Sanders : Carrier just showed corporations how to beat Donald Trump
Carrier just showed corporations how to beat Donald Trump
We need a president who can stand up to big corporations, not fold to their demands.
By Bernie Sanders December 1 at 6:00 AM
Donald Trump is going to have to toughen up if he wants to serve American workers. (Steven Senne/AP)
Today, about 1,000 Carrier workers and their families should be rejoicing. But the rest of our nation’s workers should be very nervous.
President-elect Donald Trump will reportedly announce a deal with United Technologies, the corporation that owns Carrier, that keeps less than 1,000 of the 2,100 jobs in America that were previously scheduled to be transferred to Mexico. Let’s be clear: It is not good enough to save some of these jobs. Trump made a promise that he would save all of these jobs , and we cannot rest until an ironclad contract is signed to ensure that all of these workers are able to continue working in Indiana without having their pay or benefits slashed.
In exchange for allowing United Technologies to continue to offshore more than 1,000 jobs , Trump will reportedly give the company tax and regulatory favors that the corporation has sought . Just a short few months ago, Trump was pledging to force United Technologies to “ pay a damn tax .” He was insisting on very steep tariffs for companies like Carrier that left the United States and wanted to sell their foreign-made products back in the United States. Instead of a damn tax, the company will be rewarded with a damn tax cut . Wow! How’s that for standing up to corporate greed? How’s that for punishing corporations that shut down in the United States and move abroad?
In essence, United Technologies took Trump hostage and won. And that should send a shock wave of fear through all workers across the country.
Trump has endangered the jobs of workers who were previously safe in the United States. Why? Because he has signaled to every corporation in America that they can threaten to offshore jobs in exchange for business-friendly tax benefits and incentives. Even corporations that weren’t thinking of offshoring jobs will most probably be reevaluating their stance this morning. And who would pay for the high cost for tax cuts that go to the richest businessmen in America? The working class of America.
Let’s be clear. United Technologies is not going broke. Last year, it made a profit of $7.6 billion and received more than $6 billion in defense contracts . It has also received more than $50 million from the Export-Import Bank and very generous tax breaks. In 2014, United Technologies gave its former chief executive Louis Chenevert a golden parachute worth more than $172 million . Last year, the company’s five highest-paid executives made more than $50 million . The firm also spent $12 billion to inflate its stock price instead of using that money to invest in new plants and workers.
Does that sound like a company that deserves more corporate welfare from our government? Trump’s Band-Aid solution is only making the problem of wealth inequality in America even worse.
I said I would work with Trump if he was serious about the promises he made to members of the working class. But after running a campaign pledging to be tough on corporate America, Trump has hypocritically decided to do the exact opposite. He wants to treat corporate irresponsibility with kid gloves. The problem with our rigged economy is not that our policies have been too tough on corporations; it’s that we haven’t been tough enough.
We need to re-instill an ethic of corporate patriotism. We need to send a very loud and clear message to corporate America: The era of outsourcing is over. Instead of offshoring jobs, the time has come for you to start bringing good-paying jobs back to America.
If United Technologies or any other company wants to keep outsourcing decent-paying American jobs, those companies must pay an outsourcing tax equal to the amount of money they expect to save by moving factories to Mexico or other low-wage countries. They should not receive federal contracts or other forms of corporate welfare. They must pay back all of the tax breaks and other corporate welfare they have received from the federal government. And they must not be allowed to reward their executives with stock options, bonuses or golden parachutes for outsourcing jobs to low-wage countries. I will soon be introducing the Outsourcing Prevention Act, which will address exactly that.
If Donald Trump won’t stand up for America’s working class, we must.
https://www.washingtonpost.com/posteverything/wp/2016/12/01/bernie-sanders-carrier-just-showed-corporations-how-to-beat-donald-trump/?utm_term=.98de6f6eada9

The first minute and a half or so of this video can be skipped without missing the point.
The point is that Pence acted as governor by bribing the company to remain in Indiana . 700 k$ is a small price to pay to keep 1000 jobs in state . The taxes those workers pay will quickly pay that amount back ...
I think the irony of this move is over your head.
I don't think it went over his head at all. His point was $7,000,000 is a small price to pay to keep 1,000 jobs in this country. You're thinking what Trump used to get elected, he isn't doing now and the Democrats would rather see those 1,000 jobs leave the country instead of seeing Trump succeed in saving them.
It wouldn't surprise me if some of those wackos don't boycott Carrier for staying in the country.
I think the irony of this move is over your head.
Here's a thought .. your "irony" is all in your head . But if you need to feel superior by flinging around terms you don't understand , have at it !
Trump just did exactly what he campaigned not to do, and what he called other politicians losers over. Furthermore, now he is stuck. Carrier is not the only US corporation with ambitions to leave, and Trump knows that this scenario is untenable in the long run. Keep blowing smoke up his ass though, like a good little dupe.
Doesn't it just kill them having Trump campaign right out of their playbook and beat them at it?
Remember it's unpatriotic.
This has been very big news here in Louisville, as can be expected. Dancing in the streets type of thing... Me? I'm leery of anything that signals MORE corporate breaks. Tax cuts only go to the richer people of society, not the poor schmo who is working his legs off in a factory....
Just another smoke and mirrors/Trump thing.
Let's just say the average income for each employee is $50,000. It's probably more, but that will do. So $50,000 times $1000 = $50,000,00 for next year in taxable income before deductions at the current rate of 25% for $37,651 - $91,150 incomes = $12,500,000 in Federal taxes. That pretty much so covers the $7,000,000 over the 10 year period.
These people will also be paying State taxes. They will also be paying property taxes on the home they will not have to run the risk of losing. They will also be purchasing goods with the money they earn and be paying Sales taxes. Of course they will be paying these things anyway, if they can keep their home, find another job when some of them have been working for years at Carrier and are at that ripe old age where no one wants a 50 year old man or woman at that price, the price of what they were making before they lost their job.
So Dowser, it's a mathematical calculation and it just looks overwhelmingly beneficial to the people, the Federal government, the community, and the State.
Mathematically, it hasn't worked for KY, who has given away so many tax breaks, we can't fund zilch. What seemed like a good thing in the short term, has had far-reaching consequences.
A prime example is the Noah's Ark in north central KY. The state bought the land, and gave it to them, then offered tax incentives to the on-going operation of the business. The Ark is not necessarily a bust, but it hasn't performed as well as it was predicted, so the "loan" term is now about 40 years, rather than 20. The the little town of Williamsburg, that had such dreams of hotel complexes and all kinds of tourist traps, is still the little town of Williamsburg with maybe 2 gas stations. The jobs are great, yeah, but they are all low-paying jobs, AND the workers have no place to live... There is insufficient infrastructure to support any real expansion, nor any money to build some-- thanks to the tax breaks.
What looks good on paper doesn't necessarily work in real life.
So 1000 of the original 2000 Carrier jobs that were going to leave the country are still going to leave the country.
I have a question -- is President Trump still going to make Carrier "pay a damn tax" ?
It doesn't sound like it.
You're just used to Obama overstepping his boundaries. Setting the taxes is the job of congress not the president. They've already been reporting tax reform is going to be one of the first things they start working on when Obama is out of the way and they have a president that can work with congress. Let's not put the cart before the horse he's not in power yet.
Well John, let me ask you a question? How many of those jobs did President Obama talk Carrier into keeping here in the states? You know, the current President of the United States? Or was he too busy golfing and chastising Fox News to be bothered?
I find great amusement in socialists telling businessmen how to do business.
Donald Trump told his campaign audiences that companies that moved jobs to Mexico would have to pay a heavy tax in order to sell the goods back in America.
Is that pledge still operative after Carrier was given concessions to keep half the endangered jobs in Indiana?
Hard to say, considering he's not President yet.
But what he DID already accomplish with Carrier, he did before the inauguration.
I find great amusement in socialists telling businessmen how to do business.
They certainly have no idea of how it is done.
If I were a corporation in Indiana, I'd be looking into the prospect of sending jobs across the border - now that it's out that the governor is a little bitch that can be extorted. Indiana residents must be so proud at how their taxes were just spent. Be proud America - that's your future president playing mafia with our country.
now that it's out that the governor is a little bitch that can be extorted
This is a transparent attempt to get someone to call you a little bitch & draw a CoC violation . But its far too transparent & far too inaccurate to succeed ...
Uhhhh ... ok.
Bottom line is 1,000 jobs were lost and 1,000 stayed in the U.S.
The reports are the Carrier was given $7 million in tax breaks over 10 years. If there are other concessions I haven't seen them.
1,000 have jobs. 1,000 don't have jobs and there is $7 million dollar in taxes that have to be made up somewhere.
Good deal?
I predict that once he is in office and he's able to start finalizing the "details" of this "deal" we're going to see him put in place a law that punishes companies which will end up nullifying this "deal" and Carrier will learn what so many other companies and businesses and private contractors have learned.........Donald Trump doesn't keep his word and he doesn't meet his obligations.
Donald Trump has had over 500 businesses. He's had around 50 bankruptcies. That's 10%. Over 90% of companies starting out in business go bankrupt. That's a pretty good record. You've been listening to too much MSM PJ. Didn't you learn something when The New York Times gave Hillary an 80% chance of winning the election on the day of the election? No offense, just stating some facts here.
Donald Trump is a pathological liar. Nothing will change as far as that goes just because he will be the president.
Obama will continue to be a pathological public liar until late January . Then he will pass from the public eye ...
Donald Trump is a pathological liar. Nothing will change as far as that goes just because he will be the president.
You won't get an argument from me on that issue.
Donald Trump doesn't keep his word and he doesn't meet his obligations.
You seem to have missed the point that this agreement was between Pence & Carrier . Its a state-wide thing ... DUH !
The lefties will take advantage of any opportunity to diss Trump. What a mindset.
1000 jobs more than there would have been-1000 Americans working that wouldn't be working. It's not perfect, but it's better than the amount of jobs that President Obama has talked carrier into keeping here in the states.
Not having studied Economics, I'm curious about whether the welfare and unemployment benefits that would be paid to 1000 families whose wage-earners have lost their jobs would equal or even outstrip the tax breaks given to the employer. Can anyone provide an answer to that? Let's not take into consideration the emotional distress and its effects upon the families and in many cases the mental illnesses and family breakups that ensue.
Let's put it this way. The cost per year per employee would be $700. I would be happy to pay $700 to keep my job if it was in jeopardy. The unemployment benefits in Indiana can be up to $390 per week. It wouldn't take but a couple of weeks of being unemployed to pass that $700. ($7,000,000 divided by 1000 = $700) ($390 times 26 weeks = $10,140)
Unemployment Benefits Info for Indiana
Six,
We really don't know if there was a benefit, since we don't know the deal. I have read several versions of what "those in the know", think the deal is. If he paid off Carrier, yes he saved those jobs.. but how much did he pay them off for? If he blackmailed Carrier (80% of their business in with the Pentagon), then it didn't cost us a dime, and it was a good thing. The whole issue is not that he kept the jobs, but how did he keep the jobs and that does make a difference. And from my understanding of this, no one really knows how he did it.
Buzz, without knowing the dollar amount of the unemployment benefits it would be impossible to determinate that...Unemployment benefits differ from state to state.
Maybe someone knows what such benefits are in Indiana.
I wouldn't worry too much about all this BS. So it is going to cost the American taxpayer $7 million dollars over 10 years .
At least it's not costing over $500 million dollars in less than 2 years like this one.
Vice President Joseph R. Biden touted the Solyndra plant’s groundbreaking, addressing the event by video in 2009, and Mr. Obama himself visited the plant in 2010 to tout it as an example of his green energy plans, raising the stakes involved in the project.
I assume the 7 million dollar payoff to Carrier is related in some way to the difference in their profit potential in Mexico vs Indiana. Or 7 million is all Pence could get his hands on. Carrier's parent company is a defense contractor or wannabe defense contractor. Trump is going to spend on the military. What happens when a company that wants to outsource jobs overseas is not in a state where trump's vp is governor or doesn't care about defense contracts?
States offer incentives for companies to open businesses in their states. Pence may have stated on as governor and that may have been the reason, but whether he was there or not, the states will do what they can to bring businesses into their state. No matter what, this is a small but overwhelming beneficial deal that kept the 1000 jobs in Indiana as you can see from my previous comments. It's in the math.
Let's hope we can keep many more companies in this country at such a small cost as this one was.
Actually I think we will have to find other avenues to build businesses since the whole manufacturing business is changing rapidly as well.
I think Governor Cuomo (Far Left Democrat) has been touting his plan for businesses to come to New York with 10 years of tax breaks. I guess that whole trickle down thing only works if a Democrat institutes it.
Is there a plastic surgeon in the house?
If there is, she could use a little help as well.
Well, you asked for that one, John.
Is Trump staring in a remake of Mask?
"I’ve watched as politicians talked about stopping companies from leaving our states, ... 'Here’s a tax abatement of any kind you want. We’ll help your employees.' It doesn’t work, folks. That’s not what they need. They have money. They want to go out, they want to move to another country, and because our politicians are so dumb, they want to sell their product to us and not have any retribution, not have any consequence."
- Donald Trump in Pennsylvania
At least he is admitting that he is just another dumb politician now.If Trump saved the Carrier jobs , why didn't he save all of them?
Could it be that the ones he saved were never for sure being moved to Mexico anyway?
I just saw a video of Trump saying "I told Carrier they are not taking those jobs to Mexico".
Which jobs?
The 1,000 jobs saved are a good thing, but if anyone thinks that we will ever reach the goal of bringing all manufacturing jobs back to the U.S. you're living in a dream world.
With the increase in productivity, automation, and better supply chain management, those jobs will not be coming back, because they no longer exist.
This isn't about Trump/Obama etc, it's the reality of the world and the advancement of automation. The ''new'' manufacturing job is not going to be grunt work, it's going to require computer skills. What it took 10 people to do in a automobile manufacturing plant a couple of decade ago now takes one person. Those other 9 jobs are gone forever. You can apply that to every manufacturing company in the U.S. and world wide.
U.S. manufacturing has been going though a dramatic change for years, and it's not going to be reversed.
That's the real truth of the matter, Kavika. Manufacturing is a dying business model for this country. It may be great for the third world countries, but that is because the cost of manufacturing products in their countries are very low compared to industrialized countries.
We want $15.00 an hour for taking an order at a fast food restaurant. Well the fellow in one of these third world countries wants 15 cents an hour for making your iPhone.
Carrier is making money for it's stockholders without moving to Mexico. They want more money.
This is the ultimate effect of capitalism. The thirst for more profit is insatiable , and the mechanism, one of the mechanisms, is the race for the lowest wages possible for the workers.
Trump is planning on setting up a competition among US states where they will each try and steal (lure) companies and businesses from other states. One certain component of this will be a competition to pay lower wages (more profit then for the non workers). What business will forego the opportunity to pay lower wages?
With the increase in productivity, automation, and better supply chain management, those jobs will not be coming back, because they no longer exist.
I got news for you Kavika.. those supply chain management jobs are also going to India. Just ask Matt.
Perrie, I was speaking of the mega ocean carriers that can handle up to 18,000 containers of goods. The double stack trains that carry multi contains cross country in a few days. Todays retailer has ''just in time delivery''....Which allows them control their inventory in a much better way.
The control aspect has in many ways been outsourced to India etc. That is a problem in that the white collar workers is also losing his/her job.
Trump Suggests He Followed Through on Carrier Deal Just to Save Face
By Eric Levitz
On Thursday, Donald Trump scored a big public-relations victory, which may prove to be the first step on a road to widespread corporate blackmail and systemic corruption , a long-term pattern in which Trump camouflages his Wall Street agenda with small-scale gestures of populist beneficence — or just a somewhat more secure and happy period in the lives of a bunch of manufacturing workers in Indiana.
To be more concrete: Carrier, a company that makes air conditioners and the like, announced earlier this year that it planned to shut down two of its facilities in Indiana and shift their production lines to Mexico. Carrier did not pursue this move out of financial necessity, but just to increase their medium-term profitability by a little bit.
For a right-wing populist running a campaign against bad trade deals — particularly ones involving Mexico — this was a tremendously useful story. And so Trump made keeping the Carrier plants in Indiana one of his campaign’s clearest promises.
For the past couple of weeks, Trump periodically tweeted about his frenzied efforts to convince Carrier’s senior management not to turn their backs on the Hoosier State. And this week, the president-elect reached a deal with the company, in which Carrier will receive $7 million in tax incentives from Indiana on the condition that it keep one of its facilities in the state, while also investing $16 million into that facility over the next two years. The deal is expected to save more than 1,000 jobs at the plant, and possibly more in the surrounding community, where restaurants and stores profit off the patronage of those manufacturing workers.
Carrier will still be shifting production out of its other Indiana plant, which employs roughly 700 people.
There are a lot of questions swirling around this story. Among them: Did Carrier cut this deal because its parent company was afraid of losing federal contracts ? If so, does that mean Trump will use the coercive power of such contracts to pick winners and losers in the economy on the basis of political expediency — or something far more malignant than that? Will this inspire a wave of companies to threaten to leave the country in search of tax incentives ? Or is this just a harmless little one-off stunt that has the effect of making a major, positive difference in the lives of one Indiana community?
But on one key question — that of Donald Trump’s primary motive for pursuing this unorthodox deal — we appear to have a definitive answer. Or, at least, we have an official answer. Per the Washington Post :
So: According to the president-elect, the story here is that he improvised some nice-sounding populist baloney, realized that cable news was taking it seriously, and begged Carrier to help him save face.
Now that Trump has actually won the presidency, it’s hard to keep characterizing his victories as random accidents — moments when a garbage fire just happened to be in the right garbage place, at the right garbage time.
So maybe Trump is lying about the origins of the deal and simply recognized a useful political prop and then leaned on it as hard as he could. But if that’s true, we return to a whole new set of questions: Why would he tell a national newspaper that he never intended his promise to be taken literally? Why would he portray himself as desperate, powerless phony begging a CEO to bail “us” out (in a context where us seems to refer to his political team, not the people of Indiana)?
Trump’s America is a disorienting place.
I'm sure you support the billions the taxpayer lost on Obamas government brokered bankruptcy of GM under Obama and the tax breaks they got out of the deal.
In total $51 billion taxpayer money has gone in the GM bailout. [91] Until December 10, 2013, the U. S. Treasury recovered $39 billion from selling its GM stake. The final cost of the GM bailout cost the U. S. taxpayer $11 [92] -12 billion ($10.5 billion for General Motors and $1.5 billion for former GM financing GMAC, now known as Ally). [93] Local tax incentives amounted to $1.7 billion, most of them in Michigan. [94] [95]
General Motors Co. will drive away from its U.S.-government-financed restructuring with a final gift in its trunk: a tax break that could be worth as much as $45 billion.
What do you think JR 45 billion tax break vs 7 million what is worse? GM really showed big business how to beat Obama.
To put this into perspective Trump would have to make 6400 of these seven million dollar tax break deals to equal Obamas 45 billion dollar GM tax break deal his car czar arranged.