasn't a sellout either. He fought for this country like your dad. He didn't search out Marxist professors, hang out with radicals or want to fundamentally transform this country.
No he was a Democrat. He wasn't a sellout either. He fought for this country like your dad. He didn't search out Marxist professors, hang out with radicals or want to fundamentally transform this country.
"Of course if you notice any of them searching out Marxist professors, hanging out with Communists or wearing all black and red clothing to important polit al events."
Spit it out Sixpick
Six,
No, I don't need a safe place or your sarcasm. You're attitude about "Democrats" is the whole problem with this country. You paint in broad brush to condemn an entire group of people, and frankly I am damn sick of it.
As we say here in New Yawk, capisci?
Amen!
There is nothing with that. When we were at war with Nazi Germany we were at war with all of Germany. On the home front we are a war with the Democrats. There might be a few good Democrats but they choose to be identified as bad guys. To fight socialism it is better to call a spade a spade than sugarcoat it.
Sorry Dean, but that's a rather bilious posting... Do you really feel that you are at war with about 1/2 of the American People, just because they don't buy into your political beliefs? You're AT WAR???
For Pete's sake, come down from your ramparts and open your mind, just a crack. All of us are in this together. All Americans. Together. That is more than a slightly treasonous statement-- it's utterly ridiculous!
I call Hot Air on that statement...
Dean,
And there it is. This country is such a freaking mess:
On the home front we are a war with the Democrats. There might be a few good Democrats but they choose to be identified as bad guys. To fight socialism it is better to call a spade a spade than sugarcoat it.
The fact that you think that you are at war with Democrats is utterly ridiculous. And to call most democrats socialist is even more ridiculous. It the right calling the left far our names and the left calling the right far out names (I put it in that order, since I am responding to your comment in particular), that this nation is falling apart. As an independent, I am so sick of the name calling from both parties that I want to gag.
You may notice that the balloon isn't going anywhere, just running around in a circle, spewing air...
We have to make a big issue of it so we can't call a Commie a Commie anymore. PerriE twisted my comment "I"m a Democrat, but I'm not a Commie" in order to make it a big issue, just like guns and Orlando.
Even after I said I was a Democrat, my uncle was a Democrat, most all by far of my immediate and extended family are Democrats and almost all the men served in the military.
But not one of them want to fundamentally transform this country, hang out with Marxist or are fooled by the leadership we have now.
Keep in mind I do not care for the Republicans either, but which party do you think the Commies want to lead this country?
PerriE twisted my comment "I"m a Democrat, but I'm not a Commie" in order to make it a big issue, just like guns and Orlando.
Whoa there! I didn't twist a thing. It is the extreme language that is being used that I object to. You might be a registered democrat, but your words speak differently. And what the heck does guns in Orlando have to do with this? I wasn't even in a discussion about that. Now who is twisting?
As for Democrats trying to make this a commie country, give me a break. That would be like saying Republicans are trying to make this a fascist country. Neither would be a fair statement and is the problem with politics today.
"As for Democrats trying to make this a commie country, give me a break. That would be like saying Republicans are trying to make this a fascist country"
Our rights to say both of those are protected and should not be infringed. Just as the KKK is protected to express their views. The right to express our views is a fundamental element of freedom.
Dean,
I am not discussing the right to say what you want to say. Heck, look at the tagline to NT. It's speak your mind, which means that I value the first.
But just because you can say something, doesn't mean that you should. Extreme language has gotten into the vernacular, and words have taken on new meanings to the point that I feel it's Orwellian. That's a huge problem. We can't discuss anything as a nation, if all we are doing is throwing around mud. This is why there has never been so many independents as now. They are disgusted with the extremes of both parties and the rhetoric that they use.
But hey, feel free to use it.
Maybe y'all could think about it, in terms of manners. I won't call you a right-wing nut job, if you don't call me a leftist and a commie. In fact, I won't call you names at all.
And just because the KKK does it, is no bonafide stamp of approval in my book! I mean, sheesh, there's no need to be rude to one another... You can speak your mind without name calling and being nasty.
Perrie didn't twist your words, dear Six. They're there for all to see. I'm not a communist. Nor am I a leftist. I'm a housewife, mother, and geologist. There are feelings on this side of the computer, just as there are feelings on your side of the computer... We all have to give and take and watch our language, to get along.
I can certainly understand why there is so much confusion in this country. It seems PC has many absolutely many under its control.
If I was calling anyone a Commie, it was Elizabeth Warren. Can you folks not read and comprehend words in front of your eyes? You saw what you wanted to see.
I said I was a Democrat, my uncle was a Democrat and neither one of us were Commies. I never said you or Perrie were Commies or Perrie's husband or dad or anyone else here were Commies, but your party has been hijacked and a Socialist could have possibly won the primary if the Party wasn't so corrupt and Hillary wasn't already bought and paid for..
Look how well he did with everything going against him. Take those super delegates away, those millions of dollars from Wall Street and everywhere else and where do you think Hillary would be? There's a good chance you would have Bernie Sanders as your candidate. And do you think he is as left as his followers get? I don't think so. So when you think about it, maybe the Democrat Party is leaning much more to the left than you realize.
Between Trump and Hillary, we don't have anyone running for president in 2016 that is worth a crap. I'd have to take Trump over Hillary only because I know exactly who she is. It wouldn't surprise me if we don't have an election this year.
I'm no super right winger and I don't think either of you are super left wingers
"The Republicans are going to push granny off the cliff."
"The Republicans want people to die quickly."
The media is manipulating the way people are thinking and it has nothing to do with the intelligence of the people. Evidently some are more susceptible than others.
Example:
Google "bad things democrats have said about republicans". See what you get and tell me the media and Google isn't rigged.
As I tried to say earlier, both sides are at fault-- and Perrie said it too!
I find it offensive that, because I'm a registered Dem, I'm suddenly a commie or a socialist. I am NOT either.
Where is your proof that we're all commies and socialists? What are you even talking about? Or is that just some names you throw out there, parroting what others have said... WHY do you feel this way?
I find it offensive that, because I'm a registered Dem, I'm suddenly a commie or a socialist. I am NOT either.
If you look at my other article, maybe you will see why you think I called you a Commie.
JR said Elizabeth Warren was a Republican during the 90's and during that time she obtained her employment at Harvard Law School.
I said "I'm a Democrat, but I'm not a Commie".
Now where did I say you're a Commie in that sentence?
Sorry but redistribution of wealth, "you didn't make that perfect score on the test, someone else did it" or as she said it "You didn't build that, someone else did it" isn't what I want a teacher to tell me or my children when they were the only one to make a perfect score on a test in her class. Think about it, if your son came home and said "Mom, I was the only one in the class to make a 100 on the science test, would you tell him, "Well son, you didn't do that, the school bus driver and the people who built the roads did it?"
We know everything plays a part in this society for everyone to have the opportunity to be successful, but Elizabeth Warren is not my cup of tea.
I didn't call you a Commie.
Not me, per se, but all democrats in that line. It's like saying Leftists are communists-- a general broad brush painting of all democrats are commies or socialists. Not all are, I'm sure a few of them are-- but certainly not all.
It was an indirect inference. I don't go around saying-- "I'm a republican, not a fascist, or a right wing nut job". Maybe that wouldn't bother you, but it does me...
ALL of us need to stop painting each other with such broad brushes... ALL of us. We're all individuals, and we all fall in different places on the political spectrum.
I don't think it is bad that you're not a fan of Ms. Warren. That's not my viewpoint, but it's yours and you are certainly expressing a valid opinion. When my son gets 100% on a test, I praise him, but we also, on a daily basis, thank all the people that made our over-all lives livable. Like the electric linemen who work on our electric lines-- our sewer people who are working so hard to replace an old sewer. The librarian at the library... A job is a job and worth doing well. A little recognition of their accomplishments doesn't take away from my son's achievement. See what I mean? There is a difference.
I don't think so Hal. During the financial problems of 2008 the university ask the professors to participate in lowering their salary even though Warren and her husband made around $1 million dollars she did not lower her income from the university, but the workers at the university either lowered theirs or lost their jobs.
She's just another crony Capitalist like Hillary who are best described as "Take all you want, but keep your hands off my stack".
Phony.
I assume any of her accomplishments are due mostly to affirmative action.
Comment removed for CoC violation [ph]
I have lived with the denigration of my hard-earned accomplishments for about 40 years in my career. Please, dear friend, don't assume that a woman who has worked hard to accomplish something has gotten where she is because of affirmative action or she slept with someone. The people who always said that about me, were also more than willing to gossip about how I was a lesbian-- if I were, how could I have slept my way to the top? If I was hired, just because I was a woman, would they have kept me as an employee if I couldn't do the job?
When I was out there, standing next to a drilling rig, where were they? They were in their nice, temperature controlled, clean office... They weren't out there, covered in drilling mud from head to toe, shivering or frying...
You may not like Ms. Warren's political stances, and I can understand that-- but just because she is a woman, she had NO advantage of her gender. I worked twice as hard as my male counterparts, and had to be twice as sharp... They had no barriers-- they were allowed to enter a mine without the miners threatening to go on strike because a woman entered the mine. They weren't told that having them on the rig was bad luck. I had to fire a few drillers before they learned that I wanted their best work-- clean the hole, collect a good sample, don't over-mud up the hole, use the correct kind of drilling mud that breaks down in chlorine, etc.
To this day, even after doing this for 40 years, I have to prove myself, over and over and over again, that I know what I'm doing, and I can catch you if you don't do it right. Don't lie to me about footage-- I know where we are, I keep track of how many drill stems we put into the well. Don't leave the bit down there spinning, and waller out the hole. I know what they're up to, and know all their dirty little tricks. I've had more pipe dope smeared in my hardhat that I can count. All in good fun, right? You laugh and go on-- even though it takes about 3 shampoos that get that crap out of your hair.
Whatever you feel about her political stance, don't denigrate her efforts, just because she is a woman. I seriously doubt that she slept with anyone, or was elected due to affirmative action.
It's my standard response to libs who claim my success is due to my mythological privilege.
Cerenkov, I have no doubt that you worked very hard to get where you are. So did I.
I have no issue with her being a woman and do feel that women doing the same job as men should get paid the same as her peers. In this case, Ms. Warren used a claim of Native American Heritage to land an extremely well paying job that was set aside for Native Americans. The question is, Why? And she actually has that heritage she claimed. Not really about anything else, just casts doubt on her level of integrity.
Yes, it does, and I agree. My only complaint is that she got where she is by hard work, not because she was a woman... Guys don't understand how utterly FRUSTRATING it can be to work hard, and have it all dismissed as "she slept her way to get there..." Not that any of it makes any sense, anyway!
I never referred to her sex. I spoke solely about her alleged ethnicity.
In this case, Ms. Warren used a claim of Native American Heritage to land an extremely well paying job that was set aside for Native Americans.
Which job was that?
I hope you're not expecting an answer. The right only provides accusations on this forum - particularly when it comes to Warren.
Warren, who graduated from the University of Houston in 1970 and got her law degree from Rutgers University in 1976, did not seek to take advantage of affirmative action policies during her education, according documents obtained by the Associated Press and The Boston Globe . On the application to Rutgers Law School she was asked, "Are you interested in applying for admission under the Program for Minority Group Students?'' "No," she replied.
While a teacher at the University of Texas, she listed herself as "white." But between 1986 and 1995, she listed herself as a minority in the Association of American Law Schools Directory of Faculty; the University of Pennsylvania in a 2005 "minority equity report" also listed her as one of the minority professors who had taught at its law school.
The head of the committee that brought Warren to Harvard Law School said talk of Native American ties was not a factor in recruiting her to the prestigious institution. Reported the Boston Herald in April in its first story on Warren's ancestry claim: "Harvard Law professor Charles Fried, a former U.S. Solicitor General who served under Ronald Reagan, sat on the appointing committee that recommended Warren for hire in 1995. He said he didn't recall her Native American heritage ever coming up during the hiring process.
"'It simply played no role in the appointments process. It was not mentioned and I didn't mention it to the faculty,' he said."
He repeated himself this week, telling the Herald : "In spite of conclusive evidence to the contrary, the story continues to circulate that Elizabeth Warren enjoyed some kind of affirmative action leg-up in her hiring as a full professor by the Harvard Law School. The innuendo is false."
"I can state categorically that the subject of her Native American ancestry never once was mentioned," he added.
That view was echoed by Law School Professor Laurence H. Tribe, who voted to tenure Warren and was also involved in recruiting her.
"Elizabeth Warren's heritage had absolutely no role in the decision to recruit her to Harvard Law School," he told the Crimson . "
Law School Professor Laurence H. Tribe - wonder if his name is a pun????
Isn't unfounded accusation the basis for political discussion in America today?
Aren't there so many valid reasons to reject a candidate, without resorting to bullshit?
Trump, Hillary and Pocahontas all suck for a great number of valid reasons, but the nonsense continues. It's the nonsense that keeps the conversation going...
...unfortunately.