Pipeline uncertainty illustrates broader concerns for tribes
For hundreds of protesters, it was cause to cheer when the Obama administration this month declined to issue an easement for the Dakota Access pipeline's final segment. But that elation was dampened by the uncertainty of what comes next: a Donald Trump-led White House that might be far less attuned to issues affecting Native Americans.
"With Trump coming into office, you just can't celebrate," said Laundi Germaine Keepseagle, who is 28 and from the Standing Rock Sioux Reservation, where the demonstrators have been camped out near the North Dakota-South Dakota border.
Anxiety over the 1,200-mile pipeline illustrates a broader uncertainty over how tribes will fare under Trump following what many in Indian Country consider a landmark eight years.
President Barack Obama has won accolades among Native Americans for breaking through a gridlock of inaction on tribal issues and for putting a spotlight on their concerns with yearly meetings with tribal leaders.
Under his administration, lawmakers cemented a tribal health care law that includes more preventive care and mental health resources and addresses recruiting and retaining physicians throughout Indian Country.
The Interior Department restored tribal homelands by placing more than 500,000 acres under tribes' control — more than any other recent administration — while the Justice Department charted a process approved by Congress for tribes to prosecute and sentence more cases involving non-Native Americans who assault Native American women. Before Obama, a gap in the laws allowed for such crimes to go unpunished.
In addition, the federal government settled decades-old lawsuits involving Native Americans, including class-action cases over the government's mismanagement of royalties for oil, gas, timber and grazing leases and its discrimination against tribal members seeking farm loans.
"In my opinion, President Obama has been the greatest president in dealing with Native Americans," said Brian Cladoosby, chairman of the Swinomish Tribe north of Seattle and president of the nonpartisan National Congress of American Indians, based in Washington, D.C. "The last eight years give us hope going forward with the relationships we have on both sides of the aisle."
Trump, meanwhile, rarely acknowledged Native Americans during his campaign and hasn't publicly outlined how he would improve or manage the United States' longstanding relationships with tribes.
His Interior secretary pick, Republican Rep. Ryan Zinke of Montana, sponsored legislation that he says would have given tribes more control over coal and other fossil fuel development on their lands.
But some of Trump's biggest campaign pledges — including repealing health care legislation and building a wall along the U.S.-Mexico border — would collide with tribal interests.
In Arizona, Tohono O'odham Nation leaders have vowed to oppose any plans for a wall along the 75-mile portion of the border that runs parallel to their reservation. And the nonprofit National Indian Health Board in Washington says it's aiming to work with lawmakers to ensure the Indian Health Care Improvement Act remains intact.
The law, which guarantees funding for care through the federal Indian Health Services agency, was embedded in Obama's health care overhaul after consultation with tribes.
The government's role figures prominently in Native Americans' daily lives because treaties and other binding agreements often require the U.S. to manage tribal health care, law enforcement and education.
Some tribal members say they're unsure how much Trump understands or cares about their unique relationship with the federal government.
"I think there was a great hope that we had here in Indian Country with the direct dialogue that President Obama had established with tribal nations," said Duane "Chili" Yazzie, president of the Navajo Nation's Shiprock Chapter. "If a similar effort to communicate with us were carried on by the Trump administration, I would be surprised."
Though most reservations lean Democratic in presidential elections, Trump does have some supporters in Indian Country. They hope the businessman can turn around lagging economies in rural reservations, such as the 27,000-square-mile Navajo Nation, which covers parts of Utah, New Mexico and Arizona.
"Trump is pro-job growth, and tribes need a healthy dose of business creation," said Deswood Tome, a former spokesman for the tribe from Window Rock, Arizona. "To do that, a lot of federal barriers must be removed. We're the only ethnic group who have so much federal control in our lives."
The Dakota Access pipeline illustrates another chasm between Obama and Trump.
This fall, the pipeline dispute led Obama's administration to begin tackling a final piece of its Indian Country agenda: guidelines for how cabinet departments should consult with tribes on major infrastructure projects.
A top complaint from the Standing Rock Sioux was that the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers failed to properly consult with them before initially approving a pipeline route that ran beneath Lake Oahe, the tribe's primary source of drinking water.
After the administration halted construction on the project in September to review the complaint, it held seven meetings with tribal leaders and began drafting a report on how federal officials should consult with tribes.
U.S. Interior Secretary Sally Jewell said the report will be completed before Obama leaves office, and she expects it to have a lasting impact, even with an incoming administration that promises to undo some of the president's policies.
What's unclear is whether Trump, who once owned stock in the pipeline builder, will seek to reverse the Army's decision this month to explore alternate routes.
A spokesman said only that the president-elect plans to review the move after he takes office. However, Trump's transition team said in a recent memo to campaign supporters and congressional staff that he supports the pipeline's completion.
In the meantime, Standing Rock Sioux Chairman David Archambault has begun lobbying for a meeting with Trump to make a case for his tribe's opposition to the project, which the chairman says threatens not just water but sacred cultural sites.
"You have to respect Mother Earth; she's precious," Archambault said. "You can still believe in capitalism, and you can still invest in infrastructure projects, but these infrastructure projects should be focused toward renewable energy rather than fossil fuel development."
---
Associated Press writers Susan Montoya Bryan in Albuquerque, New Mexico, and Regina Garcia Cano in Sioux Falls, South Dakota, contributed to this report.

"Trump, meanwhile, rarely acknowledged Native Americans during his campaign and hasn't publicly outlined how he would improve or manage the United States' longstanding relationships with tribes.
His Interior secretary pick, Republican Rep. Ryan Zinke of Montana, sponsored legislation that he says would have given tribes more control over coal and other fossil fuel development on their lands.
But some of Trump's biggest campaign pledges — including repealing health care legislation and building a wall along the U.S.-Mexico border — would collide with tribal interests."
'' tribes need a healthy dose of business creation," said Deswood Tome, a former spokesman for the tribe from Window Rock, Arizona. "To do that, a lot of federal barriers must be removed. We're the only ethnic group who have so much federal control in our lives."
The laws and extensive time needed to approve business on reservations is one of the biggest hold ups. The complex laws often overlap each other and the BIA/DOI control that aspect and it's a frickin' joke.
They DOI has controlled the leases of mineral/timber/grazing rights for over a century and that as well has been a complete failure by the government as can be seen by the huge amounts of money that Indians have been screwed out of because of the inept management.
The issue with the border and the Tohono O'odham is quite interesting. There is a group know as the ''Shadow Wolves'' part of ICE that patrol the area and are exceeding successful using traditional native tracking skills. Of course their funding has been reduced and instead of growing this group, it is actually in decline in members. They have gone all over the world instructing border agents of other country on these skills.
They generally work alone in this vast dangerous area.
Many of the items are covered under treaties, which according to SCOTUS are the highest law of the land. IHS being one of these.
Dear Friend Kavika: We long agreed that replacing the BIA and DOI as it related to Native Americans with a Council of Native Americas similar to the Iroquois Confederacy at Victor NY would be best for Indigenous Americans.
Who better knows the plight of those oppressed than those living with said oppression?
Dignity via Self-Sufficiency and Self-Determination are best for Native Americans, and for the moral fiber of all Americans as a society.
Native Americans do not need an absence of government.
They need their own self-government.
For the last 300 years this they have been forbidden.
It almost led to their extinction.
Let them run their own affairs, on their own land with their own resources.
The other approach we know doesn't work at all!
Peace, and Abundant Blessings Through Fairness.
Enoch.
Native Americans do not need an absence of government.
They need their own self-government.
I totally agree Enoch.
The statement from the Tohono O'odham is very easy to understand. Half of their "rez" is in Mexico and the other half in the U. S. Their "rez" is a sovereign nation which the Feds HAVE TO respect/recognize. As such, any discussion regarding building a wall on the "rez" is totally ludicrous as part of the Nation/Tribe lives on the Mexican side and constructing a wall on the "rez" would cut those members off unless a border check-point were placed on the "rez" - which ain't gonna happen. No, this ain't Canada where the northern Nations/Tribes can cross/pass through the border as a result of the Jay Treaty. Much will have to be worked between the upcoming administration and the Tohono O'odham.
The "Administration's" comment that the pipeline will continue is not a problem. According to the ACOE, the pipeline can continue - using a different route, so I don't see the issue as being tantamount. Continue with the pipeline, using an alternate route. That's what Standing Rock has been telling them all along.
In 2005, Congress enacted a massive Energy Policy Act which replaced the Indian Energy Resources Act (IERA) of 1992. The Indian Tribal Energy Development and Self-Determination Act (ITEDSA) provides that tribes may, at their option, develop tribal energy resource agreements (TERAs) with the DOI. Once a tribe has an approved TERA, it may enter into leases and other business agreements for energy resources development, and grant rights-of-way for pipelines and electric transmission and distribution lines, without secretarial approval of the specific instrument. Tribes may authorize leases, agreements, and rights-of-way for terms of no more than 30 years, except oil and gas leases, which may be authorized for the standard term of 10 years and as long thereafter as the mineral is produced in paying quantities. Because the Secretary will not approve specific instruments, tribal leases, agreements, and rights-of-way will not constitute federal action triggering the environmental review portions of NEPA. ITEDSA, however, provides that a TERA must include an environmental review process that closely mirrors the provisions of NEPA.
Standing Rock needs to, if they haven't done already, write an ironclad lease with DAPL for any future transmission lines, and it needs to be done now.
Good thread John - thanks.