How to Assess the Bannon Appointment
How to Assess the Bannon Appointment
By Alan M. Dershowitz, Gatestone Institute, November 17 2016
Alan M. Dershowitz, Professor of Law, Harvard University
President Elect Trump's appointment of Steve Bannon as his chief strategist has been criticized on the ground that Bannon is an anti-Semite. There are many reasons for opposing the appointment of Bannon, but anti-Semitism is not one of them. I do not support the Bannon appointment. But neither do I support accusing Bannon of being an anti-Semite, based on the evidence I have seen.
With regard to anti-Semitism, there are three distinct but overlapping issues: (1) Is Bannon personally an anti-Semite? (2) Does his publication, Breitbart, promote anti-Semitic views? (3) Do Breitbart and Bannon have followers who are anti-Semitic?
From what I can tell, the evidence cited in support of the accusation that personally Bannon is an anti-Semite falls into two categories: first, that his wife testified at a hotly contested divorce proceeding that he did not want his children to go to school with "whiney Jews"; and second, that he ran an article describing Bill Kristol as a "renegade Jew."
Let us consider these items of evidence in order. Senator Harry Reid tried to strengthen the first accusation against Bannon by saying that it appeared in a court document, thus suggesting that it had the imprimatur of a judge. But that is not the case. The claim was simply made by his former wife in a judicial proceeding, thus giving it no special weight. Bannon has rigorously denied making the statement and said that he and his wife were fighting over whether his children should attend Catholic school, rather than a secular school.
On the other side of the ledger is the testimony of Jewish individuals who have worked closely with him for years. These include my former research assistant, Joel Pollak, an orthodox Jew who wears a kippah and takes off all the Jewish holidays. He is married to a black woman from South Africa who converted to Judaism. Joel assures me that he never heard a single anti-Semitic utterance or saw an anti-Semitic action in the four years they worked together. The same is true of numerous other Jewish individuals who work with him, some of whom thoroughly disapprove of Bannon's politics and the way he ran Breitbart, but none of whom have reported any events of anti-Semitism.
The second alleged item of evidence is the following headline that appeared on Breitbart: "Bill Kristol: Republican Spoiler, Renegade Jew." [1] I am advised, however, that this article and the headline were written not by Bannon but rather by David Horowitz, a right-wing Jew who was upset with Kristol for his refusal to support Trump. Horowitz deemed that a betrayal of the Jewish people. While I fundamentally disagree with that appraisal and also of the article, I find it hard to characterize Bannon as an anti-Semite because Breitbart ran it. Breitbart has also personally attacked me, [2] but that doesn't change my views.
I keep an open mind waiting for more evidence, if there is any, but on the basis of what I have read, I think it is wrong to accuse Bannon of one of the most serious forms of bigotry. So I will not join the chorus of condemnation that employs this radioactive term against Bannon without compelling evidence. The Anti-Defamation League has now commendably acknowledged that there is no evidence of anti-Semitism by Bannon: "We are not aware of any anti-Semitic statements from Bannon."
As to whether Bannon promotes the alt-right, and whether the alt-right includes anti-Semites, I think the answer to that is yes. [3] Both Bannon and Breitbart have made bigoted statements about Muslims, women and others, which I do not condone. That is why I do not support Bannon, even though I do not think he's an anti-Semite. Bigotry against any group should be disqualifying for high office. But let's put this criticism of Bannon and Breitbart into context. Haaretz certainly serves as a platform for the alt-left in Israel. Though it features a wide range of commentary, primarily from the center-left, it also features hard-left writers such as Gideon Levy, who supports academic, cultural and economic boycotts against Israel and its "criminal" regime, as well as Amira Hass, who encourages Palestinians to throw stones and engage in "violent resistance" against Israel. These writers have certainly been accused, and with some justification, of promoting hatred not only against the current Israel government, but against the very nature of Israel and Zionism. [4] Their hateful writings are often quoted gleefully by anti-Zionist and anti-Semites. [5]
This is not to compare Breitbart with Haaretz , but it is to suggest caution in holding a publication responsible for all the views expressed by its writers. To be sure, Haaretz 's general orientation tends to be center-left, whereas Breitbart is hard-right, but both serve as platforms for extremes on either side. The same can be said of J Street, which is a center-left organization which serves as a platform for, and includes among its active members and contributors, BDS supporters, anti-Zionists and opponents of Israel's existence as the Nation State of the Jewish people.
Or consider Black Lives Matter, an organization with a commendable goal, that has promoted anti-Semitism by singling out one country for condemnation in its "platform" : calling the Nation State of the Jewish People an "apartheid" and "genocidal" regime. In an article in Above the Law, Joe Patrice attacks me for my critique of Black Lives Matter, claiming that "it's certainly possible someone in the movement also has sympathy for Palestinians." But there is an enormous difference between "sympathy for Palestinians" (which I share) and accusing the entire nation state of the Jewish people of "genocide" (which I believe is anti-Semitic).
Anti-Semitism and anti-Zionism are prevalent both on the hard-right and on the hard-left. The Trump election has brought hard-right anti-Semitism into public view, but the bigotry of the hard-left is far more prevalent and influential on many university campuses, both in the United States and in Europe. A single standard of criticism must be directed at each. We must judge individuals on the basis of their own statements and actions, and we should be cautious in judging publications and organizations on the basis of who they publish, who their audience is and who supports them.
People of good will, Jews and non-Jews, must condemn with equal vigor all manifestations of bigotry whether they emanate from the hard alt-right or hard alt-left. That is why I cannot support Bannon's appointment, even though he is strongly pro-Israel. But that is also why I can't support those on the hard-left who advocate good causes, while at the same time promoting anti-Semitism and the delegitimization of Israel.
Alan M. Dershowitz, Felix Frankfurter Professor of Law, Emeritus and author of "Taking the Stand: My Life in the Law" and "Electile Dysfunction."
[1] " Bill Kristol: Republic Spoiler, Renegade Jew ," by David Horowitz, 15 May 2016.
[2] See Adrian Otto, " Alan Dershowitz Hangs Up Over Clinton College Scandal ," Breitbart, Nov. 4, 2016; the article was originally published with the title "Dershowitz Goes Berserk." The article falsely claimed that Laureate University received money from the State Department, when Hillary Clinton was Secretary of State.
[3] See Allum Bokhari and Milo Yiannopoulos, " An Establishment Conservative's Guide to the Alt-Right ," Breitbart, March 29, 2016.
[4] David Lev, " Amira Hass: I've Had it With the Jew s," Israel National News, September, 10, 2011. To Levy, Israel can never do any good. In an op-ed titled "Real Leftists Won't Go to the Ceremony for Yitzhak Rabin," he writes, "Peace was murdered with or without Rabin because Israel didn't want it. It never seriously wanted it because it includes the end of the occupation, which it has never agreed to give up. No ceremony will change that." Gideon Levy, " Real Leftists Won't Go to the Ceremony for Yitzhak Rabin ," Haaretz , Nov. 3, 2016.
[5] For instance, Hass is favorably cited by Norman Finkelstein , MondoWeiss , and Democracy Now. Gideon Levy has been praised by the dean of anti-Zionist intellectuals, Noam Chomsky, as "an early Jewish prophet." Johann Hari, " Is Gideon Levy the Most Hated Man in Israel or just the Most Heroic? ", Independent , Sept. 23, 2010.
Tags
Who is online
137 visitors

Although I defended Bannon with respect to the accusation of his being an anti-Semite, I had supported his appointment as an advisor of strategy since his strategy was in fact so successful as to lead to the election of an underdog without government experience, one of the least acceptable candidates for POTUS in history, notwithstanding spending a quarter of the funds on the campaign as Hilliary had done. Obviously his strategy was effective, even if undesirable. I took a "wait and see" attitude which I believe is not unfair for anyone.
However, since I have the deepest respect for and admiration of Professor Emeritus of Law at Harvard University, Alan M. Dershowitz, I will almost always say that he speaks for me. Whether a person is a liberal or a conservative, so long as they are not ultra-liberal or ultra-conservative, makes little difference to me, and Dershowitz is a liberal. If he feels Bannon is the wrong person for the job, I will take what he says a lot more seriously than I will the usual biased pundits, and I agree with him. Therefore, IMO, Bannon is wrong for that position.
I hope this establishes that I am mature enough to be flexible in my opinions, more so than a lot of NT members and what they accuse me of.
By the way, please take note that this was published by Gatestone Institute, a source that some on this site feel is an ultra-right wing publication, whereas this article, you will note, supports a liberal viewpoint written by a liberal author.
Dershowitz managed to turn every single paragraph in this article into an examination of what various groups and people think about Jews or Israel. The issue with Bannon goes well beyond anti-semitism. The alt-right is a white nationalist world view.
You seem to not see past the Israel issue, whereas I see the article as being a declaration that Bannon is not an anti-Semite, but is a person who should not be appointed to a Trump-advisor position. God forbid Israel should be used to make a point.
In all of this article, there are about two or three sentences concerning the other groups that the alt-right is against besides Jews. That is my point, it is your freedom to accept that point or not. No problem.
I wonder why a Jewish Israel-supporter would write an article using his religion and knowledge for an example of his attitude.
As the late great Leonard Cohen wrote in his poem-song "Anthem", "There is a crack, a crack in everything. That's how the light gets in."
He can do whatever he wants. But Bannon's lack of fitness for the job goes beyond how it relates to what people think of Israel or Jews. You wouldn't know that reading Dershowitz article though.
Dershowitz wrote above:
"Both Bannon and Breitbart have made bigoted statements about Muslims, women and others, which I do not condone. That is why I do not support Bannon..."
"Bigotry against any group should be disqualifying for high office."
"People of good will, Jews and non-Jews, must condemn with equal vigor all manifestations of bigotry whether they emanate from the hard alt-right or hard alt-left."
As I said, he used that with which he was most familiar, even though it might have been limited, to make his point and apply to the generalization of why Bannon should NOT serve as Trump's advisor-in-chief. John, you are just TOO picky when it does not meet YOUR standard. Maybe it's because you despise Gatestone Institute no matter what is published by it.
Bannon's lack of fitness for the job goes beyond how it relates to what people think of Israel or Jews.
I think Dershowitz pretty much made that clear in the article.
You wouldn't know that reading Dershowitz article though.
I disagree, Dershowitz is a lawyer and he said what he thinks in the way lawyers say things.
It is nice to see you have change your point of view on Bannon. I do applaud you for your flexibility on this. I have always opposed him, but not because of any personal antisemitism of his, but rather because of his undeniable connection with and support of alt right White Nationalism, which is just a new way of saying White Supremacism, who are also as a rule antisemitic.
Thank you Randy. I have always admitted openly when I was wrong. There are others here who steadfastly refuse to do so.
Though I do think that in the grand scheme of things the appointment of Lt. General Flynn to National Security Advisor is going to to much, much, much more damage to America intentionally, considering his very,very close ties to Russia and Putin.
Though I do think that in the grand scheme of things the appointment of Lt. General Flynn to National Security Advisor is going to to much, much, much more damage to America intentionally, considering his very,very close ties to Russia and Putin.
That is only the beginning. Wait until Trump has his entire Cabinet seated. The people both the left and the right, will be wanting to impeach him before he is even sworn in.
Trumpism, if we allow it to take place, is going to do great damage to our country, domestically and in our foreign policy.
What did he have to say about Obamas current chief strategist? Probably nothing because he is an Obama - Hillary fluffer.
Hillary isn't the elected Pres, Trump is. Therefore she no longer matters. Bannon matters.
I asked what he had to say about Obamas strategist? Obama is the president.
I can tell you he would not be critical of Obamas current chief strategist because he is pro Obama and anti Trump. We see how he operates.
Bannon matters.
Bannon doesn't just matter, he matters very much. He is an issue and a story that will never go away as long as he is in the White House. The pressure on Trump to get rid of him will never go away or wane. He's just that toxic.
It's amusing watching obama voters flip out over bannon. Obama had much closer ties to an actual, full fledged racist than the eight degrees of seperation they are trying to condemn Bannon by.
And yet he was critical of the alt left, too... something you both are missing.
Obama had much closer ties to an actual, full fledged racist than the eight degrees of seperation they are trying to condemn Bannon by.
"Much deeper"?
I'm not sure who you're referring to, but I don't know of any racist that Obama appointed to take an office in the White House.
There are a lot of fish in the sea. Why not pick one that has less baggage? I hardly think that Dershowitz is an alt left guy..and he isn't condemning Bannon.
Because Trump knows who Trump wants to work with better than Dershowitz knows who Trump wants to work with. Does Trump tell Dershowitz who to hire to mow his lawn? If Dershowitz wants to pick the guy for the job than Dershowitz needs to win the presidency.
Where do you see that Dershowitz advises or tells Trump NOT to hire Bannon? From my reading of the article all he has said is that he would not personally be supportive of Trump's hiring of Bannon. He is merely giving his personal opinion but where is the demand? Nobody is denying your giving your opinion on such matters but you cannot expect us to think that you require for us to obey you.
Ok I agree with with you.
Does Trump tell Dershowitz who to hire to mow his lawn?
No one cares who mows Dershowitz's lawn or any other person he hires. They do not have an office in the American White House advising the President of the United States.
Dean said that as an example, and I see nothing wrong with his doing so having used simple examples for more complex issues myself, but it is inaccurate, as I pointed out.
"..and he isn't condemning Bannon."
Perrie, please.
From the article;
"Both Bannon and Breitbart have made bigoted statements about Muslims, women and others, which I do not condone. That is why I do not support Bannon, even though I do not think he's an anti-Semite. Bigotry against any group should be disqualifying for high office."
I'm not sure what your mean by "condemning", but that does not look like any kind of support.
Well, Jerry, condoning means agreeing with or going along with. So what Dershowitz said is that he didn't agree or go along with Bannon on those issues, but that doesn't mean he condemns Bannon. It's no different than if I said I don't agree with children reading Playboy magazine but I'm not condemning them for doing so.
Your statement "Dershowitz is a lawyer and he said what he thinks in the way lawyers say things." is quite accurate. Lawyers are very careful with the language that they use so as not to be ambiguous or misunderstood. The misuse of just one word in a contract can lead to a million dollar lawsuit.
Your statement "Dershowitz is a lawyer and he said what he thinks in the way lawyers say things." is quite accurate. Lawyers are very careful with the language that they use so as not to be ambiguous or misunderstood.
I've seen many Dershowitz interviews on CNN, and I see he is firmly planted on the left side of most issues. I believe, given the latitude, he would openly condemn the likes of Bannon.
We can argue all day about what is in the brilliant mind of Alan Dersowitz, but it makes no difference. Trump giving Steve Bannon an important advisory office in the White House is a sign we are in for a very rough 4 years of an alt-Right administration.
Good article Buzz.