The most defining moments in America, as ranked by each generation
Historic events come to define our national identity. But do we all agree on what’s important?
Pew asked 2,025 Americans from each generation to name the 10 events in their lifetime with “the greatest impact” on the country. The answers reveal a world newly redefined by the rise of domestic and foreign terrorism, and the transformative role of technology and civil rights.
Everyone agreed on one thing. The attacks of Sept. 11, 2001, stood out as the most important event, cutting across age, race, and political party. Roughly three-quarters (76%) of all respondents included the terror attacks in their top 10, and the events of that day were seen as the most defining overall for each generation, even ranking ahead of World War II for the Silent Generation (born between 1901 and 1927). The next closest contender was Barack Obama’s election to the White House, which 40% of the public named as one of their top events. (It shared the top spot among the survey’s black respondents.)
Selections were limited to events in each respondent’s lifetime. Younger generations’ rankings were dominated by school shootings, bombings, and wars in the Middle East (roughly half of the events). The brighter spots focused on digital technology, gay marriage, and Obama’s election. Baby Boomers and the Silent Generation picked the US civil rights movement, the end of the Cold War, the Vietnam war, and the assassinations of John F. Kennedy and Martin Luther King as the most impactful events in their lifetimes.
You can see all the responses below. The survey was conducted from June to July in 2016 in association with A+E Networks’ HISTORY .
Millenials (born after 1981)
GenX (1965 – 1980)
Baby boomers (1956 – 1964)
Silent Generation (1901 – 1927)
m

For some reason this set of polls left out a large group of people that are still alive, namely those born between 1927 and 1946.
I'm also not sure all these other generational dates are right.
Nonetheless, these sorts of lists are always interesting. There is no doubt that WW2 was a much more monumental "event" than 9-11. There really is no objective comparison in importance between the two.
But WW2 has long been resolved and the aftermath of 9-11 is ongoing , so people somewhat understandably put more importance on 9-11.
My own opinion is that the greatest event on any of these lists was the moon landing in 1969. It is arguably the greatest achievement of the human race.
More info on these lists and associated lists
http://www.people-press.org/2016/12/15/americans-name-the-10-most-significant-historic-events-of-their-lifetimes/?utm_content=bufferb8e99&utm_medium=social&utm_source=twitter.com&utm_campaign=buffer
Being part of the generation that they left out completely, I remember each of the events mentioned.
For me, each had a huge impact so it's difficult to name just one. Vietnam, WWII, Civil Rights movement rate at the top.
I think the advent of Facebook, representative of a ubiquitous online social media is the most important event of the current generation. Instant social communication has changed the way hundreds of millions of people look at the world, and not always for the better.
I guess I am a typical baby boomer, although I would have to move the Obama election and the tech revolution more towards the bottom of the list.
To me, the building of the Berlin Wall had more of an effect on my life than the falling of it. I mean, my Daddy was called up into National Guard service, the Cuban Missile crisis came right after that, and where ever we were living was on the reported 'hit list'. Challenger, while tragic, really had no effect on my life, other than it was shocking at the time.
Not being critical, but I thought Baby Boomers were born from 1946 to 1965...
Not being critical, but I thought Baby Boomers were born from 1946 to 1965...
My understanding as well Dowser.
I've always thought of the Boomers as basically the generation born after WW II. Roughly 1946 to 1966, give or take.
Being a 1952 boomer myself all the noted national bench marks ring true to me as well.
Though I think I'd put the Cultural Revaluation on the list as well. The Sex, Drugs & Rock-n-Roll changes of the 60's.
I know the C. R. played a big role in some of my personal defining moments. Highlighted, (pun intended), by the construction of the Astro Drive-t-In back in 1968.
After picking up Peggy Sue for our date at the Astro, I was surprised when she informed me she was "Holding". Being Sooo naive at the time I asked if she could wait until we got to the drive-in, thinking she had to pee. Peggy laughed and showed me her little match box of weed, first I'd seen. Got my mind blown two different ways that night.
The Astro was also were I first saw, "Night of the Living Dead", while tripping on mescaline. I couldn't believe what I was watching on the screen could really be happening, so much so that I would go back the next night to watch the show straight.
Yep, many fork in the road moments in my own life were thanks to the Sex, Drugs & R&R of the 60's.
One thing is stunning about this whole thing.
Very few people mention the great economic collapse of 2008 at all. This was described as the biggest economic disaster since 1929, which effected tens of millions of people in a very negative way, yet is not seen as being as important as a mass shooting in a nightclub.
The corporate media has everyone buffaloed.
For me, the "W" recession under Reagan had a larger effect, although this last little 'recession' was a nightmare... When gas goes up to $5/gal, it's a nightmare for everyone. And it is all pervasive-- affecting the cost of everything else. Prices that went up to cover the cost of furl surcharges are still there... That's the trouble with it, once they raise the prices on everything, when the reason goes away, the prices remain, and are added to the profit margin...
Dear Friend John Russell: Like our good friend Kavika, I am also of the omitted age group (circa 1946).
I concur. These lists are always interesting. Something to ponder.
I tend to understand history in terms of movements and thier culmination, rather than a specific event in isolation.
The trend in our America is one of increasing inclusion.
From considering African Americans 100% citizens, like all others, giving women the same rights to vote, hold and inherit property, desegregation, recognizing all in marriage, the gradual elimination of impediments for any citizen to exercise their franchise to vote and other such events tell me that America is albeit slowly and unevenly on the right path towards liberty and justice for all.
Those who, for any rationale insist on trying to make any person less than any other are on the wrong side of history.
America the Beautiful is most attractive when all are the same.
No One less or more than the other.
Peace, and Abundant Blessings To All Equally In This and Each Succeeding New Year.
Enoch.
There is some discrepancy in the generational listing, yes they left out a whole chunk of people commonly known as the "GI Generation", and the earlier generations are mostly irrelevant cause if there are any of them still alive, they would probably care less about such polls as this.
And we are talking about the Generations counted in the western world, there are other generations counted amongst other cultures and areas. What this is is a way for those coming of age to rationalize the importance of their contribution to the world around them in relation to those that preceded them.
The generally accepted named generations are thus:
The Lost Generation, 1883 to 1900 , also known as the Generation of 1914 ; obviously those whose major world event was WWI. the last few of these are passing off the earth now.
The G.I. Generation, 1901 to 1924 , also known as the Greatest Generation ; obviously those who grew up during the Great Depression and won WWII. the diminishing generation. In some circles also know as the "Can Do" Generation
The Silent Generation, 1925 to 1945 , also known as the Lucky Few, (described as such by their forebears simply for being born to late on the most part to have worried about WWII usually Americans, personally I would take exception to that millions of children of this generation lost their lives in WWII everywhere but the western hemisphere); the earliest of these also fought in WWII, but their stupendous moment in history would be The Korean and Vietnam wars, many of these helped support the backbone of the revolutionary antiwar '60's also. (great argument could be made to call this the greatest generation for building upon what their forebears started)
The Baby Boomers, 1946 to 1964 , Generally the children of those that won WWII. I fall into this generation (1947). too early for the Korean War, many of this generation count the Vietnam War as their coming of age, a large component of these also had theirs during the antiwar movement and social revolution that took place in America.
Generation X, 1964 to 1984, (commonly abbreviated to Gen X ) the children of the 60's - '70's Oh Boy....{chuckle}
Millennials, 1985 to 2004 , also known as the Millennial Generation or Generation Y ; this generation currently makes up the largest proportion of the population as of April 2016 surpassing the Baby Boomers.
And finally,
Generation Z, 2005 to - , also known as the Founders or Post-Millennials , the iGeneration , or the Homeland Generation ; most sociologists have not settled on a name for this generation yet, and probably won't until they reach coming of age.
Me, I'm a very early Baby Boomer, much of the counter culture sixties and seventies rings true for me, and the boomer political revolution of the 80's (once we actually decided to take charge, while our children the Gen X'ers sorted themselves out, that's embarrassing to say that. We, gave birth to those?)
Any way, each and every generation has their coming of age moment, when they finally wake up and take charge. the inputs to such, what they think of as important is directly born through what they experienced and learned as children of the previous generation.
No one is better than the others...