╌>

Another View: Why I had an abortion after 20 weeks

  

Category:  News & Politics

Via:  randy2  •  11 years ago  •  78 comments

Another View: Why I had an abortion after 20 weeks

Posted: 09/22/15, 2:54 PM EDT

In coming days, the Senate is expected to consider a federal ban on abortions at 20 weeks. Before lawmakers cast their votes, I would like them to hear my story.

If such a ban had been in place a year ago, I would have been condemned to carry and give birth to a baby who had no chance at life.

I have been happily married for more than a decade, and I have two beautiful children. When my husband and I found out last year that I was pregnant again, we were overjoyed.

At 20 weeks, my husband and I went for our favorite prenatal visit: the detailed ultrasound anatomy scan that shows your babys heart, kidneys, bladder, stomach, spine and brain and whether youre having a girl or a boy. I could barely contain myself as I sat on the exam table, eager to meet our baby more intimately. My husband and I chit-chatted with the ultrasound technician, gabbing and laughing when we recognized familiar features on the ultrasound images.

But after five minutes, only my husband and I were talking. The technician had grown quiet. She just kept printing picture after picture and pressing the wand deeper into the gel on my stomach.

My husband and I reached for each others hands. We asked the technician if everything was all right, and she said we should wait for a doctor to talk to us. When the OB/GYN entered, I remember asking point-blank, Is there a chance our child will be okay? He responded kindly, softly and unequivocally: No.

Over the next week came referrals to high-risk pregnancy specialists and more, longer, in-depth ultrasounds. In our babys brain cavity, where gray matter should have been visible, there was only black. The diagnosis was the same from every doctor: Something - we would learn it was not genetic or chromosomal - had caused two leaks in our babys brain, one on each side, destroying it almost entirely.

We would have done anything to save the baby. We asked if there was any possibility for repair, if the brain tissue could regrow. There wasnt. My baby would either die in the womb or shortly after birth.

Our child would never gain consciousness.

Our little one was gone.

I have never known horror quite like that. Adding to the pain, the brain stem was not affected, so the babys body was still moving involuntarily. But I knew there was no person in there anymore. I couldnt sleep and could barely eat, and every time the baby jerked, I suffered and mourned.

I didnt know what to tell my kids. They kept kissing my belly, feeling for kicks and singing to the baby. I didnt know what words to choose, but it hardly mattered, because I couldnt finish a sentence without sobbing.

I had a choice. I could try to live with the husk of a child inside of me for more than 100 days, swallowing tears at every cheery inquiry as I grew bigger. Or I could have an abortion. And the choice wasnt just about me. I have young children who would have had to see their mother endure this torture and give birth to someone they would never meet. So we made the painful, but I believe merciful, decision to terminate.

Even after we made that decision, it was difficult to find an available provider, even in an area with as many medical providers as the District. The hospitals had weeks-long waits. In the end, we were able to schedule an appointment at a surgical clinic for the following week.

My pregnancy was 21 weeks on the day of my abortion.

I mourn the loss of my baby every day. But I have no doubt that I made the right decision for myself and my family, and I am grateful that it was my choice to make. I am indebted to my medical providers for their compassion and care. They answered my questions, spent hours on the phone to give me as many options as possible and followed my lead.

According to the American Congress of Obstetricians and Gynecologists, just more than 1 percent of abortions take place at week 21 or later, many because of devastating medical situations like ours. Each of these mothers must battle through her own hell to decide on and find the medical care she needs, gather her friends and family to lean on, and grieve.

Congress should not take this decision away from any woman any family who is in need. Banning abortions after 20 weeks would be arbitrary, and its consequences would place an unimaginable burden on women like me.

When an abortion was the best of only horrible options, I was beyond grateful that one was available in a safe, compassionate medical establishment. And that my family could begin to heal. I hope our senators will consider women and families like mine before casting their votes.

Source link


Tags

jrDiscussion - desc
[]
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy    11 years ago

Stories like this are a large part of why I am pro-choice. If the law that the anti-choice people are pushing now succeeds (it won't, it'll never make it through the Senate) then this couple would be criminals and subject to prosecution and perhaps even jail. It shows that, unlike some would have you believe that abortion is a casual decision and just another form of birth control are full of shit.

Stories like this show that abortion is most often a painful and intensely personal decision that the woman and her family would rather not want to have to be needed. I am a male and never will have to face this difficult decision, which is why it must be left up to the woman, her doctor and her beliefs. The last thing they need is the government jamming it's sanctimonious nose in where it doesn't belong an making it just that much more painful.

 
 
 
Kavika
Professor Expert
link   Kavika     11 years ago

I cannot imagine the pain that she when through. It's stories like this that make totally reject what the wing nuts are proposing.

It's a women's decision. Plain and simple, and NO ONE else has the right to stick their noses into the decision making.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   96WS6    11 years ago
There are reasons choice is important. However, in cases where it is a healthy being, I would like to see as much emphasis put on (and as much money spent on) alternatives to abortion, and stop sugar coating the fact that abortion takes a life and making it as easy and thoughtless as possible. It SHOULD require thought.
 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   Bob Nelson    11 years ago

How much (government) money should be spent on raising children whom abortion restrictions force on unwilling parents?

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov    11 years ago
This is a poor example. Only the most fanatic of prolifers would object to an abortion in such a case. And they would be wrong. Laws should not be based on anecdotal cases.
 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy    11 years ago

Right to life supporters only care about the fetus until it becomes a born child, then they stop giving a fuck about them.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   96WS6    11 years ago

How much (government) money should be spent on raising children whom abortion restrictions force on unwilling parents?

How did you get under the impression I was advocating restrictions? On the contrary, more information and help with other options would be less restrictive. No one said anything about forcing people to raise children either. You have quite the imagination.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   96WS6    11 years ago

I said choice was important. Just because I want to see alternatives pushed as much as killing you would still label me pro life. OK I guess I do prefer it over the alternative. What do you have against spending as much on alternatives to killing babies as we do on killing them?

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov    11 years ago
Anecdotal cases are not the norm by definition. If large fractions of pregnancies involve massive brain damage after 20 weeks that WOULD be ample reason to not support a ban.
 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy    11 years ago

What if the anecdotal case represents the norm?

"According to the American Congress of Obstetricians and Gynecologists, just more than 1 percent of abortions take place at week 21 or later, many because of devastating medical situations like ours."

It would seem that it does represent the norm.

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov    11 years ago
Exactly the opposite.99% are OK at 20 weeks.
 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov    11 years ago
Yes, society does have a right and a duty to protect vulnerable children.
 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   96WS6    11 years ago

Like I said before:

in cases where it is a healthy being, I would like to see as much emphasis put on (and as much money spent on) alternatives to abortion, and stop sugar coating the fact that abortion takes a life

Perhaps if they were given all the options more thought would occur. Can't we at least offer them without being accused of trying to control women?

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    11 years ago

A pro-lifer would contradict him/herself if he/she were to agree that an abortion in such a case as this article were permissable. If they were to agree with it they would have to look within themselves and realize that their logic holds no water (pun not intended).

 
 
 
Cerenkov
Professor Silent
link   Cerenkov    11 years ago
I don't think that's true for a reasonable prolifer, Buzz. This child had no chance to survive. That should make a difference. Not everyone has fringe views.
 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    11 years ago

I don't consider pro-lifers to be reasonable. Is there a pro-lifer who doesn't believe in taking the decision out of the hands of the mother?

 
 
 
sixpick
Professor Quiet
link   sixpick    11 years ago

Planned Parenthood Not Needed for Womens Health, Groups Say

Anti-abortion activists hold a rally opposing federal funding for Planned Parenthood in front of the U.S. Capitol July 28, 2015 in Washington, DC.

As Planned Parenthood CEO Cecile Richards prepares to defend her organization before a U.S. House committee this morning, a coalition of pro-life groups are promoting a campaign and a website to show that Planned Parenthood is not needed to provide for womens health.

The coalition, led by Alliance Defending Freedom, argues that for every Planned Parenthood clinic there are 20 federally funded womens health clinics almost always performing more medical and health services than Planned Parenthood clinics.

The group, including Concerned Women for America, Family Research Council, Americans United for Life, Students for Life, Radiance Foundation, Charlotte Lozier Institute and Life Issues Institute, launched GetYourCare.org with an interactive map that shows exactly where each of the 13,540 federally funded health centers are located. The map is a sea of yellow dots that appear within miles of each other from coast to coast, though less numerous in the less populated mountain states. On the other hand, Planned Parenthood has only 665 clinics.

Besides defunding Planned Parenthood, the main theme of a press conference this morning was the lack of medical and health services provided by Planned Parenthood.

Planned Parenthood clinics provide a relatively small number of health services including birth control, manual breast exams, urinary tract inspections, STD testing, PAP testing and pelvic exams, while federally qualified health centers provide these and eleven more services including mammograms, emergency care, diabetes and glaucoma screenings, well-child services, radiological services, cardiovascular blood tests, bone mass measurements and more.

Jeanneane Maxon of American United for Life said in recent years Planned Parenthood is focusing more on its core profit center, abortion.

Since 2006, during a time when overall abortions are dropping in America, Planned Parenthoods abortion business has been growing. Cancer screening and prevention screenings have dropped from roughly 2 million to 985,000 while abortions have increased from 289,750 to 327,000. Since 2004, Planned Parenthood has increased from performing one in every five abortions to now performing one in every three, she said.

One of the central defenses of Planned Parenthood is that the group performs breast exams that save womens lives from cancer. However, since 2004, Planned Parenthood has cut its cancer screening and prevention services by more than 50 percent, says AULs Maxon.

ADFs Alison Howard said through a Freedom of Information request her organization discovered that not a single Planned Parenthood clinic in the country is licensed to do mammograms. She said, Why does a group that makes a profit of $127 million a year not buy a single mammogram machine?

I'm not totally against abortion. There is a time, place and a need in my opinion. I think we as a society should value life as much as we can and not follow a road that lessens the value of human life or any life for that matter.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy    11 years ago

I would think that her situation, specifically (baby with only a base brain) is probably one of many reasons, not the only or even most prevalent one. Can't even imagine seeing that on an ultrasound...

That's true. If only slightly more then all abortions take place at or after 21 week and many of them are because of a devastating medical condition, then no one is saying this is the only type. There are, I am sure, many other medical cases in which it is best that the fetus (not pre-born child) should be terminated via abortion. There are many cases when a fetus is not developing properly to the point where it would have a short and agonizing life or be born incredibly deformed, if it it was born alive at all. Most later term abortions are given to women who actually wanted to have a child, such as this married couple and who ended the pregnancy only for the most extreme reasons and after having to make a painful decision.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    11 years ago
"What do you have against spending as much on alternatives to killing babies as we do on killing them?"

I'm still trying to figure out what you mean here. The total cost of abortions in the US would pale in comparison to the cost of any alternatives, particularly when including fetuses with serious health concerns.

Btw, my grandson is due in one month. As you know, my daughter decided not to terminate her pregnancy in light of the fetus having two major heart defects. He has already had in utero surgery to place a stent in his heart (being only the 31st patient to ever undergo this procedure), without which he would have died at birth, and he is due for more heart and possibly lung surgeries the week he is born, followed by more surgeries later in life. This will all be on Medicaid, and I'm sure will get into the million dollar territory.
 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   Bob Nelson    11 years ago

Without going to the medical-costs scenario... There's the much simpler problem of poverty. Statistically, a child born into poverty will always be poor. So if a pregnant woman decides to abort, rather than condemn her own child to a life of poverty, what do the pro-lifers answe?

Will they contribute to the child's upbringing, to the child's "life"?

Or let's imagine a couple in difficulty, emotionally. A couple where a child would tip the balance, to the detriment of all three. What do the pro-lifers propose?

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   96WS6    11 years ago

I'm still trying to figure out what you mean here. The total cost of abortions in the US would pale in comparison to the cost of any alternatives, particularly when including fetuses with serious health concerns.

I am talking about adoption options. There are plenty of people who can't have kids that want them. Funny how many see killing it or getting "stuck with it" as the only options, in the event of complications yes it will cost more than to kill it so why do we still spend so much more killing them?

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   Bob Nelson    11 years ago

Are you willing to cover pregnancy expenses, and then foster the baby until a permanent family is found?

Or are you just telling women what they should do?

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   96WS6    11 years ago

What part of "we should spend as much on alternatives as killing babies" Don't you understand?

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   96WS6    11 years ago

I say women should be able to chose but we should spend as much on alternatives as we do killing babies and everyone here has labeled me as a pro-lifer. You seem to have a different definition of pro-life than the rest.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    11 years ago
Where do you (Cerenkov) think the line should be drawn? What about a slim chance of survival? Should a mother be forced to take a chance that her baby will suffer miserable health, thus severely impacting the entire family's future, when the odds are not in their favor?
 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    11 years ago

Sadly, I can. My sister had to have an abortion of a much wanted pregnancy because of the exact same defect. It is calledtrisomy 18. The fetus has no CNS and dies within minutes or hours of being born, depending on how much of a brain stem it has.

My sisters abortion broke her heart. She found out after her amnio, which ironically she had because both she and her husband carry the gene for cystic fibrosis. She never thought that this would be the finding.

This is why choice is such a personal decision. Even the nuns at the hospital that she went to after some mild complications, told her that there was no sin in what she did.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    11 years ago

Hal,

I hope all goes well with your new grandson.

 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    11 years ago

I am talking about adoption options.

How about the fact, that some women don't want to carry a baby to term, just to give it away, and have to live with the heartache of that decision for the rest of their lives? After all, we are not talking about giving away kittens.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    11 years ago
Thanks, Perrie. The first surgery was a success, so that's a positive thing. Other than that, there's no guarantees. We're all prepared for the worst and hoping for the best. Without access to a tremendous social service expenditure, it would not even be possible.
 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    11 years ago

Cerenkov,

I have a question for you. In NYS, if a woman decides to go through with the pregnancy and keep the baby, the state can and will go after the dad for child support. Are you good with that?

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   JohnRussell    11 years ago

So, you favor abortion "on demand" with the only deciding factor being whether or not a woman wants to continue the pregnancy for whatever reason may be ?

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy    11 years ago

Are you willing to cover pregnancy expenses, and then foster the baby until a permanent family is found?

And then you or the government pay weekly child support until it's 18 or out of high school, whichever comes last?

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy    11 years ago

My wife's child, David, was born with what is known as Hypoplastic left heart syndrome. Basically it means being born without the left side of the heart or a severely undeveloped one that doesn't function. When he was born there was no treatment for it, such as a heart transplant which is still the only good treatment, alternativesurgeries hadn't been developed yet and abortion was illegal. Back then (mid 1960's) it was a death sentence. She has said many times that if she had known he was developing with this condition that she would have found a way to get an abortion, such as traveling out of country.

She wanted another child, but it still tears her up sometimes to think of seeing him born only to have to watch him suffer and die a few weeks later and that there was nothing that could be done. She much rather would have preferred the chance to terminate the pregnancy though.

 
 
 
Hal A. Lujah
Professor Participates
link   Hal A. Lujah    11 years ago
That's what my future grandson is afflicted with. There are now medical procedures to treat it, but they are risky, cripplingly expensive, and there's no guarantee of success.
 
 
 
Perrie Halpern R.A.
Professor Guide
link   Perrie Halpern R.A.    11 years ago

I believe in abortion on demand only in the 1st trimester. After that I think it should be with a doctor's recommendation.

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   Bob Nelson    11 years ago

96,

... we should spend as much...

No, that is very, very far from sufficient. An abortion costs very little. Raising a child to adulthood is many thousands of times more costly. Will you give as much of your energy to obtaining that aid, as you do for limiting abortion?

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   Bob Nelson    11 years ago

So, you favor abortion "on demand" with the only deciding factor being whether or not a woman wants to continue the pregnancy for whatever reason may be ?

I do.

A fertilized egg is not a person... nor is a fetus, even just before birth. In particular, a fetus lacks self-awareness.Some societies have not recognized a child as a person until some milestone well after birth.

Our parental instincts are just about unbreakable after birth.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   96WS6    11 years ago

Will you give as much of your energy to obtaining that aid, as you do for limiting abortion?

Stop trying to put words in my mouth and pull your head out of your ass. Point to any statement I have EVER made that insinuates "limiting abortion" in any way shape or form. You seem to be so intent on killing babies that even suggesting an alternative to a woman makes what's left of your brain melt.

BTW I AM putting forth effort to get alternatives offered, and as I have already said many times, I would rather have my taxes spent that way than killing babies.

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   96WS6    11 years ago

Why is it the only scenarios you two can think of is killing it or "sticking" someone with it? WTF!?!?!? Do you have the slightest clue how many people want to adopt in this country? They are importing babies by the tens of thousands for adoption here for crying out loud!

Would I rather have my tax dollars go to raising a child until it is adopted instead of killing it? You bet!

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   96WS6    11 years ago

A fertilized egg is not a person... nor is a fetus, even just before birth. In particular, a fetus lacks self-awareness.Some societies have not recognized a child as a person until some milestone well after birth.

At some point it becomes a person if you don't kill it Bob. A fetus is still a living being that at some point becomes human. You are still killing. Quit trying to sugar coat it to make yourself feel better about what you advocate. Tell me, if I knock you out so you are not aware is it OK for someone to kill you? I mean, your not aware so it's OK right? If you try to argue you will become aware I would argue so will the fetus.

BTW Bob. In your opinion when exactly does it become human? Does it have to breathe air first? Is a fully formed child in the last trimester in the womb still a fetus in your opinion?

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   Bob Nelson    11 years ago

96,

Stop trying to put words in my mouth and pull your head out of your ass. Point to any statement I have EVER made that insinuates "limiting abortion" in any way shape or form.

So you're OK with abortion. In that case, I apologize for having drawn unjustified conclusions.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    11 years ago

Hard cases make bad laws.

This is an axiom that probably goes, in one form or another, back to Hammurabis Code. It is true. When you come up with a particularly horrible case that you attempt to accommodate you end up creating very bad law....

Actually, late term abortion for fetal anomaly is exceedingly rare. This should be obvious. There are a plethora of diagnostic tools available to detect those fatal anomalies that cant be corrected via surgical intervention.

How about this deal: if I give you all the babies who will be born dead to abort, will you give me the rest?

The author had already carried this child for over 20 weeks. Suppose an affidavit was signed by the womans doctor, accompanied by the medical evidence and imagery, and it went before a local judge on an expedited basis. Suppose that the medical examiner had to review the request and ensure they comported with the fetal remains. Suppose legal jeopardy attached to submitting bogus documentation (the woman would want that, right?). What harm arises?

But we all know what the answer is. No! Choice! Patriarchy! Trust Women!

This article is sheer agitprop. The authors case was a tragedy but her particular case does not represent the facts in the near total majority of other cases of late term abortion. Should the emotional distress caused her carrying a child that was going to be born dead outweigh the cost of killing 14,000 children on a whim?

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   96WS6    11 years ago

"So you're OK with abortion. In that case, I apologize for having drawn unjustified conclusions."

I beleive it HAS to be a woman's choice. It has to be to cover all circumstances. I don't think a woman that has been raped should have to keep the child. I think a mother must be able to choose because of circumstances like in this article. That does not necessarily mean I am OK with aborting a healthy baby. I think all options should be offered and assisted with and certainly options that encourage life should get the same amount of funding. I am not OK with the way it is sugar coated when a healthy baby is killed either. Let's tell it like it is. You are killing the life growing inside you. You are killing your own child.

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   Bob Nelson    11 years ago

96,

That does not necessarily mean I am OK with aborting a healthy baby.

It's not a baby. It's a ZEF: zygote, then embryo, then fetus. It is a baby after birth.

And if you are only OK with abortion in extreme cases, then you are trying to control the woman. And waffling about it.

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   JohnRussell    11 years ago

I do.

A fertilized egg is not a person... nor is a fetus, even just before birth. In particular, a fetus lacks self-awareness. Some societies have not recognized a child as a person until some milestone well after birth.

Our parental instincts are just about unbreakable after birth.

You bring up an interesting question. If a society decided that abortions done in the first or second trimester did in fact constitute killing a baby , albeit it one in an earlier stage of development, would concrete bans and illegalization of abortion then be justified ?

The suggestion seems to be that there is no point at which abortion is right or wrong , but is always predicated on the consensus beliefs of the society.

So, if pro lifers are "successful" in changing minds then abortion will be immoral and justifiably banned ?

--------------------------------------------------

Has anyone here seen this before ? I am curious

"PETER SINGER- NO DIFFERENCE BETWEEN ABORTION AND INFANTICIDE

To the dismay of popular abortion advocates, Singer rejects birth as a relevant dividing line between person and nonperson, agreeing with pro-life advocates that there is no ontologically significant difference between the fetus and a newborn. True, there are differences of size, location, dependency, and development, but these are morally irrelevant. The liberal search for a morally crucial dividing line between the newborn baby and the fetus has failed to yield any event or stage of development that can bear the weight of separating those with a right to life from those who lack such a right. 4

Instead of upgrading the fetus to the status of a person, however, Peter Singer downgrades the newborn to the status of nonperson because newborns, like fetuses, are incapable of seeing themselves as distinct entities, existing over time. 5 They are not rational, self-conscious beings with a desire to live. 6 Since, in Singers criteria, personhood hinges on these factors, killing a newborn (or fetus) is not the same as killing a person. In fact, some acts of infanticide are less problematic than killing a happy cat. If, for example, parents kill one disabled infant to make way for another baby that will be happier than the first, the total amount of happiness increases for all interested parties. 7 Singers logic can be summed up this way: Until a baby is capable of self-awareness, there is no controlling reason not to kill it to serve the preferences of the parents."

 
 
 
JohnRussell
Professor Principal
link   JohnRussell    11 years ago

I do.

A fertilized egg is not a person... nor is a fetus, even just before birth. In particular, a fetus lacks self-awareness.Some societies have not recognized a child as a person until some milestone well after birth.

Our parental instincts are just about unbreakable after birth.

You bring up an interesting question. If a society decided that abortions done in the first or second trimester did in fact constitute killing a baby , albeit it one in an earlier stage of development, would concrete bans and illegalization of abortion then be justified ?

The suggestion seems to be that there is no point at which abortion is right or wrong , but is always predicated on the consensus beliefs of the society.

So, if pro lifers are "successful" in changing minds then abortion will be immoral and justifiably banned ?

--------------------------------------------------

Has anyone here seen this before ? I am curious

"PETER SINGER- NO DIFFERENCE BETWEEN ABORTION AND INFANTICIDE

To the dismay of popular abortion advocates, Singer rejects birth as a relevant dividing line between person and nonperson, agreeing with pro-life advocates that there is no ontologically significant difference between the fetus and a newborn. True, there are differences of size, location, dependency, and development, but these are morally irrelevant. The liberal search for a morally crucial dividing line between the newborn baby and the fetus has failed to yield any event or stage of development that can bear the weight of separating those with a right to life from those who lack such a right. 4

Instead of upgrading the fetus to the status of a person, however, Peter Singer downgrades the newborn to the status of nonperson because newborns, like fetuses, are incapable of seeing themselves as distinct entities, existing over time. 5 They are not rational, self-conscious beings with a desire to live. 6 Since, in Singers criteria, personhood hinges on these factors, killing a newborn (or fetus) is not the same as killing a person. In fact, some acts of infanticide are less problematic than killing a happy cat. If, for example, parents kill one disabled infant to make way for another baby that will be happier than the first, the total amount of happiness increases for all interested parties. 7 Singers logic can be summed up this way: Until a baby is capable of self-awareness, there is no controlling reason not to kill it to serve the preferences of the parents."

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   Bob Nelson    11 years ago

LGL,

If a society decided that abortions done in the first or second trimester did in fact constitute killing a baby , albeit it one in an earlier stage of development, would concrete bans and illegalization of abortion then be justified ?

Yes.

And worse.

Much, much worse.

If a ZEF (at any moment whatsoever before birth) is legally declared a person, then every miscarriage after that moment must be investigated. If the womans behavior was less than perfect, she will be open to prosecution.

If a fertilized egg is declared a person, then any sexually active woman who takes a drink risks prosecution. Also... if she drives a car, or even rides in one.

If she leaves the house, and something bad happens... and she turns out to be pregnant... She's guilty of negligent homicide.

"Life begins at conception" is totally incompatible with women's rights.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy    11 years ago

You bring up an interesting question. If a society decided that abortions done in the first or second trimester did in fact constitute killing a baby , albeit it one in an earlier stage of development, would concrete bans and illegalization of abortion then be justified ?

To me the bigger question is, are you going to prosecute and if convicted, send the woman to prison for this? Because if the right wing wants to make abortion illegal they're going to have to be willing to go all of the way and build yet even more prisons to house women who were desperate not to carry a fetus for whatever reason. What if the travel to a country where abortion is legal? Will they still consider her a murderer when she gets back and arrested?

The truth is that the GOP leadership does not want abortion to be made illegal. It's too helpful of a tool to gin up their base over to get them to the polls. When they go to Washington they are never going to introduce any anti-abortion bill they think might actually pass, because making abortion illegal would be their biggest political nightmare. Now that they can't use gays any longer, they have to double down on abortion as a wedge issue, even though they have no plans of ever stopping it.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy    11 years ago

And sadly, even though new surgical techniques and medications will help a lot, the child will have heart problems their entire life until and if a heart transplant can be done and even then there are rejection medications to deal with that sometime work and sometimes don't. Then there are restrictions on activity, constant daily meds etc. And many insurance companies won't cover it because they still consider the treatments to be experimental. Usually one has to turn to the state for help to make it happen.

I really am glad to hear your grandson has a fighting chance to live a good life. My sincere best wishes for him, his parents, his grandparents and the entire family.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy    11 years ago

Oh and David is buried next to his great grandparents (they were still alive then) in the family plot in Connecticut. My wife refuses to go see his grave since the funeral even to this day and it's been almost 50 years.

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    11 years ago

Hal, you and your grandson will be in my thoughts. I hope everything works out well, dear friend.

Call me if you need to talk to someone. I will do my best to help.

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    11 years ago

In my state, they offer all the options to people, and require them to wait at least 8 hours from entering the facility until the procedure is performed. They get information about adoption, social services, offer chaplain counseling, etc. They perform an ultrasound of the fetus, and make you look at it. They must sign off on a legal form, that you actually saw the ultrasound and listened to the fetal heartbeat.

Then, you decide-- or sit there and wait, until you can get it over with. It used to cost about $500, (15 years ago), and you have to get there by 7:00 am. (I've been with a friend.)

I have never, ever, known anyone that didn't agonize over the choice-- since 1973. Abortion is not a form of birth control, and this poor woman in this article had to go through the horrible choice of holding onto a dead baby, (like Debbie Reynolds), or going through a procedure that would enable her family to heal.

I think all of these "doubters" do a great dis-service to women everyone, to even remotely think that women just pop off to go have an abortion when they find themselves pregnant. I don't know what kind of women you know, but I don't know anyone that would take this lightly.

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    11 years ago

Only 1% of abortions take place at 21 weeks, and I'm sure that there are some, (albeit very few), that take place later, due to the health of the mother-- OR they are induced labor situations, and the baby happens to die. So most, maybe 98%, take place earlier, when the baby is a clump of cells, not even yet a fetus. Long before the child would have a chance to survive outside the womb.

I was told that if I got any worse, or my blood pressure got any higher, they were going to induce labor, at 32 weeks, because I was going to die. I got VERY lucky, on all counts. But, I had a C-section at 36 weeks.

I don't know that you are really thinking this through. Most mothers don't have a lot of tests to see if the baby is genetically normal, unless they are old, like I was. You, me, or anyone else, can't tell that at 20 weeks 99% of the pregnancies are ok-- they may be, they may not be.

Problems can develop at any stage, severe problems, where the baby may be ok, but the mother isn't. Plus, many children born with severe birth defects or genetic problems don't show any signs until they are born. I had a really good friend that gave birth to a child with severe birth defects-- and she was 32. She had NO idea, until the child was born. And, like I said somewhere else, they spent 2 hours talking about all the birth defects they can test for, and then spent 2 hours talking about birth defects they can't test for...

And you know? Why are we still talking about this? It was decided in 1973, by the supreme court. This shouldn't even be an issue!

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    11 years ago

I understand what you are saying, and agree with it-- to a point. BUT, and this is important, no one is interested in helping the mothers keep their babies healthy, feeding them, clothing them, etc. They become labeled Welfare Queens, (NOT my definition), and are put down every day, because they are unable to support their child.

You're upset that you've been labeled "Pro-Life" for your point of view. They must have the same feelings of being unlabeled unfairly...

I'm NOT being nasty to you-- I promise. I think it would be a wonderful idea to help the women keep their babies, and take care of their medical bills, shoes, clothes, schooling, a decent place to live, etc. I think you'd also have to provide some support for the mothers-- free birth control, counseling, support groups, etc. A lot of these young teenagers have no idea how to rear a child...

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    11 years ago

I'm wondering where you think that performing an abortion is a profitable enterprise? Looked at medical expenses lately? About 15 years ago, it cost $500 for an abortion. You can't get a cavity filled at the dentist for $500!

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy    11 years ago

Far too many pro-life supporters only care about the child being born and don't give a damn into what circumstances of poverty to teen mothers the child may be born into. Then they attack the mother and child as takers when the need help. And because of this poverty, many of the male children end up filling our jails and prison systems (those that aren't killed on the street by gangs and gangs of cops). The GOP is supposed to be the party of financial knowledge and responsibility, but they are showing in this case by cutting Head Start programs, before and after school programs, lunch programs for the poor children and pre-school, that they have no concept of what a REAL long term investment really is. No wonder thy fucked up the market.

They want the fetus to become a baby and be born, just so they have more targets of derision to shoot at. More hate to hand out. More people of poverty to point at and say "See! I told you "their kind" were never any good!"

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    11 years ago

agitprop = agitating propaganda?

All these things you describe, affidavits, etc., take a long time. We have been working on getting my son's knee fixed since April of this year. Since time means waiting until the child is even more developed before performing the abortion, you're shooting yourself in the foot.

This was solved in 1973. Why do y'all keep screaming about it?

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy    11 years ago

Actually, late term abortion for fetal anomaly is exceedingly rare. This should be obvious. There are a plethora of diagnostic tools available to detect those fatal anomalies that cant be corrected via surgical intervention.

Which is exactly why late abortions should not be made illegal. The current proposals do not provide for an abortion in the case of a horribly diseased or deformed fetus that has little or no chance of living very long are who will be born with such severe brain damage (or no brain at all) that they will, in effect (if they live at all), be in a comma in a nursing home for how ever long he or she lives, with no quality of life at all. When some children are born and in many cases this can be detected before birth, severely brain damaged, is it really in their interests to spend their life blind, deaf and dumb in a bed, unable to learn anything at all because that part of the brain doesn't work either. Basically unable to function at all. With no one, no person, alive in the body. The current proposal also seek to make the choice of an abortion happen much sooner. Sooner then these defects can detected.

Your comment here;

Hard cases make bad laws.

Is exactly backwards. Hard cases make good laws. In fact they are exactly what these laws are for.

 
 
 
Buzz of the Orient
Professor Expert
link   Buzz of the Orient    11 years ago

You're upset that you've been labeled "Pro-Life" for your point of view.

But Dowser, once 96WS6 said women should be able to choose, then he is pro-choice no matter what he says about aftercare. It would be cruelty for ANYONE not to be concerned about aftercare.

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   Bob Nelson    11 years ago

Randy,

To me the bigger question is...

I'm usually not a big fan of slippery slope arguments. One can make them go almost anywhere.

But in this case, I think the conclusion is inevitable: if a fetus is a person then every miscarriage must be investigated. If the woman did anything that might have provoked the miscarriage, she must be prosecuted for "negligent homicide".

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   Bob Nelson    11 years ago

96,

(Please excuse the slow response. I missed your post when it first went up.)

BTW Bob. In your opinion when exactly...

Our first task in discussing this topic is to get straight on vocabulary. It's easy to get sidetracked into semantics, and that's a waste of time

You ask "When is it human?" It is human since before fertilization, because both the sperm and the egg are human. There is continuity of life since long before our species differentiated.Any fragment of tissue, from toenail clippings to a heart being transplanted, is "human". But I don't think that is very useful.

At this point, we need to be clear about the basis for our thinking. Personally, I have found that almost all pro-lifers base their thinking in religion, whether they do so consciously or unconsciously. Most are unable to dig very deeply into why they believe as they do, which is a pretty good indication that they are "thinking" with their guts (or heart, if you prefer, but it is still a non-thinking organ) rather than with their brain.

Faith cannot be debated by reason. (That is the "atheist's fallacy".) A faith-based position must be debated within the framework of faith. So... In this case, the conversation is about the source of the belief. With Christians: What did Jesus say? What else is to be found in the Bible?

Personally, I try to approach the topic rationally, with no input from God. (He has never spoken to me on this subject... nor on any other, for that matter.)

Whether we take a "religious" approach or a "rational" one, it seems to me that our question should be, "When does a ZEFBIAA (zygote / embryo / fetus / baby / infant / adolescent / adult) become a 'person'?"

We cannot begin to answer that question until we define "person"... which is not a simple task.

Those are, it seems to me, the necessary ground rules for a worthwhile conversation.

 
 
 
Dowser
Sophomore Silent
link   Dowser    11 years ago

I agree and I didn't label him anything... I think that everyone should care! Especially republicans, who have not shown their care for the child born into poverty...

I was just repeating his statement about how he felt. I think he is pro-choice, just like he said.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    11 years ago

This was solved in 1973.

For you it was. The millions of viable babies with functioning nervous systems that have been killed since then would probably disagree with you.

Pretty much every civilized country in the world disagrees with late term abortion on demand, but as long as you are happy with it, I guess the problem was solved.

 
 
 
Sean Treacy
Professor Principal
link   Sean Treacy    11 years ago

late term abortion for fetal anomaly is exceedingly rare

"Which is exactly why late abortions should not be made illegal"

Right. Thousands of healthy late term babies should be killed to ensure the few "diseased" babies can be aborted. "Better 10,000 healthy babies be killed than one sick baby be born." What a monstrous sense of perspective you have.

he current proposals do not provide for an abortion in the case of a horribly diseased or deformed fetus


But if you did, you would no doubt oppose them to. Zealots gotta zealot. California elects a Senator who things a baby can be "aborted" up until the time it leaves the hospital. The country elected a President who voted against giving babies who survive an abortion the right to be cared for. This country has gone so far beyond other civilized countries in ensuring babies can be killed up until the instant of birth that it's no surprise you would think killing tens of thousands of healthy babies a year for convenience is an acceptable outcome.

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   Bob Nelson    11 years ago

Sean,

Thousands of healthy late term babies should be killed...

"should"???

WTF??

 
 
 
96WS6
Junior Silent
link   96WS6    11 years ago

It's not a baby. It's a ZEF: zygote, then embryo, then fetus. It is a baby after birth.

It is someones child at every stage. There you go sugar coating it to make yourself feel better about ending life. (it is also life at every stage)

And if you are only OK with abortion in extreme cases, then you are trying to control the woman. And waffling about it.

Offering options and doing your best to persuade someone is not the same as trying to control someone.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy    11 years ago

Genesis Chapter 2, verse 7 (King James Version)

01:002:007 And the LORD God formed man of the dust of the ground, and breathed into his nostrils the breath of life; and man became a living soul.

So, if you are a religious person, then a fetus does not become a person, a living soul, until it can breath on it's own. Until God canbreathe the breath of life into it making it a living soul. I'll accept that as a good enough starting point.

Source link.

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   Bob Nelson    11 years ago

96,

It's not a baby. It's a ZEF: zygote, then embryo, then fetus. It is a baby after birth.

It is someones child at every stage.

What do you mean by "child", here? A zygote carries its parents' genes. Even when it is still microscopic, and its existence unknown. But it is certainly not a "child" in normal English usage.

I understand pro-lifers' desire to hijack emotionally changed words like "baby" and "child", in order to control the debate. After all, who could ever defend a "baby-killer"?

The problem with abusing language is that it is the pro-lifers who are snared. Someone who says "personhood begins at conception, therfore a zygote is a baby" is a prisoner of their own speech. I, and every literate English-speaker, know that the definition of the word "baby" is

a very young child, especially one newly or recently born.

Because I know that definition, I cannot be trapped by an argument that is nothing more than semantics. Your use of "child" is just plain wrong:

a young human being below the age of puberty or below the legal age of majority.
synonyms: youngster, little one, boy, girl;

More:

  • a son or daughter of any age.
  • an immature or irresponsible person.

Words have meanings. No one can just change a definition to win an argument. Attempting to do so may be interpreted as recognition of a lack of better arguments.

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   Bob Nelson    11 years ago

Randy,

The ancient Hebrews did not use the word that the KJV translates as "soul" as we do today. Here's the New International Version of Genesis 2:7:

Then theLordGod formeda manfrom the dustof the groundand breathed into his nostrils the breathof life,and the man became a living being.

In fact, the notion of a "soul" as a spiritual-world "twin" of our physical-world body is posterior to Jesus.

So... Any attempt to find scriptures concerning the soul is anachronistic.

That doesn't exclude the existence of the soul, of course. But it does eliminate the Bible as a reference.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy    11 years ago

Then the Lord God formeda manfrom the dustof the groundand breathed into his nostrils the breathof life,and the man became a living being.

I can accept that too. The KJV was just he last one I read (though that was many years ago (I can't remember what my Catholic one says...I'll check....here it it goes)) "Genesis, Chapter 2, Verse 7 the LORD GOD formed man out of the clay of the ground and blew into his nostrils the breath of life, and so man became a living being. (The New American Bible. July 27, 1970)

Either way it's pretty certain that a person does not become a living being until they breath the first breath of life.

And sceeech! 1970! It has been a long time since I bought it new and read it. Though I have taken several bible classes (one must take refresher courses, even if one is an atheistSmile.gif ) where I used it as recently as 1990, I believe. It's been awhile. Maybe I'll make a point of re-reading it just for the hell of it?

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy    11 years ago

And if it's deformed or the wrong race and in same cases even the wrong gender it's going to be a whole lot harder to adopt it out and the odds of the child being adopted drop quickly. Once past the immediate infant stage, it's a crap shoot. The older the baby gets, even after as little of time as a month, the less likely an adoption becomes. Your statement should have been "Have you any idea how many married White heterosexual couples want to adopt a healthy White baby boy?"

Fortunately as more and more states recognize gay marriage and adoption that is very slowly changing.

Would I rather have my tax dollars go to raising a child until it is adopted instead of killing it?

Then you're the exception, rather then the rule. The rule being forbid the mother from getting an abortion and then to hell with her and the child, except to demonize her as a whore, the child as a bastard and both as takers, looking to live off from the government.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy    11 years ago

Does it have to breathe air first?

According to the bible, yes.

 
 
 
Bob Nelson
Professor Guide
link   Bob Nelson    11 years ago

Randy

Either way it's pretty certain that a person does not become a living being until they breath the first breath of life.

Ah! I misunderstood your point. You're right, of course.

I was fixating on "soul" because I am convinced that almost all pro-lifers, when they say "life begins at conception" are in fact code-wording "the soul is acquired at conception". They aren't necessarily conscious of this: religious training as children goes deep into our habits.

 
 
 
Randy
Sophomore Quiet
link   seeder  Randy    11 years ago

NP

Many pro-lifers say the soul enters the body at conception, but there is nothing in any version of the bible that says that in any manner whatsoever. The only reference to a person becoming a living human being (or in some versions getting a soul) is at the first breath of life. They really should read their own book before pontificating to everyone else and insisting that everyone must believe exactly as they believe, especially since what they are insisting everyone else believes, is not even in their own holy book of instructions and damnation.

 
 

Who is online





Thomas


97 visitors