Sheriffs Refuse to Send Troops to Standing Rock as Public Outrage and Costs Mount
posted Nov 23, 2016
Sheriffs Refuse to Send Troops to Standing Rock as Public Outrage and Costs Mount
North Dakota’s resources are stretching thin.
Sheriff Kyle Kirchmeier announced the aid of CBP officers Monday following the most violent confrontation yet near the Standing Rock Sioux reservation. Dozens of activists were hospitalized after Sunday night’s standoff when police sprayed water on hundreds of people in 26-degree temperatures and fired what has been described as concussion grenades. One activist, Sophia Wilansky, 21, may face the amputation of her arm.
Even before Sunday’s subfreezing assault on the Backwater Bridge, the escalating violence, the masses of arrests—528 as of Monday—and even the routine response to demonstrations were taking their toll on local agencies. The policing costs have reached nearly $15 million. The courts are taxed. The jail is burdened. The 34 local law enforcement officers are stressed.
All this comes amid an increasingly loud public outcry against the militarized policing.
Photo by Rob Wilson.
Organized campaigns to contact the people and agencies responsible for sending officers and equipment to aid Morton County in the assaults on water protectors have in some cases been effective. YES! Magazine published that contact information Oct. 31, and in less than a month, the Facebook post had reached more than half a million people with commenters trading stories about their experiences making complaints. The article has been published by media worldwide.
It was intense public response that led Montana’s Gallatin County Sheriff Brian Gootkin to literally turn his detail around. He and his deputies were en route to Morton County when Gov. Steve Bullock raised concerns about the potential misuse of the interstate statute. The Emergency Management Assistance Compact obligates law enforcement around the country to fulfill requests for aid under any form of emergency or disaster.
“I got messages from England, Poland, New Zealand, Australia,” Gootkin recalled. And he received phone calls and hundreds of emails from his constituents, too — people that may have elected him sheriff. They were concerned about the use of force on protesters, Oct. 27, he said, and also had been affected by the public outrage from Minneapolis’ Hennepin County.
Gootkin said the callers and emailers believed the EMAC was meant for natural disasters and catastrophic events like 9/11, not for protecting a corporation’s pipeline construction. All that caused Sheriff Gootkin to change his mind. He turned to Facebook to post his decision to stand down on Standing Rock: “Although my actions were well-intentioned, you made it clear that you do not want your Sheriff’s Office involved in this conflict. One of the biggest differences of an elected Sheriff from other law enforcement leaders is that I am directly accountable to the people I serve (YOU).”
It was not an easy choice to make, Gootkin said. “I wanted to go and help my fellow law enforcement.” Then, he raised a question that has begun to rattle many communities across America lately. “I just don’t understand where we separated from the public. It really breaks my heart. We are not the enemy.”
Sheriff Dave Mahoney from Wisconsin’s Dane County was also empathetic to those decrying deployment of his officers. “All share the opinion that our deputies should not be involved in this situation,” Mahoney told the Bismarck Tribune . He and his unit stood by Morton County officers for one week before pulling out and refusing to return.
Photo by Rob Wilson.
This week, the ACLU released the most comprehensive list of law enforcement participating in the conflict at Standing Rock, 75 agencies total, all believed to be operating under the EMAC agreement. The ACLU’s current list of agency support to Morton County can be found here .
Of the $15 million spent so far to protect the pipeline construction , $4.4 million has been spent by Morton County alone, officials said. The figure also includes more than $10 million in state emergency funds, according to Cecily Fong, spokeswoman for the North Dakota Department of Emergency Services. Fong told the Associated Press that protest-related law enforcement costs reached $10.9 million dollars last week, including $6 million borrowed from the state-owned Bank of North Dakota in September and an additional $4 million on Nov. 1.
Nearly 1,300 officers have come from 24 counties.
Now it seems likely that the state will need to request even more money from its Emergency Commission. In a press conference two days prior to Sunday’s violence, Gov. Jack Dalrymple expressed frustration in the ongoing police action against protesters. “We’re incurring expenses every day,” Dalrymple said.
The governor has pressed the Obama administration for federal aid in responding to the escalating conflict. He has suggested the U.S. Marshal Service step in to evict thousands of protectors who have occupied U.S. Army Corps of Engineers land. “They are camped without a permit,” Dalrymple said of those occupying the mass encampment near the Backwater Bridge blockade. “In other words, they’re there illegally.”
But the Obama administration has refused to do that, opting to sit down with the Standing Rock Sioux and negotiate a solution. It has asked that construction of the $3.8 billion pipeline stop until one is reached, but Energy Transfer has refused. It is now suing the federal government and meanwhile continuing to advance the pipeline.
With the absence of federal assistance, Morton County has had to rely on the EMAC and support from police agencies nationwide. Since early August, the sheriff’s department says that nearly 1,300 officers have come from 24 counties, 16 cities, across nine different states.
The number of law enforcement agencies assisting Morton County has dwindled.
The farthest traveled was the president of the National Sheriff’s Association, Greg Champagne of St. Charles Parish, Louisiana. He arrived Oct. 28, the day after Morton County led its heavily militarized removal of occupants from the “1851 Treaty Camp.” In a lengthy post on Facebook, Champagne commended the multiagency action while taking special care to praise Minnesota’s Hennepin County Sheriff Rich Stanek. He said they were “protecting lives and property” that day.
But in the aftermath of the violent Oct. 27 raid, the number of law enforcement agencies assisting Morton County has dwindled — in some instances, because of the pipeline‘s polarizing effect.
Minneapolis’ Hennepin County has received some of the loudest public outrage as taxpayers, voters, even state lawmakers turned out to denounce Sheriff Stanek’s decision to send Minnesota personnel and equipment to Standing Rock. “I do not have any control over the Sheriff’s actions, which I think were wrong,” said Lt. Gov. Tina Smith in a prepared statement. “I believe he should bring his deputies home, if he hasn’t already. I strongly support the rights of all people to peacefully protest, including, tonight, the Standing Rock protest.”
Following a nine-day stint in North Dakota, Sheriff Stanek said enlisting 29 of his deputies to serve on Morton County’s front lines was “the right thing to do.”
But he also said his deputies would not be returning.

Now Customs Service and Border Patrol are going to ND...
I thought that they were overburdened...
Ever think of why the taxes your paying are going to put the BP in ND?
ND is getting so desperate to gain control over the situation that they are burying themselves deeper and deeper. And yes, what a wonderful way to use our tax dollars. What the hell does Customs Service and Border Patrol have to do with an internal state event?
Answer: Nothing.
If they show up, I am complaining to the state department. I am not paying for ND gov. to be an ass and help big oil that isn't even ours.
Seems as though they are already there from different things that I've read.
''Sheriff Kyle Kirchmeier announced the aid of CBP officers Monday following the most violent confrontation yet near the Standing Rock Sioux reservation. ''
As we all know, recently there has been animosity by certain groups against the actions of certain police, leading the police themselves to have the publicity benefit of BLUE Lives Matter. The article indicates that many Police forces are not returning to do defend the pipeline, such defence opposed by so many of their neighbours and others. I always look to classic movies for similarities and actuality contrary to the usual adage, Life Imitates Art, rather than Art Imitates Life. Near the end of the movie Schindler's List, when the war was lost by the Germans, Schindler's workers, all Jewish prisoners, were gathered together, and the Nazi officers and soldiers were there under Hitler's orders to murder them before leaving, they refused, each one, because as Schindler said to them, here they are, ready for you to kill them, but would you rather go home to your families or as men. Perhaps the forces at the pipeline want to do that as well.
Sadly Buzz, it's all becoming clear as to why the U.S. Customs Service and Border Patrol are there. Although the LEO/sheriff's are not going back or not going at all the Standing Rock Sioux received this letter for the ACOE today...They have given the Sioux a special permit to camp out north of the river, now they are closing it and the Oceti Sakowin camp, the largest of the three camps.
The feds are working for DAPL as well...
Oooops. I left out an important word. Schindler asked the German solders if they would rather go home to their families as MURDERERS or as men.
I've seen the movie a number of times and remembered the statement, Buzz...No worries.
Sorry Kavika, I'm unable to open a google link.
The link explains that the COE issued a ''special use permit'' to the Standing Rock Sioux to camp out on land north of the Missouri river...But now have told the Water Protectors that it was being cancelled and their had to leave by December 5th or be evicted.
Typical, the LEO's are not going or have left and are not returning so the COE decided to support DAPL.
On December 4th, around 1,000 Veterans Stand For Standing Rock will arrive at the grounds...
I wonder if the U.S. Customs and Border Patrol will fire on American Veterans....
In the letter from the COE it was stated that they were going to set up a ''free speech zone''...
Here's an idea: if the government is establishing zones for free speech, maybe your speech isn't so free after all.
Think about that.
Yep... Scary thought!
Definitely not FREE if you're an Indian.
Nor free if you're just a regular person, either, fighting for what you believe to be right.
Power to the Tribes.
Hopefully the government will hear you dd.
I honestly don't see how any decent LEO can go there with a clear conscience to put down the protests. It is law-abiding, peaceful, and a civil right to do so. All for big oil! And the border patrol is now stepping in? They have a lack of funds? Hell, make the pipeline company pay for the protection they are so willing to take advantage of.
I posted a letter on FB whereby the medical industry is coming out against the police for their tactics. Good thing, too!
Standing beside you, any way I can.
Dowser, post the letter here in the article.
I will if I can find it again, Kavika... I go to so many different places, it's hard to keep up.
This is not exactly what I read before, but it is close!
Our team has been working around the clock in response to Sunday's violent response from police. See video footage and commentary here from CNN International. If you want to support our efforts with a tax deductible donation, or help us replenish much needed supplies, please visit www.medichealercouncil.com/donate/
Dear Sir or Madam,
We acknowledge good receipt of your message and thank you for your interest in the Cour ... See More
I wouldn't move an inch. Free speech is guaranteed under our Constitution. Even the Westboro Baptist Church could ruin funerals of our brave service men.... and the courts supported them. This is total BS.
Dear Friend Perrie: Well said.
E.
Cheyenne River Sioux Tribe Reacts to U.S. Army Corps of Engineers Eviction Notice: Your Letter Makes a Grave & Dangerous Mistake
Published November 26, 2016
EAGLE BUTTE, SOUTH DAKOTA – Cheyenne River Sioux Tribe Chairman Harold Frazier was quick to respond to the U.S Army Corps of Engineers’ letter, dated November 25, 2016, that will evict the water protectors who are camping at Oceti Sakowin camp. The 10-day eviction notice came one day after Thanksgiving where thousands have come to show solidarity with the water protectors who oppose the Dakota Access pipeline.
Read Frazier’s letter below:
November 25, 2016
Colonel John W. Henderson
Commander and District Engineer
Omaha District, U.S. Army Corps of Engineers
1616 Capitol Avenue
Suite 900
Omaha, NE 68102
Re: November 25, 2016, Letter Regarding Closure of Treaty Lands
Dear Col. Henderson:
This letter responds to your correspondence, dated November 25, 2016, announcing the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers’ (“Corps”) plan to close certain “Corps’ managed lands to all public use and access effective December 5, 2016.” You state that “[t]his decision is necessary to protect the general public from the violent confrontations between protestors and law enforcement officials that have occurred in this area, and to prevent death, illness, or serious injury to inhabitants of encampments due to the harsh North Dakota winter conditions.”
You have warned that anyone found outside of a so-called “free speech zone” will be considered trespassing and may be subject to prosecution under federal state, and local laws.” You have asked me to “encourage members of [the Cheyenne River Sioux Tribe], as well as any non-members who support you who are located in the encampments north of the Cannonball River on Corps lands to immediately and peacefully move to the free speech zone. . . .”
The area north of the Cannonball River is both the ancestral homeland of the Lakota people and inside the boundaries of the 1851 Fort Laramie Treaty, a treaty that has not been abrogated and law that governs us all. The best of these lands have already been unjustly taken and flooded by the Corps in the disastrous Pick-Sloane legislation. We will no longer allow our rights as a Tribe or as indigenous people as a whole to continue to be eroded.
This decision, coming on the heels of the Thanksgiving holiday, is not only disrespectful, but continues the cycle of racism and oppression imposed on our people and our lands throughout history.
We ask that the Corps and the United States reconsider this decision. Treaties are the supreme law of the land and the Constitution of the United States demands that they be respected. Removal from Sioux Treaty lands should be the choice of the Oceti Sakowin Camp north of the Cannonball River, not the United States, which has been violating our rights for hundreds of years. The Cheyenne River Sioux Tribe stands with the more than 300 Tribal nations and the water protectors who are here peacefully protesting the Dakota Access pipeline while defending the rights of indigenous people.
Furthermore, your letter dangerously and profoundly misunderstands the basic function and status of a tribal government and its elected leaders. I am the chief executive of a sovereign nation that is comprised of individual citizens with physical territory within the exterior boundaries the State of South Dakota. Under the laws of the United States, my government lacks jurisdiction at Cannonball; but more importantly, I no more control the acts and behaviors of Cheyenne River Sioux Tribal members or non-member water protectors at the Cannonball site than you do, Col. Henderson.
Perhaps the most terrifying aspect of your letter is your acknowledgement of the stark reality that that the confrontation between our peaceful water protectors and law enforcement could result in death or serious injury, a fact demonstrated by the brutal attack on Sophia Wilansky by North Dakota police last week. But in the very next paragraph you guarantee that further confrontations will occur by promising that these peaceful people will be trespassing on closed areas and you threaten that they will do so “ at their own risk ” and will “ assume[] any and all corresponding liabilities for their unlawful presence and occupation of such lands. ”
I take your letter as issuing a direct and irresponsible threat to the water protectors. It appears to further empower the militarized police force that has been brutalizing and terrorizing our water protectors while imposing the blame and the risk on unarmed peaceful people. We have pleaded for the protection of the United States. Your letter makes a grave and dangerous mistake. Federal efforts to de-escalate the violence should be aimed at the wrongdoers, not at our peaceful people
Sincerely,
Harold Frazier, Chairman
Cheyenne River Sioux Tribe
Wonderful letter!!! It needs to be publicized everywhere!